Service Bulletin: Warning
Service Bulletin: Warning
Service Bulletin: Warning
TOPIC: Cooling Systems IDENT NO: 4-2429G SUPERSEDES: 4-2429F DATE: February 15, 2003 Cooling System Guidelines And Water Treatment Recommendations All Models
SUBJECT:
MODELS AFFECTED:
This bulletin releases to the field updated cooling system guidelines and cooling water treatment information which applies to all Waukesha engine models.
WARNING
In order to ensure quality engine coolant, a coolant analysis program is recommended. Failure to maintain coolant to engine specifications may result in severe engine damage. The cooling system is often overlooked in engine maintenance programs. Ignoring an engine's coolant will lead to serious cooling system damage over time. There are three types of damage that may occur: corrosion, cavitation erosion, and mineral scale and fouling deposits. All of these problems are preventable with a quality water treatment program. A competent water treatment specialist is essential in creating an effective water treatment program. Norkool Industrial Products Division of Union Carbide, Inc. (all glycol based industrial coolants); Calgon Corporation; and the Mogul Division of Dexter Corporation are knowledgeable companies who can provide the coolant analysis and services recommended in this service bulletin. CORROSION Corrosion is a natural, electrochemical process by which metal, reacting with oxygen that has entered the system, breaks down and returns to its natural iron oxide state (see Figure 1). Corrosion inhibitors, added to the engine coolant, continuously coat and re-coat the metal surfaces of the system with a film that insulates them from the electrochemical processes that break down the metal. Because the coating film is constantly being replaced, the inhibitor concentrations need to be maintained. Concentrations can only be determined through periodic testing.
Figure 2. Cavitation Eroded Steel
WAUKESHA ENGINE DRESSER, INC. WAUKESHA, WI 53188-4999
CAVITATION EROSION Cavitation is a mechanical process that erodes surfaces in liquid. Fluctuating pressure causes the formation of vapor bubbles which collapse under high pressure, allowing pressure jets to impact surfaces. If this occurs with great frequency over time, cavities will form (see Figure 2). Adding cavitation inhibitors to the coolant will raise the flash point or vapor pressure of the coolant, reducing or eliminating formation of damaging vapor bubbles. Coolant needs to be analyzed periodically to ensure that inhibitor concentration is maintained to the most effective level.
Page 1 of 11
ENGINE COMPONENT
COOLING COMPONENT
Bypass water filtration can remove debris from the cooling systems on any engine. Bypass water filtration sized to remove 15 - 25 micron particles from 2% of the water flow is recommended. Waukesha Engine offers a stainless steel coolant filter available in two sizes: small filter P/N 489501 and large filter P/N 489625. The small coolant filter is recommended for engines that have a good coolant program already in place. The large coolant filter holds more contaminants requiring less cleaning and is well-suited for new engine applications where installation debris may be present or for older engines that have mineral deposits in the cooling system. Table 2 lists the filter system part numbers and available replacement parts.
Table 2. Waukesha Engine Coolant Filter System and Replaceable Parts DESCRIPTION
Coolant Filter Assy. Replacement Element Std. Temperature 200 F (93 C) Flow Indicator High Temperature 350 F (177 C) Flow Indicator Seal Kit
NOTE:Reference Tech Data Manual for the solid water maximum outlet temperature of each engine model.
Care must also be taken when welding external cooling system pipes together or when drilling and tapping a hole anywhere in the water system. Ensure that the weld slag and chips are totally cleaned from the cooling system before the engine is operated. Debris in the cooling system will cause erosion of water passages and water pump seals. Jacket water and auxiliary water pump static inlet pressure must not exceed pressures published in the specifications section of the Tech Data Manual for the specific engine model. For information on ebullient cooled systems refer to the Waukesha Cogeneration Handbook, Form 7030 (or its replacement), and system manufacturers such as: Beaird Industries Phone (318) 865-6351 or Vaporphase Phone (314) 821-7900 Consider thermosiphoning prevention in cooling system design. Thermal shock from thermosiphoning is often a problem in engine shutdowns and engines with coolers mounted above them. A shutoff valve in the return leg from the cooler will prevent thermosiphoning. See Application Notes, No. WED 9/92, Engine Thermal Shock At Shutdown Due To Thermosiphoning. Page 3 of 11
The pressure cap must have a vacuum relief function to prevent a vacuum from forming in the tank during load reduction or cool-down operation. Only a single pressure cap must be used in a cooling system and must be at the highest point on the expansion tank. The expansion tank must be sized for 6% expansion of the coolant. An additional 5% is recommended for coolant makeup. With these volumes, an expansion tank should be sized to contain 11% of the total cooling system volume. Separate expansion tanks must be used for separate auxiliary and jacket cooling circuits. A sight glass is recommended for monitoring expansion tank level. The expansion tank height and pressure must be sufficient to provide pressure at the water pump inlet to meet the requirements on S9068 (or its replacement) for ATGL engines and S7424 (or its replacement) for all other Waukesha engines. Do not assume that a pressure cap will pressurize the tank to the caps rating.
WAUKESHA ENGINE DRESSER, INC. WAUKESHA, WI 53188-4999
Service Bulletin No. 4-2429G WATER TREATMENT FOR ENGINE COOLING SYSTEMS
The primary purpose of any water treatment program is to protect the surfaces of all water passages from corrosion and any scaling or sludge deposits which will impede the transfer of heat to or from the water. If the system is exposed to low ambient temperatures antifreeze protection is needed. In addition, cavitation erosion protection is required for engine cooling systems. GENERAL COMMENTS Cooling water quality is one of the most often overlooked factors in an engine installation. Poor water quality and lack of coolant maintenance contribute to scaling, corrosion, and sediment buildup within the entire cooling system. It leads to heat transfer problems which can result in failed parts and downtime. This is especially critical in low pressure steam systems with ebullient cooled engines. To get the most benefit from any water treatment program, it is essential to apply the chemicals properly and maintain close control over the process. Briefly, inhibitors should be selected only after a thorough study of the entire system and the specific water to be used. It may be necessary to preclean or pretreat the system before it is put into operation. Higher treatment levels may be recommended during start-up to protect the system quickly. Later, after protection is established, treatment levels can be reduced to a maintenance value. In all cases, it is essential to monitor the water condition carefully and continuously. Corrosion, scale, fouling, cavitation, and micro-biological growth can be the major problems in all types of cooling systems. Of these, corrosion is the most important. I. PRETREATMENT Pretreatment is preparation of the water system to ensure that the treatment program itself can work effectively from start-up. New systems, or existing ones being returned to service, can contain contaminants. These include films of oil, grease, or other protective coatings, biological contamination, rust spots, dirt, casting sand, and welding slag. These materials are an unavoidable result of the system's construction, transport, and storage. If these materials are not removed by suitable pretreatment, the subsequent treatment program may not be effective. Common pretreatments are water flushing and acid cleaning. Chelates can remove oil, scale and deposits from a system; flush the system with water after using chelates. Water flushing may reduce solid contaminants, but may not be effective on films. Untreated flushing water will react with unprotected metal surfaces to form corrosion. Page 4 of 11 Acid cleaning removes corrosion products and some mineral scale but has little effect on organic material. Improper cleaning may lead to severe metal attack. Improper neutralization may leave metal surfaces in a highly reactive state and vulnerable to rapid corrosion. II. CORROSION The actual corrosion process is electrochemical. Refined metals in the cooling system are returned to a more basic metallic oxide state when they combine with oxygen carried by the coolant flow. These chemical reactions usually cause a low voltage electric current. Where corrosion will occur in a water system and to what degree it will progress depends on a number of factors: quality of water, water pH, surface temperatures, the type of metals in the system, mechanical conditions (vibration, stress, relative motion of two adjacent parts, etc.), trapped air, and both the type and amount of inhibitor additives. For corrosion inhibitors to be effective (and to neutralize any blow-by gases), the jacket water pH of the standard radiator cooled engine must be kept between 8.5 and 9.5. Different system metals, such as iron, copper, aluminum, etc., corrode at different rates. An acidic coolant with a pH of less than 7 will speed the corrosion of cast iron, aluminum and steel, while a pH of 11 or higher will accelerate the corrosion of aluminum and solder. Many types of corrosion can exist in/with cooling systems: Crevice Cavitation related Fretting Selective leaching Galvanic III. MINERAL SCALES AND FOULING Compounds and minerals dissolved in water tend to come out of solution when the water is heated. They form either a scale on the metal surfaces or a fouling precipitate (sludge) in the cooling system. The primary effect of hard scale is to reduce heat transfer efficiency. To allow for efficient heat absorption by the cooling water, coolant passageways must be kept clean and free of scale. Scale is a solid formed when the impurity concentration in water exceeds its solubility limit. Buildup of scale and minerals can completely plug coolant passageways. Even if just the walls of cooling passageways are coated, the ability of the engine to transfer heat is greatly reduced. Only 0.012 of an inch of scale (0.305 mm) may cut the transfer of heat by as much as 40%. The composition of the scale will determine the actual efficiency loss. This reduced heat flow increases operating temperatures and can result in parts cracking.
WAUKESHA ENGINE DRESSER, INC. WAUKESHA, WI 53188-4999
Page 5 of 11
E. Amount of make-up water required. F. Age of installation. G. Previous water treatments used and any history of corrosion or scaling problems. H.Engine model, speed and type of operation (stand-by, loading, etc.). The manufacturer recommendations should include the following: A. Any required cleaning of the system and how it should be done. B. Any pretreatment required if the quality of the water is questionable. C.Type of water treatment to be used and the level at which it is to be maintained. D.Control limits, if required, for pH, hardness, total dissolved solids, alkalinity, chlorides, sulfates, nitrites, silica, etc. that must be held in the treated water. E. Frequency of tests for level of treatment and/or when water samples should be taken and analyzed. F. Corrective actions to be taken when control limits are exceeded. G. Amount and frequency of blowdown (ebullient cooled systems). Once the treatment program is in place, frequent testing of the engine jacket water, make-up water, and any condensate returned must be performed to ensure that the required water quality is being maintained. Table 3 lists recommended tests and acceptable limits for ebullient cooling systems. Some of these tests may be applicable to solid water systems. Consult your water treatment specialist.
TEST TYPE
Total Hardness Total Hardness Chlorides pH Conductivity
ACCEPTABLE LIMITS
0 ppm 0 ppm Should equal untreated water 10.5 - 11.5 2500 - 3000 MMHO 30 - 50 ppm sulfites 200 - 600 ppm Varies 7.5 - 8.5
CONTROL
Water softening/phosphates Water softening/phosphates Check softener rinse cycle Adjust blowdown frequency Adjust blowdown frequency Adjust treatment level Adjust blowdown frequency Adjust treatment level Adjust amine level
Condensate
pH
Page 7 of 11
Page 9 of 11
CONDENSATE RETURN FEED WATER RESERVOIR 3 4 5 6 2 O2 SCAVENGER AND CHEMICAL INHIBITORS CHEMICAL PUMP FEED WATER PUMP
BLOWDOWN PROCEDURES
1 2 3 4 5 6 Continuous surface blowdown controlled at recovery boiler Bottom blowdown for recovery boiler - Frequency should be twice/shift for 15 seconds each or as recommended by local water treatment company. Bottom blowdowns for ebullient engine - Frequency: Before startup and after shutdown (to prevent starving engine or circulating water) or as recommended by local water treatment company
CHEMICAL FEED
The O2 scavenger may be fed mechanically to the feed water section or to the hot water ebullient section based on feed water pump impulse. Consult local water treatment company. Neutralizing amine fed continuously to steam header with pump.
Page 10 of 11
NOTE 1: Pressure rise across pump will provide minimum jacket inlet pressure, provided the minimum pump inlet pressure requirement is met. (Waukesha factory installed pump.) The engine outlet is throttled to control flow and engine T Not to provide jacket pressure (A). NOTE 2: The jacket pressure is supplied by adjusting the static head pump inlet pressure (NPSH). This can be established by the expansion tank height (B) or with an air regulator (C). A pressure cap or relief valve on the expansion tank is necessary to relieve excess pressure.
A B
ENGINE
COOLER
Page 11 of 11