Nanotechnology in Agriculture:

Scope and Current Relevance

NATIONAL ACADEMY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES, NEW DELHI
December 2013
CONVENER : Dr J .C. Tarafdar, ICAR National Fellow, Central Arid Zone Research
Institute, J odhpur
EDITORS : Dr C. Devakumar
: Dr P.K. Chhonkar
REVIEWERS : Dr S. Kundu, Dr S.S. Mukhopadhyay, Dr S.K. Sanyal and
Dr K.V.B.R. Tilak
CITATION : NAAS 2013. Nanotechnology in Agriculture: Scope and Current
Relevance. Policy Paper No. 63, National Academy of Agricultural
Sciences, New Delhi: 20 p.
EXECUTIVE COUNCIL 2013
President:
Prof. R.B. Singh (Delhi)
Immediate Past President:
Dr Mangala Rai (Patna)
Vice Presidents:
Dr Lalji Singh (Varanasi)
Dr P.L. Gautam (Hamirpur)
Secretaries:
Prof. Anwar Alam (Delhi)
Dr N.K. Singh (Delhi)
Foreign Secretary:
Dr S.M. Virmani (Hyderabad)
Editors:
Dr C. Devakumar (Delhi)
Dr P.K. Chhonkar (Delhi)
Treasurer
Dr Himanshu Pathak (Delhi)
Members:
Dr S.K. Datta (Delhi)
Dr B.S. Dhillon (Ludhiana)
Dr K. Gopakumar (Kochi)
Dr Raj K. Gupta (Delhi)
Dr (Ms) Renu Khanna-Chopra (Delhi)
Dr (Ms) Gita Kulshrestha (Delhi)
Dr Biswapati Mandal (Kalyani)
Dr T.A. More (Rahuri)
Dr Mruthyunjaya (Delhi)
Dr B.S. Pathak (Ghaziabad)
Dr S.N. Puri (Imphal)
Dr M.P. Yadav (Gurgaon)
Shri Arvind Kaushal
ICAR Nominee (Delhi)
Published by Mr H.C. Pathak, Executive Secretary on behalf of
NATIONAL ACADEMY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES
NASC, Dev Prakash Shastry Marg, New Delhi - 110 012
Tel: (011) 25846051-52; Fax: (011) 25846054
Email: [email protected]; Web site: http://www.naasindia.org
Preface
Nanotechnology, which deals with the matter at nanoscale (1-100 nm), is
commonly referred to as a generic technology that offers better-built, safer,
long-lasting, cost-effective and smart products that will fnd wide applications in
household, communications, medicine, agriculture and food industry, amongst
others. Nanotechnology-based products and its applications in agriculture include
nano-fertilizers, nano-herbicides, nano-pesticides, recalcitrant contaminants from
water, nano-scale carriers, nanosensors, veterinary care, fsheries and aquaculture,
detection of nutrient defciencies, preservation, photocatalysis, nanobarcode, quantum
dots etc. This fast growing technology is already having a signifcant commercial
impact, which will certainly increase in the future. While nanotechnologies offer
many opportunities for innovation, the use of nanomaterials in food and agriculture
has also raised a number of safety, environmental, ethical, policy and regulatory
issues.
With the above backdrop, the National Academy of Agricultural Sciences (NAAS),
involving leading nanotechnologists, organised a Brainstorming Session entitled
Nanotechnology in Agriculture : Scope and its Current Relevance on April 23, 2013
to discuss issues related to the potential effects and impact on human health and the
environment that might arise from exposure to nanosized materials. I am confdent
that this Policy Paper emanating from the Session would help the Government
of India and other relevant bodies towards making strategic plans for investment
in nanoscience research and technology development with special reference to
agricultural transformation.
The Academy appreciates the efforts of Dr. J .C. Tarafdar and his team in convening
the brainstorming event. Grateful thanks are due to Resource Persons, Reviewers
and Editors of the policy paper.
(R.B. Singh)
President, NAAS
1
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
Nanotechnology in Agriculture: Scope and
Current Relevance
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Agricultural scientists are facing a wide spectrum of challenges such as stagnation
in crop yields, low nutrient use effciency, declining soil organic matter, multi-nutrient
defciencies, climate change, shrinking arable land and water availability and shortage
of labour besides exodus of people from farming. In spite of immense constraints
faced, we need to attain a sustainable growth in agriculture at the rate of 4% to
meet the food security challenges. To address these problems, there is a need
to explore one of the frontier technologies such as Nanotechnology to precisely
detect and deliver the correct quantity of nutrients and pesticides that promote
productivity while ensuring environmental safety and higher use effciency. The
nanotechnology can be exploited in the value chain of entire agriculture production
system (Subramanian and Tarafdar, 2011). Nanotechnology is emerging as the sixth
revolutionary technology in the current era after the Industrial Revolution of Mid
1700s, Nuclear Energy Revolution of the 1940s, The Green Revolution of 1960s,
Information Technology Revolution of 1980s and Biotechnology Revolution of the
1990s. It is now emerging and fast growing feld of science which is being exploited
over a wide range of disciplines such as physics, chemistry, biology, material science,
electronics, medicine, energy, environment and health sectors.
Nantechnology deals with the matter at nanoscale (1-100 nm) dimensions. These
materials when reduced to the nanoscale show some properties which are different
from what they exhibit on a macro scale, enabling unique applications. Nanoscience
has brought revolution in different felds by helping develop processes and products
that are hardly possible to evolve through conventional methods. The nanotechnology-
aided applications have the potential to change agricultural production by allowing
better management and conservation of inputs of plant and animal production.
A survey by SalamancaBuentella et al. (2005) predicted several nanotechnology
applications for agricultural production for developing countries within next 10 years.
These included - (i) Nanoforms zeolites for slow release and effcient dosage of water
and fertilizers for plants; drugs for livestock; nanocapsules and herbicide delivery
(ii) Nanosensors for soil quality and for plant health monitoring; nanosensors for
pests detection (iii) Nanomagnets for removal of soil contaminants and (iv) Nano-
particles for new pesticides, insecticides, and insect repellents.
2
Policy Paper 63
The recent statistics suggest that about 90% of the nano-based patents and products
have come from just seven countries, namely, China, Germany, France, Japan,
Switzerland, South Korea and USA while Indias investments and progress is far
from satisfactory. However, to take advantage of the fascinating feld of nano-science,
the Government of India has invested Rs. 1000 crore through the Nano Mission
Project during 11
th
Five Year Plan and the investment is likely to be several folds
higher during the 12
th
Five Year Plan period (Box 1).
Box 1. Major Highlights of the Nano Mission, 12
th
Five Year Plan
Capacity-building in this upcoming area of research is of utmost importance for
the Nano Mission so that India emerges as a global knowledge-hub in this feld
also. For this, research on fundamental aspects on Nano Science and training
of large number of manpower are receiving prime attention. The Nano Mission is
also making efforts towards development of products and processes for national
development, especially in areas of national relevance like safe drinking water,
materials development, drug delivery, etc. For this, it is forging linkages between
educational and research institutions and industry and promoting Public-Private-
Partnership. The Nano Mission is also synergizing the efforts being made by
various agencies towards promoting Nano Science and Technology. International
collaborations are also being entered into, wherever required. Major activities
of the Nano Mission include: Setting up a dedicated Institute of Nano Science
& Technology, Post Graduate Programmes (M.Sc/M.Tech.) in 16 Institutions/
Universities across the country, Funding of around 235 individual scientist-centric
research projects on fundamental scientifc aspects of Nano scale systems, and
Laying down a Regulatory Framework for Nanotechnology in India.
Source: Planning Commission, 2011
(http://planningcommission.gov.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp12/sandt/wg_dst2905.pdf)
The Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) has opened up an exclusive platform
to target Nanotechnology Applications in Agriculture. The ICAR Nanotechnology
Platform encompasses major themes such as synthesis of nano-particles for agricultural
use, quick diagnostic kits for early detection of pests and diseases, nano-pheromones
for effective pest control, nano agri-inputs for enhanced use effciencies, precision
water management, stabilization of organic matter in soil, nano food systems and
bio safety besides establishing the policy frame work. Green-synthesis and microbial
synthesis of nanomaterials for their agricultural use may be very important as they
are naturally encapsulated with mother protein, therefore, more stable and safer to
3
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
biological system. At present in India research is mainly concentrated on nano particle
synthesis, smart release of nutrients from nano-fertilizers, nano-induced polysaccharide
powder for moisture retention/soil aggregation and C build up, regulated release of
active ingredients from nano-encapsulated herbicides, nano-seed invigoration, and slow
and steady release of pesticides, nano-flm for extended shelf-life of perishables and
nano-remediation of soil and aquatic pollutants. These are cutting-edge researchable
areas which are expected to expand in the years to come. However, if the nanoproducts
and the processes for creating them are not managed judiciously, there could be
serious health and environmental risks.
With the above backdrop, the National Academy of Agricultural Sciences (NAAS),
involving leading nanotechnologists, organised a Brainstorming Session entitled
Nanotechnology in Agriculture : Scope and Current Relevance on April 23, 2013 to
discuss issues related to the potential effects and impact on human health and the
environment that might arise from exposure to nanosized materials. This document
summarizes the status of the use of the technology and the policy options and
actions for utilizing it in India.
2.0 APPLICATIONS
2.1 Application of Nanotechnology in Seed Science
Seed is most important input determining productivity of any crop. Conventionally,
seeds are tested for germination and distributed to farmers for sowing. In spite of the
fact that seed testing is done in well equipped laboratories, it is hardly reproduced
in the feld due to the inadequate moisture under rainfed conditions. In India, more
than 60% of the net area sown is rainfed; hence, it is quite appropriate to develop
technologies for rainfed agriculture. A group of research workers is currently working
on metal oxide nano-particles and carbon nanotube to improve the germination of
rainfed crops. Khodakovskaya et al. (2009) have reported the use of carbon nano-
tube for improving the germination of tomato seeds through better permeation of
moisture. Their data show that carbon nanotubes (CNTs) serve as new pores for
water permeation by penetration of seed coat and act as a passage to channelize
the water from the substrate into the seeds. These processes facilitate germination
which can be exploited in rainfed agricultural system.
2.2 Nano-fertilizers for balanced crop nutrition
In India, fertilizers, alongwith quality seed and irrigation, are mainly responsible for
enhanced food grain production (55 mt) in 1960s to (254 mt) in 2011 coinciding with
the spectacular increase in fertilizer consumptions from 0.5 mt to 23 mt, respectively.
4
Policy Paper 63
It has been conclusively demonstrated that fertilizer contributes to the tune of
35-40% of the productivity of any crop. Considering its importance, the Government
of India is heavily subsidising the cost of fertilizers particularly urea. This has resulted
in imbalanced fertilization and occurrence in some areas, nitrate pollution of ground
waters due to excessive nitrogen application. In the past few decades, use effciencies
of N, P and K fertilizers have remained constant as 30-35%, 18-20% and 35-40%,
respectively, leaving a major portion of added fertilizers to accumulate in the soil or
enter into aquatic system causing eutrophication. In order to address issues of low
fertilizer use effciency, imbalanced fertilization, multi-nutrient defciencies and decline
of soil organic matter, it is important to evolve a nano-based fertilizer formulation
with multiple functions.
Nano-fertilizer technology is very innovative but scantily reported in the literature.
However, some of the reports and patents strongly suggest that there is a vast
scope for the formulation of nano-fertilizers. Signifcant increase in yields have been
observed due to foliar application of nano particles as fertilizer (Tarafdar, 2012;
Tarafdar et al. 2012a). It was shown that 640 mg ha
-1
foliar application (40 ppm
concentration) of nanophosphorus gave 80 kg ha
-1
P equivalent yield of clusterbean
and pearl millet under arid environment. Currently, research is underway to develop
nano-composites to supply all the required essential nutrients in suitable proportion
through smart delivery system. Preliminary results suggest that balanced fertilization
may be achieved through nanotechnology (Tarafdar et al. 2012b).
Indeed the metabolic assimilation within the plant biomass of the metals, e.g.,
micronutrients, applied as Nano-formulations through soil-borne and foliar application or
otherwise needs to be ascertained. Further, the Nano-composites being contemplated
to supply all the nutrients in right proportions through the Smart delivery systems
also needs to be examined closely. Currently, the nitrogen use effciency is low due
to the loss of 50-70% of the nitrogen supplied in conventional fertilizers. New nutrient
delivery systems that exploit the porous nanoscale parts of plants could reduce
nitrogen loss by increasing plant uptake. Fertilizers encapsulated in nanoparticles
will increase the uptake of nutrients (Tarafdar et al. 2012c). In the next generation
of nanofertilizers, the release of the nutrients can be triggered by an environmental
condition or simply released at desired specifc time.
2.3 Nano-herbicide for effective weed control
Weeds are menace in agriculture. Since two-third of Indian agriculture is rainfed farming
where usage of herbicide is very limited, weeds have the potential to jeopardize
the total harvest in the delicate agro-ecosystems. Herbicides available in the market
are designed to control or kill the above ground part of the weed plants. None of
5
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
the herbicides inhibits activity of viable belowground plant parts like rhizomes or
tubers, which act as a source for new weeds in the ensuing season. Soils infested
with weeds and weed seeds are likely to produce lower yields than soils where
weeds are controlled. Improvments in the effcacy of herbicides through the use
of nanotechnology could result in greater production of crops. The encapsulated
nano-herbicides are relevant, keeping in view the need to design and produce
a nano-herbicide that is protected under natural environment and acts only when
there is a spell of rainfall, which truly mimics the rainfed system.
Developing a target specifc herbicide molecule encapsulated with nanoparticle is
aimed for specifc receptor in the roots of target weeds, which enter into roots system
and translocated to parts that inhibit glycolysis of food reserve in the root system.
This will make the specifc weed plant to starve for food and gets killed (Chinnamuthu
and Kokiladevi, 2007). Adjuvants for herbicide application are currently available that
claim to include nanomaterials. One nanosurfactant based on soybean micelles has
been reported to make glyphosate-resistant crops susceptible to glyphosate when
it is applied with the nanotechnology-derived surfactant.
2.4 Nano-pesticide
Persistence of pesticides in the initial stage of crop growth helps in bringing
down the pest population below the economic threshold level and to have
an effective control for a longer period. Hence, the use of active ingredients in
the applied surface remains one of the most cost-effective and versatile means of
controlling insect pests. In order to protect the active ingredient from the adverse
environmental conditions and to promote persistence, a nanotechnology approach,
namely nano-encapsulation can be used to improve the insecticidal value. Nano-
encapsulation comprises nano-sized particles of the active ingredients being sealed
by a thin-walled sac or shell (protective coating). Recently, several research papers
have been published on the encapsulation of insecticides. Nano-encapsulation of
insecticides, fungicides or nematicides will help in producing a formulation which
offers effective control of pests while preventing accumulation of residues in soil. In
order to protect the active ingredient from degradation and to increase persistence,
a nanotechnology approach of controlled release of the active ingredient may be
used to improve effectiveness of the formulation that may greatly decrease amount
of pesticide input and associated environmental hazards. Nano-pesticides will reduce
the rate of application because the quantity of product actually being effective is
at least 10-15 times smaller than that applied with classical formulations, hence a
much smaller than the normal amount could be required to have much better and
prolonged management.
6
Policy Paper 63
Several pesticide manufacturers are developing pesticides encapsulated in
nanoparticles (OECD and Allianz, 2008). These pesticides may be time released or
released upon the occurrence of an environmental trigger (for example, temperature,
humidity, light). It is unclear whether these pesticide products will be commercially
available in the short-term.
Plant diseases are major factors limiting crop yields. The problem with the disease
management lies with the detection of the exact stage of prevention. Most of the
time appropriate plant protection chemicals are applied to the crop as a precautionary
measure leading to avoidable environmental hazards, or else applications are made
after the appearance of the disease symptoms, thereby causing some amount of crop
losses. Among the different diseases, the viral diseases are the most diffcult to control,
as one has to stop the spread of the disease by the vectors. But once it starts showing
its symptoms, pesticide application would not be of much use. Therefore, detection
of the exact stage such as stage of viral DNA replication or the production of initial
viral protein is the key to the success of control of viral diseases. Nano-based viral
diagnostics, including multiplexed diagnostics kits development, have taken momentum
in order to detect the exact strain of virus and the stage of application of some
therapeutic to stop the disease. Detection and utilization of biomarkers, that accurately
indicate disease stages, is also an emerging area of research in bio-Nanotechnology.
Measuring differential protein production in both healthy and diseased states leads to
the identifcation of the development of several proteins during the infection cycle.
Clay nanotubes (halloysite) have been developed as carriers of pesticides at low
cost, for extended release and better contact with plants, and they will reduce the
amount of pesticides by 70-80%, thereby reducing the cost of pesticide with minimum
impact on water streams.
2.5 Nanotechnology in Water Management
Nanotechology, offers the potential of novel nanomaterials for the treatment of surface
water, groundwater and wastewater contaminated by toxic metal ions, organic and
inorganic solutes and microorganisms. Due to their unique activity towards recalcitrant
contaminants many nanomaterials are under research and development for use for
water purifcation.
To maintain public health, pathogens in water need to be identifed rapidly and
reliably. Unfortunately, traditional laboratory tests are time consuming. Faster methods
involving enzymes, immunological or genetic tests are under development. Water
fltration may be improved with the use of nanofber membranes and the use of
nanobiocides, which appear promisingly effective. Bioflms contaminating potable
7
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
water are mats of bacteria wrapped in natural polymers which are diffcult to treat
with antimicrobials or other chemicals. They can be cleaned up only mechanically,
which cost substantial down-time and labour. Work is in progress to develop enzyme
treatments that may be able to break down such bioflms.
2.6 Nano-scale carriers
Nanoscale carriers can be utilized for the effcient delivery of fertilizers, pesticides,
herbicides, plant growth regulators, etc. The mechanisms involved in the effcient
delivery, better storage and controlled release include: encapsulation and entrapment,
polymers and dendrimers, surface ionic and weak bond attachments among others.
These help to improve stability against degradation in the environment and ultimately
reduce the amount to be applied, which reduces chemical runoff and alleviates
environmental problems. These carriers can be designed in such a way that they can
anchor plant roots to the surrounding soil constituents and organic matter. This can
only be possible if we unrevel the molecular and conformational mechanisms between
the nanoscale delivery and targeted structures, and soil fractions. Such advances as
and when they happen will help in slowing the uptake of active ingredients, thereby
reducing the amount of inputs to be used and also the waste produced.
2.7 Biosensors to detect nutrients and contaminants
Protection of the soil health and the environment requires the rapid, sensitive detection
of pollutants and pathogens with molecular precision. Soil fertility evaluation is being
carried out for the past sixty years with the same set of protocols which may be obsolete
for the current production systems and in the context of precision farming approaches.
Accurate sensors are needed for in situ detection, as miniaturized portable devices,
and as remote sensors, for the real-time monitoring of large areas in the feld.
These instruments are able to reduce the time required for lengthy microbial testing
and immunoassays. Application of these instruments include detection of contaminants
in different bodies such as water supplies, raw food materials and food products.
Enzymes can act as a sensing element as these are very specifc in attachment to
certain biomolecules. Electronic nose (E-nose) is used to identify different types of
odors; it uses a pattern of response across an array of gas sensors. It can identify the
odorant, estimate the concentration of the odorant and fnd characteristic properties
of the odor in the same way as might be perceived by the human nose. It mainly
consists of gas sensors which are composed of nanoparticles e.g. ZnO nanowires.
Their resistance changes with the passage of a certain gas and generates a change
in electrical signal that forms the fngerprint pattern for gas detection.
8
Policy Paper 63
Biosensors provide high performance capabilities for use in detecting contaminants in
food or environmental media. They offer high specifcity and sensitivity, rapid response,
user-friendly operation, and compact size at a low cost (Amine et al., 2006). While
the direct enzyme inhibition sensors currently lack the analytical ability to discriminate
between multiple toxic substances in a sample (such as simultaneous presence of
heavy metal and pesticide), they may prove useful as a screening tool to determine
when a sample contains one or more contaminants. These methods are amenable
to deployment in single-use test strips (making them useful to those in the feld).
According to Hu et al. (2010), detection of multiple residues of organophosphorus
pesticides has been accomplished using a nanomagnetic particle in an enzyme-
linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) test. The authors suggest that ELISA is more
cost-effective than analytical tests requiring expensive laboratory equipment with
high levels of skill.
2.8 Agricultural Engineering Issues
Nanotechnology has many applications in the feld of agricultural machinery. These
cover: application in machine structure and agricultural tools to increase their
resistance against wear and corrosion and ultraviolet rays; producing strong mechanical
components with use of Nano-coating and use of bio-sensors in smart machines for
mechanical-chemical weed control; production of Nano-cover for bearings to reduce
friction. The use of Nanotechnology in production of alternative fuels and reduction
of environmental pollution are also worth mentioning.
2.9 Application of Nanotechnology in Animal Sciences
Nanotechnology has the ability to provide appropriate solutions for addressing the
issues of food items, veterinary care and prescription medicines as well as vaccines
for domesticated animals. Taking certain medications such as antibiotics, vaccines,
and probiotics, would be effective in treating the infections, nutrition and metabolic
disorders, when used at the nano level. Medicines used at the nano level have
multilateral properties to remove biological barriers for increased effciency of the applied
medicine. Appropriate timing for the release of drug and self-regulatory capabilities
are the main advantages of the use of nanotechnology in the application of drugs.
The C-60 carbon particle (bucky ball) is spherical molecule having nearly 1 nm
diameter. It is non-toxic to the live cells and biocompatible in nature. It can be used
as a carrier to deliver the water soluble peptides and drugs. The nanotechnology can
help to understand certain drug behaviour in an animal body. The nano particles can
penetrate the skin through minor abrasions; these are reported to be used as sensor
to detect the altered cell behaviour. The dendrimers are synthetic three dimensional
9
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
macromolecules having a core particle surrounded by branches like a tree. They
can be conjugated with the target molecule like drug as they are biocompatible
and are easily cleared from blood through the kidney. It was observed that in vivo
delivery of dendrimer-methotrexate reduce the tumour size ten times more than the
free methotrexate (Hong et al., 2007).
The nano-magnets can be used as drug delivery system specially to treat the cancerous
growth without any harm to the surrounding tissues. Different types of proteins like
albumin, gelatin, gliadin and legumin can be used to prepare nanoparticle-based
drug delivery system. Inert nanobeads were used to neutralize the antigen causing
osteoarthritis in racing horses. Use of nano based antibiotics in treatment of animal
diseases requires less amounts of antibiotics leaving less antibiotic residues. Nanoparticle
based chromium supplementation has benefcial effects on growth performance and
body composition and it increases tissue chromium concentration in the muscles. Iron
defciency is a common problem in animals, especially during the early stage of life,
gestation and parasitic infestation due to less bioavailability. The bioavailability can be
increased with the supplementation of ferric phospholic nano-particles.
Nanotechnology is used to produce the chicken/ goat meat in the laboratory in large
quantities maintaining the same nutritive value, taste, texture without any hazard
(vegetarian meat). It can be eaten by the vegetarians also. It may solve the food
scarcity problem, thereby eradicating the hunger. Use of nanotechnology in designer
egg production is well-known. It can produce the eggs with low cholesterol, less yolk
content, more nutrients, and desired antibodies. In addition, nano-based sensors can
help in early detection of egg-borne pathogens (Verma et al., 2012).
2.10 Nano technology application in fsheries and aquaculture
Nanotechnology has tremendous potential to revolutionize fsheries and aquaculture
sector. Nanotechnology tools like nano-materials, nano-sensor, DNA nano-vaccines,
gene delivery and smart drug delivery have the potential of solving many puzzles
related to fsheries nutrition and health production, reproduction, prevention and
treatment of disease. Nanotechnology will help fsh processing industry for producing
quality products by detecting bacteria in packaging, producing strong favour, colour
quality and safety.
3.0 SMART DELIVERY SYSTEMS
Nanoscale devices are envisioned that would have the capability to detect and treat
diseases, nutrient defciencies or any other maladies in crops long before symptoms
were visually exhibited. Smart Delivery Systems for agriculture can possess timely
controlled, spatially targeted, self-regulated, remotely regulated, pre-programmed, or
10
Policy Paper 63
multi-functional characteristics to avoid biological barriers to successful targeting.
Smart delivery systems can monitor the effects of delivery of nutrients or bioactive
molecules or any pesticide molecules. This is widely used in health sciences wherein
nanoparticles are exploited to deliver required quantities of medicine to the place of
need in human system. In the smart delivery system, a small sealed package carries
the drug which opens up only when the desirable location or infection site of the
human or animal system is reached. This would allow judicious use of antibiotics
than otherwise would be possible.
3.1 Nanodevices for Identity Preservation (IP) and Tracking
One of the major constraints in Indian agriculture is the quality maintenance of
agricultural produce. Proper monitoring of production system through nanotechnology
will be appropriate to promote quality and make a clear distinction with organic
products. Identity Preservation (IP) is a system that creates increased value by
providing customers with information about practices and activities used to produce
a particular crop or other agricultural products. Certifying inspectors can take advantage
of IP as a better way of recording, verifying, and certifying agricultural practices.
Through IP, it is possible to provide stakeholders and consumers with access to
information, records and supplier protocols. Quality assurance of agricultural products
safety and security could be signifcantly improved through IP at the nano-scale.
Nano-scale IP holds the possibility of continuous tracking and recording of the history
which a particular agricultural product experiences. The nano-scale monitors may
be linked to the recording and the tracking devices to improve identity preservation
of food and agricultural products. The IP system is highly useful to discriminate
organic versus conventional agricultural products.
3.2 Nanolignocellulosic materials
Recently, nanosized lignocellulosic materials have been obtained from crops and
trees which had opened up a new market for innovative and value-added nano-
sized materials and products, e.g. nano-sized cellulosic crystals have been used
as lightweight reinforcement in polymeric matrix (Mathew et al., 2009). These can
be applied in food and other packaging, construction, and transportation vehicle
body structures. Cellulosic nano-whisker production technology from wheat straw
has been developed by the Michigan Biotechnology Incorporate (MBI) International,
and is expected to make biocomposites that could substitute for fberglass and
plastics in many applications, including automative parts (Liestritz, 2007). For the
commercialization of this technology, North Dakota State University (NDSU), USA
is currently engaged in a project.
11
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
3.3 Photocatalysis
One of the processes using nanoparticles is photocatalysis. The mechanism of this
reaction is that when nanoparticles of specifc compounds are subjected to UV light,
the electrons in the outermost shell (valence electrons) are excited resulting in the
formation of electron hole pairs, i.e. negative electrons and positive holes. Analogy
with n- and p-type semiconductors, i.e., the Group IV elements, e.g. Germenium of
the Periodic Table, dopted with, respectively, minute quantities of the Group V and
Group III impurities, is worth noting. Due to their large surface-to-volume ratio, these
have very effcient rates of degradation and disinfection. As the size of the particles
decrease, surface atoms are increased, which results in tremendous increase in
chemical reactivity and other physico-chemical properties related to some specifc
conditions such as photocatalysis, photoluminescence, etc. So this process can be
used for the decomposition of many toxic compounds such as pesticides, which take
a long time to degrade under normal conditions. Nanoparticles can be used for the
bioremediation of resistant or slowly degradable compounds like pesticides.
The removal of toxins from wastewater is an emerging issue due to its effects on
living organisms. Many strategies have been applied for wastewater treatment with
little success. Photocatalysis can be used for purifcation, decontamination and
deodorization of air. It has been found that semiconductor sensitized photosynthetic
and photocatalytic processes can be used for the removal of organics, destruction
of cancer cells, bacteria and viruses. Application of photocatalytic degradation has
gained popularity in the area of wastewater treatment.
3.4 Nanobarcode technology
In our daily life, identifcation tags have been applied in wholesale agriculture and
livestock products. Due to their small size, nanoparticles have been applied in many
felds ranging from advanced biotechnology to agricultural encoding. Nanobarcodes
(> 1 million) have been applied in multiplexed bioassays and general encoding
because of their possibility of formation of a large number of combinations that render
them attractive for this purpose. The UV lamp and optical microscope are used for
the identifcation of micrometer-sized glass barcodes which are formed by doping
with rare earth containing a specifc type of pattern of different fuorescent materials.
The particles to be utilized in nanobarcodes should be easily encodeable, machine-
readable, durable, sub-micronsized taggant particles. For the manufacture of these
nanobarcode particles, the process is semi-automated and highly scalable, involving
the electro plating of inert metals (gold, silver, etc.) into templates defning particle
diameter, and then the resulting striped nanorods from the templates are released.
12
Policy Paper 63
Nanobarcodes have been used as ID tags for multiplexed analysis of gene expression
and intracellular histopathology. In the near future, more effective identifcation and
utilization of plant gene trait resources is expected to introduce rapid and cost
effective capability through advances in nanotechnology-based gene sequencing.
Nanobarcodes serve as uniquely identifable nanoscale tags and have been applied
for non-biological applications such as for authentication or tracking in agricultural food
and husbandry products. Such nanobarcode technology will enable one to develop
new auto-ID technologies for the tagging of items previously not practical to tag with
conventional barcodes. With the enhanced importance of traceability in food trade,
such technologies will be helpful in promoting biosafe international food trade.
3.5 Quantum dots (QDs) for staining bacteria
Bacteria, the most primitive life forms present almost everywhere, are useful as well
as harmful for life. There are numerous bacteria which are responsible for many
diseases in human like tetanus, typhoid fever, diptheria, syphilis, cholera, food-borne
illness, leprosy and tuberculosis caused by different species. As a remedial process,
we need to detect bacteria and for this, dye staining method is used. To stain bacteria,
the most commonly used biolabels are organic dyes, but these are expensive and
their fuorescence degrades with time. Fluorescent labeling by quantum dots (QDs)
with bio-recognition molecules has been discovered through the recent developments
in the feld of luminescent nanocrystals. QDs are better than conventional organic
fuorophores (dyes) due to their more effcient luminescence compared to the organic
dyes, narrow emission spectra, excellent photostability, symmetry and tunability
according to the particles sizes and material composition. By a single excitation light
source, they can be excited to all colors of the QDs due to their broad absorption
spectra. Bio-labeled Bacillus bacteria with nanoparticle consisting of ZnS and Mn
2+

capped with bio compatible chitosan gave an organ glow when viewed under a
fuorescence microscope. For the detection of E. coli O157 : H7, QDs were used as
a fuorescence marker coupled with immune magnetic separation. For this purpose,
magnetic beads were coated with anti-E. coli O157 antibodies to selectively attach
target bacteria, and biotin-conjugated anti-E. coli antibodies to form sandwich immune
complexes. QDs were labeled with the immune complexes via biotin-streptavidin
conjugation after magnetic separation.
3.6 Nanobiotechnology
Nanobiotechnology has the potential to increase the effciency and quality of agricultural
production and food storage, to enhance the safety of food supplies for the protection
of consumers and producers and to introduce new functionality (value-added products)
13
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
for food, fber and agricultural commodities. Nanobiotechnology will pave the ways for
new researchable areas and applications such as DNA chip, protein identifcation and
manipulation, novel nucleic acid engineering based flms, smart delivery of DNA using
gold nanoparticles. Biological tests measuring the presence or activity of selected
substances become quicker, more sensitive and more fexible when nano-particles
are put to work as tags or labels. Magnetic nanoparticles, bound to suitable antibody,
are used to label specifc molecules, structures or microorganisms.
3.7 Nano-food industry
During the last three years, food industries have witnessed that the nanotechnology
has been really integrated in a number of food and food packaging products. There
are now over 300 nanofood products available on the market worldwide. These exciting
achievements have encouraged a large increase of R & D investments in nanofood.
Today, the Nanotechnology is no longer an empty buzzword, but an indispensable
reality in the food industry. The impact of nanotechnology is huge, ranging from
basic food to food processing, from nutrition delivery to intelligent packaging. It is
estimated that the nanotechnology and nano-bio-info convergence will infuence over
40% of the food industries up to 2015. There is a strong need to develop nanofood
through nano-engineering of food ingredients. Under this, texture, taste, favour and
color of food ingredients can be modifed using nanoengineering without losing their
nutritional value or with improved nutritional quality. Nanotechnology can extend the
shelf-life of perishables like fruits, vegetables, and fowers during transportation, thus
preventing the post-harvest losses.
3.8 Nanoparticles for fltration
The NRC report (2008) on emerging technologies that will beneft farmers in
Africa and Asia lists several nanomaterials that are believed to be economical
and effective for water purifcation. Nano-enabled water treatment techniques rely
on membranes and flters made of carbon nanotubes, nanoporous ceramics, and
magnetic nanoparticles rather than the use of chemicals and ultraviolet light used
in conventional water treatment (Hillie and Hlophe, 2007). Carbon nanotube flters
can be used to remove impurities from drinking water. A fused carbon nanotube
mesh that can flter out water-borne pathogens, lead, uranium, and arsenic has
been suggested as a useful nanotechnology by the NRC report. The NRC report
also discusses the application of the NanoCeram flter, which uses a positively
charged flter to trap negatively charged bacteria and viruses. This fltering device
removes endotoxins, DNA, viruses, and micron-sized particles. A simple handheld
magnet can be used to remove the nanocrystals and the arsenic from water. Such
14
Policy Paper 63
a treatment could be used as a point-of-use water fltration process. However, the
problem remains as how to dispose of the enriched product generated during the
fltration process in an eco-friendly manner.
3.9 Wireless nanosensors for precision agriculture
Crop growth and feld conditions like moisture level, soil fertility, temperature, crop
nutrient status, insects, plant diseases, weeds, etc. can be monitored through
advancement in nanotechnology. Such real-time monitoring is done by employing
networks of wireless nano-sensors across the cultivated felds, providing essential
data for agronomic processes like optimal time of planting and harvesting of the
crops. It is also helpful for monitoring the time and amount of water application,
fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides and other treatments. This has moved precision
agriculture to a much higher level of control, for instance, in water usage, leading
eventually to conservation of water. More precise water delivery systems are
likely to be developed in the near future. The factors critical for such development
include water storage, in situ water holding capacity, water distribution near roots,
water absorption effciency of plants, encapsulated water released on demand, and
interaction with feld intelligence through nano-sensor systems.
4.0 HEALTH & ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS
Researchers noted that rats breathing in Nano particles generally have those particles
settle in the brain and lungs, which led to signifcant increases in biomarkers for
infammation and stress response and that Nano-particles include induce skin aging
through oxidative stress in hairless mice. Extremely small fbres, so called Nano-
fbres, can be as harmful for the lung as asbestos is (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/
health-193551960, 2012-08-24). The Royal Society report identifed a risk of Nano-
particles or Nano-tubes being released during disposal, destruction and recycling, and
recommended that manufacturers of products that fall under extended producers
responsibility regimes such as end-of-life regulations to publish procedures outlining
how these materials will be manage to minimize possible human and environmental
exposure. Refecting the challenges for ensuring responsible life cycle regulation, the
Institute for Food and Agricultural Standards (http://www.msu.edu/~ifas/) has proposed
that standards for Nanotechnology research and development be integrated across
consumer, worker and environmental standards. They also propose that the NGOs and
other citizen groups play a meaningful role in the development of these standards.
The ultra-small sizes that make the nanoparticles of immense usefulness, unfortunately
the same characteristic also causes several adverse effects and may represent
15
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
signifcant hazards to environment, animals, human beings and plants when used
non-judiciously. The possible hazards are mentioned hereunder:
Nanoparticles as pesticides, fertilizers or in other formulations, when air-borne,
may deposit on above ground parts of plants. They may plug stomata and
create a fne physical and toxic barrier layer on stigma preventing pollen tube
penetration. They may also enter the vascular tissue and impair translocation
of water, minerals and photosynthate.
Animals may inhale nanoparticles resulting into various ill effects and disorders.
The particles may enter the bloodstream.
Nano-pesticides may reduce environmental contamination through the reduction in
pesticide application rates, but they may also create new kinds of contamination
of soils and waterways due to enhanced transport, longer persistence and higher
toxicity.
Air-borne nanoparticles present some specifc hazards for human health, they may
enter the body through the respiratory system. Due to the entry of nanoparticles
into lungs and blood stream, there is possibility of infammation, protein fbrillation
and induction of genotoxicity.
Because of these risks, the use of nanotechnology in fertilizer and pesticide
formulations has to be addressed very cautiously, and this warrants mandatory need
to critically analyse and examine the risks involved with the nano-formulations.
5.0 WAY FORWARD: POLICY OPTIONS AND ACTIONS
Nanotechnology has emerged as a cutting edge technology with profound realized
and potential outcomes and impacts. It is a powerful tool for food and nutritional
security, management of abiotic and biotic stresses, enhanced input use effciency,
elevated yield potential and superior quality traits. However, the process and products
if not handled properly, may pose human health and environmental risks. Hence,
strategic research and policy options and actions, as informed by rigorous science,
are needed to judiciously develop this new emerging technology to be used in
agriculture for congruent enhanced productivity, proftability, social equity, biosafety
and environmental sustainability.
5.1 Strategic Research
Strengthen effcacious biological synthesis (green synthesis) of nanoparticles of
suitable size and shape.
16
Policy Paper 63
Deepen understanding on mycorrhizal fungi and root endophytes which
produce a large amount of unknown and uncharacterized nanoparticles that are
responsible for plant productivity, as also on the transport of nanoparticles from
soil solution to plants and interactions between plants and nanoparticles.
Streamline the use of Nano-embedded symbiotic fungi and their application
on plants of economic importance like sugarcane, pulses, oilseeds and those
of medicinal value, and explore the opportunities in tea and plantation crops,
spices, and tropical fruits.
Analyse non-target effects of nanoparticles/nano-formulations/nano-gels on the
natural enemies and on the population of soil-borne benefcial micro-fora, various
biological control systems such as NPV formulations, Bt formulations, Trichoderma
formulations and EPN formulations need to be studied. Also analyse the side
effects of nanoparticles on soil microbial ecology, especially microbial structure
and population dynamics.
Develop suitable protocol of seed coating with micronutrient nano-particles for
producing customized seed for micronutrient defcient areas of the country, and
develop Nano-sensor based soil, water and pesticide testing tools.
Work out the economics of the use of nanotechnology based on statistically
sound pilot trials, participatory demonstrations and feld trials. And, scientifcally
assess public perception, nano-ethics aspects like nano semantics, nano-praxis
and nano-pragmatism, and priority niche areas viz. organics, for application of
Nano-technology.
5.2 Policy Options and Actions
5.2.1 Ensure human and environmental health security
Identify, upgrade and create (if needed) institutions with relevant expertise and
facilities and accredit and network them for enhancing their effciency in biosafety
evaluation of nanoparticles. Following the Food Safety and Standards Authority
of India (FSSAI) and FAO / WHO standards, formulate clear guidelines regarding
the parameters and methodology of monitoring and evaluation.
Evaluate food and environmental safety of specifc nano food/products before
their commercial release, and build capacity to handle a large number of samples
which are expected in view of the increasing number of new nano products.
In the context of the environmental exposure to nanotechnology-based material
and products, thereby increasing the risk to human (since water resources are
17
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
particularly vulnerable to direct and indirect contamination with nano-materials),
in particular, evaluate the potential toxicity and environmental implications of
nano-materials to aquatic organisms.
Create network of qualifed and certifed dealers, trained applicators and other
personnel to promote quality products and to minimize problems at the feld
level. Compliance to the prescribed schedules and guidelines for the handling,
storage, packaging, transportation, etc. of the products must be enforced from
the time of their manufacture until the feld impact assessment, with effective
deterrents against any substandard approaches.
5.2.2 Build necessary human resources, Investment and Institutions
Initiate resident instructions and curricula on agricultural nanotechnology at
selected agricultural universities and link the concerned institutions. To begin
with, a minimum of 5 students may be sponsored at Ph.D. level for degree in
agricultural nanotechnology.
The ICAR may develop MoUs with institutes like BARC, Saha Institute of Nuclear
Physics, IUAC etc. to share the costly equipment such as ion beam etc. to
functionalize, manipulate, and fabricate nano-materials. As the nanotechnology
research and development activities require sophisticated equipment facility
in addition to the infrastructure, investment in Agricultural Nanotechnology
should be intensifed. The private sector should also complement the basic
and strategic research undertaken by the public sector through appropriate
funding and resource sharing. Leading Physics, Chemistry, Nanotechnology,
Nanobiotechnology and Electronics experts should be hired at strategic
agricultural institutions to gain insights into products that will quickly fow into
the Indian agriculture.
Enhance public awareness relating to the scope and role of nanotechnology in
sustainable natural resource management, pest control and other such related
areas through the information media. The extension personnel need to be
sensitized as to the usefulness of nanotechnology. The Krishi Vigyan Kendras
(KVKs) should be equipped to undertake this exercise.
Expose concerned agricultural scientists, extension workers and students to
the developments in nano-science and technology through periodic trainings
at selected ICAR or other national institutes as well as at leading institutions
abroad, and strengthen selective international collaboration.
18
Policy Paper 63
Review the technological application of nano-products through the regulatory
processes, keeping in view the social, political and cultural implications based on an
integrated effort of different subject matter specialists, planners and stake-holders.
Since currently our preparedness in Agricultural Nanotechnology, particularly for
risk assessment research, is inadequate for providing the desired scientifc support
to the regulatory process, a National Institute of Agricultural Nano-Technology
and Nano-Safety should be established with the state-of-art infrastructure,
human resource and research programmes for conducting frontier research,
capacity building in this feld and providing policy support and technical advice
to the government.
REFERENCES
Amine, A., Mohammadi, H., Bourais, I. and Palleschi, G. (2006). Enzyme inhibition-
based biosensors for food safety and environmental monitoring. Biosensors and
Bioelectronics 21, 1405-1423.
Chinnamuthu, C. R. and Kokiladevi, E. (2007). Weed management through
nanoherbicides. In: Application of nanotechnology in agriculture. C.R. Chinnamuthu,
B. Chandrasekaran, and C. Ramasamy (Eds.) Tamil Nadu Agricultural University,
Coimbatore, India.
Hillie, T. and Hlophe, M. (2007). Nanotechnology and the challenge of clean water.
Nature Nanotechnology 2, 663664.
Hong, S., Leroueil, P. R., Majoros, I. J., Orr, B. G., Baker, J. R. and Banaszak Holl,
M. M. (2007). The binding avidity of a nanoparticle based multivalent targeted
drug delivery platform. Chemical Biology 14, 107-115.
Hu, Y., Shen, G., Zhu, H. and. Jiang, G. (2010). A class-specifc enzyme-
linked immunosorbent assay based on magnetic particles for multiresidue
organophosphorus pesticides. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 58,
28012806.
Khodakovskaya, M., Dervishi, E., Mahmood, M., Yang Xu, Zhongrui Li, Watanabe,
F. and Biris, A.S. (2009). Carbon nanotubes are able to penetrate plant seed
coat and dramatically affect seed germination and plant growth. ACS Nano 3,
32213227.
Leistritz, F.L., Hodur, N.M., Senechal, D.M., Stowers, M.D., McCalla, D. and Saffron,
C.M. (2007). Biorefneries using Agricultural Residue Feedstock in the Great
19
National Academy of Agricultural Sciences
Plains AAE Report 07001 Working Paper, Agricultural Experiment Station, North
Dakota State University, Fargo North Dakota.
Mathew, A.P., Laborie, M.P. and Oksman, K. (2009). Cross-Linked Chitosan/Chitin
Crystal Nanocomposites with Improved Permeation Selectivity and pH Stability.
Biomacromolecules, 10, 1627.
NRC (National Research Council) (2008). Emerging technologies to beneft farmers in sub-
Saharan Africa and South Asia. Washington, D.C.: National Academies Press.
OECD and Allianz (2008). Sizes that matter: Opportunities and risks of nanotechnologies.
Report in cooperation with the OECD International Futures Programme. http://
www.oecd.org/dataoecd/32/1/44108334.pdf.
Salamanca-Buentello, F., Persad, D. L. , Court, E. B., Martin, D. K., Daar, A. S. and
Singer, P. A. (2005). Nanotechnology and the developing world. PLoS Medicine
2, 383386.
Subramanian, K. S. and Tarafdar, J. C. (2011). Prospects of nanotechnology in Indian
farming. Indian Journal of Agricultural Sciences 81, 887-893.
Tarafdar, J.C. (2012). Perspectives of nanotechnological applications for crop production.
NAAS News 12, 8-11.
Tarafdar, J.C., Raliya, R. and Rathore, I. (2012a). Microbial synthesis of phosphorus
nanoparticles from Tri-calcium phosphate using Aspergillus tubingensis TFR-5.
Journal of Bionanoscience 6, 84-89.
Tarafdar, J.C., Agrawal, A., Raliya, R., Kumar, P., Burman, U. and Kaul, R.K. (2012b).
ZnO nanoparticles induced synthesis of polysaccharides and phosphatases by
Aspergillus fungi. Advanced Science, Engineering and Medicine 4, 1-5.
Tarafdar, J.C., Xiang, Y., Wang, W.N., Dong, Q. and Biswas, P. (2012c). Standardization
of size, shape and concentration of nanoparticle for plant application. Applied
Biological Research 14, 138-144.
Verma, A. K., Singh, V. P., and Vikas, P. (2012). Application of nanotechnology as a
tool in animal products processing and marketing: an overview. American Journal
of Food and Technology DOI : 10.3923/ajft.2012.
20
Policy Paper 63
List of Participants
1. Prof. R.B. Singh, NAAS, New Delhi
2. Prof. Anwar Alam, NAAS, New Delhi
3. Dr. J.C. Tarafdar, CAZRI, Jodhpur
4. Dr. Tapan Adhikari, IISS, Bhopal
5. Dr. (Mrs.) Tinku Basu, AMITY Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
6. Dr. R. Baswaraj, CPRI, Shimla
7. Dr. Deepa Bhagat, NBAII, Bangalore
8. Dr. (Mrs.) Arpita Bhattacharya, AMITY Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
9. Dr. P.S. Brhmanand, DWM, Bhubaneswar
10. Dr. P.K. Chhonkar, IARI Adjunct Faculty, New Delhi
11. Dr. S.C. Datta, IARI, New Delhi
12. Dr. H.S. Gehlot, JNVU, Jodhpur
13. Dr. A. Jeevalatha, CPRI, Shimla
14. Dr. Anu Kalia, PAU, Ludhiana
15. Dr. Gautam Kaul, NDRI, Karnal
16. Prof. A.S. Khanna, IIT, Mumbai
17. Prof. Sunita Kumbhat, JNVU, Jodhpur
18. Dr. Bimlesh Mann, NDRI, Karnal
19. Prof. Siddhartha S. Mukhopadhyay, PAU, Ludhiana
20. Dr. (Mrs.) Ranu Nayak, Amity Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
21. Dr. A.K. Pal, CIFE, Mumbai
22. Dr. A.K. Patra, IARI, New Delhi
23. Dr. Ram Prasad, AIMT, Noida, UP
24. Dr. Ramesh Raliya, CAZRI, Jodhpur
25. Dr. Indira Rathore, CAZRI, Jodhpur
26. Dr. Dipankar Saha, CAZRI, Jodhpur
27. Dr. Vinod Saharan, MPUAT, Udaipur
28. Dr. S.K. Sanyal, Former Vice-Chancellor, BCKV, Mohanpur, WB
29. Dr. R.P. Singh, Amity Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
30. Dr. V.K. Singh, PDFSR, Modipuram, Meerut
31. Dr. O.P. Sinha, Amity Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
32. Dr. K. Sowjanya Sree, AIMT, Noida, UP
33. Prof. K.S. Subramanian, TNAU, Coimbatore
34. Prof. Ajit Varma, Amity University, Noida
35. Dr. N. Vegneswaran, CIRCT, Mumbai
36. Dr. Arunava Goswami, ISI, Kolkata
37. Dr. M.R. Khan, Amity Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
38. Dr. S.S. Simon, Amity Institute of Nanotechnology, Noida, UP
Note: The designations and affliations of the participants are as on the date of BSS.