A5 Dissertation

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 46
At a glance
Powered by AI
The passage discusses the evolution of sport from ancient times to the modern era and how it has become a central part of modern culture and society.

Sport has evolved from local games and competitions to becoming highly organized and professionalized globally popular activities. With advances like television, sport has grown into a major entertainment industry and cultural phenomenon.

Stadiums have transformed significantly from simple fields to large modern arenas. Early stadiums were basic but new technologies and the rise of professional sports have led to huge iconic structures that enhance sporting events.

Evolution of the Structure in Sport 1

Jeremiah Cahill
Where it all began....

‘The first thing to be taken into consideration when staging


a sports festival is the scenery. Before actors appear, the
scenery strikes the eyes of the spectator . . . . . . . ‘2

THIS WAS WRITTEN by the founder of the modern Olympics,


Baron Pierre De Coubertin, in the late nineteenth/early twentieth century
after the modernisation and structuring of many ancient games and lo-
cal sports. The relevance and implications of these words has grown
exponentially since they left the pen of Baron Pierre De Coubertin. With
the coming of the Enlightenment and birth of modern science came the
realization that the body, once again, is a machine to be maintained. Not
since the height of the Greek Olympians from the seventh century B.C.
to third century A.D. has sport had such a central role in our lives as in
the last century. Sport to many the common man has become a modern
1
day religion with its own prophets, messiahs and disciples(1). The stadia
of today have become churches and cathedrals of the modern era bring-
ing whole towns, cities and regions together as a modern community.
‘Sport is not an intellectual pursuit, it demands the en-
gagement of the heart not the brain……it is not so much
a pastime as a religion complete with its cathedrals and
rituals’3

Sports worldwide have taken up the mantel of bringing people


together and giving the feeling of belonging to something bigger than
themselves. This fanatic following has inspired the buildings of sport
to become places of homage and reverence. The stadiums and sport
centres which are part of the everyman’s idea of architecture and have
become iconic yet natural for him to go to and enjoy are some of the
best examples of architecture and people integrating successfully. It is
this characteristic of the stadiums that the strength of the building type is
derived from. This has motivated designers of stadia to push the bound-
aries in technology and design to create buildings equal to the sport.
Would you paint a pretty picture only to put it in an ugly frame? Probably
not and the stadium acts as the frame in which the picture of athletic tal-
ent can blossom in the best possible surroundings to the adoration of the
onlookers.
In much the same as a theatre set for a play or a musical the
stadium if designed correctly can enhance and increase the occasion of
the match, game or event. It is not a passive backdrop for the event but
an active piece in the creation of the atmosphere in the overall puzzle of
the event. The stadiums of today, for the most part, fulfil this aspect and
try to exceed their regular function of staging of the sport but this has
not always been the case. The stadiums which have become national
icons and bring local pride are designed and built after learning from the
advances of precedents that have gone in the hundred and fifty years
before them.
From the humble beginnings of simple pitches to the modern
monumental arenas, stadia have undergone rapid transformation in the
past one and a half centuries. In my opinion, this evolution has been in
reaction to four major stages.
•The codification and professionalisation of modern
sports.
•The impacts of TV nationally and globally.
•Becoming safer and more family friendly.
•Regeneration of dilapidated areas.
It is these factors that have driven stadiums forward from craters
in the ground. The four factors do not follow a strict chronological order
although they do seem to follow on from each other loosely.

‘To stage an event in a nondescript setting is to dull its aura.


As for the spectator, for much of their lives most people
live and work in unremarkable surroundings. All the more
reason therefore that the stadium should be their Xanadu,
their Hollywood, their Never-Neverland and dream factory
all rolled into one’4

1.Idea partially adapted from Stadiums; architecture for a new global culture, Rod
Sheard, 2005

2.Written by Baron Pierre De Coubertin, von Gerkan, Marg un Partner, Stadia and
Arenas, 2004

3. Sarfraz Monzoor, The fall of the last good man, The Guardian (UK), 14 April
2004

4.Simon Inglis,Foreword pg IX, Sports Architecture, Rod Sheard, 2001


‘Ponem et Circenses’
‘The general need to satisfy; that is the architects ba-
sic task here.He prepares such a crater with art, as sim-
ple as possible,so that’s its jewel becomes the people
themselves.’5

The stadiums of today, for the most part, fulfil the above aspect
and try to exceed their regular function of staging the sport but this has
not always been the case. The stadiums which have become national
icons and bring local pride are designed and built after learning from the
advances of precedents that have gone in the 150 years before them.
From the humble beginnings of simple fields for pitches to the modern
monumental arenas, stadia have undergone rapid transformation in the
past one and a half centuries. The strong effect of the ancient arenas of
ancient sports on the modern stadiums of modern sports is paramount
as it gives a logical starting point for the creators of the first modern sta-
diums.
The precedents of stadia from the early amphitheatres to the
colossus Coliseum created the basis from which the first stadiums of all
sizes could learn from in the second golden age of sport. The geometry
of all the stadia from the first golden age of sport provided a knowledge-
able founding for early stadia of the 19th century. It is this geometry of
the simple circle to the more flattened elliptical shape which has stood
the test of time as the logical and accepted form for stadia design. The
simple undecorated and functional design of the early amphitheatres co-
incided with the early stadia of the 19th century which were both no more
than craters with the athletic spectacle in the centre. The growth in popu-
larity of stadia in the first and second era of stadia created the need for
larger more complex stadia. In ancient Rome and Greece the amphithe-
atre lost its functional appearance in Augustan times when it began to be
monumentalized in cut stone, with substructures and imposing facades,
decorated with architectural character.
This provided inspiration for the second golden age of stadia as
the architects of modern stadia followed the only built precedents avail-
able such as the Coliseum in Rome. The corporate boxes which are the
choice seats of all stadiums are modern versions of the tribunals upon
which the upper classes of the Roman Empire watched the sport of their
days. The crowd control idea of the Romans ‘ponam et circenses’ or
bread and circuses was one which seemed apt for the industrial revolu-
tion of the 19th century.

3
‘Where crowds gather history is made.’6

The mass exodus of the countryside to the industrial cities


brought populations to highs not seen since the times of the Roman
Empire and with it the need for sport. The killing fields of roman amphi-
theatres were replaced with the symbolic killings fields of football, rugby
or baseball pitches. In the period of 1850 to 1900 almost all major world-
wide sports of today were created and made professional. The codifica-
tion of sport occurred during these years for with the major rules and
regulations being drawn up for soccer(1863), rugby(1871), Aussie rules
football(1859), American football(1869), and baseball(1845).

4
The sport which thrived most during these primitive days of pro-
fessional sport was undoubtedly soccer which expanded at a phenom-
enal rate becoming a global sport in decades. Notts County first profes-
sional club came a year after the codification of soccer, 1864, and were
one of many early clubs to play in dire conditions at the beginning of the
professional era. Most clubs played in simple pitches with embankments
to all sides being the only luxury at those times or else ground-shared
with cricket clubs which would have been just marginally better. The early
stadiums grew only as spectatorship grew, as was true for all sports, and
the sports were recognised for there monetary value. This brought about
the first improvements to stadiums with covered stands, bars, dressing
rooms and corporate boxes coming as a result of this injection of cash.
The crowded stadium which brought the money for change

‘To most players in the world, Wembley is the Mecca


of stadiums. To win a World Cup there would be the
highlight of anyone’s career.’7

As popularity grew so did the architectural merit in the stadiums


grow as the stadiums became symbols of grandeur and outward expres-
sions of power and success. The growth in popularity of soccer led to this
becoming not just a local phenomenon but grew to national importance
when in 1924 with the British Empire Exhibition.
The centrepiece of the 1924 exhibition was the Wembley Sta-
dium which ignited much interest in the exhibition as a whole. The site
chosen is of some architectural interest also as it was the infamous site
of ‘Watkins Folly’. This was the site of Sir Edward Watkins failed attempt
at a British version of the Eiffel Tower. In 1901 he attempted to build an
1150 ft tower but only reached 200 ft after the foundations were found to
be unstable.
The decision to build a national stadium and FA cup final venue
was made in 1914 after using the grounds of Crystal Palace football club,
aptly named after Paxton’s glass and steel masterpiece, for twenty years.
This decision proved to be justified as Wembley became an English insti-
tution and the envy of the world. Architects John Simpson and Maxwell
Ayrton designed a stadium with a variety of styles such as Romanesque
arches and colonnades, faux monumental masonry and the art deco of
the central hall all synonymous with Empirical grandeur architecture of
the world exhibition.
Built with a design loved by millions, and was fronted by the most
world renowned showpieces, the twin towers. The brilliant white twin
towers, 126 ft high, gave a dramatic effect felt by all who approached
them. The twin tower motif was a symbol of power and grandeur was an
expression of British confidence for the entire world to see in a decade
of turmoil. The initial capacity of Wembley was 126,500 yet in the 1924

5
FA cup final four days after being finished a reported 200,000 people at-
tended. The terraces of ferro-concrete withstood this stern test and the
reinforced concrete structure continued to do so for another 80 years.
The stadium underwent much refurbishment over the years with
floodlights added in 1955 and significant facelifts in 1963, 1973, and the
early 1990’s. The venue of the 1966 World Cup final, 1963,68 and 71
European Cup finals, multiple FA cup finals and numerous England inter-
nationals was a listed building, albeit grade 2, but despite all this historic
backing the twin towers were taken down in 2003 to be replaced by the
colossal arched stadium by HOK and Norman Foster Architects.

5. Johann Wolfgang Van Goethe, Italian Journey, Verona, 16 Sept 1786, pg 7, Von
Gerkan, Marg und Partner, Stadia And Arenas

6. Spiro Kostof, The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings Through History,
second edition,1999

7. Sir Bobby Moore, www.wembleystadium.com


‘Lights, Camera, Action . . . .’

‘If ever there was a marriage made in heaven it was


between television and sports’8

Wembley stadium was one of many stadia to be refurbished


around the 1950’s and 60’s with many more being newly built in this era.
The factor for this explosion in change, necessary change, was TV. Tele-
vision and sport are an inseparable couple and since the 1940’s have
grown in proportion to each other, helping each other out along the way.
In 1937, a few hundred Londoners were the first to enjoy watching sport
on TV with the very first outside broadcast coverage of British sport with
a 25 minute viewing of a men’s tennis match in Wimbledon. This is seen
by many as the first date in the run up to the now long lasting marriage
between the two. Televisions growth from a measly 5,000 sets sold in
1946 to 75% of households having one 10 years later, show its meteoric
rise with sport holding its hand along the way.
Like all relationships it has had its low moments too with the
majority having been in the tentative first few years. These low moments
came from an initial drop in attendances at stadiums where television
got an early foothold. The Boston Braves Baseball team felt this negative
impact, even after winning the National League in 1948, when in 1949
crowds fell by 81% due to signing a TV deal for the next three years. It
wasn’t just single teams that were hit by an early introduction of TV, as
the sport of College American Football was hit severely. Between 1949
and 1953 attendance declined by almost 3 million. The National Colle-
giate Athletic Association formed a television committee and introduced
strict rules for limiting broadcasts. Even then it was not until 1963 that
attendances rose back to the levels of 1949.

‘You didn’t have have to be an expert to acknowl-


edge that the Astrodome was far ahead of its time’9
6 ‘WELCOME TO THE ASTRODOME EIGHTH WONDER OF
THE WORLD’10 emphatically said the brainchild of Judge Roy Hofheinz
and his 2 architecture firms would become one of the most advanced and
famous stadiums of its era. The Houston Astrodome, opened in 1965,
was one of the first to recognise the need for stadia to match the com-
forts of home. Judge Hofheinz suggested the only way baseball would
succeed in the hot, humid, wet summers, infected with mosquitoes, of
Houston was roof the stadium leading to the extravagant solution of the
645ft span dome of the Astrodome. Judge Hofheinz was proven correct
in 1962 when the temporary Colts Stadium was used while construction
was underway with the Astrodome. The players complained of the condi-
tions and the fans just stayed in their comfortable homes.
The roofing of the Astrodome was to be the solution to this di-
lemma. The dome was capped by a 300 ton tension ring which sat on
lamella trusses that span the domes huge circumference. To allow the
grass to grow the roof was made transparent with the use of Lucite sky-
lights throughout the dome. This meant it was the first stadium
with adequate lighting for colour TV at a luminance of 300 lux. This idea
had a problem unforeseen in the drawing up of the plans and was only
found out in the first season of play. The transparent skylights gave a lot
of glare when players looked up to try catch high balls and were blinded.
The solution to this problem was to white-
wash 30% of the dome but unfortunately
this led to an even greater problem as
the grass was unable to grow minus the
light. Unfortunately what the photo to the
right doesn’t show being black and white
is how the dead grass was spray-paint-
ed green in an attempt to cover-up the
problem. This led to one of the biggest
developments in sports arena with re-
sulting answer to place synthetic grass
in the stadium, later to become known
as Astroturf in honour of its birthplace.

‘I believe before it is all over, everybody in the United States


will be visiting this stadium.’11

This problem was to be alone in the building of the Astrodome


as there are many successes in its design. Its true strength is in how it
tackled the aforementioned problem of removing fans from there comfy
homes and attract them to the stadium. The piece de résistance of the
stadium was its $2 million dollar, 4 storeys high and 474ft long scoreboard
that had over 50,000 lights that created black and white animations,seen
to the right, to excite the crowd.
The industrial steel structural design mirroring its surroundings betrayed
the luxury of the interior with its padded and upholstered theatre-esque
seats, luxury sky boxes, first to introduce them in the world, 49 conces-
sion stands and 4 restaurants, it was the envy of the nation.
It had an air conditioning unit so powerful, that coupled with high
8
humidity, it caused it to rain indoors! To create a comfortable acoustic
level in the stadium and to avoid echoing in the large dome the design
called for half the roof to be covered with acoustical coating, the lower
third of the domes walls to have sound proofing wooden panels and
each seat to contain shock absorbers. With the bountiful comforts and
the scoreboard, the fans came out in there millions with over 12 million
visiting in the first 3 years of its life and 1 and a half million of those paid
to tour the building with no game taking place.12
The success of the Astrodome is its ability to live even beyond its
use as a baseball stadium to the versatile centre it is today with rodeos,
concerts and presidential conventions. The greatest accomplishment of
the Astrodome as a stadium is in its design to be built for the spectator in
the stadium or in front of the TV. Since the existence of modern stadiums
they have been one of only a handful of buildings that can accommodate
the population of a town or city and certainly the only type that can cap-
tivate the entire gathering. The advent of TV has increased this captiva-
tion to a national and global stage.

8. Ellis Cashmore, Making Sense of Sport, pg276, 2005

9. Simon Inglis, Sightlines: Astadium Odyssey, p266, 2000

10. Scoreboard message at the Astrodome Stadium

11. President Lyndon B. Johnson, Opening game, Houston Chronicle, THE


TOP 25/From no-hitters to bullfights, Dome has been home to it all, Harry
Shattuck, 04/08/1990
12. Figures and statistics obtained from The Houston Astrodome, Craig And
Katherine Doherty,1996
9

10
Safety last?

Football is a gentleman’s game played by hooligans, and


rugby is a hooligans’ game played by gentlemen!

Where these developments in creating a comfortable family ori-


entated stadium were taking place around the world and in most sport,
there was an unusual slowness in development of this kind in soccer/foot-
ball. The reason for this inept and plain lack of change has been attribut-
ed to many reasons such as a lack of institutional governing of the Foot-
ball Associations, hooliganism and ageing stadiums. Football matches
were seen to be quite unsafe, due to the violent actions of football hooli-
gans. Football hooliganism had
spoilt the family atmosphere of
football games for many with
people fearing bringing their
11 family to a football game due to
the violent reputation that foot-
ball hooligans had given the
sport. Football stadia around
the world were also old, decay-
ing dinosaurs that were con-
sidered dangerous for families.
The changes that swept through most other major sports and stadiums
only gradually penetrated the sport of football even despite the windfall
of money and popularity. The few developments that came in the 60’s
and 70’s were poorly planned and designed due to weak regulations that
allowed for substandard and unsafe new stands and terraces.
The dilapidated stadiums of Britain got the most coverage round
the world due to the multiple disasters over the years with tragedies such
as the 66 people who died at stairway 13 in Ibrox Stadium in 1971, the 56
who died in a fire in Bradford City’s Grounds may 11th 85 or two weeks
later when in Heysel Stadium in Brussels 39 died when fighting broke out
between the 2 sets of fans and an old wall collapsed. These tragedies
were not without warning as they had been preceded by 4 reports:
• 1924 Report by The Departmental Committee on Crowds
• 1948 Enquiry by Home Secretary Hughes
• 1969 Report by Sir John Lany
• 1975 Wheatley Report
Despite this series of disasters the reports were rarely adhered
to and if so were only loosely so. It was not till 20 years ago almost to
the day on the 15th of April 1989 (12) at Hillsborough Stadium in Shef-
field that the authorities brought about change in the design of stadiums
and the control of stadiums. Hillsborough Stadium had once been re-
garded as one of the country’s leading stadiums having been chosen as
a venue for the 1966 World Cup and many FA Cup finals and semi-finals.
This was mainly due to the improvements the stadium had undergone to
attract back television audiences to the stadium with improved comfort
including a new 10,000 all-seated cantilevered stand in 1960. It was con-
sidered so modern that it was mentioned in Nicholas Pevsner’s guide to
Building of England, the only football ground to be so honoured. Despite
all these improvements over time this and other stadiums became run
down and dilapidated. It was in the respected Hillsborough stadium that
the final straw in a long line of tragic events that changed the nature of
stadiums throughout Britain. Police made the fatal error of allowing 4,000
latecomers into the ground for the FA Cup semi-final resulting in over-
crowding and the deaths of 96 fans as crushing occurred in the west ter-
race. Bill Shankly’s famous quote “Football isn’t a matter of life or death.
It’s far more important than that.”13 never rang as hollow as in 1989.
12
Lord Justice Taylor’s report into the deaths at Hillsborough and
the disasters before it brought about change to the sport as a whole
as new stringent safety rules recommended by the report finally rang
through the leagues dilapidated stadia. One of the major changes was to
have it mandatory for all stadiums to be all-seater stadia and this greatly
curbed the hooligan element at matches creating a more family orientated
arena. The first club to take the initiative with its 12,500 all seater Stand
at the North Bank end of Highbury. Not only was it an all-seater stadium,
it set a new standard in spectator facilities with supporters’ stores, res-
taurants, concession stands and multiple bars. Where Highbury’s new
North Bank led the way in facilities the Alfred McAlpine Stadium led the
way in a new standard for form.14

‘The Lobb design fulfils these wider ambitions admirably.


What this West Yorkshire town has acquired is a spectacu-
lar new landmark built alongside the River Come’15

The design by HOK Lobb Sports beat 5 conventional box de-


13
signs in the competition for the new stadium of Huddersfield Football
and Rugby with its exciting ‘banana truss’ led design(13 & 14). The dra-
matic curved form of the design opened up endless possibilities for future
stadiums but it was not just purely a building of form. The form of the
building was designed on the knowledgeable understanding of favour-
able sightlines for the fans. The curved form allowed for fans at all times
14
15
to be no more than the recommended maximum viewing of no more than
150 metres from the centre of the pitch.
McAlpine Stadium also has facilities paralleling those anywhere
else in the world including 26 private suites overlooking the pitch, five
guest lounges and a 500-person conference and banqueting suite 16
with the architects understanding the power of designing for TV and mer-
chandising revenue in mind. The bold design of the Alfred McAlpine Sta-
dium met all the new rules of the Taylor report and provided impetus for
future developments of new British stadia and despite the strictness of
the Taylor report the stadium still managed to create a design combining
intimacy with safety.

16

13. Liverpool legend Bill Shankly

14. Rod Sheard, The Stadium, Architecture for the New Global Culture, 2005

15. Dr. Brian Edwards, ‘Stadium with a Swagger’, The Architects’ Journal ,
1994

16. Dr. Brian Edwards, ‘Stadium with a Swagger’, The Architects’ Journal ,
1994
Regeneration Generation

The ascendancy of sport as the new global culture means


that’s a stadium has a central role in the city – financially,
political, geographical and spiritual’17

The stadium at the end of the 20th century and beginning of the
21st century entered a new generation, with a new direction as a tool for
regeneration. The role of the stadium evolved to be seen as a vital new
component in 21st century public space alongside shopping centres, cin-
emas and airports replacing to some degree the public spaces of old
such as cathedrals, piazzas, and market places. These pieces of archi-
tecture are now a complex planning tool and can be powerful enough to
instigate new developments in run down and forgotten parts of cities and
are the modern regeneration tool. This is where the newest generation
of stadia have come to the fore. State and local government have been
willing lately to offer publicly or privately financial support to clubs to build
iconic stadiums.

17
Their reason to backing these projects that the governments be-
lieve the stadiums can be a catalyst for urban regeneration and are often
designed to be the multi-faceted centre of a new community. This new
generation of stadiums can act as the basis for structured growth in the
rundown rust belts of forgotten 20th century industrial areas in most cit-
ies around the world. They are used as an icon to change the public’s
mindset and accept an area of neglect. The rest of the world’s sport
without the social trouble of hooliganism were the first to move in this
direction of regenerative stadia with the American sports of baseball and
American football best placed to begin the regenerative generation.

‘Although the location is stunning, it’s the architecture that


brings out the potential of the site.’18

The wealth of the sports industry in America at the turn of the


century placed its respective professional sports in the opportune po-
sition to be the leaders in the new design of stadia. The first stadia in
America to appear as a regenerative tool in larger developments in the
rust belts of industrial America were Oriole Park, Baltimore in 1992 and
Coors Field, Denver in 1996. The latest stadium to be used in this man-
ner is the AT&T Park in 2000. This stadium is situated in the Mission Bay
area of San Francisco harbour which until recently was a run down area
of the city. AT & T Park is the linchpin in the revitalization of the old 20th
century warehouse district area which is to be transformed from the 300
acres of abandoned railway tracks to a vibrant area with housing, shops,
offices and parks. The new stadium designed by HOK Lobb Sport is
the impetus in a much awaited $4 billion redevelopment of the Mission
Bay area with the AT & T Park the first building to have been put into the
area.
The stadium despite being an object of regeneration relates to
its surroundings and the history of the area with the two street facing fa-
cades consisting of brick recounting the brick warehouses of days gone
by. The internal structure is a large steel structure which compliments
the Steel Lefty O’Doul Bridge adjacent to the arena. The stadium also
has an interesting orientation faces out onto San Francisco Bay and the
Oakland Hills instead of the city having been changed due to wind condi-
tions. This gives the stadium an unmistakable character as it reactivates
the bay side and draws many boats in search of game balls on match
days. The energy brought by the stadium to the area has converted the
dingy slum into the hottest property in town.

18
‘Moving just down the road to a 60,000 capacity stadium
seems the ideal solution to me’19

It did not take as long for the stadiums of soccer to follow the
example of the rest of the world with the precedents of American stadi-
ums in the rust belts of Baltimore, San Francisco etc seen as the obvious
example for the rust belts and rundown areas of cities around Europe.
One of the best examples of this is the Emirates Stadium of Arsenal F.C.
which moved from its hallowed grounds of Highbury due to its growth in
stature and popularity in the footballing world. Where Arsenal had led the
way in safety and facilities with the North Bank of Highbury Stadium, it
has followed on from this in becoming the centre of a regeneration proj-
ect in it’s native Islington area. The local council wanting to keep the club
in the locality gave the club a 27 acre site, only one mile away from High-
bury, to be integrated into one the largest urban regeneration projects in
the UK. The Ashburton Grove redevelopment hopes to regenerate the

19
20

Lower Holloway Road area which at the moment is one of the poorest
areas in London.

‘£390m can buy you 60,000 seats, I used to argue, but not
a home. It’s taken just four visits to change my mind; this
stadium is every bit as imperious as Milan’s San Siro or
Munich’s Allianz Arena, and the sense that the Gunners be-
long here continues to grow.’20
The new 60,000 seater stadium is the centre piece of the new
community with the stadium to be surrounded by over 2,000 new homes
as well as community sports centre, health care facilities and children’s
nurseries. The 60,000 seater stadium is not just a glorified piece of in-
frastructure but a modern stadium designed to the highest standards.
Designed by HOK Lobb Sport also, it follows the same principles of
spectator viewing, providing viewing distances of less than the maxi-
mum of 150 metres throughout the stadium. The acoustics are unrivalled
by most stadia and at the time of goals being generously described with
‘The volume is deafening, on a scale which Highbury’s 38,000 could
never have imagined.’21 As with aforementioned Highbury Stadium, the
amenities are abundant with the club shop being likened to the size of a
supermarket and having many restaurants, bars and concession stands
placed throughout the stadium. These are the shops opened for match-
day but the stadium sits on a 5 metre high podium of shops and com-
munity centres which are available to the community on non matchdays
as well. The most inspiring design aspect is the clean-edged roofline with
the roof suspended by 2 primary trusses on eight structural cores which
allows the roof to hover over the stadium like a halo.

21
22
‘Barcelona hosts the Olympics. But the city has done far
more than simply build new facilities to accommodate
them’ 22

The practice of using the stadium as a tool for redevelop-


ment of an area is one which has long been used in the history of the
Olympics as its travels from one city to another every four years. The
Olympics has always been an excuse and a reason to clean up and re-
develop the city as a whole with the greatest example of this being the
Barcelona Olympics of 1992. The city of Barcelona was a city in major
need of renewal after the neglect of the Franco era over, the Olympics
being the impetus for an overhaul of the rundown and overcrowded city.
The difference between the aforementioned regeneration projects is
that they are unique and new being private projects while the Olympics
have always been about showing off the city as a whole. The Olympics
have also to build a residency complex as well as the main stadia. This
is where the strongest parts of the Barcelona ’92 Olympics regeneration
are found as to put forward the city in the best light there were many
new parks and plazas created around the city, opening up the city from
its tight and shabby beautiful streetscape but still shabby and crowded.
The residency for the athletes, Nova Icaria, created an Olympic Village
that integrated with the rest of the city allowing it to merge seamlessly
with the city after the games becoming a new community to the city.

‘Barcelona has seized the possibilities offered by making


an Olympic Village to redevelop a derelict industrial area
and to forge links between the city and the sea.’ 23
23

24
The Olympic Stadiums of Barcelona were not the most memo-
rable ever to grace the Olympics but unlike the follys of other Olympic
Stadiums these stadia were to be not unused arenas. Where stadia
such as the much celebrated Beijing Olympics Birds Nest have become
white elephants 22 of structures not finding a place in the city after the
Olympics or other major tournaments have left town. The structures of
the Barcelona ’92 while mostly based in the Olympic Ring area were
also spread out to other areas including the Archery Facilities, in Vall
d’Hebron by Enric Miralles, Olympic Port, on the shore front to the
Mediterranean by MBM Arquitectes, Basketball Arena, in Balladona
by Esteve Bonell and Francesc Ritus and the Hockey stadium in the
nearby town of Terrassa by Bach y Mora. Each stadium had its own
vital merits to the overall Olympic redevelopment with the Olympic ring
being a new multi-use sporting complex and also incorporated the reju-
venation of the Olympic Stadium from a failed attempt in 1929 to attract
the 1936 Olympics. The Archery range designed by Miralles is probably
the most daring and intriguing of the Olympic Stadia. The Basketball
arena is not set as object in its area but plays a pivotal role in its setting.
The Olympic Port at the edge of the Nova Icaria Olympic Village is the
anchor point for the village in its connection with the Mediterranean Sea
allowing the sea to almost become part of the urban fabric.
25
26
27
28
29

17. John King, A Beautiful Diamond Slightly Flawed, San Francisco Chroni-
cle, 11/4/00

18. Dennis Bergkamp, Former player, Arsenal website

19. Paolo Bandini, Arsenal’s Emirates Stadium, The Guardian(UK), Tuesday


26 September 2006

20. Paolo Bandini, Arsenal’s Emirates Stadium, The Guardian(UK), Tuesday


26 September 2006

21. Peter Buchanan, Architectural Review, Barcelona, a city regenerated,


August 1992 Issue

22. Peter Buchanan, Architectural Review, Urbane Village, August 1992 Is-
sue

23. A white elephant is a valuable possession of which its owner cannot


dispose and whose cost (particularly cost of upkeep) is out of proportion to its
usefulness.
Conclusion

Stadiums are the new modern icon for modern


cities.

The stadium has entered a new importance in the world today


as it has become one of the most iconic and powerful types of public
buildings of our time. As civilisation has become more civilised the
need for an outlet of our basic nature has taken hold in the domain
of sport. The combative nature of ourselves is appeased by the com-
petitive nature of sport while the need to feel part of something bigger
is sports latest calling as western culture is beginning to reject reli-
gion more often. As the ascendency of sport has continued unabated
throughout the 20th century and into the 21st the has inavertingly be-
come more important as a result. While they were not regarded in the
same league as the architectural stalwarts through the ages such as
churches, housing etc. The stadium with its connection with TV since
the 50’s has broadcast some the most memorable moments in 20th
and 21st century history to many people . The association of TV and
sport has created a connection across borders, religions and races as
sport has realised its power to unify the world even for the shortest of
times such as the Olympics or World Cups.

‘Sports Buildings were not simply regarded as serious


architecture in Britain, perhaps in the way that indus-
trial buildings had been treated before Norman Foster
changed that perception’25
The stadium has become the 21st centuries replacement for the
public areas such as markets, churches and piazzas. It has become one
of the most powerful regerative tools in modern planning today. The evo-
lution of stadia has allowed the stadia of today to become the landmarks
of our cities and nations with the growth in ‘monumentality’ since the
sixties moving the design of stadia to the forefront of modern architec-
ture. The mindset of stadia as serious pieces of architecture has finally
changed with the transformation from simple fields to the 21st monu-
ments they are today.

25. Rod Sheard, The Stadium, Architecture for the New Global Culture, 2005
1. Kaka celebrates after scoring in the Champions
League revealing his faith.

2. Seating Plan for the L.A. Coliseum

3. Arial View of the Coliseum in Rome

4. 1945 Match at Stamford Bridge, home of Chelsea F.C.

5. The well reknowned twin towers of Wembley Stadium

6. Astrodome Stadium at night

7. A groundsman painting the grass green at the Astro-


dome Stadium before the advent of astroturf
8. 4 different views of the astroturf scoreboard selected
scenes

9. A poster advertising the Astrodome the year of its open-


ing

10. Interior view of the Astrodome

11. An example of hooligans

12. The crowds reaction at the 20th anniversary of the


Hillsborough Disaster at Anfield Stadium on the 12th of
April this year

13. Elevation drawing of


Galpharm Stadium

14. View of the Concrete bases at the corners joining the


banana trusses
15. View from the west stand of Galpharm Stadium

16. Section drawing through the Galpharm Stadium

17. Nighttime view of AT & T Park

18. Arial View of AT & T Park with the bay

19. Plan of the proposed development of Ashburton Area


including the Emirates Stadium

20. Nighttime view of the Emirates Stadium

21. Section drawing through the Emirates


Stadium

22. Proposed view of the Emirates Stadium in 2006


23. MBM master plan for the Olympic Village of the Bar-
celona Olympics 1992, Nova Icaria

24. Olympic port Barcelona Olympics 1992

25. Olympic Ring Barcelona Olympics 1992

26. Indoor Sports Arena Barcelona Olympics 1992

27. Basketball Arena Barcelona Olympics 1992

28. Archery Range Barcelona


Olympics 1992

29. Hockey Stadium Barcelona Olympics 1992


Bibliography

• Peter Sturzebecher, Architecture for Sport, 2002

• Robert Powell, Stadium: Architecture for the New Global Culture,


2005

• Craig A. Doherty, The Houston Astrodome (Building


America),1996

• Simon Inglis, The Football Grounds of Britain,1996

• Punch & Partners Ltd., Lecture, Spirit and Substance: The New
Thomond Park Stadium, 2008

• Dr Brian Edwards, Architects’ Journal, Stadium with swagger.


The Alfred McAlpine Stadium, Huddersfield, 1994

• Winfried Nerdinger, Frei Otto Complete Works,2005

• Daniel L. Wann, Sport fans : the psychology and social impact of


spectators, 2001

• Dejan Sudjic, Building an Olympic vision, The Guardian(UK), 10


July 2005

• Dave Hill, How I learned to love the London Olympics, The


Guardian(UK), 6 August 08

• David Conn, No gold in these games, The Guardian(UK), 14


November 2008

• Robert Booth, For Sale; Flatpack stadium suitable for Olympic


Games, One careful owner…., The Guardian(UK), 27 May 2008

• Janie Hampton, London 2012: Bring your own towels, The


Guardian(UK), 3 December 2008

• Johnathen Glancey, Secrets of the Birds Nest, The


Guardian(UK), 11 February 2008
• Kriston Capps,, Architecture after the flame goes out, The
Guardian(UK), 24 August 2008

• Héléne Mulholland, London faces ‘toughest circumstances apart


from war’ to host Olympics, The Guardian(UK), 25 November 2008

• Minna Ninova,The Olympics and urban planning, The


Guardian(UK), 25 August 2008

• Colin Horgan, Olympic winners and losers, The Guardian(UK),


23 January 2009

• Sarfraz Monzoor, The fall of the last good man, The


Guardian(UK), 14 April 2004

• Richard Williams, From listless grey to silvery gleam, the birds


nests a perfect symbol, The Guardian(UK), 7 August 2008

• Tom Lutz, London 2012 stadium revealed, The Guardian(UK), 7


November 2007

• John Horne and Wolfram Manzenreiter, Sports Mega-Events,


Social scientific analyses of a global phenomenon,2006

• Ellis Cashmore, Making sense of sports(third edition), 2000

• Rod Sheard, Sports Architecture, 2001

• Von Gerkan, Marg und Partner, Stadien und Arenen(Stadia and


Arenas),2004

• Katherine E. Welch, The Roman Amphitheatre, From its Origins


to the Colosseum, 2009

• http://www.columbia.edu/cu/gsapp/BT/DOMES/HOUSTON/
houston.html

• Harry Shattuck, THE TOP 25/From no-hitters to bullfights,


Dome has been home to it all, Houston Chronicle, 04/08/1990
• Allan Turner ,TEXANS Inaugural season / FADING GLORY
/ `8th Wonder of World’ faces downsized future, Houston Chronicle,
08/04/2002

• Harry Shattuck, 20 years of games under glass, Houston Chroni-


cle, 03/31/1985

• Geraint John & Rod Sheard¬¬, Stadia, A Design and Develop-


ment Guide, 1994, (Third edition) 2000

• Stephen Morley, Stadia: Structural Giants, Ingenia Online, Article


- Issue 22, Mar 2005

• Tracey Taylor, San Francisco’s Mission Bay Renewed, Financial


Times, January 13 2007

• John King, A Beautiful Diamond Slightly Flawed, San Francisco


Chronicle, 11/4/00

• John King, Start of something good, Mission Bay: near the ball-
park, a promising new neighbourhood, San Francisco Chronicle,

• The Architectural Review, Barcelona Transformed, August 1992

• Paolo Bandini, Arsenal’s Emirates Stadium, The Gaurdian(UK),


Tuesday 26 September 2006

• www.thestadium-highbury.com

You might also like