This document provides an introduction to health insurance. It discusses what health insurance is, providing a brief history and key milestones in the evolution of health insurance in the United States, UK, and India. Some of the main points covered include defining health insurance and its purpose of addressing rising medical costs, benefits of health insurance for individuals, and inherent problems in health insurance markets like moral hazard and adverse selection.
This document provides an introduction to health insurance. It discusses what health insurance is, providing a brief history and key milestones in the evolution of health insurance in the United States, UK, and India. Some of the main points covered include defining health insurance and its purpose of addressing rising medical costs, benefits of health insurance for individuals, and inherent problems in health insurance markets like moral hazard and adverse selection.
This document provides an introduction to health insurance. It discusses what health insurance is, providing a brief history and key milestones in the evolution of health insurance in the United States, UK, and India. Some of the main points covered include defining health insurance and its purpose of addressing rising medical costs, benefits of health insurance for individuals, and inherent problems in health insurance markets like moral hazard and adverse selection.
This document provides an introduction to health insurance. It discusses what health insurance is, providing a brief history and key milestones in the evolution of health insurance in the United States, UK, and India. Some of the main points covered include defining health insurance and its purpose of addressing rising medical costs, benefits of health insurance for individuals, and inherent problems in health insurance markets like moral hazard and adverse selection.
Copyright:
Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 0
Page 1 of 19
Chapter 1: Introduction to Health Insurance
Certificate in Health Insurance
Confidentiality statement
This document should not be carried outside the physical and virtual boundaries of TCS and its client work locations. Sharing of this document with any person other than a TCSer will tantamount to violation of the confidentiality agreement signed when joining TCS.
Notice The information given in this course material is merely for reference. Certain third party terminologies or matter that may be appearing in the course are used only for contextual identification and explanation, without an intention to infringe. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 3 of 19
Contents
Chapter - 1 Introduction to Health Insurance .................................................................... 4 Introduction ...................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 What is Health Insurance? ...................................................................................... 5 1.2 History of Health Insurance....................................................................................6 1.3 Milestones in Evolution of Health Insurance ..........................................................6 1.3.1 United States: ....................................................................................................6 1.3.2 UK ...................................................................................................................... 7 1.3.3 India: .................................................................................................................. 8 1.4 Necessity of Health Insurance ................................................................................ 8 1.5 Benefits of Health Insurance ..................................................................................9 1.6 Additional Benefits of Health Insurance ............................................................... 10 1.7 Rising Healthcare costs a driver for transition to Health Insurance....................... 11 1.8 Comparative analysis of Healthcare spending ..................................................... 13 1.9 Public Health and Aging ...................................................................................... 14 1.10 Inherent Problems in Health Insurance Markets .................................................. 14 1.10.1 Moral hazard ................................................................................................ 14 1.10.2 Adverse selection ......................................................................................... 14 1.10.3 Covariate risks .............................................................................................. 15 1.10.4 Information problem .................................................................................... 15 Summary ........................................................................................................................ 16 References ...................................................................................................................... 18
Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 4 of 19
Chapter - 1 Introduction to Health Insurance
Introduction Since ancient ages, the saying goes health is wealth. And perhaps that is true, today you spend a fortune if a health problem arises. To keep the fortune and meet the expenses of the healthcare, insurance has emerged as an ally. Health Insurance plays an important role in the global economy today with innovative products and services. Particularly it is a useful risk mitigating tool. This chapter provides an overview of the healthcare industry from its nascent stages to its current scenario in the world economy. In this chapter we will identify the key events in the evolution of Health Insurance.
Learning Objectives On completion of this chapter, you will understand the: Healthcare reimbursement / Health Insurance Evolution / Milestones in Health Insurance Purpose of Health Insurance Benefits and drivers of Health Insurance
Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 5 of 19
1.1 What is Health Insurance?
Health Insurance is also known as medical insurance, accident and health insurance or sickness and accident insurance. It covers all types of disability, loss of income, medical expense and accidental death. It can be defined as any form of insurance whose payment is contingent on the insured incurring additional expenses or losing income because of incapacity or loss of good health. In medical insurance, benefits become payable on disability as a result of accident or sickness. Health insurance can address the problems related to rising medical expenses.
Health insurance is a kind of insurance wherein the insurance company pays medical expenses of the insured in case he/she falls sick due to causes covered. It may also cover expenses when the sickness is due to accidents. Such insurance results in faster healthcare facilities to the insured. For example, when someone is suffering from cancer, expenditure is very high and medical care could be for an extended period of time. A person may not have the resources normally for such conditions, but insurance can help pay for all such expenses.
Health insurance functions as a shield against rising medical costs. As any other insurance, health insurance is also a contract between the insurer and an individual or group (proposed insured), wherein the insurer agrees to provide health insurance at a given premium. Based on policy type, premium can be paid in regular installments or in lump sum. The insurance policy is a contract renewed annually.
Health insurance is based on the principle that what is highly unpredictable to an individual is predictable to a group of individuals.
Health insurance expenses could be paid in two ways either as a direct payment or reimbursement for expenses paid by insurer for illness and injuries. The extent of expenses and kind of illnesses covered depends on the policy and insurance company.
When health insurance claims are made, the individual policy-holder needs to pay a deductible and co-payment. For example, hospitalization may need that the first $100 of fees has to be borne by the insured and also $50 per night charge for hospital stay. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 6 of 19
Health insurance policy often mentions what medical benefits are offered including tests, drugs and treatment services. The insurer agrees to cover expenses relating to certain benefits mentioned in the policy. These are termed "covered services."
Health insurance is also at times clubbed with other plans such as pensions, life insurance which is sponsored by the employer.
Health Insurance may fall under the category of both Life as well as General Insurance, it can be termed as Life when the insurer indemnifies the insured in case of loss of income due to health constraints, where as it is termed as General or Non Life when insurer pays/ reimburses the medical expenses of insured. 1.2 History of Health Insurance
Health Insurance evolved with the advancements in healthcare and inventions in the field medicine. Health insurance concept was pioneered by Hugh the Elder Chamberlen from the Peter Chamberlen family in 1694. Also in 17 th century medieval guilds in Germany had the solidarity-based relief funds. In the latter part of 19 th century, health insurance was provided in the form of disability insurance, as it covered only those which caused disability.
In 1883, Germany passed the first ever national compulsory health insurance law. The compulsory health insurance idea spread slowly from Germany, accelerating after the turn of the 20th century. Today, over 60 nations have some form of compulsory governmental program. The programs vary widely, and some allow private insurance to supplement the governmental program. 1.3 Milestones in Evolution of Health Insurance 1.3.1 United States:
Year 1850 - Franklin Health Assurance Company of Massachusetts started providing accident insurance, to cover injuries related to railroad and steamboat travel. 1890 - First individual disability and illness policy 1929 - First modern group health insurance plan was formed Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 7 of 19
1939 - American Hospital Association (AHA) started a non-profit organization called Blue Cross to designate healthcare plans 1946 - Physician-sponsored plans combined to form Blue Shield 1940s - 1950s - Employee benefit plans introduced and unions bargained for better benefit packages, including tax-free, employer-sponsored health insurance. 1965 - Government initiated Medicare and Medicaid programs 1980s - 1990s - Employer-sponsored group insurance plans switched from fee-for-service plans to the cheaper managed care plans. 1993 - Healthcare reform plan that guaranteed health insurance for all Americans 1996 - Mental Health Parity Act (MHPA), to require some employers to offer health plans with psychiatric benefits and also Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) 1997 - The State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), was established by the federal government to provide health insurance to children in families at or below 200 percent of the federal poverty line 2010 - The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act was enacted for introducing mandated health insurance with reforms designed to eliminate some of the worst practices of the insurance companies
1.3.2 UK
Year 1832 - British Medical Association (BMA) was founded 1911 - National Insurance Act was introduced 1930s A conventional mix, 90% of the workforce had social insurance and the other 10% and all dependants either had private insurance or made full out-of-pocket payments 1942 - Beveridge Report recommended a service that was universal (covering all people) and comprehensive (covering all needs) 1946 - National Health Service (NHS) was founded 1948 Hospital System was nationalized CMS (Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services) predicted that Americas national health spending would grow at 5.8 percent annually from 2010-2020, while its GDP is witnessing an average annual growth rate of 3.8 percent. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 8 of 19
1990 - National Health Service and Community Care Act was passed to set up independent Trusts that managed hospital care 1.3.3 India:
Year 1912 - Insurance Act, 1912 passed to regulate Insurance Industry 1923 Workmans Compensation Act passed to provide relief to factory workers in case of factory accidents 1938 Insurance Act, 1938 passed. Categorization:-Life & Non- Life Insurance 1948 - Employees State Insurance (ESI) Act passed for welfare of workers & dependants in organized sector for sickness, death and maternity. 1954 - The Central Government Health Scheme came into existence covering all the Central Government employees. 1956 - Life Insurance industry nationalized and Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) was set up. 1972 - General Insurance industry nationalized; General Insurance Corporation of India (GIC) came into existence. Existing private companies merged into 4 companies namely: - NICL, NIACL, OICL and UIICL. 1981 - GIC offering Limited Hospitalization Cover 1986 - GIC introduced Mediclaim insurance 1996 - Differential Premiums introduced by GIC 1999 - Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA) Act passed, Private participation allowed, FDI ceiling marked at 26% 2001 - Indian Insurance Amendment Act, 2001. GIC became re-insurer. IRDA provisions for TPA (Third Party Administration) in Health Insurance. General Insurance (Public Sector Companies) Association (GIPSA) formed by merging subsidiaries of GIC. 1.4 Necessity of Health Insurance
As any other insurance product, health insurance can be considered a risk mitigation tool, to meet any expenses associated with uncertain health conditions in the future. And for any society or a country it is tool to address the healthcare needs of the whole set of people.
Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 9 of 19
The primary purpose of health insurance is to protect people from the financial risks of illness by enabling people to incur healthcare costs without worrying too much about the financial consequences. In other words, insurance allows patients to focus on solving the health problem rather than paying for it. It minimizes the uncertainty of both the timing of treatment and the cost of treatment.
1.5 Benefits of Health Insurance
The following are the benefits offered under health insurance: i. Medical Expense Cover: Basic hospitalization expenses are reimbursed. It covers payment of expenses related to hospitalization and the services rendered by the doctor and the nursing home. In the US context medical insurance is popularly covered through Blue Cross and Blue Shield insurance schemes. These medical schemes take care of the medical expenses. The main benefit under these insurance schemes is that a pre-determined number of days stay in the hospital and hospital costs are covered under the scheme. Apart from these costs, all other costs for services provided by the hospital are covered while the insured remains to be hospitalized. Blue shield plans, pay to the doctor/hospital on behalf of the insured. In some cases the balance of the expenses are to be borne by the insured himself. ii. Major Medical Expense Cover/Long-term Care Insurance: It covers expenses related to major surgery or operations, due to serious illness or disease. Major medical coverage continues protection after basic medical expense insurance benefits have exhausted. The major medical insurance policies may add benefits for some services not covered by the medical expense insurance policies. A high deductible is applied to major medical insurance. The insured must pay an amount of medical bills equal to the deductible, so that the insurer will pay the expenses in excess of the deductible. iii. Disability Income Cover: This policy is primarily aimed at indemnifying the lost income during the disability period/treatment period. It tries to replace the income that cannot be earned due to sickness of the assured. The benefit is usually paid as a percentage of the capital sum insured, and is paid weekly. It is basically an indirect A person asked God, What surprises you most about mankind? God answered, They lose their health to make money and then money to restore their health. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 10 of 19
protection to the insured. The period for such compensation can either be short/long. iv. Pre & Post Hospitalization Expenses: Many companies allow these expenses. The permitted number of days differs from company to company. v. Transportation Charges to the Hospital (Ambulance Charges): Some insurers schemes provide for reimbursements. vi. Extent of Cover: A majority of schemes are operational throughout the country. Some schemes are operational in selected hospitals only. vii. Domiciliary Treatment Charges: Generally, allowed for a stipulated minimum number of days. Subject to acceptable proof that such treatment was required. viii. Cashless Hospitalization Treatment: Majority of insurers are now offering this facility by the way of TPAs (Third Party Administrators). ix. Donor Expenses: All hospitalization expenses incurred by the donor in case of major organ transplant are covered in certain insurance policies
1.6 Additional Benefits of Health Insurance
Apart from providing protection to the insured, health insurance provides benefits as a long-term savings tool and reduces undue mental tension at the time of critical illness or disability. Following are the additional benefits of health insurance: i. Savings Tool: People may prefer to save in various saving instruments than buying a health policy. But these savings involve a lot of time and may not be available at short notice and at the time of need. A saving program will yield very little in the beginning, while an insurance policy guarantees the full value and also various benefits mentioned in the policy at any point of time during the tenure of contract. Thus, if a person is unable to save sufficient amount in the early stages of his life, he should at least obtain a health insurance policy to meet any contingency related to his health/disability. A 2008, Mckinsey Report states that, 40% of medical travelers seek advanced technology, while 32% seek better healthcare. Another 15% seek faster medical services while only 9% of travelers seek lower costs as their primary consideration Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 11 of 19
ii. Safe and Beneficial Instrument: A health insurance policy can be used as an accumulation plan. In addition to this, tax benefits are also available on the health policies, which increase its attractiveness as a saving tool. iii. Minimizes Worry: A health policyholder need not worry about the medical expenses incurred or loss of income in case of disability. The health policy takes care of all this and thus reduces undue tension on the part of the individual and his family. iv. Promotes Thrift: Health insurance policy may also lead to compulsory savings, if it is in the form of cash value policy. In a cash value policy, if the policyholder didnt make any claims earlier, the whole sum insured is paid back. Thus, it leads to accumulation of savings through health insurance. 1.7 Rising Healthcare costs a driver for transition to Health Insurance
Following are the key factors that contribute to the rise in healthcare expenditure:- Rising Personal Income: Economists agree that rising personal income leads to higher spending on healthcare. Because healthcare is a desired service, people naturally demand more of it as their income rises; other things being equal, rising income will lead to an increase in the quantity of healthcare demanded and therefore higher total spending. Defensive Medicine and Supplier-Induced Demand: "Defensive medicine" refers to services that have little or no clinical value but that physicians order or perform at least partly to avoid lawsuits. Advances in Medical Technology: Medical technology saves lives, decreases pain, enhances lifestyles, increases function and improves health. Advances in medical science during the past several decades have greatly increased the set of available medical services, allowing practitioners to treat patients in ways that were not previously possible. Most health policy analysts agree that the long-term increase in healthcare spending is principally the result of the healthcare systems incorporation of these new services into clinical practice Taxation: Various governments are trying to impose newer set of taxes which are further going to add up to healthcare costs. Demographics: This holds good for nations like US and UK, where there is an aging population, who are naturally prone to frequent medication and hospitalization. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 12 of 19
Overtreatment: The one thing almost everyone can agree on is that overtreatment is one of the primary causes of increasing healthcare costs, and many factors contribute to overtreatment: Quantity over Quality: Americas fee-for-service payment system rewards doctors for the number of patients they see and the number of treatments they prescribe, rather than the quality of care they provide. Medical Malpractice: Healthcare providers in order to increase the billing to the insurer try to increase the quantity of services by providing even unnecessary services. Consumer Choice: Too many people see doctors when theyre not ill and insist on tests or treatments they dont need. Experts say almost 25 percent of the doctor visits are nothing more than social calls and nearly half of all emergency room visits are for medical care that could have been received during a regular doctor appointment. Stringent Regulations on Pharmaceutical companies: With the intervention of regulators and NGOs (Non-Governmental Organisations) in the clinical trial policies of Pharmaceutical companies, the cost of R&D in rolling out a drug has risen, leading to a burden on the cost of medicine being sold. Prescription Drugs: Usually prescription drugs are costly when compared to generic drugs. And the use of prescription drugs has increased leading to a higher expenditure on healthcare Preventable Illnesses: Another big factor in soaring medical expenses is the cost of caring for patients who are chronically ill.
Of the $2.3 trillion that Americans spent on healthcare in 2007, somewhere between $500 billion and $700 billion was spent on tests, treatments and hospital stays that did nothing to improve their health. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 13 of 19
1.8 Comparative analysis of Healthcare spending Table 1 Healthcare spending across nations Country Brazil China India Japan USA UK
Year 2009 2009 2009 2009 2009 2009
Total expenditure on health as a percentage of gross domestic product
9.0 4.6 4.2 8.3 16.2 9.3
General government expenditure on health as a percentage of total expenditure on health
45.7 50.1 32.8 80.0 48.6 83.6
Private expenditure on health as a percentage of total expenditure on health
54.3 49.9 67.2 18.5 51.4 16.4
General government expenditure on health as a percentage of total government expenditure
6.1 10.3 4.1 17.9 18.7 15.1
Social security expenditure on health as a percentage of general government expenditure on health
0 66.3 15.9 81.5 28.3 0
Out-of-pocket expenditure as a percentage of private expenditure on health
57.1 82.6 74.4 80.6 24.2 63.7
Private prepaid plans as a percentage of private expenditure on health 41.2 6.2 2.3 13.8 69.3 6.7
Source: WHO Statistics
Interpretation: From the above mentioned tabular of statistical data on spending on healthcare by various countries, following are the extracts:- USA has got the highest healthcare spending to GDP ratio of all. In Japan, government bears the major share on the healthcare expenditure. Most of the healthcare expenditure is borne by Individuals and private Insurers China and India are the countries which have got least health insurance penetration and in a country like USA health insurance penetration is highest. Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 14 of 19
1.9 Public Health and Aging Decline in fertility and an increase in the average life-span have lead to an increase in the median age of the worlds population. The growing number of older adults increases demands on the public health system and on medical and social services. Chronic diseases, which affect older adults disproportionately, contribute to disability; diminish quality of life and increased healthcare and long-term-care costs. 1.10 Inherent Problems in Health Insurance Markets Health insurance is complex and there are serious market-failure problems. Because of various demand and supply side imperfections, there are a lot of concerns in the health insurance markets. Important constraints to insurance contracts are: Moral hazard Adverse selection Covariate risks Information problems 1.10.1 Moral hazard
It arises because policyholders would like to take decisions and actions which maximize their own benefit and do not want to bear the full cost. Unregulated healthcare markets and private insurance encourage this behaviour since insurance lowers or avoids the cost of treatment at the point of treatment: Consumers tend to demand more (consumer moral hazard). Providers have an incentive to render more or unnecessary care that might be medically appropriate (provider induced moral hazard). To combat this problem, most insurance companies use mechanisms and conditionalities which in the end only create a burden on policyholders with respect to cost. Some of the mechanisms which insurance companies have adopted are co-payments or co-insurance, deductibles, or a reduced premium bonus for the future. 1.10.2 Adverse selection
Adverse selection arises when persons belonging to high-risk groups seek coverage and the insurer cannot identify the risk. All the policyholders are required to pay the same premium, Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 15 of 19
whereas those belonging to high-risk groups are likely to consume more than the average quantity of services; who finds the insurance policy more attractive and those with good health will find insurance premium to be too high. Hence very few low-risk people will enrol in insurance scheme and, as a result, the insurer finds a pool of more risk cases. 1.10.3 Covariate risks
The basic objective of any insurance mechanism is to protect individuals from risk. In most situations, the insurer helps in protecting policyholders from unique health risks and it is expected that these risks are not related to others in the insurance pool. However, if covariate or collective risks cause damage to a lot of members or even to all the members of pool at the same time, there is nothing to be gained by co-operation. If all policyholders face similar risks, risks cannot be reduced much by having insurance. 1.10.4 Information problem
Availability of information would have significant bearing on the development of insurance contracts. The severity of a moral hazard problem and adverse selection problems will depend on differences in availability of information between the insurer and policyholders. In order to address this problem insurance companies need significant investments in infrastructure and development of systems.
Hence these risks and their impacts on different stakeholders are summarized in the following tabulation:
Insurance settings Risks and concerns Govt Market Member Moral hazard -- + ++ Adverse selection +++ -- - Covariate risks +++ ++ +/- Cost efficiency -- ++ +/- Quality - +++ +/- Equity of access ++ --- ++
+++ strong comparative advantage / (---) strong disadvantage Govt: universal insurance run by government Market: private voluntary insurance Member: insurance systems run by member-based organisations Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 16 of 19
Summary Health Insurance can be defined as any form of insurance whose payment is contingent on the insured incurring additional expenses or losing income because of incapacity or loss of good health Health insurance is based on the principle that what is highly unpredictable to an individual is predictable to a group of individuals. Health insurance concept was pioneered by Hugh the Elder Chamberlen from the Peter Chamberlen family in 1694 In the year 1850, Franklin Health Assurance Company of Massachusetts started providing accident insurance, to cover injuries related to railroad and steamboat travel in US In the year 1911, National Insurance Act was introduced in UK In the year 1912, Insurance Act was passed to regulate Insurance Industry in India The primary purpose of health insurance is to protect people from the financial risks of illness by enabling people to incur healthcare costs without worrying too much about the financial consequences. Health insurance provides cover for the following expenses: Medical Expense Cover Major Medical Expense Cover/Long-term Care Insurance Disability Income Cover Pre & Post Hospitalization Expenses Transportation Charges to the Hospital Extent of Cover Domiciliary Treatment Charges Cashless Hospitalization Treatment Donor Expenses Additional benefits of health insurance include: It acts as a Savings Tool Safe and Beneficial Instrument Minimizes Worry Promotes Thrift
Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 17 of 19
Key factors contributing to the rising healthcare expenses are: Rising Personal Income Defensive Medicine and Supplier-Induced Demand Advances in Medical Technology Taxation benefits Demographics of nations Overtreatment which is because of provider preferences of quantity over quality, use of medical malpractices and customer preferences Stringent Regulations on Pharmaceutical companies Prescription Drugs Preventable Illnesses USA has got the highest ratio of healthcare spending with respect to its GDP over other nations Inherent problems (risks) in health insurance markets are: Moral hazard Adverse selection Covariate risks Information problems
Certificate in Health Insurance TCS Business Domain Academy
Page 18 of 19
References K.Sujatha Rao, Financing and Delivery of Health Care Services in India, Commission on Macroeconomic and Health insurance in India Jonathan Gruber and Helen Levy, The Evolution of Medical Spending Risk, Journal of Economic Perspectives-Volume 23, Number 4-Fall 2009, Pages 2548 Bhat Ramesh & Mavlankar Dileep (2000), Health Insurance in India: Opportunities, Challenges and Concerns, Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad. World Health Organization (2002), World Health Report 2002: Reducing risks, promoting healthy life, WHO: Geneva. World Health Organization (2006), Health financing: A strategy for the African Region, Addis Ababa: World Health Organization.
Notice The information given in this course material is merely for reference. Certain third party terminologies or matter that maybe appearing in the course are used only for contextual identification and explanation, without an intention to infringe.