2014 CEO Pay in The Eurotop 100
2014 CEO Pay in The Eurotop 100
2014 CEO Pay in The Eurotop 100
Contents
Introduction, highlights and key pay trends
3-4
5-9
Analysis of
Actual Total Direct Compensation (TDC)
1015
1621
2224
Appendices
2533
Our services
2 towerswatson.com
34
Introduction
t There is much talk of pay convergence across
Europe but the differences in pay levels and
practices for the chief executives of the
Eurotop 100 are as interesting as the similarities.
t The Shareholders Rights Directive will bring
more commonality of reporting and voting on
board pay (whatever the board structure
unitary or dual) for all companies incorporated in
European Union member states.
t Many institutional shareholders have regional if
not global reach and are calling for the similar
policies and practices in the jurisdictions in
which their investee companies operate in
search of the holy grail of alignment of interest.
t Nevertheless, while the components of pay
and some of their features may be similar, the
mix of pay continues to differ across Europe
and regulatory intervention in some markets is
driving more difference.
t Our 2014 report the second we have
published - provides a snapshot of
compensation levels, incentive design practices
and emerging remuneration trends for CEOs in
the Eurotop 100.
t We summarise key pay trends and
recent corporate governance developments
(with specific focus on the Shareholders
Rights Directive) as well as an analysis of
CEO remuneration levels and incentive design
practices observed in the last financial year in a
selection of markets.
t Our analysis covers 95 companies within
the Eurotop 100 which had published their
remuneration reports as at 10 June 2014.
Since our last report published in 2013, three
companies have joined the index (Associated
British Foods, Continental and Credit Agricole)
and three companies have left the index
(Centrica, Rolls-Royce and Tenaris).
The median market capitalisation of the
Eurotop100 companies increased by 19.5% from
36,144 million to 43,210 million.
t This list and composition of companies
is included in the appendix together with
details of the LTI valuation methodology
supporting our analysis.
t If you have any questions or would like to
know more, please contact your usual
Towers Watson consultant.
Pay at a glance
CEO pay remains stable
Base salary
t The median base salary level for the
last financial year was approximately
1.277 million for the CEO. We observe
limited change compared to last year of
1.279 million.
t The majority (60%) of companies did not
increase base salary levels for the CEO in
the last financial year.
Annual bonus
t The median actual bonus received for
performance in the last financial year was
115% of base salary for the CEO, similar to
the level reported in the previous year (111%).
t Median target and maximum bonus
opportunity levels for the CEO, where
disclosed, were 100% and 180%
respectively for the last financial year and
remain unchanged from the previous year.
t Deferral of bonus continued to be prevalent.
Getting on for half (43%) of companies
required the executive to compulsorily defer
bonus, typically, 50% of bonus paid.
t Profit/ income, non-financial and individual
measures continued to be the most
prevalent performance measures on shortterm incentive plans.
Long-term incentives
t Most companies made awards of
performance shares with relative TSR being
the most common performance metric
attached to long-term incentive plans.
t For awards granted in the last financial year,
the median long-term incentive expected
value for the CEO was 135% of base salary.
Actual Total Direct Compensation (TDC)
t The median actual TDC level for the
last financial year was approximately
5.4 million for the CEO, a slight increase
from 5.1 million reported last year.
Shareholding guidelines
t Almost half of companies have shareholding
policies. At median, the guideline level was
275% of base salary for the CEO (unchanged).
Short-term
incentives
Long-term
incentives
4 towerswatson.com
Germany - DAX
UK - FTSE 100
Netherlands - AEX
Spain - IBEX 35
r;FSPCBTFQBZ
increase at median
r;FSPCBTFQBZ
increase at median
r.FEJBOCBTFQBZ
increase of 2.5%
r;FSPCBTFQBZ
increase at median
r;FSPCBTFQBZ
increase at median
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r'FXDPNQBOJFT
have increased
maximum
opportunity levels
r*ODSFBTFEGPDVTPO
financial metrics
r*NQMFNFOUBUJPOPG
CSR metrics
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r4USFOHUIFOJOH
of rules and
performance
conditions/metrics
r*ODSFBTFE
introduction of caps
on overall variable
compensation, as
well as lower STI
maximum pay out
opportunities
r*ODSFBTJOHVTFPG
clawback provisions
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r*ODSFBTFE
prevalence of malus
and/or clawback
provisions
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r$PNQBOJFTTUBSUJOH
to consider design
changes
r*ODSFBTJOHVTFPG
clawback provisions
r*ODSFBTJOHVTF
of non-financial
measures
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r-JNJUFEDIBOHFT
to design
r'PSNBMJTBUJPOPG
qualitative factors
r/FXNFUSJDTBOE
performance scales
r-FWFMTTUBCMFJO
terms of number of
shares but higher in
terms of face value
r*OUSPEVDUJPOPG
supplementary
performance
conditions
r*ODSFBTJOHTUSFUDI
in performance
conditions
r7FIJDMFNJYDIBOHFT
towards shares or
cash-based plans
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r'VSUIFS
implementation of
4-year performance
periods
r/FXQFSGPSNBODF
metrics
r*ODSFBTFE
introduction of caps
on overall variable
compensation
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r%FDMJOFPGTIBSF
matching plans
r*ODSFBTFE
prevalence of
extended holding
periods
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
r.PSFTUSJOHFOU
performance
conditions
r%FDSFBTFE
weighting on
TSR or change
in measurement
methodology
r'VSUIFS
implementation
of qualitative
performance
criteria
r-FWFMTSFNBJO
stable
rPGDPNQBOJFT
have implemented
changes to plan
design
r*ODMVTJPOPG543
conditions mixed
with operational
metrics
r.PSFTIBSFCBTFE
plans
Disclosure, voting
and fiscal changes
Improved disclosure
and binding vote on
policy proposed
r%JTDMPTF
standardised tables
for: pay realised,
showing minimum,
target and
maximum pay-out
levels
Disclosure
Say on pay
Pay caps
Tax
Other
6 towerswatson.com
Germany
r/POCJOEJOH
shareholder votes
on remuneration
awarded to the
CEO and other
corporate officers
(mandataires
sociaux and
administrateurs)
r$BQPG
p.a. on base pay
and bonus of
corporate officers
of state-controlled
businesses
UK
Netherlands
r/FXSFQPSUJOH
framework
r5ISFFZFBS
forward-looking
binding vote on
remuneration
policy and annual,
advisory vote on
all remuneration
realised over
the year
r$PNQBOJFTTIPVME
define absolute pay
caps for short- and
long-term and total
compensation
Spain
r/FXUFNQMBUFT
have to be used
for remuneration
reports
r.BOEBUPSZ
discussion of
remuneration
policy during AGM
binding vote on
policy changes
already in place
r1SPQPTFE
binding vote on
remuneration
policy at least
every three years
r4IBSFIPMEFS
approval of
maximum total
remuneration as
well as of fixed
and variable
remuneration
r$BQPOHBJO
on share price
increase as a result
of a corporate
events - applicable
to shares received
as compensation
r$BQPOOBODJBM
entities that
have received
money from the
Government
r-FHBM
implementation of
clawback and test
of reasonableness
r-JNJUBUJPOPG
(tax facilitated)
pension accrual
(as per 2015)
r1SPQPTBMUPSFEVDF
NEDs appointment
to four years
r$PNCJOFE$&0
Chairman to be
approved by two
thirds of the Board
r5BSHFUHFOEFS
balance
r4VQFSUBYPO
remuneration
package over 1m
with the employer
paying 50%, along
with social taxes
r$POTJEFSBUJPO
of relationship
between pay
development of
executive board vs.
staff generally
r$POTJEFSBUJPO
of relationship
between pay
development of
executive board vs.
staff generally
Remuneration Policy
Remuneration Report
REVIEW
ACT
Business
Strategy
Alignment
Governance
Record
ENGAGE
VOTE
N
Historic
View
Lens
1
Lens
5
Lens
2
Lens
4
Stakeholder
View
DRAFT
Lens
3
E
S
Future
View
Review current
arrangements from
new perspectives
Amend policies,
practices, plans
as relevant
Engage investors,
directors and other
stakeholders
AGM
8 towerswatson.com
Long-term pay
Disclosure
Say on pay
Differentials
Termination
Governance
CRD IV
AIFMD
UCITS V
2016/17
Implementation Schedule
2014
Solvency II
LQ
Median
UQ
1,451,686
1,150,000
1,277,285
1,505,818
Actual Bonus
(% of base)
128%
51%
115%
155%
Target Bonus
(% of base)
115%
76%
100%
135%
Maximum Bonus
(% of base)
205%
140%
180%
230%
3,225,285
1,988,938
2,852,375
3,742,813
173%
58%
135%
241%
5,558,642
3,561,165
5,395,740
6,926,587
Base Salary
Actual TDC
10 towerswatson.com
7,840
7,910
6,610
6,630
5,860
6,235
4,800
Utilities (n=4)
4,715
5,210
4,995
Banks/Insurance (n=18)
5,280
Technology/Telecoms (n=6)
4,090
4,685
4,645
3,500
Industrials (n=7)
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
2,550
7,018 (n=7)
7,635 (n=8)
Switzerland
6,100 (n=17)
5,705 (n=21)
UK
6,071 (n=5)
Spain
7,215 (n=5)
5,720 (n=3)
Benelux
3,965 (n=5)
5,665 (n=15)
6,305 (n=15)
Germany
4,878 (n=2)
4,130 (n=4)
Italy
3,950 (n=16)
3,785 (n=14)
France
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
2,106 (n=7)
1,910 (n=7)
Nordics
12 towerswatson.com
14,000
y = 2594.7ln(x) - 22552
2
R = 0.24787
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
200,000
180,000
160,000
140,000
120,000
100,000
80,000
60,000
40,000
20,000
2,000
UK
Spain
Italy
Germany
France
Switzerland
Benelux
Nordics
Banks/
Insurance
Consumer
Goods/
Services
Basic
Materials
Technology/
Telecoms
Health
Care
Median
market
capitalisation
(millions)
32,891
35,908
43,463
45,463
53,045
55,324
70,860
98,854
Median CEO
actual TDC
(thousands)
3,500
4,800
5,210
6,610
4,685
5,280
5,860
7,840
Industrials
Health Care
Consumer
Goods/Ser.
Oil & Gas
Technology/
Telecoms
Banks/Ins.
Utilities
Basic
Materials
Industrials
Median Market Cap
Statistics by Country (sorted by market cap)
Median
market
capitalisation
(millions)
Median CEO
actual TDC
(thousands)
Benelux
France
Italy
Nordics
Switzerland
UK
Germany
Spain
29,722
37,495
39,118
44,448
48,022
53,045
55,239
55,310
5,720
3,950
3,220
2,106
7,169
6,100
5,665
6,071
Switzerland
UK
Spain
Benelux
Germany
France
Italy
Nordics
Median Market Cap
14 towerswatson.com
100
57% 49%
27% 31%
52% 50%
50% 42%
35% 31%
38% 34%
18% 17%
17% 19%
90
37%
80
46%
19%
12%
48%
70
36%
45%
60
69%
25%
32%
64%
28%
30%
50
13%
22%
40
22%
22%
45%
23%
41%
38%
37%
33% 33%
30
20
25% 24%
26%
28%
34%
28% 28%
20%
Benelux
Base salary %
Germany
UK
Actual bonus %
Switzerland
France
Italy
Spain
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
10
2013
Nordics
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
Profit/Income Measure
52%
49%
Individual
38%
31%
Cashflow
31%
24%
EPS
Operating Margin
19%
19%
15%
Customer Service
8%
5%
TSR
5%
3%
2%
1%
Share Price
0%
10%
20%
16 towerswatson.com
These cover
a wide range
of strategic
measures.
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
UK
Spain
Italy
Germany
France
Switzerland
Benelux
Nordics
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
Many companies in
Switzerland and
Benelux operate 2
or more plans
17% No plan
16 companies do
not operate an
LTI plan
These include
restricted shares,
share matching plans,
stock options and plans
with pre-grant
performance conditions.
26% None
15% Three measures
18 towerswatson.com
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
80
78%
70
60
50
These are
most common
in UK, Switzerland
and Nordics.
40
30
20
23%
19%
Typically operated
in Switzerland,
Nordic and Benelux.
18%
10
11%
0
Performance
shares/units
Share matching
plans
Stock options/
units
Long-term
cash
Restricted shares/
units
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
Restricted shares/units
Benelux
Performance shares/units
France
Performance shares/units
Stock option/units
Long-term cash
Stock option/units
Performance shares/units
Germany
Long-term cash
Italy
Long-term cash
Performance shares/units
Performance shares/units
Nordics
Restricted shares/units
Stock option/units
Performance shares/units
Switzerland
Performance shares/units
While share
matching plans are
gaining prevalence
in Germany, they are
declining in the UK.
Long-term cash
Share matching plans
Restricted shares/units
Stock option/units
Long-term cash
Restricted shares/units
UK
Performance shares/units
20 towerswatson.com
Pay for performance and analysis of incentive design and shareholding guidelines
Shareholding guidelines
Almost half of companies impose shareholding guidelines.
t Shareholding guidelines are most common in
UK and French Eurotop 100 companies.
t Guidelines are typically expressed as a
percentage of base salary. At median,
51% Yes
40
44%
30
Shareholding
guidelines are not
common in Spain.
27%
20
13%
10
8%
4%
0
UK
France
Switzerland
Germany
Nordics
2%
Italy
2%
0%
Benelux
Spain
Executive Directors
Compensation
t Short-term incentive
performance measures and
relative weightings
t Short-term incentive
deferral analysis
t Long-term incentive vehicles
t Long-term incentive
performance measures,
relative weightings and
performance targets
t Long-term incentive
performance periods,
vesting arrangements and
holding periods
t Analysis of forward-looking
amendments to short and
long-term incentive plans
and details of new plans
t Analysis of shareholding
guidelines
Chairmens and
Non-Executive Directors
Compensation
t Base/fixed fee levels
t Chairmanship and
membership fees for board
committees (e.g. audit,
remuneration, nomination)
t Attendance fees and
travel allowances
t Other incentives
and benefits
22 towerswatson.com
Belgium
BEL20
BELMID
France
CAC 40
SBF 80
Ireland
ISEQ 20
Italy
MIB 40
Germany
DAX 30
MDAX
SDAX
Nordics
OMX Sweden
OMX Denmark
OBX Norway
AEX
AMX
AScX
IBEX 35
IBEX Medium
Cap
SMI
SMI MID
FTSE 100
FTSE 250
Netherlands
Spain
Switzerland
UK
TecDAX
Contact name
Phone
UK and Ireland
Richard Belfield
Sonia Padda
Laurent Nguyen
+33 1 53 93 13 14
Gerald Joliy
+33 1 53 93 13 38
Helmuth L. Uder
Stephanie Schmelter
Hans Muench
Maike Wehage
Sven Slavenburg
Manuel Montecelos
Cristina Martin
Edoardo Cesarini
+39 06 367361
Leonardo Mansueto
Anders Tapper
Mikael Ullen
Noemie Tack
France
Germany
Switzerland
Netherlands
Spain
Italy
Nordics
Belgium
24 towerswatson.com
Appendices
Country
Market Capitalisation
( m)
Sector
Nordics
40,521
Industrials
ABB LIMITED
Switzerland
39,880
Industrials
AIR LIQUIDE
France
33,514
Basic Materials
AIRBUS GROUP
France
41,183
Industrials
"--*"/;
Germany
56,492
Banks/Insurance
ANGLO AMERICAN
UK
25,096
Basic Materials
"/)&64&3#64$)*/#&7
Benelux
129,801
Consumer Goods/Services
ASML HOLDING
Benelux
28,436
Technology/Telecoms
UK
29,679
Consumer Goods/Services
"453";&/&$"
UK
67,523
Health Care
ATLAS COPCO AB
Nordics
25,840
Industrials
AXA
France
43,717
Banks/Insurance
#"/$0#*-#"07*;$":""3(&/5"3*" Spain
55,310
Banks/Insurance
BANCO SANTANDER
Spain
88,712
Banks/Insurance
#"3$-":4
UK
48,981
Banks/Insurance
BASF
Germany
78,328
Basic Materials
#":&3
Germany
87,301
Basic Materials
BG GROUP
UK
51,300
BHP BILLITON*
UK
127,951
Basic Materials
BMW
Germany
58,752
Consumer Goods/Services
BNP PARIBAS
France
64,126
Banks/Insurance
BP
UK
112,846
UK
82,186
Consumer Goods/Services
BT GROUP
UK
38,718
Technology/Telecoms
CHRISTIAN DIOR*
France
27,205
Consumer Goods/Services
CONTINENTAL
Germany
34,721
Consumer Goods/Services
CREDIT AGRICOLE
France
28,893
Banks/Insurance
CREDIT SUISSE
Switzerland
35,165
Banks/Insurance
DAIMLER
Germany
74,235
Consumer Goods/Services
DANONE
France
34,932
Consumer Goods/Services
DEUTSCHE BANK
Germany
30,366
Banks/Insurance
DEUTSCHE POST
Germany
32,891
Industrials
DEUTSCHE TELEKOM
Germany
55,239
Technology/Telecoms
DIAGEO*
UK
58,914
Consumer Goods/Services
Appendices
Country
Market Capitalisation
( m)
Sector
E ON
Germany
28,586
Utilities
ELECTRICITE DE FRANCE
France
47,449
Utilities
ENEL
Italy
39,118
Utilities
ENI
Italy
67,668
ERICSSON B
Nordics
29,904
Technology/Telecoms
(%'46&;
France
49,523
Utilities
"44*$63";*0/*(&/&3"-*
Italy
25,829
Banks/Insurance
GLAXOSMITHKLINE
UK
94,403
Health Care
GLENCORE XSTRATA*
UK
53,045
Basic Materials
).)&//&4."63*5;"#
Nordics
51,945
Consumer Goods/Services
HEINEKEN
Benelux
29,722
Consumer Goods/Services
)&/,&-"($0.1"/:,(""
Germany
34,625
Consumer Goods/Services
HERMES INTERNATIONAL
France
27,448
Consumer Goods/Services
HSBC HOLDINGS
UK
146,125
Banks/Insurance
IBERDROLA
Spain
33,665
Utilities
UK
31,571
Consumer Goods/Services
INDITEX
Spain
65,792
Consumer Goods/Services
ING GROEP
Benelux
40,175
Banks/Insurance
INTESA SANPAOLO
Italy
40,011
Banks/Insurance
KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS
ELECTRONICS NA
Benelux
22,190
Industrials
LINDE
Germany
28,881
Basic Materials
--0:%4#"/,*/((3061
UK
68,508
Banks/Insurance
LOREAL
France
77,677
Consumer Goods/Services
-7.)
France
73,826
Consumer Goods/Services
.6/$)&/&336&$,7&34*$)&36/(4
GESELLSCHAFT
Germany
27,803
Banks/Insurance
NATIONAL GRID
UK
38,150
Utilities
NESTLE
Switzerland
185,549
Consumer Goods/Services
NORDEA BANK
Nordics
44,448
Banks/Insurance
/07"35*4
Switzerland
175,672
Health Care
/070/03%*4,
Nordics
83,762
Health Care
ORANGE
France
31,641
Technology/Telecoms
PERNOD-RICARD
France
23,516
Consumer Goods/Services
26 towerswatson.com
Appendices
Country
Market Capitalisation
( m)
Sector
PRUDENTIAL
UK
43,210
Banks/Insurance
RECKITT BENCKISER
UK
45,463
Consumer Goods/Services
3&140-:1'
Spain
26,636
39,811
Consumer Goods/Services
RIO TINTO
UK
72,038
Basic Materials
ROCHE HOLDING
Switzerland
188,873
Health Care
30:"-#"/,0'4$05-"/%(3061
UK
47,278
Banks/Insurance
30:"-%65$)4)&--
UK
186,655
SABMILLER*
UK
64,342
Consumer Goods/Services
SANOFI
France
103,305
Health Care
SAP
Germany
68,280
Technology/Telecoms
SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC
France
40,058
Industrials
SIEMENS
Germany
86,250
Industrials
SOCIETE GENERALE
France
33,573
Banks/Insurance
STANDARD CHARTERED
UK
40,552
Banks/Insurance
STATOIL
Nordics
70,860
SWISS RE
Switzerland
23,806
Banks/Insurance
4:/(&/5"
Switzerland
26,555
Basic Materials
TELEFONICA
Spain
55,409
Technology/Telecoms
TELENOR
Nordics
26,926
Technology/Telecoms
TELIASONERA
Nordics
23,338
Technology/Telecoms
TESCO
UK
29,308
Consumer Goods/Services
Switzerland
23,553
Consumer Goods/Services
TOTAL
France
120,263
UBS
Switzerland
56,233
Banks/Insurance
UNICREDIT
Italy
38,129
Banks/Insurance
6/*-&7&3
UK
91,994
Consumer Goods/Services
7*/$*
France
32,998
Industrials
7*7&/%*
France
25,953
Consumer Goods/Services
70%"'0/&(3061
UK
66,702
Technology/Telecoms
70-,48"(&/
Germany
88,696
Consumer Goods/Services
70-70
Nordics
22,720
Industrials
;63*$)*/463"/$&(3061
Switzerland
32,483
Banks/Insurance
Appendices
Composition by country
20% France
16% Germany
5% Italy
6% Spain
11% Switzerland
27% UK
10% Nordics
5% Benelux
Composition by industry
9% Basic Materials
6% Health Care
10% Industrials
10% Technology/Telecoms
6% Utilities
24% Banks/Insurance
Market capitalisation ( m)
Revenues ( m)
Lower Quartile
30,969
17,028
Median
43,210
32,031
Upper Quartile
68,394
58,707
28 towerswatson.com
Appendices
CHF
GBP
USD
AUD
HKD
SEK
DKK
NOK
0.8125
1.1777
0.7533
0.727
0.097
0.1156
0.1341
0.1283
Appendices
30 towerswatson.com
Company
Incumbent
ABB Limited
Ulrich Spiesshofer
Anglo American
Mark Cutifani
AP Moller - Maersk
Nils S. Andersen
ASML Holding
Assicurazioni Generali
Mario Greco
Banco Santander
BT Group
Ian Livingston
EDF
Henri Proglio
GDF Suez
Grard Mestrallet
Hermes International
Patrick Thomas
ING Groep
Intesa Sanpaolo
Carlo Messina
Rio Tinto
Tom Albanese
Ross McEwan
Siemens
Joe Kaeser
Swiss Re
Michel M. Lis
Syngenta
Michael Mack
Telenor
Teliasonera
Johan Dennelind
Appendices
Definition
Base salary
The annual base salary received for the last financial year, as reported
in the emoluments table
The percent increase in the annual base salary reported for the last
financial year
Actual bonus
The total annual bonus earned for the last financial year (including
bonus deferred without additional performance conditions)
The sum of base salary (as defined above), actual bonus (as defined
above) and amount received under a profit sharing plan. The analysis
excludes fees received for membership of board
The sum of actual total cash (as defined above) and LTI expected value
(as defined above)
Appendices
Stock options
t The value of stock options is calculated using
a binomial lattice model, based on a number of
input assumptions (as set out below). A discount
is then applied to this value to take account of any
applicable performance vesting conditions.
t Our valuations are based on an expected life
approach when computing the binomial value of
the option. This expected life is taken as the midpoint between the vesting period and the term of
the option (for example, for an option with a 3 year
vesting period and a 10 year life, the expected life
is 6.5 years).
t Where applicable, the relevant performance
condition discount factor is determined by the
type of the applicable condition:
t Relative Total Shareholder Return tests:
A country-specific discount is applied to the
binomial lattice value.
t Absolute share price/Total Shareholder Return
tests: We value such awards by incorporating
the absolute share price target into the binomial
valuation model. For absolute TSR tests,
an equivalent absolute share price target is
calculated using a company specific dividend
yield assumption.
t Internal/non-market tests: We apply a single
discount factor to take account of such
performance conditions. This discount factor is
country-specific, based on our experience of the
average proportion of shares that might typically
be expected to vest, based on typical local
performance condition calibration.
32 towerswatson.com
Performance/restricted shares
t The value of performance / restricted shares
represents the face value of shares (i.e. the
number of shares multiplied by share price) as
at the date of grant, less the value of dividends
paid during the vesting period if participants do
not receive the benefit of these, with a discount
applied to take any applicable performance
vesting conditions into account.
t Where applicable, the relevant performance
condition discount factor is determined by the
type of the applicable condition:
t Relative Total Shareholder Return tests:
We consider the awards specific vesting
schedule and calculate the expected
proportion of shares due to vest, assuming
that all percentile ranks are equally likely to
be achieved. We apply an uplift factor to this
value to take into account the strong correlation
between relative TSR performance and share
price growth. This adjustment factor is 20% if
the comparator group is made up of selected
sector peers, 25% if the company uses a broad
index. For tests comparing the companys
TSR performance to that of an index, we apply
the above methodology, assuming that the
condition is calibrated such that threshold
vesting is achieved for the equivalent of median
performance, and maximum vesting achieved for
the equivalent of upper quartile performance.
t Absolute share price/Total Shareholder Return
tests: We value such awards as nil-cost
options with the performance condition
incorporated into the binomial valuation model
as described above.
t Internal/non-market tests: We apply a single
discount factor to take account of such
performance conditions. This discount factor is
country-specific, based on our experience of the
average proportion of shares that might typically
be expected to vest, based on typical local
performance condition calibration.
t Where there is no defined maximum award size
and awards are expressed as a target number
of shares with the potential for the actual
vesting number to be higher or lower based on
performance levels, the value is more simply the
face value of this target number of shares as at
the date of grant.
Appendices
Input assumptions
Co-investment plans
t Similar to deferred bonus matching plans, we
assume that executives seek to maximise their
reward opportunity and will therefore elect to
co-invest the maximum amount. Co-investment
matching share awards are then valued as
performance share awards (see above).
Dividend yield
t Dividend yield assumptions have been calculated
based on the average actual dividend yield for
each company over the one-year period to
1 January 2013. Where this historic average is
likely to be unrepresentative of future dividend
yield levels, an assumption based on more
detailed analysis is used.
Risk-free rate
t Risk-free rate assumptions have been calculated
based on the yield on a zero-coupon government
bond for the country in which the company is listed
over the vesting period/expected share option
term as at 1 January 2013.
Our services
Our services
Towers Watson is a
full service consulting
company, providing a
comprehensive array of
services in the areas of
talent and rewards, benefits,
and risk and financial
services. Our Executive
Compensation consulting
services include:
Towers Watsons Executive Compensation services
Policy
Analysis
Communication
t Directors Remuneration
Reports
t Assistance on investor
consultations
t Total reward statements
t Training and materials for
non-executive directors
34 towerswatson.com
Towers Watson
71 High Holborn
London
WC1V 6TP
towerswatson.com
/company/towerswatson
@towerswatson
/towerswatson