Lesson 1 Ghosts and The Psyche

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 28

Ghosts and the Psyche

Dienstag 18 Dienstag 18 Dienstag 18 Dienstag 18- -- -20 Uhr 20 Uhr 20 Uhr 20 Uhr, UdL 6, , UdL 6, , UdL 6, , UdL 6, 3031 3031 3031 3031
Email: simone.natale@hu Email: simone.natale@hu Email: simone.natale@hu Email: simone.natale@hu- -- -berlin.de berlin.de berlin.de berlin.de
Dr. Simone Natale
Gastdozent
Vielfalt der Wissensformen
Humboldt Universitat zu Berlin
Sommersemester 2014
ummar! o" last #ee$%s lesson
Ghosts and cultures of death
Philie !ri"s# Western Attitudes toward Death: From the
Middle Ages to the Present $1%&4'(
Ghosts and the culture of mournin) $Trauer'
&o'i(s "or toda!%s (lass: ghosts and the 's!(he
1( *mer)ence of the lin+ bet,een the )host and mental states
$s-cholo)-'
2( .err- /astle0s theor- on the 1sectralization of the mind2
3( 4reud0s Das Unheimliche
)host as a''arition * +ision * illusion
Secter $n(' c(1500# 6fri)htenin) )host#6 from 4rench sectre 6an
ima)e# fi)ure# )host6 $15c('# from 7atin sectrum 6aearance# vision#
aarition6 $see sectrum'( 4i)urative sense 6ob8ect of dread6 is from
1&&4(
Phantom $n(' c(1300# fantum6illusion# unrealit-#6 from 9ld 4rench
fantosme $12c('# from Vul)ar 7atin :fantauma# from 7atin hantasma
6an aarition6 $see hantasm'( .he h; ,as restored in *n)lish late
15c( $see h'( <eanin) 6secter# sirit# )host6 is attested from late
14c(= that of 6somethin) havin) the form# but not the substance# of a
real thin)6 is from 1&0&(
)hosts and the mind in
toda!%s language
*>ressions lin+in) )hosts to states of mind?
1.he ghosts in -our head2
1! thou)ht that haunts me2
@
What does it mean 1to see a )host2A !nd ,h-
do ,e use )hostl- metahors in our ever-da-
lan)ua)e in order to describe thou)hts and
mental statesA
&err! ,astle on the -s'e(trali.ation
o" the mind/
.err- /astle# historian of literature# currentl- Walter !( Haas
Professor in the Humanities at Stanford Universit-(
Boo+ 1.he 4emale .hermometer#2 ublished in 1%%B
$available as df in our <oodle a)e'
'e(trali.ation o" the mind
Cuestion? When does the )host becomes a metahor for our
mental states# our thou)htsA !nd ,hich are the
conseDuencesA
!nal-sis of !nn Eadcliffe0s novel The Mysteries of Udolpho
$1&%4'
$German edition? Udolphos Geheimnisse'
TheMysteriesofUdolpho
!rchet-al Gothic novel# )reat oular
success
.heme of the suernatural F )host
Eational e>lanations? the )host is the
roduct of our ima)ination and of
suerstition
,astle%s anal!sis o" TheMysteriesofUdolpho
19ld;fashioned )hosts $in the <-steries of Udolho' have
disaeared from the fictional ,orld# but a ne, +ind of aarition
ta+es their lace( .o be a Eadcliffean hero or heroine means 8ust this?
to be Ghaunted0# to find oneself ossessed b- sectral ima)es of
those one loves( 9ne sees in the mind0s e-e those ,ho are absent=
one is befriended and consoled b- hantoms of the beloved2 $/astle
1%%B# ( 123'(
;;H 7in+ ,ith shifts in the rocess of mournin)# ,hich increasin)l-
becomes a more rivate issue $see Aris on mournin) in our societ-'
0 ne# 'er(e'tion o" human e1'erien(e
1In the moment of romantic self;absortion# the other ,as
indeed reduced to a hantom J a urel- mental effect# or
ima)e# as it ,ere# on the screen of consciousness itself( .he
cororealit- of the other J his or her actual life in the ,orld J
became stran)el- insubstantial and indistinct? ,hat mattered
,as the mental icture# the )host# the hauntin) ima)e2
$/astle 1%%B# ( 12B'(
;;H 1Sectralization2 of the other? romantic conviction that the
dead and the absent lives in our mind
4rancisco Go-a#
1*l sueKo de la razLn
roduce monstruos#2
1&%&;%%
&he s'e(trali.ation o" the mind toda!
1.he t,entieth centur-# I hoe to sho,# has comletel-
naturalized this historic shift to,ard the hantasmatic( We are
used to the metahor of the haunted consciousness J indeed
hardl- reco)nize it as metahoric( 9ften enou)h# ,e sea+
colloDuiall- of bein) haunted b- memories or ursued b-
ima)es of eole inside our heads( $@' Mot coincidentall-# the
most influential of modern theories of the mind J
s-choanal-sis J has internalized the )host;seein) metahor2
$/astle 1%%B# ( 12B'(
2ationalist dis(ourses and the s'e(trali.ation
o" the mind
/astle? 1.he rationalists did not so much ne)ate the
traditional sirit ,orld as dislace it into the realm of
s-cholo)-2
;;H Ghosts are internalized
'iritualist debun$ing and rationalist
dis(ourses
'iritualist debun$ing and rationalist
dis(ourses
.,o e>lanations?
1( Ghosts as decetion
2( Ghosts as creation of our mind
$ ;;H and therefore a sub8ect for s-cholo)ical inDuir-'
'iritualist debun$ing and rationalist
dis(ourses
Walter /ooer Nend-# senior sur)eon at the Eo-al Infirmar- for
/hildren# eDuates )hosts to an intense idea $ide fie'?
!"t is as easy to #elie$e in the power of mind in con%uring up a spectre
as in entertaining a simple thought& it is not strange that this thought
may appear em#odied' especially if the eternal senses #e shut& do we
not see a form in our mind(s eye' and if this idea #e intensely defined'
does it not #ecome a phantom)*
3s!(hoanal!sis and the s'e(trali.ation o" the
mind
4reud? ,hat the mind re8ects in one form ma- return to
another
Ghosts as the dead ,ho returns ;;H )hosts as the reressed
ima)e ,ho returns
$!ccordin) to /astle# Ps-choanal-sis ,ould have not been
thin+able ,ithout the sectralization of the mind in Western
societies'
4reud%s -Das Unheimli(he/ 516167
*n)lish translation? the Uncann-
Interest in the issue of belief but also in literature and other
fictional reresentations of uncann- henomena
;;H Nouble life $reli)ious belief O fictional reresentation'
of )hosts and other uncann- manifestations
4reud on the meaning o" -unheimli(h/
PNas deutsche Wort QunheimlichR ist offenbar der Ge)ensatz zu
heimlich# heimisch# vertraut und der SchluS lie)t nahe# es sei et,as
eben darum schrec+haft# ,eil es nicht be+annt und vertraut ist(1
But 4reud also notes that Pheimlich unter den mehrfachen Muancen
seiner Bedeutun) auch eine zei)t# in der es mit seinem Ge)ensatz
unheimlich zusammenfTllt( Nas heimliche ,ird dann zum
unheimlichen( $@' Wir ,erden Uberhaut daran )emahnt# daS dies
Wort heimlich nicht eindeuti) ist# sondern z,ei Vorstellun)s+reisen
zu)ehVrt# $@' dem des Vertrauten# Beha)lichen und dem des
Verstec+ten# Verbor)en )ehaltenen(1
0mbi+alen(e
+eimlich seems to mean t,o oosin) thin)s
simultaneousl-?
1' Belon)in) to the house or the famil-# or re)arded as so
belon)in)=
2' /oncealed# +et from si)ht# so that others do not )et to
+no, about it# ,ithheld from others
P!lso heimlich ist ein Wort# das seine Bedeutun) nach einer
!mbivalenz hin ent,ic+elt# bis es endlich mit seinem
Ge)ensatz unheimlich zusammenfTllt( Unheimlich ist
ir)end,ie eine !rt von heimlich(1
&!'es o" things that arouse sense o" the
un(ann!
Inanimate objects that seem animate and vice versa
DoublesFconfoundin) of selfFother
; double first as assurance of immortalit-# later as harbin)er
of death
&!'es o" things that arouse sense o" the
un(ann!
Involuntary/unintended returns
; 4reud0s e>amle of endin) u over and over in the red li)ht
district
Involuntary repetition $e()( numbers reeatin) several times
durin) a da-'
Attitude towards death
0nimism
PNie !nal-se der 4Tlle des Unheimlichen hat uns zur alten
Weltauffassun) des !nimismus zurUc+)efUhrt# die aus)ezeichnet ,ar
durch die *rfUllun) der Welt mit <enschen)eistern $@'( *s scheint# daS
,ir alle in unserer individuellen *nt,ic+lun) eine diesem !nimismus
der Primitiven entsrechende Phase durch)emacht haben# daS sie bei
+einem von uns ab)elaufen ist# ohne noch TuSerun)sfThi)e Eeste und
Suren zu hinterlassen# und daS alles# ,as uns heute als QunheimlichR
erscheint# die Bedin)un) erfUllt# daS es an diese Eeste animistischer
SeelentTti)+eit rUhrt und sie zur WuSerun) anre)t1
)hosts and Unheimli(he
Nas Unheimliche as somethin) that comes bac+? PNas Unheimliche sei
et,as# ,as im Verbor)enen hTtte bleiben sollen und hervor)etreten
ist(1
PIm allerhVchsten Grade unheimlich erscheint vielen <enschen# ,as
mit dem .od# mit 7eichen und mit der Wieder+ehr der .oten# mit
Geistern und Gesenstern zusammenhTn)t(1
Death and animisti( belie"s
1!ber auf +aum einem anderen Gebiet hat sich unser Nen+en und
4Uhlen seit den Urzeiten so ,eni) verTndert# ist das !lte unter dUnner
Nec+e so )ut erhalten )eblieben# ,ie in unserer Beziehun) zum .ode(
$@' Na fast alle von uns in diesem Pun+t noch so den+en ,ie die
Wilden# ist es auch nicht zu ver,undern# daS die rimitive !n)st vor
dem .oten bei uns noch so mTchti) ist und bereit lie)t# sich zu TuSern#
so,ie ir)end et,as ihr ent)e)en +ommt(1
3s!(hoanal!sis and the s'e(trali.ation o" the
mind
Nas Unheimliche as the return of the reressed $the rimitive
animistic beliefs O the reressed events of childhood'
Ghosts are creations of our mental life# of our s-cholo)ical life
;;H sectralization of the mind
8e1t #ee$
The ,at and the ,anary $US! 1%2&'#
directed b- Paul 7eni
Dan$e9
simone(nataleXhu;berlin(de

You might also like