The International Journal of Engineering and Science (The IJES)
The International Journal of Engineering and Science (The IJES)
The International Journal of Engineering and Science (The IJES)
: 2319 1805
Origin, Probable Uses And Investigations Of The Hydraulic Connectivities Of The Small Tropical Lakes In Nsukka Se Of Anambra Basin Southeastern Nigeria - A Preliminary Approach To Water Resource Development
Dr. Nwagbara1, Johnbosco Okechukwu2
1 Onunkwo A, Adepartment Of Geosciences, Federal University Of Technology, Owerri
,2,
-----------------------------------------------------ABSTRACT----------------------------------------------------The origin, probable uses and the investigation of the hydraulic connections of the small tropical lakes found in parts of Nsukka SE in Anambra River Basin of South-Eastern Nigeria was studied. The aim is to integrate the lake characteristics into the water resource development of the region. The study using various analytical apparatus include measurement of static water levels at different seasons of the year, Hydrogeochemistry of the lakes and emphasis laid on geochemical correlation of the waters of the various lakes. A total of six lake bodies were studied. The concentrations Ca2+, Mg2+, Na+, Mn2+, Cl- Pb, Cd, K+, Cu physical parameters, Fe2+, Tds, Turbidity, HCO3- and SO42+ were measured. Water level variation of the lakes were also estimated at both the dry and rainy seasons. The result shows that All the lakes are magnesium rich and have Ca Mg facies. The lakes are mildly acidic to acidic and have high iron content. Other chemical constituents are in conformity with the acceptable standard of world health organization 1984 for drinking water. The range of abundance of major cations and anions are in the following order. Mg > Ca > Na + K and Cl > SO4 > HCO3. This indicates that magnesium and Chloride are the major dissolved constituents. The lake waters are fresh dominated by magnesium and no dominant anion. The lakes are ideal for industrial, agricultural and domestic uses except that treatment to reduce iron content and elevate the ph is required. Finally, it was discovered that the lakes are Eutrophic, of tectonic origin and connected underground.
KEYWORDS: small tropical lakes, water resources, development, Anambra drainage basin, se Nigeria
Nsukka SE -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Submission: 18, June ,2013 Date of Publication: 7, Aug ,2013 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.
INTRODUCTION
The area of study consists of Ekwegbe, Opi, EhaAlumona, Ehandiabu and Orba. The terrain is dotted by surface water bodies which are lakes. Effort has been made to examine the origin of the lakes and to examine the probale uses also if there is any underground hydraulic connections between the waters of the lakes. The aim is to integrate the lake study into the water resources development of the region. Investigations were also made to examine if the lakes have connections with the rivers / streams. The six major lakes selected for the study include, varavara lake, Iyiohe lake, Ijii, Ohere, Idodo and Ajoiyi, all of them are within the farm land lowlying areas of discharge environment. From literature the lakes are classified as Eutorophic (Winter, 2003). Winter (2003) defined eutrophic lakes as those that are shallow, green to yellow to brownish green, have low transparency and are rich in calcium and dissolved oxygen though not often above 40%. The shape and size of a lake are largely dependent on the forces that produced them (Stephenson 2004). According to Winter 2003, individual lakes may be formed as a result of the combination of more than one of these factors Glacial action, aqueous agencies (Karst Lakes) tectonic activity volcanic agencies. Stephenson (2004) proposed two views on the possible origin of the lakes in the area of study. These are paleocurrent and tectonic forces. Origin dependent on paleocurrent is based on the depositional cycle of the formations in the Anambra basin. The lakes could be regarded as abandoned water bodies during the regression of the sea in the Maastritchian period (Reyment, 1965), as the sea was withdrawing, some of its waters were entrapped within small depressions within the deposited sediments. The entrapped water bodies remain without drying up because they are underlain by impermeable shale strata of Mamu Formation. They are recharged by underground water ( Welch, 2000).The origin based on tectonism holds that the lakes were formed as a result of tectonism in the Benue Trough of which Anambra basin is a part Ofoegbu (1985).
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 60
II.
METHODOLOGY
2.1.Description of study area: The area is a part of Anambra basin whose rocks are upper cretaceous in age (Reyment 1965). It lies within latitude 6 42 N and 6 48 N, longitude 7 26 E - 7 36 E and covers an area of about 160km2 Fig 1
Fig. 1: Topographical Map of the study area The stratigraphic sucession in Anmabra basin is given in Table 1. Three geological formations that outcrop in the area include Mamu Formation ( lower Maastritchian Ajalli Sandstone (upper Maastritchian ) and Nsukka Formation (Danian) Fig 2
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 61
Fig. 2: Geological map of the study area The Nsukka Formation is described as cap rock previously known as the upper coal measures (Simpson 1954, Reyment 1965). The Mamu Formation consists of mudstone, sandy shales and fresh water sandstone Reyment (1964) noted the presence of ammoniferous shales in some parts of the Formation. Coal seams have also been described at Enugu. The measured value of average dip of the area gives 4 to 8 in the western direction (Onunkwo-Akunne, 2000). The sandstone unit of the formation is fine grained . The Mamu Formation provides the shaley impermeable base on which the waters of Ajali aquifer are trapped. The Mamu Formation is comformably overlain by Ajali sandstone. The Ajali Sandstone (upper Maastritchian is about 451m thick Agagu et al (1985). Lithologically the Ajali sandstone consists mainly of medium to coarse grained, poorly consolidated white sands with characteristic cross bedding ( Hoque and Ezepue, 1997). Outcrops of Ajali sandstone is very thin within the farm land discharge areas of the low lying environment that habours the lakes (Agagu et.al. 1965). Agagu et al (1965) have reported presence of such Ostracods as cytherella , ovocytherides and a few foraminifera such as Hyplophragmoids and a few foraminifera such as Hypophragmoids and Ammobaculites in the Ajali sequence. The Nsukka Formation is related to Mamu Formation in many aspects except that Nsukka Formation has no coal seam in the study area. Outliers of Nsukka Formation dot the area with Ajali sandstone providing the base (Hogue and Ezepue, 2004). Table 1 Stratigraphic Succession in Anambra basin (Reyment 1965)
Age Epoch Tertiary Age Miocene-recent Formation Benin Formation Lithology Medium-coarse grained, poorly consolidated sands with clay lenses and stringers. Unconsolidated sands with lignite seams. Grey clayey sandstone and sandy clay stones. Laminated clayey shales Sandstones intercalating with shales Poorly consolidated sandstone, typically cross beded with minor clay layers. Shales, sandstones, mudstones and coal seams. Dark grey shale, clayey shale with clay lenses Bluish grey shale with clay lenses. Black shale with clay and limestone lenses.
Ogwashi Asaba Formation Ameki Formation Imo Shale Nsukka Fm Ajali Sandstone
Upper Cretaceous
Lower Cretaceous
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 62
III.
METHOD OF STUDY
The method of study includes literature review and reconnaissance work. Topographic and geologic maps of the area were employed in the identification of the various lakes of the area. Activities involved measurement of static water levels in the lakes at different periods of the year with emphasis on the peak of the rainy season (September) and dry season (January ) as to ascertain the nature of recharge. The hydrogeochemistry of the lakes were studied and emphasis laid on geochemical correlation of the waters of the various lakes, also water samples were collected from lakes springs and streams of the area. The final phase was used for laboratory studies in which chemical analysis of water samples were carried out. 3.1.Data Acquisition: A total of 6 lake bodies were studied and include varavara lake, Ojii lake, Idodo lake, Iyioha lake Ohere lake and Ajoiyi lake. All the lakes are located within the discharge lowlying areas of the study environment ( see fig. 2 ). The water levels in the lakes were measures by a meter rule fixed at the middle of the lakes. Initial readings were then recorded. Other readings were taken at the peak of the rainy and dry seasons. Water samples were collected from the various lakes for geochemical analysis and correlation. Atomic absorption spectroscopy was employed for the measurement of Ca 2+, Na+, Mn2+, Cl-, Pb and Cd. Potassium (K+) was determined using flame photometer, while copper was analysed with spectrophotometer while concentrations of total iron (Fe2+) were determined calorimetrically using Spekker absorption meter. Total dissolved Solids (Tds) was determined using glass fiber filter. The concentrations of Ca 2+, Mg2+ and Na+ in milliequivalent per litre were used to obtain sodium absorption ratio (SAR). Turbi metric method was used to assess turbidity. Physical parameters like pH and dissolved oxygen were measured insitu in the field with appropriate standard meters, while anions like HCO3- were estimated by titrimetric method. Clean plastic container were used to contain the water samples, they were rinsed several times with the same water samples to be analysed, then covered with air tight-cork, carefully labelled and sent to the laboratory for chemical analysis within 24 hours of collection. All details of analytical procedures are reported in Omidiran, (2005).
IV.
The results of the study are displayed in tables 2, 3 and 4 respectively. Table 2: Water level variations of the lakes (in meters) AVERAGE READINGS DRY SEASON READINGS Date water Levels Iyiohe Lake Ohere Lake Ajoiyi Lake Idodo Lake Vara vara Lake Ojii Lake
15-1190 Initial WL
20
15
10
20
30
50
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 63
-10
-5
+15
+25
-25
+62
Effluent and influent lakes Effluent and influent lakes Effluent and influent lakes General rise in WL
-5
-2
+30
-30
-20
+70
-3
-1
+38
-36
-14
+75
+80
+90
+55
+45
+50
+95
+100
+100
+60
-70
-67
+100
General rise in WL
+117
+114 .6
+70
+105
+80
+125
General rise in WL
Note: Negative values indicate a drop from the initial water level (WL). Positive values indicate an increase from the initial water levels (the instrument is a measuring rule in meters fixed in the Lakes and projected above the lake WL). Table 3: Hydrogeochemical Constituents of the lakes
Alkalinity Magnesiu m Iron Location Dissolved Oxygen Nitrate Hardness Phosphat e HCO3 Conducti vity ph Remarks Ac idi ty an d Ir on Co nt en t is hi gh Temp C Sulphate Calcium Sodium
TDS
Varavar a Lake
1 0
28. 2
14. 4
Ojii Lake
1 0
30. 3
17. 8
Ohere Lake
1 0
31. 8
11. 8
Idodo Lake
1 0
30
13. 4
5 . 4 5 5 . 1 8 6 . 1 6 5 . 3
3.1
2 . 7 3 . 2 2 . 4 3 . 0
1 2
1 . 6 6 . 3 4 . 7 1 . 8
3.2
3.7
1 5
3.4
1 . 8
1 1 . 6 1 1 . 6 1 1 . 6 1 1 . 6 1 1 . 6
9 . 7 1 4 . 6 9 . 7 9 . 7
1 . 6 1 . 2 1 . 7 2 . 5
2 8
1 . 4 1 . 8 1 . 9 1 . 8
8.2
. 7 3 . 1 2 . 3 5 . 6 2
.2
2 4
6.4
.5
4 6
12. 4
.7
2 5
6.4
Ajoiyi Lake
1 0
29. 5
14
5 . 8
3.5
2 . 6
1 . 6
1 . 6
9 . 7
1 . 2
.6
4 3
1 . 8
9.2
. 4 5
Average
1 0 . 0
29. 82
14. 17
5 . 4 8
3.3 8
2 . 6 7
9 . 7 3
3 . 4 5
1 1 . 6
1 0 . 5 2
1 . 6 2
.1. 77
. 3 5
1 . 4 5
10. 17
0 . 4 5
www.theijes.com
The IJES
K+
Page 64
Table 4: Cations and anions computations for the lakes in Milliequivalents per litre
Lakes Cations Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Ca2+ Mg2+ Na+ K+ Anions Conc (mg/L) 1.6 9.7 8 7.3 6.3 14.6 .2 .12 4.7 9.7 .6 .43 4.7 9.7 .5 .35 1.8 9.7 .7 .62 1.6 9.7 .6 .45 Conc (mg/L) 8.2 2.7 11.6 2.2 6.4 1.2 11.6 30 18.4 .48 11.6 22 12.4 .4 11.6 2.2 Atomi c Wt 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 40.08 24.31 22.98 39.10 Atomi c Wt 61.02 62.0 96.06 35.45 61.02 62.0 96.06 35.45 61.02 62.0 96.06 35.45 61.02 62.0 96.06 35.45 Charg e 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 Charg e 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 Conversio n Factor .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 .04990 .08226 .04350 .02557 Conversio n Factor 0.01639 0.01613 0.02082 0.02821 0.01639 0.01613 0.02082 0.02821 0.01639 0.01613 0.02082 0.02821 0.01639 0.01613 0.02082 0.02821 Equivale nt Mass 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 20.04 12.155 22.98 39.10 Equivale nt Mass 61.02 62.0 48.03 35.45 61.02 62.0 48.03 35.45 61.02 62.0 48.03 35.45 61.02 62.0 48.03 35.45 Milliequivale nt per litre .08 0.78 .35 .19 .31 1.20 0.009 0.003 0.23 0.80 0.03 0.01 0.23 0.80 0.02 .009 0.09 0.80 0.03 0.02 0.08 0.80 0.03 0.01 0.92 Milliequivale nt per litre 0.02 0.04 0.24 0.62 0.10 0.02 0.24 0.85 0.03 .007 0.24 0.62 0.20 .006 0.24 0.62 % total of Meq/L 5.71 55.71 25 13.57 20.40 78.95 0.59 0.20 21.50 74.77 2.80 0.93 21.70 75.47 1.89 0.85 9.57 85.12 3.19 2.13 8.70 86.96 3.26 1.09 100 % total of Meq/L 2.17 4.35 26.09 67.39 8.26 1.65 19.83 70.24 3.33 0.78 26.67 68.89 18.69 0.56 22.43 57.94
Varavara 1
Iyiohe 2
Ijii 3
Ohere 4
Idodo 5
Ajoiyi 6
Total Lake
Varavara 1
HCO3 NO3 SO4 CL HCO3 NO3 SO4 CL HCO3 NO3 SO4 CL HCO3 NO3 SO4 CL
Iyiohe 2
Ijii 3
Ohere 4
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 65
Ajoiyi 6
Fig. 3: Piper Trilinear plot representing the chemical characteristic of the lakes of the study area
Legend:
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Varavara Lake Iyiohe Lake Ijii Lake Ohere Lake Idodo Lake Ajoiyi Lake
Fig. 3: Piper Trilinear plot representing the chemical characteristics of the lakes - Varavara lake, Iyiohe lake, Ijii lake, Ohere lake, Idodo lake, Ajoiyi
Sodium content was used to classify the water quality of the lakes for irrigation purpose because of its reaction with soil to reduce permeability (Etuefeotor 1981). Thus the relation sodium absorption ratio (SAR)
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 66
Some of the lakes did not meet the specification of America Water Works Association 1991 for industrial water. Problem of inadequacy of total dissolved solids and pH are in shortfall and need to be upgraded to AWWA, 1991 status except Ohere lake whose pH is 6.16. The pollution index of Horton 1995 was also applied to ascertain the pollution index of the lakes as to assess the extent of their pollution (Horton, 1995). The Horton scale is shown in fig 5
Unit value (1) indicates tolerable standard, but above this value (1) the water is polluted and below this value the water is not polluted (Horton, 1995). The pollution index (piji) of the lakes was calculated employing equation (1) Where Ai is the measured parameter and wij is the universal standard . From equation (1) and employing the results of table 6 the average pollution index of the lakes give 4.3 indicating pollution, probably due to high iron and acidic content. Table 6: Computation of pollution Index of the lakes
Parameter Phat 29C Turbidity (NTU) Conductivity (ms) Tds Iron (Fe2+) Calcium (Ca 2+) Magnesium (Mg2+) Potassium (K+) Sulphate (SO42-) Phosphate (PO42-) Nitrate (NO3-) Chloride (Cl-) Carbonate (CO3-) Mean Ai 4.83 14.17 35 1.82 3.45 10.52 .45 11.6 1.75 4.4 10.17 Wij 6.50 _0 8.50 5.0 100 500 0.3 50 30 50 250 10 4.5 250 Ai / wij 0.64 .14 .07 6.07 .07 .68 .009 .05 .8 .10 .04 0.17 Result Max Ai Wij = 6.07 Mean Ai / wij = 0.17
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 67
Influent Lake
Effluent L ake
Water table
Fig 6: Schematic illustration of influent and effluent lakes (After Winter, 2001). Sieve analysis of the Ajali sandstone taken from the areas around the lakes indicate high permeabilities. From the works of Egboka and Uma (1983), the conductivity values of Ajali sandstone Formation is high in the area. Thus, there is probably hydraulic connection between the lakes. The lakes that loose water are at higher elevation than those that gain water. Stiff diagram indicate that Mg2+ and Cl- are the major dissolved species and also show uniformity in anion and cation plots which is another evidence of underground hydraulic connection. Pipers trilinear diagram shows that the lakes are magnesium type with no dominant anion and have Ca-Mg facies. The lakes are acidic to mildly acidic, above all, the highly permeable nature of Ajali sandstone in the sub layers of the lakes provide other evidence suggesting possible connections underground. The chemical constituents of the lakes are in conformity with world health organization standard guide lines for drinking water (Who, 1984). The range of abundance of the major cation anions are in the following order: Mg2+ > Ca2+ > Na+ > K+ for Cations and Cl- > So42-> HCO3- for anions. This indicates that Magnesium and Chloride are the major dissolved constituents. The lake waters plot within the zone of fresh water, though anion plot is undefined, but it is probable that Mg2+ and Cl- water is recommended. Acidity and iron content is high with low dissolved solids. Comparism of the lakes with American Water Works Association for industrial uses, shows that the lakes are ideal for industrial applications except that iron and acidity are out of range and therefore needs treatment. The Sodium absorption ratio of the lakes ranges from 0.007 to 0.38 indicating water excellent for irrigation Etuefeotor (1981). The waters of the lakes were also compared with the pollution indices of Horton (1995), and it shows that the average value for the lakes gives 4.3 indicating pollution, probably due to high iron content and acidic level of the lakes.
V.
The lakes found within Nsukka South East are Eutropic and the origin is due to tectonism. The lakes are hydraulically connected underground. It is also likely that fractures due to tectonic activity occurs underground. The lake waters are of magnesium type and are ideal for human consumption, agricultural and industrial purpose though iron and acid treatment are required. Alkaline fertilizer is recommended for formers as this will correct the acidic water. These informations should be integrated into the formulation of the water resource development of the region.
REFERENCES
[1]. [2]. [3]. [4]. [5]. [6]. [7]. [8]. [9]. [10]. Agagu, O.K., Fayose, E.A. and Peters S.W.(1985). Stratigraphy and Sedimentation in the Senonian Anambra basin of Southeastern Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Mining geology v 22(1) pp 25-36 AWWA (1995) American Water Works Association for industrial Waters pp 16-30. Egboka, B.C.E. (2003). Analysis of the groundwater resources, of Nsukka area and environs, Nigerian Journal of Min. and Geol. V. 20pp 1-6. Egboka, B.C.E. and Uma, K.O. (1986). Comparative analysis of transmissivity and hydraulic conductivity value, from Ajali aquifer system, Nigeria Journal of Hydrol v. 83, pp 185-196 EtuEfeotor, J.O. (1981). Preliminary hydrogeochemical investigation of the sub surface waters in parts of Niger Delta, Min. Geol. Pp 31-105. Edokwe, E.S. (2005). Soil variations under forest savanna mosaic of Nsukka area. Unpublished Ph.D thesis University of Nigeria Nsukka Hoque, M and Ezepue, M.C. (2004). Petrology and paleoheogrpahy of the Ajali Sandstone J. Min.Geol. V. 14 P 16 -22 Horton, (1995). An Index number rating system for rating water quality pollution control pp 37. Iloeje , N.P. (1995). A new Geography of Nigeria. (Revised Edition) Longman Nig. Ltd. Murat, E.C. (1980). Stratigraphy and paleogeography of the cretaceous and lower Tertiary in Southern Nigeria. In African Geology.pp 252-266. Ibadan University Press.
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 68
www.theijes.com
The IJES
Page 69