Linear Loaded Vert 80-40
Linear Loaded Vert 80-40
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
T op of article
1 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
As a lot of you will appreciate, to work good DX requires a low angle of radiation from the antenna.
It is possible to achieve this low angle with a horizontal antenna, but only if sufficient height above
ground can be achieved. T hough this is possible on the higher bands, it is nigh on impossible at 40
metres and 80 metres (at least in the majority of UK sites). T he vertical antenna looks to be the
perfect low angle radiator, except for one thing... the height of a 1/4 l at 80 metres is 20 metres, or
66 feet, which is not practical to construct, erect or, more importantly, keep erected.
I started this article with a bold statement, which needs some explanation for those of you who do
not appreciate how a low angle of radiation can work better DX . So here is a simplified description
of how radio signals radiate from an antenna.
In figure 1, the signal transmitted from a horizontal antenna mounted at 1/4 l over a perfect earth is
shown. In figure 2, this is represented with the same antenna at less than 1/4 l over the same
perfect earth. A perfect earth is considered as a flat surface which is a perfect conductor and
contains no resistive losses. In practice, this is impossible to obtain, but for the purpose of these
illustrations it is adequate, and keeps the explanation clear and easy to comprehend. In figure 3, it
can be seen that the vertical antenna shown, has a much lower angle of radiation.
2 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
Most of the problems with home-made antennas are what I call the 3 'M's - materi al s,
mechani cal and man-power.
Materi al s are usually the first stumbling block, and a good imagination along with some
experimenting can provide excellent results. I use a lot of peculiar objects when experimenting
with antennas, from plastic sandwich boxes to electric car antenna units. A look around your
favourite DIY shop can produce a number of useful objects; check the plumbing department for any
number of different plastic and metal fittings. From the hardware department, there are metal
brackets, screws, bolts and fittings, and from the kitchenware department, there are a multitude of
useful plastic boxes (most of which are waterproof). Another good source of tubing is an office
furniture manufacturer, and it is often much cheaper than a traditional source.
When it comes to designing a vertical with a loading coil the two major items for the shopping list
are the metal tubing for the element and an appropriate former for the coil. In my experience, it is
always the coil former which causes the most problems. T he best solution I have ever found is to
make my own using a piece of the tubing to be joined as a mould and filling this with epoxy resin.
When the resin has set, I cut lengthways down the tubing to expose a perfect insulator. Maplin
Electronics sell a 'potting compound' which works extremely well. However, if this is for a loading
coil at the base of a tall vertical, then the diameter of the former has to be greatly oversized to
provide enough strength.
Mechani cal problems probably top most peoples lists, when it comes to building antennas. T his
requires only a bit of experience, some basic testing and the willingness to re-design anything which
doesn't work first time. Do not expect 'professional' results from your first antenna building
efforts, or you will be sadly disappointed. Instead, try and get the antenna working first, test it and
see that it can withstand the rigours of the weather - then improve the design and build version 2.
Every experiment which works, should be detailed and perhaps used again in another design later. I
remember seeing a dustbin on top of a friends car, at a radio rally. So, I inquired what it was for and
3 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
how did it work, he showed me, in detail, all the notes he had taken on every stage of the
development, up to the final version (I think it was version 5...). It was, of course, a mobile antenna
for 160M, using the plastic dustbin as a former for the coil and an ingenious tuning mechanism using
a plastic spatula with a piece of copper board stuck to it for the fine tuning. Ingenuity is the key to
success.
When designing a vertical antenna, two areas of the mechanical construction usually cause
problems; the first is how to connect all the sections of tubing to be mechanically strong and
electrically bonded and the second is the connections to the feedline and matching network.
I think most people can make an electrical bond sufficient for an experimental antenna (I use
electricians 'chocolate block'), but for a permanent installation, of the final version, then the type
of materials used for screws, hardware and etc. must be considered as well as adequate
weatherproofing. T his is especially true when two (or more) dissimilar metals are joined together.
T his leaves the mechanical side of things to explore. Because not all the materials you might use in
your antenna were designed for the special environment of home made antennas, you need to
experiment and test new materials. Simple tests, like connecting a number pieces of tubing together
and seeing how it stands up when there is a light breeze, a winter storm, or heavy rain. If you are
designing a horizontal beam then experiment how long an element you can make before requiring a
truss to support the ends and, if necessary, the best place for the truss-to-element connections.
Other tests I perform are to leave a piece of an insulator material I want to test, out in the sun for a
summer and see what happens to it. UV (Ultra-Violet) energy from the sun, acid rain, and
temperature fluctuation, breaks down a lot of materials, including some which were designed for
outdoor use! Of course, and insulator must also insulate and I subject my samples to about 30
seconds in the microwave oven, to check for heating. If the sample is cold when it comes out, then
it is a good sign that it is an insulator to RF. I always put a glass of water in the microwave beside
the sample, in case it is a perfect insulator, otherwise damage to the microwave oven can occur.
My final 'M' is for man-power. Usually, though not always, home-made antennas are heavier and
more cumbersome than commercial antennas. T his is usually because they are built from available
materials rather than custom made components. For reasons of safety, and ease of installation, get
help when erecting, adjusting or dismantling an experimental antenna (T his, of course, is also valid
for any antenna work - but more so for home-made ones). I get help from my next door neighbour,
who is not an amateur and doesn't make wise-cracks about my latest inventions, but a friendly (is
there any other type?) amateur is better than trying to do it yourself. Remember, if the antenna
falls off the roof, you end up with a pile of junk metal, but if you fall off the roof you end up in
hospital. Safety first, at all times is the key to successful installations. Even if you are lucky enough
to have a pump-up or tilt-over tower, watch out for electric power lines and telephone cables, etc.
OK, so let's get back to my linear loaded vertical for 40 and 80 metres.
T op of article
4 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
build one.
5 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
T op of article
Well, he bought the idea, hook, line and sinker, and the next weekend he hired a digger to lift all the
turf and laid a complete covering of the ground in close-spaced chicken wire. I ensured that all the
sections of the wire were 'properly' joined together and that copper ground rods were installed to
hold the mesh in the ground. T hat was a year ago, and there are no mole hills in the part of the
garden he covered, so his problem was solved, and, cunningly, I got a nice groundplane covering
about 50 square metres. I also took the opportunity to bury some garden hose from the shack to the
centre of the garden which I use to run my coax cables out to the centre of the garden. Oh
joy...much better DX with my Cushcraft vertical - but everything has its downside, the radiation
pattern from my 80M dipole at 6 metres high was so altered by the new groundplane that I could no
longer work the UK reliably, all the signals were going skywards. I moved the dipole to the edge of
the earth mat and raised it by 2 metres, and that made all the difference.
Now, I appreciate, having lived in a flat near London for 8 years, that not every site can have an
installation like mine. Do the best you can with the property you have.
T op of article
6 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
length of tubing was squeezed in a vice to square off the sides and provide a secure mounting place
for the strips. T he strips, themselves, were simply placed in the vice at 50mm, heated slightly with
a blow-torch and bent to a 90 degree angle.
At a later date, in order to supply some extra strength to the top-hat assembly, a small (150mm)
circular aluminium plate was placed over the top of the element to support the strips of the
capacity hat. T he strips were screwed tightly to the plate using self taping screws through the holes
in the plate. T his altered the tuning only slightly.
T op of article
7 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
so:
Length of tubing total = 8000mm
Length required = 7736mm
Difference = 8000 - 7736 = 264mm
3 joins required therefore each = 264/3 = 88mm
I always find it easier to convert all the terms of my equations to the smallest common base,
before doing the calculations, in this case I chose millimetres.
8 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
T he wire is stiff enough to hold this shape with the stand off insulators, in all but the absolute worst
of outdoor weather.
I made the stand-off insulators from a piece of plastic strip which is used to edge
MDF furniture. T he strip was cut into lengths and screwed to the main radiator
with a self-tapping screw. I cut 5 strips of 50mm, 14 strips of 120mm and one
strip of 320mm, which used most of the 2.75-metre length of plastic strip.T his
type of strip has an edging on each side, and holes were drilled in these edges to
accept the wires.
Each wire was held in place on the insulator with hot-melt glue after the final testing and alignment
was performed.
9 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
10 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
After getting the antenna matched to the transmitter I hot-melt glued all the wires to the plastic
insulators and made permanent connections to the two feedlines inside a plastic weatherproof box,
which was mounted on the bottom of the radiator element. Originally, I designed the antenna for
40M only, and added the 80M length afterwards, based on the success I had with the 40M version.
Both antennas are mounted on the same telescopic radiator, and each is fed with a separate coaxial
feeder. A switch or relay could be mounted at the base to allow a single feeder to the shack. I tried
connecting both elements together and feeding them from one feeder, and 40M worked perfectly,
however, 80M was unusable with this configuration, as the 40M length is effectively shorting out
the 80M element.
T o make the antenna portable you could cut the element wires and re-joined them with electricians
'chocolate block' so that the antenna could be dismantled and transported in a easy way. After having
tried this, I reassembled the entire antenna and the whole antenna was tested again. T he tests
showed that nothing much had changed.
Knowing that not all amateurs can have a groundplane such as mine, I made four 20-metre radials and
linear loaded them into a 10 metre square area, in an attempt to emulate a common UK 'postage
stamp' garden. I then erected the antenna and attached it to this groundplane and checked the VSW R
again. T here was virtually no difference in the VSW R readings (1.5:1 instead of 1.2:1), however, the
DX I could hear and work was slightly weaker than when the antenna was in the middle of my big
groundplane.
T op of article
11 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
One great thing about this antenna is that no special tools or skills are required to construct it, you
do not need to cut any of the tubing, make any fancy brackets, buy any special parts or construct a
complicated matching network. A small drill, a tape measure, a screwdriver, some glue or a hot-melt
glue gun and a pair of side cutters are all the tools required.
T op of article
The Conclusions
I found the antenna easy and fun to build. Comparing it with my Cushcraft AP8A vertical, the antenna
performs much better for DX on both 80M and 40M. I built a full size 1/4 wave vertical for 40M for
comparison and the DX was the same with both antenna on 40M. I would like to thank the DX
stations whom put up with me asking them to compare the two antenna and to those stations on this
side for their co-operation and understanding (well most of them, anyway).
T op of article
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
David Reid, 35, was first licensed in 1981 as GM6JLQ in the Borders Region of Scotland. He joined
the RSGB in 1980 after spending many hours in the shack of GM4CX P, Derrick. David was also the
first UK Class 'B' radio amateur to be awarded a CW certificate (by the GQRP club - working under
a variance on his class 'B' callsign). In 1985, he passed his CW exam and became GM0BZF. Since
then, he has held numerous callsigns including GJ0BZF, G0BZF and now holds PA3HBB as well as
keeping G0BZF. His interest in antennas began with the citizen band radio era in the late 1970's and
early 1980's. He has been active in the design of antennas right from the beginning of his amateur
hobby. He has had a number of articles published in various magazines (including Radio
Communication). Many people will testify to the strong VHF signals emanating from YP07 square
and X P07 from is home made antennas in the early 80's. His craziest antenna was a 2-metre dish
made from scrap strips of PCB material. T he dish was strapped to the back of a kitchen chair and fed
by a dipole. With only 10 watts of power he was getting 59+ reports from as far as Newcastle and
Hull, from his QT H in the tweed valley. He has been involved with many contests and contest
groups throughout the years and is always trying to improve his antenna systems. He operates
mobile as well and even constructed a monster 160M mobile antenna from copper plumbing pipe
and litz wire.
David also makes and sells low cost amateur radio kits from his web-site and through Syon T rading in
the UK, these include morse electronic keyers and morse tutors - both on a 25.4mm PCB
Professionally, he has a background in electronics and computer hardware, but these day is making a
living in Europe as a technical author/editor.
Re fe re nce s
1. T he Antenna Experimenter's Guide, G3LDO, Peter Dodd, first edition, Sept 1991, DD
publications, ISBN 0 9516024 0 3
2. Radio Data Reference Book, G6JP, G.R.Jessop, fifth edition,1985, RSGB, ISBN 0 900612 67
3
3. ARRL Antenna Anthology, "Linear loaded 20-meter beam", W 0YNF, Cole Collinge,
QST ,1788, ARRL, Library of congress catalog card 78-71955
13 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM
http://www.qsl.net/pa3hbb/ll.htm
T op of article
14 of 14
04/18/2009 02:09 PM