Challenges of Large Class Teaching at The University: Implications For Continuous Staff Development Activities
Challenges of Large Class Teaching at The University: Implications For Continuous Staff Development Activities
Challenges of Large Class Teaching at The University: Implications For Continuous Staff Development Activities
Abstract
Class size is a major concern to any educational system. At university, a class
of any size (small or large) appears to be an acceptable norm. However, when
classes are too large, they are considered to contribute some complex challenges
related to the teaching and learning process. Whether the class is big or small,
instructors are expected to teach and assess students effectively. This paper
presents a general reflection on the authors personal experiences with teaching
two large classes at undergraduate level at a university. The paper aims at
sharing this personal account of experiences with fellow educators who may
find themselves in similar situations of teaching and assessing large groups of
students at any level of education. Although what constitutes a large class has
been a subject of debate in literature, the author adopts from previous authors
to define a large class as one in which characteristics and conditions present
themselves as inter-related and collective constraints that impede meaningful
teaching and learning. Therefore, in the context of this paper, this meaning is
adopted as a working standard that sets the parameters of the discussion of
the concept of a large class. Furthermore the paper is based on the critical
reflective practices and experiences as the author draws most of the evidence
based on narrative practices and principles. A narrative representation of the
author is found to be the most appropriate method of telling this experience.
105
to 17,500 in 2013(Ihemba, 2013).The increase in enrollment has been called the mass
sification of higher education and has happened worldwide (Mohamedbhai, 2008).
Given the high demand of higher education and the worldwide phenomenon of educational
expansion, large class sizes become a part of a teaching setup at the university especially
at undergraduate level. Mulryan-Kyne (2010), has found out that large classes of between
300 and 1, 000 and even more at the undergraduate level are common at institutions of
higher learning in a number of countries. This occurrence, according to research, poses
challenges to both experienced and inexperienced educators who are assigned to teach
larger classes (Lantz, Smith and Branney, 2008).
As pointed out in the preceding paragraph, the issue of large classes is not unique to
the University of Namibia, but is found at other higher institutions all over the world. It
is believed that since the 1970s, class sizes in universities across the world have been
increasing (Gibbs and Jenkins, 1992). Stanley and Porter (2002) note that, large classes
are very prevalent in many universities and are often gateway courses to students major
fields of study (p.xxii). Twigg (2003) however, reveals that, failure rates in these courses
contribute heavily to overall institutional drop-out rates between the first and second
years (p.24).,
Yet at most universities, introductory courses or classes that fulfill general
education requirements often carry enrollment of hundreds of students. These
large-class settings have historically been heavily lecture-centered, requiring
minimal student engagement and expecting little more than memorization of terms
and concepts as evidence of student learning. The sheer size and anonymity of
large classes seem to militate against the very elements that promote students
involvement and intellectual development, learning, and success. Inattention or
absence from class and mediocre student performance seem to be tolerated simply
as unfortunate realities. Macgregor, Cooper, Smith, and Robinson (2000, p.1)
The situation quoted above may create more challenges to both students and instructors
and can consequently lead to less effective teaching and learning. Botha, Fourie and Gyser
(2005, p. 63) observe and caution that:
Large classes are often cited as proof that higher education institutions care more
about generating income than educating students. Defenders of big classes have to
acknowledge that these large classes can turn into big disasters. Too often, young
and inexperienced lecturer [sic], who have not even had the time to frame their
qualifications, are pushed in front of a sea of staring students, handed a piece of
chalk, and told to teach them something.
106
The realities in some universities would be that reducing classes to a smaller number would
not be economically viable in terms of the availability of human resources and teaching
and learning facilities. With this condition, large classes will continue to exist.
presenting a history lecture to 220 students in a lecture room designed for 200 (p. 176).
However, Jungic and Kent (2006) further define large classes as classes with students
above 200 in large university lecturing rooms.
Other scholars define a large class from the context point of view. For example, writing
from an African context, Onwu (1999) defines a large class as, one where the majority of
characteristics and conditions present themselves as inter-related and collective constraints
that impede meaningful teaching and learning (p. 126).According to this definition, the
factors which can affect the learning environment may include:
Lack of physical space for moment due to overcrowding;
Diminished opportunities for all learners to participate actively in the learning
process;
The impersonalizing of teaching;
Teachers resorting to predominantly lecture and teacher demonstrations;
Excessive workload, and a long homework assignment turnaround;
Limited opportunities to meet individual student needs for self-activity and inquiry,
motivation, discipline, safety and socialization (Onwu and Stoffels, 2005, p.79).
From what has been presented so far in the literature, it becomes evident that the concept
of large class size is subjective, largely contextualized and situational based. Therefore, a
large class in the Western world can be a small class in Africa or Asia or vice versa. This is
because the teaching contexts differ.
Challenges Confronting Teaching Large Classes
The report on the UNESCO workshop (undated) that took place in Kenya identified some
problems associated with large classes teaching, for example:
Students become faces instead of people.
It is hard to give individual advice and guidance to students.
Organizational problems are compounded, making it difficult to schedule tutorials,
laboratory sessions, and field work.
There can be technical problems working with large classes e.g. difficulties in
projecting slides that are clearly visible to all students.
Monitoring of attendance can be difficult, thus encouraging students to cut classes.
108
109
Methodology
Since this paper is based on the account of personal experiences of teaching large classes
at a university level and the reflections on those experiences, the author is guided by
narrative research practices and principles.
Schon (1993) has recommended that professional careers such as teaching require a
person to reflect when faced with new problems or difficulties for which s/he does not
have sufficient skills or training in. A narration as a form of presentation is found to be a
suitable method of sharing and exchanging these experiences and reflections because the
author narrates his experiences of teaching large classes.
Narrated Findings of teaching large classes
The findings are presented in accordance with the following themes: authors first encounter
with large class teaching, challenges arising during larger class teaching, possible teaching
strategies employed in large classes regarding classroom interactions and contextualized
teaching, classroom attendance and managing student assessment. In addressing these
themes, where possible, the author makes direct connections to the literature.
Authors First encounter with a Large Class Teaching
The author joined the university as a lecturer in the Department of Curriculum, Instruction
and Assessment Studies. In the first year of employment at the university, the author
was assigned to teach two core modules in the teacher training programmed namely:
Assessment and Evaluation of Learning and Educational Research. These modules are at
levels 7 and 8 respectively of Namibias National Qualification Framework (NQF) and are
taught in the third year of studies to all undergraduate students who are training to be
secondary school teachers. The Assessment and Evaluation of Learning module introduces
students to principles, practices and policies associated with assessment both in general
and local contexts. Educational Research module requires students to apply research
concepts to practical situations. Each of the two is a semester module with an intake of
close to 170 students excluding distance learning students that the author was teaching
face to face during vacation schools.
As pointed out in the literature review, large enrollment can become a daunting task
to a person who has never taught at a university level before. At one point the author
111
considered giving up because he thought there was little chance for him to get such a
group of students to learn meaningfully and to provide them with quality teaching. He
was also worried that he would not be able to control the discipline aspects of the class.
The primary concern was how he would effectively teach and assess a group of close to
170 students in one class group. Another equally important concern was how he would
manage and control the class. While there were other numerous logistical and practical
issues related to the size of the class to contemplate, the author made sure that his
module content and teaching strategies were closely aligned with the learning outcomes
which always enlightened his assessment approaches in order to promote quality teaching
and learning. As the author taught the modules, he applied the philosophy of reflective
practitioner especially when he was confronted by new challenges, worries and concerns
of teaching larger classes.
Teaching a large group of students can be intimidating for both students and lecturers
(Jungic, Kent and Menz, 2006). Although the author was quite intimidated by this large
group, he was also excited that he would have diverse views and learning styles in that
large group of students. In addition, the author also thought at the time that students
would have an advantage of forming study groups to work on real classroom based issues.
His views reflected the conclusions of earlier research done by Hess (2001) who argues
that large classes are characterized by rich human interactions because there are plenty
of diverse students.
On his first day of class the author took a colleague with him to the lecture theater, that
stayed with him for at least 20 minutes. This was purely for moral support and also to boost
his confidence for standing in front of such a big group. Also, the author was a bit scared to
stand in front of such a big class. This colleague was also new at the University and they had
been sharing ideas about how to handle large classes as she was also assigned to teach a
large class. The colleague spent 20 minutes helping the author distributing course outlines.
After the colleague had left, I felt stronger in handling the class because her presence
made a difference in boosting my confidence level. Although the author was professionally
qualified and an experienced teacher he was not trained to handle large classes and he
had neither worked with large classes in his previous duty stations nor worked with large
classes when he was a tutor during his undergraduate studies. The maximum number of
students I had handled in my previous work stations was 30 or even less.
Challenges and Teaching Strategies Employed in Large Classes
The following challenges were of serious concern and kept on challenging the author to
the end of his first and second semesters of his first year of teaching at the university. The
author has also discussed how he handled these challenges by looking at the teaching
strategies he employed.
112
113
Another example the author used was to show a Power Point slide of two school buses
(of different designs) involved in an accident, endangering other road users and close-bypassengers. Housed this picture to illustrate to the students that one of the drivers failed
to meet the criteria for good driving, and that is criterion reference assessment, while
perhaps this driver was racing before getting involved into the accident thinking that his
bus was faster than the other one, then that becomes a norm reference assessment. It
becomes a norm reference, because the driver is comparing his buss speed with the other
one. Students easily got the meaning of the concepts, asking questions, as they relate
things and issues to what they see on daily basis. Through this, the lessons became student
centered, interesting and engaging.
As advised by Pascarella and Terenzini, (1991, p. 616), the greater the students
involvement or engagement in academic work or in the academic experience of college,
the greater his or her level of knowledge acquisition and general cognitive development.
Morgan, Whorton and Gunsalus (2000) who did a comparison study lecture combined
with discussion versus cooperative learning found that when the lecture presentation
format is combined with discussions, students highly retain the material information being
presented.
In his teaching, the author found through Power Point presentations, students to have
constantly maintained interest in the lessons, always paid attention to what is being
presented, and helped simplify explanations of concepts. This finding is consistent with
similar findings of Szabo and Hasting (2000) and Apperson, Laws and Scepansky (2006)
with regards to the benefits of Power Point software in projecting and in facilitating the
explanation of information.
Classroom Attendance
The author was fully aware of the attendance policy of the university in which the students
are required to attend at least 80% of lectures and to complete the required elements
that make up the continuous assessment mark (University of Namibia, 2012, p.17).
He was then concerned on how to safeguard and implement 80% attendance policy of
the lectures by a group of 170 students. He was also concerned that if students are not
attending lectures, they might not perform well in both examinations and continuous
assessment activities.
Reflecting back, two strategies worked quite well for the author. One, he gave randomly
unannounced in-class quizzes requiring short answers either at the beginning or at the end
of the lesson. These quizzes were always peer marked and the students appeared to enjoy
that. This encouraged them to fully attend the class because the students did not know the
day they would write these quizzes. It was also made very clear that if a student has missed
the quiz, there would not be a make-up consequent task.
114
The second strategy was to give students case studies during class time after the lecturer
had presented concepts and theories. Students liked this instructional strategy because
it gave them an opportunity to get involved in solving real and practical problems related
to school. For example, one of the case studies was requested the students to promote a
learner to the next grade. It reads as follows:
Jade is a Grade 9 learner at Mureti Secondary School in Kunene Region. She has
never repeated any grade at this phase level. Her school attendance and conduct
are both satisfactory. She obtained the following results in the final examination,
English Second Language D, Afrikaans First Language E, History F, Geography D, Life
Science C, Mathematics E, Accounting D and Entrepreneurship C.
By studying this case the students would carefully read the policy on promotion
requirements and the attendance policy as well as the policy on repetition and also used
their own discretions to prevent worst scenarios that might occur as a result of their
decisions. Case studies such as this one allowed the author to combine his lecture with
discussion and also created an opportunity for students to form study groups to interrogate
issues raised in the case study in depth.
Managing Student Assessment
Assessment at any level of schooling is an important component in student learning.
Students generally like to know how they will be assessed and also understand the
assessment tools to be used for evaluation. The author was confronted by the constant
fact that his experience in handling large classes can result into poor management and
planning of assessment issues. He was therefore worried that he would be left with no
opportunity but to revert to his traditional way of doing assessment. That is a test and an
examination assessment approach.
In addition to small continuous graded and ungraded class activities which counted for a
significant percentage of the continuous mark, the author had initially planned two big
tests. One with all multiple choice questions only and the other one with a combination of
multiple choice questions and short questions but set in such way that verbs used require
answers at the different levels of thinking of Bloom Taxonomy. He had also planned for
a two page written assignment to be done in pairs for which he should assess using well
defined rubrics. The author was afraid that if heave students essay type of questions, he
would not be able to provide immediate and quality feedback. For this, the author was also
reminded by Botha, Fourie and Gyser (2005, p. 64) who argue that,
As class sizes go up, assuming the staffing remains the same, and the same
assessment methods continue to be used, one of two things is likely to happen
115
with regard to assessment, and in both cases the effect on students is detrimental.
It is either likely to be done well less rigorously and with less and more superficial
feedback to the student and to take longer to be returned.
With all these assessment activities, the author wanted to provide an opportunity for the
prospective teachers to understand that assessment is an essential element of teaching
and learning development. As quoted in Black and William (1998, p.19) that,
Assessment is to be seen as a moment of learning, and students have to be
active in their own assessment and to picture their own learning in the light of an
understanding of what it means to get better.
Implications of Large Classes on Staff Development Activities
Evidence from literature and from the author narrated experience indicates that issues
that confront teaching large classes are similar to those of teaching smaller classes as
well. These issues include student motivation, provision of feedback, taking attendance,
provision of quality instruction, classroom management, and designing quality assessment
tasks. However, it is evident that these issues become more demanding when teaching
large classes compared to smaller classes. Based on the authors experiences, and which
are in line with what the literature has documented, large classes are not necessarily less
effective than smaller classes. What is important is for a person teaching large classes to
be more organized and put more effort in planning the teaching and learning activities
that encourage active participation of students. This is a critical point when considering
and planning staff development activities because the attitudes and behaviors of staff
members are important to bring changes in the classroom. As proposed by Day (1999, p.4):
Professional development consists of all natural learning experiences and those
conscious and planned activities which are indeed to be of direct benefit to the
individual group or school, which contribute, through these, to the quality of
education in the classroom. It is the process by which, alone and with others,
teachers review, renew and extend their commitment as change agents to the
moral purpose of teaching; and by which they acquire and develop critically the
knowledge, skills and emotional intelligence essential to good professional thinking,
planning and practice with children, young people and colleagues throughout each
phase of their teaching lives.
The authors personal critical practices and reflections on these experiences of teaching
large classes suggest that planning and designing of continuous professional development
ought to be focused but not limited to the following:
116
Use of time
Management of large classes
Planning for a large class
Principles and strategies of teaching large classes
Communication strategies in large classes
Student motivation
Flexibility and creativity in large classes
Designing authentic assessment tasks
Organization strategies.
In addition to continuous professional development activities such as suggested above, the
author recommends that critical reflective practice and sharing of experiences with peers
should be encouraged. There is a need for the University of the author of this paper or
other universities with similar situations to bring together lecturers teaching large classes
in order to reflect on their current teaching practices and experience in order to identify
both short and long term solutions to challenges related to large classes. As Biggs (2003, p.
7) stated, Learning new techniques for teaching is like the fish that provides a meal today;
reflective practice is the net that provides meals for the rest of your life.
Conclusion
Teaching large classes is a worldwide phenomenon, especially when it comes to the
provision of the university education. It is clear that teaching a large class requires hard
work, effective planning both in terms of logistical arrangements and provision of learning
activities, instead of relying on straight lecturers, which according to empirical evidence
are not highly effective. These brief reviews of literature, accompanied by own narrated
experience of teaching large classes highlighted some challenges associated with large
classes. It is clear from this paper that lecturers assigned to teach large classes should
be supported through continuous professional development activities in order to deliver
meaningful learning activities in such settings. Had the author received professional
development in teaching approaches of large class teaching, the author could have coped
well and or could have done things differently in order to deliver better quality education.
117
References
Apperson, J.M., Laws, E.L. &Scepansky, J.A. (2006). The impact of presentation graphics on
students experience in the classroom. Computers and Education, 47, 116-126.
Biggs, J. (1999). Teaching for quality learning at university. Berkshire: Society for Research
in Higher Education and the Open University Press.
Biggs, J. (2003). Teaching for quality learning at(university (2nd edition). Berkshire: Society
for Research in Higher Education and the Open University Press.
Black, P., & William, D. (1998). Raising standards through classroom assessment: A short
version of assessment of classroom learning in assessment in education. Principles, Policy
and Practice, 5(1), 1-62.
Bligh, D. A. (2000).Whats the use of lectures? (1st Ed). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Botha, L.; Fourie, N. & Geyser, H. (2005). Teaching, Learning and assessment in large classes
a reality of educational change. Education as Change, 9 (1), 60-79.
Center for Excellence in Learning and Teaching (1992). Teaching large classes well: Solutions
from yourepeers. Available online from, http:www.psu.edu/celt/newsletter/ID_Oct92.
html.Retrieved on, 12 January 2010.
Coleman, H. (1989). The study of large classes. Lancaster- Leeds language learning in large
classes research project. Report no 2.
Day, C. (1999). Developing teachers: The challenges of lifelong learning. London: Falmer
Press.
Deed, C. (05 September 2007). Students walking out onelectures. The Australian. Available
Onlinefrom,http://www.theaustralian.com.au/higher-education/opinion/studentswalking-out-on-lectures/story-e6frgcko-1111114343695.Retrieved, 10 June 2012.
Exley, K. &Dennick, R. (2004).Giving a lecture from presenting to teaching. London:
Routledge Falmer.
Gibbs, G. & Jenkins, A. (Eds.). (1992). Teaching large classes in higher education. London:
Kogan.
Government of the Republic of Namibia. (1992).University of Namibia Act 18of 1992.
Windhoek: Government Press.
Hess, N. (2001). Teaching large multilevel classes. Cambridge: CUP.
Hoxby, C.M. (2000). The effects of class size on student achievement: New evidence from
population variation. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115, 1239-1285.
118
119
Pascarella, E., &Terenzini, P. (1991).How college affects students: Findings and insights
from twenty years of research. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Papo, W.D. (1999). Large class teaching: is it aeproblem? College Student Journal, 33 (3),
354-357.
Romer, D. (1993). Do students go to class? Should they? Journal of Economic Perspectives,
7, 167-174.
Schon, D. A. (1983).The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. London:
Temple Smith.
Slavin, R. E. (1989). Class size and student achievement: small effects of small classes.
Educational Psychologist, 24 (1), 99-110.
Snowball, J & Wilson, M. (2005).What matters in large class and learning? A case study
of an introductory Macroeconomics course. Grahamstown: Department of Economics,
Rhodes University.
Stanley, C., & Porter, E. (Eds.). (2002). Engaging large classes: Strategies and techniques for
college faculty. Bolton, MA: Anker Publishing Company.
Szabo, A. & Hasting, N. (2000). Using IT in the undergraduate classroom: Should we replace
the blackboard with PowerPoint? Computers and Education, 35, 175-187.
Thatcher, A., Fridjhorn. And Cockcroft, K. (2007). The relationship between lecture
attendance and academic performance in an undergraduate psychology class. South
African Journal of Psychology, 29 (3), 375-394.
Todd, R. W. (2006). Why investigate large classes? KMUTT Journal of Language Education,
9, 1-12.
Toth, L., &Montagna, L. (2002). Class size and achievement in higher education: A summary
of current research. College Student Journal, 36(2), 253-261).
Twigg, C. A. (2003). Improving Quality and reducing cost: Designs for effective learning.
Change, 35 (4), 23-29.
University of Namibia.(2012). General information and regulation. Unam. Windhoek
UNESCo (undated). Learning and Teaching in higher Education. Workshop Report, held at
Moi University, Kenya. Available from http://www. unesco-bamako.org/guide/fp/modules.
pdf. Retrieved, 11 June 2012
Ur, P. (1996). A course in language teaching: Practice and theory. Cambridge University
Press.
120
Abstract
This paper examines several important elements of measuring performance
in primary and secondary education and its contribution to best practice in
education. Education management has increasingly been dominated by the
norms and requirements of general management ideologies that focus on
performance controls and target achievements. Under this regime, solving
the labour problem relatively low productivity has taken priority over all
other forms of management. There are tendencies of individually grievance,
absenteeism, increased instrumentalism and dull compliance in the job
according to Sugrue and Day 2002, p. xv. The application of tighter controls over
performance will encourage development through the allocation of real and
meaningful responsibilities to employees. Performance management can raise
levels of performance to achieve better outputs and outcomes in education.
In England the introduction of performance related pay means that poor
performance, as indicated by pupil test scores, may be taken into account in
appraising teacher performance and reviewing pay according to the OECDS
report.
Namibia does not award any type of credits to teacher performance, not even as
related especially to the outcomelof external exams. From experience, in many
public schools in Namibia no action is taken due to cases of poor performance.
According to (Sugrue& Day 2002, p. xv) changes need to be done based on
Performance Management which can be used as a method to put pressure
on(teachers, management and the whole education syste) to force management
to addresseunderachievement. There is a growing need to increase productivity
in schools as a result of improving theestandards. The Namibian Ministry of
Education will need to review current practices and develop an understanding of
performance management and to assist teachers as such.
121