Fabrication of Composite Natural Fiber
Fabrication of Composite Natural Fiber
Fabrication of Composite Natural Fiber
In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Bachelor of Technology in Mechanical and Automation Engineering Dhawal Shikhar Joshi Aditya Gupta Tirth Chauhan Arun Kumar Under the guidance of Mr. Shubham Sharma DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL & AUTOMATION ENGINEERING AMITY SCHOOL OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY AMITY UNIVERSITY UTTAR PRADESH NOIDA (U.P.)
1
Table of Contents List of Figures List of Tables Declaration Certificate Acknowledgement Abstract Contents 1. Introduction 1.1 Definition of a Composite 2. Classification of composites 2.1 According to the type of reinforcing material 2.2 According to type of matrix material 2.3 Hybrid Composites 2.4 Natural Fiber Reinforced Composites 3. Literature Review 4. Materials and Methods 4.1 Raw Materials 4.2 Fabrication of Composite Fiber 4.3 Testing 5. Result and Discussion 5.1 Tensile Test 5.2 Impact Test 5.3 Bending Load 5.4 Comparison 6. Conclusion and Future Prospects References 3 3 4 5 6 7
8-9
9-11
12-15 16-24
25-27
28 29-30
Description
Performance of a composite fiber as compared to glass fiber when used as a bonnet. Coir Fiber Bagasse Fiber Saccharum Munja Casting Procedure Cutting of Laminates Tensile Testing Flexural Testing
Page No. 15
17 18 18 21 22 23 23
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
LIST OF TABLES
Table Number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Description
Tensile Test Tensile Strength Impact Test Bending Load Impact Test Comparison Bending point Comparison Heat Resistance Test
Page Number
25 25 25 26 26 26 27
DECLARATION
We, Dhawa l S hikhar Joshi, Adit ya Gupt a, Tirt h Chauhan and Arun Kumar , student(s) of B.Tech (MAE) hereby declare that the project titled Fabrication of Composite Natural Fiber which is submitted by us to Department of Mechanical and Automation Engineering, Amity School of Engineering and Technology, Amity University Uttar Pradesh, Noida, in partial fulfillment of requirement for the award of the degree of Bachelor of Technology in Mechanical and Automation Engineering , has not been previously formed the basis for the award of any degree, diploma or other similar title or recognition.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
It is with a feeling of great pleasure that we would like to express our most sincere heartfelt gratitude to our mentor Mr. Shubham Sharma, Dept. of Mechanical and Automation Engineering, Amity School of Engineering and Technology, Amity University, Noida for his support and guidance throughout the course of our project. We are thankful to Prof. Vivek Kumar for his valuable suggestions. We would also like to thank all the lab assistants of the MAE Department for their help in fabrication work. Last but not the least, We would like to thank Narang metallurgical and spectro services for helping us with the testing work.
CERTIFICATE
On the basis of declaration submitted by Dhawal S hikhar Jo shi, Adit ya Gupt a, T irt h Chauhan and Ar un Kumar , students of B.Tech (MAE), I hereby certify that the project titled Fabrication of Composite Natural Fiber which is submitted to Department of
Mechanical & Automation Engineering, Amity School of Engineering and Technology, Amity University Uttar Pradesh, Noida, in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree of Bachelor of Technology in Mechanical & Automation Engineering, is an original contribution with existing knowledge and faithful record of work carried out by them under my guidance and supervision. To the best of my knowledge this work has not been submitted in part or full for any Degree or Diploma to this University or elsewhere. Noida Date 04/03/2013 Shubham Sharma Department of Mechanical & Automation Engineering Amity School of Engineering and Technology Amity University Uttar Pradesh
ABSTRACT
The experimental study conducted aims at studying the mechanical properties and behavior of composite natural fiber Made up of Coir (Coconut fiber) and Bagasse (Sugarcane fiber) and compare it with other composite fibers and woods. Samples of Coir-Bagasse-Epoxy & Saccharum munja-BagasseEpoxy hybrids were fabricated using hand layup method where the stacking of plies was alternate and according to a specific pattern. Specimens were cut from the fabricated laminate according to the ASTM standards for different experiments. 3 tests were conducted on the specimens namely Bending point test, breaking load test and impact test and the results were compared with that of tests conducted on samples of wood and other composite fiber. The tensile strength & impact strength of the coir-bagasse fiber was also calculated. Results pointed out the advantages of applying the natural composite fiber composites in place of wood in varied uses.
The following are some of the reasons why composites are selected for certain applications: High strength to weight ratio (low density high tensile strength) High creep resistance High tensile strength at elevated temperatures High toughness Low price Sustainability
2. CLASSIFICATION OF COMPOSITES
2.1 According to the type of reinforcing material composites can be classified as: (1)Fibrous Composite:
A fiber is characterized by its length being much greater compared to its cross-sectional dimensions. The dimensions of the reinforcement determine its capability of contributing its properties to the composite. Fibers are very effective in improving the fracture resistance of the matrix since a reinforcement having a long dimension discourages the growth of incipient cracks normal to the reinforcement that might otherwise lead to failure, particularly with brittle matrices. Man-made filaments or fibers of non polymeric materials exhibit much higher strength along their length since large flaws, which may be present in the bulk material, are minimized because of the small cross-sectional dimensions of the fiber. In the case of polymeric materials, orientation of the molecular structure is responsible for high strength and stiffness.
(2)Particulate Composites:
In particulate composites the reinforcement is of particle nature. It may be spherical, cubic, tetragonal, a platelet, or of other regular or irregular shape. In general, particles are not very effective in improving fracture resistance but they enhance the stiffness of the composite to a limited extent. Particle fillers are widely used to improve the properties of matrix materials such as to modify the thermal and electrical conductivities, improve performance at elevated temperatures, reduce friction, increase wear and abrasion resistance, improve machinability, increase surface hardness and reduce shrinkage.
2.2 According to type of matrix material they are classified as (1)Metal Matrix Composites:
Higher strength, fracture toughness and stiffness are offered by metal matrices. Metal matrix can withstand elevated temperature in corrosive environment than polymer composites. Titanium, aluminium and magnesium are the popular matrix metals currently in vogue, which are particularly useful for aircraft applications. Because of these attributes metal matrix composites are under consideration for wide range of applications viz. combustion chamber nozzle (in rocket, space shuttle), housings, tubing, cables, heat exchangers, structural members etc.
9
temperature. Also equipments required for manufacturing polymer matrix composites are simpler. For this reason polymer matrix composites developed rapidly and soon became popular for structural applications. Two types of polymer composites are:
10
low. The mechanical properties of a hybrid composite can be varied by changing volume ratio and stacking sequence of different plies.
11
3. LITERATURE REVIEW
A composite is a material made by combining two or more dissimilar materials in such a way that the resultant material is endowed with properties superior to any of its parental ones. Fiber-reinforced composites, owing to their superior properties, are usually applied in different fields like defense, aerospace, engineering applications, sports goods, etc. Nowadays, natural fiber composites have gained increasing interest due to their eco-friendly properties. A lot of work has been done by researchers based on these natural fibers. Natural fibers such as jute, sisal, silk and coir are inexpensive, abundant and renewable, lightweight, with low density, high toughness, and biodegradable. Natural Fibers such as jute have the potential to be used as a replacement for traditional reinforcement materials in composites for applications which requires high strength to weight ratio and further weight reduction. Bagasse fiber has lowest density so able to reduce the weight of the composite upto a considerable amount. So by using these fibers (coir, bagasse, and munja) the composite developed is cost effective and perfect utilization of waste product. Natural fiber reinforced polymer composites have raised great attentions and interests among materials scientists and engineers in recent years due to the considerations of developing an environmental friendly material and partly replacing currently used glass or carbon fibers in fiber reinforced composites. They are high specific strength and modulus materials, low prices, recyclable, easy available in some countries, etc. . Joshi et al. [1] compared life cycle environmental performance of natural fiber composites with glass fiber reinforced composites and found that natural fiber composites are environmentally superior in the specific applications studied. Natural fiber composites are likely to be environmentally superior to glass fiber composites in most cases for the following reasons: (1) Natural fiber production has lower environmental impacts compared to glass fiber production; (2) Natural fiber composites have higher fiber content for equivalent performance, reducing more polluting base polymer content; (3) The light-weight natural fiber composites improve fuel efficiency and reduce emissions in the use phase of the component, especially in auto applications; and (4) End of life incineration of natural fibers results in recovered energy and carbon credits.
Rana et al. [2] in their work showed that the use of compatibilizer in jute fibers increases its mechanical properties. At 60% by weight of fiber loading, the use of the compatibilizer improved the flexural strength as high as 100%, tensile strength to 120%, and impact strength by 175%. The following conclusions may be drawn from this paper: 1. The sharp increase in mechanical properties and decrease in water absorption values after addition of the compatibilizer. 2. All these results justify that the role of jute fiber was not as a filler fiber but as a reinforcing fiber in a properly compatibilized system. 3. This system produced a new range of low-energy, low-cost composites having interesting properties and should be given priority over costly and high-energy synthesis reinforcing fiber wherever possible.
12
Shah and Lakkad [3] try to compare the mechanical properties of jute-reinforces and glass-reinforced and the results shows that the jute fibers, when introduced into the resin matrix as reinforcement, considerably improve the mechanical properties, but the improvement is much lower than that obtained by introduction of glass and other high performance fibers. Hence, the jute fibers can be used as reinforcement where modest strength and modulus are required. Another potential use for the jute fibers is that, it can be used as a filler fiber, replacing the glass as well as the resin in a filament wound component. The main problem of the present work has been that it is difficult to introduce a large quantity of jute fibers into the JRP laminates because the jute fibers, unlike glass fibers, soak up large amount of resin. This problem is partly overcome when hybridizing with glass fibers is carried out. Ray et al. [4] in their work, Jute fibers were subjected to alkali treatment with 5% NaOH solution for 0, 2, 4, 6 and 8 h at 300C. It was found that improvement in properties both for fibers and reinforced composites. The fibers after treatment were finer, having less hemicellulose content, increased crystallinity, reduced amount of defects resulting in superior bonding with the vinylester resin. As fibers, the improvements in properties were predominant around 6 8 h treatment whereas as composites. It was maximum when reinforced with 4 h-treated fibers at 35% fiber loadings. The modulus of the jute Fibers improved by 12, 68 and 79% after 4, 6 and 8 h of treatment, respectively. The tenacity of the fibers improved by 46% after 6 and 8 h treatment and the% breaking strain was reduced by 23% after 8 h treatment. For 35% composites with 4 h-treated fibers, the flexural strength improved from 199.1 to 238.9 MPa by 20%, modulus improved from 11.89 to 14.69 GPa by 23% and laminar shear strength increased from 0.238 to 0.283 MPa by 19%. On plotting different values of slopes obtained from the rates of improvement of flexural strength and modulus, against NaOH treatment time, two different failure modes were apparent before and after 4 h of NaOH treatment.
Saha et al. [5] in their paper, jute fibers were treated with alkali(NAOH) solution and physic-chemical properties of jute fibers was investigated. The treatments were applied under ambient and elevated temperatures and high pressure steaming conditions. The results indicated that the uniaxial tensile strength increased by up to 65% for alkali-steam treatment. The treatments without steaming were not as effective. Physico-chemical characterization of fibers showed that the increase in tensile strength was due to the removal of non-cellulosic matters like lignin, pectin and hemicellulose. Gassan and Bledzki [6] used the coupling methods to improve the properties of composites. Composites have high level of moisture absorption, poor wettability, and insufficient adhesion between untreated fibers and the polymer matrix leads to debonding with age. To improve the properties of the composites, the natural reinforcing fibers can be modified coupling methods. The coupling agents have chemical groups which can react with fiber or polymer and thus improve the interfacial adhesion. This paper concerns with the use of MAH-PP copolymers as coupling agents in jute-propylene composites. It is found that the flexural strength was increased by 40% and flexural modulus by 90%. SEM investigation showed the improved fiber-matrix adhesion which was due to the chemical bonds between fiber and matrix provided by the coupling agent.
13
Monteiro SN. Rodriquez et al. [7] tried to use the sugar cane bagasse waste as reinforcement to polymeric resins for fabrication of low cost composites. They reported that composites with homogeneous microstructures could be fabricated and mechanical properties similar to wooden agglomerates can be achieved. Hassan et al. [8, 9] have converted the bagasse into a thermo formable material through esterification of the fiber matrix. The dimensional stability and mechanical properties of the composites prepared from the esterified fibers were reported in this work. BC Ray [10] used 3-point flexural test to qualitatively assess such effects for 55, 60 and 65 weight percentages of E-glass fibers reinforced epoxy composites during cryogenic and after thawing conditions. The specimens were tested at a range of 0.5 mm/min to 500 mm/min crosshead speed to evaluate the sensitivity of mechanical response during loading at ambient and sub-ambient (- 80C temperature). These shear strength values are compared with the testing data of as-cured samples. After reviewing the existing literature available on natural fiber composites, particularly natural fibers (jute and bagasse) composites put efforts to understand the basic needs of the growing composite industry. The conclusions drawn from this is that, the success of combining vegetable natural fibers with polymer matrices results in the improvement of mechanical properties of the composites compared with the matrix materials. These composite fibers are cheap and nontoxic, can be obtained from renewable sources, and are easily recyclable. Moreover, despite their low strength, they can lead to composites with high specific strengths because of their low density.
Case Study
C alves et al [11] carried out a research named Ecodesign of automotive components making use of natural jute fiber composites C. Alves a,*, P.M.C. Ferrao a, A.J. Silva a, L.G. Reis a, M. Freitas a, L.B. Rodrigues b, D.E. Alves c a Instituto Superior Tecnico, Lisbon, Portugal b Universidade Estadual do Sudoeste da Bahia,Itapetinga, Brazil c Instituto de Artes Visuais, Lisbon, Portugal The goal of this study was to assess the environmental impact of using jute fiber composites and their necessary technical treatments for automotive design applications to manufacture the enclosures of a buggy vehicle. Thus, compare them with the impacts raised by current enclosures made of glass fiber reinforced plastic (GFRP) composites over the entire life cycle of the buggy. Most of the environmental impacts of a vehicle are related to its use phase due to the fuel consumption. In this sense, the bonnets made of glass and jute fibers were added with about 64.36 kg and 58.81 kg of petrol, respectively, taking into account the density of the petrol at 0.72 kg/L. The higher mass of petrol assigned to the glass bonnet is due to its higher weight that implies directly an increase of the fuel consumption of the vehicle. The main core of this buggy case study was to analyze the environmental impacts related to the replacement of the composite reinforcements to produce buggys enclosures. Nevertheless, in the development processes of products there are other important requirements to ensure their success. In this sense, qualitative and quantitative results will be presented to show how important are jute fibers in the whole aspects of the buggys project. In regards to the social requirements, jute fiber plays an important role from the cultivation of the plant to the production of the bonnet. In its cultivation phase jute means income source to the local farmer
14
communities contributing to the sustainability of the region, avoiding the rural exodus hence its social problem in industrial cities. In the production phase, jute fiber causes fewer health risks and skin irritation than glass fibers for the employees that are directly involved in the production of the components. Related to the economical advantages, for Ancel Reinforced Plastics, jute fibers cost about seven times less than glass fibers, while production costs are almost the same, since it is possible to produce either jute or glass composites with almost the same setup and production processes. Using jute fibers also implies lower fuel consumption, so it means an economical advantage for owners of the buggy. Still, the potential global market for natural fibers in the automobile industry is expected to increase. Nowadays in the USA more than 1.5 million vehicles are the substrate of choice of bio fibers such as kenaf, jute, flax, hemp and sisal and thermoplastic polymers such as polypropylene and polyester. Regarding to the technical parameters, all of bonnets were produced and tested under ASTM standards (D-3039/D-790/D-256). The results show that the superficial treatments of the jute fibers improved the mechanical properties of their proving the improvement of the interface polyester/jute. These results are closer of glass composites which become jute composites treated bonnets increased about 250% while their maximum strain decrease about 70%, before. Finally, we see a semi-quantitative overview comparison of the all aspects of the bonnets based on sustainable design procedure and on the triple bottom line approach added to the technical aspects, since the eco design of materials needs to reach technical requirements. The better results were assumed as100% while other values are the fraction them. Related to the technical parameters, the elastic modulus of the jute composites are 40% of the glass composites, then it was assigned as 60%. Social parameters is a qualitative aspect, it was based on the social effects of the fibers reinforcement in all of phases, jute fibers present better aspects in all of them, which glass fibers just present some advantages in raise industrial employment. Environmental aspects, was presented by LCA that jute fiber implies an increase of about 15% of the performance of the composites, while the economical aspects, jute fibers cost about seven times less than glass fibers. In this sense, it is possible to note that jute fibers have many advantages in the replacement of glass fibers to reinforce composite materials. It is possible to observe that jute composites related to the four aspects, present the better overview performance than glass composites. The overall performance of this jute fiber bonnet can be observed in the diagram below. (fig 1)
15
1. Fabrication of Coir-Bagasse fiber and Saccharum munja-Bagasse fiber. By Hand Lay-Up method. Cutting of Laminates into samples of desired dimensions. 2. Impact Test 3. Bending point test 4. Breaking load test 5. Calculation of tensile strength of fabricated material
Saccharum munja
(ii) Epoxy resin (iii)Hardener
16
17
The sugar cane bagasse is a residue widely generated in high proportions in the agro-industry. It is a fibrous residue of cane stalks left over after the crushing and extraction of juice from the sugar cane. Bagasse is generally gray-yellow to pale green in color. It is bulky and quite non uniform in particle size. The sugar cane residue bagasse is underutilized, renewable agricultural material that consists of two distinct cellular constituents. The main chemical constituents of bagasse are cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin. Hemicellulose and cellulose are present in the form of hollow cellulose in bagasse which contributes to about 70 % of the total chemical constituents present in bagasse. Another important chemical constituent present in bagasse is lignin. Lignin acts as a binder for the cellulose fibers and also behaves as an energy storage system.
18
used by low income locals for making ropes, hand fans, baskets, brooms, mat, hut and shields for crop protection.
4.1.5 Hardener
In the present work Hardener (araldite) HY 951 is used. This has a viscosity of 10-20 poise at 25 Degree Celsius.
20
4.2.5 Casting
First of all the mould is covered with a layer of plastic and the first layer of epoxy-hardener mixture is spread uniformly with a soft roller. The thickness of this layer is kept 2mm. After that, we place one layer of coir fibers spreading them uniformly covering the entire surface area. Above that we pour the hardener-epoxy mixture. Now we lay a layer of sugarcane bagasse followed by a layer of epoxy resin and hardener. This process is repeated 3 times. This sample is then left for 72 hours. The composite gets dried up in 72 hours in which the silk fiber and the polymers adheres itself tightly in the presence of hardener. After a day we put out the weights. Then carefully the nailed bits are removed from the wooden board. Now we have the composite attached with the glass. The hardener has so strong effect that it attachs the glass with the composite. This attachment is slowly and gently hammered on the boundary of its attachment when the glass and the composite separate.
Figure 5
21
statistics of the main sample with those of the the others. The fabrication was done in similar ways as the sugarcane bagasse and coir fiber. The samples which were tested were: Coir fiber with sugarcane bagasse using epoxy resin and hardener. Saccharin munja with sugarcane bagasse using epoxy resin and hardener. Coir fiber with sugarcane bagasse using Gypsum Plaster. Wood
Furthermore, by laying multiple layers of fiber on top of one another, with each layer oriented in various preferred directions
4.3 Testing
The following tests were conducted to study the properties and behavior of the composite fiber. 1. Impact Test 2. Breaking Load test (with bending load) 3. Calculation of Tensile Strength
Fig 6 A WIRE HACKSAW blade was used to cut each laminate into smaller pieces, for various experiments:
TENSILE TEST- Sample was cut into flat shape (300x30x10) mm. FLEXURAL TEST- Sample was cut into flat shape (300x30x10) mm.
22
(Sample in the loaded Condition on the UTM for Tensile Testing) Figure 7
23
measured by loading desired shape specimen (6x6-inch) with a span length at least three times the depth. The flexural strength is expressed as modulus of rupture (MR).
24
Thickness (mm) 10 10 7
The maximum load given by this test was then used to calculate the tensile strength of the material by using the dimensions of the fiber under experiment. The dimensions of the wood (cross sec) were 6cm x 0.7cm.
5.4 Comparison
Tensile Strength - Data in MPa (Tensile strength of materials)
1. c-b-c 38.3 2. Douglas fir wood 50 3. Pine wood 40 4. Marble 15 5. Polypropylene 40 6. Polystyrene 40 7. Glass 33 8. Rubber 15 Impact test Sample Name c-b-c s-b-s Wood Impact Strength 2.70 X 1.87 X X Table 5
Bending Point Sample Name c-b-c s-b-s wood Bending Point 2.2 X 1.5 X X Table - 6
26
Test for water resistance The fiber was submerged in water for 4 hours with weight kept on it and the fiber came out of water unaffected, and dried up pretty quickly. Compared to plywood, its better at resisting water attack as the plywood gets soaky and stays wet for long. Prolonged submerging of ply in water leads to ruining the material. Test for heat resistance The fiber was tested for heat and water resistance by keeping the fiber sample in hot water and recording the behavior according to the temperature.
Behavior NORMAL SLIGHTLY DAMP but regains original form within 5 minutes. Table - 7
The results show that the c-b-c fiber has better material properties than the other two samples used for comparison. Weather resistant material Great impact strength Great load bearing capacity Variety of textures Resistance to temperature Stiffness and toughness
27
28
References
[1] S.V. Joshi, L.T. Drzal, A.K. Mohanty, S. Arora The mechanical properties of vinylester resin matrix composites reinforced with alkali-treated jute Fibers Part A 32 (2001) 119127. [2] A. K. RANA, A. MANDAL, B.C. MITRA, R. JACOBSON, R. ROWELL, A. N.
BANERJEE Short Jute Fiber-Reinforced Polypropylene Composites: Effect of Compatibilizer Journal of Applied Polymer Science, Vol. 69, 329-338 (1998). [3] A. N. Shah and S. C. Lakkad, Mechanical Properties Of Jute-Reinforced Plastics, Fiber Science and Technology 15 (1981) 41 46. [4] D. Ray, B.K. Sarkara, A.K. Rana, N.R. Bose The mechanical properties of vinylester resin matrix composites reinforced with alkali-treated jute Fibers Part A 32 (2001) 119127 [5] Prosenjit Saha, Suvendu Manna, Sougata Roy Chowdhury, Ramkrishna Sen, Debasis Roy, Basudam Adhikari Enhancement of tensile strength of lig nocellulosic jute fibers by alkali-steam treatment 101 (2010) 31823187 [6] Jochen Gassan, Andrzej K. Bledzki, Possibilities for improving the mechanical properties of jute/epoxy composites by alkali treatment of Fibers, Composites Science and Technology 59 (1999) 1303-1309. [7] Monteiro S.N.; Rodriquez R.J.S.; De Souza M.V., D'Almeida J.R.M., Sugar Cane Bagasse Waste as Reinforcement in Low Cost Composites, Advanced performance Material, Volume 5, No.3, (December 1998): p. 183-191. [8] Hassan M.L., Rowell R.M., Fadl N.A., Yacoub S.F. and Chrisainsen A.W. Thermo plasticization of Bagasse. I. Preparation and Characterization of Esterified Bagasse Fibers. Journal of applied polymer science, Volume 76, (2000): p. 561- 574. [9] Hassan M.L., Rowell R.M., Fadl N.A., Yacoub S.F. and Chrisainsen A.W. Thermo plasticization of Bagasse. II. Dimensional Stability and Mechanical Properties of Esterified Bagasse Composite. Journal of applied polymer science, Volume 76, (2000): p. 575-586.
29
[10] BC Ray Loading Rate Sensitivity of Glass Fiber-epoxy Composite at Ambient and Subambient Temperatures Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, National Institute of Technology, Rourkela.
[11] Ecodesign of automotive components making use of natural jute fiber composites C. Alves a,*, P.M.C. Ferrao a, A.J. Silva a, L.G. Reis a, M. Freitas a, L.B. Rodrigues b, D.E. Alves c a Instituto Superior Tecnico, Rovisco Pais Av., 1049-001 Lisbon, Portugal b Universidade Estadual do Sudoeste da Bahia, Praa da Primavera, 40, 45700-000 Itapetinga, Brazil c Instituto de Artes Visuais, Design e Marketing, D. Carlos I Av., 4, 1200-649 Lisbon, Portugal
30