Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.:
ETABS 2013 0
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002
WIDE FLANGE MEMBER UNDER BENDING EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION The frame object bending strengths are tested in this example. A continuous column is subjected to factored moment Mx = 1000 kN-m. This example was tested using the NZS 3404-1997 steel frame design code. The design capacities are compared with independent hand calculated results. GEOMETRY, PROPERTIES AND LOADING
Mx
L A A
Section A-A
L=6m Material Properties E = 200x103 MPa v = 0.3 G = 76923.08 MPa Loading Mx = 1000 kN-m Design Properties fy = 250 MPa Section: 350WC197
TECHNICAL FEATURES TESTED Section compactness check (bending) Section bending capacity Member bending capacity
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002 - 1
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.:
ETABS 2013 0
RESULTS COMPARISON Independent results are taken from hand calculations based on the CSI steel design documentation contained in the file SFD-NZS-3404-1997.pdf, which is available through the program Help menu. Percent Difference 0% 0% 0%
Output Parameter Compactness Section Bending Capacity, Ms,major (kN-m) Member Bending Capacity, Mb (kN-m)
ETABS Compact 837.5 1210.6
Independent Compact 837.5 1210.6
COMPUTER FILE: NZS-3404-1997 EX002 CONCLUSION The results show an exact comparison with the independent results.
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002 - 2
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.:
ETABS 2013 0
HAND CALCULATION Properties: Material: fy = 250 MPa Section: 350WC197 bf = 350 mm, tf = 28 mm, h = 331 mm, tw = 20 mm I22 = 200,000,000 mm4 Z33 = 2,936,555.891 mm2 S33 = 3,350,000 mm2 J = 5,750,000 mm4 Iw = 4,590,000,000,000 mm6 Member: le22 = 6000 mm (unbraced length) Considered to be a braced frame Loadings: M m * = 1000 kN-m This leads to: M 2 * = 250 kN-m M 3 * = 500 kN-m M 4 * = 750 kN-m Section Compactness: Localized Buckling for Flange: = e (b f tw ) f y 350 20 250 = = 5.89 2tf 250 2 28 250
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002 - 3
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.:
ETABS 2013 0
Flange is under uniform compression, so:
ep = 9, ey = 16, ew = 90 = e 5.89 < = 9 , No localized flange buckling ep
Flange is compact Localized Buckling for Web:
= e
fy h 331 250 = = 16.55 tw 250 20 250
Web is under bending, so:
ep = 82, ey = 115, ew = 180
= e 16.55 <= ep 30 , No localized web buckling Web is compact. Section is Compact. Section Bending Capacity: Z = Z = min( S ,1.5Z ) for compact sections e c
3,350, 000 mm 2 Z = Z = e 33 c 33
250 3,350, 000 /10002 M= M s ,major = f y Z= s 33 e 33
= M s 33 M = 837.5 kN-m s ,major
Member Bending Capacity: kt = 1 (Program default) kl = 1.4 (Program default) kr = 1 (Program default) lLTB = le22 = 6000 mm
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002 - 4
Software Verification
PROGRAM NAME: REVISION NO.:
ETABS 2013 0
le = kt kl kr lLTB = 1 1.4 1 6000 = 8400 mm 2
= = M M oa o
2 EI 22 2 EI w + GJ l 2 le 2 e
2 2 105 2 108 2 2 105 4.59 1012 76,923.08 5, 750, 000 M oa = Mo = + 8, 4002 8, 4002
M = M = 1786.938 kN-m oa o
2 2 M Ms 837.5 837.5 s 3 0.6 3 = s 0.6 + = + M oa 1786.938 1786.938 M oa s = 0.7954
= m
( M 2 *) + ( M 3 *) + ( M 4 *)
2 2
1.7 M m *
2.5
= m
1.7 1000
2 2
( 250 ) + ( 500 ) + ( 750 )
= 1.817 2.5
2
M b = m s M s =0.7954 1.817 837.5 M b = 1210.64 kN-m
NZS-3404-1997 Example 002 - 5
