ACM 1998 Workshop on

Java for High-Performance Network Computing

CONVERTING C POINTERS
TO JAVA REFERENCES

Erik Demaine
Department of Computer Science
University of Waterloo, Waterloo, Ontario, Canada
[email protected]

http://daisy.uwaterloo.ca/~eddemain/papers/Java98

February 28, 1998

Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 1

OUTLINE
 Motivation
{ C pointers versus references
 Related work
 Our work
{ General conversion
{ Various improvements
 Conclusion
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 2

MOTIVATION
 C is popular
{ Lots of code written in it
 Developers want to extend their programs
{ Exploit features of new programming languages
{ Need to convert code to the language
 Example:
{ Port program to Java for demonstration on WWW
 C and Java have similar syntax
 Main diculty: converting pointers into references
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 3

C POINTERS
 C pointers are overly exible
 Can represent
{ Basic value
{ Array
{ Structure
{ Element of array or structure
{ Byte
 Can be
{ Cast into integers or pointers of other types
{ Split into pieces and later rejoined
{ Oset by arbitrary amounts (pointer arithmetic)
{ Compared for inequality
 Unnecessary exible
{ Dangerous
{ Dicult to debug
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 4

REFERENCES
 Examples:
{ Java
{ Modula, Pascal
{ Perl 5
{ Fortran 90
{ ML
 Limited access to references themselves
{ Assign to a reference
{ Compare references for equality
 Often no dereference operation
{ Use of reference is implicitly about target
 Safer and simpler
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 5

RELATED WORK
 \C++ to Java"
{ c2j (1996): written in C++
{ c2j++ (1997): written in Java
{ Ignore pointers: remove all dereferences
{ Often correct for objects and pointers to objects
{ Never correct for arrays
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 6

OUR WORK
 Specically on converting pointers to references
{ Focus: Scientic applications
{ Example: SuperLU (1997): 15,000 lines of C
 Start with general conversion
 Optimize common cases
{ Crucial to implement arrays eciently
{ Goal: Convert C arrays into Java arrays
{ Similarly, convert C structures into Java objects
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 7

GENERAL CONVERSION
 Could build C runtime environment at user level
{ Create duplicate representation of heap
{ Hence understand pointers to objects within heap
Block

Pointer Structure Int

 Can navigate through heap

{ Can do pointer arithmetic
{ Supports untyped pointers
 Cannot use binary representations of values
{ No union types
{ Cannot cast between integers and pointers
 EXAMPLE OF GENERAL CONVERSION

main () f main () f
f g
int a[4] = 1,2,3,0 ; f
Int[] a = new Int (1), new Int (2),
n
printf ("%d n", sum (a)); g
new Int (3), new Int (0) ;
g Struct a = new Struct (a );
int sum (int *a) f System.out.println (sum (new Pointer (a)));
int s = 0; g
while (*a != 0) int sum (Pointer a) f
s += *(a++); int s = 0;
return s; while (((Int) a.target).val != 0)f
g s += ((Int) a.target).val;
a.increment ();
g
return s;
g
 EXAMPLE OF IMPROVED CONVERSION

main () f main () f
f
int a[4] = 1,2,3,0 ; g f
int[] a = 1,2,3,0 ; g
n
printf ("%d n", sum (a)); System.out.println (sum (a));
g g
int sum (int *a) f int sum (int[] a) f
int s = 0; int a i = 0;
while (*a != 0) int s = 0;
s += *(a++); while (a[a i] != 0)
return s; s += a[a i++];
g return s;
g
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 10

OPTIMIZATIONS
 Indexable arrays: most general pointer representation
{ Common to use C pointer as \alias" to element of array
{ Convert C pointer into Java array plus integer index
C Java
int a[5]; 7 ! int[] a = new int[5];
int *p = a; 7! int[] p = a;
int p i = 0;
p++; 7 ! p i++;

*p = 5; 7! p[p i] = 5;
p[2] = 10; 7! p[p i+2] = 10;

f (p); 7 ! f (p, p i);

f (a); 7! f (a, 0);

 Arrays: if index is always zero, discard it

{ Maps C arrays to Java arrays
 Call by reference: pointer always to basic value
{ Either
2 Array of size one
2 Object with one entry
{ Typically objects more ecient
{ May vary in the future
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 11

STATIC ANALYSIS
Pointer Desired conversion
To element of an array Array plus index
Representing an array Array
To a basic value Object (or possibly 1-element array)

 Statically analyze code to determine best guarantees on kinds of

pointers
 Major unknown is pointers passed to functions
Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 12

FUNCTION COPYING
 At call side, should have better \bound" on kind of pointer
 For each type of call (mix of pointer kinds), duplicate function
{ Optimize each function copy by exploiting known bounds on
pointer kinds
void f (Int i) f
i.val = 5;
g
void f (int *i) f void f (int[] i) f
*i = 5; ! i[0] = 5;
g g
void f (int[] i, int i i) f
i[i i] = 5;
g
C Java
int i; 7 ! Int i;
f (&i); 7! f (i);

int a[5]; 7 ! int[] a = new int[5];

f (a); 7! f (a);

int *p = &a[2]; 7! int[] p = a;

int p i = 2;
f (p); 7! f (p, p i);

 Worst case: Quadratic code expansion

Converting C Pointers to Java References Erik Demaine Slide: 13

CONCLUSION
 Can achieve complete and automatic C-to-Java conversion
{ Provides a general framework
 Optimizations improve \common" cases
{ Arrays ! arrays
{ Structures ! objects
{ Occasional \bad" case should not aect other cases
 The better written the code, the better the conversion
 Similar ideas apply to any pointer-to-reference conversion
{ For example, C to Fortran 90
 Future work:
{ Implement C-to-Java converter
{ Extend to C++ as source language