Scribd
Upload
206 views1 page

Annotation Rubric

The document provides guidelines for annotating a text. It outlines an annotation rubric with criteria for excellent, proficient, adequate, and inadequate annotations. Criteria include thoroughly annotating the text with questions, observations, and reflections; demonstrating analysis and interpretation beyond surface level details; accomplishing different purposes with comments; and marking and defining a minimum number of vocabulary words. It also lists critical thinking and active reading demonstration criteria like employing meaning-making strategies, weaving connections between annotations, emerging multiple meanings, providing logical support and reflection, and ensuring clarity. Finally, it provides additional guidelines for annotating novels, such as creating chapter titles, summarizing plots, recording quotes, highlighting characterization, analyzing author's craft, tracing themes,

Uploaded by

Camelia Pesquera
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
206 views1 page

Annotation Rubric

The document provides guidelines for annotating a text. It outlines an annotation rubric with criteria for excellent, proficient, adequate, and inadequate annotations. Criteria include thoroughly annotating the text with questions, observations, and reflections; demonstrating analysis and interpretation beyond surface level details; accomplishing different purposes with comments; and marking and defining a minimum number of vocabulary words. It also lists critical thinking and active reading demonstration criteria like employing meaning-making strategies, weaving connections between annotations, emerging multiple meanings, providing logical support and reflection, and ensuring clarity. Finally, it provides additional guidelines for annotating novels, such as creating chapter titles, summarizing plots, recording quotes, highlighting characterization, analyzing author's craft, tracing themes,

Uploaded by

Camelia Pesquera
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 1

Guidelines for Annotation

Name __________________________________

Annotation Rubric annotations will be worth 25 points


(Project):
Excellent (A): 23-25 points
Text has been thoroughly annotated with questions, observations, and
reflections of the content as well as the writing; variety of topics marked
for discussion; variety of stylistic devices marked

Comments demonstrate analysis and interpretation thinking goes


beyond the surface level of the text. Thoughtful connections are made to
other texts, life experiences.

Marginal comments accomplish a great variety of purposes.

Consistent markings appear throughout text (not bunched)


At least 25 vocabulary words are marked and defined in text
Proficient (B): 20-22
Text has been annotated reasonably well with questions, observations,
and/or reflections of the content as well as the writing.

Comments demonstrate some analysis and interpretation thinking


somewhat beyond the surface level of the text. Attempts at making
connections are evident.

Marginal comments accomplish a variety of purposes.

Some lapses in entries exist; may be sporadic


At least 15 vocabulary words are marked and defined in text
Adequate (C): 18-19
Text has been briefly annotated.

Commentary remains mostly at the surface level. The commentary


suggests thought in specific sections of the text rather than throughout.
There is little or no attempt to make connections.
At least 10 vocabulary words are marked and defined in text
Inadequate (D/F): 17 or below
marks and marginal comments are sparse
only skimpy annotations
paraphrase rather than analysis
Less than 10 vocabulary are marked and defined in text

Critical Thinking and Active Reading Demonstration:


1. Full range of "meaning-making" strategies (connect, reflect, evaluate,
compare/contrast, ask questions, predict, apply, conclude, summary or restatement) employed consistently.
2. A thread, connecting the annotations and highlighting together, begins
to be woven, creating a unified structure to the interpretation of meaning.
3. More than one such thread exists, so that multiple meanings begin to
emerge.
4. Annotations reflect logical, strong support for the interpretation,
reflections, evaluations, etc., and/or ask reflective questions in need of
thinking and discussion with attempt at hypothetical answer.
5. Annotations are of the necessary depth/length so that the reasoning is
clear to the reader.

Create a clever title for every chapter (if there are no chapters,
divide the book into several sections) that reflects the theme/deeper
meaning, then
- at the end of every chapter (or section), write a quick
summary of the plot (2-3 brief bullet points should suffice).

Record important quotes

Highlight information that leads to characterization

Analyze the authors craft (syntax and style)

Themes: Trace their development; consider what they represent,


how and why they appear in the novel.

While reading, write in the margins:


-ask questions
- make predictions
-reflect/react/comment
- formulate opinions
-identify patterns/repetitions
- make connections

You might also like