PCB Power Decoupling Myths

Debunked
Bruce Archambeault, PhD
Jay Diepenbrock
IBM, RTP, NC
[email protected]
[email protected]

Conventional Wisdom
Need a variety of capacitance values to
maintain low impedance over frequency
range
Many capacitors of one value is better
than many values
Place capacitors close to ICs as possible
Location does not matter
Spread capacitors over entire board
2

Power Plane Noise Control

Ground
Bounce
3

What is Capacitance?
Q
C=
V
Capacitance is the
ability of a structure to
hold charge
(electrons) for a given
voltage

Q = CV
Amount of charge
stored is dependant
on the size of the
capacitance (and
voltage)

Note: Capacitance has no frequency dependence!

4

High Frequency Capacitors

Myth or Fact?

Its really the inductance that matters!

5

Capacitance and Inductance

Capacitance
amount of charge stored
Inductance
speed that the charge can
be delivered from capacitor

Decoupling Capacitor Mounting

Keep planes as close to capacitor pads as
possible
Via Separation

Inductance Depends
on Loop AREA
Height above Planes

0603 Size Cap Typical Mounting

9 mils

9 mils

10 mils*

20 mils

10 mils*

Via Barrel 10 mils

60 mils

108 mils minimum

128 mils typical

*Note: Minimum
distance is 10 mils but
more typical distance is
20 mils

0402 Size Cap Typical Mounting

8 mils

8 mils

10 mils*

20 mils

10 mils*

Via Barrel 10 mils

40 mils

86 mils minimum
106 mils typical

*Note: Minimum
distance is 10 mils but
more typical distance is
20 mils

Connection Inductance for Typical Capacitor Configurations

with 10 mils from Capacitor Pad to Via Pad
Distance into
board
to planes (mils)

0805 typical
(148 mils
between via
barrels)

0603 typical
(128 mils
between via
barrels)

0402 typical
(106 mils
between via
barrels)

10

1.2 nH

1.1 nH

0.9 nH

20

1.8 nH

1.6 nH

1.3 nH

30

2.2 nH

1.9 nH

1.6 nH

40

2.5 nH

2.2 nH

1.9 nH

50

2.8 nH

2.5 nH

2.1 nH

60

3.1 nH

2.7 nH

2.3 nH

70

3.4 nH

3.0 nH

2.6 nH

80

3.6 nH

3.2 nH

2.8 nH

90

3.9 nH

3.5 nH

3.0 nH

100

4.2 nH

3.7 nH

3.2 nH

10

Connection Inductance for Typical Capacitor

Configurations with 50 mils from Capacitor Pad to Via Pad

Distance into
board
to planes (mils)

0805
(208 mils
between via
barrels)

0603
(188 mils
between via
barrels)

0402
(166 mils
between via
barrels)

10

1.7 nH

1.6 nH

1.4 nH

20

2.5 nH

2.3 nH

2.0 nH

30

3.0 nH

2.8 nH

2.5 nH

40

3.5 nH

3.2 nH

2.8 nH

50

3.9 nH

3.5 nH

3.1 nH

60

4.2 nH

3.9 nH

3.5 nH

70

4.5 nH

4.2 nH

3.7 nH

80

4.9 nH

4.5 nH

4.0 nH

90

5.2 nH

4.7 nH

4.3 nH

100

5.5 nH

5.0 nH

4.6 nH
11

Via Configuration Can Change

Inductance
SMT Capacitor
Via

Best

The Good
Capacitor Pads

The Bad
Better
The Ugly

Really Ugly

12

Comparison of Decoupling Capacitor

Via Separation Distance Effects
Via Separation
10 mils

0.1 uF Capacitor
Via separation, mils

Inductance, nH

Impedance @1 GHz, Ohms

20

0.06

0.41

40

0.21

1.3

60

0.36

2.33

80

0.5

3.1

100

0.64

4.0

150

1.0

6.23

200

1.4

8.5

300

2.1

12.7

400

2.75

17.3

500

3.5

21.7

13

Example #1
Low Cap Connection Inductance
IC

Cap
PWR
GND

PCB

14

Example #2
Hi Cap Connection Inductance
IC

PCB

Cap

PWR
GND

15

Example #3
Lower Cap Connection Inductance
IC

PCB

PWR
GND

Cap

16

Example #4
High Cap Connection Inductance
IC

Cap
PWR
GND

PCB

17

Capacitor Connection Inductance Ratio

ESL

L2

Cap

L3=L3 + ESL

L3

PCB

PWR
GND

Power/GND
plane
spacing,
(mils)

via
diameter,
(mils)

L2
(nH)

10

10

0.32

10

13

10

62mil brd
centered
plane
spacing,
mils

L3/L2

L3/L2
w/extra
100 mil
trace
length

L3/L2
w/extra
200 mil
trace
length

0603
SMT
L3'
(nH)

0.304

10

25

0.27

35

35

10

1.1

35

13

1.07

35

25

0.95

L3/L2
w/extra
300 mil
trace
length

1.66

6.75

9.13

11.50

13.88

0.92

1.29

1.98

2.67

3.36

For local decoupling need L3/L2 < 3

18

Decoupling Must be Analyzed in

Different Ways for Different Functions
EMC
Resonance big concern
Requires STEADY-STATE analysis
Frequency Domain

Transfer function analysis

Eliminate noise along edge of board due to
ASIC/IC located far away
19

Decoupling Must be Analyzed in

Different Ways for Different Functions
Provide Charge to ASIC/IC
Requires time-limited analysis
Charge must get to the IC during the time it is
needed!

Charge will NOT travel from far corners of the

board fast enough
Local decoupling capacitors dominate
20

Decoupling Capacitor Mounting

Keep as to planes as close to capacitor
pads as possible
IC Connection
Inductance Loop
IC

Capacitor

Capacitor Connection
Inductance Loop

Plane Inductance Loop

21

Current in IC During Logic Transitions

(CMOS)
IC
driver

VCC
switch

IC load

Z0, vp

CL

VDC

GND
VCC
IC
driver

charge
Z0, vp

shoot-thru
current
GND

logic 0-1

VCC
IC load

IC
driver

discharge IC load

VCC

Z0, vp
Shootthru
current

GND

0V

logic 1-0
22

Typical PCB Power Delivery

DC/DC converter
(Power source)
electrolytic
capacitor

SMT capacitors
GND

GND
VCC
VCC

GND
VCC

IC load
GND

GND
VCC

IC driver

GND

VCC

VCC
23

Equivalent Circuit for Power Current

Delivery to IC
connector
and wiring

via interconnect

capacitor
leads

distance
inductance

PCB
wiring

Ltrace

Lps

Lbulk

Lvia

IC load
Cplanes

VDC
Cbulk

DC/DC
converter

CSMT

electrolytic
capacitors

SMT
capacitors

VCC/GND
plane

24

Power Bus Charging Hierarchy

HUGE
Lps
power
supply
(DC/DC
converter)
ultimate charge
source
SLOW

BIG
Lbulk

SMALL
Lvia

TINY
Lplanes Ltrace

leaded
capacitors

SMT
capacitors

DC power
planes

100s uF

0.01-100s uF

pFs-100 nF

POKEY

QUICK

FASTEST

25

Traditional Analysis #1
Use impedance of capacitors in parallel

ESR1

ESR2

ESL1

ESL2

1uF

Impedance to IC
power/gnd pins

0. 1uF

ESR3
ESL3
0.01uF

ESR4
ESL4
.001uF

No Effect of Distance Between Capacitors

and IC Included!
26

Traditional Impedance Calculation

for Four Decoupling Capacitor Values
1000

100

.1uF
.01uF

Impedance (ohms)

.001uF
.0001uF

10

All in Parallel

0.1

0.01
1.00E+07

1.00E+08

1.00E+09

Frequency (Hz)

27

Traditional Analysis #2
Calculate loop area Traditional loop
Inductance formulas
Which loop area? Which size conductor

ESR1

ESR2

ESR3

ESL1+Ld1

ESL2+Ld2

ESL3+Ld3

1uF
Impedance to IC
power/gnd pins

0. 1uF

0.01uF

ESR4
ESL4+Ld4
.001uF

Over Estimates L and Ignores Distributed Capacitance

28

More Accurate Model Includes

Distributed Capacitance
Intentional Decoupling Capacitors
IC Power Pin

Distributed
capacitors

29

Distributed Capacitance
Schematic
Intentional
Capacitor

Distributed Capacitance

ESR
Loop L

Capacitance

Source

Note: L increases
as distance from
source increases

L = Loop L + ESL, but Loop L dominates

30

Effect of Distributed Capacitance

Can NOT be calculated/estimated using
traditional capacitance equation need to
use full-wave technique
Displacement current amplitude changes
with position and distance from the source

31

Sample Parameters for

Comparison to Measurements
Dielectric thickness = 35 mils
Dielectric constant = 4.5, Loss tan = 0.02
Copper conductivity = 5.8 e7 S/m

32

Impedance at Port #1
Single 0.01 uF Capacitor at Various Distances (35mil Dielectric)
30

20

Impedance (dBohms)

10

-10

-20

no caps
300 mils
500 mils
700 mils
1000 mils

-30

-40
1.0E+07

1.0E+08

1.0E+09
Frequency (Hz)

1.0E+10

33

Z11 Phase Comparison as Capacitor distance Varies for 35 mils FR4

ESL = 0.5nH
2

1.5

Phase (rad)

0.5

-0.5

100 mils
200 mils
300 mils
400 mils
1000 mils
2000 mils

-1

-1.5

-2
1.0E+06

1.0E+07

1.0E+08

1.0E+09

Frequency (Hz)

34

Impedance at Port #1
Single 0.01 uF Capacitor at Various Distances (10mil Dielectric)
20

10

Impedance (dBohms)

0
no caps
300 mils
500 mils
700 mils
1000 mils

-10

-20

-30

-40

-50
1.0E+07

1.0E+08

1.0E+09
Frequency (Hz)

1.0E+10

35

Effect of Capacitor Value??

Need enough charge to supply need
Depends on connection inductance

36

Charge Depletion
IC draws charge from planes
Capacitors will re-charge planes
Location does matter!

37

Model for Plane Recharge Investigations

r = 4.5
b = 10

Port1
(8,7)

Port2
(4,5)
Port3
(4,4.95)

Cdec
(4.05,5)

d = 35 mil

Vdc
a = 12
I input

Decoupling Capacitor :
C = 1uF
ESR = 30mOhm
ESL = 0.5nH

DC voltage used to
charge the power
plane

Port 2 represents IC current draw

38

Charge Between Planes vs. Charge

Drawn by IC
Board total charge : C*V = 3.5nF*3.3V = 11nC
Pulse charge 5A peak : I*dt/2 = (1ns*5A)/2 = 2.5nC

39

Charge Depletion vs. capacitor distance

40

Charge Depletion for Capacitor @ 400

mils for various connection Inductance

41

Noise Voltage is INDEPENDENT of

Amount of Capacitance!

Dist=400 mils

As long as there is
enough charge

ESR=30mOhms
ESL=0.5nH

42

Capacitor Locations and Orientation

Many myths about decoupling capacitor
design
Proximity between capacitors has been
shown to impact capacitors performance
Wish to quantify these various effects, not
just show which is best
Current (not voltage) important for
decoupling capacitor analysis
43

What Happens if a 2nd Decoupling Capacitor

is placed near the First Capacitor?

Via #1
distance
Observation
Point

Via #2 Moved in arc

around Observation
point while
maintaining 500 mil
distance to
observation point

500
mils

44

Second Via Around a circle

Port 3 ( x,

y)

d1

Port 1

d2
d1 = R
d 2 = 2 R sin

r: radius for all ports in mil

d: thickness of dielectric layer in mil

Port 2

d (R + r ) (d1 + r )
ln
4
r 3 (d 2 + r )
2

R: distance between Port 1 and Port 2

in mil

+r

d
R+r

4
d +r

ln 2

d1

ln 2

d
R + r)
(

=
ln
3
4 (2 R sin( / 2) + r )r

d1: distance between Port 3 and Port 1

in mil
d2: distance between Port 2 and Port 3
in mil
theta: angle as shown in the figure in
degree
Courtesy of Jingook Kim, Jun
Fan, Jim Drewniak
Missouri University of Science
and Technology
45

Effective Inductance for Various Distances to Decoupling Capacitor

With Second Capacitor (Via) Equal Distance Around Circle
Plane Seperation = 35 mil -- Via Diameter = 20 mil
2100
2000
1900
1800
1700

250 mil
Inductnace (pH)

1600

500mil

1500

750 mil

1400

1000 mil

1300
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
600
500
0

50

100

150

200

Angle (degrees)

46

Effective Inductance for Various Distances to Decoupling Capacitor

With Second Capacitor (Via) Equal Distance Around Circle
Plane Seperation = 5 mil -- Via Diameter = 20 mil
400

350

300
500mil
Inductnace (pH)

250 mil
250

750 mil
1000 mil

200

150

100

50

0
0

50

100

150

200

Angle (degrees)

47

Understanding Inductance Effects and

Proximity
1 via

10cm

2 via with degree 30

10mm

20cm
10cm

2 via with degree 90

2 via with degree 180

20cm

48

Current Density - simulation

[m]

[m]

A/m2

A/m2

[m]
[m]

[m]
[m]

A/m2

A/m2

[m]

[m]

49

DUT for Experimental Validation (Single Plane pair)

10cm
Shorting via

1 shorting

2mm

10cm
Short Vias

G-S probing
port
Short Vias
0.8mm

2 shorting with 30

2 shorting with 180

= 0,30,180
G-S probing
port
50
50

Experimental Validation (Single Plane Pair)

Measured Input Impedance

10
Impedance [ ]

0.1
50

100
Frequency [MHz]

400

Even in the case with two

shorting vias at opposite sides
( =180), the inductance
value is 68.8% of that with
one shorting via
As two shorting vias get
closer together, mutual
inductance between two
shorting vias increases.

1000

with only 1 via (852pH)

900

Total inductance [pH]

850

with 2 vias with 30 (687pH)

800
750

with 2 via with 180

(586H = 68.8% 852pH)

700

650
600
550
500
0

50

100

150

200

theta (degree)

250

300

350

(
d
R + r)

ln
3
4 (2 R sin( / 2) + r )r
51
Equation

Observations
Added via (capacitor) does not lower
effective inductance to 50%
70-75% of original single via case

Thicker dielectric results in higher

inductance

52

Multiple Capacitors
GND_cap

PW R_cap

Decaps
Cavity1
GND

GND
PWR

Cavity2

GND

PW R

PWR

Cavity3
GND

Cavity4
PW R

53

Via Spacing
9 mils

9 mils

10 mils*

20 mils

10 mils*

Via Barrel 10 mils

60 mils

108 mils minimum

128 mils typical

Distance to Planes
(mils)

40 mil Spacing (nH)

0402 SMT (nH)

0603 SMT (nH)

10

0.3

0.9

1.1

20

0.5

1.3

1.6

30

0.75

1.6

1.9

40

0.95

1.9

2.2
54

Possible Configurations

Dense,
nonalternating

Dense,
alternating

Spread,
nonalternating

Spread,
alternating

55

Effective Inductance for 16 Decoupling Capacitors for Dense and Spread

Configurations and Plane Pair Depth
120

Effective Inductance (pH)

100

80

60

Dense Non-Alternating
40

Dense Alternating
Spread NonAlternating
Spread Alternating

20

40 mil via spacing

0
0

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Distance into PCB (mils)

56

Number of Capacitors
0.6inch
1 cap

2 caps

4 caps

8 caps

16 decaps

57

Effective Inductance vs. Number of Capacitors and Plane Pair Depth

Effective Inductance (pH)

1000

100

1 Capacitors
2 Capacitors
4 Capacitors
8 Capacitors
16 Capacitors
10
0

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Distance into PCB (mils)

40 mil via spacing

58

Effect of Plane width on Inductance

Case1 : 10 inches

Case2 : 5 inches
Case3 : 2 inches

Port1

Port2

1 inch

59

Inductance as Board Width Changes

(Current Density Also Changes)
Case2 : 5 inches
Case1 : 10 inches

~ 330pH

Case2 : 2 inches

~ 250pH

~ 560pH

60

Summary
Capacitance values should be as large as possible
within the package size
In most cases, IC takes charge from between the plates,
capacitors replenish that charge
Capacitors are better able to provide charge when
spread out
If placed near each other, capacitors should alternate
power/ground pins
Worst configuration is when capacitors are close
together and all pins in the same direction
When plane pair is deep in PCB stackup, effective
inductance is higher
61

Conventional Wisdom
Need a variety of capacitance values to
maintain low impedance over frequency
range
Many capacitors of one value is better
than many values
Place capacitors close to ICs as possible
Location does not matter
Spread capacitors over entire board
62

63

Backup

64

Modeling Technique
Difficult to model many layer PCB with full wave
models
Multi-Via Transition Tool (MVTT)
Breaks multiple layers into individual via transitions
Cavity resonance technique to find impedance
between planes
Capacitance calculation for via-to-plane effects
Concatenate S-parameters from all individual
elements

65

Breaking the Problem

One via between a power

plane: 2-port network
Top Port

Via Barrel

Top Power
Plane
Bottom Power
Plane

Bottom Port

66

Via Configurations
S Top Port
Signal Via

G Top Port

GND Via

PWR Plane

PWR Plane

Signal
Via (S)

GND
Via (G)

Zpp

PWR Plane

PWR Plane

S Bottom Port

Signal Via

G Bottom
Port

S Top Port

GND Via
GND Plane

PWR Plane
Signal
Via (S)

GND
Via (G)

Zpp

PWR Plane

PWR Plane
S Bottom Port

Signal Via

GND Via

G Bottom
Port

S Top Port

GND Plane

GND Plane

PWR Plane
Signal
Via (S)

Zpp

GND
Via (G)
PWR Plane

S Bottom Port

67