Problem Tree Analysis
Problem Tree Analysis
Introduction
Youth Forum
Guyana
Agenda
1. What is a project?
2. What is project management?
3. What is the project cycle?
4. Project Identification
I. Problem, Objectives and Strategy Analysis
What is a project?
A temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product,
service, or result
Key things to note:
Definite start and end
End defined by attainment of objectives or termination of the project
Temporary does not necessarily mean short in duration
Temporary does not generally apply to the product, service or result
SCOPE
BUDGET
Evaluation
Implementation
& Monitoring
Preparation
Appraisal
2.
PREPARATION - detailed design of the project addressing technical and operational aspects
3.
APPRAISAL - analysis of the project from technical, financial, economic, gender, social,
institutional and environmental perspectives
4.
5.
EVALUATION - periodic review of the project with feedback for next project cycle and
assessment of attainment of objectives
Identification of Projects
Projects should always be structured as possible solutions to
identified and defined problems
Problem analysis is a critical methodology for identifying
projects
Problem Tree
Key Steps:
1. Brainstorm priority problems
2. Select a starter problem
3. Establish the cause effect hierarchy
a)
b)
4.
5.
Sort all other problem is the same way ( what causes that?)
Connect problems with arrows to create the cause-effect relationships
Key features:
Problems should always be phrased as negative statements
State problems in a simple format , with 1 problem at a time
Analysis of Objectives
This is a methodology used to:
Describe the situation in the future once the problems are solved
Verify the hierarchy of objectives
Illustrate the means-end relationship
Key steps:
1. Reformulate all negative statements to positive
2. Check the means-end relationships for completeness
3. Revise statements if necessary
Analysis of Strategies
A methodology used to select the most relevant and appropriate approach to solving
the problems identified, essentially selecting the scope of your proposed project
Key questions/consideration include (but not limited to):
Should all the identified problems and/or objectives be tackled, or a selected few?
Environmental Impact
Technical feasibility
Project Rationale
Project Description
Implementation Plan
Budget
Problem Definition
Project Context
Rationale
Objective
Components / Description of
Activities
Targets / Expected Results
Project Team
Project Management
Participation of Stakeholders
Monitoring & Evaluation
Project Schedule
CDB
Stakeholders
4 pages
3 pages
2 pages
1 page
Evaluation Criteria
Project Rationale
Project Description
Implementation Plan
Budget *
Total
20
20
40
20
100
*(max 20 for matching CDB contribution with cash or in-kind resources from
Stakeholders)