N.

Nandhivarman General Secretary Dravida Peravai

1
 The articles of Nandhivarman in internet and the
venom split by enemies of Tamils

N.Nandhivarman
General Secretary Dravida Peravai

irst Edition: September 2009 : Anna Centenary year

Price: Rs: 150
Copies: 300
Published by :Aringnar Anna Foundation

2
In the footsteps of Genius Anna we are educating the Tamils amidst
brickbats hurled at us.

The articles I wrote in www.indiainteracts.com, an internet social

platform where many issues are debated, record the number of
viewers indicating that my messages have gone down well with the
readers. Handful used filthiest language and vulgar abuses, which too
I have reproduced here as reaction to my views.

The enemies of Tamils splitting venom against Periyar EVR, Aringnar

Anna and Kalaignar M.Karunanithi is not censored here, but in
verbatim given below my articles. It is for Tamils to judge these
people and the culture of the yesteryear invaders or sneakers.

Anna inculcated in us the nobility to expose the enemy by excusing

the foe and leaving it to people to decide. We have the heart to
withstand any curses, abuses, attacks since we are clean in our public
and private lives.

The debates of current times will reflect the stand of Dravida Peravai.

N.Nandhivarman

www.dravidaperavai.org.in

3
Contents

1. Search Ram before Ram’s bridge 005

2. A Berlin wall across our National Seaway 018

3. Anna DMK becomes Amma DMK 020

4. New Sea-way like Sethusamudram 037

5. Plundering ECR Environment for Power plants 044

6. Emergence of New Nations and Tamil Eelam 056

7. Junior Vikatan opens Pandora’s Box of MGR 057

8. The Kashmir Confusion: Bureaucratic blunders 061

9. Slaves from British and French India 065

10. Colonization-Decolonization-Recolonization 068

11. Derogatory Remarks about Bharathiar 082

12. Long drawn struggle against Auroville 086

13. No sanctuary for Sita in Ramayana 092

14. Oil Summit-India needs pro-people policy 104

15. Malaysian Tamils Open Appeal 107

16. Tamilnadu becoming dumping ground of Fly-ash 127

17. Unearth submerged Ports of Chozha Empire 132

4
Search Ram First before
Searching for Ram’s Bridge

[Published on October 20th, 2007 in Parties, Politics | Views 2773]

Nandhi Varman - General Secretary Dravida Peravai

The BJP and its policies based on a mythical hero with no relevance to
people’s issues is a mirage chase. A mirage which BJP cannot reach to
quench its thirst for power. Hue and cry over non existent Ram’s bridge had
been catapulted into a matter of national debate. Dravida Kazhagam, the
parent body of all major and minor Dravidian political parties including
Dravida Peravai had done the logically correct thing to counter the
propaganda of falsehoods unleashed by the forces of fascism.

Paula Richman wrote a book titled ‘Many Ramayana’s. Yes the question
before us is to accept which Ramayana as true story? Vishwa Hindu
Parishad is not ready to accept truth or explore hidden truth or accept the
multiplicity of Ramayana versions. That is fascism and nothing else. Paula
Richman refers an incident in her book. ‘In 1993 the VHP destroyed an
exhibition because it depicted the Jain Dasaratha Jathaga version of Rama
and Seetha as siblings.’ Who could be the arbiter? Should anyone take the
matter to International Court of Justice because it involves Ramayana’s
originating from different cultures and countries? Individuals cannot go to
International Court of Justice. Some nation must take the matter to court, to
prove its version of Ramayana as true history. Till the matter is decided, no
question of resolving Ram’s birth place and Ram’s Bridge could be resolved
or settled. First and foremost to be decided is which of the Ramayana’s is
true history?

Laos Ramayana: Buddha recited the story of Rama to his disciples, in

Laos; they believe that the jataka tale to be tale of Buddha’s previous birth.
There are two popular versions of Ramayana namely Phra Lak Phra Lam
and Gvay Dvorahbi. According to these Ramayana’s, Ravana is the nephew
of King Dasarath. Rama while roaming in desert in search of Sita eats a fruit
and becomes a monkey. [The biblical Adam and Eve’s story and its
resemblance could also be taken note of] After becoming monkey Rama
meets Nengsi, a woman turned into monkey and marries her. Hanuman is
their son. After killing Ravana, Ram marries his widow.

5
Thai Ramayana: The earliest version of Ramakien dates back to 13 th
century and Thais believe their version to be the original story. In Ramakien
many places in Thailand have been identified with Ramayana episodes. The
city of Ayutthaya i.e. Ayodhya has been mentioned as capital of the
kingdom. Ramakien vividly describes the marriage of Hanuman. According
to Thais, Hanuman had many affairs and children.

Jain Ramayana: According to historian D.N.Jha in Jain Ramayana it is

Luxman who kills Ravana. Neither Ram, Luxman nor Hanuman is
monogamous. Luxman has 16,000 wives while half that number Ram has,
says D.N.Jha. ‘In Buddhist Ramayana Rama and Sita are siblings who later
got married while in Jain Ramayana Rama has 8000 wives. Historian
D.N.Jha links the monogamous Rama to the patriarchal society, a symptom
of which is also Sita’s agnipariksha.’

Cambodian Ramayana: Cambodian version ‘The Reamkher’ states Ram as

incarnation of Vishnu. Akaingameso which means God’s doorkeeper was
reborn as Ravana. Sita, in her earlier birth was the wife of Indra, who was
insulted by Ravana. To avenge the wrong she was born as Ravana’s
daughter. Ravana was cautioned by his astrologer and brother Bibhek about
his daughter’s evil birth. Ravana put her in a chest and buried her. King
Janaka later discovered her. The Reamkher follows Valmiki episodes on
Ram’s friendship with monkey chiefs and construction of the bridge. There
is one important deviation. Sita gave birth to a son named Ramalaksha
parented by Valmiki.One day she went to the river for a bath with her son
when the sage was in deep meditation. After meditation Valmiki could not
see his son, hence created another son by his yogic power and named him
Jupalaksha.

These are some of the versions. BJP and VHP must first of all find out
whether Sita is the wife of Valmiki? They must find out whether Rama had
8000 wives, Lakshman had 16000 wives or Dasarathan had 60000 wives.
The Ravana and Sita being father and daughter and the Rama and Sita being
brother and sister, are existing stories in various cultures. We did not write
these Ramayanas, and all Ramayanas are written by pious people and not
atheists like me.

The Dravidian Movement took up cudgels against the Kamban’s version of

Ramayana and the journal Kudi Arasu edited by Thanthai E.V.Ramasamy

6
Periyar published series of articles by Chandrasekara Paavalar. Aringnar
Anna challenged Tamil scholars to come for open one to one debate on the
purpose of Kambaramayanam and its imposition on Tamils to subjugate
them under Aryan Illusion.

Navalar Somasundara Bharathiar and Chollin Chelvar R.P.Sethu Pillai

debated with Anna and openly admitted they have lost the debate. This
debate in Tamil Book ‘Let Fire Spread’ wants to illuminate Tamil hearts by
symbolically burning Kamba ramayanam. Pulavar Kuzhanthai wrote
Ravana Kavyam can be considered as Dravidian version of Ramayana.

The question before us which of these versions is based on true historical

facts. These are not days where everyone will accept anything with blind
faith. If you place new facts to reopen a settled issue in history, you should
place facts and prove it. Blind faith of BJP and VHP will not stand the
scrutiny of the Age of Science.

Chinese had some truth to add to world’s history; yes they wanted to tell
the world that their sons only discovered America and not Columbus. Gavin
Menzies wrote a book: 1421: The Year China Discovered America. The
book states about the 7 expeditions by Admiral Zheng He between 1405 and
1423 with a fleet of 317 ships and 28,000 men. Chinese Government
organized exhibitions, and the postal authorities of Hong Kong, Macao,
Singapore, Malaysia and Thailand issued postage stamps commemorating
Zhen He’s discovery. At a cost of 50 million dollars a Museum is being set
up. If BJP and VHP had truth in their arsenal let them use it first.
Lungpower alone will not establish truth. When they ruled India, BJP
combine tried its best to use all money at its command to prove many
falsehoods; ultimately they failed in all such adventures.

How Fast Do Monkeys Fly?

In October 2004, a lecture by Berkeley Professor R.P.Goldman titled ‘How

fast do monkeys fly? How long do demons sleep’ which took place in New
Delhi is reported in the Times of India [Mumbai edition] dated Saturday
October 30 2004. According to Dr.R.P.Goldman ‘ancient Sanskrit scholars
who made intense study of Hindu mythological texts like Ramayana tried to
rationalize several of the seemingly improbable tales like Ravana’s ten
heads, or how fast Hanuman the monkey god could have flown to get the

7
sanjivini or elixir, for Laksman or even how long Kumbakarna, Ravana’s
brother, might have slept.’

In order to apply the rationalist paint to the absurd story of Ravana having
10 heads, since none of the findings about extinct species have found a
single 10 headed human fossil, they said that Ravana actually had one head
and the other 9 were reflection on the large 9 polished gems that he wore
around his neck. The success of rationalist movement compels scholars to
spin new tales to justify foolish tales.

Another important question that these scholars raised was how long could
Hanuman have taken to fly to the Himalayas to the Mahodaya Mountain to
fetch the life giving herb for Laksmanan from Lanka, where the battle was
raging? Goldman says that some of the scholars calculated that roughly at a
speed of 660 kilometers per hour Hanuman flew, plucked the mountain, and
flew back to Lanka. Then ‘Hanuman was quite ecologically conscious’ the
Professor R.P.Goldman states in order to save ecology Hanuman flew again
back to Himalayas and pasted the plucked mountain with an adhesive still
not found by scientists.

This is the scholarly research which BJP and VHP want us to accept. Can
anyone with brain assimilate this research as proven scientifically and
established beyond an iota of doubt? No one will swallow this foolish
finding. Dravida Peravai wants BJP and VHP to prove all these impossible
feats first before staking claim to Rama’s Bridge in Gulf of Mannar.

Rama’s Bridge

So far historians have found evidences that first human on Earth dates back
to 60,000 years. Journey of Man by Spencer Wells which was also telecasted
in National Geographic Channel claims that first human beings were from
Africa. The book also claims that all humans are one; there exists a common
gene named Sangene in all human beings. While writing about this book in
my article titled Black Race and Brahma’s Face, I had written that these
findings which prove human race is one is a severe indictment of a race that
claims superiority among others and one which never accepts all humans as
equals, thus people who claim to have born from Brahma’s face who built
castles of lies in the name of varunasharadharma, have been proven to be
totally unscientific and idiots claiming superiority on earth at the cost of
fellow human beings,

8
The reason to state this is because in www.virtuallibrary.com of Srilanka
claims: ‘NASA Images Find 1,750,000 Year Old Man Made Bridge between
India and Srilanka’

Under this title the Aryan lobby writes ‘In the 18 th incarnation of Lord
Krishna, the Lord appeared as King Rama. In order to perform some
pleasing work for the demigods, he exhibited superhuman powers by
controlling the Indian Ocean and the killing of the atheist King Ravana, who
was on the other side of the Sea’…. Srimad Bhagawatham, the site claims.

Let us examine the falsehoods one by one. We from the Dravidian

Movement are atheists but not Ravana; all know that Ravana as per epics is
a devotee of Lord Siva. The doubt which arises to me is why should a
reincarnation of God perform superhuman deeds to impress demigods? Does
it mean that Demigods are more powerful than the Original God on
reincarnation?

How does God control Indian Ocean?

UNESCO had constituted an Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission

to undertake research of the Indian Ocean. This commission had not found
yet anything that Gods did in Indian Ocean as per Srimad Bhagawatham.
Well Dravida Peravai urges the Indian Government to refer the matter of
Rama’s Bridge to this Intergovernmental Commission and if this
commission says that there is no Rama’s bridge, will all BJP and VHP
followers give up their religion and become atheists. Graham Hancock had
written a book titles Underworld: The Mysterious Origins of Civilization.

In 1981 Daniel Behrman had written a book Assault on the Unknown.

There are many books on Indian Ocean. All these books give us evidences
on the continental drift, the submerged lands of the Lemuria, which Tamils
prefer to call as the Kumari Kandam. The challenge posed by BJP and VHP
must be accepted and we must use the National Institute of Oceanography to
indulge in the study of under water archaeology to bring to light the great
past of the Tamils. Tamil literature says 49 countries were lost to the seas,
including River Kumari and River Pahruli. If Ramayana, an epic says Rama
constructed a bridge and if that has to be probed, we Tamils demand that
what all Tamil literature says about First and Second Tamil Sangams and the
land loss to Tamil homeland namely Kumarikandam also should be studied.

9
In 2004 Dinamani Tamil Daily reported that in Bangalore a scientist
Graham Cook displayed finds from the under water exploration he
made near off the coast of Poompuhar, the Chozha Port and displayed
video scenes of submerged Poompuhar and displayed out 2000 artifacts
from the Sea. Using carbon dating and other scientifically proven
methodology in archaeology he said that the Poompuhar Civilization dates
back to 7500 B.C. Tamils must be proud to have scientific evidence that
pushes its civilization to an earlier period compared to Indus Valley
Civilization. Instead of repeating like parrots that we have 2000 years of
history, Tamil scholars must claim that we have a civilization which is
10,000 years old.

The probe BJP wants to undertake will only prove the Tamils past. It is well
known fact that due to rise and fall of sea level both India and Srilanka got
linked up in land 65,000 years ago, Before 27000 years due to rise in sea
level India and Srilanka got separated. Around 17,000 years ago when sea
level dropped both land masses joined and later parted. The study made by
Trichirapalli Bharathidasan University Earth Sciences department states that
before 1.4 million years sea was close to Madurai.

Before 90,000 years Chennai, Puducherry and Vedaranyam were surrounded

by seas. We all know that global warming will result in rise in sea level and
Tamilnadu coast will undergo changes. These are all natural phenomenon.
When lands get linked and then get separated sand domes will naturally be
formed. Such domes could not be claimed as bridge. Contrary buildings
exist beneath the seas near Poompuhar, where we can prove Tamil
civilization,

Right from the beginning Srilanka had been conspiring to stall

Sethusamudram project, and we all know the proposal by Srilanks to
construct a bridge linking Srilanka and India, for which it gave an eye
catching name Hanuman Bridge, perhaps to hoodwink the BJP. For
argument sake if Hanuman Bridge had been constructed instead of
Sethusamudram project will it not affect the Rama’s so called Mirage
Bridge? Dravida Peravai opposed it by calling it a Berlin Wall across the
Seas.

Now again with no economic programme in its arsenal BJP wants to use an
emotional appeal, hence resorts to Ram’s bridge. But BJP conveniently

10
forgets that Atal Bihari Vajpayee speaking in Indian Parliament in 1974
called Kachateevu as Valideep, where Rama fought Vali. Why BJP is
silence on Valideep? Why they don’t want to reclaim Valideep? Loss of
Kacchateevu results in out fishermen getting killed. Reclaiming Kachateevu
is not in BJP’s agenda, but a Bridge is what a mentality these fascist forces
have?

- Asian Tribune -
[I first posted this in Tamil Aaraichi e-group wherefrom Asian Tribune
picked and published creating false suspicion about my Eelam credentials,
later I reproduced same in India Interacts.com]

18 Responses to “Search Ram First before Searching for Ram’s Bridge”

1. Indian Says: Posted on October 20th, 2007

I am not sure whether Nandivarman even knows the meaning of the word
“fascism”. The more I get the opportunity to read on Dravidian “leaders”,
the more I get enlightened about their knowledge, political or otherwise,
their intellectual capacity etc. I can only feel pity for the poor people of
TamilNadu (oh! that includes me too)

2. Ramarsetu Says:
Posted on October 20th, 2007

Nandivarman you should first change your name to “erumai arasan”. Nandi
is a Sanskrit word which refers to the bull which Shiva rides. As a Tamil
fanatic atheist why do you still have a religious Sanskrit name? It is a good
idea to get a research body to investigate the Ramar bridge, but go tell that
“Dravida Dhritrashtra” Karunanidhi that he should not demolish it so we can
do some research! How come you never mentioned the periyar’s version of
Ramayana known as “Ravana Kaviyam”? I hope you guys still read ravana
kaviyam everyday. The irony is that even going by what your leader said
Rama existed! What is even worse is that Ravana’s father was a Brahmin
and periyar accepted him as his hero, although he was anti-Brahmin. Asian
tribune is very advanced for you. They are not going to publish this long,
directionless garbage.

3. Soleswaran Says:
Posted on October 20th, 2007

11
I very much appreciate all these Dravidian party members who are fighting
for the welfare of Mr. Karunanidhi’s family. I don’t know who is getting
benefited by such projects except Mr. Karunanidhi who will get his share of
commission without any doubt. Earlier he opposed Lord Ram and now he is
withdrawing all his remarks, in order to implement sethusamudram project
so that his source of income won’t vanish away. So ultimately he is ready to
compromise on his anti-Hindu stand, in order to safe guard his family
income. If he spends that 2400-5000 crores in building industries, roads, and
basic amenities in the state, people will see whether he is really spending
them for those purpose, so using his master brain he introduced this new
concept of govt project in ocean where people can’t go and see what is
happening.

4. Vedaprakash Says: Posted on October 20th, 2007

Nandi, you have no guts to face the challenge raised either in your controlled
“Tamilarytchi” or in “Wordpress.com”.You have again vomited the same
thing as you did in the wordpress.com. Of course, you have made the
corrections pointed out by us, here in this posting. I d not know how long
you thrive on the knowledge of others. If you have courage, come on,
respond here.

5. Sridharsampath Says:
Posted on October 20th, 2007
Nandhivarman wants to know why BJP is fighting for Kachateevu or
Valideep. Why can’t he ask the same question to MK? After all, he claims to
control the State as well as the Central government.

6. Sridharsampath Says:
Posted on October 20th, 2007
A correction to my earlier post - the first sentence should read ‘…….why
BJP is NOT fighting for Kachateevu……’ Nandhivarman should realize that
the Hindus in India subscribe, by & large, to the Valmiki version of the
Ramayana. How can we be held responsible if people in Laos or Thailand
follow a different version? This is absurd. In fact, he himself mentions about
the Dravidian version of the Ramayana authored by Pulavar Kuzhanthai.
This only proves that this is something about which the traditional Hindus
can do nothing about.

12
7. MNachiappan Says:
Posted on October 21st, 2007

I re-post here what I have posted in response to the same stuff appearing in
wordpress.com with mistakes, as Mr. Vedaprakash pointed out. Let us see
how Nandi reacts or retreats. About the meeting at Salem, I would like to
point out as follows:
1. Anna took more than two hours, thus leaving no time to others.
2. Moreover, the moment, Somasundara Bharathi started speaking, the
crowd was booing at him and Sittaiyan, the friend of Bharathi, who
compelled to bring him for the meeting felt very sad.
3. Bharathi himself openly informed in his starting of his speech that he did
not want to come there as Anna and others had already decided what they
wanted to do.
4. After bringing him booking ticket by train, Anna was speaking even after
8 pm on March 14, 1943. Therefore, Bharathi had no other way but to cut
short his speech and catch the train as per his schedule.

5. He exposed Anna of his authoritarian attitude and the hostile crowd.

6. Therefore, nowhere Anna could win intellectually Bharathi or R. P.
Sethupillai. With crowd-power, Anna wanted to shout down the debaters.

7. Ironically, Ramachandra Chetti, the President of “Hindumatha Paripalana

Nilayam” felt ashamed of Anna’s speech. As the crowd on that day was
about to run riot, the organizers were afraid of the crowd and concerned
about the safety of M/s. RPS and Srinivasan. That is why when Srinivasan
started speaking; the crowd started showing their mob-behavior.

M. Nachiappan
[email protected]

8. MNachiappan Says:
Posted on November 1st, 2007

Another response appearing in the same site:

http://nandhivarman.wordpress.com/2007/05/07/before-human-race-
evolved-ramas-bridge-construction/ on 24 May 2007 at 10:56 am4
Brahmallahchrist

13
The responses are interesting. But, why the person challenged has been
keeping quite is not known. His assertion, “Dravida Peravai challenges the
contention and puts forward our views, which is open to debate, as we are
rationalists, we will not run away from debate”, should have some response.
At least, he should have read the sources once, before jumping to write
something based on the secondary evidences. Criticism could be there and
debate also, as they are not all new for the Indian tradition. But, the one
initiated by Nandivarman appears to be malicious, venomous and
blasphemous too. His posting filed under “Stateless Indians” proves that he
has bent upon anti-Indian posture and it is not known what this posting has
to with such anti-Indian attitude coupled with anti-Hindu. First of all, it is
not known as to whether, he is writing such things from India or outside
India. Anyway, since he has challenged, let us see that he would run away as
he has asserted!

Brahmallahchrist,
A True Secularist.

9. Tvvenkatesh Says:
Posted on November 1st, 2007

Well, I wonder, with such credentials like, being unable to answer, being
unable to enter a debate et al, how was it possible for him to cling on to the
post of Vice Chancellor of Azhagappa University. I am sure that by only
“sombu-adichifying” MGR and MK successively, he was able to do this.
There is absolutely no intellect in this man and hence his posts are not worth
commenting, unless he comes out to either explain or defend himself.
Thanks a lot Nachiappan for bringing this staring anomaly to the forefront

Regards,
Venkatesh

10. Laadlabakdaas Says:

Posted on November 1st, 2007

Mr. Nandi Varman wrote

“The BJP and its policies based on a mythical hero with no relevance to
people’s issues is a mirage chase “Even the political parties in the last 60

14
years have been of no relevance to majority of Indians who are poor and
starving to death. Does that mean all the crooks and goons in different
parties are going to quit politics??? When people vote out successive
governments it’s a signal to the politicians that they are of no relevance to
the public. If Mr. Nandi Varman had any guts like any Dravidian he must
first denounce the creation of Pakistan based on Religion since Islam itself is
of no relevance to anybody.

11. Nandhivarman Says:

Posted on November 3rd, 2007

As a true democrat I have kept others comments for public scrutiny and to
compare whether they have answered the points raised in my debate. Instead
of refuting the arguments, they have stooped to the level of changing my
name, which falls under my individual right or my parental right. Even there
the meaning of bull is Kaalai and not Erumai, hatred had blinded them. I am
not a Vice Chancellor as someone says; a Vice Chancellor had written a
book wherein I am mentioned.

The Tamil book Thee Paravattum is available in book stalls which contains
full debate of Aringnar Anna and his opposite side comprising Navalar
Somasundara Bharathiar and R.P.Sethu Pillai.It is known fact in their own
words they have accepted defeat in the debate over Kambar’s Ramayana.
Since I cannot type it in Tamil I left it. People have read my post and the
comments. They will judge. After all the so called Rama has found these
lawyers who cannot defend him in better way.Nandhivarman III, the Pallava
King gave his life for Tamil, hence my name. Indian Constitution had
allowed me liberty of free speech which includes propagating atheism and
having my right to exist with my name.

12. Jayakarthi Says:

Posted on November 4th, 2007

Dear comrades, when we pose a question, whether people’s welfare is

important or God. Many people choose the people welfare. On that basis
only we should support the Sethu Samudram Canal Project. Don’t be silly
with God. Where is God? If we raise this question nobody answers in proper
manner. We take a simple example. We are demolishing temple/churches on
proposed Road and all we accept that. On that basis, why we cannot accept
300M cut in Adam’s Bridge i.e. in Rama Sethu. For welfare measure we

15
should accept it in broad mind. We should not think in crooked manner.
First think for the human being, and then think for the god. Don’t foolishly
attack any one in the name of God. Debate anything in scientific manner.
God is illusion. So “Ezhaiyin sirippil iraivanai kanpon”.

13. Janakiram Says:

Posted on November 4th, 2007

Nandhivarman Sir, You wrote an excellent piece on the imaginary character

called Rama. But our so-called educated boys are diverting the issue by
writing irrelevant things. Some of them have been calling us names and they
are very irrational. They live up to the statement” Bhakti vandhidil Puththi
poyvidum” meaning when you faithfully follow a religion you lose your
mind and reason. Three cheers to your good rational views.
Regards.

14. Tvvenkatesh Says:

Posted on November 5th, 2007

Nandivarman, sorry that was me and I did not read your profile properly.
Well if you are not a Vice-Chancellor, then “Thank God”. And when are you
going to stop talking about this non-existent Aryan-Dravidian divide? The
whites have left our country. So you people don’t need to be faithful to them
anymore. So please come out of that illusion. If you were still thinking that
they are around us and ruling us and hence need to be faithful to them, here
is the reality. India has attained independence. Oh wait wait!!!! I am sorry, I
jumped into conclusion. You are probably right and your loyalty is towards
the foreigner who is currently ruling us. Sorry, I agree that your are correct
and I forgot this fact.

Jayakarthi, you said “So “Ezhaiyin sirippil iraivanai kanpon”. Which ezhais
are going to become a poor or at least have a hearty laugh due to the Sethu
Samudram Project? I am sure the Poors(!!??) like MK and TRBaalu are the
ones who will definitely have the last laugh For those who does not believe
in God, you can all ask the believers to show where is God. The only reply
is, Sorry we cannot show you, the non-believers, where God is. We the
believers know where the God is and you will not accept it. Fine. For you
people, you will only believe what you see. So just stop asking the question
“Where is God”. First try to find him in you.

16
Janakiram, When you said in your blog” Venkatesh, I am really busy my
friend, please give me some time”, I apologized for my jumping to
conclusion and have given you all the time in the world. But you have only
proven that what all other said about your disappearance is true. Now
suddenly you jump from no where and start parroting the same thing for
which when questioned you could not answer properly.

Regards,
Venkatesh

15. Ramarsetu Says:

Posted on November 5th, 2007

Nandivarman - constitution gave you liberty of free speech which includes

propagating atheism and having my right to exist with my name. I agree
with that. The same constitution gave the right for Hindus to practice their
religion freely - why do you want to infringe on it by destroying something
they believe as sacred? Why did your moronic leader Periyar break Hindu
idols and tear sacred threads of Brahmins?

As for Nandhivarman III, he was a staunch vaishnavite who propagated

Brahminic traditions in TamilNadu and patronized various vaishnavite
temples in Kanchi. Go read history of South India. This name is completely
not apt for an atheist like you. You are really embarrassing yourself in this
forum.

16. Ramarsetu Says:

Posted on November 5th, 2007

Nandivarman can you actually tell us more about Nandhivarman III’s

contribution to Tamil? You just claim that he gave his life - which means
nothing until you substantiate it.

17. Tvvenkatesh Says:

Posted on November 5th, 2007

Ramarsetu, Very well said. For people like Nandivarman, to defend

themselves, they will hide under the Constitution, but will go all out to
condemn the same when they want to offend some one. Nice comments.

17
Regards,
Venkatesh

18. Neversayno32 Says:

Posted on November 5th, 2007

Ramarsetu/TVV, It is waste of time trying to give some logical explanation

to these DK jerks. This fellow called Janakiram conveniently gave a silent
funeral for his blog, bloody he never had the nerve to answer/reply to the
questions posed to him and now here out of blue the un-gentleman (sic) pops
up and makes a remark - ” these educated boys”. Bhakti vandhadil some non
sense he has uttered so true, the blind following of the foolish joker these
DK/DMK morons follow is exactly the BHAKTHI VANDHADHIL
BUDDHI STUFF………Brood…….To all the so-called irrationals,
spineless and brainless (this goes hand in hand), you have a vital organ
called BRAIN, use it and don’t foolishly parrot things which are not relevant
today. Using constitutional rights at your convenience is nothing but being
selfish and cheap…….but what else to expect from you guys…You
DK/DMK clan shamelessly use everything which is a share of others under
the constitution, has anyone at anytime poked into your belief of atheism,
why do you people time and again poke your nose into the THEISM, this
only goes to prove ALL OF YOU GUYS ARE NOT GAINFULLY
EMPLOYED..THALAI SARIYA IRUNDHA VAAL SARIYA IRUKKUM,
EVR - JOKER, had he been sensible in preaching something civic it would
have been nice, foolishly he uttered some nonsense and blindly the tempo is
kept alive for personal gains DMK/DK leaders stand testimony to this.
A Berlin Wall across Our National Seaway

India and Sri Lanka recently declared that a feasibility study to construct a
"Hanuman Bridge" across the Palk Straits will be undertaken. And now
within few months Srilankan Investment Corporation Chairperson Mr.
Jayasooriya had said that the feasibility is over and soon India and Sri Lanka
are going to put their signatures for green signaling this project at a cost of
Rs 4000 crores. A six way track for rail and road traffic is mooted. The
distance of 29.2 kilometeres between Thalaimannar and Thanuskodi which
will be connected by this bridge, will dwarf the 23 kilometer sea bridge
connecting Sweden and Denmark, Mr. Jayasoori proudly states.

18
At the outset this bridge seems to be a Berlin Wall to stall the Sethu
Samudram Canal project conceived before 142 years, much before Suez
Canal was mooted. India's coast from West to East extends to 3555 miles
and to enable Indian ships to navigate within Indian territorial waters, the
only missing link will be interlinked if Sethu Samudram Canal becomes
reality. Further due to United Nations backed demarcation of exclusive
economic zones will see our territorial waters extended up to 350 nautical
miles from the coast. In such a changed milieu, it will be appropriate to
expedite the construction of Sethu Samudram Canal. The last date of receipt
of global tender for preparation of a feasibility study on Sethu Samudram
Canal ended on 15th December 2001, and the nodal agency for
implementation of Sethu Samudram Canal namely the Tuticorin Port Trust
had then stated that the feasibility study will be over in 18 months. Now
National Environmental Engineering Research Institute which had done
preliminary study is entrusted with the task of doing the final study. Even
the newly inducted Minister of State for Shipping Mr.Su.Thirunavukkarasar
had said soon Sethu Samudram Project will commence.

If one had to recall the past it contains so many feasibility reports in queue.
In 1860 Mr. A. D.Taylor of Indian Marine in his report estimated that the
project could be completed in an estimated cost of 50 lakhs. These are the
other feasibility reports during British rule namely British Parliament
Committee Report (1862), The Report of Sir John Stuart the Chief Assistant
Surveyor of Government of Ceylon (1871), The Report of Harbour Engineer
George Robertson (1872), The Report of the South Indian Ship Canal Port
and Coaling Station Ltd (1884), Southern Railway Company Report (1902),
Sir Robert Brislow Harbour engineer of Government of India (1921), The
Report of the Government of Madras on Harbour Development (1947).

In Independent India, for the first time the henceforth Rameswaram

Shipping Canal got renamed as Sethu Samudram Canal in 19.5.1955 and
plans to initiate a technical investigation for including this project in the II
nd Five Year Plan gained momentum. Sir A. Ramaswamy Mudaliar
Committee report (1955) in which the estimate of the project was merely
9.98 crores did not find favour for inclusion in the 2nd Five Year Plan.
Thereafter Dr. Nagendra Singh Committee Report (1963), C.V.
Venkateswaran Committee Report (1965), The revised estimate of C.V.
Venkateswaran Committee (1971), The Technical Committee of
Government of India (1980), The Report of the Harbour wing of the
Ministry of Shipping (1981), Laksminarayanan Committee Report (1983),

19
The unanimous resolution of Tamil Nadu Assembly (1986), Pallavan
Transport Committee Report (1996), The National Environmental Research
Institute report (1998) are in the league of reports that had favored this
project over a period of 140 years. Now this project, which had been
included in the IX th Plan, is going to be subjected for another feasibility
study by global players.

As the rationale to have a National High ways is justifiable by all means, the
dire need to have a National Seaway too is logical and is in national interest.
If this canal is built near Adams Bridge linking Palk Straits with Gulf of
Mannar, we can have an uninterrupted National Seaway.

And the recent decision of Indian and Srilankan Prime Ministers to have a
bridge becomes a way for decent burial of for Sethu Samudram Canal.
Instead in national interest India must desist from building a bridge and go
ahead with the canal project. As Hanuman Bridge is attractive for the
emotional of the ruling elite, we can even rename Sethu Samudram as
Hanuman Samudram Canal and give clearance for this dream project.

Dravida Peravai will launch a march from Pondicherry to Rameshwaram to

draw the attention of the people of Southern Tamil Nadu over the neglect of
Tuticorin Port and the overall economy of South by constructing a BERLIN
WALL ACROSS PALK STRAITS WHICH WILL SEND SETHU
SAMUDRAM CANAL PROJECT FOR A BURIAL. We are meeting CPI
State Secretary Nallannu who is here in Pondicheery today 14th July 2002
and will meet Dr.S.Ramadass PMK founder on 16 th and will meet all
leaders including DMK PRESIDENT Dr.M.KARUNANITHI. We have
appraised the situation by email to COMRADE GEORGE FERNANDES,
NDA CONVENOR, and today i.e. 14th July 2002. Nandhi Varman July 14,
2002
General Secretary Dravida Peravai

ANNA DMK BECOMES AMMA DMK

Betraying
SETHU SAMUDRAM SEAWAY: DREAM OF ANNA

The Sethusamudram story till it was accepted by the Union Cabinet headed
by Hon'ble Manmohan Singh is told here. The story begins with the Atal
Bihari Vajpayee government announcing the launch of the project. It goes to

20
show by betraying Aringnar Anna's dream, Anna DMK has lost credibility
to use Anna's name, hence better it be renamed as Amma DMK.
N.Nandhivarman General Secretary Dravida Peravai

In Tamil Nadu at Madurai, Ramanathapuram and at Tuticorin, The Union

Defense Minister George Fernandes announced the launching of Sethu
Samudram project. Breaking that news THE HINDU, English Daily dated
January 8, 1999 wrote:

A 138-YEAR SUSPENSE BROKEN

The Sethu samudram canal project will go down in history as gift of the 20
th century to the southern districts of Tamil Nadu. A 138 year old suspense
was broken by the Union Defense Minister Mr. George Fernandes, on
Wednesday when he announced at Rameshwaram that work on the project
will commence in the next few months.

Conceived in 1860 by Commander A.D.Taylor of the Indian Marines, the

project, envisaged to link the Gulf of Mannar and the Palk Bay, has been
reviewed umpteen times over the years but a decision could not be made. At
a time when the people of southern districts began to think that
Sethusamudram would remain a pipe dream like linking of the Ganga and
Cauvery, came the announcement from the Prime Minister A.B.Vajpayee in
Chennai that his government would implement the project. The Prime
Minister followed that announcement by entrusting the project to the
Defense Minister, who did lot of spadework in the last four months before
making an aerial survey of the project on Wednesday. Light could be seen at
the end of the tunnel. Since the conception of the Sethu Samudram, two
other canals- the Suez Canal (1869) and the Panama Canal (1915) have been
built in the world.

Though many reasons could be attributed to the delay in the project taking
shape, lack of political will has been the major factor. Like marking the
twelfth man in a cricket team, Sethu Samudram found a place in the election
manifestoes of all political parties during elections. Hopes about the
implementation of the project soared when the Union Government appointed
the Sethu Samudram Project Committee in 1955, headed by
Dr.A.Ramasamy Mudaliar, which was charged with the duty of examining
the desirability of the project. After evaluating the costs and benefits, this
committee found the project feasible and viable. Several reviews of the

21
proposals followed this till Mr.Vajpayee announced his Governments
commitment to execute the project.

What is paramount importance to the country are the strategic advantages

that would accrue from this project. Though the country has a peninsular
coast running to 3554 nautical miles, it does not have a continuous sea-lane
within its territorial waters. Ships navigating from one side of the country to
the other have to circumnavigate Sri Lanka due to the presence of Adam’s
bridge, a sand stone reef near Ramasewaram coast. A memorandum
submitted to the Central Committee on Sethu Samudram Ship Canal project
by the State Government on August 1981 pointed out that the canal will
afford secret and sheltered passage for our naval ships and Coast Guard
vessels. Otherwise, they will have to suffer exposure to the foreign countries
in the Indian Ocean and also suffer more wear and tear voyaging around
Srilanka.

The distance between Cape Comerin and Chennai would be reduced to 402
nautical miles from the present 755 after the completion of the project. The
distance between Cape Comerin and Vizag will be 719 nautical miles
against the present 1014, between Cape Comerin and Calcutta 1098(1357),
Tuticorin and Chennai 335(769). Tuticorin and Vizag 652(1028), Tuticorin
and Calcutta 1031(1371). Apart from effecting savings in fuel the project is
expected to provide a tremendous boost to the economic and industrial
development of coastal Tamil Nadu. The project will be of particular
significance to the Tutucorin harbour, which has the potential to transform
itself into a nodal port such as Singapore and Colombo. The State
Government has announced its proposal to develop 13 minor ports,
including Ennore, Cuddalore, Nagapattinam, Thondi, Valinokam, Colachel
and Kanyakumari. And the Sethu samudram canal will improve coastal
shipping. There is also a possibility of introducing passenger and freight
services along the coast.

The normally drought prone Ramanathapuram district will be the major

beneficiary of the project in terms of providing employment. The maritime
skills of the people living in the Rameshwaram and Pamban areas could be
harmonized for the development of the region. There is also the scope for
the development of a major port like Port Said of the Suez Canal in the
district. Apart from improving the fishing trade, the canal will be a major
tourist attraction.

22
Though there has been a vociferous demand from various quarters for the
implementation of the project, there is also opposition to it. albeit in low
pitch from environmentalists. They point out that the dredging of the Palk
Bay and the Gulf of Mannar would endanger precious marine species and
wealth. However official environment clearance has been given for the
project. The contention that the Sethu Samudram canal will cut through
coral reefs and disturb the ecology as a mistaken fear. Since the coast is
either clayey or sandy in nature the ecology will not be endangered, it has
been pointed out.

The announcement of the Defense Minister and the commitment

demonstrated by the Planning Commission has raised hopes of the people of
south Tamil Nadu.

By Staff Reporter: Courtesy: THE HINDU English Daily. (Jan 8, 1999)

In one such meeting held at Tuticorin, N.Nandhivarman General Secretary

Dravida Peravai translated the speech of Union Defense Minister George
Fernandes. That was on 6.1.1999. Then elections came in the way. Again
when Nandhivarman stressed the necessity to include Sethu Samudram
project in National Democratic Alliance Manifesto, the President of Samata
Party George Fernandes in a letter dated August 5-1999 wrote: "The matters
pertaining to interlinking of rivers and related issues did figure in the last
meeting of NDA. Sethu Samudram cannot be discussed at that moment as
that would violate the code. However you can be rest assured that once the
NDA is returned to power these items will be high on the agenda of the
government."

National Democratic Alliance came to power. And Comrade George

Fernandes was kind enough to recommend to the Union Surface Transport
Minister Nitish Kumar on his own the need to appoint Nandhivarman as one
of the Trustees of Tuticorin Port Trust. Participating the in 4 th ordinary
meeting of the Board of Trustees for the year 2000-2001 held on 25 th
August 2000 Nandhivarman's observations as per the agenda papers are as
follows: "Mr.Nandhivarman enquired about the stage at which the Sethu
Samudram project stood. According to information available to him, a
Belgian company was keen to take up the project on B.O.T.Basis. The
Chairman explained that the firms in Belgium and Holland were interested
in the project because of the large dredging component. The operation and
maintenance of the canal after its construction would be quite expensive and

23
therefore, it is necessary to study the traffic and income potential in detail
before venturing into it. Therefore all these aspects were being studied by
the Government and once it is found to be commercially feasible project
then the Government could take a decision on how to implement it"

Meanwhile in the Board the NEERI Report was tabled to inform the Board
of Trustees of Tuticurin Port Trust

Initial Environmental Examination of Sethu Samudram Ship Canal Project

prepared by National Environmental Engineering Institute – Nagpur
(December 1998).

The executive summary in verbatim is given below:

Preamble:

1. India does not have, within her own territorial waters, a continuous
navigable route around the peninsula due to the presence of a shallow (3.5m)
coral reef called “Adams Bridge" at Pamban near Rameshwaram between
the south eastern coast of India and Talaimannar of Srilanka. Consequently
the ships calling at Ports on the East Coast of India have to go around Sri
Lanka entailing an additional distance of more than 400 nautical miles and
36 hours of ship time.

2. The Sethu Samudram Ship Canal Project, now under the consideration of
the Ministry of Surface Transport, Government of India envisages
construction of a ship canal of varying lengths to suit different drafts (30',
31' and 35') through dredging/excavation. The canal will originate from
Tuticorin new harbour in the Gulf of Mannar extend north east in straight
line up to Mansfield pitch south of Pamban island, then cut through the
island east of the Kodandaramasamy temple and thereafter turning north
east, proceed parallel to the International Medial line as the Bay of Bengal
Channel.

3. Different alignments for the proposed canal were considered, and in the
light of representations from the public, the fishermen and the pilgrims, the
alignment through the island about 4 km east of Kodandaramasamy Temple
has been proposed.

24
4. The Tuticorin Port Trust, the nodal agency identified for the
implementation of the project, in pursuance of its decision to incorporate
environmental considerations in the design phase of the project, retained, in
March 1998, the National environmental Engineering Research Institute
(NEERI) to conduct the Initial Environmental Examination of the project.

5. This report presents briefly the project setting, describes the baseline
environmental status of the project area, identifies environmental issues,
predicts and evaluates impacts due to the proposed canal project.

6. The Initial Environmental Examination has primarily drawn upon the

available information on the proposed project., the hydrograph, marine water
quality and ecological resources in the project area, and the primary data
generated for one season during the course of the study. A comprehensive
environmental impact study with intensive data collection covering all
seasons of the year is essential for a fuller description and appreciation of the
natural processes occurring in the study area, and to delineate the
environmental consequences including the ecological risk associated with
the proposed project.

Project Setting

7. The proposed Sethusamudram Ship canal will have two legs; one near the
Point Calimere called the Bay of Bengal channel and the other across the
narrow Dhanushkody Peninsula near Kodandaramasamy temple. The canal
will cut the existing road connecting Rameswaram and Danushkody. The
Bay of Bengal channel traverses the Palk bay wherein the sea bed is mostly
soft to hard clayey stand in nature. The entire coast of Danushkody
peninsula on the North and South is all sandy.

8. In addition to the construction of the proposed ship canal, a number of

infra-structural facilities are envisaged under the project. These include the
construction of a lock rubble mound breakwaters on either side of the land
canal, navigational aids, flotilla, shore facilities and staff and administration
buildings.

9. As per the study of Pallavan Transport Consultancy Services Ltd, the

estimated cost (1994prices) of dredging various segments of the Channel for
three different drafts viz 30', 31' and 35' is Rupees 478 crores, Rupees 549
crores and Rupees 965 crores respectively. The estimated cost of all the

25
project components including the navigational aids and floating crafts is
Rupees 685 crores, Rupees 760 crores, and Rupees 1200 crores respectively.
The construction period will be about 4 to 6 years. Based on the Net Present
Value (NPV) method of appraisal, with an interest rate of 9% per annum, an
Internal Rate of Return (IRR) of 10 to 17% on the investment has been
estimated. The project will start generating a surplus from the 16 th to 17 th
year of its operation.

EA Requirements

10. In keeping with the nature and magnitude of the investment programme,
the proposed Sethusamudram Ship Canal project would fall under category
A of the World Bank classification and hence would require full EA.

11. At the national level the environmental clearance to the project is subject
to compliance with the stipulated safeguards under the provisions of
Environment (Protection) Act 1986, Forest( Conservation) Act 1980, The
Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974,The Water
( Prevention and Control of Pollution) Rules 1975, The Water (Prevention
and Control of Pollution) Cess Act 1977, The Water (Prevention and Control
of Pollution) Cess Rule 1978, The Water( Prevention and Control of
Pollution) Act 1981, and other rules and regulations in force. Land Use on
the coastline will be subject to regulation as per Coastal Regulation Zone
Notification issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forests,
Government of India under the Environment Protection Act 1986.

This notification is administered by the State Pollution Control Board.

12. The Wild Life (Protection) Act of India (1972) provides legal protection
to many marine animals including reef associated orgasms. Chapter IV of
this Act dealing with sanctuaries, National Parks, Game Reserves and
Closed Areas is equally applicable to marine reserves and marine parks and
biospheres.

13. The Tamil Nadu Pearl and Chunk Fisheries Rules 1978 of the Indian
Fisheries Act 1897 prohibits harvesting of pearl oysters and chunks in
specified areas except under a license granted under the rules.

14. Under Section 5 of the Tamil Nadu Marine Fishing Regulation Act 1983
the State government can regulate, restrict or prohibit fishing in any

26
specified area, the type of fishing gear that can be used, and also the class of
fishing vessels that can operate in any area.

15. The Tamil Nadu State environmental Committee is the apex advisory
body constituted by the Government (G.O Ms.No.10 dated December 12,
1983) in the matter of protection of environment in the state. Development
projects costing over Rupees 50 million are subject to review and clearance
by this committee (GTN G.O Ms.No.161 dated September 26, 1988).

16. Through an executive communication from the Secretary to the

Government of India, Ministry of environment and Forests to the Chief
Secretary, Government of Tamil Nadu, the Gulf of Mannar Marine
Biosphere Reserve has been notified in 1989. There is however no
legislation as yet on the biosphere reserves either at the national or at state
level.

17. Acquisition of private lands for the project will be governed by the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act of 1894/The Tamil Nadu
Requisitioning and acquisitioning of Immovable property Act of 1956.

18. Resettlement and Rehabilitation, if any, due to the project has to be

addressed within the broad framework of the World Bank Operational
Directive O.D 4.30 or as per existing provisions of the Tamil Nadu
Government whichever is applicable.

19. As per the MEF, Government of India notification dated April 10, 1997,
Public Hearing is mandatory for environmental clearance of projects. The
notification has also laid down the procedure for Public Hearing.

20. During the operational phase of the project, the most important
instrument to be complied with relates to the International Convention for
the Prevention of Pollution from ships 1973 as modified by the Protocol of
1978 to which India is a signatory.

ENVIRONMENT SETTING

21. Palk Bay and the Gulf of Mannar covering an area of 10,500 kms in
which the proposed ship canal is to be constructed are biologically rich and
rated among the highly productive seas of the world. Its diversity is
considered globally significant. In the Gulf of Mannar between the coastline

27
and the proposed alignment there are 21 islands which have been declared as
National Marine Parks by the Tamil Nadu Forest Department and the MEF,
Government of India. Van tivu is the nearest island about 6 kms from the
proposed canal alignment in the Tuticorin area and Shingle is the nearest
about 12 Kms Island in the Rameshwaram area.

22. As for hydrograph, there are two circulations of water masses in the Bay
of Bengal in the clockwise circulation of the south-west monsoon and the
counter clockwise circulation of the north-east monsoon. The reported
current velocities in the Palk Bay and Gulf of Mannar are as mild as 0.2 m-
0.4m/sec except on few days during south-west monsoon when it rises up to
0.7 m/sec. The directions of the currents follow the direction of prominent
winds. The analysis of current data shows no potential threats to siltation of
the canal.

23. Primary data on physic-chemical characteristics and marine biological

resources was collected from April 29- May 10, 1998 from 10 sampling
stations along the 50 kilometer long alignment and 20 stations, 5 km on
either side of each of the aforementioned 10 stations. Data on
hydrodynamics was generated on July 10-11of 1998 at 10 locations in the
study domain with the assistance of the Staff of the Chief Hydrographic
Surveyor of India, Dehradun. The present bathymetry is assumed to be not
significantly different from the bathymetry data depicted in Naval Chart 317.

24. Primary data on physical-chemical characteristics of marine water shows

no significant variation in alkalinity (102-106 mg/L) and pH (8.0-8.2) along
the proposed canal alignment. The DO values varied from 3.2 to 5.7 mg/Ll
and the silicates from 0.003 mg/L to 0.017 mg/L. No significant variation in
salinity was observed between surface and bottom samples. An inverse
relationship between salinity and silicates was observed. The concentrations
of heavy metals except iron, boron, and arsenic were below detectable
limits.

25. The gross primary productivity values along the proposed canal
alignment varied from 142 to 472 mg C/m3/day indicating that Gulf of
Mannar and the Palk Straits are a biologically productive region. The
zooplankton was dominated by copepod. Macro benthos was represented by
78 varieties exhibiting fairly good diversity. The meiofauna comprised larval
polychaetes, nematodes, worms and shrunken bodies of a few forms.

28
26. Sediment samples collected along the proposed canal alignment showed
the presence of organic carbon, total nitrogen, total phosphorous and
sulphates in concentrations adequate for biological growth. Almost all the
sediment samples had oil and grease. The concentration of heavy metals was
high in some of the sediment samples from the Palk Bay as compared to the
samples from other locations.

27. The presence of corals along the proposed ship canal alignment is
negligible. Occurrence of major group of biological resources like sea fan,
sponges, pearl, oysters, chunks, and holothurians at various sampling points
has been recorded. In general, the density of economically/ecologically
important species along the proposed alignment is not significant.

28. All the three group of prochordata organisms considered as the

connecting link between invertebrates and vertebrates via, hermichordata,
cephalochordata and unorchordata comprising 1, 6 and 59 species
respectively were recorded mostly around the islands of Gulf of Mannar.

29. There are 87 fish landing stations between the South of Point Calimere
and Pamban in the Palk Bay and 40 stations in the Gulf of Mannar between
Pamban and Tuticorin. Out of 600 varieties of fishes recorded in this area,
72 are commercially important. During 1992-1996, the fish production has
increased gradually from 55325 tones in 1992 to 102897 tones in 1996.

30. Non conventional fishing in the region is represented by pearl, chunk,

sea weeds, ornamental shells and holothurians. There has been a declining
trend in the production of these organisms as evidenced by the revenue
received by MPEDA.

31. Rare and endangered species of sea turtle, dolphin, sea cow, and whale
are recorded in the Gulf of Mannar and Palk Bay. The sea cow inhabitants
the shallow shore regions where grass occurs, while endangered animals
mostly prefer deep sea far away from the proposed alignment.

32. Several species of green algae (32), red algae (59) blue-green algae (3)
and sea grasses are recorded in the Gulf of Mannar and the Palk Bay. A few
of the 21 islands are reported to possess patches of mangroves predominated
by avicennia sp. and Rhizophora sp.

29
33. Most of the habitats of the sensitive biota viz corals, pearls, oysters,
chunks, dugong, holothurians, and marine algae are along the coast and
around the 21 islands and mostly away from the proposed canal alignment.

34. Based on an analysis and interpretation of IRS IC LISS-III satellite data

(Path 102 and Row 67 dated 19.05.1998 in CD ROM about 20 square
kilometers of Pamban island, barren sandy areas (35 sq, kms) between
Pamban island and coastal wedge of Mandapam and an area (329 sq.kms)
close to the National Highway (NH 49) from Rameshwaram to Madurai
have been identified as potential sites for disposal of dredged material.

35. There are no archaeologically significant structures along the proposed

canal alignment. However there exists a probability of
cultural/archaeological artifacts being encountered during the excavation of
the canal.

36. Along the coast of Gulf of Mannar and the Palk Bay there are 138
villages and towns spread over 5 districts. The socio-economic profile of the
fisherman in the villages of Gulf of Mannar coast is low and more than 40 %
of families are in debt. While the local population welcomes the project,
they have an apprehension that the construction of the canal might result in
reduction in their fishery income.

Impacts due to the Project

37. The locations of the proposed land based structures and the extent of
required construction are yet to be firmed up. Likewise the potential sites for
disposal of dredged material are yet to be decided. Hence, the pre-
construction phase impact due to land acquisition, resettlement and
rehabilitation of affected population as also compensation, if any, cannot be
assessed at this juncture.

38. As the proposed alignment is more than 5 kms away from the existing 21
National Marine Parks in the Gulf of Mannar, the marine biological
resources around the islands will not be affected to any significant level.

39. The existing level of primary productivity in the project area will remain
practically unaltered during the construction and operations phase of the ship
canal. There would not be any significant change in the water quality

30
including turbidity due to the proposed deployment of trailer suction hopper
dredgers and cutter section dredgers for capital and maintenance dredging.

40. Due to the dredging the bottom flora and fauna on an area approximately
25 sq.kms along the canal alignment will be lost permanently. This loss
however will be very insignificant compared to the total area of 10,500 sq,
km of the Gulf of Mannar Marine Biosphere Reserve.

41. During the construction of the land portion of the canal and the shore
based structures there will be considerable increase in the rail and road
traffic to and from the island for transportation of men, material, machinery
and equipment. These would lead to congestion of traffic and increased
levels of air and noise pollution with their associated impact on the public.

42. Due to the construction of the canal, the land access, now available to the
local fisher folk, to Dhanushkody area for traditional fishing will be
hindered unless alternative arrangements are made. The dredging and
shipping operations will have to be so regulated as to cause minimum
disturbance to the normal fishing activities.

43. Hydrodynamic modeling studies using Depth Integrated Velocity and

Solute Transport (DIVAST) model have shown that for the highest spring
tidal water conditions there will be no significant change in the magnitude
and direction of the current velocities along the proposed alignment due to
the construction of the canal.

44. During the construction and operation phases of the canal, the potential
sources of marine pollution are spillage of oil and grease, marine litter,
jetsam and flotsam including plastic bags, discarded articles of human use
from the sea borne vessels which will have to be controlled.

45. The canal may facilitate the movement of fishes and other biota from the
Bay of Bengal to the Indian Ocean and vice versa. By this way, the entry of
oceanic and alien species into the Palk Bay and the Gulf of Mannar as also
dispersal of endemic species outside the Palk Bay and Gulf of Mannar could
occur.

46. The canal will establish a continuous navigable sea route around the
peninsular coast within Indian territorial waters reduce shipping distance by
about 400 nautical miles and voyage time of 36 hours, as also the attendant

31
operating costs. The canal will become a valuable asset from national
defense and security points of view, enabling easier and quicker access
between the coasts.

47. Once the canal is in place, the clandestine and illegal activities in the
Palk Bay and Gulf of Mannar will be minimized due to constant vigilance
and regulation of movement of ships and vessels.

48. The project will provide employment opportunities and avenues of

additional income through establishment of small ancillary industries. The
project will also trigger development of coastal trade between the Ports of
the South and North of Rameshwaram consequently reducing the load and
congestion on railways and roadways.

49. The project will help save considerable foreign exchange through
reduction in oil import bill and generate revenue income from dues levied on
ships transiting the canal which will add to the national economy.

Analysis of Alternatives

50. Five alternative routes for the construction of Sethusamudram ship canal
were considered. Based on the evaluation of impacts of the project during
construction and operation phases, the alignment (4) suggested by the
Steering Committee near the Moonru Iruppu Chatram has been identified as
the best alternative (Refer: Fig.5.16) which will cause the least damage to
the biota and the environment.

This report is not the first of its kind. For 140 years many such reports were
gathering dust. N.Nandhivarman General Secretary Dravida Peravai in a
Memorandum personally handed over to Union Defense Minister George
Fernandes at Delhi on 22.02.2001 and published in World page of Dinamani
Tamil daily dated 23rd February 2001. In verbatim it is reproduced here:

Presenting last year's Union budget (2000-2001) The Honorable Union

Minister of Finance was kind enough to announce in the floor of Parliament
as: "Hon'ble members are aware that the Sethu Samudram Ship Canal
project has the potential of providing a shorter route between the East and
West Coast Ports. I am glad to inform that Government had approved the
undertaking of a detailed feasibility study and environmental impact

32
assessment of the project at a total cost of Rs 4.8 crore. I have made
necessary provision for this in the budget."

"Though it is in the manifesto of the National Democratic alliance and

almost all leaders of Tamil Nadu have demanded this project, nothing
emerges out of these promises, I am sorry to point out. The Union Finance
Minister's budgetary announcement was hailed as a great achievement
because after having been conceived 140 years back, there appeared to be
light at the end of the tunnel. But in spite of the recent promise made by the
Prime Minister, I am sorry to say, it is going to be a chase of the mirage. I,
as one of the Trustees to the Tuticorin Port Trust, the nodal agency to
implement this project had been raising this issue in the board meetings.
Quoting from the minutes of the Tuticorin Port Trust, it becomes evident
that the nodal agency had no information or plans, while once again election
platforms will hear promises galore from personalities. About 20 expert
committees have conducted detailed studies and came to the conclusion that
the scheme is technically feasible and economically viable.

Report of Commander A.D.Taylor of the Indian Marine, 1860 (Cost Rs 50

lakhs)
Report of the British Parliamentary Committee, 1862
Sir John Stuart, Chief assistant to the Surveyor General of Ceylonese
Government 1871
Harbour Engineer George Robertson Report 1872
Proposal by the South Indian Ship Canal Port and Coaling Station Ltd 1884
Proposal by the South Indian Railway Railway Company 1902
Report of the Harbour Engineer Sir Robert Brislow to Government of India
1921
Port Development scheme by Government of Madras 1947
Dr.Sir.A.Ramasamy Mudaliar Committee 1955
Dr.Nagendra Singh Committee 1963
C.V.Venkateswaran Committee 1965 (Rs 37 crore)
C.V.Venkateswaran Committee ( cost upgradation) 1971 ( Rs 53 crore)
Government of India Technical Committee confirms feasibility of the
scheme but shelves it due to cost factor 1980 ( Rs 110 crore)
Ministry of Shipping and Transport (Port Wing) Commitee 1981
H.R.Lakshminarayanan Committee 1983 ( Rs 282 crore)
Tamil Nadu Assembly passes unanimous resolution seeking implementation
of Sethu project 1986

33
Report of Pallavan Consultancy Services Ltd 1996 ( Rs 685 to Rs 1200
crores depending on the draft)

Now that it becomes clear that all these expert committees have found the
project feasible, the one constituted in the allocation made by the Union
Minister would have also have endorsed the same view.

Way back in 1860 when the Suez Canal was on the drawing board the
British Maritime pioneers had discovered that a shipping canal off
Rameshwaram coast will save approximately 36 hours of sailing time
between Madras and Tuticorin and reduce the distance by 434 nautical miles
i.e. about 803 kms. The latest in the series of studies is by the Tamil Nadu
Government owned Pallavan Consultancy Services, which says in its Report
on March 1996 that "the project can be completed at an estimated capital
cost (1996 price) of Rs 685 crore, Rs 760 crore, and Rs 1200 crore for a
canal of 30 feet, 31 feet, and 35 feet draft respectively. The payback period
is 17 years, and thereafter the benefit from the canal project would be Rs 47
crore in the first year and Rs 100 to Rs 120 crore in the subsequent years.
According to the 1996 ratings earnings of foreign exchange is estimated at
Rs 35 crore besides a reduction in fuel import by Rs 200 crore. The
approved Sethu Canal alignment envisages the creation of a 180 km long
and 200 meters wide canal to connect the Gulf of Mannar with the Palk
Straits off Rameshwaram in Tamil Nadu. But major dredging needs only to
be done only for about 15 kms on Mannar side and 12 kms on the Palk Bay
side since a natural shipping canal already exists there.

In view of the economic benefits that will generate prosperity to Southern

Tamil Nad, We urge the Union Government to give the go ahead or speed up
negotiations to hand over the project too private sector under B.O.T.Basis.
Nanguneri Free Trade Zone inaugurated recently is in the near vicinity.
Unless infrastructure projects of gigantic nature like Sethu Canal project are
taken up it will not achieve the required prosperity in our times.

We only urge what the NDA Manifesto promises, what the Prime Minister
promised to the people of Tamil Nadu in a Marumalarchi DMK rally at
Chennai, what has been incorporated in the previous years budget, what had
been announced by the Union Defense Minister in Rameshwaram and
Tuticorin on 6.1.1999 and in which as translator of his speech, I have little
memory left to recall that promise, to be fulfilled before the Assembly
elections ahead, as after having waited for 141 years for this project, the

34
people of Tamil Nadu must get it.". Thus Dravida Peravai urged the Union
Government.

Close on the heels of submission of this memorandum, the Union Budget

was presented for the year 2001-2002. Dinamani, Tamil daily in its front
page published the salient features of the budget. In the same front page it
pointed out that no funds were allocated for the Sethu Samudram project.
The funds allocated for the year 2000-2001were not utilized since a
comprehensive feasibility study for which those funds were earmarked was
not undertaken during that financial year. Dinamani recalled
Nandhivarman's meeting with Union Defence Minister previous week in this
connection and said as feared, in budget no funds were allocated for Sethu
samudram project. It also stated MDMK General Secretary Vaiko expressed
disappointment over these lacunae. Subsequently Junior Vikatan published a
story in its issue of 14 th March 2001.Then there were protests from all
quarters.

Meanwhile Srilanka suddenly announced that India and Srilanka will

undertake a feasibility study to construct a Hanuman Bridge across the Palk
straits. Srilankan Investment Corporation Chairperson Mr.Jayasoorya had
said that the feasibility is over and soon India and Srilanka are going to put
their signatures for green signaling this project at a cost of Rs.4000 crores.
According to that project a six way track for road and rail traffic was
mooted. The distance of 29.2 kilometers between Thalaimannar and
Dhanushkody will be connected by this bridge. Sweden and Denmark have a
sea bridge for 23 kilometers. If this bridge is completed it will beat that
record, Sri lanka proclaimed.

Dravida Peravai criticized this project as a BERLIN WALL ACROSS THE

PALK STRAITS PLANNED TO SEND SETHU SAMUDRAM PROJECT
FOR BURIAL. In Parliament the Rajya Sabha member from Pondicherry
Mr.C.P.Thirunavukkarasu (DMK) raised his voice against this project. The
Swadeshi Protection Movement organized protest in front of Memorial Hall
Chennai. MDMK General Secretary Vaiko wrote to the Center protesting
this plan.

After so much delay suddenly Tuticorin Port Trust on 1.09.2001 called for
global tender... The Notice Inviting Global Tender vide No
E(C)/F.42/8/2001/DB was published in all newspapers. Last date for receipt
was extended to December 15, 2001. The Chairman of Tuticorin Port Trust

35
said in the media that the feasibility study will be over by April 2002. In this
process the same National Environment Engineering Research Institute was
selected and it gave its Report. Acting on that report, National Democratic
Alliance government did not do anything.

2004 POLLS: Unprecedented victory of all 40 seats in Tamil Nadu and

Pondicherry by the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam led Alliance resulted in
United Progressive Alliance coming to power. The DMK nominee in the
cabinet holding shipping “Surface Transport portfolio Mr.T.R.Baalu used all
persuasive powers at his command to get a cabinet nod for this project.
Union Finance Minister P.Chidambaram too did his best to see this project
become a reality. And meanwhile in public hearings on this project
politically motivated vested interests plotted to raise hue and cry against this
project. To politically deny credit to DMK Ministers every effort was taken.
The Tuticorin Port Trust under the dynamic leadership of Chairman
Ragupathy answered all doubts raised by full page advertisements in many
papers. It deserves reproduction separately.

GOOD NEWS ATLAST

Ultimately CABINET CLEARS SETHU SAMUDRAM PROJECT.

Canal to reduce distance between East and west coast by 424 nautical miles,
travel by 30 hours

CABINET NOD FOR SETHU PROJECT

New Delhi May 19, 2005, the government today cleared the long delayed
Sethu Samudram Ship Canal project off Rameshwaram in Tamil Nadu that
would vastly reduce distance between East and west Coasts of India. This
2427.40 crore project cleared by the Cabinet Committee on Economic
Affairs may also tap the capital market through initial public offering or
private placements to raise Rs 226 crore.Announcing the CCEA decision
Finance Minister P.Chidambaram said a special purpose vehicle would be
set up for the implementation of the project that would create a navigational
canal. The canal will reduce distance of up to 424 nautical miles and sailing
time up to 30 hours for ships between the east and west coast. Elaborating
this project Chidambaram said it was a dream for over 100 years. With the
cabinet nod, the Government had fulfilled the CMP and budget promises, he
said.

36
“It opens up a channel that would enable ships to avoid going around
Srilanka". he said. Adding the channel would bring benefits as was the case
with Suez Canal and Panama Canal. The total project cost would be Rs
2,333 crore and financing cost Rs 194.40 crore. Chidambaram said adding
the SPV will raise the funds. He said the financial structure of the SPV
would be in the debt equity ration of 1:5:1The Finance Minister said the
Sethu samudram Corporation Limited will be the nodal agency for raising
resources and implementing the project through Tuticorin Port trust.
Elaborating on the Government contribution in the SPV, Chidambaram said
it would contribute Rs 495 crore, while the Shipping Corporation of India
and Tuticorin Port Trust will contribute Rs 50 crore each. The Dredging
Corporation of India along with Port Trusts of Chennai, Ennore, Vizag and
paradip will contribute Rs 30 crore each. The project has been hanging fire
for almost a century and a half, envisages linking the Arabian Sea with the
Bay of Bengal by dredging the shallow waters to the north of Srilanka,
thereby creating a navigable canal across the Gulf of Mannar, Palk Bay and
the Palk Straits.

These waters have hitherto not been navigable by cargo shipping and the
justification for the project is that it will save about 400 kilometers of sailing
distance between east and western coasts of India. An environmental impact
assessment report was prepared by the NEERI of Nagpur although it has
reportedly had no previous experience with marine projects of this nature.
(PTI)

Courtesy: New Indian Express May 20, 2005.

THANKS FOR ALL WHO MADE ANNA’S DREAM COME TRUE

This website thanks the Union Government headed by Mr.Manmohan Singh

for having given the clearance for Sethu Samudram project. Dravida Peravai
first thanks A.D.Taylor who mooted this suggestion in 1860. Dravida
Peravai thanks all parties of the United Democratic Alliance for having
stood for this project. Though many had strived the efforts of Kalaignar
M.Karunanithi, President DMK with all his national stature and political
clout led to the green signaling of this dream project. A special thanks to
him by all Tamil peoples.Marumalarchi DMK General Secretary Vaiko can
be equally singled out for praise for his tireless efforts. Dravida Peravai
thanks Comrade George Fernandes for the efforts he had taken during his

37
tenure, but which failed against the Srilankan lobby which was against this
project fearing it would eat into the profits of their country's harbours.
Dravida Peravai had a small role in the long drawn struggle for that project.
Our intention is to place that on record. Having said all, it should be stated
that Sethusamudram project was mentioned by Arignar Anna as one of the
1000 crore projects he spelt out for Tamil Nadu's prosperity as Opposition
Leader in the floor of the Assembly in 1957-1962.On becoming Chief
Minister of Tamil Nadu to urge the Union Government grant this project and
Salem Steel plant he gave a call to organize "Ezhucchi Naal "(Day of
Uprising). As Student DMK Convener N.Nandhivarman spoke at Senji Salai
thidal of Pondicherry at that time. Now whole Tamil Nadu feels happy that
Anna's dream is coming true.

[Published on 28-11-2007 In National Viewed 2579 times]

NEW SEAWAYS LIKE SETHUSAMUDRAM

The Suez Canal (1869) and Panama Canal (1915) Sethu Samudram Canal
(1860) and Tenth Degree Canal have been mooted to create short
navigational routes to bring prosperity to their respective regions and
countries. The French initiative to build Siene_Norde Canal is an example
for the keen interest evinced by developing countries to promote trade and
overall development. Dravida Peravai is bringing out certain historical facts
with the humble request to Union Minister T.R.Baalu to take an active
interest for the construction of Tenth Degree Canal, which can bring
prosperity to Andaman “Nicobar islands of India and Thailand, apart from
boosting bilateral trade.

You must go back to the pages of history to know that Thailand then known,
as Siam is an enemy country of the British and an ally of the Japan during
the World War II. On the conclusion of the Second World War II, one of the

38
last secretive acts performed by the colonial Government of India was the
signing of a Peace Treaty with Siam (Thailand). A Peace Treaty between her
Majesty’s Government and the Government of India on one hand and the
Kingdom of Siam on the other, on January 1, 1946 at the Government House
Singapore. The signatories were for the Britain Mr. Moberly Dening,
Political Adviser to Lord Louis Mount batten, for Government of India
Mr.M.S.Aney and for Siam (now Thailand) Prince Viwat Anajai Jaiyant,
Lt.General Phya Abhai Songgram and Nai Serm Vinichayakul. This treaty
contains 24 articles. Out of this Article 7 assumes importance in the context
of this letter.

Article 7: Siam undertakes to construct no canal linking the Indian Ocean

and the Gulf of Siam (i.e. across the Kra Isthmus) without British consent.
(Keesing’s Contemporary Archives 1946-48 Vol VI, p 7695).

This article had done great havoc to Indian shipping costing our nation
billions of extra money by way of fuel imports, in view of shelving of the
Tenth Degree Canal project with the imposition of a condition in this Peace
Treaty. It has also blocked the economic prosperity of Thailand and held up
the development process by half a century and more.

Hence Dravida Peravai urges the Government of India and Government of

Thailand to look into the unfavorable condition imposed by a colonial rule,
that too at the threshold of a defeat in Second World War II on Thailand, an
ally of Japan. It is in the interests of India and Thailand that a Canal be cut
across the Isthmus of Kra where the isthmus narrows to just 75 miles and to
develop this canal vigorously so that a detour of 1500 nautical miles down
the Malayan Coast via the Straits of Malacca and up the Gulf of Thailand in
the South China Sea is avoided. The proposed Tenth Degree Canal will be
an extension of the Tenth Degree channel in between Andaman and Nicobar
islands. The opening of Tenth Degree canal will result is saving millions of
tons of fuel foe world shipping. The Tenth Degree canal reduces the
importance of other major canals of the world namely Suez Canal and
Panama Canal. The Tenth Degree Canal would develop Andaman " Nicobar
Islands and bring prosperity to its economy. The opening of this canal will
also benefit the Indian East Coast Ports like Haldia, Paradeep,
Visakapatinam, Chennai and Tuticurin. There are more than 138 minor and
intermediary ports under the control of various state governments in India. If
Indian Government creates a National Seaway Authority and permits private
sector vessels to transport cargo and passengers connecting all Indian Ports,

39
these 138 minor and intermediary Ports, which mostly are inoperable, will
be busting with activity and the opening up of the Tenth Degree Canal by
Thailand will also improve its share in international trade and access to
Indian market. The completion of Sethu samudram Project along with the
Tenth Degree canal Project, will give a boost to Indian coastal shipping,
cargo shipping and major boost to Indian and Thailand’s economy. The
Tenth degree Canal will boost the economies of SAARC and ASEAN
nations. The savings in fuel will be so great for Japan, and it may fund this
project. India and China too would benefit with this Canal, and this will
boost bilateral trade. The Tenth Degree Canal reduces the cost of shipping
for the nations of the Pacific rim of Asia.

The Indian Governments vision to look towards East is laudable and the
Free Trade Agreements India signing with its neighbours is a right step in
the right direction, as world is moving towards regional blocks and common
markets, Dravida Peravai urges both India and Thailand to foster their
economic cooperation with speedy construction of Tenth Degree Canal as a
Indo Thailand joint venture to open a New Seaway to East. Economists like
Dominic Wilson and Roopa Purushothaman an alumnus of London School
of Economics have in their joint report predicted that Brazil, Russia, India
and China could become a powerful economic block like G-6 nations and
will race ahead of developed nations by 2050. It will be appropriate to have
a common Asian Market and A Common Asian currency for the resurgence
of the economies of the Asian block, and by launching schemes with
foresight both India and Thailand along with other neighbouring countries
must set the agenda for changing their economies into one common market
with a common currency.

The proposed land bridge between Thailand and Andaman is not necessary
and instead the cutting of a canal right east from Andaman will be the easiest
and best way to open a New Sea Way to South China Seas and EAST. India
at the moment is planning a transshipment harbour in Indira point, the last
island in our border, and this too could get a boost with the construction of
Tenth Degree canal. There may be some voices of concern in environment
angle, but such opposition will also be there for the land bridge mooted by
the Thailand Government .Sethu Samudram and 10 th Degree canal must
come. The 10 th degree canal can be named as Chozha canal.

Published on 06-11-2007 In National Viewed 2850 times |

40
11 Comments

Can you tell us how much economic prosperity the projects that you suggest
will bring? Stop posting bullshit grandiose plans without substantiating the
economic benefits claimed.

Ramarsetu - Comments as on- 07-11-2007

Ramarsetu - you are only degrading yourself by posting comments filled

with HATE. If you disagree with a view point, try to give your view point in
a decent manner. If you are unable to do that, please refrain from posting
any comment. I know it’s hard to contain, when you have a strong point to
make, but such comments don’t add any value other than creating an
IMPASSE for progress and snowballing into HATRED.

Pandyan - Comments as on- 07-11-2007

I am really fed up with what goes in our country. In the name of grand
development projects our politicians have squandered money. I am really
upset that my fellow countrymen do not even have the basic needs - food,
shelter, healthcare and education. Why don’t our politicians talk about how
to address them rather than come up with crazy ideas such as the “Chozha

41
canal”? If you read my rant about the poor track record of implementing of
such grandiose ideas here I hope you will agree:
http://tinyurl.com/359tml

Ramarsetu - Comments as on- 07-11-2007

Sethu canal controversy is motivated politically, it has to come at any cost

for the welfare of the country as a whole, after its implementation and the
successful completion of the project, if the country wants it could be
deepened and widened as in the case of Panama Canal project. I have not
heard of this ” tenth degree canal” if is true then the countries in the east,
right from Japan, china, Korea, Thailand, Burma, Bangladesh to India
should take serious steps and implement the scheme, which will do good for
all these countries together. It is high time for the Asian countries to join
hands together and improve the economic condition of their fellow
countrymen. Let better sense prevail.

Krishna Kumar - Comments as on- 07-11-2007

This is a hypothetical canal which will benefit no one. Even Thailand will
not allow it due to dis- membering the Isthmus of Kra. See the distances:
Chennai-Kra (thru 10 d channel) -Brunai is 1700 & Chennai-Malacca-
Brunei is 2000 nm. Southern tip of S Lanka, (Dindra head) - Kra- Brunei is
1700 & Dondra-Malacca-Brunai is 1800 nm. What are we talking about
millions of tons of fuel? Suez Canal saves 3 and Panama saves 6 weeks of
sailing time. Formidable savings! Can we compare that with this miniscule
advantage we may derive? There is no need of making 10 degree channel- it
is already there. Wide and deep, separating the Andaman and Nicobar group
of islands. The Kra is also narrow at 10 degree- about 120 km. That does not
mean we start digging. What are we achieving? It is not a joke of digging a
canal thru land. See the terrain in the Google Earth. Even Sethusamuthiram
was scientifically rejected by the world’s most renowned marine civil
engineer (of his time) Sir Robert Bristow. He has said that if we make a
canal in this area, the maintenance dredging will be prohibitive that it will
not be economically viable. We are stealing from our next generations (for
petty politics) what the nature had carefully preserved in the environment
over centuries!

GVKU - Comments as on- 07-11-2007

42
The Convener of National Democratic Alliance George Fernandes and Atal
Bihari Vajpayee added two projects in the NDA manifesto. I, as leader of an
associate party of Samata party and special invitee to its National Executive
acted as catalyst for these getting into the manifesto. Thiru Atal Bihari
Vajpayee assigned Sethucanal work to Comrade George Fernandes, who
tirelessly studied the project and on 6.1.1999 announced the launch of the
then 138 year dream in Socialist Conference at Tuticurin and later I was
made trustee of Tuticurin Port for 2 years when Thiru.Nitish Kumar was
Union Surface Transport Minister.

Having launched Sethusamudram project NDA allocated 4 crores for

feasibility study. It was not utilized that financial year. In Next year budget
no funds was allocated. So my comment came below the budget in full in
front page of Dinamani with Delhi date line. In Junior Vikatan “Yaarukum
Aarvamillai” interview of mine appeared. So NDA launched the project
called for global tender to do feasibility study but settled for NEERI which
had earlier done preliminary survey. This was during Rajnath Singh’s tenure
as Union Surface Transport Minister. No where these people thought that
they should study whether a so called Ram’s bridge existed, because they
know it is a natural formation. The 10 th degree canal was presented to
Union Minister of State of External Affairs Thiru.Digvijay Singh at South
Block. He lauded this project.
It was mailed to Thailand Prime Minister. About our memorandum center
page all edition news appeared in Dinamani. We discussed this canal with
Planning Commission Member Dr.S.B.Gupta, who was also in some

43
committee under PMO where this was discussed during Atalji’s time.NDA
could not pursue these projects in sincerity.

The river interlinking mooted decades ago by Congress remained in cold

storage. NDA made noises about implementing it. They did not proceed
further. So I went to Supreme Court seeking directions. That details in link
below.http://www.boloji.com/environment/22.htm

Supreme Court bench rejected my writ. Then I wrote in New Times

Observer which reached Dr.A.P.J.abdul Kalam, who stressed this in
republican day speech. Later some Delhi lawyer filed a writ before same
bench that rejected my writ, which is now pending before Supreme Court of
India.

Now I am happy few mails with constructive criticism are appearing here.
The man who sends hate mails is blind to the truth that never DK occupied
any political office. If he had to attack he should have attacked DMK or
AIADMK which were in power. His hatred towards social reformer Periyar
EVR blinds his vision. He says River interlinking is DMK project. The type
of criticism GVKU had added are the ones that a democrat will welcome,
though I beg to differ with him.

Nandhivarman - Comments as on- 08-11-2007

It is all fine that you claim credit for all the visionary projects. Now tell us in
hard numbers how much profit India will realize and when? As a DK
follower who hates Hindus and their practices you can’t expect much love
from the majority of population. Stop cribbing about hate mails. All I have
raised are valid criticism of your ideologies and hypocrisy. You haven’t
been able to prove that any of them were invalid. In my view DK politicians
include DMK and AIADMK members who subscribe to DK’s views on
bashing Hinduism.

Ramarsetu - Comments as on- 08-11-2007

Dear brothers,
Article on economics of SSCP.
http://www.epw.org.in/epw/uploads/articles/10823.pdf Nalasethu -
Comments as on- 09-11-2007

44
Excellent article which summarizes that the project benefits are
overestimated and costs are underestimated grossly!
Thanks Nalasethu.

Ramarsetu - Comments as on- 10-11-2007

THE AUTHOR OF THE BOOK TITLED ” SEALANES OF

COMMERCE :SECURITY IN ASIA PACIFIC Prof Quigsang says in the
sea route from Bay of Bengal to Indian Ocean and then to South China seas
at the moment daily 275 ships are traveling both ways. By 2010 the traffic
will increase by three fold. Then there will be traffic congestion in Malacca
Straits. To reduce that congestion 10 th degree canal will be a step well
thought much before crisis deepens. Hence all must think of promoting this
idea.

Nandhivarman - Comments as on- 11-11-2007

Dear brothers,
Please follow the link for annual traffic in Indian ports.
http://www.ipa.nic.in/oper3e_2006.htm

Nalasethu - Comments as on- 12-11-2007

45
Plundering ECR environment for Power Plants
Published on 10-11-2007 In National Viewed 3929 times

The need for power should not be met at the cost of plundering our
environment in East Coast Road. During the visit of Union Power Minister
Shusil Kumar Shinde it was announced that 2 power plants would be set up
closer to East Coast Road. Immediately Dravida Peravai sent a detailed
memorandum to the Union Minister for Power. Later Dr.S.Ramdass, founder
of PMK protested. Thereafter the Tamil Nadu Power Minister Arcot
N.Veerasamy had gone on record that Cheyyur Thermal power plant will be
dropped but Marakanam project will take off. In this background to awaken
the Union Government to evolve a Power Policy keeping in mind of global
initiatives in renewable energy quest, Dravida Peravai memorandum dated
10 th September 2007 is given below in verbatim.

Our objections to the 2 proposed Mega Thermal Power Projects off East
Coast Road

During your recent visit you had announced that the Union Government will
be sending an official team to Tamilnadu to study the possibility of setting
up one more ultra mega power project, as reported in the media. Though we
agree on the need to enhance our power capacity it should not be at the cost
of great human sufferings uprooting people practicising traditional
professions practiced beyond 2000 years. In your interview you had
mentioned that Tamilnadu Power Minister Thiru.Arcot N.Veerasamy had
suggested Marakanam for setting up of 4000 MW capacity ultra mega power
project. The Tamilnadu Power Minister had stated that Center had already
finalized Cheyyur as the site of one mega power project. We are here
opposing the 2-mega power projects and our views are submitted for your
perusal.

An attempt was made by National Thermal Power Corporation in 1999 to set

up a power plant in Cheyyur when Thiru.Rangarajan Kumaramangalam was
Union Minister of Power. The Hindu, a national daily with concern for
people alerted people and rulers on Sunday March 21, 1999 issue in a front

46
page story by Thiru.Mukund Padmanabhan under the heading: Proposed
Power Plant will be in a Lagoon. “The 3000 acres to be made available to
NPTC in five villages in the Cheyyur area lie in low lying area into which
there is copious flow of rainwater from the surrounding uplands and a little
seawater ingress. The picturesque water body which attracts a large number
of birds and is used for fishing acts as storm water run off for an estimated
42 villages in Cheyyur area” wrote Thiru Mukund Padmanabhan a senior
journalist in The Hindu.

Dravida Peravai heeded to the warning signals unleashed by Thiru.Mukund

Padmanabhan and wrote to the Indian Prime Minister Thiru.Atal Bihari
Vajpayee on April 2 of 1999.Dravida Peravai having been admitted as
associate party of Samata party and which remained a special invitee to its
National Executive ever since 1997 December, had the moral support of
Comrade George Fernandes. Hence our memorandum did in fact act as an
eye opener. In our memorandum dated April 2 of 1999, we had urged upon
the Union Government to adopt the internationally practiced precautionary
principle in preventing pollution.” The term precautionary principle was
raised by the German delegation at first North Sea Conference in 1984 when
faced with the problem of dealing with one of the world’s most
contaminated seas. Since then the approach had been adopted by a number
of regulatory regimes including Oslo and Paris Commissions (1989), The
UNEP Governing Council (1989), Nordic Council (1989), The Bergen
Declaration (1990), The London Convention (1991), The Bamako
Convention (1991) The Barcelona Convention (1991) and The UNEP Rio
UNCED Declaration (1992).

On September 8, 2007-Asia-Pacific leaders agreed and adopted a "long-term

aspiration goal" to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the region in support
of the U.N global efforts, announced Australian Prime Minister John
Howard. Under the Sydney Declaration on Climate Change, Energy Security
and Clean Development, the goals are to reduce energy intensity by at least
25 percent by 2030 from the 2005 level, and to increase forest cover in the
region by at least 20 million hectares of all types of forests by 2020. The
non-binding numerical targets indicate that APEC leaders wish to throw
their political muscle behind an international push to avert the worst
consequences of a warming planet. This is the first year that leaders from the
21 APEC member economies have included climate change discussions in
their annual summit.

47
While other countries follow precautionary principle in India we neither
have the intention nor the political will to arrest pollution of our seas, rivers
and water bodies. While Salman Khan’s are arrested for single killings, in
Cheyyur and Marakanam all the migratory birds to these water bodies have
to loose their natural habitat and the offenders will go scot-free.

LET US HAVE A LOOK AT THE PROBLEMS FACED BY OTHER

COUNTRIES THAT HAVE OPTED FOR THERMAL POWER PLANTS:

Quoting China Daily news [Sept 9-2007] “ China’s environmental watchdog

warned in Beijing that booming thermal power plants may worsen China's
acid rain pollution if their sulfur dioxide emission is not well controlled. Pan
Yue, vice-director of the State Environmental Protection Administration
(SEPA), made the remark when reporting to the press the crackdown against
the Guiyang thermal power plant in the southwestern province of Guizhou,
which had put the newly built power set into use without the
desulphurization equipment.

"Thermal power plants discharge a large proportion of the country's total

sulfur dioxide emission. If their emissions are not well controlled, the acid
rain pollution will probably worsen, “Pan said. Although China's power
production and generation capacity reached the second place of the world by
the end of 2003, they still cannot satisfy the soaring economy's appetite for
energy. Reportedly China will suffer from severe power shortage this
summer. There are already 24 provinces and municipalities, which set limits
on industrial and civil use of electricity. Thermal power plants, accounting
for 74 percent of total power supply, spring up to fill the gap.

Exhaust gas discharged by thermal power plants, which are based on coal
burning, contains abundant sulfur dioxide a chemical causing acid rain.
Statistics show that China's annual sulfur dioxide emission, of which thermal
power emission makes up 34.6 percent, exceeds the maximum of
environmental capacity by 80 percent. The resulting acid rain costs annual
loss of 110 billion Yuan (US$13.3 billion), two or three percent of the
annual Gross Domestic Production. China's laws and regulations state that
the desulphurization equipment must be designed, built, and put into
operation simultaneously with the power sets. Unfortunately, most investors
are too eager for instant profits to stick to the rule, according to Pan. SEPA
updated the environmental standards for thermal power plants in March,
which tightens their sulfur dioxide emission. SEPA also demands all plants

48
install an exhaust gas monitoring system, which could be connected to
SEPA's central server. To reduce the thermal power sulfur dioxide emission
to 7.84 billion tons in 2020, 80 percent of thermal power plants have to set
up the desulphurization equipment before 2005. Besides, SEPA will enforce
economic policies including implementing an emission licensing system,
add desulphurization cost to the power price and raise the sulfur dioxide
emission fee.

CHINA FACES A PROBLEM AND IT HAS ACTED TO CONTAIN

POLLUTION DO WE IN INDIA, OR DO OUR COMMUNIST
COMRADES DO NECESSARY HOMEWORK TO OPPOSE THERMAL
POWER PLANTS? After all China shows the way and it is not America,
hence they need not feel embarrassed to oppose thermal power plants and
the pollution unleashed by such plants. In 1997 the E.U.-15 member states
set themselves the task of doubling Europe’s renewable energy sources from
6 percent to 12 percent by 2010. A decade later, even though the
contribution from renewable sources had increased in absolute terms by 55
percent, the E.U.’s new Renewable Energy Roadmap admitted that not only
was 12 percent unfeasible, but a figure well below 10 percent was more
realistic. By January 2007, the original E.U.-15 member states (the E.U. had
expanded to 27 states by then) had actually achieved a figure of only 6.4
percent from renewable sources. So when the E.U. summit in March 2007
upped the renewable energy sources target to 20 percent by 2020, its
acknowledgment that the target would prove “challenging” was viewed by
most energy insiders as something of a gross understatement. The Roadmap
stated that Europe’s renewable share was growing too slowly. To speed
things up, a plan was devised for the main sectors: electricity bio-fuels for
transport, and heating and cooling. The Roadmap sees electricity as the key
sector for producing genuine progress. It argues that if all of the 27 E.U.
member states made their national quotas on renewable for 2010 in this
sector, the proportion of electricity consumption from renewable would be
21 percent. But only nine E.U. member states – Denmark, Germany,
Finland, Hungary, Ireland, Luxembourg, Spain, Sweden, and the
Netherlands – are in fact on track. The reality is that unless the present
trends change, the E.U. will achieve a target approaching at best 19 percent.
IN INDIA: “In Jharkhand about 9,000 tones of fly ash is being generated
everyday from the coal based thermal power plants with present generation
of about 1500 MW. Fortunately, the state is utilizing over fifty present of the
fly ash through environmentally sound techniques such as abandoned mine
reclamation, Cement Manufacturing, Brick manufacturing etc. Damodar

49
valley Corporation is reclaiming Central Coalfield Limited (CCL)
abandoned mine using its pond ash, Tata Power at Jhamshedpur is feeding
all its fly ash to Lafarge Cement, ACC and other cement plants. Jharkhand
State Pollution Control Board has taken a lead in the utilization of fly ash in
the Sate with the co-operation of Thermal Power Plants, Mining Industries,
Cement Industries, Brick manufacture etc” If in 1500 MW Thermal power
plant 9000 tones of fly ash is generated in Jharkand as per Jharkand
Pollution Control Board’s statistics, In Cheyyur 4000 MW mega power
plant will generate 36,000 tones of fly ash polluting the entire ECR road,
about which Deepa H.Ramakrishnan of The Hindu wrote as The Road
Beckons [Metro plus Sept 8 of 2007]. The Road Stinks may be her article if
she travels next year in same ECR Road. The Swedish Energy System: Role
Model for India Electricity production in Sweden is basically fossil-free.
Approximately half of the electricity production comes from hydropower
and the remainder is provided by nuclear power. Swedish scientists were
among the first to discover the effects of acid rain; this was a focal point in
the first UN Environmental Conference in Stockholm in 1972, twenty years
before the following conference in Rio de Janeiro in 1992. Swedish industry
was also among early world pioneers in demonstrating the first technological
solutions for flue gas desulphurization. We live in a world which is known
now as global village. If we fail to follow the footsteps of pioneers and opt
for outdated un clean technologies, it is a national shame to the genius of
India. Our Planning Commission will have hundreds of committee reports
arguing all good things on earth but all remain in paper and only lip service
is rendered. Sweden shows the way and our planners will have all blueprints
for future ready in their shelves but our Ministers opt for unclean
technologies, may be because of other considerations. DROP CHEYYUR –
MARAKANAM THERMAL POWER PROJECTS Dravida Peravai urges
the Government of India to have a rethink on starting many more thermal
power plants, and we oppose the proposed Cheyyur and Marakanam power
projects on the following grounds. · The formal classification in the land
registry-adangal records declare that the 2888.06 acres meant for the project
is an area comprising salt puramboke and grazing land. In reality it is a
waterbody.Survey number 352 at Mudaliarkuppam [274.12 acres] and
Survey number 359[ 103.32 acres] under Panaiyur villages where National
Thermal Power Corporation plans to have the fly ash disposal plant and
main site are in fact are water bodies. We are aware of how fly ash is
disposed in Ennore Thermal Power Plant and how Pulicut Lake has become
dead lake with pollution and waste dumping. Similar fate will befall
Kaluveli Tank.· National Thermal Power Corporation in 1999 short listed 4

50
sites Kovalam near Chennai, Mahabalipuram, Cheyyur and a site beyond
Cuddalore. Two days ago a private company which was planning to set up a
Power Project near Cuddalore had to face the people’s anger when the
District Collector of Cuddalore convened a consultative meeting. Police lathi
charged and arrested many villagers of Thiagavalli near Cuddalore in
September 2007.TamilNadu electricity Minister Arcot Veerasamy is
uprooting people when their traditional dwellings in order to fill his personal
overflowing coffers, people have started to gossip about the fortunes
made.Kovalam is a Beach, Mahabalipuram a tourist spot of historical
antiquity.Cheyyur where NPTC took the first step, they were halted by our
agitations. Now Cheyyur has become once again the target of evil eyes
which want to spoil the natural beauty of our coast. Marakanam, an ancient
Port known then as Eyilpattinam is the centre of salt pans providing
livelihood for thousands for centuries.Dravida Peravai does not see any valid
argument for shifting the focus from tourism promotion exploiting the
nature’s bounty of our beaches to thermal power generation and converting
water bodies as dumping grounds of waste and polluting the air apart from
driving salt pan workers out of jobs.· The argument advanced by Tamilnadu
Electricity Minister to bring coal from Orissa by ships, Marakanam harbour
will be of use, is just wishful thinking. Apart from 12 major ports which are
governed by Major Port Trusts Act, none of the 138 minor or intermediary
ports under the control of various governments are functioning ports. Neither
they are economical, viable, profitable for public utility. All minor ports
with the exception of minor ports under Gujarat Maritime Board remain
monuments of wasteful expenditure. On the way to Chennai in ECR Road
we can see Cyclone Shelters in depilated conditions, which are another
monument of wasteful expenditure. There had been no plan on how to use
these shelters apart from cyclone times; hence they remain without
maintenance and use. To develop Marakanam as Port just to bring coal will
also meet the same fate. All moneys pumped into development of minor
ports by various state governments have led to criminal and wasteful
expenditure. This is because the Union Government has no national policy
to reduce the traffic congestion in our surface transport. We have the longest
coast in east and west of our peninsula. If only the Union Government had
heeded to various memorandums/press statements/port trust minutes,
wherein Dravida Peravai had mentioned and argued the need to create a
National Seaway Authority and frame policies for cargo/passenger ferries
interconnecting these minor ports, travel in roads would be eased in
congestion. Only on the event of shifting focus from lorry and rail cargo
carrying to carrying cargo by ships and only when inducing people to travel

51
by ships with well connected chain between all minor ports of the country,
then ventures like developing Marakanam Port will become profitable.
Focus on utilizing our ports for people’s usage is missing but focus is on
wasting money on port development. Can Government of India order a study
on the investments made by various State Governments in the name of
developing minor ports and the yields from such investments? If such a
probe is made you can find all moneys have created assets which yield
nothing draining the public exchequer.· We understand that there prevails a
policy wherein the power generating project need not be situated in states
where power is consumed but states can set up power projects near coal
mines and the power can be routed through the national grid to reach the
beneficiary state.Puducherry Government on August 15 th media release had
announced about a coal block allotted in Orissa.We presume Puducherry
Government will put up the project in Orissa as per this new policy of the
Center. Our question is while Puducherry can set precedent why should not
Tamilnadu follow that instead of ferrying coal from Orissa to Marakanam
and setting up power projects off ECR road which was meant to promote
tourism and not pollution. Dravida Peravai has reservations about
Puducherry Government not selecting big industrial houses in India or going
for cleaner technologies in alliance with multinationals but opting for
Dr.Jagathratchagan’s enterprise which has no expertise in power sector as its
partner in the Rs7500 crore mega power projects, and we will come out in
detail soon on this. Throwing dalits and fishermen out of their traditional
homes and professions in Marakanam_Cheyyur belt by mega projects which
have become outmoded in western countries, is a crime against fellow
human beings, the citizens of India, who are the real masters as per the
lexicon of democracy.

N.Nandhivarman General Secretary Dravida Peravai

1 Comment

Is this power plant still coming up in Mudaliyarkuppam or has it been

scrapped? We do not hear much about it in the news these days... Also there
is a rumour that the NIOT (National Institute of Ocean Technology) is
planning to acquire land here to set up a de-salination plant... Is this true?

preetha01 - Comments as on- 13-12-2007

52
[This article made Mrs.Jesurathinam of Coastal Action Network who had
difference of opinion with me on Sethusamudram, invite to a consultative
meeting against few power plants coming up in Nagapattinam District of
Tamilnadu in 2009. My memorandum to the District Collector follows:]

UNEARTH ANCIENT POOMPUHAR: PROMOTE CULTURAL

TOURISM BUT STALL POLLUTING POWER PLANTS

TheCollector of Nagapattinam District 23.09.2009

Tamilnadu

Respected Collector

Subject: Historical and Environmental reasons cited to oppose the proposed

Thermal Power plant regarding

We appreciate the District Collector of Nagapattinam for calling for this

public enquiry. Our views will be in Tamil’s historical interest and the
traditional rights of indigenous communities like fishermen and farmers of
Tamilnadu.

Pichavaram to Kodikarai is highly important area for unearthing our

civilization since ancient harbours existed in this belt with hidden heritage at
sea. It needs to be subjected to researches highly important for marine
archaeology and coastal archaeology.

Already 250 km out of 1076 km of Tamilnadu coast is without fishermen.

The need for preserving the catamaran people and their traditional
knowledge is important. Hence all development projects must aim at
protecting indigenous communities like fishermen and farmers and should
not uproot them from where for centuries they made a livelihood. In fact
more assistance to these communities with new scientific equipments would

53
enable them to earn more foreign exchange to our country’s coffers than
offering soaps at the cost of public exchequer to projects of plunder.
Generating alternative renewable energy like ocean thermal energy, ocean
tidal energy will be more helpful. Developed countries have bid adieu to
thermal power. Coal bearing ships and conveyer arrangement will be hazard
for the coastal area and will stimulate global warming through carbon
discharge. The waste generated from plant will create pollution at sea
.Thoothukudi lost its pearl culture of the past cultural heritage by the non
ocean oriented people. Bearing these in mind we urge the Government of
Tamilnadu to stall all thermal power projects coming up in Nagapattinam
District, more particularly the one near Poompuhar.

▼ We all are aware that apart from the Indus Valley excavations, equally
important cities of our ancient civilization could not so far be unearthed in
South India due to our own lethargy. We have stone inscriptions, copper
plates and burial pots and this is not sufficient to establish the greatness of
our past. Our literary evidences on submergence of ancient Tamil land
illuminate us about our past but western scholars look for more scientific
proof. Hence there is a need for undersea-archaeological search to find out
our roots. No other ethnic group of Earth possesses so much literary
evidences but remains lazy to go to the submerged cities of their ancient
land. Though we have a place named as Poompuhar where Dr.Kalaignar
M.Karunanithi during his rule erected monuments to recapture the past, it
could only serve as tourist spot and could not satiate a researcher’s quest to
unravel a hidden city of our ancient civilization beneath the bowels of our
sea in Bay of Bengal. We all know about the changes that continuously
occur and the ancient Port City of Chozha Empire is not the Poompuhar of
our times, but it is within the sea nearer or far to current Poompuhar’s coast.

▼ Graham Hancock wrote many books out of which Underworld: The

Mysterious Origins of Civilization by Crown Publishers, New York 2002
containing 760 pages ISBN 1400046122 hardback priced $ 27.50 is of
relevance to our Poompuhar. He undertook marine archaeology in 2002
and brought out as reported in Dinamani that a city with 9500 year old
civilization remains hidden off coast of Poompuhar. [Dinamani news
clipping enclosed] His earlier books Fingerprints of the Gods and Heaven’s
Mirror had mentioned about his findings. But in this latest book, he lays out
evidence “based on modern scientific research, comparative mythology,
religious and spiritual observances, first hand diving exploration of
underwater megalithic structures and ancient maps to demonstrate the

54
likelihood that a technically advanced civilization unrecognized by modern
science capable of navigating the globe and with a profound understanding
of architecture and building existed and was washed out by global flooding”.

▼Inundation maps created by Dr.Glen Milne of Durham University shows

vast tracts of mostly coastal land which were submerged by three waves of
cataclysmic flooding between 17,000 and 8000 years ago. Nearly 5 percent
of Earth’s surface or 25 million square kilometers of land stands submerged.
These maps and other sources made Graham Hancock to set his foot in
Tamilnadu. Graham Hancock used scuba diving and found many artifacts
and evidences roughly 2000 pieces which he displayed in Bangalore
exhibition, as per media reports of the day. Graham Hancock had updated
Tamil history to 9500 years old.

▼We like parrots were repeating 2000 years as time limit of our ancient
civilization, and when Graham Hancock updated Tamil history with fresh
facts, the Government of Tamilnadu which is going to celebrate World
Tamil Conference, must take pains to employ more scuba divers and marine
archaeologists to find out about our Kaveripoompattinam. We should honour
Graham Hancock in that Conference.

▼The coast or sea near Poompuhar should not be plundered and kept free
from industrialization if our ancient glory brought out powerfully by
Dr.Kalaignar had to be proven scientifically. Mr.Graham Hancock
investigated about our “Kumari Kandam, an anti-diluvia civilization said
to have existed thousands of years ago around South India. It is believed
to have been a greater center of learning with magnificent academies
which may have left a legacy of cartographic and astronomical knowledge
which exists today in the ancient Indian texts. Interestingly the author
spoke to local fishermen who described often diving to free their nets
caught on underwater temples and columns, pyramidal pagodas and
buildings with doorways”.

▼Coinciding to our Poompuhar, in Gulf of Cambay to city which is 7500

years old was found but media highlighted that and did not do justice to
Poompuhar’s findings. If a scientist within few weeks with the help of
National Institute of Oceanography could bring out so many artifacts, is it
not the duty of Tamilnadu Chief Minister Dr.Kalaignar M.Karunanithi who
instilled in our hearts the greatness of Poompuhar by his powerful pen to
employ all scientists, marine archaeologists, scuba divers, and constitute a

55
multi disciplinary State-Sponsored Task Force under Anna University and
Tamil University of Thanjavur to explore our exclusive economic zone and
our territorial waters in Bay of Bengal at least to begin with to pick up the
thread from where Mr. Graham Hancock left in 2002.

▼▼ Dravida Peravai hence appeals to the District Collector of

Nagapattinam in the public hearing on Public Hearing on the proposed
2x500 MW Coal Based Power Plant by M/s. PEL Power Ltd to stop this
power project. Allowing such plants to be set up here with whatever
technology will disrupt the scientific and historical research that is needed to
unearth our past beneath Bay of Bengal off Poompuhar. We are enclosing a
map which shows how much land near our coast had been submerged. This
is an indication of how much more land would have been submerged for
centuries running into thousands of years back. My article Save the Coast in
New Indian Express is enclosed. Letting out effluents or dumping waste into
rivers and seas had been going on unabated though technically they will
promise to use clean technology and blinded by that promise our
environmental agencies will give them clearance. First of all we should bear
in mind what all technology we get is outmoded and unwanted in developed
countries, hence such technologies are dumped on developing countries like
India. If we are really a super power we should follow the Swedish
precedent to completely abandon thermal power projects to save its
environment. Here it is not only to save our environment but also to prove to
the world we are an ancient civilization, we need to keep Poompuhar coast
and seas close to Poompuhar free from industrial garbage and litter.

▼Coal based power projects are being set up in Tamilnadu coast. There
seems to be a policy which permits setting up of power plants near coal
mines, so that through National Power grid equivalent quantum of power
can reach the power seeking State. Under this policy a current Union
Minister of State before he came to power got a Coal Block allotted in
Orissa.In this project of a Tamilnadu politician Puducherry Government’s
PIPDIC is a partner. This joint venture plans to set up power project in
Orissa to generate power and pass on to the grid so that Puducherry
Government will get power without polluting the Union Territory of
Puducherry. If a tiny state like Puducherry could follow this route, what
compulsion prevails for Tamilnadu to bring coal all the way by ships to
set up a power plant in the Nagapattinam coast that too near ancient
Port city of Poompuhar?

56
▼ There seems to be a race to set up more and more ports without planning
what products could be brought in or exported from these ports. The
Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee when he visited
Kanyakumari announced a scheme called Sagar Mala, which means
Garland of the Seas. In fact I mooted the suggestion to create a National
Seaway on the lines of National Highways to introduce ship connectivity to
all the 138 minor or intermediary ports to bring inland cargo that was
coming by Lorries and to ferry passengers. This suggestion through
Planning Commission reached then Prime Minister who wanted to make use
of existing infrastructure to connect all ports in Indian coast. At that time
only Gujarat particularly Gujarat Maritime Board was making good use of
its minor ports. Tamilnadu which launched a Poompuhar Shipping
Corporation under DMK rule lost the race by making its vessels ferry
coal and did not think of diverting cargo and passengers from road use
to sea lanes. Roads could be re-laid year by year but traffic congestion, loss
of lives, making more and more lanes, land acquisition etc could be avoided
if our existing ports could be connected under the Sagar mala scheme of
Vajpayee. Instead opening new ports with no cargo to handle breeds even
sand smuggling to Maldives which was caught red handed by you, the
Hon’ble Collector. Hence we Dravida Peravai, a splinter of DMK but with
great regard for Dr.Kalaignar in view of personal friendship undiminished
by parting of ways, urge Nagapattinam to accord to priority to unearth our
ancient city of Kaveripoompattinam and keep this coast free from polluting
industrialization.

▼Interestingly the National Institute of Oceanography , Chennai had

announced that its scientists in collaboration with Experimental Design
Bureau of Oceanological Engineering of the Russian Academy of Sciences
had developed a vehicle named ROSUB 6000 capable of exploring the
ocean up to a depth of 6 kilometers and can be remotely operated. Though
we have to go further deep not only off the coast of Poompuhar but also
even beyond our exclusive economic zone, this vehicle could be used to
gather further evidences on our submerged Port City of Poompuhar.

▼International Seabed Authority has allocated 150,000 square kilometers of

seabed in the Indian Ocean to India for exploration of cobalt, manganese,
nickel and copper which are in the form of polymetalic nodules. Well
Government of India will be happily exploring Indian Ocean for minerals
and metals but let Government of Tamilnadu explore Indian Ocean to
discover the lost continent of Kumari and the Port Cities of Chera, Chozha

57
and Pandyas, including the ancient capitals of Thonmadurai and
Kavadapuram which our literature speaks.

With Regards
Yours sincerely

N.Nandhivarman
General Secretary Dravida Peravai

EMERGENCE OF NEW NATION STATES AND

TAMIL EELAM
Published on 17-06-2008 In World Viewed 471 times

The newly launched Tamil literary monthly e-magazine carries an article by

N. Nandhivarman on the global scenario of various independent nations
seeking U.N.recognition

Comments 1 Comment

Hearty Congratulations! A high quality factual magazine is need of the hour.

It is sad that even today we have to tell the so called educated what is the
truth because so much in historical and literary terms are created lies. There
are so many words that are of Tamil origin but commonly believed to be of
Sanskrit origin. We have to bring together our other Dravidian brothers as
historical compatriots rather than competitive linguists.
As for Thamil Eelam, after years of Gandhian struggle and a fanatic
Buddhist monks un compromising beliefs, there is no other way but to go
their own way. If the Sinhalese will let them the Tamils can make even their
lives better!

58
Ilangovan - Comments as on- 20-06-2008

Junior Vikatan opens the Pandora's Box of MGR

Published on 24-12-2007 In National Viewed 4733 times

Junior Vikatan magazine opens The Pandora’s box on MGR The December
26 th dated issue of Tamil investigative bi weekly Junior Vikatan had carried
a wrapper story titled “ What happened on December 24 th 1987 early
morning in MGR’s house? The journal carries an interview by
M.G.Ramachandran’s brother M.G.Chakrapani’s son M.G.C.Sukumar. His
sister Leelavathy donated her kidney when M.G.Ramachandran had kidney
failure. But this fact was suppressed and did not reach the knowledge of
M.G.Ramachandran till Valampuri John, a former M.P wrote a poem on the
sacrifice made by Leelalavathy. After reading the poem MGR came to know
and through his cabinet colleague Panruti S.Ramachandran got it confirmed,
the interview mentions.

Panruti S.Ramachandran is my close and respected friend from 1967, when

he won the first election to Tamilnadu Assembly. During 1974 assembly
polls to Pondicherry Panruti S.Ramachandran, a cabinet minister under

59
Kalaignar M.Karunanithi’s government was deputed by the DMK high
command to coordinate with me, the then Propaganda Secretary of DMK in
charge of 1974 election campaign nominated by official party notification by
then General Secretary of DMK Navalar R.Neduncezhian. Currently Panruti
S.Ramachandran is the Chairman of Desiya Murpokku Dravida Kazhagam
led by Actor Vijayakanth. Panruti.S.Ramachandran brought out an English
book compiling all the Parliamentary speeches of Aringnar Anna, which till
date is the only initiative in compiling collected works of Aringnar Anna.
M.G.Ramachandran had immense faith in Panruti S.Ramachandran, who
was deputed to speak in United Nations on the Tamil Eelam issue. Having
said all about the stature of Panruti S.Ramachandran, I beg to him to unravel
the mysteries surrounding the M.

M.G.Ramachandran’s demise, the conspiracy to hijack his hidden wealth in

that dark day of his demise, of course the earnings could not be by legitimate
sources.

M.G.Ramachandran before parting company with DMK in 1972 suddenly in

a public meeting at Thirukazhukundram sought that all branch secretaries to
top functionaries of DMK must come out clean with their accounts and
disclose their assets. In his lifetime, he did not emulate what he sought from
DMK in the new party he founded on his own. At least now when a member
of MGR’s own family opens the debate on the mysterious behavior of the
coterie around MGR, as a cabinet colleague or closest confidant of MGR in
that period, Panruti S.Ramachandran, my respected friend, must break his
silence. He is one of the few living witnesses, and the media that has opened
the Pandora’s Box or channels like CNN-IBN must seek an interview with
those named in the interview, to spell the beans.

M.G.Sukumar, who seems to have soft corner for Miss. J.Jayalalitha,

directly points out that both Kalaignar M.Karunanithi and J.Jayalalitha were
forbidden from having a last glimpse of MGR’s body. Both may be rivals in
politics, but day in and day out both are shooting statements after statements.
They must open their mouth and say what happened to them at that time.
Kalaignar M.Karunanithi gracefully left, M.G.C.Sumukar says. He also says
M.G.R’s body was smuggled out of the MGR gardens. It is also a public
scene when J.Jayalalitha was humiliated when she tried to get into the army
vehicle that carried MGR’s body. Let us hope the Indian media which writes
pages and pages on Princess Diana’s death, will have the moral guts to get
the version of Kalaignar and Jayalalitha on these incidents. Though

60
M.G.C.Sukumar tries to shift the blame on a coterie around MGR’s widow
V.N.Janaki, who also occupied the illustrious Chief Minister’s chair for a
short period, truth should not be killed.

Who is V.N.Janaki? Everyone knows but no one speaks. She was the wife of
Ganapathy Bhatt who co-starred M.G.Ramacandran in a film
Manthrikumari, and deserted her husband and became M.G.Ramachandran’s
third wife. During the 1962 election campaign, while MGR was addressing
the public meeting late midnight in Cuddalore he got the news about his
second wife Sathananthavathy’s demise, and he left the campaign midway. I
was a witness in that public meeting. MGR did not have any issues. The
third wife is V.N.Janaki and the fourth cannot openly claim to be his wife,
thereby gain credentials to carry his legacy. In West the morality of leaders
are put to public scrutiny when they try to occupy high offices in those
countries, here known amoral behavior of leaders are condoned or
camouflaged to create a charisma to hoodwink the public.

We have a Right to Information Act in India. Kalaignar M.Karunanithi is the

Chief Minister, legally empowered who had to expose what happened in that
fateful day? Who hijacked how much money, and more than that how did
MGRamachandran amassed so much wealth? These questions may not be of
mere historical value. The ill-gotten wealth of MGR hijacked by others
around him had become an investment in political business of Tamilnadu,
and his wives or concubines could employ that to create a power crazy
political class that has spelt doom to the clean politics of Aringnar Anna.
Hence Let the Cat be Out of the Bag or Let Truth be resurrected from the
coffin and catacomb of Mr.M.G.Ramachandran.

Comments 6 Comments

You are asking the wrong person, MK, for coming out with truth. Starting
from EVR, who has the moral authority in Dravidian parties to speak about
Truth? EVR himself is an embodiment of buffoonery and MK himself is
surrounded by wives / concubines leave alone the rest of his followers …
and who will account how he accumulated wealth?? All rotten!! At least
MGR was good enough to attempt correction of corruption let loose by MK
in TN! Leave him alone to rest in peace!

Nathappan - Comments as on- 27-12-2007

61
First of all, will our dravidar peravai’s patron come open with how much he
amassed and how much his colleagues in DMK amassed in various
periods...? How many wives and concubines they control and how much
wealth he and his colleagues of patronized in their name. This could be the
best starting step before dissecting other’s business...
Regards
Kumar

Kumar - Comments as on- 28-12-2007

Nvarman says “...ill-gotten wealth of MGR …” This is a biased anti-MGR

article. What about MK’s wealth? Nandhi Varman will lose his credibility if
he opposes MGR and at the same time support MK. to me MK is more
corrupt than MGR. So will Nandhi varman dares to attack MK.

Gsuresh - Comments as on- 29-12-2007

Are you implying that VN Janaki was not legally married to MGR? Also, is
this a fact about Ganapathy Bhatt, who co-starred M.G.Ramacandran in a
film Manthrikumari, I can’t find this anywhere. I’m dying to see a picture of
G. Bhatt. Elilis - Comments as on- 21-07-2008

DK/DMK tradition is that it is a party where one can become a leader only if
one cannot state with certainty who that person’s father was? I don’t know
much about MGR’s poorvigam but it could be the lumpens are angry
because MGR knew who is father was? Certainly it can’t be corruption
because their ‘father’ was corrupt even in 1930 when he ran away in the 30’s
with funds collected by the then congress party of which he was the treasurer
and as a means of trying to defend himself Siriyan Ramasamy started his
Porkigal Kazhakam. Yes it could be only this that causes consternation
among the lumpens

Peveve - Comments as on- 22-07-2008

As per my readings, Ganapathy Bhatt was a make up artist and not an actor.
Nandhivarman’s assertion that V.N.Janaki starred in ‘Manthrikumari ‘(1950)
needs verification. The actresses who had starring roles in ‘Manthri Kumari’
were Madhuri Devi, G.Shakuntala, and T.P.Muthulakshmi. ‘How MGR did

62
amass so much wealth?’ questions Nandhivarman. Where has he been
living? MGR was the most popular Tamil actor for nearly three decades and
so many of his movies raked up money not only for him, but also for his
producers, co-artistes, and distributors - not only within India, but also in Sri
Lanka and Malaysia. MGR amassed his wealth in the old fashioned way - he
earned it by hard work, endurance and serving the demands of his fans.

Kantha - Comments as on- 26-08-2008

THE KASHMIR CONFUSION: BUREAUCRATIC

BLUNDERS AND BORDER WARS
Published on 21-11-2007 In National Viewed 1360 times |

India had spent crores of public money to safeguard our borders; thousands
of our brave men have given their lives to secure our borders. The War with
our neighbour is not a footnote in history, but a chapter of sacrifice made by
our army men. The cat on the wall Maharaja Harisingh’s clan till today
enjoys patronage from the ruling establishment as reward for bartering their
loyalty to India.

The Indian Army only needed a nod from Indian Prime Minister at a crucial
period of Indian history to drive Pakistan out of Kashmir. The Indian Home
Minister Sardar Vallabai Patel was urging Indian Prime Minister to give

63
green signal to our Army Chief Major General Kariappa to secure
Hyderabad and Kashmir at one go. While Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru
consented for army intervention in Hyderabad, which fell for Indian arm in a
day, hesitated to give his consent with regard to Kashmir. This indecision
resulted in ever bleeding never-ending Kashmir dispute between India and
Pakistan. It is not treason to look back at history.

Similarly it is not a sin to pin point the blunders committed by our

bureaucrats. Only politicians are portrayed as villains but bureaucrats enjoy
immunity. This is bad practice. While workforce of the country, the real
masters in a democracy are subjected a hire and fire policy, why not hire and
fire policy be framed for bureaucrats and only such a whip will make them
deliver goods without delay to the people. We reproduce a letter addressed
to then Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee on 5.1.2004. His
government did not act nor do I hope any government by bureaucrats and for
bureaucrats will punish the guilty. But people of the country, the supreme
power in a democracy have the right to know where and how it went wrong.

Hon’ble Prime Minister of India Thiru.Atal Bihari Vajpayee

Respected Atalji

Subject: A white paper sought on the Kashmir issue to evolve national

consensus and fix responsibility for faulty maps

All Indians will echo your feelings with regards to the Pakistan’s bartering
away of Kashmiri territory to China, our neighbour.

At the moment out of the total area of 222.336 square kilometers of

Kashmiri state the possession is as follows: Area of Jammu and Kashmir in
possession of India: 101,387 square kilometers. Illegally occupied by
Pakistan: 78,114 square kilometers illegally handed over to China by
Pakistan: 42,735 square kilometers Illegal occupation of China and Pakistan:
120,849 square kilometers

All this is shown as total area of Jammu and Kashmir 222,336 square
kilometers. This figure is shown from 1988/89 to 1999 in all manuals
brought out by the Ministry of information and Broadcasting.

64
So while with spirit of nationalism and patriotism we are ready to share your
feeling of hurt for Pakistan’s handing over an area of 42,735 square
kilometers to China. But let me request your office to trace out my letter-
dated 24.8.1999 in which I had complained first about the following grave
mistake.

I humbly submit that from the Source of INDIA: A REFERENCE

MANUAL 1953 brought out by the Publications Division of the Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting in page 1…. “THE AREA OF JAMMU AND
KASHMIR STATE WAS GIVEN AS 92,780 square miles which is
equivalent to 240,300.20 square kilometers? How could this become
222.336 square kilometers in 1988?

Pakistan holds 78,114 square kilometers. China owns 42,735 square

kilometers. India owns 101,387 square kilometers. By mistakes committed
by our bureaucracy in preparing faulty maps, we have lost 18,036.20 square
kilometers. Are we to take it for granted that 18.036.20 square kilometers
vanished into thin air? Like Bermuda’s triangle in our earth’s oceans do we
have a Bermuda’s triangle in our Ministries, which had swallowed
18,036.20 square kilometers? Who is responsible for this? Who is going to
be held accountable for this? Are we going to find scapegoats? Or whether
The National Democratic Alliance Government has the moral guts to fix the
responsibility on the Congress governments that caused this national loss to
our country?

While 1953 Manual says 92,780 square miles equivalent to 240.300.20

square kilometers, in 1960 Edition the area becomes 86,024 square miles
equivalent to 222.802.16 square kilometers. Official reference journal
published by a Ministry of the Government of India in 1960 at page 24-25, a
district wise break up of the area of Jammu And Kashmir State is given. The
total of this area arrives at a figure of 84,476 square miles, which is
equivalent to 218,792.84 square kilometers.

In 1964 Edition page 7 has a different story to tell. It contains two different
figures. In the column area figure a) shows 86,023 square miles equivalent
to 222.799.57 square kilometers. Figure (b) shows 56665 square miles,
which is under Indian possession. This amounts to 146,762.25 square
kilometers? In 1965 Edition page 7 changes over to 222.896.78 square
kilometers? In 1966 Edition page 7 Area of Jammu and Kashmir once again
changed to 222,800 square kilometers? In 1968 Edition page 8 area of

65
Jammu and Kashmir once again changed to 222,870 square kilometers .In
1988-89 edition the area of Jammu and Kashmir was shown as 222.236
square kilometers. In the very same edition in a different page693, the area
of Jammu and Kashmir was shown as 222.236 square kilometers and a note
inserted which stated “That this area includes 78,114 square kilometers
under illegal occupation of Pakistan, 5280 square kilometers illegally
handed over by Pakistan to China and 37,555 square kilometers illegally
occupied by China “

The Congress party and its campaign managers including its President Sonia
Gandhi owes this nation an explanation because it is under Congress rule we
have lost 18,036.20 square kilometers of our land. Congress party that hurls
abuses against am immaculate patriot Defense Minister George Fernandes
and boycotts him in Parliament with no strong case for its cause except
hatred caused by George Fernandes leading a multi party combine to a full
term in office, must come out clean and admit its guilt in causing our nation
this loss.

Dravida Peravai urges the National Democratic Alliance to bring out a

White paper on this Anti National crime committed by the Congress
governments and make it an election issue.

With Regards

Yours fraternally
N.Nandhivarman General Secretary

5.1.2004

Copy to: Hon’ble Comrade George Fernandes Union Defense Minister

2 Comments

Nandi you seem to suck up to George Fernandes quite often. How come you
like him although he is friendly with BJP, which supports Hindutva? May be
you know George but George doesn’t know you!

Ramarsetu - Comments as on- 26-11-2007

66
In “Tamilarchi” forum, he wrote one letter not only supporting the Muslims
but also pleading for their cause. Here, he calls “Kashmir confusion”. He has
been double-speak. He does not worry about the Hindus driven out who
have been living as “refugees” in our own country. And I never heard Karu
singing or writing any poem for the oppressed, suppressed, broken and
tortured Hindus. I never heard Kanimozhi speak about the lakhs of Hindu
women driven out from their homes, raped by the Islamic terrorist, living on
the platforms and tents, etc.

MNachiappan - Comments as on- 29-11-2007

SLAVES FROM BRITISH AND FRENCH INDIA

On Voyage towards Slavery from French India by N Nandhivarman

Published on 24-10-2007 In World Viewed 1664 times

67
 Deccan Chronicle dated 24 th October 2007 published a book review about
THE SLAVE SHIP:A HUMAN HISTORY written by Markus Rediker.This
made me recollect my story on the slaves from British India and French
India published in e-magazine Voice of Voiceless.Mahakavi Bharathiar
alone shed poetic tears for our kinsmen taken as slaves while Negroes
attained liberation. The full text is below:]

“Jahaji Bhai” is a documentary film with an Urdu title, which means

brothers of the ship. These are not sailors of the same boat as the English
idiom indicates but literally are slaves taken away in the same ship. These
are bonded labour taken 167 years ago in ships to erstwhile colonies of the
Caribbean region. Suresh Kumar Pillai had tried to capture their miseries in
this documentary on a totally forgotten peoples. Why did people from India
go to Caribbean’s? The historical necessity arrives with the abolition of
slavery in the nation ruled by white colored people. After the black race got
reprieve from slavery, to work in the sugar plantations Indians from Chota
Nagpur areas, mostly tribal people were lured into.

The first ship left Calcutta in February 1838 and reached Guyana on May 5
th 1838. There were 420 hill coolies, as they were called; out of which 50
are women and 10 children. Many succumbed to diseases in mid way and
those who reached there had either to perish under stress and strain within
the 5-year contract period or to be killed for so called violations.

In fact many ships went missing and no one was there to shed a single drop
of tear. If an Indian coolie absented for 7 days he was fined $24 dollars,
which is equivalent to 6 months wages. These Indians lost their roots and
culture. While liberated Negro slaves climbed in the social ladder, Indians
filled that vacuum at the rock bottom of society. They were induced to
become addicts to alcoholism. With few women around polyandry became
the order of the day. Africans joined Europeans to suppress the brown race.
Picturing their everyday lives and showing lot of documentary proof with
regard to their plight from various sources, Suresh Kumar Pillai in this
documentary records an unknown chapter on Indian migration. Ravi Dev,
Leader of the Roar Guyana Movement speaks for his fellow brethren and a
103 old man tries hard to recollect his fellow passengers of the ship that
carried them from India, all shown in the documentary.

While British India stopped labour supply due to awareness and campaigns,
French India provided a fertile ground for hunting neo-slaves. Suresh Kumar

68
Pillai had shot another documentary on these pathetic brethren. “Songs of
Malabaris”

The Indian labourers in French colonies had to face stiff resistance from the
Africans because the Indians had to work for paltry pittance, which freed
Africans refused to comply. Thus Indians occupied the lowest of the low
position in the French Caribbean society and called as “Cooli Malabarise”or
“Chappa Coolies”. Indian coolies were never allowed to practice their
religious faiths or to speak their native tongues on the plantations .The
labourers had to be French in every sense. This was in sharp contrast to other
Dutch colony of Suriname or British colony of Trinidad and Guyana where
the Indians had some amount of freedom to retain their language and culture.
The film looks at the history of migration of Indians to French West Indies
and their struggle to retain their religion and culture against the French
policy of assimilation.

Suresh Kumar Pillai holds a Post Graduate Diploma in Mass

Communication along with fifteen years journalistic experience in print and
electronic media. “Once More Removed”, a documentary film on 19th
century migration of an Indian family from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh to
Caribbean for HBO Documentaries USA is another memorable
documentary. “The Song of Malabaries” for Nederland based OHM media
network was telecast on Nederland National Television Channel in June
2004. Mr.Pillai also researched, wrote, shot, produced and directed a three
50 minutes documentary series Jahaji Bhai on the Indian communities in
Guyana and Trinidad under own banner Trikkan Image Systems. The film
was widely circulated and telecast in several TV stations in Caribbean and
India 2003

With documentaries like these screened in Dutch and French televisions to

his credit Suresh Kumar Pillai has set his eyes on a sleepy village called
Arikkamedu in the suburbs of Pondicherry. Arilkamedu, the site of
archeological excavations, which had established Pondicherry’s connections
with Roman Empire in pre-Christian era, had caught his imagination and
Pillai rented a house and is living for 6 months and more to collect artifacts
for his film. In that process he wants to set up a site museum there.
Mr.K.K.Chakravarthy Secretary to Union Government and Director General
National Museum New Delhi recently in a meeting of scholars convened by
Department of Arts and Culture Government of Pondicherry expressed the
desire for landscaping and recreating the past to draw tourists to our

69
museums. Professor Kishore K.Basa Director of Indra Gandhi Rastriya
Manav Sangrahalaya Bhopal stressed the need to promote archaeological
tourism. And Mr.Pillai’s dream to start a private museum to promote
Arikamedu falls under the categories advised by these scholarly bureaucrats.

While working on his current dream project Mr. Suresh Kumar Pillai had
done right thing to draw our attention towards the descendants of those
survived Indian indentured migrants today who form a significant ethnic
minority in the larger Black Caribbean world known variously as East
Indians, Indo-Caribbean, and West Indian Indians. The people of Indian
origin spread across several island nations such as Trinidad "Tobago,
Jamaica, Grenada, Barbados, and St. Vincent, St. Lucia and in South
American countries like Guyana and Surinam. “The extraordinary cultural
fusion that took place in the New World, a grand meeting place of four great
civilizations - Amerindians, Indians, Africans and Europeans gave birth to
some unique social, cultural and religious practices which are traditional in
its content but western in its formal expressions” says Suresh Kumar Pillai
in his introductory note on the film. Film after film he has set noble tasks
and the awareness he generates by such documentaries reach abroad, but he
is concerned more in awakening the sleepy village of Arikkamedu which has
become his home now.

(Nandhivarman Nagarathinam is the General Secretary of Dravida Peravai

based in Pondicherry (a southern union territory of India). He graduated in
Economics and Law. He was the student DMK state secretary in the 60s. He
served as DMK’s Propaganda Secretary in the 70s. From 1997 the Samata
Party of India headed by former Indian Defense Minister George Fernandes,
admitted Dravida Peravai as associate party and special invitee to its
National Executive till Samata party existed in that name) is a film on coolie
migration from Pondicherry and its enclaves towards Caribbean sugar
plantations. All South Indians are called as Malabaris or Madrasis it must be
remembered. The French recruited the labourers mainly from Pondicherry,
Karaikal, Chandranagore and Mahe and between 1854 and 1920 around
50,000 Indian labourers were taken to Guadeloupe and Martinique to work
as coolies. It should be stressed that only Mahakavi Bharathiar immortalized
the woes of the sugar plantation labourers in his poem”karumbu thottathile”.
No one else bothered about our unfortunate kinsmen.
http://www.voiceofvoiceless.com/current/m2.asp
Colonization- Decolonization and Recolonization

70
Published on 07-12-2007 In General Viewed 2378 times

[General Secretary Dravida Peravai feels it is relevant to reproduce this paper on

colonialism, since what we now face in Malaysia also reminds us about the colonialist
past.] (Paper presented in the SEMINAR ON INDIA AND FRANCE-PAST-PRESENT
AND FUTURE organized by Center for Nehru Studies and School of International
Studies Pondicherry University, sponsored by Government of Pondicherry and Indian
Council for Historical Research New Delhi held on 26-28 October 2004)

Introduction: History is still shrouded in mystery. Selectively people cling

to certain cliché and try to define history as they conceive it. The mindset of
the general mass is tuned to listen to one-sided views that put a lid on the
truth. Parrots repeat what is taught, and people conditioned to colonial
reflexes, sings lullabies for their colonial masters. It is true all humans and
rulers are not bad, but to differentiate between bad and good rule, a true
historian has a unique role to play. We live in an era of information
technology transforming towards nano-technology era. This era of global
village brings to us many painful stories of the past, when as bonded labors
and slaves our people faced the wrath of colonialists. Indian born Kumud
Merani had produced a documentary titled Girmit Ki kahani in Hindi and
Sweet Sorrow in English on the injustices meted out to Indian labourers who
were duped and sent to Fiji between 1879 and 1916. This documentary had
won the Asia Pacific Broadcasting Union Award in the News and Current
Affairs category for the year 2004. Similar travails of Pondicherrians taken
to French colonies are yet to be compiled from archival materials. These
pages need not be kept in dark. What has happened has happened. We have
no prerogative to portray what we want to, instead of telling what really
happened. India obtained freedom at midnight, but Pondicherry at one fine
dawn. Yet there is no comparative study on Pondicherry’s decolonization in
comparison with other French colonies. Nor there exists a comparative study
incorporating Pondicherry’s freedom struggle with other freedom
movements in former French colonies. There is need for India centric
comparative study on British, Portuguese and French colonialism. These
remarks are aimed at scholars and Institutions of Pondicherry intending to
stimulate and activate them to rectify these lapses in our historical thought.
Let us think about our past, present with dreams for future. Decolonization
Drive of 20 th Century: Decolonization became the societal goal of the
peoples under colonial regimes aspiring to achieve self-determination. It
reflected in the United Nations General Assembly's proclamation on 14

71
December 1960 of the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to
Colonial Countries and Peoples - resolution 1514 (XV). The Declaration
states that "the subjection of peoples to alien subjugation, domination and
exploitation constitutes a denial of fundamental human rights, is contrary to
the United Nations Charter, and is an impediment to the promotion of world
peace and cooperation, and that steps should be taken to transfer,
unconditionally, all powers to the Trust and Non-Self-Governing Territories
so that they might enjoy complete freedom and independence". Also in
1960, the Assembly approved resolution 1541 (XV), defining free
association with an independent State, integration into an independent State,
or independence as the three legitimate options of full self-government
Liberation of Colonies: Let us have a look at colonies that attained
liberation. A British Colony and Protectorate Togo land united with the Gold
Coast in 1957 to form Ghana. French administered Togo land became
independent as Togo in 1960.Italy ruled Somaliland joined with British
Somaliland protectorate in 1960 to form Somalia. French colony of
Cameroon’s gained independence as Cameroon in 1960 while British ruled
northern territory of Cameroon’s joined Nigeria and southern territory with
Cameroon in 1961. British administered Tanganyika became independent in
1961. In 1964, Tanganyika and the former protectorate of Zanzibar, which
had become independent in 1963, united as a single State under the name of
the United Republic of Tanzania. Belgian administered Ruanda-Urundi
voted to divide into the two sovereign States of Rwanda and Burundi in
1962. New Zealand ruled Western Samoa became independent as Samoa in
1962. Australia administered Nauru attained independence in 1968.
Australian ruled New Guinea united with Papua and became the independent
State of Papua New Guinea in 1975. That is how the fresh air of freedom
was breathed by various colonies in the previous century. Now let us have a
look at the time- table of French colonies on their road to independence.

French Colonies towards liberation:

Indo-China gained Independence as Viet Nam (1945) Laos (1949) and

Cambodia (1953). French Establishments in Oceania “French Guiana,
Martinique, Reunion, St.Pierre “Miquelon, Guadeloupe and dependencies
underwent change of status in 1947. Morocco in 1956 and French Guinea
obtained Independence, as Guinea in 1958.French Sudan became
independent Mali in 1960. Ivory Coast after Independence changed the name
to Mauritania in1960. French West Africa gained Independence as Dahomey
(now Benin) in 1960.Niger Colony became Niger and then gained

72
Independence as Senegal in 1960. French Somaliland attained
Independence as Djibouti in 1977. Madagascar (1960) and Comoros (1975)
gained independence. New Hebrides is under Anglo-French Condominium.
Tunisia attained independence (1956), Cameroon (1960), Togo (1960), and
Vanuatu (1980). Italy Somaliland Trust Territory got Independence as
Somalia (joined with British Somaliland) in 1960.

Others: East Timor attained independence in May 2002 and joined the
United Nations in September 2002 as Timor Leste. In 1963, the Federation
of Malaya became Malaysia, following the admission to the new federation
of Singapore, Sabah (North Borneo) and Sarawak. Singapore became
independent in 1965.Following the ratification in 1964 of Articles of Union
between Tanganyika and Zanzibar, the United Republic of Tanganyika and
Zanzibar was formed and later changed its name to the United Republic of
Tanzania.

Colonies of Today: United Nations documents issued in 2002 lists the

following areas as ones still considered being without self-rule. That means
colonialism is yet to be completely wiped out. In AFRICA Western Sahara
is first in that list alphabetically. In ATLANTIC AND CARIBBEAN United
Kingdom administers Anguilla, Bermuda, British Virgin Islands, Cayman
Islands, Falkland Islands (Malvinas), Montserrat, St. Helena, Turks and
Calicos Islands whereas United States of America rules United States Virgin
Islands. In EUROPE Gibraltar is under the control of United Kingdom. In
the PACIFIC AND INDIAN OCEANS American Samoa and Guam are with
United States. Pitcairn under United Kingdom and Tokelau remain with
New Zealand. Since on 2 December 1986, the United Nations General
Assembly determined that New Caledonia was a Non-Self-Governing
Territory, we can say that New Caledonia is the only colony under France
even in this century.

The Catalyst for Change: Decolonization British style:

The aftermath of Second World War, led to rapid disintegration of the

European empires. Colonialism downed its shutters. A salubrious breeze of
freedom swept colonialism. Colonies became independent states.
Decolonization and the British Empire 1775-1997 by Professor of Political
Theory in University of Wales D. GEORGE BOYCE analyses the ideas
and policies that governed the British experience of decolonization. It shows
how the British political tradition, with its emphasis on experience over

73
abstract theory, was integral to the way in which the empire was regarded as
being transformed rather than lost. This was a significant aspect of the
relatively painless British loss of empire. It places the process of
decolonization in its wider context, tracing the twentieth-century domestic
and international conditions that hastened decolonization, and, through a
close analysis of not only the policy choices but also the language of British
imperialism, it throws new light on the British way of managing both the
expansion and contraction of empire. With India's declaration of
independence it became apparent that it was only a matter of time before
Britain’s other colonies demanded their own independence. By 1957 only
two of Britain’s colonies in Africa had gained their independence they were
the Gold Coast and Sudan. The rest were to quickly receive their
independence between 1957 and 1964. The characteristics of these
independences were the methods with which they carried out by the British.
They followed the same plan in each colony, which was to prepare the
colony for self-rule by training people for the new positions within
government and in other sectors which the British settlers had dominated in.
This meant the new independent country would be able to support her. It
also meant that the likely hood of a power vacuum would be reduced after
the British left, opines a comparative study.

Decolonization French way:

France was another great imperial power who decolonized after the Second
World War although her reasons and methods were quite different from
Britain. Whereas the British realized the colonies were beginning to become
a burden the French believed they had to re-assert their national prestige by
keeping control of their colonies. This may explain why the French
experience of decolonization was so different to Britain’s. French
decolonization was bloody and bitter whereas Britain’s was quite peaceful
and quite painless. France fought two costly and bloody wars over her
colonies. The first of these was in Indo-China, which had been under French
rule since the 19th Century. During the Second World War Indo-China was
invaded and occupied by the Japanese. Vietminh led by Ho Chi Minh
fought a guerrilla war against the Japanese. At the end of the Second World
War the French intended to retake control of Indo-China but before they
could the Vietminh declared independence. Fighting broke out in 1946 and
continued for eight years before the French suffered a massive defeat at Dien
Bien Phu. This was the decisive point of the war with an armistice being
signed soon after. France had lost much in the war including 91,000 men

74
and their colony. France’s African Empire started to decolonize after the
humiliating defeat at Dien Bien Phu as riots spread across the French
African states. France realized she could not hold her empire together
anymore and begun decolonizing. All the French African colonies were
granted their independence between 1956 and 1960 with the exception
Algeria. Algeria held a unique place within the French Empire as it had been
formally integrated into France thus making it not a colony but a part of
France itself. An armed rebellion led by the F.L.N. (Front d'Liberation
National) in 1954 led to bloody civil war in Algeria. In 1958 General de
Gaulle was persuaded to come out of retirement to end the conflict in
Algeria. Charles De Gaulle realized that France could not win the war and
that it would be a major strain on the economy to continue it. He begun talks
for independence and he and the F.L.N. leader signed a settlement in 1962.

French dream to colonize Pondicherry:

History of French in India is a monumental work written by Colonel

G.B.Malleson, which narrates the events that lead to the founding of
Pondicherry in 1674 to the capture of that place in 1761. In the reign of
Louis XII, in the year 1503, two ships of the merchants of Rouen took to
seas and were never heard thereof. This marks the first French attempt to set
foot on Indian soil. Though many had the urge nothing concrete emerged.

On June 1 1604 a company was established under Kings letters patent,

granting it exclusive trade for 15 years. This also failed to take of due to
faction feuds among the founders. 7 years later Louis XIII tried again in vain
to activate the company. During 1615 two merchants sought transfer of the
company to them, which was stiffly opposed by the company. Hence as
compromise formula the King created a coalition of both sides and conferred
on July 2, 1615 letters patent. The next year two ships set to sail to India.
Commodore de Nets was in charge of the big vessel and Captain Antoine
Beaulieu of the smaller vessel. The Dutch crew in Beaulieu's ship obeying
the diktats of their government left the vessel of Beaulieu. And Beaulieu had
to dispose the ship and join the vessel of Commodore de Nets. In spite of all
such travails the venture was profitable. So the company launched 3 more
vessels on trip to India. Mont Morenci with 162 men, 22 guns with 450-ton
capacity, L’Esperance with 117 men, 26 guns and 400-ton capacity,
L’Hermitage with 30 men, 8 guns and with 75-ton capacity, were placed
under Beaulieu’s chief command. In that trip the Dutch sank L’Hermitage.
Next 20 years no further efforts to reach east were undertaken. In 1642 a

75
new company La Compagnie des Indes with Richelieu was launched but
before ships could set to sail he passed away. A resting place mid way to
Indes became their passion. The first French vessel to Madagascar reached
its shores in summer of 1642.The local people resisted French settlers. The
company had to incur heavy losses in combating local people and ultimately
gave up its claims to Madagascar in 1672. In 1664 French Compagnie des
Indes with a capital of 15,000,000 livres was formed. A charter by the
Government granted the company exclusive rights for 50 years to trade with
India with total exemption from taxation. Government also agreed to
reimburse all losses if any. They first went for Madagascar. On March 7,
1665 with four ships and 520 men. They changed its name to Isle Dauphin.
Earlier Portuguese had called it Saint Lawrence. The local revolt against
French occupation continued and culminated in the fierce massacre of
almost all within the walls of Fort Dauphine. These abortive attempts
gradually led to French setting foot on Indian soil and making it a colony of
France.

Reason for India becoming a destination: Why do all colonialists set their
eye on India? It is needless here to narrate how French obtained a foothold
on Indian soil and how they later became rulers. It is vital to know why India
was colonized, be it by the British, French and the Portuguese? The East
India Company was founded in 1600 to sell British woolen cloth to India.
Their ships arrived in Surat in 1608 with vast quantities of broadcloth but
the trade soon faltered and died out. What changed their fortunes was the
discovery of cotton, which was completely unknown in the west, says Ms.
Crill who had coauthored a book Trade, Temple and Court: Indian Textiles
from Tapi Collections. Another author of the same book Ms.Ruth Barnes
states that Textile trade surfaces repeatedly in the social and economic
histories of these times. For centuries textiles were crucial currency in the
Indian Ocean trade. If you wanted a piece of the spice trade in the 14 th
century, you did not have a chance unless you showed up in the Eastern
Indonesia with high quality textiles. Well these textile scholars have stated
one reason for India being a popular destination for colonialists. Colonialists
came to market their products but were drawn towards buying Indian
fabrics. Millions of Indian cotton arrived in England at that time, so much so
that the wool and linen weavers began to protest and a law prohibiting
Indian textiles was passed in 1700? Says Rosemary Crill of the V"A
Museum, London in her book.

Decolonization of French India:

76
Let me quote verbatim the last rituals performed for decolonizing
Pondicherry as written in the book Decolonization of French India, since I
do not want to be drawn in controversies by writing a new version myself.
The procedure incorporated into the joint communiqué¬ which was
simultaneously published from New Delhi and Paris, ran as follows
Desirous of reaching a final settlement on the question of the French
establishments in India, The government of India and the Government of the
French Republic through their representatives in Delhi has engaged in
negotiations. As a result of these negotiations the two governments have
agreement on the following procedure. All elected members of the
representative assembly and the Municipal Councils of the establishments
will be met at a Congress on October 18 in the settlement of Pondicherry to
consider the joint proposals of the two governments for a final settlement of
the future of the settlements and record their decision on these proposals as
an expression of the wishes of the people .An arête of the Commissaire de la
Pepublique was published on 11 October in the Journal official of
Pondicherry with a view to acquainting the people the conditions of the
consultation. The Pondicherry Government issued summons to the elected
municipal members of the south Indian settlements and the Representative
assembly to meet at Kizhur about 10 miles on the border of west of
Pondicherry on 18 October at 10 o’clock to decide the future of the French
settlements in India. The members of the four settlements whose election
was valid up to 1 st January 1954 had been asked to vote on that day either
for the continuation of French rule in these settlements or for merger of these
settlements with the Indian Union. The importance of the Congress and the
necessity of the members to attend the Congress were expressed in a
circular, which was signed by the Secretary General for French India and
dispatched to the elected members accompanied by the topographical map of
the place where the congress was to be held together with the admission
card. There was a proposal to hold the congress at Karaikal, but that was set
aside. Kizhur, a tiny hamlet situated in Indian Territory was finally chosen in
order to avoid the disturbances, which the presence of Goubert and
Muthupillai might have provoked if the congress had been held at
Pondicherry. Balasubramanian, President of the Representative Assembly
acted as presiding officer of the Congress. Out of 178, 170 members voted
overwhelmingly in favour of the merger with Indian Union and 8 voted
against. The results were declared in the presence of Pierre Landy and
Kewal Singh. The period of suspense was over. The usual scene of
excitement tension and violence, which had tainted previous elections in

77
French India, was totally absent here in this hamlet. It was so to speak a
parody of consultation. France had to agree to this as a sop to satisfy her
constitutional requirements and India had to accept this verdict given by the
members of the municipal councils and representative assembly whose
elections she had protested as irregular. The signing of the treaty at New
Delhi on 21 October followed this. The remaining 10 days witnessed the
French India authorities make hectic preparations for total withdrawal from
Pondicherry and Karaikal. As fixed earlier Escargueil left Pondicherry for
France on 31 st October handing over charge to Pierre Landy. The French
national flag was removed from the top of the Governors house in the
evening of the same day. On 1 November of 1954 at 6.45 in the morning a
document of transfer was signed between Pierre Landy representing France
and Kewal Singh, Indian Consul general and Indian Commissioner designate
in the official residence of the former. In Karaikal too Boucheney aided by
Duvauchelle, an Officer of the foreign department who had recently arrived
here, handed over power to the India administration?

Immediately after this the Indian national flag was unfurled over the
government house to the tumultuous ovation of thousands of people who
had gathered there marking the close of seven-year tortuous negotiations.
Throughout the day there was jubilation everywhere in Pondicherry, In
Karaikal, in Mahe and in Yenam and the rest of India in this hour of joy. As
a result of the historic decision taken at kizhur more than 3 lakh people
rejoined their mother country India at the dawn of 1 November thereby
ending 240-year-old French rule on the four settlements of South India. The
people of India welcomed the residents of the erstwhile French settlements
into the larger fold of Indian citizenship. A part of India separated from the
motherland is coming back to us on its own freewill Prime Minister
Jawaharlal Nehru and President Rajendra Prasad said we should be equal
partners in a common endeavor to work for the progress and prosperity of
India. The congress of Kizhur facilitated the dissolution of French colonial
rule in the French pockets, but French sovereignty over them continued
legally till dejure transfer had taken place in 1962.

FRENCH AND FRENCH CITIZENS IN INDIA PRESENT STATUS:

The colonial rule created a new class of citizens, Indian born yet French
citizens by option. These Indians have roots in Pondicherry but have their
work and homes in France. For those left in the soil of Pondicherry France
has constitutional arrangements to look after the interests of Indian born
French citizens. This arrangement is unique and deserves close appraisal.

78
The notification issued by the Rastrapathi Bhavan few years ago had stated
that hereafter the Ministry of Non Resident Indians will be named as
Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs in English and Pravasi Bharatiya Karya
Mantralaya in Hindi which has come into operation now. But within our
country we have residing Non Resident French citizens but who are Indians
by birth but French citizens by option. It will be interesting to compare with
what French does for Overseas French affairs. When French left their former
colonies, they left large sections that opted to become French citizens. There
are more than 20 million French citizens living abroad in various former
French colonies including Pondicherry, which is a Union Territory under
Indian Union. One hundred and fifty five delegates are elected by direct
universal suffrage by the French communities abroad for a period of 6 years
and this body is presided by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of France.
French citizens in America elect 32 delegates and from Africa 47 seats thus
the total of A series of constituencies is 79. In B series there are 76 seats and
the break up is 52 seats from Europe and from Asia-Oceania and the Orient
24. Within these 24 seats two are chosen from Pondicherry. Half of the
Electoral College is renewed every 3rd year. All former colonies are divided
into 52 electoral districts, with one or more delegates per district. A country
may have several electoral districts, just as an electoral district may cover
several countries. French people residing abroad through their 155
representatives elect twelve Senators to French Parliament. They get elected
one-third at a time for 8 years in 2004 and for 7 years in 2007 and for 6
years from 2010.

The Constitution of 27 October 1946 (IVth Republic) stipulated that the new
Parliament would comprise a National Assembly and a "Council of the
Republic" (as the Senate was called until 1958) within which "the French of
the Exterior" would be represented. This may be like our lower and upper
houses in Parliament. The National Assembly pondered and decided how to
effect this representation. It decreed, in a resolution dated 13 December
1946, that three "Councillor of the Republic" seats (out of 320) would go to
personalities representing Non Resident French citizens living in Europe,
America and Asia-Oceania-Orient respectively.

For more than two decade the following associations were looking after the
interests of Non Resident French citizens in Paris. They are the Union of
French Chambers of Commerce Abroad, the French Overseas Teachers
Association, the Non-Resident French War Veterans Federation, and the
Overseas French Union (Union des Franç¡©s de l?é´²anger, UFE), founded

79
in 1927. These four bodies mooted a suggestion for creation of a "high
council" by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The then Prime Minister, Robert
Schumann, and his Foreign Minister, Georges Bidault signed a Decree
setting up the High Council for French People residing abroad. On 7 July
1948. The first High Council was composed of 55 members: 8 ex officio
members (the three Senator-Councilors of the Republic, the president and
director of the UFE, the presidents of the Chambers of Commerce, of the
Teachers Association and of the War Veterans Federation, 42 elected
officials, and 5 members nominated by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.” The
first CSFE elections of 1950 were held in seventy countries of Europe,
America, Asia and Oceania, according to a protocol defined in a Ministerial
Decree dated 10 December 1949 and signed by Robert Schumann.

Article 24 of the Constitution of 25 September 1958 states, "French

nationals settled outside France should be represented in the Senate." Two
Executive Orders were issued, on 15 November 1958 and 4 February 1959
respectively, for organizing this representation and providing the CSFE with
new status. The CSFE, while retaining its advisory role, became the sole
Electoral College for electing Senators from abroad. Their numbers
increased from three to six, two representing Europe and America, one
representing Asia-Oceania and three representing Africa. It was thus divided
into three sections for the Senatorial elections of 23 April 1959. The CSFE
had 84 elected members but it became clear that Europe and America were
under-represented in comparison with Africa. The number of Senators was
therefore brought up to nine for 1962 elections. After the creation of the
Democratic Association of French Citizens Abroad (Association Dé-
¯cratique des Franç¡©s à ¬? Estranger - ADFE) in 1980, the CSFE was
reconstituted in 1982. The Act of 7 June 1982 paved way for the election by
universal suffrage of Delegates to the CSFE, which (with the exception of
twenty-one members chosen for their competence but not having Senatorial
voting rights) was no longer a body of appointed personalities. And the
election of twelve Senators thereafter is only by the elected members of the
CSFE. The Minister of Foreign Affairs defines the objectives and priorities
of the assembly chaired by him. The Senators place before the Senate, the
National Assembly and the Economic and Social Council the propositions,
motions, resolutions and wishes expressed by their electors. The twelve
Senators, ex officio members of the AFE, can introduce Bills or legislative
amendments reflecting the hopes and needs of French people living around
the world. The French Minister of Foreign Affairs on the basis of their

80
particular qualifications designates the appointed councilors. The members
of the Council may form political groups. The college of Vice-Presidents
(or conference of Vice-Presidents) enacts the work of the Council and
reports back to the President. The plenary assembly, attended by the ex
officio members, the appointed members and the elected members, meets
once a year in Paris at the beginning of September. Members are divided
among specialized committees, which prepare reports for submission to the
plenary assembly.

The AFE exercises real political authority at the moment when Senators
representing French people abroad are elected. Elected AFE members can
sponsor a candidate for the French presidential elections. The AFE is "called
upon to give the Cabinet opinions on matters and projects of concern to
French People residing abroad and on developing France’s presence
abroad". They are not prior opinions, however. The AFE could rather be said
to fulfill the role of a specialized Economic and Social Council. The Cabinet
may consult it, or it may intervene at its own initiative. AFE members, as
elected representatives of the various French communities abroad, are
concerned to defend the interests of French People residing abroad. They
study matters relating to the education of French people abroad, their rights,
their social situation, and their economic and taxation problems. The AFE
may use background studies to inform the French authorities on specific
problems (education, law, social affairs, foreign trade, taxation, etc)
affecting the interests of French People residing abroad.

This French experience is novel and it must be studied by the Government

of India to evolve novel methods to solve the issues that haunt the Overseas
Indians and the newly formed Ministry must emulate the representative
system followed by France. British left India satisfied with getting 2
nominated M.P Seats in the Loksabha for Anglo-Indians. France did not
plead for seats in the legislature for Franco-Indians. It worked out the above
stated arrangements to manage the Indian born French nationals. From Fiji
to Srilanka people of Indian origin are there. Will it be advisable if a similar
arrangement is made for them under the aegis of the Ministry of Overseas
Affairs? Union Territory Act has provision for 3 nominated members but it
should be done according to the procedure adopted for Rajyasabha
nominations i.e.: educated and social activists alone are nominated. That is
another story. Problems galore left by colonial legacy: Colonial policy had a
couple of goals: (1) to control the supply of valuable raw materials, such as
minerals, petrol, wood, plantation crops such as rubber, sugar, pepper, cotton

81
etc., (2) to secure a market for the industrial exports of the colonizing
country, (3) country to settle in for the colonizing country's emigrating
population, (4) strategic importance. Let us have a look at the problems left
over by the colonial legacy. In the colonies, decades, in some countries
centuries of colonial rule had resulted in major changes. In many cases, the
borders of the colonies had been unilaterally drawn by Colonial powers with
little regard for ethnicity and history. The border dispute India has with its
neighbours is a left over of the colonial legacy. The contiguity of
Pondicherry is missing and the enclave territories separated by miles
scattered as dots remain in Indian map, which is also an issue of the colonial
legacy and poses problem for gaining statehood to be on par with other
Indian states. The infrastructure established by the colonial administration
served mainly the interests of the colonial administration. There are many
fields that warrant a study. More information may be in French and their
archives. It is high time our scholars scan all such information to provide an
in-depth study of Pondicherry's colonization and decolonization.

While such study into past is also needed, there is greater need to study how
decolorized nations have faced the challenges in the post-colonial era. We in
India are still facing the issues left by the colonial legacy. Let us see the
experience of Singapore and Malaysia and the issues, which will be of
importance too from our standpoint. Lee Kuan Yew of Singapore stated
once that empires never last forever, that either the master and subject races
finally merged to a unified society or the empire ends with subject races
clashes violently and finally emerging as separate nation and entity.
Ironically, his statement can equally be applied to the independent country
of Malaysia where race and racial issues are still a sensitive and election
issue. Ethnocentrism was and is still not something that can ever be stamped
out.

The Kingdom at a Crossroads written by Marijke van der Meer tells the
story of Surinam. In the late 18th century the British swapped their South
American colony now known as Surinam for Manhattan, and then controlled
by The Netherlands. For many years the Dutch reckoned they had the better
of the deal, after all the British lost Manhattan quite quickly, while Surinam
only gained its independence in on November 25 1975. Professor Oostindie
opines that there was not enough time to find solutions to many of Surinam's
long-standing issues. "The Dutch government did whatever was necessary to
accomplish independence," he says, "basically this was done by not solving
several problems such as the border dispute with Guyana. They offered more

82
development aid than had been conceived of before and they said that all
Surinamers, even five years after independence, would be eligible for Dutch
nationality, stimulating an exodus to The Netherlands. Today there are just
over 400,000 people in Surinam but there are 300,000 people of Surinamese
descent in The Netherlands. The whole demographic growth of this nation
has been in The Netherlands rather than Surinam. The offer of French
citizenship to people of Pondicherry origin by the French created a similar
exodus, which needs a comparative study. Reports from a wild country:
Ethics of Decolonization by Deborah Bird Rose explores some of
Australia’s major ethical challenges. Written in the midst of rapid social and
environmental change and in a time of uncertainty and division, it offers
powerful stories and arguments for ethical choice and commitment. The
focus is on reconciliation between Indigenous and Settler? Peoples, and with
nature. The above stated problems are just examples and lot remains to be
studied about the postcolonial problems left over of the colonial legacies in
all former colonies. Recolonisation and Neocolonialism: Colonization and
decolonization could be understood easily as that process is over and a post
mortem is possible. But what about recolonization? This word entered the
political discourse in the aftermath of Iraqi invasion by America. America of
the 20 th century was not in favour of colonization. But in 21 st century
doubts over its moves aimed at recolonization exists in peoples mind. Neo
colonialism needs a fresh study. Now we are one in India, and we cannot
think Pondicherry in isolation from rest of India and its burning issues. We
live in an area of free markets. You should remember that the drive to
market their products and purchase our raw materials only opened the doors
to colonial rule few centuries before. History is repeating in a different form.
The export and import of toxic wastes justified in the name of recycling is
now one of the biggest threats to global environment. The import of toxic
wastes by Third World countries is cause of grave concern. Take for
example the Ship Building Yard at Alang in Gujarat.350 ships are scrapped
in India every year. According to Central Pollution Control Board 12,428
metric tons of hazardous and non hazardous waste is produced in Alang,
which seriously affects soil, water and air. Dr.Wishwas Rane of All India
Drug Action had brought out a comprehensive guide called Banned and
Banable Drugs. That guide lists out 23 out of 80 top selling drugs as
irrational and hazardous. While our country becomes dumping ground for
hazardous pills banned in West, Indian Council for Medical Research has
clearly established that an herbal product Vijaysar obtained from a bark of a
tree Pterocarpus marsupium helps control blood glucose levels, yet it has to
take off and enter the markets. Neocolonialism rules the roost, and we fail to

83
resist recolonization by west, which is trying to capture our medical market.
You may be aware that the Suez Canal (1869) and Panama Canal (1915)
Sethu Samudram Canal (1860) and Tenth Degree Canal have been mooted
to create short navigational routes to bring prosperity to their respective
regions and countries. The French initiative to build Siene_Norde Canal is
an example for the keen interest evinced by developing countries to promote
trade and overall development. You must go back to the pages of history to
know that Thailand then known, as Siam is an enemy country of the British
and an ally of the Japan during the World War II. On the conclusion of the
Second World War II, one of the last secretive acts performed by the
colonial Government of India was the signing of a Peace Treaty with Siam
(Thailand). A Peace Treaty between her Majesty’s Government and the
Government of India on one hand and the Kingdom of Siam on the other, on
January 1, 1946 at the Government House Singapore. The signatories were
for the Britain Mr. Moberly Dening, Political Adviser to Lord Louis Mount
batten, for Government of India Mr.M.S.Aney and for Siam (now Thailand)
Prince Viwat Anajai Jaiyant, Lt.General Phya Abhai Songgram and Nai
Serm Vinichayakul. This treaty contains 24 articles. Out of this Article 7
assumes importance in the context of this letter. Article 7: Siam undertakes
to construct no canal linking the Indian Ocean and the Gulf of Siam (i.e.
across the Kra Isthmus) without British consent. (Keesing's Contemporary
Archives 1946-48 Vol VI, p 7695). This article had done great havoc to
Indian shipping costing our nation billions of extra money by way of fuel
imports, in view of shelving of the Tenth Degree Canal project with the
imposition of a condition in this Peace Treaty. It has also blocked the
economic prosperity of Thailand and held up the development process by
half a century and more. Government of India and Government of Thailand
must look into the unfavorable conditions imposed by a colonial rule, that
too at the threshold of a defeat in Second World War II on Thailand, an ally
of Japan. It is in the interests of India and Thailand that a Canal be cut across
the Isthmus of Kra where the isthmus narrows to just 75 miles and to
develop this canal vigorously so that a detour of 1500 nautical miles down
the Malayan Coast via the Straits of Malacca and up the Gulf of Thailand in
the South China Sea is avoided. The proposed Tenth Degree Canal will be
an extension of the Tenth Degree channel in between Andaman and Nicobar
islands. The opening of Tenth Degree canal will result is saving millions of
tons of fuel foe world shipping. The Tenth Degree canal reduces the
importance of other major canals of the world namely Suez Canal and
Panama Canal. The Tenth Degree Canal would develop Andaman " Nicobar
Islands and bring prosperity to its economy. But instead of thinking on these

84
lines to develop Andaman Nicobar islands, the colonial mentality makes us
think of bartering away 23 remote Lakshadeep and Andaman islands to
foreigners. In Kerala people had to resist moves to hand over rivers to
multinationals. This how our Moghul rulers, Sultans, Nawabs, Nayaks and
other Indian kings opened the doors to colonialism in yesteryears. Let not
our soil become a breeding ground for neocolonialism. Let us not welcome
recolonisation.

Derogatory Remarks about Subramania Bharathiar

In Free Encyclopedia Deleted by Dravida Peravai

Indiainteracts.com is a platform where all sections can discuss many issues

and when my friend R.Bhagwan Singh of Deccan Chronicle suggested me to
join I felt that I can have interaction with editors and columnists here. I
thought I can read variety of subjects here. There are many thinkers who are
contributing to the national debate here, except a handful. They too need
Ram’s bridge to reap electoral dividends like the earlier Babri Masjid, where
they have washed their hands once power was gained. Because of these
electoral compulsions certain bloggers here have lost their mental
equilibrium to present views and leave it for the silent majority which reads
to arrive at their own conclusion. Dravida Peravai had taken up many issues
since its inception. Few years ago I rendered the following speech at
Mahakavi Bharathiar Museum Puducherry. You can read what I spoke. Not
only that we deleted the derogatory references against Bharathiar in
Wikipedia. That will show the decorum of the followers of Aringnar Anna.

Bharathi Anbargal Arakkattalai, is a group of Mahakavi Bharathiar’s fans

who gather at the initiative of the then Secretary to Government

85
S.Hemachandiran I.A.S and made it regular to meet in the Mahakavi
Bharathiar Memorial Museum on every month 11 th, since 11 th is the
birthday of Mahakavi. This month unusually a politician was called to speak
on Mahakavi. Sahitya Academy Awardee Writer Raja Narayanan, Professor
Panjangam, Dr. Daniel Jayaraj and other Bharathi followers were there.

N.Nandhivarman said that ‘While we Indian citizens are hailing Bharathiar

as a Bard of Indian Nationalism, we should also be aware that derogatory
remarks against him are spreading among netizens in all languages of the
world. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia in the net world has two pages of
reference about Bharathiar. The one under the title Subramanya Bharathi has
some lines under conspiracy theories, wherein the other side views of
Bharathiar are recorded, unnecessarily. Quoting verbatim what appeared in
the free encyclopedia:

Conspiracy theories: These conspiracy theories may be offensive to a few

Tamilians. Bharathi was addict to Ganja, a narcotic drug and was somewhat
mentally ill Though he publicly espoused the cause of freedom to women,
he didn’t provide enough freedom to even his wife .Though his poems and
words were against casteism, in reality he was living as a typical Iyer .He
was running a cotton mill and the product price was much higher than the
one by British. This situation makes the people to go for British products;
which affected Bharathi’s business and he started fighting against the British
for his business than for Indians

‘If in all languages such derogatory remarks against Bharathiar reach all the
nook and corner of the world, what should we do? Is it time to just sing
sonnets on Bharathi sitting at our homes, while in world Bharathiar is
portrayed as an oppressor of women, drug addict, casteist, selfish convert to
nationalist cause etc. Similarly in written Encyclopedias among the famous
diarists of the world renowned Ananda Ranga Pillai had not found his
legitimate place. Tamils and Tamil Scholars are closing their eyes to what
happens elsewhere. Otherwise how could our eminent men are left out in
written encyclopedias and in net encyclopedias derogatory remarks remain
without being expunged because our scholars did not raise voice of protest.’
said N.Nandhivarman

‘Mahakavi Bharathiar had been rare statesmen, visionary, and a universal

man whose thirst for world affairs made him the most knowledgeable
species of his times.’ said N.Nandhivarman and quoted from a book

86
Mahakavi Bharathi in the Hearts of Soviet people published in Russia in
1982 on the eve of his centenary. Sergei A.Baroozdin, a Soviet Writer states
that ‘Subramania Bharathi was a real friend of the Soviet Union. When the
first Soviet Revolution (1905-1907) took place in Old Russia, it was
Bharathi who wrote in the following in 1906. (Article: Russian Revolution
published in India magazine September 1906.) So when media was not as
powerful as of now, Bharathi amidst his poverty was keenly watching the
events in the world and commenting upon it.

Writer Raghunathan in the preface to the book mentioned above records ‘In
Fact Bharathi blossomed into the bard of freedom and projected himself into
the limelight of patriotic poetry at the turn of this century, in the wake of
Russian Revolution, which as is known, was one of the main factors that
prompted the Indian National liberation movement to turn militant, led by
able leaders like Bala Gangadhara tilak. Hence naturally Bharathi expressed
his support to ‘The just efforts of our Russian comrades in their struggle for
emancipation and for abolition of tyranny’ in an article written in September
1906 itself, said Raghunathan.

The Tamil Department in Pondicherry is named as Subramania Bharathiar

School of Tamil Studies, but Bharathiars followers are not offering practical
suggestions on how that Department could serve better, this lethargy should
go and scholars must offer practical suggestions, said N.Nandhivarman. He
also handed over a Report which he has submitted for creation of a
Bharathiar Chair in the Pondicherry University and the subjects it can
research upon.

[Published on November 27th, 2007 in Writing-Poetry | Views 1106]

Comments of Readers:

1. Ramarsetu Says: Posted on November 27th, 2007

How come you support Bharathi the barbarian? I am not saying that. Your
wily parent organization DK termed that those who worship gods were
barbarians! Bharathi was a Brahmin who wrote about ‘Aryan’ god Krishna,
so doesn’t he automatically become anti-Dravidian, as per what you have
claimed earlier.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subramanya_Bharathy#Religious__and_philoso
phical_poems

87
Tvvenkatesh Says:
Posted on November 27th, 2007

Well Nandhivarman, I might have lost my mental balance in your parlance,

when I said that you don’t understand Tamizh. Amazing that you took it in
some spirit and now try to give a justification that you had spoken highly
about Bharathi. Of course I do see larger shades of your mentor MK in all
the above writing. To me it only looks like when MK said Sri Rama is a
drunkard and later when he realized through his spies that he had indeed
antagonized a lot of Hindu believers, jumped in to say that he did not utter
anything derogatory and only that Valmiki said that. When people like Cho
pointed out the actual meaning of the word ‘Madhu’ as honey and not arrack
as intended by MK (He might be a great in Tamizh, but definitely restraint
needed while taking on other languages, especially the one which he hates so
much), he just had to keep quiet. Now you misquoted Bharathi conveniently
and when your flaw was pointed out, you say that the person who pointed
out is a brainless fellow and that you have spoken only great about Bharathi.
What is the use of speaking great about Bharathi, if you cannot understand
the real intentions of Bharathi while using certain words in poetic meter,
which otherwise may mean a little different.
Enna sir, logicke illayae unga vaadhathula.
Regards,
Venkatesh

3. MNachiappan Says:
Posted on November 27th, 2007

To put the facts straight, the anti-Hindu forces act internationally in different
angles. The Wikipedia is handled by fanatic Christians and they manipulate
the entries according to their vested interests. There is a proverb in Tamil
itself, ‘Wolf is so worried about drenching of a small lamb’. I have read
Nandi’s postings in other forums also and he is not a person who has any
steady stand or thinking. Claiming himself as ‘Dravidian’, atheist, etc., he
has been indulged in anti-Hindu, anti-Brahmin, anti-Hindi, anti-Indian
propaganda with his friends. Therefore, his apologia for Bhrathiar is
intriguing. As people criticize Mahatma Gandhiji, some people would
criticize Bharathiyar. Critical study is different from maligning personality.
Nandi does exactly maligning under the guise of supporting Bharathiar.

88
THE LONG DRAWN STRUGGLE
AGAINST AUROVILLE

Published on July 7th, 2008 in News, Politics | Views 936

The Government of India and International donors must take note of the
words of appreciation my blogs and statements are receiving from the
followers of Aurobindo Ghosh. All the mails we got and comments we
received had been a source of strength to us. Mr.Tushar N.Mohapatra, a
dedicated follower of the Aurobindonian family had posted on June 24 th of
2008 the following comments:

[Tuesday, June 24, 2008

89
N. Nandhivarman is doing a yeoman’s service for propagation of the Savitri
Era Religion [DRAVIDA PERAVAI 23 Jun 08 SAVE AUROVILLE
FROM FINANCIAL IRREGULARITIES] by nandhivarman]

N. Nandhivarman is doing a yeoman’s service to the evolutionary revolution

that was launched by The Mother and Sri Aurobindo. By turning the
searchlights upon Sri Aurobindo Ashram and the Auroville, he is generating
a lot of awareness as well as curiosity among the public. It is good for the
hospitality industry in Puducherry and also for the propagation of Savitri Era
Religion. If this nexus can work more openly and systematically, then we
shall really be able to take the idea of Human Unity very far. All kinds of
issues besetting a globalized world will look forward to a Puducherry
rendezvous for their solution. [TNM] Posted by Tusar N Mohapatra at 10:40
AM 0 comments Links Tuesday, June 24, 2008But I must place before the
world his views much before I started the recent open debate on Auroville.
Though I had spoken against Auroville in the Atheists Conference of 2006
and had written in Sinthanaiyalan Pongal issue of 2005, there had been
voices within Aurobindonian family to show the door to the Ex-Maharaja of
Kashmir Dr.Karan Singh, who like absentee landlord manages Auroville.

Also other demands raised by Tushar N.Mohapatra are given in his words
below including the date, year of that demands. Sunday, July 22, 2007 a
resident of Auroville should become the President of Auroville .The
President of India, the Prime Minister, and the members of his Cabinet
reside in India. The Chief Minister of Puducherry is a resident of the State.
But most of the persons nominated to the Governing Board of The Auroville
Foundation are not residents of Auroville. This is untenable; they must
resign forthwith. A resident of Auroville should become the President of
Auroville. [TNM] Posted by Tusar N Mohapatra at 9:44 AM 1 comments
Links Wednesday, July 18, 2007 they have no business to continue in such
positions

[For first time, govt to choose IIM directors The Times of India 18 Jul 2007
MUMBAI: This could be the final blow to the long-held autonomy of the
Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs).]

Are the 5 nominated members of The International Advisory Council of the

The Auroville Foundation well versed with the teachings of The Mother and
Sri Aurobindo? If not, they have no business to continue in such positions.

90
There are lot many others among the devotees with records of life long
dedication to the cause of the Life Divine. The Government must not impose
its bureaucratic whims over the organic growth of Auroville. [TNM] Posted
by Tusar N Mohapatra at 6:39 PM 1 comments Links

Thursday, June 12, 2008 Savitri Era Party welcomes N. Nandhivarman"s

100 Questions N. Nandhivarman, General Secretary, Dravida Peravai, in his
article, “AUROVILLE’s MATRIMANDIR: AN EYE OPENER," has
promised that he will raise “100 Questions for generating awareness about
the happenings in Auroville and to ensure Government of India intervenes to
effect amendment to Act and initiate corrective measures." [7:06 AM “12:22
PM] Savitri Era Party welcomes this. [TNM] Posted by Tusar N Mohapatra
at 6:26 PM 0 comments Links Saturday, June 14, Saturday, June 14, 2008
Savitri Era Party demands free elections, accountability, and transparency in
Auroville

[THANKS FOR BBC INITIATED DEBATE ON AUROVILLE -

indiainteracts.com By Google Inc. THANKS FOR BBC INITIATED
DEBATE ON AUROVILLE indiainteracts.com, India - The New Age
commune revealed on TV is guiltier of child neglect than abuse, says Loic
Rich. “I was not surprised by the allegations of child abuse at. …The New
Age Living Blog - http://newagelivinblog.com THANKS FOR BBC
INITIATED DEBATE ON AUROVILLE indiainteracts.com - Chennai,
Tamil Nadu, India “I was not surprised by the allegations of child abuse at
Auroville – a progressive European community in India- that BBC news
team made this week. …See all stories on this topic]

The recent BBC (un)coverage on Auroville is admittedly low on propriety

but compensating high on priority. Probably, years of good work get a bad
name all of a sudden, but simultaneously, some sordid goings on also come
under scrutiny, which otherwise would not have happened so easily.

The Congress has the satisfaction that it rules at least a tiny patch of Tamil
Nadu through Dr. Karan Singh. But the 1988 Act, without territorial
demarcation, deems to be in fructuous as of today. As such, continuation of
the present Governing Body is not only illegal but also
illegitimate.Matrimandir is the sacred shrine for the innumerable adherents
of Savitri Era Religion. It is painful for the Savitri Erans to learn that certain
high-ranking persons are colluding with nefarious activities and indulging in
falsehood. Savitri Era Party wants change and demands free elections,

91
accountability, and transparency. [TNM] Posted by Tusar N Mohapatra at
6:41 PM 0 comments Links

THE QUESTION NOW HAUNTING US? WHY DOES WESTERNERS

CHOOSE AUROVILLE. OUR PEOPLE WENT TO CARRIBEANS TO
EARN A GOOD LIVING WHICH TURNED OUT TO BE A MIRAGE
CHASE. THEY LOST THEIR CULTURE. HERE WESTERNERS HAVE
COME TO MAKE A GOOD LIVING BETTER THAN WESTERN
STANDARDS. THEY ALSO HAD ADMINISTERED CULTURAL
SHOCKS ON OUR SOCIETY.GAY SEX:

One person talks about his homosexual relationship in a letter with us. He
says since 1977 he was having homosexual relationship. His Indian male
partner had sent 120 love letters to this western male, as per his letter dated
6th October 1996. The westerner had given 19 lakhs to the homo-partner,
and to earn this the German had worked in petrol bunks during his visits to
his home country Germany. It appears that the innocent Indian polluted by
this German also cheated Dieter Wilm of Germany. This German tells in his
letter that his Indian contact gave him marijuana to sell in Germany and it
was found by German police. This Germans letter speaks of a triangular
homosexual relationship. It also mentions about many western names, of
Aurovillians of those days. Later this German went to live in Puducherry.
His name is Volker A.Annuss. Auroville had such people, it is history. It is
their duty to weed out such crimes if it exists now instead of barking against
citizens who voice concern for public good.

LESBIAN SEX:
We gave a CD which was sold in free markets titled Auroville Beauties,
wherein a western man will be watching two poor young Tamil girls made to
perform lesbian acts before the camera. Also in another clipping a western
man will be making sex with a Tamil girl before the camera. This indicates
shooting of such scenes for selling in abroad. Dravida Peravai gave those
CD’s to the then Superintendent of Intelligence Bureau Mr.Ramdass for
forwarding to Government to take stringent action .There ends the matter.
What action government took it is only known to Government of India. Such
CD’s were given to BBC, but due to ethical standards British press did not
publish nor did BBC telecast such porn videos.

The Tamil boys who had made it regular hobby to chase white girls, and
Tamil women falling prey into contracts to live with westerners in exchange

92
of monetary gains only to be ditched sooner, and a story of one Tamil’s wife
got married to a westerner without divorcing the husband, all such real
happenings undermining our culture and society, the free media of our
country must come forward to expose through investigative journalism.

N.Nandhivarman, General Secretary, Dravida Peravai

This entry was posted on Monday, July 7th, 2008 at and is filed under News,
Politics.

7 Responses to “AUROBINDO DEVOTEES VOICE CONCERN ABOUT

AUROVILLE”
1. Peveve Says:
Posted on July 7th, 2008

Why blame the west. Let’s take the case of OP Raman who married a
beautiful girl from Sri Lanka in a self respect marriage in true pseudo-
Dravidian style. What happened to his married life after the lumpen who
handed over the thali and conducted the marriage sent OPR on a trip
immediately to Singapore alone on an official trip and who came back to see
the powerful lumpen had already stolen his wife of few days and later on
became the wife of another lumpen. Which westerner influenced this lumpen
behaviour sir? And let’s not forget your propensity to shoot off letters to
Antonia Maino and Raul vinchi. Can you tell us how one person who claims
was born in Dec 1943 when that person’s father was in jail in distant Soviet
Union since 1940 for being a Nazi? Where was that person born, Orbassano
or Luciano? And you are obsessed with auroville. The degeneration of
society in TN is plainly because of vulgar movies of Kamalahssan and
others of his ilk and the entry of movie lumpens into politics.

2. Nandhivarman Says:
Posted on July 7th, 2008

The beautiful language you command is a gift exclusively for you. On Earth
no one can excel you in weaving words with such great hidden facts about
history. Instead of wasting time in reading my useless blogs and
commenting on that if you can write novels on the subjects you have in
mind, you can be a best novelist. Wish you concentrate your energies there.

93
3. Peveve Says:
Posted on July 8th, 2008

Thanks for your words. Maybe you don’t blv about OP Raman but these are
facts that was revealed by one lumpens trusted former aide. I don’t know if
he is alive but what I heard is he has lost his senses thanks to the ravenous
leader machinations. Isn’t it a shame that the stolen wife of OP Raman was
foisted on another lumpen who was just an ordinary clerk in a Central govt
office and enjoys the patronage of this lumpen leader? Is it hurting to read
these Mr. Nandhivarman as the truth slowly unfolds about this modern day
prophet Maha Moodan. Even in the graveyard marriage he almost mimicked
him only he forcibly married a 16 year old to prolong his useless life the
only difference is the other one raped an 8 year old Ayesha.This lumpen
leader who got into trouble earlier for a Volvo car was of such poor IQ and
was once heard admonishing his driver when the car he was travelling broke
down and shouted at him for not filling in radiator water. And once while
discussing with his nephew on the Indo-Pak war of 1971 asked his great
“educated’ nephew how dog fights took place in the air. His ‘well-read’
nephew said one plane flew over the other and he will open his cockpit
window and drop the bomb on the other plane! Such wonderful men of
rationalist thinking. I heard these from a person who used to be always with
this lumpen and that person is no more and hence his physical safety cannot
be affected for revealing them now.

4. Ramji Says:
Posted on July 10th, 2008

Mr Nandivanam,
I thought I will do a cut and past job for a change about your elite leader,
none other than the great manjul thunndu fame,, the one and the only one, Dr
M.K.the curse of the Indian community, in particular, the Hindu community.
Enjoy it! Apparent speech by our beloved leader M.K:

5. Peveve Says:
Posted on July 10th, 2008

Really enjoyed every word of yours ramji. Gr8 keep it up. While this rascal
has made his billions there is another snake in the grass PC. He has made
100,000 crores in the stock market scam. Karthi with his benami classmates

94
is going around in two cars. One car stuffed with cash to buy land left right
and centre. Mr. Nandhivarman next time you spot Karthi in Pondichery just
ask the public in Pondichery to catch hold of the car that follows and let the
public split the looted money. Will you do it, Sir?

6. Ramji Says:
Posted on July 11th, 2008

Thanks Peveve, I should not any take credit for this post, it was a cut and
paste job, from? Tamil Hindu, if I remember correctly, all credit goes to that
person who penned it, it was hilarious!!!

7. Peveve Says:
Posted on July 14th, 2008

Hi, traitor is you a devotee? If you are one you would be ashamed to
associate yourself with anything named Dravida with all the wrong
connotations it stands for. Stop your drama.

NO SANCTUARY FOR SITA

IN RAMAYANA PLAY
Sita as a rape victim who chose to die by jumping into Ravana’s funeral pyre
as the agni pariksha [test of fire] - this is the dramatic new interpretation of

95
the Ramayana published in the form of the play, Sanctuary, released in
Bangalore on Thursday i.e. 10 th July 2008.Bangalore born Author Hema
Ramakrishna, who has been living in Srilanka since a decade, asks “What
makes anyone think a man who abducted a woman will keep her in ivory
tower and worship her? “

“It is psychologically inadmissible” she told MAIL TODAY. Hema has

taken many liberties with the original story. The Lanka in her play becomes
Ranka and is located near the Chilka lakes of Orissa. The image of the
maryadha purusha [ideal man] Rama is questioned as his treatment of two
women, his wife Sita and Ravana’s sister Surpanaka, comes under strong
feminist scanner.

The trigger for Ravana kidnapping Sita was Rama’s brutal rejection of the
beautiful Surpanaka and her mutilation. Hema has brother Ravana stating
“What ruffians to treat a woman like this?” Sanctuary was first published
four years ago in Srilanka by Vijita Yapa Publications, and the same
publisher has now released it in Bangalore. The delay was owing to the time
Hema took to gather the courage to release the book in India.

“Now I feel the country is civilized enough to accept another view point on
the myth. It is we who have made it a religion, The Ramayana is a myth
about a man and his people” she contented.

Even the thought of the ruling BJP in Karnataka has not deterred her from
releasing the book there. “I have lot of respect for the CM. I think he will see
the book for what it is and hold back rabid elements.” she said. The play
features a deglamourized Sita, who loses her beauty and vitality with the
rape. Ravana even has her tongue cut out, because of the abuses she heaps
on him during the act. Finally when Rama does see Sita at Asokavana, he is
repelled by her. An enraged and despairing Sita jumps into Ravana’s funeral
pyre and dies at the end of the play, even as Rama moans “My punishment is
come upon me now. My dreaded punishment is come “. For Hema, Sita is a
representative of all women. “What happened to Sita is an eternal enigma
and as long as there are women, we will keep writing about it”, she said.

Yapa, a former journalist, who released the book with Hema, said he
published the book as he was always interested in alternative view points.
“If it causes a storm here, I am willing to face it “, he stated.

96
Courtesy: By Sowmya Ali from Bangalore published in MAIL TODAY,
daily at New Delhi on 11 th July 2008.

This post is dedicated to the very few hate mailers who instead of writing
their blogs or views will post irrelevant comments unconnected to the topics,
I discuss with dignity and decorum.

This entry was posted on Saturday, July 12th, 2008 at and is filed under
News, Parties, and Politics...

16 Responses to “HEMAYANA SAYS SITA IS RAPE VICTIM”

1. Peveve Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

And Roberto Rajiv Ghandy is a rape victim too by a professional seductress

from Italian-German origin. What about OP Raman’s wife? By the way are
in true kalaignar’s tradition too. How many victims you have under your
belt? Or are you like Siriyan Ramasamy first rape and then marry in true DK
style?

2. Peveve Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

I think as a ‘Dravidian’ historian of “repute” you will be able to confirm if it

was true that Veeramani was ‘kept’ by a widow of that organization and that
is how he laid his hands on the entire assets of that organization which was
nothing but looted wealth.

3. Vedaprakash Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Mr. Nandivarman, I have challenged many times, but as a coward, you have
been keeping quite or running away from one forum or the other. For your
earlier Paula Richman’s book, I have posted a counter article as follows, but
you have no dignity or decorum to respond. The so-called 300 / 3000
Ramayanas: The Dravidian propaganda
http://vedaprakash.indiainteracts.com/2008/03/16/the-so-called-300- 000-
ramayana s-the-dravidian-propaganda/

Coming to your posting, you simply vomit the so-called “feminist scanner”
without going into the details. Who are these Hema Ramakrishna and
Sowmiya Ali? If they really scan in their feminist approach, they should

97
have done it in all aspects. When there has been a time of writing
“Kimayana” (the opposite of Ramayana). When you depend upon Hema,
you are suppressing her. Hema’s arrogance is revealed when she contends
that, “Now I feel the country is civilized enough to accept another view
point on the myth. It is we who have made it a religion, The Ramayana is a
myth about a man and his people”. Who is to decide about the ‘civilized or
uncivilized status of India”? Should not Nandi have some sense when she
treks on such path of haughtiness?

Taking your posting: “The play features a deglamourized Sita, who loses her
beauty and vitality with the rape. Ravana even has her tongue cut out,
because of the abuses she heaps on him during the act. Finally when Rama
does see Sita at Asokavana, he is repelled by her. An enraged and despairing
Sita jumps into Ravana’s funeral pyre and dies at the end of the play, even as
Rama moans “My punishment is come upon me now. My dreaded
punishment is come “. For Hema, Sita is a representative of all women.
“What happened to Sita is an eternal enigma and as long as there are women,
we will keep writing about it”, she said”. • Is it actually feminist scanning or
feminist sadism psychologically?• When she has decided to fly in imaginary
world, she should thought about Ravana cutting Sita’s tongue and other
torturous acts committed on her.• The play features a deglamourized Sita,
who loses her beauty and vitality with the rape. Wonderful, indeed the
scanning! • In fact, I need not discuss such things, as only imagination roosts
without anything. • “An enraged and despairing Sita jumps into Ravana’s
funeral pyre”, yes, she is not Sita and also Sita of Valmiki Ramayana, but
Hema’s “ayana” – “Hemayana”.

• If her imagination has not been conditioned, tainted or imbibed, the, she
should start scanning, all women like Sita. Can she take the cases of Mary
and Kathija? • Nandi, can you recommend her? • Like Kimayana, why there
has not been any “Gibal”, “Kiran” etc. or Hemable, Hemakuran?

• Being a woman, that too so popular, how she could have forgotten those
two Goddesses, ladies or angles or simply women? Here comes the
hypocrisy, scanning duplicity, feminist selectivity, women supporting
womanizers and so on. Ironically, I tried for the e-paper:

http://mailtoday.in/epapermain.aspx?
queryed=9&querypage=4&boxid=2414431& amp;
parentid=8096&eddate=07/11/08, but it is virus infected just like the

98
notorious ones. So if you cannot debate, just keep quiet, instead of posting
here and there and run away. VEDAPRAKASH 12-07-2008.

4. Vedaprakash Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Now, I find that purposely, 2005 news is repeated here now through “mail
today” dated 11-07-2008. It appeared in August 12, 2008 - The Times of
India. Ramayana gets a feminist twist 12 Aug 2005, 1006 hrs IST, Sowmya
Aji Mehu, TNN

BANGALORE: Giving a new dimension to the Rama-Sita relationship, a

Bangalore-based author has written a poetic English play, Sanctuary that
inverts several accepted standards in the Ramayana. Hema Ramakrishna, 60,
has thrown fresh light on the quintessential Indian drama. In her foreword to
the play, she says her work is part of the intellectual and emotional churning
in the country, post-Babri Masjid demolition in 1992.

Her story de-glorifies both Rama and Ravana. Hers is a strongly feminist
view: Rama’s treatment of two women-Sita and Surpanaka-comes under the
scanner. Hema says, “Rama is that perfect being that can do no wrong. No
doubt whatsoever is cast on his person, never mind how fraught his actions
are with expediency, especially when it comes to the shabby treatment of his
wife. And the unsavory details of Surpanaka’s mutilation.'’ The play has
been published by a Lankan bookhouse. But the Lanka in the play is not the
same. It is Ranka, located in the ‘Mahasamund’ Bay of Bengal, next to
Orissa’s Chilka lakes.

The other changes are practical- Ravana is not ten-headed. He has ten men
beheaded to ward off his predicted “untimely death'’.Hanuman and gang
don’t build a bridge across the sea, but Vibhishana, Hanuman, Rama and
Lakshmana swim with Vanaras to Ravana’s island and sneak in through a
secret way into the palace-castle. There is no war. The street-smart Rama
knows Vanaras cannot match Ravana’s crack army. He marches into
Ravana’s bedroom in the night and kills him. Surpanaka is the story-trigger;
Ravana kidnaps Sita because his sister is mutilated by Rama and
Lakshmana. The demon king tells the audience: “What ruffians to attack a
woman like this!'’ Sita comes in just one scene, but Hema endows her with
doom. The invasion of Ranka is because of her, “a mere woman'’, much to
the Vanaras’ disgruntlement.

99
Hema’s reworked storyline is all in reported speech: Sita fights Ravana, but
cannot match his force. Her tongue is cut for cursing him. She loses speech,
beauty, vitality and cowers in fear in Asokavana. Rama, repelled by the
changes, rejects her.

The Agni Pariksha conveys new thought. Hema makes it an angry rejection
of male-dominance: Sita jumps into Ravana’s burning funeral pyre and dies,
leaving Rama guilt-ridden. The end is Trikala Narada’s epilogue: “Long
before the first poets sang of him, Rama’s name and fame were well known.
But somewhere along the way, on the long and dusty road taking us back to
Ayodhya, many changes crept into being. For it is we who invent our myths,
we who create them, shape them and sing them out..'’So why repeat it now?
Just to create problem or otherwise? Mr. Nandi, clarify immediately.

5. Nathappan Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Excellent Vedam!!

The DK & their worms like Nandi can only vomit or cut/paste from others’
works, just for propaganda purposes, but cannot think straight!!Dishonest
idiots like him will not answer your replies, because they are just idiots and
do not care to think for themselves, only follow what KV or MK says!!
‘Decency, decorum…’ - all tall claims by rogues like you cannot deceive us
any more - it is a bigger conspiracy by all anti-Hindu elements!!

6. Nathappan Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Nandi, you think only you can cut & paste??From organizer -Rajnath is
right. Secularism has become communal By Shyam Khosla

Two other concepts—Socialist and Secular—were added to the Preamble

during the hated Emergency by the 42nd Constitutional Amendment that
came into force on January 3, 1977. How irrationally even knowledgeable
persons react to innocuous suggestions because of political compulsions and
ideological confusion is borne out by Congress spokesperson Abhishek
Manu Singhvi’s and CPM leader Sitaram Yahcuri’s response to BJP
President’s remark that the correct Hindi translation of secular was
panthnirpeksh and not dharamnirpeksh that is often perceived to be the
synonym of the concept. Yachuri’s comment that it was Sangh’s
terminology to underline its belief that Hinduism is a religion and other

100
religions like Christianity and Islam are sects, betrays the Communist
leader’s gross ignorance of the RSS thinking and Hindu ethos. He will do
well to come out of his Marxist shell and make some effort to at least
understand rival viewpoints.

One, however, can’t ignore the galling observations made by Congress

leader giving his knowledge of our cultural values and the Constitution. He
is well aware that the authorized Hindi translation of the Constitution talks
of panthnirpeksh and not dharamnirpeksh. It is outright absurd on his part to
suggest Singh’s observations that words secular and socialist were
unnecessarily inserted in the Preamble to the Constitution in 1976-77
amounted to the subversion of the basic tenets of the Constitution and
negation of its soul. The fact remains that these terms were inserted to meet
political exigencies at the fag end of the Emergency. Socialism is a political
philosophy with which a vast majority of Indians are not comfortable and
our Constitution was no less secular before the insertion of the term in the
Preamble. BJP President committed no crime by asking his colleagues and
the Government to stick to the correct terminology. Why is the aging party
protesting too much? Isn’t it yet another gimmick to mislead minorities?

The founding fathers of our Constitution had wisely adopted the Preamble
that solemnly resolved to constitute India into a Sovereign Democratic
Republic. Two other concepts—Socialist and Secular—were added to the
Preamble during the hated Emergency by the 42nd Constitutional
Amendment that came into force on January 3, 1977. The Preamble is a
vision statement through which the Constitution Assembly expressed its
intent. Can this intent be amended subsequently? More importantly, is such
an exercise morally and politically correct?

Interestingly the Supreme Court had in one of its landmark judgments laid
down the concept of basic structure and while doing so underlined the
importance of the Preamble to the Constitution. That judgment came long
before the 42nd amendment which inserted two additional concepts. These
were inserted into the all-important Preamble when democracy was under
siege with a large number of parliamentarians were rotting in jails, press had
lost its freedom and even the judiciary was under tremendous pressure. It is
high time that there is an in-depth public debate on the political and moral
desirability of retaining these two words in the Preamble. Nothing will be
lost if these two concepts are removed from the Preamble of the
Constitution.

101
Much of the confusion in public mind is caused by the flawed belief that
religion and dharma are synonyms. As a result, characteristics of a narrow
religion are automatically attributed to the concept of dharma. Religion
means a creed or a sect. Longman English Dictionary defines religion as a
system of beliefs and practices relating to the sacred and uniting its adherent
in a community. Religion, thus, is a comparatively narrow concept that
believes in one sacred book, a messenger and a God likes the ones in
Judaism, Christianity and Islam. These religions believe that there is only
one path to the achievement of the highest spiritual goal—whatever it may
be called. Hindu Dharma, on the other hand, is a vastly wider concept that is
concerned with all aspects of human life. The fundamental principles of
dharma are eternal and universal. It transcends religions and holds that all
paths lead to the same goal. This concept is beautifully expressed in the
Vedic maxim: Ekam Sadvipraha Bahudha Vadanti (Truth is one, savants tell
them variously). Fundamental laws of human nature that decides the
propriety of human behaviour is dharma. M.V. Nadkarni in his work,
Hinduism—A Gandhian Perspective, points out that the traditional term for
Hinduism is Sanatana Dharma. He argues that it doesn’t connote fixed, let
alone stagnant. The dictionary meaning of Sanatana is eternal. The secret of
Hinduism’s perpetuity is that it is not fixed for all times but refreshes itself
every now and then, adjusting to new circumstances, incorporating new and
noble values. Sanatana, he insists, also doesn’t mean orthodox or
conservative. The secret of its endurance for millennia is its dynamism. Shri
Basaveshwara says, “What is standing fixed perishes, but not one which is
dynamic”. The quality of dynamism is very closely related to tolerance for
pluralism, for diversity, for inclusiveness and, thus, to liberalism in its purest
form. That is why Arnold Toynbee called Hinduism a “live and let-live
religion”. Question may be asked if dharma is eternal and applicable to all
times and all climes and races, why call it Hindu Dharma. The fact of the
matter is that since times immemorial, it was called Sanatana Dharma—
eternal law. However, in the course of history, it began to be called Hindu
Dharma. Somehow, the word Hindu stuck and is now more popularly used
than Sanatana Dharma.

“Secularists” refuse to see reason. They persist with their hidden agenda by
projecting Hinduism in a narrow context that is rationally and historically
flawed. In the political sense, secularism requires separation of the state
from any particular religious order. Nobel Laureate Amritya Sen, who by no
stretch of imagination is “communal”, in his Argumentative Indian says

102
secularism can be interpreted in at least two different ways. The first view
argues that secularism demands that the state be equidistant from all
religions refusing to take sides and having a neutral attitude towards them.
The second—more severe—view insists that the state must not have any
relation at all with any religion. The equidistance must take the form, then,
of being altogether removed from each other. In both interpretations,
secularism goes against giving any religion a privileged position in the
activities of the state. Calling himself an “unreformed secularist”, Sen, goes
on to admit that the former—broader interpretation of secularism—is the
dominant approach to secularism in India. He insists that the state must
maintain a basic symmetry to all religious groups. Unfortunately, the
concept has been taken to absurd lengths by certain elements by extending
certain rights to a particular minority that are not available to majority
community not necessarily out of commitment to secularism but for petty
partisan gains. Since secularism demands basic symmetry to all religious
groups, any attempt to favour a particular religious group amounts to
distorting the concept inviting ridicule. This distorted version of secularism
has been aptly dubbed as pseudo-secularism.

Theocracy has no place in our value system and secularism as a value—

justice to all and discrimination against none—is an integral part of the
Indian value system and national psyche. This land has been a great melting
pot that has assimilated people of countless religious faiths and races that
made this country their home. The shared cultural outlook and civilization
that evolved in this land for millennia have produced such cohesion—a
homogenous identity—that is one of the essential attributes of nationhood.
Muslims and Christians rulers who held sway over large parts of the country
for about 800 years were, of course, non-secular. They discriminated against
religious groups and bestowed huge favours on persons belonging to their
respective faiths. There were exceptions in the long and glorious history of
this land that never discriminated against people on the basis of their
religious faith or race.

7. Ramarsetu Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Guys read here about Periyar’s diary entry as to how Nandivarman became a
eunuch and why he vomits shit. Poor men have pity on him. Please post your
sympathy for him there.

http://tinyurl.com/5fpdxo

103
8. VandeMataram Says: Posted on July 12th, 2008

Only a law suit will teach people like Nandhivarman & Sowmya Ali better
lessons than what Ramayana can teach.

9. Vedaprakash Says: Posted on July 13th, 2008

I am extremely sorry for the typographical errors appearing in my above

posting, as I typed hurriedly provoked by Nandi.However, kindly note that
“Sowmya Aji Mehu” is mentioned in TOI, but Nandi records it as “Sowmya
Ali’ with due courtesy. Of course, it is left to “Sowmya” as to whether her
husband is “Ali” now in 2008 or “Aji Mehu” in 2005.But Nandi has to
respond. Friends, these guys have been supported with hackers with a lot of
IT expertise behind it just like www.allempires.com
They send virus, crack our pass words, intrude into your computers, and
crash them. I do not know whether out IT friends would help us. I was
terribly attacked twice by these guys (computer crashed) losing all my data.

10. Nandhivarman Says:

Posted on July 13th, 2008

The learned scholars instead of posting their original thoughts usually

exhibit their inborn hate towards bloggers like me, by posting abusive stories
about Periyar EVR, Aringnar Anna and Kalaignar, though I am not in DMK
and parted company in 1994, neither I was from DK.Periyar EVR and
Aringnar Anna are our icons. Though running a separate party I respect
Kalaignar. I have a right to respect these leaders as the people who comment
have right to criticize them.

Most of the readers who don’t comment are the JUDGES, who read my
blogs and its comments. They will arrive at their own conclusion. One thing
surprises me. ALL THOSE WHO COMMENTED HAVE NOT TOUCHED
Ms.HEMA RAMAKRISHNAN in their COMMENTS. Therein may remain
the hidden reason. May be she is Brahmin, so our friends don’t want to
attack her, instead they call me eunuch.

A king, who married 60,000 wives, could only be an imaginary character of

a myth. Otherwise how could he sleep with all 60,000 in his life time would
have become a research topic? Lord Indira who was cursed, Lord Brahma

104
who lost one head, The petty god born out of gay sex between two great
gods, are not written by me or anyone of our movement. Let these
champions take on those who created these myths. These comments do not
deserve a reply. It is for people to judge by reading both sides.

11. Vedaprakash Says: Posted on July 14th, 2008

Nandi, you are playing double-game. Just morning, I send this reply to you
and your friends / groups mentioned (as forwarded by Mr. K. V.
Ramakrishna Rao), but they are not going, but being returned one by one, as
I type this. Any way, since you have responded, I post my reply now:

Dear friends, Vanakkam.I have been also watching carefully about the
wrangle between Nandi and others. In fact, I too oppose the way in which
Nandi reacts against the issues, which have been anti-Hindu. I have also
posted my response / challenge, “Challenge to Feminists, atheists and others:
Discuss about all Goddesses, Angles or women.”
at:http://vedaprakash.indiainteracts.com/2008/07/13/challenge-to-feminists-
atheists -and-others-discuss-about-all-goddesses-angles-or-women/Here, no
mincing of words, etc., if possible, any one can discuss, debate or counter.

I am also a Tamilian, born and brought up in Tamilnadu and I know Tamil

as you know. May be some of you have some complexities working at
different levels imbibed with various ideologies coupled with hypotheses
and theories.Mr. K. V. Ramakrishna Rao, historian has given details the way
he was treated in Tamil groups” (you may be knowing the facts). This is
only one example. Intellectually arguing with facts is different from
oppressing and suppressing of the views of others, just because they expose
your outdated, politically biased, racial, and incidentally anti-Hindu. By
being an atheist, reformer, or a Tamilian, he need not be anti-Hindu, anti-
Hindi, and anti-north, anti-Indian opposing the factors of culture, tradition,
heritage and civilization of India. You cannot expect every Tamilian to be
pro-LTTE, as otherwise, he is anti-Tamil. This attitude is totally wrong and
most of the Tamil groups are doing that mistake.EVR, Anna, Karunanidhi or
any Dravidian ideologist or protagonist would be naturally opposed by the
ideologists of opposite groups, because of their biased views. They have to
be studied critically. I have posted many topics in the so-called
www.indiainteracts.com. They are open. In fact, I tell you some serious
Tamils like M. Nachiappan, Ezhavendan and others have been questioning
the Dravidian ideology. Kindly go through the threads and respond. If you

105
pour venom on their factors, naturally, they could do the same. After all
dogs bark against each other also. But let us not be dogs, but human beings.

VEDAPRAKASH
14-07-2008.
—————————
Read my posting as mentioned and then talk about. I again challenge you
and all your friends, if you have guts respond to my article. I have discussed
about everything: do not talk nonsense of all these things 60,000 wives and
all. When most of the Dravidian leaders - your mentors / Gurus have more
wives; that is myth but your friends are real and contemporary.

You are not able to change the contemporary society, social members, social
groups, but talk about myth and set one group of people against other by
mentioning Brahmin, non-Brahmin etc. This is ridiculous. Why disown your
Karu? Where is your respect to leaders of India? Can you imagine any Arab
talking nonsense like you against Allah or Mohammed and his wives? Can
you expect any Israeli to talk rubbish about their Gods and national heroes?
Can you note any Christian of Christian nation abusing Jehovah, Jesus
Christ, Joseph, Mary etc? But as an Indian you and your friends do. As an
atheist, as a Tamil, as a Dravidian, .you do and try to get away. Shame
Nandi, shame.

Your are exposed, because of your duplicity not for anything.

12. Peveve Says: Posted on July 14th, 2008

Francois Gautier says that thanks to Buddha Indians lost the will to fight.
Even the great Yudhistra shouted that Ashwathamma was dead without
adding that it was the elephant. Vedaprakash sir, you are wrong on how to
fight these rascals. Fight sword with sword filth with filth they understand
only such language. The days of pussy footing are over. Just to fight the
anti-Hindus one should not blindly support the characterless people like
Vajpayee or Advani (where is the promised Ram Temple?) We don’t need
Mahajans in a party like BJP with roots from SP Mukerjee, Deen Dayal and
Balraj Madhok. If BJP has to grow they have to unceremoniously dump
these characters and take on the anti-Bharat forces under Modi. Bhagvatam
says that India will once again regain its rightful place -the most powerful
nation on earth under a Sanyasi. It has been Modi. Poor Nandhivar, man and
other spies and traitors like mba Nasriddinpoovai and gsuresh. It is ordained

106
that Modi will be the PM. Thankfully Advani’s horoscope clearly indicates
he won’t become the PM ever. He is only a hot air bag. Tomorrow he will
sell India if that will make him the PM.

13. Peveve Says: Posted on July 14th, 2008

Quote: I was from DK.Periyar EVR and Aringnar Anna are our icons.
Though running a separate party I respect Kalaignar. I have a right to respect
these leaders as the people who comment has right to criticize them…” If
these are the type of characterless characters are your icons (don’t include
the public), we expect you will only repeat what they’ve done. Rape and
marry. Only goons will respect a crass human being like MK.
14. Kumar Says: Posted on July 14th, 2008

This shows the emptiness of these idiots. They cannot imagine and write a
story and the easiest way to stardom is to take an established line, rape it and
present some nonsense as if it is an innovation. If you go to periyar thidal
you can listen to lot many concocted versions of the puranas and no wonder
our nandi feels thrilled. If it is anything that relates to sex our nandi gets
thrilled. He is worried about how a man with 60,000 wives entertained his
wives. In the same breath, can nandi also clarify how was an old man with a
walking stick who cannot hold “his stick” marry an bosom, voluptuous
women and entertained her day in and day out. Was it done to serve her as a
treat to his adivarudigals...Pathetic? Shut up and pack up Nandi. You have
no place in an intelligent society and Hema Ramakrishnan think India is now
civilized without thinking about idiots like you.

15. Nathappan Says: Posted on July 14th, 2008

Sorry Kumar, I do not know about this -“can nandi also clarify how was an
old man with a walking stick who cannot hold “his stick” marry an bosom,
voluptuous women and entertained her day in and day out. Was it done to
serve her as a treat to his adivarudigals” but I know, you know and everyone
knows that the siriyon evr married his ‘daughter’ at a very old age, that even
anna ridiculed it as ‘70-30′!! What a champion!!Even Dasaratha with 60,000
wives is better than being a ‘pedophile’ like evr!!Evr joined nudist societies
while he was in Germany and that is a fact that cannot be wished away by
these jokers!!What a leader! What disciples!!Utterly shameless!!

16. Peveve Says: Posted on July 15th, 2008

107
This nincompoop only had Brahmin tenants in Erode. Such was the
champion of non-Brahmins! A chap who called Thamizh as barbarian
language (just because barbaric DK lumpens, momins and xians also speak
that language it cannot become barbaric is a fact he is undeveloped skull
hole did not know!). Did he utter it in frustration because even MK could
write decently in Thamizh, is a moot question that deserves some delving.

OIL SUMMIT- OIL PRICES-INDIA NEEDS PRO-

PEOPLE GLOBAL POLICY
MAKE AMARTHYA SEN FINANCE MINISTER SACK CHIDAMBARAM

Today the meeting of Oil Producing and Exporting Countries is taking place
initiated by Saudi Arabia which was pressurized by G-8 and others to ponder
over stabilizing the oil prices. The panacea Saudi Arabia offers is a hike of 6
percent of its oil production, hoping other countries will follow suit. We are
of the opinion that this will not work. The rising prices of oil and petroleum
products could not be arrested. Why do we opine so, let me record our
views.

1. Saudi Arabia is not, as many may be thinking, the largest producer of oil.
Russia stands first, and there is no hope that Russian President will play the
Saudi Arabian tune of increasing oil production.

2. The worlds largest 20 oil fields were all discovered between 1917 and
1979 and the annual output from these oil fields is falling by 4 million
barrels per day, says a Report of Earth Policy Institute. Taking into account
country specific data details and projections, German based Energy Watch
Group concludes that world oil production has peaked. It will also decline
by 7 percent a year falling to 58 million barrels per day in 2020.

3. The year our former President A.P.J.Abdul Kalam predicted to be a

turning point to make India a super power, 2020, will make India run from

108
pillar to post begging for oil. The begging for oil is going to be the order of
this century, and there has to be introspection.

4. Venezuela, the fifth largest producer of oil had declined to attend the
Summit of OPEC called by Saudi Arabia. It opines cosmetic exercises like
hike in production a little bit will not be a long term solution. The Socialist
President of Venezuela, Mr. Hugo Chavez, who finds a place among leaders
this century must emulate displayed in Dravida Peravai banners, feels the
increase in production is not to ease oil prices and reduce the burden on
common man, but to help speculation. He had earlier said in a BBC
interview in 2006 that by 1990, the price of a barrel was just 20 US dollars.
The oil producing countries must have a long term policy and fix the
maximum profitable and reasonable price of 50 US dollars per barrel, and if
the countries arrive at a consensus to sell oil 50 US dollars per barrel for a
long period, that alone will help the world, Mr. Hugo Chavez opines.

Dravida Peravai feels he is the voice of the conscience of the world. A

nation that got Independence led by Mahatma Gandhi must back Venezuelan
President in world forums but India also joins the chorus of greedy nations,
sorry greedy companies that dictate their nation’s choices, in keeping oil
prices in high. Our rulers are only for slight reduction in prices as eye wash.
They are not even speaking loud for common good of the mankind.

The supply and demand of oil on an average remains 85 million barrels per
day. Till 2003 USA was only holding 350 million barrels as buffer stocks.
Now it had doubled to 750 million barrels, which also creates artificial
scarcity resulting in hiking of prices. By 2006 when oil prices touched 60
US dollars per barrel, The Senate Committee of USA woke up and examined
the ground reality and told the ‘stock piling of companies hoping to make a
kill when prices go up’ is also one of the reasons of soaring oil prices.

M.R.Venkatesh, a Chennai based chartered accountant rightly pointed out in

rediff.com, that OPEC is not determining the prices of oil, but 4 American
finance companies. Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, J.P.Morgan Chase, and
Morgan Stanley are determining the rise in oil prices, this Indian scholar
points out an accusing finger. American financial markets are investing in
commodity trading, which they see is profitable than stock markets.

How this is being done? “After loosing money in the housing market, big
hedge funds and investment banks are now pouring money into commodity

109
markets, including oil, which are much less regulated than stock markets.
They are not buying or hoarding actual oil, and hence do not have to incur
the cost of storage. Instead they are buying oil futures with borrowed money
at low rates of interest that is buying papers that entitle the holder to get oil
after, say three months, at a price negotiated today. These papers are traded
in commodity exchanges, just like company shares in stock markets” says
Alok Ray, Professor of Economics at IIM Calcutta.

Indian Government headed by Mr.Manmohan Singh, with a Finance

Minister like Mr.P.Chidambaram, with whom we cannot sympathize
because he is a Tamilian, will never rule India with the interests of Indian
common man in mind. They will be the spokespersons of the American
companies, helping greedy men of the world to rob the mankind. Their
advisers like Mr.Shankar Acharya, not the enemy of Jayalalitha, but a
Member of the Board of Governors at Indian Council for Research on
International Economic Relations say that “oil pricing had been seriously
bungled by the Government in last few years. Government should raise fuel
prices gradually and more frequently”. If a Government that keeps such
advisers is run by anti-people vested interests shielding the western countries
and their greedy companies, we have to be content with periodical oil price
rises followed by cosmetic reductions in election eve to hoodwink the
people.

INDIA MUST HAVE A NON-POLITICAL FINANCE MINISTER. This

demand by a registered political party Dravida Peravai may surprise the
readers. We in our party manifesto registered with Election Commission of
India, have advocated party-less democracy as panacea to Indian political
party dominated political scenario. Hence it falls in our moral duty to
suggest that Nobel Laureate Amarthya Sen should be made India’s Finance
Minister.

The Union Government must have convened the National Integration

Council or convened the Chief Ministers Conference to discuss the Value
added Tax on petrol and diesel. Gujarat imposes 29.13 percent VAT on
diesel and 29.88 percent VAT on petrol. The Left ruled West Bengal
imposes 20.62 percent VAT on diesel and 27.66 percent on petrol. West
Bengal also levies 4 percent tax each on kerosene and cooking gas. In
Andhra Pradesh ruled by Congress 33 percent VAT on diesel is the order of
the day. Punjab imposes 30 percent VAT on petrol. IS IT NOT THE DUTY
OF THE UNION GOVERNMENT TO DISCUSS WITH STATES TO

110
BRING UNIFORM REDUCTION IN VAT AND TO REDUCE OIL
PRICES DRASTICALLY AFTER ALL THE PEOPLE ARE THE
ULTIMATE MASTERS IN A DEMOCRACY.

[Press Release of 22nd June 2008, a part of which will be telecasted by a

local channel Rainbow channel]

N.Nandhivarman, General Secretary Dravida Peravai

MALAYSIAN TAMIL MAKES

OPEN APPEAL TO WORLD MEDIA
A MALAYSIAN CITIZEN’s OPEN APPEAL TO MALAYSIAN PRIME
MINISTER AND WORLD MEDIA.

DMK had fought emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi, when she was the
Prime Minister of India. The DMK Government headed by Kalaignar
M.Karunanithi was dismissed, and while news of dismissal spread like
wildfire, I rushed to his Gopalapuram residence. The Telephone connections
were cut. Seyal Mani and few Thousand Light party activists like Hussein
were there, and the house appeared deserted. In couple of days after
dismissal the death anniversary of Aringnar Anna came. In Murasoli, the
DMK daily, my poem appeared on that day and my writings in official organ
of DMK Namnaadu and Kazhaga Kural, apart from the eveninger brought
out by Murasoli group Thamizh Mani exposed Indira Gandhi’s emergency.
Indira Gandhi arrested DMK Leaders excluding Kalaignar showing gratitude
towards Kalaignar because he sustained her party in power when Congress
broke into Indicate and Syndicate. We could not even mention in media who
have been arrested. Murasoli team cleverly published a List of People who
could not come to Anna Samadhi to pay their respects. Rumour mill
unleashed by angry countrymen ultimately swept Indira Gandhi from seat of
power. That is past. An unknown person with a Christian name who
proclaims he is Hindu having heard about me in Internet had sent a mail,
which says, is a copy of his open letter to Malaysian Prime Minister. As a

111
true democrat, I did not edit anything and I am placing it below. I do not
endorse all his views, but feels that every citizen on earth has his right to
express his woes and problems before humanity seeking justice. I am not
Hindu and I welcome demolition of all temples that encroach roads and that
are unauthorized. I am not a man who drums Islamic phobia. Yet Aringnar
Anna, the great humanist taught us to show tolerance to the views of others.
This is a voice of a tamilian in distress, and I cannot think of his religion or
caste here. It is uppermost in my mind that his views should be placed
before the media and people. Every Tamilian has a right to be heard. Let us
hear his story on Malaysian Tamil Problem.

Mr. Ambrose Sabastian. Penang, Malaysia.

NRIC No.: 4563861 [email protected] December 14, 2007. YAB

Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, The Premier / Home Minister of
Malaysia. Dear Prime Minister, At first my apology for not sending this
letter in private because I believe this letter can go into trash without your
attention. If it goes like street demonstration with vast publicity, it will be
attended like VIP treatment. So I have no choice had to send to various
channel to all MP’s, media / press and some NGO’s to reach you. I will
personally post this letter to some Internet groups to circulate around. Past
weeks media and press were reporting some psychological disturbing news
blasting with mighty power showoff. Logical persons like others and me can
easily come to conclusion that your BN government was afraid to lose
power and confident of the public. We clearly know the news in local media
and press were carrying half-truth or untrue news. Most people appear in
media and press to support your government was coached to act. This will
make lose credibility of the environment. We can tell lies once and not
always. You and your lieutenant ministers including amok minister Nazri
were blasting non stop against the defenseless BERSIH and more on
HINDURAF. Why the group consider defenseless because you BN
government armed with the local media / press and police to tell all kind of
fanciful news. Why continue harping so afraid of losing ground? It’s true
after HINDRAF rally, your long time friend MIC had lost ground and shaky.
Everyone knew that MIC had neglected the real Indian community welfare
except the leaders and their cronies enrich themselves. They became rich by
selling of Indian rights and privileges to UMNO Malays for secure their
position. They may argue with some propaganda. Why not they (leaders)
debate in an open public forum? Why not allow my views in media and
press without censored? Now the MIC leaders had to follow your footsteps.

112
Must bribe three million ringgit to every MIC division in the name of
development so the leaders can get continue support and the top post will be
safe. You had taken the taxpayers money to bribe your division leaders but
where does the MIC leaders can get that kind of money? Maybe MAIKA? If
you are a Prime Minister believes and uphold the true principle of Islam, you
should see the welfare of Malaysian Indians without second thought. A very
long time the Indians had cried for help for lost of their money to scrupulous
MAIKA shares. But you never care. You should appoint Royal Commission
to investigate one of the long outstanding MAIKA issues for Indians. You
were saying it is not our culture to bring the matter in the street and has
many avenues to bring forward. Is it true? I don’t think so because the over
crowded Malay government staffs thinking it is their country and side lined
our non-Muslims matter into trash. Which avenues are you talking to solve
the problems? Police detained me in lockup exactly sixty days; later one
year Pulau Jerjak Detention camp and banished one year at Seremban
arrested me under ISA (EO). While I was in Pulau had protested and
appealed. I had learnt Appeal board is not an independent body and they are
government puppets. After released I had lodged twice in Police HQ that
police had fabricated charges against me and sentenced me for the crime
which I never committed. Until now the Police were refused to investigate
and waiting for all the witness to die. Because of this action I had suffered in
many ways of getting opportunities in my life. Second was the police
arrested me and charge for rioting in front of Police HQ, Penang. When we
request for trials, the magistrate never allowed and give us discharge not
amounting to acquittal. Later I had asked DPP several times to proceed the
case but they refused. Even I had filed the case on my own against the
police/ government and the court refuse to continue saying it was DNAA. Is
it looking funny? During Mamak Tun Mahathir era I had applied for Private
Investigation permit but was rejected for the ground of not being a Muslim
or Bumiputra. Mamak Mahathir became Bumiputra because he is a Muslim.
He is the one who had planted the seed in ground of hatred among
Malaysians. Read carefully his Malay dilemma book. He was talking to
chase away the ethnics Indian and Chinese to their respective countries. He
had fooled the Malays in this country and ruled twenty-two years as a
dictator. Sooner I will reveal how the Hindu God from his ancestor country
helped him to rule as an iron fist. After you became premier I wrote twice
for application permit forms to Home ministry requesting for private
investigating And Finance Ministry for 4d outlets, till now no reply. I
believe my letter had gone to trash like many other non-Muslims students
application for local Universities and government scholarships. Now you tell

113
me after going through all this what Avenue shall I follow according to law?
I never beg the government for loans to build up my carrier. But you are
hindering one Indians progress in life by putting all kind of permit / license
laws. Why is your government doing this? You are expecting me to suffer
and fate up of staying in Malaysia. Silently you are telling either I should
commit suicide or leave the country. Or turn into new identity by converting
to Islam and change my culture to become new pure community. This is
called ethnic cleansing. Other Indians in variety of matters faced the same
types of problems like me. If Malays and Muslims were to do illegally no
action taken but non-Muslims were denied had to face many difficulties. For
example, in front of Penang snakes temple more and more illegal restaurants
were built and no action was taken. In Penang Bayan Baru, Sikh community
asking the government a land to built Sikh temple was not granted. Since I
lost and fate up of all avenues, shall I have to take to the street for attention
or satisfying myself to become suicide bomber? Don’t worry! I will not
become suicide bomber for the sake of going to meet seventy-two virgins in
heaven. Luckily I believe in GOD. My belief in God never allowed me
taking others and ones life. Can your DAMAI group the silent community
able to solve my above problems? Your Barisan Nasional government had
arranged some people to talk like peace lovers and oppose street rallies
because they never got burned their finger so they do not know the pain of
the individuals. Unless it happened to them or their families then they will
not open their mouth even they were paid to act in media and press. For
example, why BERSIH group had to take the street to give the memo to our
beloved King regarding mal practices of election commission. Earlier they
had chosen right way sitting at the table but the EC chief was very stubborn
to listen and told that he is the superior prerogative decision maker that he
can’t listen anyone do anything to change the system. He had told the
BERSIH group even the Agong come and tell the system can’t be changed
as long EC is under his command. That’s why his tenure of age to 66 in EC
office was passed in haste in parliament few days ago. So the BERSIH
group took the streets to highlight the matter to public. These are Internet
news, which can’t be available in your controlled media and press. In other
words the silent DAMAI communities were agreeing and siding ruling
government officers that our Agong can be belittle by words and make funs?
Like me there is many others not only Indians were suffering due to
negligence, push around, unattended, deaf and refused by government had
no choice but had to be grouped to show dissatisfaction in the streets? Is
there any other ways? You are proclaiming yourself like prophets that you
are the only Prime Minister for all Malaysians but afraid or fear to meet the

114
HINDRAF leaders. Why have you refuse to see them before they go to the
street? The reason you wanted them to go to the street so can make all kind
of allegation later against the lawyers and their supporters. Last few weeks
can see a lot of fanciful stories about HINDRAF movement in media and
press. Now you had made HINDRAF lawyers as a guinea pig to test the ISA
law. By detaining them, you are trying to gag the opposition political parties
mouth before the upcoming general election. Our country security is not
under threat. As long our beloved King and his command of Armed forces
there we are safe. Only threat you feel is your Barisan National government
is under threat and afraid of losing in ballot box this upcoming general
election. You are afraid of losing the Prime Minister job. That’s why you as
a Home Minister had directed the police not to issue the permit for
opposition parties or anyone going against your BN government. What is the
purpose of November 10, BERSIH walk? For highlighting the inefficiency
and biased election method was conducted for your BN parties to win.
Nearly more than a month past of BERSIH March but the election
commission did nothing. In fact they were defending themselves giving
statements by statements and the amok minister was telling kindergarten
story in parliament and press. Right now the commission should organized
state-by-state public forums and listen where the defect in the election
process was. Do you think another public walk had to be organized for the
election commission to listen the grouses? Let talk about HINDRAF rally
planned for giving petition to British high commission. Why the police
permit is not given or court order was issued against? According to BN
statements claimed that only a small number of Indians show dissatisfied in
this country then why have to block the rally? After learning the truth that
large number of Indians was not satisfied against the Barisan National
government, you had issued order the police not to issue the permit. Later
police gave statement that they had allowed and asked only the lawyers to
present the petition to British High commission but the HINDRAF leaders
refused to do so. Do you think HINDRAF lawyers were stupid and fell in
the police trap? If the police allow them to deliver, why the court order was
pasted all over the town against them? Can the police have power to override
the court order? IGP had lied to public. Suppose, if the permit was issued
more than 100 thousands in number of solitary Indians you can able to see!
You can’t lie that only small number of Indians were against you BN
government. The Indians wanted to show solitary in a peaceful gathering in
front of British Commission to show you the real number was not satisfied
against your government. The peaceful Indians never provoke the police but
the police provoke by shooting tear gases and cannon of waters after green

115
lights given by MIC and you. News spread there is a truck of LTTE tigers on
standby. Actually your BN Indian cahoots (MIC) had sent some thugs to
create trouble with the Police impersonating as LTTE tigers. Is the police
were so stupid, even they knew never arrested the whole bunch of truck
LTTE tigers? Your plan was intend to make this peaceful gathering into
violent mess so you can show an example to ban the entire mass rally of
opposition parties in future. You are afraid if these kinds of rallies continue
will lose votes in upcoming general election, which will be held late
February next year. Was BN afraid of losing the ballot box battle? Actually
every non-Muslim was angry because of demolition of worship places like
temples and churches. Before breaking the temples authorities should
provide alternative places to rebuild with finances. It is not proper to
demolish the temples and after public protest gives the alternative sites.
According to Hindu religious custom alternative temple must be built first
then moving the power of deity from old temple. This is proper method. But
your Islamic followers are going against. It is not like Islam one can talk big
about religion and practice opposite by consulting sorcerers and mediums
and having talisman as a protection. Is Muslim never believed that ALLAH
is the great protector? Are you? Now you and your lieutenant ministers were
threatening and bullying the Indians with ISA law. Many will afraid of
death. Only few were dared to die become suicide bombers / prepared for
gallows. Many who had stolen public money have to worry about ISA law
or death because can’t enjoy the money. Those decent people fight for the
true cause never fear any detention neither death. How many people can you
put in detention? What about ten thousand to 100 thousand willing to march
in for ISA detention cans your jails and detention camp accommodates
everyone? After marching in as a solitary refused to come out, what will you
do? Kick them, shoot them or kill them? If large number was detained will
prove it is genocide to wipe out one race. Do you love to fell in this trap by
showing evidence of ethnic cleansing and resign? You are having wrong
advisors around you. They are planning you got stuck and drowned. Indians
are not your enemy. Your UMNO people are your own enemy. What is
ethnic cleansing? Ethnic cleansing refers to various policies or practices
aimed at the displacement of an ethnic group from a particular territory
(from Hindu culture) in order to create a supposedly ethnically "pure"
society. (Silently abolishing the Hindu culture and pressured to convert to
Islam). Ethnic cleansing is a well-defined policy of a particular group of
persons to systematically eliminate another group from a given territory on
the basis of religious (temple demolition) ethnic or national origin. Such a
policy involves violence (teargas and water cannon) and is very often

116
connected with police operations and military. It is to be achieved by all
possible means, from discrimination to extermination, and entails violations
of human rights and international humanitarian law. When HINDRAF told
of ethnic cleansing pointed out the Kg. Medan incident and temple
demolition cases, they had tried all legal avenues but denied without proper
reason. You had told the media and press that there is no evidence to prove
and if there is evidence you will resign. How do you know there is no
evidence? What made you so confidence? Did you had order your people to
destroy the evidence? Tell me. What kind of evidence do you want? I can
ask my boys to get them. Please do not talk like the attorney general.
Without trial, he was acting like a judge can tell some ACA investigation
matters that the person is clean and free from any crime. If the person is
innocent, why should the investigating officers have to submit the
investigating files to attorney general for further action? Now every layman
in this country were talking that Attorney General was taken bribes and
close down some files without any action taken. Frankly speaking I am not
accusing Attorney General taking bribes but only GOD knows the truth? He
should promise in a holy Quran book to clear himself as an honest Attorney
General. You were saying if there were evidence, you would resign. Is it
true? Can we trust your words? FYI, recently some UMNO leaders had met
me asked to help in any ways to defeat you and your son-in-law Khairy in
this upcoming general election. If both of you defeated, they promised me to
pay RM2 million. Your enemy is within UMNO itself and not HINDRAF. If
I asked them they can provide me some evidence documents and connection
which can help you to remove from the post. Many in UMNO are interested
in your post. According to my Hindu God six people interested. Don’t ask
me who is the UMNO leader because it is not a crime for me to reveal. It is
up to me whether I wanted to accept their offer. Don’t be so over confident.
If I asked my Hindu Gods help, sure you alone can be defeated in this
upcoming general election. If you never believe ask your Indonesian
talisman provider. My Hindu God had already talked to him and given some
messages to pass over to you. Now you are trying to fix up some Malaysian
Indians pretext as terrorists link to LTTE. In Malaysia any Indians going
against police and Barisan National government will be branded as a Tamil
Tiger terrorist link to LTTE. Even Police Special Branch was keeping files
about me as a LTTE Tamil Tiger? Why? If I am a Tamil Tiger why last
twenty-five years the policemen who had falsely fixed me up were living
peacefully? Why nothing happened to them? It is a great ploy of your
government to divert the real problems faced by Indians. Quick cover-up. It
is not like you had selected some Indians to talk in TV shows that they are

117
well cared and progressive? It is a false propaganda through media and press
to cheat the public. If most are well cared why should the public have to
choose the streets? Police are fixing falsely the lawyers linking to LTTE so
that they can shut the mouth of local’s as well international communities.
Police told blatant lies against the HINDRAF leaders. Recently we heard
India government was very concerned about Malaysian Indians. Later we
heard the Indian Government distance itself because the HINDRAF Indians
had connection with terrorist group. Every Malaysians knew that to make an
appointment to meet President Bush had been paid sixteen million to the
middleman. But to the Indian leaders never needed middleman. Can be deal
direct? LTTE fighters were fighting the war within their country and never
carried their war to other countries. Not like Palestine war was carried to
Malaysia to protest in front of US Embassy. Is it our war had to go to the
street as illegal gathering in front of US Embassy? You are saying lawyers
are not above the law. How about your son-in-law Khairy? Is he above the
law? All right! Since you are talking about the law it means that you are not
above the law too. In fact all the investigating agencies like police and ACA
are working under your armpits. Whatever mistakes you had done no one
dare to investigate or the report can go to rot inside fridge. Like the Malacca
minister talking like thugs using parang (sword) and someone had lodged a
report. No news about it all after that? Since every law enforcement agencies
are under your armpits, the public can approach to only one person. That is
our beloved king. Since your UMNO machinery had activated to get
millions of signature to claim HINDRAF and opposition parties claims were
not true then I had activated my own machinery to get one hundred
thousands signature campaign to submit to our beloved King to investigate
against you. You had abused your power in using your position by misusing
the taxpayers’ money by bribing your UMNO political division each ringgit
three million with the pretext of division development. It is very clear that
this bribing is not division development but to garner continue support for
your top seat. This matter of clear bribery had been published in all local
newspapers as evidence. Also included in the signature campaign is asking
our beloved King to take election commission and Anti Corruption Agency
under his full control of power like Armed Forces. Malaysian Muslim was
giving moral and financial support to Muslim insurgents in Southern
Thailand and Moro / Abu sayib Muslim terrorist group in Philippines. Our
country leaders were having relations with them directly and indirectly,
which means our Malaysian Muslim leaders having links to terrorist? Are
they terrorist? Come on don’t talk like a child? Every Tamil in cultural
connection are giving moral support and sometimes-small contribution to

118
LTTE. Even Dato Samy Velu had contributed money to LTTE. So can we
call him Tamil Tiger terrorist? I am neutral person not supporting any sides
political or groups but after reading and listening repeated threatening and
bullying by using ISA laws against the Indians, re-arresting the Indians after
court bail, branding them as terrorist made me to support them. Now I from
POOLYGALS declare openly supporting the cause HINDRAF had
undertaken. Even you use your utmost power to deregister the group; the
HINDRAF will stay every mind of the Indians. Ask yourself. HINDRAF
had deeply had penetrated your mind so last two weeks you were crying foul
about HINDRAF in media and press. My support will be morally and
financially (which I can afford). After all I am one man easily can be
crushed. Please do not ask the police about my details because the Special
Branch can feed you with false information. They will lie by saying I am a
well-trained Tamil Tigers from Sri Lanka and having an army of Tamil
Tigers soldiers base in Malaysia. Do you know something twenty years back
special branch police had asked me voluntarily stay in psychiatric hospital
for two months to get mental certificate? For two months stay they are
willing to pay me 20K. My financing to HINDRAF is a small amount,
which I can afford. Nobody have rights to say they don’t have permitted to
take money from me (public). It is my money and no one has any right to
question of donating to HINDRAF lawyers. With my money, I don’t care
how they use. I don’t bother if they will use my money to buy toilet roll or
honeymoon in Hadjai. At least they had done something that I wanted to do.
Couple year’s back, I had mooted with an idea written in Sangkancil forum
group that to find out the true constitution rights of every Malaysian citizen
must file a case in Malaysian court. If it turns down must file alternative in
British court. It will cost a lot to file a case in foreign country. I had written
to authority in China and India to provide me some highly qualified lawyers
and some fund.

That is my initiative for two races Chinese and Indians. Recently

HINDRAF took initiative on their own for Indians matters to British court.
They had taken the right steps accordance with law. Whether they are telling
the truth or lies depends in court trials. Why your famous Attorney general is
not qualified in arguing in British court? It seems only some UMNO Malays
(not majority) were unhappy saying the HINDRAF never respect our King
and our justice system. Let me explain why the HINDRAF had chosen
British court instead of Malaysian court?

119
First of all, I will never trust our country judicial system because I had
personal experience with court. The judges never bothered the ordinary
citizen and always siding your government. Actually our judicial system is
not independent. It is your Machinery like puppets. Do we have a King in
Malaysia? (My humble apology to our beloved King). In our country the
King was made to look like puppets for government ceremonial purposes.
The UMNO is branding our king as their puppets. About 13 years back,
UMNO leaders were explaining about the King and rulers privileges
removal to their grassroots members in nation wide close door meeting. In
Penang it was held at Dewan Sri Pinang. I went to listen. Dear Prime
Minister, you had tossed in the microphone left and right about our rulers
and King at that time. To refresh your memory, I had walked to the stage
and handed over a letter. Remember! Since the UMNO leaders blasting the
Agong and making those as their puppets we had to believe whatever the
media and press were publishing. Agong never denied or showed his
absolute power till now. That’ why the HINDRAF never submit the petition
to Agong? Even it was delivered to Agong and he can’t make any decision.
The UMNO staffs will answer. It is not the HINDRAF Indians never respect
our King but the UMNO leaders had pictured the Agong as their puppets to
every citizen’s mind through using controlled media and press. Whose fault
is that? I am supporting the HINDRAF because wanted to see some untold
or hidden true facts can emerge during trials in British court. We are not
dreaming to get ringgit one million from British government. We want
justice as a human accordance with law. If not, what is the point talking
about Islam and GOD if one never gets justice. Daily I am reading news
published with bad faith about HINDRAF. Frankly speaking your Barisan
National Government was shivering after BERSIH and HINDRAF public
rallies. First your government was afraid of losing in ballot box in upcoming
general election. So using HINDRAF as scapegoat, you and your BN
government trying to all kind of statements to cover your past governments
wrongs in the press and media. Actually no one asks how many non-Muslim
ministers having in your cabinet? Most of yours and your government
statements must save it to tell in court if you were summoned by British
court. We Malaysians know the truth what is happening in our country?

You had told BERSIH (opposition parties) stop pulling our King into
politics. What makes you to say this word? I understand with logic answers
after I read the news in MalaysiaToday.net by Raja Petra Kamarudin said
that our beloved King had ordered the 19th Brigate of the Royal Malay
Regiment was on stand-by, to move in if there are any fatal casualties

120
violence against the citizen by police. This has worried your BN
Government plan never worked by using the police to stop the BERSIH
rally. Later the riot control police had to turn to traffic policemen. Your plan
had completely failed. So in revenge of our beloved King, you are using the
rulers to voice out for your BN government political gains using HINDRAF
rally as scapegoat. Why did you never use the rulers when your son-in-law
Khairy riots in front of US Embassy? It is a double standard. The rulers
should be act unbiasedly to uphold justice when they voice out our country
matters.

Actually I am very angry of Muslim led Malaysian government taking harsh

ways to demolish the Temples. I had some personal experience of this kind
in Penang Kg. Rawa Temple demolition. When the Indians agreed to move
the temple in peaceful ways about 2000 Muslim rioters standing at the back
police barricade nearly 35 ft away. They were throwing stone after stone at
us while we are carrying the idols. Stones hit many of us. Mosque speakers
were blasted, “Hindu Pariah (Hindu low-caste); Hindu sembayang syaitan
(Hindus praying Satan); Bunuh semua Hindu (kill all Hindus); Pechah
semua tokong Hindu (demolish all Hindu Temple); etc.” Even after we
moved the statue the Muslims enter the empty structure and break it. What a
nasty feeling the Muslims have against the Hindus. Riot police were
standing there smiling. Next day, the Muslims were unhappy that we Hindus
moved to new location peacefully. After Friday prayers they charged at new
location and wanted to break the moved statues. They were not happy. When
the Hindus wanted to defend their fanatic crazy action like amok minister
the riot police fired tear gas at Hindus. It has escalated to many areas. Even
the Muslim had used automatic revolvers shot at devotees far away temple.
Many temples were attacked. Many young Indian boys were arrested. Some
were sent to detention centers and others banishment for no reason. At the
time MIC leaders were cooling themselves inside the sarong of their ladies.
Even Hindu Sangam leader accused me that we are coward Tamil Tigers for
not revenge and kill the Muslims. True Hindus are peaceful people and love
the king and country. If continued whacked they can turn tougher and
dangerous. REMEMBER. I understand from my Hindu God that you are
making the Indians and Malays angry so to start a racial clash. If your plan
succeeds, it will not only destroy our country and you are making the
innocent Muslim lives in danger in India. For your information, your
Barisan National Ministers are liars. Before we move the Kg. Rawa temple
Koh Tzu Khoon and Samy Velu agents told the ministers taking full
responsibility of built new temple once we moved. After moved the temple

121
be neglected and have to depend on public donation to build. Muslim in this
country simply breaks and destroys the temple of worship. They believe
Hindu idols were only stone. Also many born Indian Hindus with Hindu
names knew a lot about their religion well. They knew Hindu idols were
strong and powerful GOD and GODDESS so they are afraid to show others
the mighty power of their GOD? These knowledgeable Hindus even asked
me to change my name before I talk Hinduism. For choosing God one must
get name permit? These knowledgeable Hindus were hypocrite and do not
have full faith in their own GOD. I chose Hinduism and identify myself with
Christian name. I knew very little about Hinduism than those carrying Hindu
names. Well! With my little knowledge in Hinduism I am calling a
challenge with Malaysian Muslim authorities. Previously I had called the
Muslim leaders worldwide including you and nobody dare. Now I am
inviting the fanatic Malaysian Muslim authority for a challenge. Just inform
me eight months earlier one Hindu Goddess temple in Malaysia they intend
to demolish. After eight months on an appointed date you can send large
group of police and UMNO thugs not less than hundred to demolish the
temple. All policemen should be Muslim. I will arrange foreign media to
film the event. Don’t worry no public will protest. Hindus will stand far and
watch the event. I am the only person there with Hindu GOD and
GODDESS will be protesting. Wanted to test the power of Hindu GOD?

After seeing all duped one-sided news in media and press, I came to
conclusion to find out the truth.

1. I wanted to walk alone carrying placards on 30-12-2007 at 3.00 p.m. from

Luring Kulit Hindu Temple to Esplanade. I will post or fax the below reason
letters to our Agong upon reaching esplanade. With me four friends will
walk together and distribute the leaflets informing why we are walking. Less
than five people never need police permit neither it is not an illegal
gathering. Below are reasons of the letter will be delivered asking direct
reply from our king through live telecast?

Does the King himself told the BERSIH rally is illegal? Does the King
refused to accept the petition from his country citizen? Is King himself
directed one of his palace worker who is a UMNO member to call
emergency press conference informing the public the BERSIH rally is illegal
and citizens can’t give any petition to our beloved King? Who is the First
Lady in this country? Is our Permaisuri Agong or Prime Ministers wife? The

122
BN government branding the Agong as their puppet through media and
press. They are claiming Agong will dance to their finger tics? Is it true?

d. I am humbly appeal to our beloved King to order the police to release all
BERSIH leaders and HINDRAF Indians from prosecutions. It is like abuse
of power against Indians and others. Indians never provoked but the Police
provoke under the command of Home Minister Abdullah Ahamad Badawi.
It is not the HINDRAF supporters obstruct the traffic. Only the police blocks
made it like crime scenario. The BN government was trying all sorts to scare
the public by using laws against the Indians. It never used the same law
against his son-in-law when he protested in front of US Embassy. If our
beloved King never put a stop this BN corrupted government, the situation
going to be worst. He is not a smart Premier. He does not know how to
cover the hole. In fact he is expanding the whole bigger leading to conflict.
He is architect to plan to start a racial clash. If conflict start in our country
every achievement will be destroyed. Nobody will gain. (I had learned
something from foreign sources and from my Hindu GOD if conflict start. I
can’t reveal here. I can only tell the secret to our King, Sultan of Perak,
Sultan of Selangor and Raja Nazrin provided they grand me an audience
privately without any government spy agents.)

Again I wanted to walk carrying placards on 5-1-2008 at 3.00 p.m. from

Lorong Kulit Hindu Temple to Gurney Drive. With me four friends will
walk together and distribute the leaflets informing why we are walking. Less
than five people never need police permit neither it is not an illegal
gathering. The walk is for alerting the public about the missing girl Nurin
Jazlin Jazmi who was murdered and stuffed in a sport bag and the
incompetent police investigation. I was unhappy when one minister stupidly
threatens Nurin’s father saying law is a law. In fact poor people have to earn
money for their rice bowl. Twenty-four hours they can’t guard their children.
It will very nice if it happened to one of the Ministers child and we can see
how the law works?
Deputy Internal Securities Minister Datuk Mohd Johari told in Parliment
that even with the help of the FBI, the enhanced CCTV images did not show
the registration number clearly. The Police can’t conclude this case and can’t
find the killer. Now I put up a challenge with Home Minister that what a
great Scotland Yard Malaysian Police and the Greatest FBI can’t do to solve
Nurin’s murder case but we can able to solve within short period. I can ask
my boys in KL and Klang to solve this case easily provided you have to
accept to agree my condition as follows:- a. Investigate my case for the

123
detention in Pulau and banishment. Once find out the truth pay me
compensation ringgit 25 million for suffering twenty-five years.b. IGP and
deputy IGP should resign / suspend with immediate for inability to solve
Nurin’s murder case and replaces Chinese officer as an IGP. Dato
Christopher Wan is best candidate. Prove that you are not a racist
government by appointing a Chinese officer to the highest position. Again I
wanted to walk carrying placards on 12-1-2008 at 3.00 p.m. from Esplanade
to Penang ACA office. Upon reaching the ACA office I will report to ACA
about the election commission mal practice. In Ijok by election they never
took any action against the Barisan National abuse of power and over
spending the limit. The newspaper is given a clear picture of mal practices.
Many things were done for the ijok residents to buy votes. If the same thing
were fulfilled to nation wide Malaysian it was not considered not vote
buying. Is the ijok residents are the only humans in Malaysia? What about
other places Malaysians?

This time it is not a walk. After casual talk to large number of grassroots
members of UMNO, MIC and MCA, I had made a decision to convey the
message to the ruling government. To show dissatisfaction against the ruling
government start January 1, 2008 to January 31, 2008 I will start to wear a
yellow ribbon on my right arm. I strongly feel we Indians were cheated by
MIC. The slogan is, “MIC tipu India.” (Tipu means cheat). If Malay or
Chinese intend to follow to wear the ribbon then you guess what will be the
slogan will be? Actually I am not against the NEP policy. In God grace all
Malays in this country should get benefited from this policy but some people
had hijacked it to their own benefit to get private jets and luxury yachts,
leaving most Malays stuck in the poor list. All the hijacked money and
property should be returned to the poor Malays.

In fact, UMNO grassroots members’ support you had became prime minister
but neglected them after you climb to the top. Because of them you are able
to purchase private jet, luxury yachts and mansion in Australia. Do we not
know how much of our public money you had deposited in foreign bank
accounts? You had given ringgit three million to only division leaders to
share among few branch leaders. What about grass root members? Are they
worth only for nasi lemak and the tarik? Every UMNO grass root members
should demand a new car from their leaders. If they refused to give chuck
them away in party election and select new leader. Dear prime minister, I
know that you are not loyal to King and rulers because you had chucked
them in your speech thirteen years ago. But my question was, are you

124
patriotic in our country? You are not. As a leader you should show good
examples to all country citizens. We are looking foreign investment to grow
but you are investing in other country. Why you should buy multi-million-
dollar mansion in Australia? You know our country is not safe because you
are planning to start racial clash. If anything happens you intend to run away
to Australia using the private jet. If the air route blocked, you will use the
sea route by luxury yacht. You are promoting and implementing Islamic
laws in our country. It makes a great hardship to all Muslim in Malaysia. If
you are talking so much Islam as your breath, why are you not purchase the
mansion in Islam countries? Why? You believe the Islam countries are not
peaceful nation or can’t enjoy the freedom like westerners? You purchase
the mansion in Christian country so you can enjoy your meal in Haram place
in casino? Do you love gambling? Finally my Hindu God had passed me
some messages for you. The best person to lead UMNO is Tengku
Razaleigh bin Tengku Hamzah. If he becomes the next prime minister the
country will be stable and clean. Ask your son-in-law to retire from politics.
His own UMNO rival group will kill him. If you continue to press the
Indians in the pretext of security and start to create a racial clash for your
political gain, my Hindu God had promised to take away your life sooner.
Please listen

What my Hindu God says. I am not a hypocrite like Hindu Sangam. You
don’t argue to me about my Hindu God. Go and ask your talisman provider
and he will tell you. A message is waiting for you.

Note: Former sacked Anwar Ibrahim can become next prime minister
provided he must apologize and break one coconut in one Hindu temple and
do something with my guidance. Can a Muslim break coconut in Hindu
temple? Well! Muslim can believe talisman as protection? Since Malaysian
Muslim believe talisman as protection instead of Allah, so Anwar Ibrahim
has no problem breaking coconut in Hindu temple. Looking forward your
reply soon in media and press. Thank you. Sincerely,

Comments 1 Comment

Historically let me briefly summaries and classify where the Malaysian

people income status for each race (Chinese, Indians & Malays) during the
races economic growth in Malaysia or Malaya before it all begin.

125
1. The Chinese went to work in the tin mines. Income received is DAILY for
Chinese communities = (Hours served daily = Approx. 12 - 16 hours dawn
to dusk)

2. The Indians went to work in the plantations estates. Income received is

DAILY for Indian communities = (Hours served daily = Approx. 4 - 6 hours
dawn till noon)

3. The Malays being left out of the exportable products income above were
still left with the traditional way of planting padi. Income receive is ONCE
A YEAR after harvest. (Hours served = Daily dawn to dusk: From nursery,
planting, maintenance (i.e. pest etc...) harvesting. Income received has to be
shared with for the extra help required)

HOW IT WAS SPENT TO GOOD USE

The Chinese had a head start with the large fund they got. Besides the
emergence hundreds of their communities & societies to churn their business
& contacts they also build chambers of commerce to further enhance the
business plans & counterparts.The handful of discipline Indians put their
money to good use by providing and promoting good educations to their
children. But the rest starts happy hour at noon.

The Malays income were use to pay the extra help and payback a whole year
of debt backlog. After that, they sit back to wait for the next rainy season for
another year of paid planting process. So the question here is who is to be
blame? The self centered fore-fathers that neglected the importance of
education which they should guide and strive to their children? Or for
having an early start for happy hours everyday? I could write on and on…
But let this point ponder to all who had read through. LIVE IS FOR THE
LIVING. SO LIVE IT! (Like your fore fathers did)

So be thankful of where you are and what you are today! Things could have
been worst than herding cows & whipping their hips under the hot sun of
mother land India. Britman - Comments as on- 25-03-2008
TAMILNADU BECOMING
DUMPING GROUND OF FLYASH
The Collector of Nagapattinam District
30.10.2K9

126
Officials of Tamilnadu Pollution Control Board.

On the eve of the public hearing on the proposed1820 MW Coal

Based Power Plant by M/s. Tridem Port and Power Co. Ltd., &
150 MW Coal Based Power Plant by M/s. Nagapattinam Energy
Pvt. Ltd, we are submitting our views to oppose the coal based
thermal power plants.

We would like to bring to your notice that within Union Cabinet there is
difference of opinion which came to public light after The Hindu, a daily
carried out the following news:

▼ The Hindu, English daily reported on July 5 th of 2009 that

Environment and Forest Minister Jairam Ramesh has written to Power
Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde seeking to put an end to laying of
foundation stones for projects without proper and formal clearances
and advising all state power PSUs like National Thermal Power
Corporation, National Hydro Power Corporation , Sutlej Jal Vidyut
Nigam and North Eastern Electric Power Corporation to show greater
sensitivity to environmental concerns at the highest level.

Under such situation we would urge the Nagapattinam District

Administration and Tamil nadu Government to have a re-think on all
coal based thermal power projects.

▼ Recent news from our neighbor China as reported in China Daily

dated October 28 th of 2009 states that Chinese Environment ministry
had suspended or rejected 29 applications of new construction in
petrochemical, steel-making and electricity-generating industries with
a total investment of 146.7 billion yuan (US$21.5 billion).Chinese
government has promised that its economic stimulus plan would not
compromise anti-pollution efforts and policies would not be loosened to
allow more projects to pass environmental examinations.
Environmental Protection Minister Zhou Shengxian said the
government would abide by strict environmental standards when
evaluating new projects.

Unfortunately Tamilnadu is not observing strict environmental

standards. It craves for power at all costs.►Tamilnadu has 4 major
thermal power plants producing 2970 MW of power. The Hindu, daily
dated 6 th February 2009 carries a confession by the Chairman of
Tamilnadu Pollution Control Board. Mr.R.Balakrishnan admits that
thermal power plants in coastal areas of the state are not meeting
pollution control standards. If truth could come out of Chairman’s
mouth, our voices in protesting power plants stands justified by
international, national and regional yardsticks.

127
► Thermal Power Plant in Tuticurin, a joint venture between Neyveli
Lignite Corporation 89% and Tamilnadu Electricity Board with 11%
stake is a 4000 crore project aiming to generate 1000 MW. Bharat
Heavy Electricals Limited and Tamilnadu Electricity Board have joined
together to start 1600 MW power project at a cost of Rs.8700 crore in
Tuticurin District.The coal from Neyveli has to be carried by congested
roads to Tuticurion. It can be argued that it goes within our state from
one part to other. Also by sea route coal may get transported. One can
say within the source of raw material i.e. our state power project
comes up.

Even this could be assimilated for argument sake but not bringing 4.6
million tons of coal annually from Orissa to Ennore port in order to
enable Tamilnadu Energy Company, a joint venture between National
Thermal Power Corporation and Tamilnadu Electricity Board to
generate 1000 MW at Vallur in Tiruvallore District of Tamilnadu. The
cost is 4500 crores.

█There is a national policy to set up power plants near mine heads,

where coal is mined. Under such policy instead of bringing coal from
Orissa to Ennore, Tamilnadu could have planned to set up power plant
in Orissa and pass on power to national grid and then draw equal
quantum here through national grid. By this way Tamilnadu could have
had power as well as avoided unnecessary construction of new harbors
and unnecessary pollution of our soil.

Mind boggling statistics reveals that Ashok Leyland Project, First Corp
Petrochem project, UTL Utility Systems project, Essar Power, GMR
Power, Trichy Power Project and Coal and Oil Company of Dubai’s
project which have planned to produce 1000 MW power each could be
avoided if the policy to set power projects at mine head is observed.
After all even if power projects are set up same Orissa and Bihar labour
have to be brought to work here, since all industries of Tamilnadu and
Puducherry uniformly follow a policy to engage only Orissa and Bihar
labour and never to disturb local labour from watching free television
and eating Rs 1 per kg rice given by noble leader Dr.Kalaignar.

Empee Power and Infrastructure Ltd aim generation of 1200 MW. A

company from Spain aims 2000 MW. Then comes the 4000 MW power
project by National Thermal Power Corporation near Thirukuvalai, Chief
Minister Dr.Kalaignar’s birth place. Central University coming in his
home district is welcome but not polluting industries. The rice bowl of
Tamilnadu should have agro-based industries and should promote
agriculture and fisheries, the traditional people pursuing these
professions for centuries or millennium. Similarly 2000 MW power

128
project near Cheyyur also will erase the ecology of Kaluveli tank; a
place of haven for migratory birds, and the tourism potential of ECR
road will have to be wiped out to dump fly ash everywhere, congesting
roads with coal transport.

We urge the Tamilnadu Government to re-think its energy policy. The

Memorandum of Understanding signed with Tri-Sakthi Energy P Ltd for
525 MW of power. India Power project, SPIC Energy Private Limited,
Chennai Power Company etc for 1000 MW each and Cuddalore Thermal
Power Project to generate 1320 MW too are coal based. Reliance plans
3000 MW power project. All these projects are coal based
environmental hazards.

☼☼►Dravida Peravai lauds only 2 initiatives of Tamil Nadu Power

Minister. The Memorandum of Understanding signed with an American
firm for generating sea solar power is welcome. The Project that comes
in Udangudi of Tuticurin District to generate 100 MW of Solar Thermal
Power is welcome. As on January 31st of 2009 out of total national
production of 9756 MW of wind energy Tamilnadu produces 42 percent
and this is a good development. We whole heartedly welcome these
solar, wind, and ocean thermal power projects. But we oppose the Coal
based Thermal Power projects that are coming up in Nagapattinam
Districts, for which this public enquiry is called for.

►National Thermal Power Corporation of India is pumping 500 million

US dollars in a joint venture with Ceylon Electricity Board to set up a
power project at Sampur in Srilanka. India that could not ensure safety
sail for Indian fishermen in Bay of Bengal more particularly in Gulf of
Mannar and Pak Straits is going to ferry coal to Srilanka from Orissa.
From Anuradhapura in Srilanka to Thalaimannar of Tamilnadu both
India and Srilanka had planned under sea link to transmit power at a
cost of Rs 2200 crore. India that for 30 years had not linked its rivers to
help Indian farmers, but now wants to link Srilanka and Tamilnadu by
under sea link to bring power to boost the growth of all polluting
industries in Tamil soil. If India had annexed Tamil areas of Srilanka
and merged North and East Districts of Srilanka with Tamilnadu and
created a Tamilnadu State within Indian Union on both sides of Pak
Straits, then such link between Tamil states may be welcomed but not
the current project.

► Dravida Peravai mooted an idea when the undersigned was Trustee

in Tuticurin Port Trust, and took up with Planning Commission and
through then Defence Minister Comrade George Fernandes apprised
then Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee on the need to create a
National Seaway Authority like National Highways. Every state

129
government has minor and intermediary ports under its control but
they are idle monuments with no revenue generation with the
exception of Gujarat’s minor ports. Hence to interlink these 138 minor
and intermediary ports for passenger and cargo traffic, creation of
such authority is must, we suggested. Accepting that during his visit to
Kanyakumari, then Prime Minister announced Sagar Mala scheme for
this purpose, which is yet to take off. We now also urge Indian
Government and Tamilnadu Government to go for reviving that idea, to
use existing harbors for passenger and cargo traffic, thereby creating
jobs for educated fishermen coming out of maritime university. It will
ease traffic congestion in roads. Unfortunately the regular hidden
incomes through frequent laying of roads will be the only loss to the
officials and political bosses. Instead of using Sagar mala scheme to
purposefully use existing harbours there seems to be a craze to allow
harbours under private only to ferry coal to coal based power plants.
This ridiculous policy causes the new creation of Ports in Nagapattinam
District which we oppose.

▼Tamilnadu must give clearance to biomass power plants. Times of

India dated 29 th October 2009 states that 9 companies have
approached Tamilnadu Energy Development Agency for permissions to
start biomass power plants. Tamilnadu Electricity Board must give
clearance for these 9 companies to generate 487 MW of power. The
speed with which clearances came for coal based power projects is
lacking here, that too for small quantum of power, which can be
termed as tokenism too TN Government lacks political will. The
biomass energy produced currently is 111 MW writes Vivek Narayanan
in Times of India. Hence according clearances for clean energy is must
in days when we sing lullabies on climate change.

▼If India has to reduce its carbon emissions; it would mean a major
reorientation of her energy strategy, especially if that warranted a shift
from its current coal-based to an oil and gas based energy system.
Murthy, Panda and Parikh (2000) examined the consequences of
alternative CO2 emission reduction strategies on economic
development and, in particular, the implications for the poor by
empirically implementing an economy-wide model across India over a
35-year time horizon. A multi-sectoral, inter-temporal model is used for
this purpose. The model has specific technological alternatives and
endogenous income distribution with dynamic behavior; it covers the
whole economy in an integrated top-down-bottom-up model. Such
alternative thinking must dawn on Tamilnadu Government.

▼International Seabed Authority under the auspices of United Nations

has earmarked 1,50,000 square kilometers of sea bed in Indian Ocean

130
for mining of cobalt, nickel , copper etc. We are not aware whether any
such area is earmarked in Bay of Bengal. If the pursuit to mine sea-bed
begins apart from natural gas to minerals, the traditional living sources
of fishermen will be totally robbed from them. Even after Exclusive
Economic Zones have been earmarked under International Law of Seas
by United Nations, the fishermen of India particularly Tamil fishermen
could not tap the fish wealth in their countries exclusive zones. Foreign
fishing vessels creep in, sneak in, and poach in our zones, and
fishermen with catamarans cannot compete. Fish wealth is near their
eyes yet their country allows sharks from other nations to rob that
instead of arming Indian fishermen with finances and schemes to make
a better livelihood. The policy to uproot people from their traditional
professions is suicidal, cynical, unethical and anti-national. Yet hand in
glove with corporate world that greases their palms for petty gains and
better lives today, our political masters are ruining traditional
fishermen and agriculturalists depriving them a decent livelihood, thus
earning a historical curse on them for their historical blunder.

▼ In precious stone rich Jharkand and Orissa, mining of this wealth

which remained in the bowels of earth over which indigenous tribal
peoples lived for millions of years is bartered to corporate world.
Dravida Peravai had incorporated in its party manifesto that if a dam is
constructed or project is set up uprooting people, such uprooted
people and all villagers over which these projects come up must be
made share holders in the projects that come up. Share the profits with
the displaced people, compensate permanently elevating the lives of
the deprived than throwing paltry pittance to political class, companies
must be told. This includes the harbour and power project that comes
up in Nagapattinam District. If a power project comes in Chief Ministers
home village, all its villagers must be made share holders in that
projects, all the jobs must be given to every educated youth forbidding
total hiring of outsiders, and if talent is needed it should be only from
Tamilnadu. No contracts labour system, because Chief Minister’s home
village must emulate a national model for development. Let Tamilnadu
plan projects that will not aggravate our climate change. Let Tamilnadu
go for clean technologies to generate power like Sweden. If our Chief
Minister cannot make Tamilnadu a Sweden in energy, a cleaner
Singapore in environment, then no one else in India can envisage and
transform people’s lives.

With Regards Yours fraternally

N.Nandhivarman
General Secretary Dravida Peravai

131
UNEARTH SUBMERGED PORTS
OF CHOZHA EMPIRE

The Collector of Nagapattinam District 23.09.2009

Tamilnadu

Respected Collector

Subject: Historical and Environmental reasons cited to oppose the

proposed Thermal Power plant regarding

We appreciate the District Collector of Nagapattinam for calling for this

public enquiry. Our views will be in Tamil’s historical interest and the
traditional rights of indigenous communities like fishermen and
farmers of Tamilnadu.Pichavaram to Kodikarai is highly important area
for unearthing our civilization since ancient harbours existed in this
belt with hidden heritage at sea. It needs to be subjected to researches
highly important for marine archaeology and coastal archaeology.

Already 250 km out of 1076 km of Tamilnadu coast is without

fishermen. The need for preserving the catamaran people and their
traditional knowledge is important. Hence all development projects
must aim at protecting indigenous communities like fishermen and
farmers and should not uproot them from where for centuries they
made a livelihood. In fact more assistance to these communities with
new scientific equipments would enable them to earn more foreign
exchange to our country’s coffers than offering soaps at the cost of
public exchequer to projects of plunder. Generating alternative
renewable energy like ocean thermal energy, ocean tidal energy will
be more helpful. Developed countries have bid adieu to thermal power.
Coal bearing ships and conveyer arrangement will be hazard for the
coastal area and will stimulate global warming through carbon
discharge. The waste generated from plant will create pollution at
sea .Thoothukudi lost its pearl culture of the past cultural heritage by
the non ocean oriented people. Bearing these in mind we urge the
Government of Tamilnadu to stall all thermal power projects coming up
in Nagapattinam District, more particularly the one near Poompuhar.

▼ We all are aware that apart from the Indus Valley excavations,
equally important cities of our ancient civilization could not so far be
unearthed in South India due to our own lethargy. We have stone
inscriptions, copper plates and burial pots and this is not sufficient to
establish the greatness of our past. Our literary evidences on
submergence of ancient Tamil land illuminate us about our past but
western scholars look for more scientific proof. Hence there is a need

132
for undersea-archaeological search to find out our roots. No other
ethnic group of Earth possesses so much literary evidences but
remains lazy to go to the submerged cities of their ancient land.
Though we have a place named as Poompuhar where Dr.Kalaignar
M.Karunanithi during his rule erected monuments to recapture the
past, it could only serve as tourist spot and could not satiate a
researcher’s quest to unravel a hidden city of our ancient civilization
beneath the bowels of our sea in Bay of Bengal. We all know about the
changes that continuously occur and the ancient Port City of Chozha
Empire is not the Poompuhar of our times, but it is within the sea
nearer or far to current Poompuhar’s coast.

▼ Graham Hancock wrote many books out of which Underworld: The

Mysterious Origins of Civilization by Crown Publishers, New York 2002
containing 760 pages ISBN 1400046122 hardback priced $ 27.50 is of
relevance to our Poompuhar. He undertook marine archaeology in
2002 and brought out as reported in Dinamani that a city with
9500 year old civilization remains hidden off coast of
Poompuhar. [Dinamani news clipping enclosed] His earlier books
Fingerprints of the Gods and Heaven’s Mirror had mentioned about his
findings. But in this latest book, he lays out evidence “based on
modern scientific research, comparative mythology, religious and
spiritual observances, first hand diving exploration of underwater
megalithic structures and ancient maps to demonstrate the likelihood
that a technically advanced civilization unrecognized by modern
science capable of navigating the globe and with a profound
understanding of architecture and building existed and was washed
out by global flooding”.

▼Inundation maps created by Dr.Glen Milne of Durham University

shows vast tracts of mostly coastal land which were submerged by
three waves of cataclysmic flooding between 17,000 and 8000 years
ago. Nearly 5 percent of Earth’s surface or 25 million square kilometers
of land stands submerged. These maps and other sources made
Graham Hancock to set his foot in Tamilnadu. Graham Hancock used
scuba diving and found many artifacts and evidences roughly 2000
pieces which he displayed in Bangalore exhibition, as per media
reports of the day. Graham Hancock had updated Tamil history to 9500
years old.

▼We like parrots were repeating 2000 years as time limit of our
ancient civilization, and when Graham Hancock updated Tamil history
with fresh facts, the Government of Tamilnadu which is going to
celebrate World Tamil Conference, must take pains to employ more
scuba divers and marine archaeologists to find out about our

133
Kaveripoompattinam. We should honour Graham Hancock in that
Conference.

▼The coast or sea near Poompuhar should not be plundered and kept
free from industrialization if our ancient glory brought out powerfully
by Dr.Kalaignar had to be proven scientifically. Mr.Graham Hancock
investigated about our “Kumari Kandam, an anti-diluvia
civilization said to have existed thousands of years ago around
South India. It is believed to have been a greater center of
learning with magnificent academies which may have left a
legacy of cartographic and astronomical knowledge which
exists today in the ancient Indian texts. Interestingly the
author spoke to local fishermen who described often diving to
free their nets caught on underwater temples and columns,
pyramidal pagodas and buildings with doorways”.

▼Coinciding to our Poompuhar, in Gulf of Cambay to city which is 7500

years old was found but media highlighted that and did not do justice
to Poompuhar’s findings. If a scientist within few weeks with the help of
National Institute of Oceanography could bring out so many artifacts, is
it not the duty of Tamilnadu Chief Minister Dr.Kalaignar M.Karunanithi
who instilled in our hearts the greatness of Poompuhar by his powerful
pen to employ all scientists, marine archaeologists, scuba divers, and
constitute a multi disciplinary State-Sponsored Task Force under Anna
University and Tamil University of Thanjavur to explore our exclusive
economic zone and our territorial waters in Bay of Bengal at least to
begin with to pick up the thread from where Mr. Graham Hancock left
in 2002.

▼▼ Dravida Peravai hence appeals to the District Collector of

Nagapattinam in the public hearing on Public Hearing on the
proposed 2x500 MW Coal Based Power Plant by M/s. PEL Power
Ltd to stop this power project. Allowing such plants to be set up
here with whatever technology will disrupt the scientific and historical
research that is needed to unearth our past beneath Bay of Bengal off
Poompuhar. We are enclosing a map which shows how much land near
our coast had been submerged. This is an indication of how much more
land would have been submerged for centuries running into thousands
of years back. My article Save the Coast in New Indian Express is
enclosed.Letting out effluents or dumping waste into rivers and seas
had been going on unabated though technically they will promise to
use clean technology and blinded by that promise our environmental
agencies will give them clearance. First of all we should bear in mind
what all technology we get is outmoded and unwanted in developed
countries, hence such technologies are dumped on developing
countries like India. If we are really a super power we should follow the

134
Swedish precedent to completely abandon thermal power projects to
save its environment. Here it is not only to save our environment but
also to prove to the world we are an ancient civilization, we need to
keep Poompuhar coast and seas close to Poompuhar free from
industrial garbage and litter.

▼Coal based power projects are being set up in Tamilnadu coast. There
seems to be a policy which permits setting up of power plants near
coal mines, so that through National Power grid equivalant quantum of
power can reach the power seeking State. Under this policy a current
Union Minister of State before he came to power got a Coal Block
allotted in Orissa.In this project of a Tamilnadu politician Puducherry
Government’s PIPDIC is a partner. This joint venture plans to set up
power project in Orissa to generate power and pass on to the grid so
that Puducherry Government will get power without polluting the Union
Territory of Puducherry. If a tiny state like Puducherry could
follow this route, what compulsion prevails for Tamilnadu to
bring coal all the way by ships to set up a power plant in the
Nagapattinam coast that too near ancient Port city of
Poompuhar?

▼ There seems to be a race to set up more and more ports without

planning what products could be brought in or exported from these
ports. The Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee when he
visited Kanyakumari announced a scheme called Sagar Mala,
which means Garland of the Seas. In fact I mooted the suggestion
to create a National Seaway on the lines of National Highways to
introduce ship connectivity to all the 138 minor or intermediary ports
to bring inland cargo that was coming by Lorries and to ferry
passengers. This suggestion through Planning Commission reached
then Prime Minister who wanted to make use of existing infrastructure
to connect all ports in Indian coast. At that time only Gujarat
particularly Gujarat Maritime Board was making good use of its minor
ports. Tamilnadu which launched a Poompuhar Shipping
Corporation under DMK rule lost the race by making its vessels
ferry coal and did not think of diverting cargo and passengers
from road use to sea lanes. Roads could be re-laid year by year but
traffic congestion, loss of lives, making more and more lanes, land
acquisition etc could be avoided if our existing ports could be
connected under the Sagar mala scheme of Vajpayee. Instead opening
new ports with no cargo to handle breeds even sand smuggling to
Maldives which was caught red handed by you, the Hon’ble Collector.
Hence we Dravida Peravai, a splinter of DMK but with great regard for
Dr.Kalaignar in view of personal friendship undiminished by parting of
ways, urge Nagapattinam to accord to priority to unearth our ancient

135
city of Kaveripoompattinam and keep this coast free from polluting
industrialization.

▼Interestingly the National Institute of Oceanography , Chennai had

announced that its scientists in collaboration with Experimental Design
Bureau of Oceanological Engineering of the Russian Academy of
Sciences had developed a vehicle named ROSUB 6000 capable of
exploring the ocean up to a depth of 6 kilometers and can be remotely
operated. Though we have to go further deep not only off the coast of
Poompuhar but also even beyond our exclusive economic zone, this
vehicle could be used to gather further evidences on our submerged
Port City of Poompuhar.

▼International Seabed Authority has allocated 150,000 square

kilometers of seabed in the Indian Ocean to India for exploration of
cobalt, manganese, nickel and copper which are in the form of
polymetalic nodules. Well Government of India will be happily
exploring Indian Ocean for minerals and metals but let Government of
Tamilnadu explore Indian Ocean to discover the lost continent of
Kumari and the Port Cities of Chera, Chozha and Pandyas, including the
ancient capitals of Thonmadurai and Kavadapuram which our literature
speaks.

With Regards
Yours sincerely

N.Nandhivarman
General Secretary Dravida Peravai

136