Silo Design Final For Mombasa Is Niladri
Silo Design Final For Mombasa Is Niladri
Silo Design Final For Mombasa Is Niladri
25428
1.4
T/M3
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
21164
4126
224
25
15
10
25565
T
T
T
T
T
=
=
=
344.71
314.16
659.00
T
T
T
47.00
1.00
k2
0.98
(Upto 10.0 M)
k2
1.02
(10.0 M to 15.0 M)
k2
1.05
(15.0 M to 20.0 M)
k2
1.10
(20.0 M to 30.0 M)
k2
1.15
(30.0 M to 50.0 M)
k2
1.22
k3
1.00
Vz
46.06
(Upto 10.0 M)
Vz
47.94
(10.0 M to 15.0 M)
Vz
49.35
(15.0 M to 20.0 M)
Vz
51.70
(20.0 M to 30.0 M)
(30.0 M to 50.0 M)
v)
x)
147.26
5036.74
785.38
137.42
75.40
2356.29
67.09
2451.38
613.55
42.41
11713.00
xiv)
Vz
54.05
xv)
Vz
57.34
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
0.127
b.
c.
=
=
0.138
0.146
d.
e.
=
=
0.160
0.175
f.
0.197
T/M2
T/M2
1
2
3
4
5
5
6
7
8
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
110.76064
58.755
26.879
5.976
6.881
11.556
21.334
0.000
0.000
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
11738.299
TM
(consider
50.00
30.00
20.00
17.56
15.00
10.00
0.00
-0.50
-3.50
(consider
T/M2
T/M2
M and
M and
M and
M and
M and
M and
M and
M and
M and
(2 floors @
a.
83.50
50.00
30.00
20.00
17.56
15.00
10.00
0.00
-0.50
T/M2
T/M2
& at
& at
& at
& at
& at
& at
& at
& at
& at
2.133
T/M
=
=
2.311
2.449
T/M
T/M
=
=
2.688
2.938
T/M
T/M
3.306
T/M
50.00
30.00
20.00
17.56
15.00
10.00
0.00
-0.50
-3.50
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
1855.241
4658.006
6487.558
6974.051
7500.926
8576.070
10890.807
11011.877
11738.299
=
=
11011.877
6974.051
TM
TM
Type of Soil.
Basic Horizontal Seismic coefficient
Importance Factor
Response Reduction Factor
Design Horizontal Seismic coefficient
Item
R
h
h
d
=
=
TYPE OF SOIL
Medium
0.828
Hard
0.609
Soft
1.017
Moment about
Moment about
Moment about
raft bottom
raft top
24.605
142.722
3.314
5.377
0.583
2138.759
7711.202
39.867
144.293
7.019
2064.945
7283.036
29.925
128.161
5.269
1620.585
4705.475
65134936
615.464
38536.978
36690.586
25575.304
3239.10
3443796
32.541
1061.042
963.420
375.736
29011.94
87268574
49639.159
47165.340
32277.100
86.93
54.03
12.03
26.83
12.03
344.62
5174.17
2423.39
790.38
426.68
2603924
15104362
350715
569092
61749
62.61
16613.62
32.61
Wihi2
VB X
Wi
TOTAL
=
=
=
=
=
=
Wihi2
Mass
Material below
Inv. Cone Top
x
sqrt (d)
1.6418632 s
Hard
0.016
1.75
3.00
0.028423
Wihi2
Ht. from
Base hi
Top Slab
Top Shell
Bot Shell
Inv. Cone
Equip. Floor
Material above
Inv. Cone Top
0.09
VB
824.60626
Circular of diameter
Area
=
=
34
957.67
40
M
M2
T/M2
Thickness
1.0 DL + LL + ML
Load
Bearing Pressure
=
=
37323.5
T
38.973187 T/M2
OK
(max)
42.02
T/M2
Min.Bearing Pressure
(min)
35.93
T/M
3.0 DL + LL + WL
Max.Bearing Pressure
(max)
15.32
T/M2
Min.Bearing Pressure
(min)
9.24
T/M2
Max.Bearing Pressure
(max)
51.49
T/M2
Min.Bearing Pressure
(min)
25.76
T/M2
OK
OK
3.00
10.050
b
q
=
=
17.00
58.46
M
T/M
=
0.2
has been considered for reinforcement calculation)
=
r/a
k1
k2
=
=
=
=
Qr
For
Mr
Mt
Qr
For
Mr
Mt
For
qa2
[ k1
16
9.81
For
For
For
For
b/a
poinssion's ratio
1.6915423
4
2 loge
k1
k1
-(
[ k1
2
(
-1.0412098
2
(
-14.775523
a
q
2
1
q
a2
16
q
a2
16
a
q
2
>
1
-(
+(
-(
+(
0.98
0.09
0.05
1.00
2.453125
0.244092 0
0.9964501 1
4.90625
0.4881841 0
0.9432018 1
7.359375
0.7322761 0
For
10.475
1.0422886 0
For
13.7375
1.3669154 0
For
17
1.6915423 0
For
For
r
r
=
=
15.550
13.377
i)
v)
a2
16
(
(
2 loge
2 loge
-508.57087 TM
24
-0.02
-0.02
NA
NA
0.94
NA
0.76
NA
0.7124592 1
0.46
NA
-0.1801899 1
-0.09
-2.4911345 1
-0.87
-7.1871253 1
-1.86
TM
1]
At a distance of 0.75 a
Mr
= -1017.4855 TM
Mt
= -700.86494 TM
At a distance of 0.00 a
Mr
=
-384.2
Mt
=
-384.2
Mt
24
ii)
1
loge
Mt
TM
TM
23]
0.05
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
0.04
0.04
-0.08
0.58
0.31
-0.46
1.50
0.53
-0.65
=
-950.1
TM
At
a
distance
from
outer
face
of
silo wall
ix)
v
Qr
T
=
88.72
23]
TM
-688.58162 TM
0.87*fy2 /
(fck*b)
Reinforcements Required
Steel
Top
Reinforcements Provided
Bottom
Steel
Top
Bottom
N/mm
N/mm3
mm2/M
s in mm
s in mm
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
15848.413
3747.607
4452.1788
6602.7459
10320.23
13699.528
2138.0981
0
25
32
32
32
32
25
25
25
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
s in mm
51
215
181
122
78
59
376
NA
mm2/M
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
16084.954
8042.4772
8042.4772
8042.4772
16084.954
16084.954
8042.4772
8042.4772
25
32
32
32
32
25
25
25
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
s in mm
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
1047767.1
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
5.99343
9562.5302
3747.607
4099.1481
5162.7862
6966.7632
9594.2165
6839.4776
4996.6684
25
32
32
32
32
25
25
25
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
84
215
196
156
115
84
118
161
16084.954
8042.4772
8042.4772
8042.4772
16084.954
16084.954
8042.4772
8042.4772
25
32
32
32
32
25
25
25
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
32
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
100
No of
Layers
=
=
0.303
0.8
x
pt
6.89
0.85
N/mm2
fck
=
x
pt
10.589636
sqrt (
0.8
>
0.2741131
fck)
x
( sqrt (
1+
5
6
x
1)
0.3796027
1.0150527
=
=
0.829
0.8
6.89
0.85
N/mm2
fck
x
pt
pt
5.2948182
sqrt (
0.8
fck)
0.5482261
( sqrt (
1+
av
1)
2d
2
1
1
1
2
2
1
1
2
1
1
1
2
2
1
1
3.8
(k)
= 1.0
x
f
(As per Table 2 of IS:4995 (Part-1), Powdery material)
e
f
e
f
e
H
(l)
(m)
(n)
(o)
(p)
(q)
1.0
x
(As per Table 2 of IS:4995 (Part-1), Powdery material)
(As per Table 2 of IS:4995 (Part-1), Powdery material)
(As per Table 2 of IS:4995 (Part-1), Powdery material)
tan f
tan e
Height of Fill considering level surface at top
314.15927 M2
20.00
M
20.00
M
65.79
M
62.83
M
5.00
M
1.40
T/M3
63.44
M
O
36
O
36
=
=
=
=
=
=
36
0.50
0.70
0.7265425
0.7265425
63.44
Determination of Lateral pressure in wall (Ph), Vertical pressure (Pv) and Frictional pressure (Pw)
Maximum pressure
Pw
=
WR
During Filling
7.00
T/M2
WR
During Emptying
=
7.00
T/M2
Ph
WR/ f
9.63
T/M2
WR/ e
9.63
T/M2
Pv
Zof
WR/ f /f
19.27
T/M2
WR/ e/e
13.76
T/M2
R/ff
13.76
Zoe
R/ee
9.83
Pi(z)
1st Stage 2nd Stage 3rd Stage 4th Stage 5th Stage
1.
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
Z / Z0e
Z / Z0f
(1 - e -Z/Zoe)
(1 - e -Z/Zof)
(M)
0.35
4.85
9.56
9.63
14.60
19.56
19.63
23.59
27.56
27.63
33.60
39.56
39.63
51.54
63.44
46.12
0.036
0.493
0.972
0.980
1.485
1.990
1.997
2.399
2.803
2.810
3.418
4.024
4.031
5.242
6.453
4.691
0.025
0.352
0.695
0.700
1.061
1.421
1.426
1.714
2.002
2.007
2.441
2.874
2.879
3.745
4.609
3.351
0.03497
0.38941
0.62183
0.62451
0.77351
0.86324
0.86422
0.90923
0.93939
0.93982
0.96721
0.98212
0.98224
0.99471
0.99842
0.99082
0.02511
0.29698
0.50071
0.50325
0.65380
0.75856
0.75978
0.81984
0.86498
0.86567
0.91294
0.94354
0.94383
0.97635
0.99004
0.96494
Emptying
0.245
2.726
4.353
4.372
5.415
6.043
6.050
6.365
6.576
6.579
6.770
6.875
6.876
6.963
(1 - e ( -Z/Zo ) )
Z
(M)
0.35
4.85
9.56
9.63
14.60
19.56
19.63
23.59
27.56
27.63
33.60
39.56
39.63
51.54
(Pi)max
During Filling
0.24191
2.86133
4.82421
4.84861
6.29919
7.30844
7.32024
7.89890
8.33382
8.34042
8.79590
9.09069
9.09345
9.40686
9.53871
9.29690
63.44
6.930
6.989
23501.83
M2
0.27618
30050
10.55
N/mm
>
<
10.64
29056
OK
Including moment for wind/seismic load. So 33.33% allowable stress will increase
Minm. % of Vertical Rebars to be provided as per code
As reqd.
0.20
3.10
475
mm2
Provide 16 @ 120 c/c (IF), 20 @ 120 c/c (OF) upto 3 stage & 12 @ 120 c/c (IF), 16 @ 120 c/c(OF) above 3 stage of wall
Design against Hoop Tension due to Load Ph
rd
Kd
1.0
Kl
Height
1st Stage 2nd Stage 3rd Stage 4th Stage 5th Stage
rd
1.0
Overpressure Co-efficient
Design
Factored
Hoop Tension
T = Ph * D / 2
Steel
from top
Reqd.
s reqd.
s prov.
(M)
0.35
4.85
9.56
9.63
14.60
19.56
19.63
23.59
27.56
27.63
33.60
39.56
39.63
51.54
63.44
T/M
0.337
3.752
5.991
6.017
7.453
8.317
8.326
8.760
9.051
9.055
9.319
9.462
9.464
9.584
9.619
T/M
0.590
6.566
10.484
10.530
13.042
14.555
14.571
15.330
15.839
15.846
16.308
16.559
16.561
16.772
16.834
T/M of Height
6.037
67.216
107.334
107.797
133.516
149.006
149.173
156.944
162.149
162.223
166.951
169.524
169.546
171.699
172.339
mm /m
257.41081
2866.0219
4576.6441
4596.3915
5693.0243
6353.4755
6360.6165
6691.9603
6913.9006
6917.0655
7118.6631
7228.3698
7229.3036
7321.0766
7348.3919
mm
16
16
16
16
16
16
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
mm (c/c)
1562
140
88
87
71
63
99
94
91
91
88
87
87
86
86
mm (c/c)
90
90
90
70
70
70
75
75
75
75
75
75
65
65
65
mm
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
25
25
25
25
25
25
Rebars (OF
3.11 Temperature Change through Bin Wall (refer IS: 4995 Part II - 1974)
o
o
i
o
C
C
=
90
=
5
( i
t
Cc
1
Ca
t
Cc
M
c
Therefore,
=
=
5000
/
1
Cs
1
15
c
x
SQRT cu/2
893098.96 cm4
M
= 13.067839 T-M/M
Ast
= 1419.6211 mm2/M
46.14
0.475
2
1
7.5
0.4375
where,
136930.639376 kg/cm
0.000011
i)
Calculation of Crack-Width for Silo Wall (refer IS: 4995 Part II - 1974)
'
cr
) sa
=
10^(-6)
( 4
po
'
po
As
2.00
As
Act
cm
=
118.46
0.05
sa
Act
4750.00
cm2
3610.5
mm
OK
0.003
6
x
po
)2
sa
2.494
cm2
ii) Minimum thickness of Silo Wall (refer IS: 4995 Part II - 1974)
t
= 10 + 2.5 * ( D - 3 ) / 3
=
241.67
mm
= 10 + 2.5 * ( h - 6 ) / 12
=
219.67
mm
t
=
150
mm (Minimum for Slipform Concrete)
t
t(min)
241.67
mm
Provided
475.00
iii) Minimum thickness of Silo Wall (refer IS: 4995 Part II - 1974)
(n*Es + sa - mt')
t(min) =
* (Ty)st
(100*sa*t')
3.12
n
Es
2000000 kg/cm2
sa
1454.8665 kg/cm2
Modular ratio
280/3/cbc
cbc
100
t'
(Ty)st
t(min)
134.38
9.333
kg/cm
1.19*sqrt(cu)
1723
6.52
kg/cm3
kg/cm
mm
10.05
=
=
6.50
8.25
M
N/mm2
<
<
N/mm2
8.0
10.64
OK
OK
Including moment for wind/seismic load. So 33.33% allowable stress will increase
Minm. % of Vertical Rebars to be provided as per code
Provide
16
@
120
on each face of the silo
Minm. % of Circumferential Rebars to be provided as per code
Provide
25
@
120
on each face of the silo
3.13
=
=
17.42
Tm/m
450
1897.4
66.0
339.9
340.5
1.35
0.75625
mm
mm2/m
As reqd.
0.20
0.25
=
As reqd.
850
=
mm2
1062.5
0.14073
0.18609
Depth
0.77
2.30
3.83
5.36
6.89
8.43
9.96
11.49
13.02
14.55
Total
Dia
Ph
Pv
Normal
Tangent
0.88
2.65
4.42
6.19
7.96
9.73
11.50
13.27
15.04
16.81
11.86
11.89
11.89
11.85
11.77
11.60
11.33
10.91
10.26
9.24
23.73
23.77
23.78
23.71
23.53
23.21
22.66
21.81
20.51
18.48
17.95
17.98
17.98
17.93
17.80
17.55
17.14
16.50
15.51
13.98
3.34
3.35
3.35
3.34
3.31
3.27
3.19
3.07
2.89
2.60
Cantilever Mom
Diff. In Mom. (Temp. Codn.)
Diff. In Mom. (Cantilever Codn.)
Design Mom
Axial Force (imposed)
Net Axial Force
Net Vertical Force (F)
Eff. Depth
Mom about Tensile Steel
Maxm. Mom without comp. Steel
Comp. Steel Reqd
Tensile Steel Reqd.
41.6
2.0
12.6
38.8
15
111.7
112.9
450.0
61.2
56.3
1000
985.9
TM
TM
TM
TM
T
T
T
MM
TM
TM
mm2
mm2
2000
mm
Friction
Vert. Wl
6.85
6.86
6.86
6.84
6.79
6.70
6.54
6.30
5.92
5.34
99.60
Mom abt
Ten. Steel
20.77
27.20
33.63
40.00
46.19
52.07
57.38
61.79
64.69
65.03
Tensile St
Reqd.
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
1897.36
Comp.St.
Reqd.
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
1000.00
Comp.
Force
16.76
48.92
81.07
112.89
143.88
173.24
199.83
221.85
236.39
238.06
651.867532754
Tensile Steel=T*10/.23
28342.067 mm2
This force will be resisted by hoop steel in ring beam and in part of wall adjacent to ring beam (effective height 2M)
Reinf in Wall :- 25 @70 c/c + 25 @ 140 c/c + 20 @140 c/c =
25014.9315 mm2
Reinf in Ring Beaml :- 10-20 f +12-25 f =
12867.96351 mm2
Total
37882.89501 OK
3.15 Design of Bracket
Total material weight =
Frictional Forces =
Weight of Upper wall =
38012
6258
7776
=
=
=
0.87*fy*d
0.87*fy^2/(fck*b)
Area of Steel required for torsion
Area required for hoop tension
Total reinforcement area required
Reinforcement provided
=
=
123.76
T
T
T
85.5
475
T-m/m
T-m/m
100.75
337942.8 N/mm
4.7476473 N/mm3
3117.6853 mm2
=
=
6099.1929 mm2
21-32 + 15-25
24252.31 mm2
505.37
99.60
9216.8782 mm
763
517
202
850
OK
(1 - e ( -Z/Zo ) )
Lateral Pressure (T/M2)
During Filling
0.24191
2.86133
4.82421
4.84861
6.29919
7.30844
7.32024
7.89890
8.33382
8.34042
8.79590
9.09069
9.09345
9.40686
9.53871
9.29690
OK
Overpressure Co-efficient
1.75
s reqd.
s prov.
mm
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
25
25
25
25
25
25
mm (c/c)
203
110
85
85
74
68
68
66
64
101
99
98
98
97
96
mm (c/c)
90
90
90
70
70
70
60
60
60
75
75
75
70
70
70
0.01458677
<
0.02
OK
mm2
Comp.
Force
16.76
48.92
81.07
112.89
143.88
173.24
199.83
221.85
236.39
238.06
Allowable
Force
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
375.00
202
800
25.31
Vertical
Force
29.16
175.29
292.20
407.94
520.63
627.44
724.13
804.22
857.08
863.17
5301.26