Borden Drive Extracts
Borden Drive Extracts
Borden Drive Extracts
DRIVE
JOURNEYS THROUGH FILM,
CITIES AND LANDSCAPES
IAIN BORDEN
reaktion books
For Claire
Published by
Reaktion Books Ltd
33 Great Sutton Street
London EC1V 0DX
www.reaktionbooks.co.uk
First published 2012
Copyright Iain Borden 2012
The publishers gratefully acknowledge support for the publication of this book
by the Architecture Research Fund of the Bartlett School of Architecture, ucl
All rights reserved
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying,
recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the publishers.
Printed and bound in/by
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Borden, Iain.
Drive : automobile journeys through film, cities and landscapes.
1. Automobile travel Social aspects. 2. Automobiles in motion pictures.
3. Travel in motion pictures. 4. Automobile travel in literature.
5. Automobile driving History.
I. Title
306.4'819-dc23
isbn: 978 1 78023 026 9
CONTENTS
1
2
3
4
INTRODUCTION 7
CITIES 17
JOURNEYS 67
MOTOPIA 119
ALTERED STATES 167
CONCLUSION 227
REFERENCES 237
SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY 256
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 270
INDEX 273
INTRODUCTION
It is no longer the cars forms and functions that call forth human
dreams but, rather, its handling, and before long, perhaps, we shall
be writing not a mythology of the automobile but a mythology
of driving.1
Roland Barthes
01
Kalifornia
(Dominic Sena,
1993).
DRIVE
listen to the landscape, and the very emotions and attitudes we have
towards this pursuit. Furthermore, this immense assemblage is made
even more complex when we realize that there are differences of
people, cars, speeds, roads, landscapes, historical periods and countries
all of which creates yet more variation.3
With this context firmly in mind, Drive is an exploration of
cultural meanings, as visible and expressed through the real place
of the car: on the road, being driven and operating as a dynamic
machine. As one early motorist, A. B. Filson Young, whose Complete
Motorist provides many illuminating insights into driving and to
which I return many times in this study, stated, the true home of
the motor-car is not in garage or workshop, showroom or factory,
but on the open road. There it comes into its own, there it justifies
itself, there it fulfils its true and appointed destiny.4
In this age of urgent environmental concerns, it is also worth
noting that some might be somewhat aghast at a study of car-driving
cultures. Indeed, much of the most recent academic literature on car
driving has tended to focus on the negative qualities and connotations
of this practice, and to identify the various ways in which non-automotive living might be encouraged. For example, Against Automobility
and several other publications all make substantial contributions to
this necessary and important critique of automotive society.5 By
contrast, Drive, while certainly being aware of many of the negative
qualities of car driving alienation and placelessness, accidents and
death, traffic jams and environmental impact all make an appearance
nonetheless explores just why it is that so many people choose to
drive, seem to enjoy driving and even revel in doing so. In this
sense I am following Ruth Brandons salient remark in her excellent
8
INTRODUCTION
social history of the car, Auto Mobile: How the Car Changed Life,
that we must recognize the intoxicating pleasures of automobility
because we are all addicts now.6 In this context, a consideration of
the cultural and experiential richness of driving seems a worthwhile
trajectory to follow. Indeed, underlying Drive is an implicit engagement with current debates about car-usage that is, it argues that
the role of the private car cannot be simply replaced by improved
forms of public transport without first understanding, and responding to, the various pleasures and experiences offered by automobile
driving. In other words, why do people often seem to prefer their
own car to the number 73 bus?
In this sense, this book is an exploration of the undeniable
delight which many people not all but many, not always but often
derive from driving. A primary concern here is the pleasures of
driving, with such qualities, whether they be perceived and/or real,
as liberation, fun, adventure, encounter, intimacy, visual stimulation,
self-understanding, contemplation, pure speed, risk and danger.
Such pleasures are not simple inventions of our most recent society.
Even by the early 1900s, Filson Young foresaw that the automobile
would not just be the rich mans toy, the idle mans excuses, the
brutish mans weapon but rather should be seen as good genius
that will make of poor mens wishes wings to carry them out of
themselves and their surroundings, out of darkness into sunlight
and the pure air.7 There is, therefore, a history to be told of how
such driving-related perceptions have been borne, and how they
have been carried through for over a century and into all corners of
the world. We need to understand how we have come to love driving
quite so much, while, conversely, it would be at our peril to simply
9
DRIVE
INTRODUCTION
DRIVE
point is to drive. That way you learn more about this society than all
academia could ever tell you.15
In order to undertake this kind of study, many writers and academics have commented on the need for interdisciplinary approaches,
including, in particular, Merriman and the various contributors to
Automobilities. So why then the particular interdisciplinary intersection of Drive, which here brings together concerns with driving
experiences, social space and cinema? The need for a consideration
of driving experience is already outlined above, and in terms of social
space, this book forms part of my general concern with how architectural, urban and other forms of space are constructed socially, and
how these are reproduced in different forms according to different
people, practices, histories, times and cultures.16 But why the additional
element here of a particular (if not wholly exclusive) reference to
cinema, movies and film?
There is of course the simple issue of the sheer extent of
the subject-matter, whereby a vast number of primary sources of
information, from personal diaries and government reports to
enthusiast car magazines and specialist websites, combines with
a wide geographical and historical range, as well as with a plethora
of representational materials such as novels, films, animations,
paintings, sculpture, music and poetry. My own bibliographic
database has over 100,000 references to automobile-related
materials in print-based form alone. A focus on film thus provides
one way of filtering this material down to a manageable size.
But the concentration on film is far from being purely prosaic.
First, cinema, more than any other representational form, provides
the most direct sense of what it actually feels like to drive, its visual
12
INTRODUCTION
DRIVE
INTRODUCTION
DRIVE
1 CITIES
The single most powerful idea attached to urban driving is that
cars and driving are true harbingers of democracy, creating a world
where all men and women are equal, where they can go anywhere, do
anything, meet anyone. The road is the meeting place of democracy,
asserted engineer Pedro Juan Larraaga, a place where the RollsRoyce limousine, the Ford tourer, the cycle and the donkey cart
will learn to know and respect each other.1 Importantly it is not the
car itself but the car journey that fulfils the promise of the city as
a place of work and creativity, anonymity and sociability, structure
and adventure, history and progress, now liberated by the drivings
propensity for communication, discovery and speed. The wheels
move endlessly, always moving, always forward and always lengthening the American road, proclaimed a Ford advertisement 1951.
On that road the nation is steadily traveling beyond the troubles
of this century, constantly heading towards finer tomorrows.2
DRIVE
CITIES
02
The final shot
from The Grapes
of Wrath
(John Ford, 1940).
DRIVE
leaves the state of Georgia for the very first time, crossing over into
Alabama while driving Daisy to a family event in Mobile. Contemporary racism in America is also explored here, as when Hoke is
stopped by Alabama highway patrolmen, who refer to Miss Daisy
as an old Jew woman and Hoke an old nigger. Above all, the car
interior becomes a space of class and ethnic negotiation, and although
Driving Miss Daisy romanticizes racially constructed relationships
of employment and servitude, it also displays considerable sensitivity
to complex questions of multiculturalism, especially when Hoke
gains Miss Daisys grudging respect and friendship. Eventually
Hoke as with many Southern state African Americans who used
cars to provide mobility and social status manages to purchase his
employers Hudson Commodore.6
As Driving Miss Daisy suggests, the association between
freedom and driving is particularly evident in prosperous everyday
circumstances. Even before the Second World War, many Californian
youngsters viewed a car as a social necessity, and from the 1950s
onwards cars became an increasingly common purchase for the
American urban as well as rural working classes.7 Consequently
in Nicholas Rays Rebel Without a Cause (1955), automobiles like a
1941 Chevrolet Special De Luxe, 1946 Ford Super De Luxe and 1949
Mercury Coupe provide transport for teenagers; even the 15-year-old
Plato has a 1940 Motor Glide motorized scooter. Similarly in George
Lucass nostalgic American Graffiti (1973), driving is the key for
teenage transition to adulthood, granting young men the freedom
to move across town, hook up with girls and generally fool around.
An English exploration of similar themes occurs in The Loneliness
of the Long Distance Runner (Tony Richardson, 1962) when bored
20
CITIES
working-class Colin and Mike steal a Ford Consul Mk1 for a cheery
joyride, during which they pick up Gladys and Audrey with promises
of scooting up and down them hills and round them bends. The
seduction works, and Colin loses his virginity with Audrey. Similar
explorations of coming of age and youthful masculinity occur in more
recent American settings like Corvette Summer (Matthew Robbins,
1978), Boulevard Nights (Michael Pressman, 1979) and John Hughess
massively popular Ferris Buellers Day Off (1986), although in the
latter the teenage frivolity of high-school seniors Ferris, Sloane and
Cameron in a 1961 Ferrari gt California which initially stimulates
escapism, fantasy and teenage sexuality eventually culminates in
an emerging sense of responsibility after Cameron sends the car
careening out of his fathers glass-walled house into a ravine.
Many other 1960s films also returned to the kinds of class
sensibility articulated in The Magnificent Ambersons and The Grapes
of Wrath some twenty years earlier. For example, Blow-Up (1966),
Michelangelo Antonionis seminal study of media, aesthetics and
morality in mod London, is partly based on the life of the workingclass photographer David Bailey. As part of his glamorous life,
Thomas (David Hemmings) guides his Rolls-Royce Silver Cloud iii,
replete with radio-telephone messaging, while scouring places for a
shoot amid new housing, demolition sites, working-class streets and
industrial areas. A year later, Charlie Bubbles (Albert Finney, 1967)
also shows its eponymous character driving a Rolls-Royce Silver
Cloud iii as celebrated writer Charlie (Finney) returns to his native
Manchester. This time, however, the car marks not a way of connecting but being distanced from working-class streets. Beginning
his journey north in the golden limousine, Charlie and his young
21
DRIVE
03
Thomas using the
radio-telephone
messaging service
in his Rolls-Royce.
Blow-Up (Michelangelo Antonioni,
1966).
CITIES
DRIVE
in the liberatory space of the car and the highway. This should not
be taken to be a particularly unusually setting for the declaration
of love, for by 1967 around 40 per cent of marriage proposals in
the u.s. were taking place in automobiles.10 Sometimes love, with
the aid of a car, can be found in the most unlikely of places.
CITIES
DRIVE
repeated many times over the next 40 years, as with two films from
1955: To Catch a Thief (Alfred Hitchcock), where Francie propels
a Sunbeam Alpine around challenging Mediterranean roads, and
The Fast and the Furious (John Ireland and Edward Sampson) in
which Connie handles a speedy Jaguar xk120 in a purposefully
energetic manner. Id appreciate, Connie demands at one point
to an assailant, you returning my car and my freedom. During
the 1960s, a decade when Ford was actively selling the sports
pony car Mustang to independent young women, such depictions
became even more commonplace, ranging from the glamorous
Ethel, who drives an Aston Martin db3 drophead for a heist in
Two Way Stretch (Robert Day, 1960), to the blowsy and adulterous
Liz Gruffydd-Williams, who waywardly pilots an ostentatious
Oldsmobile convertible around the Welsh town of Aberdarcy in
Only Two Can Play (Sidney Gilliat, 1962). Even in the very epitome
of male bravado and sexual prowess 1960s Bond films starring
26
04
SPECTRE agent
Fiona Volpe takes
007 for a ride.
Thunderball
(Terence Young,
1965).
CITIES
DRIVE
this is a tough job for a woman and asks if she isnt afraid at night;
the driver simply replies afraid of what? Clo, later called a spoiled
child for her endless cab rides, admires this taxi driver for her
courage and gutsy, street-smart attitude. Later, another of Clos
friends has just gained her licence and determinedly comes to grips
with an old open-topped Citron 11 bl. Thus while Clo, who cannot
drive, is full of fears about her health and future, these two other
women are making their way by car in the capital in an unashamedly
independent manner.
During the 1960s it was increasingly the image of the energetic,
independent female driver that came to the fore, someone like Claire
Chingford (Julie Christie) in The Fast Lady (Ken Annakin, 1962),
who is at once fashionably dressed and free-spirited, detailed in her
knowledge of cars (Red label Bentley. Late 27s. Three litre. Short
chassis speed model with long stroke four cylinder engine fitted with
single overhead camshaft) and exuberant in her driving of a 1962
Mini Cooper Mk1. This is not the pure invention of a film industry
promoting an idealized version of the modern girl about town: in
1968, for example, English television star Cathy McGowan was
actively promoted in photographs showing her smiling in the driving
seat of her new Mini, having just passed her driving test, ready to take
off around town. At a personal level, therefore, driving 1960s cars like
the original Mini helped people to cross class and gender divides and
to express their own liberation in the post-war metropolis.
Since the early 1990s, and particularly following the 1991
release of Ridley Scotts hugely successful Thelma & Louise (explored
in the next chapter), many films have reinvested the theme of
womens driving with new values. In Germany, for example, the
28
CITIES
DRIVE
30
05
Abernathy, Kim
and Zo deal with
Stuntman Mike.
Death Proof
(Quentin
Tarantino, 2007).
CITIES
DRIVE
begins with a tracking shot from a slowly moving car showing the
graveyard, houses, shacks and impoverished people of New Orleans,
portraying the black and white city as listless and down-at-heel. The
unseen automobile here is only a voyeur of poverty never a means
of escape from it.
Those who can drive are not immune to the effects of driving,
and of course alienation of drivers and passengers through car driving
and ownership has been a constant theme of much exploration,
both sociological and cinematic, over the last century.17 In movies,
these range from the heartless and dysfunctional Alexander Joyce
in Journey to Italy (Viaggio in Italia, Roberto Rossellini, 1953), to
the comedic portrayals of Play Time (Jacques Tati, 1967), where
city dwellers guide cars with robotic choreography and struggle
with parking meters, to the innumerable transport tribulations
of Planes, Trains and Automobiles (John Hughes, 1987). A decade
later, The Truman Show (Peter Weir, 1998) implies that we are all
controlled by the mind-numbing schedules, systems and regulations
of the modern world. Unaware that his whole life is one giant media
construct, Truman is allowed to drive by the television programmes
controllers, but artificial routines, repetitive patterns and frequent
radio messages prevent him from ever leaving his local world. At
one point, sensing something is wrong with all this, Truman literally
drives around in circles before eventually being blocked by stagemanaged traffic.
It is, of course, not even necessary to drive to encounter
alienation through the car. Tobacco Road (John Ford, 1941), for
example, uses new automobiles as symbols of unnecessary commodity consumption, hostile modernity and personal narcissism.18
32
CITIES
Many European films of the late 1950s and 60s make similar
observations, notably at a drinks party in Pierrot le fou (Jean-Luc
Godard, 1965), where husbands and wives eulogize about cars and
beauty products in staggeringly banal tones:
Husband #1: An Alfa Romeo has great acceleration,
powerful disk brakes, holds the road perfectly and is
an exceptional touring car. It is safe, fast, pleasant to
drive, responsive and stable.
Wife: It is easy to look fresh. Soap cleanses, cologne
refreshes and scent perfumes. And to avoid perspiration, I use Printil, and feel fresh for the rest of the
day. Printil is available as a stick deodorant, a roll-on
or a spray.
Husband #2: But the Oldsmobile Rocket 88 is even
better. Look at its rigorous design. Its powerful, sober
lines show that elegance and exceptional performance
can be combined.
Mon oncle (Jacques Tati, 1958) makes similar comments when M.
Arpel takes delivery of a ghastly apple-green, pink and lilac 1956
Chevrolet Bel Air, as does Les Tricheurs (Marcel Carn, 1958) when
carefree Mic rejects the Vespa scooters used by other Paris teenagers
for a 1955 Jaguar xk140, a wonderful piece of style and technology
that she has long coveted but which, she quickly discovers, cannot
compensate for her unfulfilled love for Bob. In another popular
33
06
M. Arpel takes
delivery of a multicoloured Chevrolet
Bel Air. Mon oncle
(Jacques Tati, 1958).
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
07
New York as
seductive and hostile beauty. Taxi
Driver (Martin
Scorsese, 1976).
DRIVE
CITIES
08
Max confronts Los
Angeles, an assassin and himself.
Collateral (Michael
Mann, 2004).
and make him realize that his ambition to set up a cool high-end
Island Limo car service is still entirely unfulfilled. Aggravated by
this goading, Max finally takes charge, speeding up the taxi, driving
through red lights and deliberately crashing. The nights driving is
thus ultimately a testing ground for Max where he is shaken out
of his comfort zone and compelled finally to act in a decisive and
dramatic fashion.
Leaving such dramatic events behind, a more everyday kind
of conflict and self-negotiation is presented in Mike Leighs HappyGo-Lucky (2008). Scott (Eddie Marsan), a depressive, repressed
and intolerant driving instructor, is surprised to find himself both
encumbered with and attracted to the annoyingly upbeat Poppy
(Sally Hawkins), whose frivolous attitude to driving, inappropriate
footwear and constant innuendo-riddled chatter he mistakenly
interprets as signs of flirting. At first Scott seeks to dominate Poppy
in his role as instructor, berating her in a summary manner. You
39
DRIVE
have no respect for order, Scott proclaims, You are arrogant, you
are disruptive. And you celebrate chaos. Yet as tensions escalate
and Scotts barely expressed feelings for Poppy go unrequited, it
is Poppy who, like Max in Collateral, takes the initiative, and in a
concluding meeting between the two it is Poppy who throws back
at Scott some of his favourite aphorisms regarding the responsibility
and dangers of car driving, and who ultimately decides who will
and will not drive. Rejecting Scotts style of aggressive, anger-fuelled
driving, at the movies end it is Poppy, for all her apparent childishness and flippancy, who is most in control of her own emotions,
behaviour and wider social responsibilities.
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
09
The city as playground. The Italian
Job (Peter Collinson,
1969).
43
DRIVE
CITIES
DRIVE
10
BMW-era Minis
make their escape
in Los Angeles. The
Italian Job (F. Gary
Gray, 2003).
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
Sensing
As we have seen, filmic depictions of urban driving include such
disparate notions as democracy and freedom, gender, alienation,
negotiation, adventure and fun, thus constructing myriad correlations of the city, automobiles and social concerns. But what are
some of the more visual, temporal and spatial aspects of these
kinds of construction? In particular, what sensory experiences are
involved in city driving, and how do films open these up?
DRIVE
11
The Japanese city
as lights, signs and
signals. Freeway
Speedway 6
(Nikkatsu
Corporation,
1996).
12
Montage of signals
from the dystopian
city of Alphaville
(Jean-Luc Godard,
1965).
DRIVE
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
13
Rhythms and
visual delights
of Amsterdam
rain. Regen (Joris
Ivens, 1929).
57
DRIVE
14
The rhythms
of Londons
Limehouse Link
road tunnel. A13
(William Raban,
1994).
DRIVE
the fluidity of time and space is the title sequence to Changing Lanes
(Roger Michell, 2002), where traffic pulses dramatically: slow at
intersections, speeded up down city streets, suddenly pulling up
behind cars, fast when changing lanes, medium-paced on elevated
freeways and so forth. All of this is shown at variable film speeds,
angles and viewpoints, and an accompanying drum and bass score
heightens a variable and discordant cadence in which the sense of
a pulsating city rhythm comes from velocities, views and music
rather than from montage or complex edits. Such filmic depictions
emphasize the disparate temporal rhythms of cities, where the slow
comes up against the fast, the speedy is interwoven with the plodding,
hurried and rapid movement is punctuated by tedious waiting and
stillness and, above all, the movement of cars adds its own distinct
rhythm and speed to the city. This is faster, more dynamic and
often more continuous than walking or cycling, at once creating
barriers to and modulations of these slower activities. The sum
total is indeed, as Ruttmann realized in the title of his Berlin film,
a symphony of speeds and times, all coming together to create the
complex, exhilarating and thought-provoking experience given to
us by modern cities.
CITIES
DRIVE
CITIES
DRIVE
15
Lyle sends the
bullion truck into
a right-hand turn
during a Los
Angeles traffic jam
of his own making.
The Italian Job.
CITIES
16
Gittes drives into
Chinatown.
Chinatown (Roman
Polanski, 1974).
a matter of making mobile sense of the city even when that city
resists conventional mapping. For example, the multiple car journeys
of Quentin Tarantinos Reservoir Dogs (1992) and Pulp Fiction (1994)
invoke a world of dislocated sensibilities and spaces in their depiction
of postmodern Los Angeles, which, as urban geographer Edward
Soja pointed out shortly before Reservoir Dogs, is the epitome of
a fractured city, being at once profoundly conflictual in its history,
limitless in its changing spatiality and appearing like an confusing
collage of signs.47 A similar process occurs in an earlier Los Angeles
movie, Roman Polanskis cinematic masterpiece Chinatown (1974).
Within a plot based in part on the land and water disputes of interwar California, the driving sequences in Chinatown disclose the
essentially unknowable and unmappable nature of the modern city.
In particular, a closing sequence shows detective Jake Gittes (Jack
Nicholson) driving into the Chinatown area of Los Angeles. While
we ride with the camera in the rear seat, city space is here both
65
DRIVE
66
2JOURNEYS
In 1904, when the automobile was still the preserve of the wealthy,
early motorist Filson Young was already speculating about the cars
potential to enable the thousands who had otherwise been hopelessly
engulfed in cities to access the good life of the English country-side,
its spaces and silences, its winding roads and peaceful landscapes.1
Henry Ford agreed when five years later he foresaw that his motor
car for the great multitude would allow any man with a good salary
to enjoy with his family the blessings of hours of pleasure in Gods
great open spaces.2 Car manufacturer William Morris saw an
equivalent market among the British middle classes,3 while Adolf
Hitler believed that a peoples car would be of particular benefit to
the less well-off as it would enhance their Sundays and holidays,
giving them a great deal of future happiness.4
During the interwar years these automobile visions became a
common reality, either as a gentle Sunday drive in the countryside
or as a more extended tourist drive, taking the motorist to exciting
landscapes and distant sights. As Filson Young declared, the road
sets us free [and] allows us to follow our own choice as to how fast
and how far we shall go, permits us to tarry where and when we
will.5 The car thus enabled the traveller to visit places unreachable
by train, such as Raton Pass in America. Only by motor car can
you climb such heights, exclaimed Dallas Lore Sharp, and halt
67
DRIVE
where you will and as long as you will.6 Unlike the train, which
seemed to many travellers to be overly mechanistic in the way it
passed places by, moving at a constant speed according to a predetermined route and timetable, the automobile provided a more
sociable way of travelling, hence restoring independence, intimacy
and personal time.7
Above all, early motoring journeys were complex affairs of
slowness, intimacy and unpredictability as well as of nature, landscapes, pre-industrial society and generally of encountering a world
which had recently become lost among the modern buildings and
bustling commerce of the metropolis. They were, undoubtedly,
also strewn with contradictions. For example, the 1920s American
practice of relaxed and simplistic motor camping increasingly
relied on luxurious campsites and hotels, technological gadgetry,
codified behaviour and even regimented timetables as motorists
sought to make miles between ever distant destinations.8 Guidebooks feverishly implored motorists to take time to see things,9
disclosing the disappearance of slow, gypsy-like travels and the
arrival instead of faster, view-at-a-glance tourism run according
to a strict itinerary and a checklist of sights.
Glimpses of all this are supplied by biographies and memoirs,
such as H. V. Mortons popular In Search of England and E. B.
Whites similarly influential account of American travels in Farewell
to Model T.10 But it is in film that the relatively innocent joys of
early motoring really come alive, most notably in a documentary,
Friese-Greenes The Open Road, made two years before Mortons
famous literary work, where an expansive journey by Vauxhall
D-type opens up Britain to both the driver and cinema audiences.
68
JOURNEYS
17
Claude FrieseGreene passes
through an English
village. The Open
Road (1925).
DRIVE
Kinaesthetics
Sometimes, when Im driving across the moors at dusk on a summers
night, there are moments when Im going downhill and it feels like
falling into the landscape. I feel as if Im swooping down like a bird
of prey, the moors coming up to meet me.11 As this quotation
suggests, some countryside driving pleasures are less dependent
70
JOURNEYS
on seeing new places or people, and instead are embedded within the
sensual pleasures of driving: what motoring journalist Steve Cropley
aptly describes as the rich satisfaction derived from the rhythm,
the absorption and the simple pleasure of motion.12 This condition
of sensory experiences produced in motion sometimes referred
to as kinaesthetics has been particularly explored in artistic and
literary debates, notably by Sara Danius.13 At first glance, this can
be a complex conceptualization, and it is therefore worth recapitulating its main features here under three categories the appearance
of objects, ways of seeing and the intensification of these effects
through speed while also indicating how these three kinaesthetic
conditions have been explored in film.
DRIVE
18
The mobile and
the immobile.
Man with a Movie
Camera (Dziga
Vertov, 1929).
Man with a Movie Camera provides a strong sense of the mobile and
the immobile, particularly when a split screen has a static camera
shot of trams crossing (where the trams are clearly moving) contrasted against a car-mounted image of trams moving (where the
trams appear static in relation to the camera). From the 1950s
onwards, these kinaesthetic games are more commonplace, and
so in Journey to Italy, Wild Strawberries (Smultronstllet, Ingmar
Bergman, 1957), Les Tricheurs and Breathless we see blurred views
of passing trees, trains, telegraph poles and buildings; while in Duel
(1971), director Steven Spielberg engenders a great sense of speed
through long-lens shots of the cliff walls flashing by on the inside
of the demonic, chasing tanker.20 In a similar manner, John Frankenheimers Grand Prix (1966) emphasizes a tremendous sense of
high-velocity driving at Monza with trees, bridges, hedges and signs
all hurtling past the car-borne cameras. Franois Truffaut displayed
73
DRIVE
74
19
The Eiffel Tower
depicted in
Proustian terms.
The 400 Blows
(Franois Truffaut,
1959).
20
Montage of views
of the American
landscape from
Rain Man (Barry
Levinson, 1988).
DRIVE
Ways of Seeing
As Rain Man, To Wong Foo and Sideways all suggest, another aspect
of kinaesthetics is that the way we see is changed by driving. By
releasing objects from their context, the process of seeing objects
is in turn freed from contextual knowledge; as a result, this seeing
process becomes a form of seeing in the first person. In short,
driving helps us to forget what we know, and to focus instead on
what we simply see. This process is particularly attractive to artists,
writers, film-makers and other creative producers, providing them
with appropriate metaphors or other reflections on modern life.
Unsurprisingly, this aspect of driving kinaesthetics is frequently
apparent in avowedly experimental films. For example, Man with
a Movie Camera introduced as a truly international absolute
language of cinema based on its total separation from the language
of theatre and literature is as much an analytical film about filmmaking as it is a portrayal of urban life, thus leading to the kinds
of split-screen depiction of mobile and immobile trams described
above. Less self-referentially, Emak-Bakia clearly shows how moving,
changing and vibrating vision fashioned from a moving automobile
can help explore Dada-Surrealist concerns with dreams, sexuality
and the Freudian subconscious. As Kiki de Montparnasse propels
76
JOURNEYS
21
The journey
between external
and internal worlds.
Emak-Bakia (Man
Ray, 1926).
her car, angled views, movement blurs and juddering bumps infer
a strange and uncontrolled journey into her deeper, uninhibited
desires; driving here is a journey between the external world of
physical pleasures and the inner world of thoughts, longings and
yearnings. Similar depictions occur in Man Rays Les Mystres du
chteau du d (1929), where fast and jerky windscreen shots reveal
passing trains, telegraph poles, buildings, trees, village streets, slower
traffic, signs and hedges in a highly uncertain and transitory manner
all of which indicates a concern with the role of chance and the
fleeting nature of modern life. Equally experimental, albeit with
the different concerns of an industrial documentary director,
Geoffrey Joness Shell Spirit (1962) also exploits kinaesthetic
pleasures to reveal elusive meanings. This two-minute advertisement uses rhythm-edited and sun-drenched shots of road lines,
houses, boats, pigs, a woman, the sky, wheels, patterns, textures
and so forth, all set alongside South African Kwela pennywhistle
street music. The overriding impression is of freedom to be gained
77
DRIVE
by driving out in the countryside and seeing new sights. Above all,
Shell Spirit is a celebration of the joyful sensation of movement and
a truly modern way of seeing.
Other forms of seeing are also implicated in the driving
experience, notably the way the windscreen acts as a frame, limiting
the landscape within a carefully prescribed boundary and hence
converting it into an object of visual pleasure; as film historian
Anne Friedberg summarily describes this condition, the visuality
of driving is the visuality of the windshield, operating as a framing
device.22 Through this frame, landscapes become fragmented into
a series of discrete objects, vistas and markings, but are then recombined by the particular driver, car and journey. Examples of this in
art are manifold, from academic painter Hubert von Herkomers
realization in 1905 that in his car one picture after another delights
78
22
Montage of rhythm
edited shots from
Shell Spirit
(Geoffrey Jones,
1962).
JOURNEYS
DRIVE
If speed changes how objects appear to us, and how we view these
objects, then it also heightens our sense of these experiences. As
has been noted for train travel, increased velocity calls forth a
greater number of visual impressions for the sense of sight to deal
with, a condition which equates with sociologist Georg Simmels
realization that modern life intensifies urban perceptions.26 In
automobiles, where the driver has even greater exposure to speed
coming through the windscreen, this produces a correspondingly
greater intensification, and in particular exacerbates a sense of
strangeness, disconnection and velocity. In art we see this in early
Futurist paintings such as Giacomo Ballas Abstract Speed series
(191314) and Luigi Russolos Dynamism of a Car (191213),
while abstract films like Walter Ruttmanns Opus 1 (1922) and
Len Lyes A Colour Box (1935), Kaleidoscope (1936), Swinging the
Lambeth Walk (1939) and Particles in Space (196771) similarly
80
JOURNEYS
23
Windscreen view
as representation
of landscape and
metaphor for film.
The Brown Bunny
(Vincent Gallo,
2004).
DRIVE
24
Abstracted movement intensifying
the anticipation of
a murderous act.
The Killers (Robert
Siodmak, 1946).
JOURNEYS
DRIVE
writes Mirbeau. Speed defines his life. He drives like the wind,
thinks like the wind, feels like the wind, makes love like the wind,
lives a whirlwind existence. Mirbeau also extends this description
in cinematic terms, noting how life rushes at the driver from all
directions, only to then flicker away like a film.30 Movie depictions
of such people abound, most recently in Ryan Goslings portrayal
of the anonymous avenger in Refns Drive. But it is in the appropriately named The Driver (Walter Hill, 1978) that we find the
figure of the driver-defined-by-driving in the most extreme form.
Without a name, The Driver is entirely circumscribed by his
ability to control an automobile: to hotwire cars, drive fast, evade
police, cause and avoid accidents, react to the visual conditions,
keep calm (even under gunfire), navigate streets and traffic at high
speed and even destroy a vehicle. Played by Ryan ONeal, The
Driver says less than 400 words in the whole movie, and thus
takes his whole raison dtre not from relationships with people
or surroundings but from the act of driving itself, and in all of its
possible variants.
In summary, the kinaesthetics of driving involves a substantial
re-orientation of the experience of time and space, in which sight,
senses, intellect, landscape, meaning, creativity and the human
body are all potentially reconfigured. As Filson Young wrote, such
driving flattens out the world, enlarges the horizon, loosens a little
the bonds of time [and] sets back a little the barriers of space, while
the driver simply lives more quickly.31 This is not an experience
restricted to the worlds best artists, race drivers or extreme thrillseekers. Rather, such experiences are available to us all; indeed,
they are often unavoidable whenever we drive or even passenger
84
JOURNEYS
Existential Self
Here we arrive at one of the most important aspects of automobile
experience: driving as an existential condition whereby the driver
seeks to confront, explore, express and produce the self through
encountering the world around them in other words where the
driver reassesses their sense of autonomy, freedom and self-reliance.
In particular, the road movie of the 1950s and 60s, which often
contains elements of social critique, later gave way, especially in
the 1980s, to road movies where driving across a real landscape is
used to indicate a psychological, emotional, philosophical or similar
personal transformation.32 Indeed, of all the ways in which driving
has been represented in film, it is the road movie that, along with
the car chase and the crash, has become particularly prevalent. It
is also the area of cinematic driving that has been most analysed by
critics and historians.33 In order to navigate this range of movies
and interpretations, I look here at three different themes: discovery,
reconfiguration and nihilism.
85
DRIVE
Transgression
In contrast to the highly individualistic experiences that invoke
the transcendental or sublime, another dimension to high-speed
driving is that of transgression, where the driver knowingly crosses
social boundaries, breaks rules, violates conventional mores and
challenges the established balance between right and wrong, and
between social responsibility and personal freedom. This, of course,
has been a common feature in film from the beginning, as made
clear in The ? Motorist where two speeding Edwardian motorists
outwit courtroom officials and the police.
Even more compelling than sensationalized drama and action
films are depictions of real-life transgression, and recent years have
seen the appearance of innumerable specialist dvds and video games.
Especially popular are the Japanese Megalopolis Expressway Trial
dvd series (Nikkatsu, 198896) portraying illegal racing on the
Shuto Expressway and other Tokyo roads, and now known globally
through street racing video games like Midnight Club (Rockstar,
20008). Other games incorporating transgressive street racing
include Grand Theft Auto (dma/Rockstar, 1997) and Need for
Speed (Electronic Arts, 1994). Within real-life street racing, dvd
180
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
DRIVE
58
Approaching Sainte
Trinit. Ctait un
rendezvous (Claude
Lelouch, 1976).
DRIVE
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
mount, the driver was Lelouch was himself, and a Ferrari (Lelouchs
own 275gtb) was indeed deployed but only for the soundtrack
added during post-production. Many of these clarifications are now
well known, diffusing the considerable aura around a film that for
many years was viewed only through private screenings and illicit
video copies. Nonetheless, the interlocked three-way reaction which
many have to the film admiration for the authentic speed and reality,
fascination through hypnotic immersal and reprehension at the risktaking and danger to others remains as strong as ever, and this is no
doubt why Ctait un rendezvous continues to maintain its reputation
as one of the most compelling of all driving films.
Moreover, many have recreated Ctait un rendezvous in their
own terms. For example, in the short The Fast and the Famous (Jeremy
Hart, 2009), American chat show host and car enthusiast Jay Leno is
inspired by Lelouchs film to take a Mercedes sls amg on an early
morning search for the hidden racetrack within Los Angeles. Other
projects inspired by Lelouchs film include the Getaway in Stockholm
series and The Run (John Bruno, 2003), a promotional dvd wherein
a Nissan 350z undertakes a six-minute dash through cobbled Prague
to rendezvous with a woman, as well as numerous television programmes, such as the uks Fifth Gear, which in 2007 retraced the
Paris run using a small Citron and front-mounted camera. Earlier
that year, rock band Snow Patrol used extensive footage from
Ctait un rendezvous for their video to Open Your Eyes, where
the otherworldly quality of Lelouchs trajectory comes to the fore.
Such depictions help to increase awareness of films like Ctait un
rendezvous car enthusiast Internet forums, for example, frequently
refer to it but in these later versions the outright transgression seen
185
DRIVE
Chase
Of all filmic depictions of driving, the car chase is undoubtedly
the most distinctive means of conveying drama and thrills. Indeed,
the reputations of The French Connection and Bullitt are today
dominated by their chase sequences, while other films, Ronin and
Gone in 60 Seconds for example, are constructed almost entirely
of chases (the latter includes a single car chase lasting 34 minutes,
the longest in movie history). And although some might see such
car chases as offering little more than surface drama, these scenes
are often deeper explorations of many different themes, subjects
and meanings.
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
DRIVE
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
DRIVE
60
A manic Popeye
Doyle. The French
Connection
(William Friedkin,
1971).
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
191
DRIVE
and the roles are now reversed. Lightweight Arriflex cameras allow
for a great variety of unusual shots including details of the drivers
faces and the clipping-in of a seatbelt all of which announce that
the real action is about to begin. As the hitmen suddenly turn left,
the distinctive bass and saxophones of Lalo Schifrins jazzy score
abruptly stop, and we are left with only the distinctive roar of the
Ford and Dodge as the chase takes off. As the cars surge around the
brows, descents, dips and corners of San Francisco, all of what we
now think of as the standard elements of the car chase make an
appearance: dramatic jumps, fast turns, fierce acceleration, near
misses, false turns, jolting bumps, squealing tyres and roaring
engines. The effect, as with all good car chases, is compelling and
thrilling, as we are sucked into a captivating dynamic.
Fast-moving automobile action as sound and vision is supplied
in abundance, but why have so many cited Bullitts as the greatest of
all movie car chases?22 The distinctive soundtrack, rumbling cars and
Billy Frakers inventive cinematography (including retina-detaching
vibrations and other visceral feeds from numerous car-mounted
cameras) are worth noting, but three other factors are particularly
important. First, the city itself provides much of the drama, with
San Franciscos hills creating not only a menacing terrain around
which Bullitt and the hitmen slowly stalk, and then a pulsating roller
coaster as they accelerate fiercely, but also dramatically vertiginous
views; at times, the Mustang and Charger seem to be launched into
the cityscape and bay below. The city too, then, is an active participant in the chase. Second, for all the undoubted thrills and skills on
display, this is a chase of psychology as much as of action, where
tension and determination as well as gasoline and v8s propel the
192
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
61
Frank Bullitts
Ford Mustang
appears in the
rearview mirror.
Bullitt (Peter
Yates 1968).
DRIVE
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
DRIVE
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
62
Norson heads
through an alien
New York. Side
Street (Anthony
Mann, 1950).
DRIVE
hes going to be all right. Three years earlier, The Naked City (Jules
Dassein, 1947), the first crime film to use extensive location shooting,
mapped New York through telephones and police networks,28 and
here Side Street, one of the very first films to include a modern setpiece car chase, extends the same logic to automotive technology
and mobility. Consequently, through its car chase Side Street represents the dangerous and unruly life that the modern city delivers
to its residents, while, by contrast, the polices control of that same
chase underlines their ability to maintain conditions of safety,
morality and behaviour. If the city for its everyday citizens is
unmappable and untamed, then for the authorities it is a place
to be understood and secured. We as audience thus come to know
the city through the same logic, as irrational and wild when encountered through immediate experience, but as coherent and protective
when comprehended through the eyes of the police, film and other
modern technologies.
By contrast, a very different city is presented in many other
car chases. In the exhilarating final chase within Ronin (John Frankenheimer, 1998) Paris loses the mesmeric otherworldliness evoked
by Ctait un rendezvous, becoming a forbidding and inescapable
labyrinth of narrow streets, dark tunnels and dense traffic, fabricated
from hard tarmac, concrete and metal, and wherein collisions and
explosions suddenly occur. At one stage Deidre, Seamus and Gregor
in their 1991 bmw 535i are chased by Sam and Vincent in a 1996
Peugeot 406 through the dimly lit Champerret Tunnel (eerily similar
to the Pont de lAlma underpass where Princess Diana died one year
earlier), drilling through oncoming traffic, and violently battering
and shooting their way into the daylight.
198
A LT E R E D S TAT E S
Returning to New York, the 12-minute car chase in The SevenUps (Philip DAntoni, 1973) is a cinema classic, and shows renegade
policeman Buddy Manucci (Roy Scheider) in a 1973 Pontiac Ventura
Spring chasing two police-killers in a 1973 Pontiac Grand Ville around
Upper Manhattan and across the George Washington Bridge. The cars
surge over pavements, through red lights and across intersections,
weaving through traffic and hitting parked cars in a highly realistic
New York replete with crowded pavements, pressing buildings, blaring
horns, pot-holes and playing kids. The use of extensive low-down,
windscreen and tracking shots, as well as glassy reflections of city
architecture, at once increases frenzied motion and brings the grainy
urban fabric right into the action. The Seven-Ups thus depicts a very
different New York to Side Street, one that is no longer systematically
controlled by the police at a distance, and now a place of hands-on
entanglements, fast-moving events and gritty exploits. Above all, it is
a place where things go wrong as often as they go right. Indeed, at the
end of the chase, Manucci submarines his Pontiac under the rear of a
stationary truck. Improbably avoiding serious injury, his deeply silent
and shocked manner, blowing hard while walking away from the roofless wreckage, nevertheless shows that Manucci has taken on all New
York has to offer, and has very nearly paid the ultimate price. The city
here is multifarious and unforgiving, and not to be messed with lightly.
Crash
Manuccis near-fatal crash in The Seven-Ups is a reminder that car
chases, races and many other forms of cinematic driving often end
199
CONCLUSION
75
A track day driver
in a Lotus Elise.
DRIVE
74
Delaney immediately after his tumultuous crash. Le
Mans.
CONCLUSION
DRIVE
CONCLUSION
DRIVE
more effusive terms. The mind is calm, unruffled, yet utterly ecstatic.
You experience a thrill, a joy, a rush of delight of being alive . . . This
is nirvana my friends. Some attain it by sitting; others by chanting;
folks such as me (and maybe you) by taking the road more swiftly
travelled.12 It is exactly through this kind of vital experience through
the driving of an automobile that the human subject emerges as
someone who has encountered one of the most distinctive and
ubiquitous conditions of the modern world, who indeed has not
only survived but thrived within it, and who has become, as a result,
a different kind of person.
Returning now to some of the comments made in the introduction to Drive regarding contemporary concerns around private,
public and mass transportation, then if we are indeed to deal with the
problems of congestion, pollution, energy consumption, health and
safety that car use undoubtedly contributes towards, then we must,
in doing so, also seriously consider that the undoubted pleasures of
driving play no small part in why people will not simply abandon
their cars even if fully affordable, efficient, ubiquitous and useful
forms of public transport were suddenly to become readily and
universally available. In short, without addressing the cultural
reasons as to why people like to drive, a purely quantitative,
economic, managerialist or scientific approach to transportation
will always fall short of its desired aims. Indeed, the oft-stated
functionalist approach to reducing the amount of private car driving
namely that journeys by car should only be made when absolutely
essential could be simply reversed. That is, car driving should
never be essential, never be necessary; rather, driving should only be
undertaken as a form of pleasure and hence the kinds of cultural
232
76
Edwardian
motorists flee their
pursuers in The ?
Motorist (Walter
Booth for R. W.
Paul, 1906).
DRIVE
77
Poppy learns to
drive in Happy-GoLucky (Mike Leigh,
2008).
234
235
REFERENCES
INTRODUCTION
1 Roland Barthes, Mythologie de
lautomobile: La Voiture, projection
de lego, Oeuvres compltes [1963]
(Paris, 2002), pp. 23442, and quoted
in Jean Baudrillard, The System of
Objects (London, 2005), pp. 256 n7.
2 John Urry, The System of
Automobility (2002), at
www.its.leeds.ac.uk; and Ruth
Brandon, Auto Mobile: How the Car
Changed Life (London, 2002), p. 385.
3 Mimi Sheller and John Urry, The
City and the Car, International
Journal of Urban and Regional
Research, xxiv/4 (2000), pp. 73757;
Mike Featherstone, Nigel Thrift and
John Urry, eds, Automobilities
(London, 2005); and Steffen Bhm,
Campbell Jones, Chris Land and
Mat Paterson, Introduction:
Impossibilities of
Automobility, Sociological Review,
liv/1 (2006), pp. 116.
4 A. B. Filson Young, The Complete
Motorist: Being an Account of the
Evolution and Construction of the
Modern Motor-car, Etc. (London,
revd 5th edn, 1905), p. 274.
5 Steffen Bhm, Campbell Jones, Chris
237
DRIVE
REFERENCES
DRIVE
4
5
7
8
10
11
240
REFERENCES
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
241
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
DRIVE
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
242
44
45
46
47
48
REFERENCES
5
6
8
9
10
11
12
13
243
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
DRIVE
22
23
24
25
26
244
27
28
29
30
REFERENCES
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
DRIVE
REFERENCES
4
5
6
7
8
247
DRIVE
15
16
17
18
19
248
1994), p. 18.
20 Dimendberg, Will to Motorization,
pp. 12737.
21 Martin Pawley, Where the Big Sheds
Are, in The Strange Death of
Architectural Criticism: Martin
Pawley, Collected Writings, ed. David
Jenkins (London, 2007), p. 226,
quoted in Joe Moran, On Roads:
A Hidden History (London, 2009),
p. 149.
22 Iain Borden, Playtime: Tativille and
Paris, in The Hieroglyphics of Space:
Reading and Experiencing the Modern
Metropolis, ed. Neil Leach (London,
2002), pp. 21733.
23 David Matless, Landscape and
Englishness (London, 1998), p. 64;
and Moran, On Roads, p. 130.
24 Iain Sinclair, London Orbital: A Walk
around the m25 (London, 2002).
25 Anon, A Car Talk With Julian Opie,
Carls Cars, 12 (Summer 2005),
pp. 98101.
26 R. J. Gibbens and Y. Saacti, Road
Traffic Analysis Using midas Data:
Journey Time Prediction (Cambridge,
University of Cambridge Computer
Laboratory Technical Report 676,
December 2006), p. 17.
27 Seiler, Republic of Drivers, p. 126.
28 Brandon, Auto Mobile, p. 353.
29 Moran, On Roads, p. 22.
30 Ibid., p. 101; and The Secret Life of
the Motorway: Falling In Love, The
Honeymoon Period and The End of
the Affair, three-part bbc television
documentary (produced and directed
REFERENCES
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
249
38
39
40
41
42
DRIVE
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
REFERENCES
DRIVE
4
5
6
252
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
CITIES
www.stevemcqueen.com.
26 At www.ponysite.de; and
www.imboc.com.
27 Steven Jacobs, From Flneur to
Chauffeur: Driving through
Cinematic Cities, in Imagining the
City, vol. i: The Art of Urban Living,
ed. Christian Emden, Catherine Keen
and David Midgley (Oxford: Peter
Lang, 2006), p. 218.
28 M. Christine Boyer, Twice-told
Stories: The Double Erasure of
Times Square, The Unknown City:
Contesting Architecture and Social
Space, ed. Iain Borden, Jane Rendell
and Joe Kerr with Alicia Pivaro
(Cambridge, 2001), pp. 3053.
29 Brian Ladd, Autophobia: Love and
Hate in the Automotive Era (Chicago,
il, 2008), p. 73.
30 George R. Chatburn, Highways and
Highway Transportation (New York,
1923), p. 204, cited in T. C. Barker,
The International History of Motor
Transport, Journal of Contemporary
History, xxix/1 (1985), p. 15.
31 World Health Organization (who),
Global Status Report on Road Safety
(Geneva, 2009), pp. viiix and 13;
and Mark Dery, Always Crashing in
the Same Car: A Head-on Collision
with the Technosphere, Against
Automobility, ed. Steffen Bhm,
Campbell Jones, Chris Land and
Matthew Paterson (Oxford, 2006), p.
228.
32 Duffy, Speed Handbook, pp. 2245.
33 Schnapp, Crash, pp. 345.
DRIVE
CITIES
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
255