A5 Dissertation
A5 Dissertation
A5 Dissertation
Jeremiah Cahill
Where it all began....
1.Idea partially adapted from Stadiums; architecture for a new global culture, Rod
Sheard, 2005
2.Written by Baron Pierre De Coubertin, von Gerkan, Marg un Partner, Stadia and
Arenas, 2004
3. Sarfraz Monzoor, The fall of the last good man, The Guardian (UK), 14 April
2004
The stadiums of today, for the most part, fulfil the above aspect
and try to exceed their regular function of staging the sport but this has
not always been the case. The stadiums which have become national
icons and bring local pride are designed and built after learning from the
advances of precedents that have gone in the 150 years before them.
From the humble beginnings of simple fields for pitches to the modern
monumental arenas, stadia have undergone rapid transformation in the
past one and a half centuries. The strong effect of the ancient arenas of
ancient sports on the modern stadiums of modern sports is paramount
as it gives a logical starting point for the creators of the first modern sta-
diums.
The precedents of stadia from the early amphitheatres to the
colossus Coliseum created the basis from which the first stadiums of all
sizes could learn from in the second golden age of sport. The geometry
of all the stadia from the first golden age of sport provided a knowledge-
able founding for early stadia of the 19th century. It is this geometry of
the simple circle to the more flattened elliptical shape which has stood
the test of time as the logical and accepted form for stadia design. The
simple undecorated and functional design of the early amphitheatres co-
incided with the early stadia of the 19th century which were both no more
than craters with the athletic spectacle in the centre. The growth in popu-
larity of stadia in the first and second era of stadia created the need for
larger more complex stadia. In ancient Rome and Greece the amphithe-
atre lost its functional appearance in Augustan times when it began to be
monumentalized in cut stone, with substructures and imposing facades,
decorated with architectural character.
This provided inspiration for the second golden age of stadia as
the architects of modern stadia followed the only built precedents avail-
able such as the Coliseum in Rome. The corporate boxes which are the
choice seats of all stadiums are modern versions of the tribunals upon
which the upper classes of the Roman Empire watched the sport of their
days. The crowd control idea of the Romans ‘ponam et circenses’ or
bread and circuses was one which seemed apt for the industrial revolu-
tion of the 19th century.
3
‘Where crowds gather history is made.’6
4
The sport which thrived most during these primitive days of pro-
fessional sport was undoubtedly soccer which expanded at a phenom-
enal rate becoming a global sport in decades. Notts County first profes-
sional club came a year after the codification of soccer, 1864, and were
one of many early clubs to play in dire conditions at the beginning of the
professional era. Most clubs played in simple pitches with embankments
to all sides being the only luxury at those times or else ground-shared
with cricket clubs which would have been just marginally better. The early
stadiums grew only as spectatorship grew, as was true for all sports, and
the sports were recognised for there monetary value. This brought about
the first improvements to stadiums with covered stands, bars, dressing
rooms and corporate boxes coming as a result of this injection of cash.
The crowded stadium which brought the money for change
5
FA cup final four days after being finished a reported 200,000 people at-
tended. The terraces of ferro-concrete withstood this stern test and the
reinforced concrete structure continued to do so for another 80 years.
The stadium underwent much refurbishment over the years with
floodlights added in 1955 and significant facelifts in 1963, 1973, and the
early 1990’s. The venue of the 1966 World Cup final, 1963,68 and 71
European Cup finals, multiple FA cup finals and numerous England inter-
nationals was a listed building, albeit grade 2, but despite all this historic
backing the twin towers were taken down in 2003 to be replaced by the
colossal arched stadium by HOK and Norman Foster Architects.
5. Johann Wolfgang Van Goethe, Italian Journey, Verona, 16 Sept 1786, pg 7, Von
Gerkan, Marg und Partner, Stadia And Arenas
6. Spiro Kostof, The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings Through History,
second edition,1999
10
Safety last?
16
14. Rod Sheard, The Stadium, Architecture for the New Global Culture, 2005
15. Dr. Brian Edwards, ‘Stadium with a Swagger’, The Architects’ Journal ,
1994
16. Dr. Brian Edwards, ‘Stadium with a Swagger’, The Architects’ Journal ,
1994
Regeneration Generation
The stadium at the end of the 20th century and beginning of the
21st century entered a new generation, with a new direction as a tool for
regeneration. The role of the stadium evolved to be seen as a vital new
component in 21st century public space alongside shopping centres, cin-
emas and airports replacing to some degree the public spaces of old
such as cathedrals, piazzas, and market places. These pieces of archi-
tecture are now a complex planning tool and can be powerful enough to
instigate new developments in run down and forgotten parts of cities and
are the modern regeneration tool. This is where the newest generation
of stadia have come to the fore. State and local government have been
willing lately to offer publicly or privately financial support to clubs to build
iconic stadiums.
17
Their reason to backing these projects that the governments be-
lieve the stadiums can be a catalyst for urban regeneration and are often
designed to be the multi-faceted centre of a new community. This new
generation of stadiums can act as the basis for structured growth in the
rundown rust belts of forgotten 20th century industrial areas in most cit-
ies around the world. They are used as an icon to change the public’s
mindset and accept an area of neglect. The rest of the world’s sport
without the social trouble of hooliganism were the first to move in this
direction of regenerative stadia with the American sports of baseball and
American football best placed to begin the regenerative generation.
18
‘Moving just down the road to a 60,000 capacity stadium
seems the ideal solution to me’19
It did not take as long for the stadiums of soccer to follow the
example of the rest of the world with the precedents of American stadi-
ums in the rust belts of Baltimore, San Francisco etc seen as the obvious
example for the rust belts and rundown areas of cities around Europe.
One of the best examples of this is the Emirates Stadium of Arsenal F.C.
which moved from its hallowed grounds of Highbury due to its growth in
stature and popularity in the footballing world. Where Arsenal had led the
way in safety and facilities with the North Bank of Highbury Stadium, it
has followed on from this in becoming the centre of a regeneration proj-
ect in it’s native Islington area. The local council wanting to keep the club
in the locality gave the club a 27 acre site, only one mile away from High-
bury, to be integrated into one the largest urban regeneration projects in
the UK. The Ashburton Grove redevelopment hopes to regenerate the
19
20
Lower Holloway Road area which at the moment is one of the poorest
areas in London.
‘£390m can buy you 60,000 seats, I used to argue, but not
a home. It’s taken just four visits to change my mind; this
stadium is every bit as imperious as Milan’s San Siro or
Munich’s Allianz Arena, and the sense that the Gunners be-
long here continues to grow.’20
The new 60,000 seater stadium is the centre piece of the new
community with the stadium to be surrounded by over 2,000 new homes
as well as community sports centre, health care facilities and children’s
nurseries. The 60,000 seater stadium is not just a glorified piece of in-
frastructure but a modern stadium designed to the highest standards.
Designed by HOK Lobb Sport also, it follows the same principles of
spectator viewing, providing viewing distances of less than the maxi-
mum of 150 metres throughout the stadium. The acoustics are unrivalled
by most stadia and at the time of goals being generously described with
‘The volume is deafening, on a scale which Highbury’s 38,000 could
never have imagined.’21 As with aforementioned Highbury Stadium, the
amenities are abundant with the club shop being likened to the size of a
supermarket and having many restaurants, bars and concession stands
placed throughout the stadium. These are the shops opened for match-
day but the stadium sits on a 5 metre high podium of shops and com-
munity centres which are available to the community on non matchdays
as well. The most inspiring design aspect is the clean-edged roofline with
the roof suspended by 2 primary trusses on eight structural cores which
allows the roof to hover over the stadium like a halo.
21
22
‘Barcelona hosts the Olympics. But the city has done far
more than simply build new facilities to accommodate
them’ 22
24
The Olympic Stadiums of Barcelona were not the most memo-
rable ever to grace the Olympics but unlike the follys of other Olympic
Stadiums these stadia were to be not unused arenas. Where stadia
such as the much celebrated Beijing Olympics Birds Nest have become
white elephants 22 of structures not finding a place in the city after the
Olympics or other major tournaments have left town. The structures of
the Barcelona ’92 while mostly based in the Olympic Ring area were
also spread out to other areas including the Archery Facilities, in Vall
d’Hebron by Enric Miralles, Olympic Port, on the shore front to the
Mediterranean by MBM Arquitectes, Basketball Arena, in Balladona
by Esteve Bonell and Francesc Ritus and the Hockey stadium in the
nearby town of Terrassa by Bach y Mora. Each stadium had its own
vital merits to the overall Olympic redevelopment with the Olympic ring
being a new multi-use sporting complex and also incorporated the reju-
venation of the Olympic Stadium from a failed attempt in 1929 to attract
the 1936 Olympics. The Archery range designed by Miralles is probably
the most daring and intriguing of the Olympic Stadia. The Basketball
arena is not set as object in its area but plays a pivotal role in its setting.
The Olympic Port at the edge of the Nova Icaria Olympic Village is the
anchor point for the village in its connection with the Mediterranean Sea
allowing the sea to almost become part of the urban fabric.
25
26
27
28
29
17. John King, A Beautiful Diamond Slightly Flawed, San Francisco Chroni-
cle, 11/4/00
22. Peter Buchanan, Architectural Review, Urbane Village, August 1992 Is-
sue
25. Rod Sheard, The Stadium, Architecture for the New Global Culture, 2005
1. Kaka celebrates after scoring in the Champions
League revealing his faith.
• Punch & Partners Ltd., Lecture, Spirit and Substance: The New
Thomond Park Stadium, 2008
• http://www.columbia.edu/cu/gsapp/BT/DOMES/HOUSTON/
houston.html
• John King, Start of something good, Mission Bay: near the ball-
park, a promising new neighbourhood, San Francisco Chronicle,
• www.thestadium-highbury.com