Regenerative Braking Research Paper
Regenerative Braking Research Paper
Regenerative Braking Research Paper
DOWN
Pavas Sah;Dinesh Kumar
Abstract This paper will explore and assess the
technology and benefits of regenerative braking in electric
and hybrid cars. Regenerative braking is a technology that
recovers and harnesses some of the energy lost to friction
during braking and converts it to electrical energy to be
used to charge the cars batteries. Shifting our focus from
traditional vehicles to hybrid and electric vehicles would
alleviate much of our dependence on fossil fuels, and aid in
the restoration of the environment. Regenerative braking is a
key feature of hybrid and electric cars: one that will make
the transition to zero-emission vehicles more appealing,
cost-effective and environmentally beneficial. Our paper will
explore the process and mechanics by which regenerative
braking works. We will then discuss examples of how
regenerative braking is currently being used to demonstrate
its improvement over traditional braking. We will also
discuss some of the limitations of regenerative braking.
Throughout, our paper will focus on the economic and
environmental benefits of regenerative braking, and
demonstrate its potential as a long-term energy saving
solution.
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
component that generates the electrical energy that will be
utilized to perform these functions. This component is the
electric traction motor drive.
Electric Traction Motor Drive
The electric traction motor drive is the integral component in
determining the efficiency of a regenerative braking system,
as it is the part of the system that actually recovers the
energy from braking. But, as the electric motor of the
vehicle, it also provides the power in the form of electrical
energy to the vehicles wheels, generating torque, and
allowing the vehicle to propel forward [5]. When looking at
the history of electric traction motor drives, they are
certainly not a new technology. They have been commonly
used in electric trains and subways for many years. The
motor drives in these situations though, require a large
amount of power and generally have a constant supply of
power through the use of overhead railway lines [6]. But for
a typical vehicle, the battery, a source that can only provide
a limited amount of power, supplies the power, which
creates some difficulties in the design of this traction motor
to optimize performance.
When considering the electric traction motor drive in a
hybrid or electric vehicle, many considerations must be
taken into account to maximize the motors efficiency. In
the propulsion of hybrid and electric vehicles, it is expected
that the traction motor be utilized throughout the entire range
of velocities and torques that the vehicle can achieve. Thus,
the motor must be able to handle relatively frequent starting
and stopping and rapid acceleration rates, which requires the
motor to be able to produce a large amount of torque at all
speeds [5]. High torque density, or the ratio of the torque
produced by the motor to the mass of the motor system, is
greatly desired [5]. A lightweight electric traction motor
with a high torque output will certainly help maximize a
motors efficiency. Other attributes such as controllability
and stability are required for a successful electric traction
motor, and thus, the motor must be tested at all possible
combinations of torques and velocities that the motor is
capable of [5].
A widely accepted and convenient method of describing
the efficiency of electric traction motor drives is by an
efficiency map. An efficiency map plots the motor speed
versus the torque supplied by the motor and provides an
efficiency rating at these points [5]. Efficiency maps prove
to be extremely useful in that they allow engineers to
analyze the efficiency of these traction motors at all ranges
of speed and torque that can be supplied by the motor. A
typical efficiency map for an electric traction motor is
displayed in figure 1.
FIGURE 1
TYPICAL EFFICIENCY MAP OF A TRACTION MOTOR FOR A HYBRID VEHICLE
[5]
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
approximately 80% of the emissions from a typical vehicle
are created during the ignition and initial driving of a cold
engine [4]. A goal in regenerative braking systems is to use
some of the recovered energy to warm the engine before
ignition, greatly reducing carbon emissions.
FIGURE 2
REGENERATIVE BRAKING SCHEMATIC [4]
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
braking is also more than just a theory with accompanying
schematic drawings; it has been successfully tested and
developed, as the proceeding section will discuss.
FIGURE 3
INCREASE IN FUEL EFFICIENCY VS. ULTRACAPACITOR CAPACITY FOR
KODA FABIA [7]
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
eliminating carbon emissions from people who decide to use
an electric scooter as transport.
When the EVT 4000E electric scooter was outfitted with
a regenerative braking system and an ultracapacitor, the
scooters range per charge efficiency significantly increased.
An 18% increase in the electric scooters range per charge
can be seen in Figure 4 shown below, with an optimum
energy capacity of just 1 Wh [7]. This small optimal energy
capacity of the ultracapacitor in the electric scooter also
minimizes the weight of the regenerative braking system to
just 1 kg, and therefore also helps reduce the cost of the
whole system [7].
FIGURE 4
INCREASE IN FUEL EFFICIENCY VS. ULTRACAPACITOR CAPACITY FOR EVT
4000E SCOOTER [7]
FIGURE 5
REGENERATIVE ENERGY OVER TIME FOR NEDC DRIVING STANDARD [7]
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
spoken about the constraints and limitations that must be
considered when designing and deploying a regenerative
braking system. Some limitations are inevitable results of the
nature of regenerative braking. For example, even though
the conversion of electrical potential energy to kinetic
energy in the wheels measures around 80%, kinetic energy
must be converted back to electrical potential energy at the
same efficiency, so the energy retention given a 80%
conversion rate is 80% * 80% = 64%. At best, we can hope
to minimize energy dissipation to increase conversion
efficiency [10].
Other limitations restrict when regenerative braking can
be used. Safety becomes a concern under more extreme
braking conditions, where the negative torque imparted by
the regenerative brakes can cause the car to be unstable. To
ensure stability, regen is limited if the wheels start to slip.
Additionally, energy regeneration must be limited when the
battery is fully charged to prevent potential from rising to
dangerous levels [10].
Despite these limitations, however, the Tesla Roadster
has managed to make excellent use of regenerative braking.
This is not only apparent in the energy efficiency of the car,
but also the cars low CO2 emissions. It is an incomplete
assessment to say that because the car is purely electric, it
gives no emissions. While this is technically true, it doesnt
consider the indirect emissions from the energy generation
process. With these indirect emissions in mind, it is apparent
that how much electric vehicles cut emissions depends on
how clean the energy generation process is. For countries
like the U.S. and U.K., the well-to-wheels CO2 emissions
decrease is actually relatively small, especially when
compared to the decrease in a country like France, where
electricity is primarily generated by nuclear power [11]. The
comparisons of well-to-wheels CO2 emissions in these three
countries for the Tesla Roadster and two other electric
vehicles, the REVAi and the TH!NK City, are shown in
figure 7 below.
FIGURE 6
ENERGY REGENERATION UNDER EMERGENCY BRAKING CONDITIONS [8]
FIGURE 7
WELL-TO-WHEELS CO2 EMISSIONS FOR THE TESLA ROADSTER, TH!NK
CITY, AND REVAI [11]
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
Even so, the decrease in CO2 emissions when using an
electric vehicle when compared to a traditional combustion
engine vehicle is very tangible, even in the US and UK. In a
hypothetical situation where the fleet of all passenger cars in
each country is replaced with a fleet of electric vehicles such
as the Tesla Roadster, the decrease in CO2 emissions is
extremely significant. The comparisons of current and
hypothetical EV fleets are shown below.
TABLE 1
Possible Limitations
Pavas Sah
Dinesh Kumar
Energies. http://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/4/9/1461/#cite. Accessed: 26
January 2012.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank our parent and friends for providing
helpful advice to improve our paper. We would also like to
thank our seminar incharge Ms. Shallu for guiding us in the
writing of our paper. Finally, we would like to thank Ms.
Shallu for providing inspiration as we chose our topic.
REFERENCES
[1] (2009). 50by50: Global Fuel Economy Initiative. FIA Fuel Economy
Initiative
[Online].
Available:
http://www.fiafoundation.org/50by50/pages/homepage.aspx
[2] Frequently Asked Global Change Questions. Carbon Dioxide
Information
Analysis
Center.
[Online].
Available:
http://cdiac.ornl.gov/pns/faq.html
[3] C. Lampton. How Regenerative Braking Works. How Stuff Works.
[Online]. Available:
http://auto.howstuffworks.com/auto-parts/brakes/brake-types/regenerativebraking5.htm
[4] L. R. Brandenburg, E. T. King. (1992, November 10). Hybrid Electric
Vehicle Regenerative Braking Energy Recovery System United States
Patent.
[5] S. Williamson, A. Emadi, K. Ragashekara. Comprehensive Efficiency
Modeling of Electric Traction Motor Drives for Hybrid Electric Vehicle
Propulsion Applications. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.
[Online]
Available:
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpls/abs_all.jsp?arnumber=4273755&tag=1
[6] Advanced Green Technology. Genovation Cars. [Online] Available:
http://www.genovationcars.com/the-g2/technology
[7] P. Clarke, T. Muneer, K. Cullinane. 21 February 2010. Cutting vehicle
emissions
with
regenerative
braking.
Science
Direct.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1361920910000039;
[8] D. Peng, Y. Zhang, C. L. Yin, and J. W. Zhang. 29 January 2007.
Combined control of a regenerative braking and antilock braking system
for hybrid electric vehicles. International Journal of Automotive
Technology. http://www.springerlink.com/content/x2707734h5p38402/;
[9] Roadster Features and Specs. Tesla. [Online] Available:
http://www.teslamotors.com/roadster/specs
[10] Solberg. The Magic of Tesla Roadster Regenerative Braking. Tesla.
[Online]. Available: http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/magic-tesla-roadsterregenerative-braking
[11] A. Holdway, O. Inderwildi, D. King, A. Williams. Indirect Emissions
from Electric Vehicles: Emissions from Electricity Generation. Smith
School of Enterprise and the Environment. [Online] Available:
http://www.theengineer.co.uk/Journals/1/Files/2010/9/20/SSEEPolicyBrief-Indirectemissions%20v5.pdf
ADDITIONAL SOURCES
(2009). Nissan Unveils Leaf The Worlds First Electric Car Designed
for Affordability and Real-World Requirements. Nissan News Releases.
[Online].
Available:
http://www.nissanglobal.com/EN/NEWS/2009/_STORY/090802-02-e.html
Guoqing Xu, Weimin Li, Kun Xu, and Zhibin Song. (22 September 2011).
An Intelligent Regenerative Braking Strategy for Electric Vehicles.