Multi-Engine Class Rating: Flight Test Guide
Multi-Engine Class Rating: Flight Test Guide
TC-1003710 *TC-1003710*
Please direct your comments, orders and inquiries to: The Order Desk MultiMedia Publishing Services Transport Canada (AARA-MPS) 330 Sparks Street Ottawa ON K1A 0N8 Telephone: Fax: E-Mail: 1-888-830-4911 (in North America) 613-991-4071 (other countries) 613-991-1653 [email protected]
Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of Transport, 2009. Permission is granted by the Department of Transport, Canada, to copy and/or reproduce the contents of this publication in whole or in part provided that full acknowledgment is given to the Department of Transport, Canada, and that the material be accurately reproduced. While use of this material has been authorized, the Department of Transport, Canada, shall not be responsible for the manner in which the information is presented, nor for any interpretations thereof. The information in this publication is to be considered solely as a guide and should not be quoted as or considered to be a legal authority. It may become obsolete in whole or in part at any time without notice.
TC-1003710
DEFINITIONS
examiner means a Pilot Examiner accredited under section 4.3 of Part 1 of the Aeronautics Act or a Civil Aviation Inspector authorized to conduct this flight test. flight test item means a task, manoeuvre or exercise listed on the flight test report. ground flight test items are the planning and preparatory tasks performed prior to the pre-flight inspection of the aircraft. air flight test items are tasks or manoeuvres performed with the aircraft, including the pre-flight inspection, start-up, run-up, taxiing and emergency procedures.
Changes that effect prerequisites or competency standards are indicated by a bold vertical line along the right margin.
2.
3. 4. 5.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
GENERAL ........................................................................................................................................................1 ADMISSION TO THE FLIGHT TEST ..................................................................................................................1 ADMISSION TO A PARTIAL FLIGHT TEST .......................................................................................................1 AEROPLANE REQUIREMENTS.........................................................................................................................2 FLIGHT TEST...................................................................................................................................................2 REPEATED FLIGHT TEST ITEM .......................................................................................................................2 INCOMPLETE FLIGHT TEST ............................................................................................................................3 FAILURE OF A FLIGHT TEST ...........................................................................................................................3 PARTIAL FLIGHT TEST ...................................................................................................................................4 COMPLETE RE-TEST .......................................................................................................................................4 PRE-TEST BRIEFING .......................................................................................................................................4 DEFINITIONS ...................................................................................................................................................5 FLIGHT MANAGEMENT ..................................................................................................................................6 Problem Solving and Decision Making.....................................................................................................6 Situational Awareness ...............................................................................................................................6 Communication..........................................................................................................................................6 Workload Management..............................................................................................................................6 AIRMANSHIP ...................................................................................................................................................6 FLIGHT TEST RESULTS ...................................................................................................................................7 ASSESSMENT OF FLIGHT TEST PERFORMANCE .............................................................................................7 ERRORS...........................................................................................................................................................8 Minor Error ...............................................................................................................................................8 Major Error ...............................................................................................................................................8 Critical Error .............................................................................................................................................8 DEVIATIONS ...................................................................................................................................................8 Minor Deviation.........................................................................................................................................8 Major Deviation.........................................................................................................................................8 Critical Deviation ......................................................................................................................................8 4-POINT MARKING SCALE ......................................................................................................................9 HOW TO PASS THE FLIGHT TEST .................................................................................................................10 FLIGHT TEST ITEMS.................................................................................................................................11 EX. 1 - AEROPLANE FAMILIARIZATION AND PREPARATION FOR FLIGHT ............................11 A. Documents and Airworthiness ...........................................................................................................11 B. Performance and Limitations.............................................................................................................12 C. Principles of Flight One Engine Inoperative .................................................................................13 D. Weight and Balance, Loading ...........................................................................................................14 E. Pre-Flight Inspection (Air Item) ........................................................................................................15 F. Engine Starting, Run-up and Use of Checklists ................................................................................16 EX. 2 - ANCILLARY CONTROLS/OPERATION OF AIRCRAFT SYSTEMS....................................17 EX. 3 - TAXIING ........................................................................................................................................18 EX. 4 - TAKEOFF, CIRCUIT AND LANDING .......................................................................................19 A. Takeoff ................................................................................................................................................19 B. Circuit.................................................................................................................................................20 C. Approach and Landing ......................................................................................................................21 EX. 5 - CRUISING FLIGHT ......................................................................................................................22 EX. 6 - ENGINE FAILURE (CRUISE FLIGHT) AND MANOEUVRING WITH ONE ENGINE INOPERATIVE ...........................................................................................................................................22 A - Aeroplane Control .............................................................................................................................23 B Cockpit Checks ..................................................................................................................................23
i
C Single-engine Manoeuvring..............................................................................................................23 EX. 7 - MANOEUVRING AT REDUCED AIRSPEED............................................................................24 EX. 8A - STALL..........................................................................................................................................25 EX. 8B APPROACH TO STALL............................................................................................................26 EX. 9 - STEEP TURN .................................................................................................................................27 EX. 10 - ENGINE FAILURE DURING TAKEOFF OR OVERSHOOT .................................................27 A - Aeroplane Control .............................................................................................................................28 B Cockpit Checks ..................................................................................................................................28 EX. 11A - INTENTIONAL ENGINE SHUTDOWN ................................................................................29 EX. 11B - ARRIVAL, APPROACH AND LANDING - ONE ENGINE INOPERATIVE .....................29 EX. 12 - EMERGENCY PROCEDURES/MALFUNCTIONS .................................................................30 RECOMMENDATION FOR FLIGHT TEST...........................................................................................31 RECOMMENDATION FOR PARTIAL FLIGHT TEST .......................................................................33
ii
GENERAL
Admission to the Flight Test
For admission to a flight test required for the issuance of a Multi-Engine Class Rating and to meet the requirements of CAR standard section 421.14, the candidate will present: (a) (b) (c) photo identification; a Pilot Licence - Aeroplane category and a medical certificate validating the licence; a recommendation letter dated within 30 days prior to the flight test from a person qualified in accordance with section 425.21(5) of the Personnel Licensing Standards certifying that: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) the candidate has successfully completed a pre-test evaluation of all the applicable flight test items; the candidate has received training in accordance with the Instructor Guide Multi-Engine Class Rating (TP 11575); the candidate is considered to have reached a sufficient level of competency to undertake the flight test for the issuance of a multi-engine class rating; the candidate is recommended for the flight test.
Sample letters of recommendation are included at the end of this flight test guide.
Aeroplane Requirements
The candidate will provide an aeroplane that: (a) (b) has a flight authority pursuant to CAR 507 and that authority has no operating limitations that prohibit the performance of the required manoeuvres; and meets the requirements of section 425.23 - Training Aircraft Requirements subsections (1) and (2) of the Personnel Licensing Standards.
Flight Test
All of the flight test items required by the flight test report and described in this guide must be completed and the minimum pass mark for the Multi-Engine Class Rating flight test of 73 (70%) must be achieved. All flight tests will be conducted when weather conditions do not present a hazard to the operation of the aircraft, the aircraft is airworthy and the candidate and aircrafts documents, as required by the Canadian Aviation Regulations, are valid. It is the sole responsibility of the examiner to make the final decision as to whether or not any portion or all of the flight test may be conducted. Ground flight test items 1A to 1D will be assessed before the flight portion of the flight test.
(d)
Note: These provisions have been made in the interest of fairness and safety and do not mean that instruction, practice, or the repeating of a flight test item or manoeuvre unacceptably demonstrated, are permitted during the flight test evaluation process.
Complete Re-test
A complete re-test will be required in the following situations: (a) the required pass mark is not obtained during a complete flight test; (b) failure of a ground item; (c) failure of more than two air items during a complete flight test; (d) failure of an item during a partial flight test; (e) displaying unsafe flying or dangerous behaviour that is not linked to a skill, lack of training or competency; (f) a demonstrated pattern of failing to use proper visual scanning techniques is displayed during the flight test; or (g) a partial flight test is not completed within 30 days of the original complete flight test. Note: The candidate should not present the flight test report from the previously failed complete flight test to the examiner.
Pre-Test Briefing
Flight test examiners are required to brief test candidates on the following details: (a) The sequence of flight test items. There is no need for the candidate to memorize the sequence, as the examiner will give instructions for each item. (b) If in doubt -- ask! Candidates who do not clearly understand what they are being asked to do should feel free to ask. It may be that the examiner was not clear in giving instructions. (c) Who is pilot-in-command? The pilot-in-command should be the flight test candidate and, if the examiner is a Transport Canada employee, it will always be the flight test candidate. (d) Who will do what in the event of an actual emergency? A briefing by the candidate should detail the actions to be taken by the candidate and examiner in the event of an actual emergency. (e) How to transfer control. There should never be any doubt as to who is flying the aircraft, so proper transfer of control through the words "You have control" and "I have control" is expected during a flight test. A visual check is recommended to verify that the exchange has occurred. (f) Method of simulating emergencies. What method will be used? Verbal? Simulated zero thrust setting? Engine failures will only be simulated in accordance with the manufacturers recommendations or, in their absence, by closing the throttle or by reducing power to flight idle. The moving of mixture controls to idle cut-off will only be used where specifically recommended by the manufacturer. No simulated engine failure will be initiated below 500 feet AGL. Note: The practice of closing fuel valves, shutting off magneto switches or pulling of circuit breakers will not be used during a flight test.
Definitions
(a) (b) (c) Critical engine - The engine that, upon failure, would most adversely affect the performance or handling qualities of an aeroplane. Design Flap Speed (VF) - the maximum speed at which wing flaps may be extended. Intentional One Engine Inoperative Speed (VSSE) - a speed above both (VMC) and stall speed, selected to provide a margin of lateral and directional control when one engine is suddenly rendered inoperative. Intentional failing of one engine below this speed is not recommended. In the event that the POH/AFM does not state a VSSE, use a speed equal to VMC +10 knots. Manoeuvring Speed (VA) - the maximum speed at which the application of full available aerodynamic control will not overstress the aeroplane. Maximum Flap Extended Speed (VFE) - the maximum speed permissible with the wing flaps in a prescribed extended position. Maximum Landing Gear Extended Speed (VLE) - the maximum speed permissible with the landing gear extended. Maximum Landing Gear Operating Speed (VLO) the maximum speed permissible for operating the landing gear. Minimum Control Speed (VMC) - the minimum flight speed at which it is possible to retain control of the aeroplane and maintain straight flight, with maximum rudder deflection and not more than 5 degrees of bank, following sudden failure of the critical engine. NOTE: (VMC) for an aeroplane type is generally determined under the following conditions: (i) (ii) (iii) all engines developing maximum rated power at the time of critical engine failure; the aeroplane is at a minimum practical test weight with a rearmost centre of gravity; landing gear retracted, flaps in take-off position and the propeller of the failed critical engine windmilling.
At speeds below (VMC), the aeroplane will yaw and roll towards the failed engine. It cannot be too strongly emphasized that control will be regained only by a reduction in power of the good engine or by increasing airspeed through a change in pitch attitude, or both. (i) (j) (k) One Engine Inoperative Best Angle-of-Climb Speed (VXSE) - the speed that provides the maximum altitude gain for the horizontal distance travelled with one engine inoperative. One Engine Inoperative Best Rate-of-Climb Speed (VYSE) - the speed that provides the maximum altitude gain per minute with one engine inoperative. Stalling Speed (VSO) - the minimum steady flight speed at which the aeroplane is controllable in the landing configuration.
Flight Management
Flight management refers to the effective use of all available resources, including working with such groups as dispatchers, other crewmembers, maintenance personnel, and air traffic controllers. Poor performance of an item or task can often be explained by weaknesses in flight management competencies.
Situational Awareness
(a) (b) (c) (d) actively monitors weather, aircraft systems, instruments, ATC communications avoids tunnel vision - awareness that factors such as stress can reduce vigilance stays ahead of the aircraft in preparing for expected or contingency situations remains alert to detect subtle changes in the environment
Communication
(a) (b) (c) (d) provides thorough briefings asks for information and advice communicates decisions clearly asserts ones position appropriately
Workload Management
(a) (b) (c) (d) organizes cockpit resources well recognizes overload in self eliminates distractions during high workload situations maintains ability to adapt during high workload situations
Airmanship
The candidates airmanship will be assessed along with other factors in determining the mark awarded for each item. Items such as looking out for other aircraft, use of checklists, consideration for other aircraft on the ground and in the air, choice of run-up areas, choice of runways and clearing the engine during prolonged glides will be assessed. The candidate will be expected to demonstrate good airmanship and complete accurate checks on a continuing basis.
Errors
Error: means an action or inaction by the flight crew that leads to a variance from operational or flight crew intentions or expectations.
Minor Error
An action or inaction that is inconsequential to the completion of a task, procedure or manoeuvre, even if certain elements of the performance vary from the recommended best practices.
Major Error
An action or inaction that can lead to an undesired aircraft state or a reduced safety margin, if improperly managed; or an error that does not lead to a safety risk, but detracts measurably from the successful achievement of the defined aim of a sequence/item:
Critical Error
An action or inaction that is mismanaged and consequently leads to an undesired aircraft state or compromises safety such as: Non-compliance with CARS or non-adherence to mandated standard operating procedures; or Repeated improper error management or uncorrected and unrecognized threats, which risk putting the aircraft in an undesired state; or Repeated major errors or the non-performance of certain criteria prescribed in the Performance Criteria* that are essential to achieving the Aim* of a test sequence/item.
Deviations
Deviation: means a variance in precision with respect to a specified tolerance published for a manoeuvre within a test item or sequence, which is a result of pilot error or faulty handling of the aircraft.
Minor Deviation
A deviation that does not exceed a specified tolerance:
Major Deviation
A deviation that exceeds a specified tolerance or repeated minor deviations without achieving stability:
Critical Deviation
A major deviation that is repeated, excessive or not corrected, such as: Repeated non-adherence to specified tolerance limits; or More than doubling the specified value of a tolerance limit; or Not identifying and correcting major deviations.
Performance is observed to include minor errors: Aircraft handling with appropriate control input but includes minor deviations. Technical skills indicate an adequate knowledge of procedures, aircraft systems, limitations and performance characteristics to successfully complete the task. Situational awareness is adequately maintained as candidate responds in a timely manner to cues and changes in the flight environment to maintain safety while achieving the aim of the sequence/item. Flight management skills are effective. Threats are anticipated and errors are recognized and recovered. Safety margins are maintained through effective use of aircraft systems and mandated operational protocols.
Performance is observed to include major errors: Aircraft handling is performed with major deviations and/or an occasional lack of stability, over/under control or abrupt control input. Technical skills reveal deficiencies either in depth of knowledge or comprehension of procedures, aircraft systems, limitations and performance characteristics that do not prevent the successful completion of the task. Situational awareness appears compromised as cues are missed or attended to late or the candidate takes more time than ideal to incorporate cues or changes into the operational plan. Flight management skills are not consistent. Instrument displays, aircraft warnings or automation serve to avert an undesired aircraft state by prompting or remedying threats and errors that are noticed late. Safety margins are not compromised, but poorly managed.
Performance is observed to include critical errors or the Aim of the test sequence/item is not achieved: Aircraft handling is performed with critical deviations and/or a lack of stability, rough use of controls or control of the aircraft is lost or in doubt. Technical skills reveal unacceptable levels of depth of knowledge or comprehension of procedures, aircraft systems, limitations and performance characteristics that prevent a successful completion of the task. Lapses in situational awareness occur due to a lack of appropriate scanning to maintain an accurate mental model of the situation or there is an inability to integrate the information available to develop and maintain an accurate mental model. Flight management skills are ineffective, indecisive or noncompliant with mandated published procedures: and corrective countermeasures are not effective or applied. Safety margins are compromised or clearly reduced.
(f)
10
11
(vii) maximum flap extended speed (VFE); (viii) intentional one engine inoperative speed (VSSE). (b) calculate, for the proposed flight: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) the acceleratestop distance, where data is available; the total take-off distance required to clear a 50 foot or existing obstacle; time and fuel required to climb to a specified altitude; one engine inoperative rate of climb; one engine inoperative enroute performance at the planned cruising altitude; the power setting proposed for the planned cruising flight (percentage, manifold pressure and RPM) and the expected cruise speed in KTAS;
(vii) the available flight time with the fuel load and power settings proposed for the flight; and (viii) the total landing distance required to clear a 50 foot or existing obstacle;
12
explain the configuration, airspeed and flight profile that the aeroplane must be in to successfully complete a one-engine inoperative overshoot with the aeroplane to be used for the test.
13
14
15
Note: Failure to use the appropriate checklist will constitute failure of this item.
16
17
EX. 3 - TAXIING
Aim To determine that the candidate can manoeuvre the aeroplane safely on the ground and avoid unnecessary interference with the movement of other traffic. Description The candidate will be expected to taxi the aircraft to and from the runway in use and as otherwise required during the test. If traffic permits, the candidate will taxi along taxiway centrelines where they exist. While taxiing, the candidate will be expected to confirm the proper functioning of the flight instruments. Should the candidate omit flight instrument checks, the examiner will ask the candidate to complete these checks prior to take-off. Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) perform a brake check; use power controls, flight controls and brakes appropriately; use appropriate taxiing speeds; safely manoeuvre the aeroplane, considering other traffic on aprons and manoeuvring areas; adhere to local directives, procedures and Air Traffic Services (ATS) clearances and instructions; identify and correctly interpret aerodrome taxiway and runway signs, markings and lighting; confirm the proper functioning of flight instruments; after landing, clear the runway/landing area and taxi to a suitable parking/refuelling area; and park the aeroplane correctly and appropriately, considering the safety of nearby persons or property.
18
19
B. Circuit
Aim To determine that the candidate can operate the aeroplane in the vicinity of an aerodrome in a safe manner and with a degree of accuracy. Description The candidate will demonstrate correct circuit procedures, including departure and joining procedures for the aerodrome(s) being used. The candidate will demonstrate an ability to comply with ATF/MF procedures and ATS clearances or instructions, while maintaining separation from other aircraft. Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) comply with actual ATS clearances or instructions; comply with circuit entry and departure procedures; comply with established circuit patterns; fly an accurate circuit maintaining correct position and separation from other aircraft; correct for wind drift to maintain proper ground track; remain oriented with the runway/landing area in use; maintain circuit altitude (100 feet) and an appropriate airspeed (10 knots); complete appropriate checks; and comply with other procedures that may be in effect at the time.
20
21
EX. 6 - ENGINE FAILURE (CRUISE FLIGHT) AND MANOEUVRING WITH ONE ENGINE INOPERATIVE
Aim To determine that the candidate can maintain control of the aeroplane after an engine failure during cruising flight and manoeuvre the aeroplane with one engine inoperative. Description At an operationally safe altitude or the manufacturers recommended minimum height, whichever is higher, the examiner will simulate the failure of an engine during straight and level flight or during a medium level turn. If the failure occurs during a turn, the candidate will be expected, with minimal pause, to continue the turn towards the assigned heading. The candidate will be expected to control the aeroplane, identify the failed engine, perform the cause checks, simulate feathering the propeller and simulate shutting down the failed engine in accordance with the appropriate checklist. The candidate will be asked to turn toward and away from the inoperative engine to specific headings (using appropriate angles of bank, not to exceed 30), climb and descend to assigned altitudes and maintain straight and level flight. The candidate will demonstrate good decision-making to deal with the consequences of such a failure during cruising flight.
22
A - Aeroplane Control
Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) control the aeroplane; maintain directional control and maintain an assigned heading or continue, with minimal pause, the turn to an assigned heading (20 degrees) using angles of bank not exceeding 30 degrees; set the power controls, confirm cruise configuration, and identify and verify the inoperative engine; establish a bank toward the operating engine, as recommended for best performance; take appropriate action to restore power; and then simulate the action required to feather the propeller and shut down the failed engine; trim the aeroplane as required; maintain recommended airspeeds (10 knots); and maintain assigned altitudes, if the aeroplane is capable (100 feet).
B Cockpit Checks
Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) complete engine failure vital action checks from memory; attempt to determine the possible cause of the (simulated) engine failure; complete all actions in accordance with the emergency checklist (Engine Failure in Flight); determine the feasibility of restarting the affected engine, and if feasible, follow the appropriate restart procedures; if not, complete shut-down checks and other necessary checks in accordance with the appropriate emergency checklist(s); monitor the operating engine and take appropriate action to keep the operating engine parameters within limitations; and demonstrate good decision-making to deal with the consequences of the failure.
C Single-engine Manoeuvring
Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) use appropriate pitch and bank attitudes; properly use controls and trim while climbing and descending and turning to assigned headings.
23
NOTE: This exercise is to be conducted in level flight. There is no requirement to climb or descend at the target airspeed.
24
EX. 8A - STALL
Aim To determine that the candidate can recognize and safely recover smoothly and correctly from an actual stall in a clean configuration with a minimum loss of altitude. Description At an operationally safe altitude that would allow recovery at or above 2,000 feet AGL or the minimum height recommended by the manufacturer, whichever is higher, a stall will be entered in a clean configuration from straight and level flight, with the power set at or near idle on all engines. The candidate will recognize, enter and recover smoothly and correctly from an actual stall, with a minimum loss of altitude. Note: In cases where the POH/AFM states that intentional stalls should be avoided or are prohibited, the candidate will be expected to recover at the first indication of an imminent stall. Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) (i) complete appropriate safety precautions before approaching the stall; establish the specified configuration; transition smoothly to an attitude that will induce a stall; recognize the onset of a stall; and enter a stall; promptly and smoothly recover using control application in the proper sequence and appropriate attitude control; maintain directional control and recover safely with a minimum loss of altitude; avoid entering a secondary stall; and return to the altitude, heading and airspeed specified by the examiner.
25
26
27
A - Aeroplane Control
Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) (h) recognize the simulated engine failure promptly; control the aeroplane; set the power controls and reduce drag by using control application, in the proper sequence; identify and verify the inoperative engine; bank toward the operating engine, as recommended for best performance; maintain directional control within 20 degrees of assigned heading. establish a positive rate of climb, if the aeroplane is capable; accelerate to and maintain one engine inoperative best angle-of-climb speed (VXSE) (+10/-5 knots), if required for obstacle clearance, or accelerate to and maintain one engine inoperative best rate-of-climb speed (VYSE) (+10/-5 knots); trim the aeroplane, as required; and continue the overshoot towards a specified altitude;
(i) (j)
B Cockpit Checks
Performance Criteria Assessment will be based on the candidates ability to: (a) locate the necessary controls and switches to carry out and complete the emergency procedures in accordance with the approved emergency procedures checklist (Engine Failure during Takeoff or Overshoot): (i) (ii) (iii) (b) complete prescribed engine failure vital action checks from memory; complete the emergency drill, in accordance with the emergency checklist; complete engine shutdown checks and other necessary checks in accordance with the appropriate emergency checklist(s).
monitor the operating engine and take appropriate action to keep the operating engine parameters within limitations.
28
29
Note: Although it is recommended that one of these emergencies be tested in flight, it is the sole responsibility of the examiner to determine if aeroplane performance, weather conditions and other factors permit the safe conduct of this item in flight or on the ground with engines running. Some of the items may be tested on the ground with engines shut down.
30
the above noted candidate has successfully completed a Pre-Test Evaluation of all flight test items; the candidate received training in accordance with the Instructor Guide Multi-Engine Class Rating (TP 11575); the candidate is considered to have reached a sufficient level of competency to complete the flight test required for the issuance of a Multi-Engine Class Rating and I hereby recommend the candidate for the flight test; and I am qualified through the privileges of my pilot licence and experience on aeroplane class and type to make this recommendation.
FTU Code No.:
(d)
Person Recommending:
Licence No.:
Signature:
Date:
I, the undersigned, certify that: (a) (b) (c) I have conducted a review of flight test item(s) _____________________________________ and have completed additional training with the above named candidate; I consider the candidate to have reached a sufficient level of competency to successfully complete the flight test for the issuance of the Multi-Engine Class Rating; and I hereby recommend the candidate for the partial flight test.
Person Recommending:
Licence No.:
Signature:
Date: