Comparision Sheet-Ccoling Towers
Comparision Sheet-Ccoling Towers
Comparision Sheet-Ccoling Towers
SCOPE OF ENGINEERING & SUPPLYSN Description Cooling tower frame work, fill, structure, overhead support, fan cylinders and all mechanical equipments, hardware shall be supplied by Paharpur. However construction of RCC basin based on our dimension drawing and load data schedule as well as supply and fixing of all the RCC basin fittings shall be in other's scope. Ok Ok GEM PALTECH PAHARPUR MIHIR
Cooling tower frame work, interior and exterior walls and deck.
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Hot and cold water distribution system with nozzle, valves, bends, supports and Termination point of 3 supporting structures. The piping shall be piping is our hot terminated upto battery limit with flanges water inlet flange as per ANSI B 16.5. 4 Drift eliminator at air outlet Ok
Supply of distribution nozzles, 2 nos. flow control valves per cell and 1 no. tee per cell basin will be in Paharpur's scope. However all other piping as well as supply and fixing of cold water fitting basin shall be in other's scope. Ok Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok we are providing diflector which is inbuilt with casing valve to divert the water inside the basin Ok
Cooling tower fan and fan drive assemblies 6 with gear box drive shaft, couplings, base plate, safety guard.
Ok
Ok
Ok
Make-up and drain piping upto distance 5 m with valves, fittings, supports and 7 supporting structures, cooling tower basin, ladder , fan stack, Sump screen, sluice gates/damboards.
NOT GS
Make-up and drain piping upto distance 5 m with valves-we are providing but in clients scope.sluice gates/damboards.not applicable
Vibration switch for fan & Level switch for 8 the sump.
Not Applicable
By others
By others
9 Testing of equipment as per agreed quality assuranceOk plan. 10 First fill of oil lubricants and grease. Ok Fixing Arrangement, Holding down bolts, Foundation bolts, Hardwares, Matching 11 flanges, Inter connecting pipes & pipe fittings, Valves etc. 12 Tools and tackles for erection and maintenance 13 Commissioning spares 14 Spares for 2 years of operation Any other item required for completeness/safe and efficient operation 15 of equipment not specifically mentioned above 16 Supervision of commissioning
Ok Not Applicable
Ok Ok
Ok Ok
Ok Ok ok.Matching flangesInter Connecting Pipes & pipe fittings, Valves etc.-not in our scope of supply not applicable not applicable -
Ok
By others
By others
Ok Ok
Ok Ok
Ok Ok
Will be quoted
Separate offer for the same submitted. Refer Annexure V of our proposal
Ok Ok
Ok Ok
Ok Ok
Not applicable. Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok
Ok Not Applicable
SN 1 2 3 4 5
DESCRIPTION Cooling tower Capacity Outlet Temperature Evaporation losses Fan brake, horse power + 2% kW tolerance
ANNEXURE - IV PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE-RAJASHREE-750m3/h UNITS GEM PALTECH PAHARPUR PCFR-2424 SCT 500-3/3R 372-103 750 CMH 750 750 Deg C 32 32 32 % 2.02 1.98 2.167 10.26 8.71 14.54 125 micron in vertical direction at the top of motor.
MIHIR
4FM16-9E-12.5 750 32 2.16 7.91
UNITED
UFC-341-S 750 32 2.12 15
Vibration level measured at bearing housing not to exceed mm/sec 3mm/sec (Peak to peak)
OK
OK
OK
OK
SN 1 2 3 4 5
DESCRIPTION Cooling tower Capacity Outlet Temperature Evaporation losses Fan brake, horse power + 2% kW tolerance
ANNEXURE - IV PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE-RAJASHREE-600m3/h UNITS GEM PALTECH PAHARPUR PCFR-2424 SCT 400-3/4R 368-103 600 CMH 600 600 Deg C 32 32 32 % 1.99 1.98 2.167 7.56 5.57 14.54 125 micron in vertical direction at the top of motor.
MIHIR
4FM16-7.5E-10 600 32 2.16 6.37
UNITED
UFC-331-S 750 32 2.12 11.25
Vibration level measured at bearing housing not to exceed mm/sec 3mm/sec (Peak to peak)
OK
OK
OK
OK
ANNEXURE - IV PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE- RAWAN SN 1 2 3 4 DESCRIPTION Cooling tower Capacity Outlet Temperature Evaporation losses UNITS CMH Deg C % kW GEM SCT 500-3/3R 750 32 2.02 10.26 PALTECH PCFR-2424 750 35 1.98 8.71 PAHARPUR 372-103 750 32 2.167 14.54 125 micron in vertical direction at the top of motor.
MIHIR
4FM16-9E-12.5 750 32 2.16 7.91
UNITED
UFC-341-S 750 32 2.12 15
5 Fan brake, horse power + 2% tolerance Vibration level measured at bearing 6 housing not to exceed 3mm/sec (Peak to peak)
mm/sec
OK
OK
OK
OK
TECHNICAL DATASHEET-RAWAN II SN A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 17 B 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Description Cooling Tower Item no. Manufacturer Type No. off Model no. Water flow Water Holdup volume in tower Hot water temperature Cold water temperature Design wet bulb temperature Drift loss Evaporation loss No. of cells Water flow rate per cell, Normal/Min./Max Fill type Drift eliminator Nominal cell dia ( LxW ) Overall cell dimensions (LxWxH) Cooling Tower Fan No. of fans Diameter / no of fan blades Speed of fan Fan tip speed Brake KW of fan (each) Material of fan blade / Hub Total static pressure Total velocity pressure Air discharge(minimum) Fan static efficiency mm of WC m3/min m m UOM GEM PALTECH PAHARPUR MIHIR
GEM Counter flow 1 SCT-500 3/4R 750 NA 45 32 26 0.05 2.01 3 250 FILM FLOW C-19 ANGULAR FILM FLOW 5X5 5.49 3 mm RPM m/s kW 3050/?? 360 57.4 8.87 MSHDG 8.576 2.693 3378 78
Paltech Induced Draft Counterflow 1 PCFR-2424 750 Depends on RCC Basin Height by Client 45 32 26 0.05 1.98 3 250 FILM FILL CELLULAR 4.876x?? 4.986 x 5.08 3 2337/6 560 < 65 8.3 FRP / HDGMS 9.317 5.367 2574 75
45 32 26 0.05 2.167 3 250 PVC V Bar Treated Timber 48'-7/12 x 23'-2 " 48'-7 /12" x 23'-2" x 12'-6 1/8" 3 2438/ 6 444 56.65 14.54 Cast aluminium alloy/Cast iron latter Latter Latter latter
45 32 26 0.01% 2.16 4 187.5 PVC HONEY COMB PVC HONEY COMB 3.3 X 3.3 3.5 X 3.5 X 4.7 4 2400/6 500 62.8 7.31 FRP / CI + CAST ALUMINIUM ALLOY 160 Pa 2015 82
C 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 D 1 2 E 1 2 F 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Speed Reducer Type / Model Manufacturer Reduction ratio AGMA KW rating Service factor Vibration Lubrication Motors Power/Speed Power supply Vibration Switch Type/ no. off Make Material of Construction Casing/Basin Framework Fill/Fill support Drift eliminator Fan stack Sump screen Cat ladder Bolts/ Nuts/ washers Handrailings Nozzles FRP FRP PVC / SS PVC MSHDG SS MSHDG SS 304 BASIN NOT OUR SCOPE MSHDG MSHDG PVC MSHDG NA MSHDG SS 304 MSHDG Polypropylene FRP / RCC (By Client) FRP PVC/ HDGMS PVC FRP NA MSHDG SS 304 NA NA ACB Pressure Treated Wood PVC V bar supported on GRP grids Treated wood FRP By others Treated Timber HDH Steel excluded from our scope Polypropylene FRP FRP FRP / MSHDG PVC FRP MSHDG FRP MS GALVANISED NA Polypropylene ACD kW mm/sec HELICAL ROSEE 4:01 20 ABOVE 2 2 Not Applicable Due to Direct Drive System Spiral Bevel/Series 20T Paharpur Cooling Towers Ltd. 3.27:1 latter 2 latter Splash type 18.5/1500 415/3/50 By others By others INLINE HELICAL PREMIUM (GREAVES) 2.88 : 1 2.24
kW/rpm V;Ph;Hz
15/485 415/3/50
UNITED
UNITED Induced Draft Counterflow 1 UFC-341-S 750 75 45 32 26 0.05 2.12 3 250 PVC PVC 4.2x4.2x4.9 4.2x12.6x4.9 3 2350/?? 560 68.02 15 ALUMINIUM 6.75 129.27 48.87 41.08
direct driven
Not Applicable
TECHNICAL DATASHEET-RAJASHREE IV 750m3/hr SN Description A Cooling Tower 1 Item no. 2 Manufacturer 3 Type 4 No. off 5 Model no. 6 Water flow Water Holdup volume in 7 tower 8 Hot water temperature 9 Cold water temperature 10 Design wet bulb temperature 11 Drift loss 12 Evaporation loss 13 No. of cells Water flow rate per cell, 14 Normal/Min./Max 15 Fill type 16 Drift eliminator 17 Nominal cell dia ( LxW ) Overall cell dimensions 17 (LxWxH) B Cooling Tower Fan 1 No. of fans 2 Diameter / no of fan blades 3 Speed of fan 4 Fan tip speed 5 Brake KW of fan (each) 6 Material of fan blade / Hub 7 8 9 10 Total static pressure Total velocity pressure Air discharge(minimum) Fan static efficiency mm of WC m3/min % m m UOM GEM PALTECH PAHARPUR MIHIR
GEM Counter flow 1 SCT-500 3/4R 750 NA 45 32 26 0.05 2.01 3 250 FILM FLOW C-19 ANGULAR FILM FLOW 5X5 5.49 3 mm RPM m/s kW 3050/?? 360 57.4 8.87 MSHDG 8.576 2.693 3378 78
PALTECH Induced Draft Counterflow 1 PCFR-2424 750 Depends on RCC Basin Height by Client 45 35 26 0.05 1.98 3 250 Film Fill Cellular 4.876 4.986 x 5.08 3 2337/ 6 560 < 65 8.3 FRP / HDGMS 9.317 5.367 2574 75
45 32 26 0.05 2.167 3 250 PVC V Bar Treated Timber 48'-7/12 x 23'-2 " 48'-7 /12" x 23'-2" x 12'-6 1/8" 3 2438/ 6 444 56.65 14.54 Cast aluminium alloy/Cast iron latter Latter Latter latter
45 32 26 0.01% 2.16% 4 187.5 PVC HONEY COMB PVC HONEY COMB 3.3 X 3.3 3.5 X 3.5 X 4.7 4 2400/6 500 62.8 7.31 FRP / CI + CAST ALUMINIUM ALLOY 160 Pa 2015 82
C Speed Reducer 1 Type / Model 2 Manufacturer 3 4 5 6 7 D 1 2 E Reduction ratio AGMA KW rating Service factor Vibration Lubrication Motors Power/Speed Power supply Vibration Switch kW mm/sec HELICAL ROSEE 4:01 20 ABOVE 2 2 Not Applicable Due to Direct Drive System Spiral Bevel/Series 20T Paharpur Cooling Towers Ltd. 3.27:1 latter 2 latter Splash type 18.5/1500 415/3/50 By others ACD By others INLINE HELICAL PREMIUM (GREAVES) 2.88 : 1 2.24
KW/RPM V;Ph;Hz
15/485 415/3/50
1 Type/ no. off 2 Make F Material of Construction 1 Casing/Basin 2 Framework 3 Fill/Fill support 4 5 6 7 8 Drift eliminator Fan stack Sump screen Cat ladder Bolts/ Nuts/ washers FRP FRP PVC / SS PVC MSHDG SS MSHDG SS 304 BASIN NOT OUR SCOPE MSHDG MSHDG PVC MSHDG NA MSHDG SS 304 MSHDG Polypropylene FRP / RCC (By Client) FRP PVC/ HDGMS PVC FRP NA MSHDG SS 304 NA NA
ACB Pressure Treated Wood PVC V bar supported on GRP grids Treated wood FRP By others Treated Timber HDH Steel excluded from our scope Polypropylene
FRP FRP FRP / MSHDG PVC FRP MSHDG FRP MS GALVANISED NA Polypropylene
9 Handrailings 10 Nozzles
UNITED
UNITED Induced Draft Counterflow 1 UFC-341-S 750 75 45 32 26 0.05 2.12 3 250 PVC PVC 4.2x4.2x4.9 4.2x12.6x4.9 3 2350/?? 560 68.02 15 ALUMINIUM 6.75 129.27 48.87 41.08
SN Description A Cooling Tower 1 Item no. 2 Manufacturer 3 Type 4 No. off 5 Model no. 6 Water flow 7 Water Holdup volume in tower
UOM
MIHIR
UNITED
GEM Counter flow 1 SCT-400 3/4R 600 NA 45 32 26 0.05 1.99 3 200 FILM FLOW C-19 ANGULAR FILM FLOW m m 4X4 5.79 3 mm RPM m/s kW 2440/?? 485 62.5 6.35
MSHDG
PALTECH Induced Draft Counterflow 1 PCFR-2424 600 Depends on RCC Basin Height by Client 45 35 26 0.05 1.98 3 200 Film Fill Cellular 4.876 4.986 x 5.08 3 2337/ 6 560 < 65 8.3
FRP / HDGMS
UNITED Induced Draft Counterflow 1 UFC-331-S 600 60 45 32 26 0.05 2.12 3 250 PVC PVC 4x4x4.9 4x12x4.9 3 2350 560 68.02 11.25
ALUMINIUM
8 Hot water temperature 9 Cold water temperature Design wet bulb 10 temperature 11 Drift loss 12 Evaporation loss 13 No. of cells Water flow rate per cell, 14 Normal/Min./Max 15 Fill type 16 Drift eliminator 17 Nominal cell dia ( LxW ) 17 B 1 2 3 4 5 Overall cell dimensions (LxWxH) Cooling Tower Fan No. of fans/cell Diameter / no of fan blades Speed of fan Fan tip speed Brake KW of fan (each)
45 32 26 0.05 2.17% 3 200 PVC V Bar Treated Timber 36'-7/12" x 21'-2" 36'-7 1/2" x 21'-2" x 12'-6 1/8" 3 2438/6 444 56.65 14.5
Cast aluminium alloy/Cast iron
45 32 26 0.01% 2.16% 4 150 PVC HONEY COMB PVC HONEY COMB 3.3 X 3.3 3.5 X 3.5 X 4.7 4 2400/6 500 62.8 7.31
FRP / CI + CAST ALUMINIUM ALLOY
7 8 9 10 C
Total static pressure Total velocity pressure Air discharge(minimum) Fan static efficiency Speed Reducer
mm of WC m3/min %
6.55 118.17 42.63 41.08 direct driven NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 11.25/?? 440 /3/50 MECH/ 1 PER CELL UNITED
1 Type / Model 2 Manufacturer 3 4 5 6 7 D 1 Reduction ratio AGMA KW rating Service factor Vibration Lubrication Motors Power/Speed NOT APPLICABLE kW mm/sec Not Applicable Due to Direct Drive System
kW/RPM V;Ph;Hz
11/485 415/3/50
18.5/1500RPM 415/3/50
2 Power supply E Vibration Switch 1 Type/ no. off 2 Make F Material of Construction 1 Casing/Basin 2 Framework 3 Fill/Fill support 4 5 6 7 Drift eliminator Fan stack Sump screen Cat ladder
BASIN NOT OUR SCOPE MSHDG MSHDG PVC MSHDG NA MSHDG SS 304 MSHDG Polypropylene
FRP / RCC (By Client) FRP PVC/ HDGMS PVC FRP NA MSHDG SS 304 NA NA
ACB Pressure Treated Wood PVC V bar supported on GRP grids Treated wood FRP By others Treated Timber HDG Steel excuded from our scope Polypropylene
FRP FRP FRP / MSHDG PVC FRP MSHDG FRP MS GALVANISED NA Polypropylene