Depressive Disorders
Depressive Disorders
Depressive Disorders
Pathophysiology
Several areas of the brain are involved in mood functions. Sleep,
appetite, and memory are commonly disturbed in persons with
depression. Except for the pituitary, all cerebral components
responsible for these functions are broadly considered to be a part of
the limbic system; all components normally receive signals from
neurons that secrete serotonin or norepinephrine or from neurons of
both types. Reductions in the activity of circuits that use serotonin and
norepinephrine are thought to contribute to depression.
Frequency
United States
Reported prevalence rates for depression in children and adolescents
vary. Differences may be due to different populations sampled and
variable criteria used.
In 1988, Kashani and Sherman conducted epidemiologic studies in the
United States that revealed the incidence of depression to be 0.9% in
preschool-aged children, 1.9% in school-aged children, and 4.7% in
adolescents.1 A study of a randomly selected sample of high school
students revealed that 22.3% of females and 11.4% of male high
school students reported one current or lifetime episode of unipolar
depression. The percentage of male and female students with 2 or
more episodes was 4.9% and 1.6%, respectively. In 1997, Garrison et
al conducted a study of adolescents aged 11-16 years in the
southeastern United States and found that the 1-year incidence of
major depression was 3.3%.2
Mortality/Morbidity
As many as 15% of those with depression or bipolar disorder commit
suicide each year. In 1996, the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC) listed suicide as the ninth leading cause of death in
the United States, accounting for 30,862 deaths. Many believe this
number is a gross underestimate. For example, children's deaths are
often ruled as accidental when the intent of the deceased is not
apparent. The feasibility of suicide among children is frequently
unthinkable, even to health professionals. Because mood disorders,
such as depression, substantially increase the risk of suicide, suicidal
behavior is a matter of serious concern for clinicians who deal with the
mental health problems of children and adolescents. The incidence of
suicide attempts reaches a peak during the mid adolescent years; the
mortality rate from suicide increases steadily through the teenage
years; suicide is the third leading cause of death in that age group.
Risk factors for completed suicide include the presence of a major
mood disorder, occurrence of command auditory hallucinations, use of
substances, and evidence of specific plans and an attempt to prevent
discovery. Major depression with psychotic features, such as
hallucinations, places an individual at increased risk of harm to
themselves or others. Psychosis and risk of harm to self or others are
indications for hospitalization.
Race
Cultural norms associated with differing racial and ethnic groups can
affect the experience and reporting of symptoms of depression. For
example, in some cultures, depression may be experienced largely in
somatic terms, in place of sadness or guilt. Several studies point
toward the role of culture in childhood and adolescent depression. For
example, the stress of acculturation was found to have a role in the
increased incidence of depressive symptoms and suicidal ideation
among Hispanic youths.
In an epidemiologic study of youths aged 12-17 years in Los Angeles
County in 1998, Siegel et al found that Hispanic youths reported more
symptoms of depression, independent of socioeconomic status, when
compared with white, African American, or Asian American
adolescents, using the Children's Depression Inventory (CDI).6 This
study also found significant effects of social class on depression. As
income decreased, the average level of depression increased.
More extensive studies of ethnic subpopulations of adolescents who
are depressed are needed. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) states that a symptom
should not be dismissed because it is part of a cultural norm.7
Likewise, culturally distinctive experiences (eg, fear of being hexed or
bewitched; experience of visitations from the dead) should be
distinguished from actual hallucinations or delusions that may be part
of a major depressive episode with psychotic features.
Sex
Sex issues and depression in youths has been the subject of much
research. In 1998, Hankin et al conducted a prospective, 10-year,
longitudinal study of preadolescents through young adulthood and
found that the most critical time for sex differences to emerge is the
period when adolescents are aged 15-18 years.8 During this period,
the increase of the overall rates of depression and onset of new cases
of depression peak. The rates of depression increase dramatically for
both sexes, and the rate of depression in females grows to twice the
prevalence rate for males. No sex differences are noted for depression
symptom severity or recurrence.
Age
Evidence suggests that the presentation of some symptoms may
change with age. Symptoms, such as somatic complaints, irritability,
and social withdrawal, are more common in children, whereas
psychomotor retardation, hypersomnia, and delusions are less
common prior to puberty than in adolescence and adulthood.
Clinical
History
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Third
Edition (DSM-III); the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, Third Edition Revised (DSM-III-R); and the DSM-IV use the
same basic criteria to diagnose depression in adults and children. A
few small adjustments were made to the diagnostic criteria to account
for the differences in age and stage of development in adults and
children.
The DSM-IV diagnostic criteria for depressive disorders are the same
for children and adolescents as they are for adults, with small
exceptions stated as notations to the criteria.
Physical
Causes
Whether ego-damaging experiences or biological processes cause
depression remains the topic of some debate. The final common
pathways to depression involve biochemical changes in the brain.
• Neuroimaging
o A recently discovered abnormality in an area of the
brain that helps to control emotional reactions contributes
to a new understanding of why persons develop
depression and other affective disturbances. By using
positron emission tomographic (PET) images, researchers
found an area of the prefrontal cortex with an abnormally
diminished activity in patients with unipolar depression and
bipolar depression. This region is related to emotional
response and has widespread connections with other
areas of the brain. These other areas are responsible for
the regulation of dopamine, noradrenaline, and serotonin,
which have important roles in the regulation of mood. PET
imaging provides the means for the study of receptor
volume and the effect a compound may have on
receptors; however, PET is problematic for use with
children and adolescents because it requires complex
equipment and uses radiation.
o MRI, magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS), and
magnetoencephalography (MEG) are best suited to study
the structural, physiological, and developmental brain
abnormalities in youths because they do not involve
ionizing radiation or radioactive isotopes. To date, few
neuroimaging studies have been performed in depressed
youths. In 1996, Steingard et al observed 65 latency-aged
children and adolescents who were hospitalized with
depression.9 MRI was used to compare depressed patients
with 18 hospitalized psychiatric controls who did not have
a depressive disorder. Depressed youths had a
significantly smaller ratio of frontal lobe volume to total
cerebral volume and a significantly larger ratio of lateral
ventricular volume to total cerebral volume than controls.
The researchers in this study suggest that these
alterations in cerebral volumes may suggest a role for the
frontal lobes in the development of early-onset depression.
o In 1998, Tutus et al observed adolescents with MDD
using single-photon emission tomography (SPET) in order
to examine cerebral perfusion and any association
between perfusion indices and clinical variables.10
Fourteen adolescent outpatients (aged 11-15 y) with MDD
and 11 age-matched controls were studied. Significant
differences were found between the perfusion index
values of untreated depressed patients and those of the
controls. The findings were indicative of relatively reduced
perfusion in the left anterofrontal and left temporal cortical
areas. They suggest that adolescents with MDD may have
regional blood flow deficits in left anterofrontal and left
temporal cortical regions with greater right-left perfusion
asymmetry compared with healthy controls.
• Neuroendocrine abnormalities
o In 1996, De Bellis et al studied neuroendocrine
changes in prepubertal children who were depressed.11
They examined nocturnal secretion of adrenocorticotropin
(ACTH), cortisol, growth hormone (GH), and prolactin in
the depressed groups and control groups, respectively.
Prepubertal children who were depressed had lower
cortisol secretion during the first 4 hours of sleep than did
children in the control group. ACTH, GH, and prolactin
secretion did not differ between the 2 groups.
o Possible abnormalities of the neurotransmitter
systems remain under investigation. In 1999, Nobile et al
found that human platelet 5-HT (serotonin) uptake is
differentially influenced in nondepressed and depressed
children by a common genetic variant of the promotor
region of 5-HTT.12 In 1997, Birmaher et al found that, prior
to onset of affective illness, children who were at high risk
had the same pattern of neuroendocrine response to 5-
hydroxy-L-tryptophan (L-5-HTP) challenge as did children
with major depression.13 These findings could constitute
the identification of a trait marker for depression in
children.
• Genetic studies: Several studies of adults who are
depressed, such as those reported by Akiskal and Weller in
198914 and Weissman et al in 1984,15 suggest a genetic
component in the etiology of depressive disorders.
• Parent-child relation model
o This model conceptualizes depression as the result
of poor parent-child interaction. Adults with depression
report low paternal involvement and high maternal
overprotection during early childhood. Troubled
relationships with parents, siblings, and peers are
common in children and adolescents with affective illness.
A child who is affectively ill often has a parent who is
affectively ill. For children to report abuse and/or neglect
by their parent(s) who is affectively ill is not uncommon.
o In 1991, Hammen et al reported a significant
temporal association between mother and child.16 They
found that children with substantial stress exposure who
also had symptomatic mothers were significantly more
depressed than children who were exposed to comparable
levels of stress only.
• Cohort effect: In 1987, Klerman and Gershon reported a
progressive increase in the lifetime cases of major depression
over the last 70 years. They found high rates of affective
disorders among relatives, with a younger age of onset in
successive cohorts.
Differential Diagnoses
Anxiety Disorder: Generalized Anxiety
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
Child Abuse & Neglect: Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
Mood Disorder: Bipolar Disorder
Mood Disorder: Dysthymic Disorder
Other Tests
Treatment
Medical Care
Opinions vary about whether cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy,
pharmacotherapy, or a combination of both should be offered as first-
line treatment for children and adolescents with MDD. Safety is always
the first concern in the evaluation of MDD in children and adolescents.
Cognitive-behavioral therapy has been shown in multiple randomized
clinical trials to be effective in the treatment of mild-to-moderate MDDs
in children and adolescents. Evidence from randomized clinical trials
suggests efficacy in the treatment of moderate-to-severe MDD using 3
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs): fluoxetine, sertraline,
and citalopram.
Overall, the choice of the initial acute therapy depends on the severity,
number of prior episodes, chronicity, subtype, age of the patient,
contextual issues (eg, family conflict, academic problems, exposure to
negative life events), compliance with treatment, previous response to
treatment, and the motivation of the patient and family for treatment. In
mild cases, psychosocial interventions are often recommended as
first-line treatments, whereas, in the most severe cases, medication in
addition to psychotherapeutic intervention is often recommended.
Treatment of a child or adolescent who is depressed should occur
within a biopsychosocial context. Such an approach includes the
psychotherapies (eg, individual, family, group), medication
management, social skills training, and educational assessment and
planning. The clinician should choose a treatment setting prior to
initiation of a treatment plan. The clinician must carefully assess the
risk for suicide in any child who is depressed. If a child is obsessed
with thoughts of suicide or has definite plans, the patient must be
hospitalized. Also, the clinician should weigh factors, such as the
child's ability to function and the stability of the family plus any history
of previous suicide attempts, when determining whether or not to
hospitalize a child or adolescent.
Psychotherapy appears to be a useful initial acute treatment for mild-
to-moderate depression. Cognitive-behavioral therapy has been
extensively studied, and other forms of psychotherapy, such as
psychodynamic psychotherapy, interpersonal psychotherapy, and
family therapy, have been found to be effective and are used clinically.
More studies that compare the complementary and differential effects
of these therapies are needed.
Antidepressant medications may be indicated for children and
adolescents with nonrapid cycling bipolar depression, psychotic
depression, depression with severe symptoms that prevent effective
psychotherapy, and depression that does not respond to
psychotherapy; however, given the psychosocial context in which
depression occurs, pharmacotherapy is insufficient as the only
treatment. Even when the patient's mood has been stabilized using a
medication-only treatment, evidence suggests that the environmental
and social problems associated with MDD remain, preventing the
necessary full stabilization.
Combined treatment increases the likelihood not only of mitigating
depressive symptomatology but also increases the likelihood of
increasing self-esteem, coping skills, and adaptive strategies and
improving family and peer relationships. Psychodynamic
psychotherapy, interpersonal therapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy,
behavior therapy, family therapy, supportive psychotherapy, and group
psychotherapy have all been used for the treatment of youths with
MDD.
Many clinicians have found psychodynamic psychotherapy useful in
the treatment of depression in youths. Controlled studies using
psychodynamic psychotherapy for the treatment of depression in
children and adolescents are particularly difficult to design and
expensive to conduct but are greatly needed. Psychodynamic
psychotherapy can help youths understand themselves, identify
feelings, improve self-esteem, change maladaptive patterns of
behavior, interact more effectively with others, and cope with ongoing
and past conflicts.
Interpersonal therapy focuses on problem areas of grief, interpersonal
roles, disputes, role transitions, and interpersonal difficulties. In a 1996
study, Mufson and Fairbanks found that interpersonal therapy may be
useful in the acute treatment of adolescents with MDD.18 They also
found the rate of relapse to be relatively low after acute interpersonal
therapy treatment.
Medication
Studies on the use of medications for youths with MDD are few, and
some have methodologic problems. Additionally, very few
pharmacokinetics studies have been performed in children. The few
studies in children have focused on the effects of tricyclic
antidepressants (TCAs), with few studies addressing SSRIs. Other
antidepressants, including heterocyclics (eg, amoxapine, maprotiline),
monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs), bupropion, venlafaxine, and
nefazodone, have been found to be effective in the treatment of adults
who are depressed.
The clinician needs to inform parents and patients about adverse
effects, the dose, the timing of therapeutic effect, and the danger of
overdose, particularly with TCAs, before initiating pharmacologic
treatment. Parents should take responsibility for medication storage
and administration, especially with younger children and children at
risk for suicide. Because of the potential of the TCAs to induce a fatal
overdose, the clinician must carefully determine the exact amount of
medication to be prescribed at each appointment.
The TCAs require a baseline ECG, resting blood pressure, and pulse.
Weight should also be frequently documented. No laboratory tests are
currently indicated before or during the administration of the SSRIs.
No other tests are indicated in a healthy child before starting
antidepressants.
Because of reports that SSRIs are effective for the treatment of youths
with MDD and because of reports that SSRIs have a relatively safe
adverse effect profile, very low lethality after overdose, and only once
daily administration, the clinician may support the use of the SSRIs as
first-line medications.
Open studies, such as those in 1997 by Leonard et al22 and Rey-
Sanchez and Gutierrez-Casares,23 have reported 70-90% response to
the SSRIs in the treatment of adolescents with MDD. Also in 1997,
Emslie et al conducted an 8-week double-blind study of the treatment
of a large sample of youths with MDD and showed that children and
adolescents responded significantly better to fluoxetine than to
placebo (58% vs 32%).24 Despite the significant response to fluoxetine,
many patients had only partial improvement; only 31% achieved full
remission.
A possible explanation for the partial response is that the effective
treatment may involve variation in dose or length of treatment. Also,
the ideal treatment likely involves a combination of pharmacologic and
psychosocial interventions. Except for lower initial doses, the
administration of SSRIs in children and adolescents is similar to the
treatment protocols used for adult patients. The clinician should treat
patients with adequate and tolerable doses for at least 4 weeks. At 4
weeks, if the patient has not shown even minimal improvement, the
clinician should consider increasing the dose. If, at this time, the
patient shows improvement, the dose can be continued for at least 6
weeks. On the contrary, if no improvement is apparent at 6 weeks,
other treatment strategies should be considered.
The clinician must cautiously apply this recommendation; whether
longer trials with SSRIs increase the number of patients with late
improvement is not clear. The SSRIs possess a relatively flat dose-
response curve, suggesting that maximal clinical response may be
achieved at minimum effective doses; therefore, adequate time must
be allowed for clinical response and frequent early dose adjustments
must be avoided. Blood levels are rarely indicated in clinical settings,
but they may help clarify concerns about toxicity or medical
compliance.
The adverse effects of all SSRIs in children are similar to those in
adults. They are dose-dependent and may subside with time. SSRIs
may induce mania, hypomania, and behavioral activation, in which
patients become impulsive, silly, agitated, and daring. Other adverse
effects include GI symptoms, restlessness, diaphoresis, headaches,
akathisia, bruising, and changes in appetite, sleep, and sexual
functioning. The long-term adverse effects of SSRIs are not yet
known.
Follow-up
Further Inpatient Care
• See Treatment.
Complications
• Because of individual variation in the pharmacokinetics of
TCAs, monitoring plasma concentration is helpful to determining
optimal dosage. A plasma level of 150-250 mg/mL is considered
the range of therapeutic effectiveness, although an upper level
in children has not been established.
• Perform ECG before starting TCA therapy.
• Be alert to changes in the patient that might signify a
switch from a depressive state to a manic state. Childhood-onset
depression is commonly a precursor of bipolar disorder.
• TCAs in large doses can be lethal and should be avoided
in youths who are at risk for suicidal behaviors.
Prognosis
Patient Education
Miscellaneous
Medicolegal Pitfalls