Scribd
Upload
46 views3 pages

Week 4 Ob Transcript

This week's discussion focuses on the concept of food addiction and whether overeating may be driven by an uncontrolled compulsion to eat high-sugar and high-fat foods, similar to a drug addiction. While food addiction has entered public discourse by comparing it to addictions like heroin, defining and diagnosing food addiction is complex. Recently, the Yale Food Addiction Scale has been used to attempt to determine if an individual's eating behaviors meet criteria for food addiction. However, there is reluctance to medicalize behaviors, and food addiction may not necessarily lead to obesity or apply to all obese individuals. Accepting food addiction could impact personal responsibility, treatment approaches, and food industry responses in unintended ways.

Uploaded by

Albert Rofi
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
46 views3 pages

Week 4 Ob Transcript

This week's discussion focuses on the concept of food addiction and whether overeating may be driven by an uncontrolled compulsion to eat high-sugar and high-fat foods, similar to a drug addiction. While food addiction has entered public discourse by comparing it to addictions like heroin, defining and diagnosing food addiction is complex. Recently, the Yale Food Addiction Scale has been used to attempt to determine if an individual's eating behaviors meet criteria for food addiction. However, there is reluctance to medicalize behaviors, and food addiction may not necessarily lead to obesity or apply to all obese individuals. Accepting food addiction could impact personal responsibility, treatment approaches, and food industry responses in unintended ways.

Uploaded by

Albert Rofi
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

Critical Thinking in Global Challenges Week 4 Global challenge focus: Obesity, Dr John Menzies

Greetings MOOCers and welcome to the introductory talk on the second topic related to the challenge of obesity. This week we are going to address the concept of food addiction, the idea that the high levels of obesity we see in our modern society may be driven, at least in part, by an uncontrolled compulsion to eat. A desire to eat that is analogous to a drug addicts desire to use a drug.

We saw in last weeks session that the prevalence of obesity has been steadily increasing over the past few decades and I mentioned the simple idea that obesity is driven by overeating. One notable thing, in Western countries at least, is that the increase in obesity has been accompanied by an increase in food availability. But this does not directly explain obesity, just because more food is available and it has become relatively cheaper, that does not mean that we should necessarily eat more. But the root cause of obesity is overeating. So what drives this overconsumption?

Slide 1 There are many factors that can drive eating. One of the most important is reward, the idea that we find high-sugar, high-fat palatable foods like chocolate more appealing, more rewarding and more pleasurable to eat. Compared to bland foods like grains and green vegetables, we experience chocolate as more rewarding, so much so that we will eat it even when we are not hungry.

Slide 2 There is no doubt that we are more motivated to consume these rewarding foods in preference to other sorts of food. But is it possible that our natural, evolved preference for energy-dense foods could tip into something more dangerous? Could we become addicted to these foods? By addiction I mean uncontrolled eating, eating that does not result in a pleasant sensation of satiety and fullness but in physical discomfort or feelings of regret or shame.

The idea of food addiction has been around for at least the past ten years and seems now to have entered the public consciousness.

Slide 3 This shows a selection of stories from the online media that compare overeating with addictions to heroin or tobacco. It is certainly clear that heroin addiction and an addiction to smoking exist, and on the face of it, it might seem appealing to consider that an addiction to food also exists. Not least because understanding such a phenomenon might lead to a better understanding of how the brain controls food choice.

But addiction of any sort is a complex condition, so what evidence is there for addiction to food? Long gone are the days where people who misused substances were considered to have some sort of behavioural or moral defect. We now recognise that using substances like alcohol or tobacco or other drugs can change the way the brain functions, and change it in an undesirable way. However, unlike say, diabetes for example, where the insulin and glucose in a patients blood can be measured to provide a diagnosis, addiction is much harder to define. Instead of being able to measure changes in body processes empirically, we must use psychological or psychiatric criteria to define addiction.

Slide 4 Such criteria already exist to diagnose addiction to drugs. For a diagnosis several but not all of these criteria need to be fulfilled. One is tolerance needing more of the drug to achieve the same effect. Others are the development of a withdrawal syndrome after stopping use, taking more of the substance than one intends, unsuccessful attempts to stop using the substance, or continued use despite unwanted consequences.

Is it possible that these criteria could be adapted to develop a way of defining food addiction? Recently, that has been attempted by adoption of the Yale Food Addiction Scale. This scale has been proposed to be a valid way of determining whether an individual is food addicted.

Slide 5 The scale is a questionnaire that asks the responder to think about their eating behaviour in the last year, with particular reference to palatable high-sugar or high-fat foods like chocolate or fried foods. They are asked whether they frequently overeat even when they are not hungry, whether they worry about eating certain foods, or trying not to eat them, whether overeating or the fear of overeating has resulted in them missing work or social activities, that sort of thing. By indicating how often they have such feelings or experiences a score is generated which is used as the basis for a diagnosis of food addiction. Use of the Yale scale is starting to become rather widespread

Slide 6 and it has been suggested that patients defined as food addicted using this scale are more susceptible to food cravings and binge eating. Furthermore, these patients are suggested to be more impulsive and more emotionally reactive. And they may also show a greater tendency to eat during periods of stress.

There is, rightly I think, a reluctance to characterise extreme forms of everyday activities as psychiatric or medical problems. How would we decide who lies at the upper limit of normal behaviour and who is at the lower limit of food addicted? As with most psychiatric diseases, this would be decided case by case with the attendant problems of different diagnoses between different psychiatrists and so on. And if food addiction does exist does it necessarily lead to obesity? Is it possible that a food addict could maintain a normal body weight? Similarly, it is surely not the case that all obese individuals are addicted to food.

Slide 7 At any rate, what might be the consequences of acceptance by the medical community of food addiction as a real phenomenon? Might it lead to a reduction in personal responsibility in certain groups? Would the overweight claim No! This is not my fault! Im addicted to food, my brain made me do it!. Would there be a rush to medicalise the problem? Would drug companies try to develop treatments for food addiction? Perhaps by adapting medicines already used for, say, alcohol dependence? How would the food industry respond? A new market could open up foods for the food-addicted. Would governments feel compelled to act to control this new public health problem, to create legislation to control our access to foods? Even if we could treat food addiction, what unintended consequences might that have on other normal human behaviours?

Considering what we currently understand about the pathways in the brain that mediate the sensations of reward and pleasure, it seems to be the case that the pleasure associated with many behaviours, not just eating, but sex and caring for ones children for example, all converge on the same brain pathways. If we were able to reverse food addiction by reducing the reward and pleasure associated with food maybe there would be unintended consequences. Perhaps we would also dull our responses to the other pleasures of life. Surely an unwanted outcome.

You might also like