TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

15

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

There is no recipe for adapting general education curriculum to meet each students needs. Each teacher, each student, each classroom is unique and adaptations are specific to each situation. Keep in mind that curriculum does not always need to be modified. By providing multi-level instruction you will find that adapting a lesson may not always be necessary. Differentiating instruction and providing multiple ways assess allows more flexibility for students to meet the standards and requirements of the class. At other times, the curriculum can be made more accessible through accommodations. In addition, supports for one student may not necessarily be the same in all situations, e.g., a student who needs full time support from a paraprofessional for math may only need natural supports from peers for English, and no support for art. And, supports should not be determined by the disability label, instead supports should be used when the instructional or social activity warrants the need for assistance. (Fisher and Frey, 2001). The forms and examples on the following pages provide information about curriculum and types of adaptations that could be considered in developing the appropriate strategy for a particular student. Examples are provided for both elementary and secondary levels.

16

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

A Curricular Adaptation and Decision-making Process

This decision-making flowchart can be used to conceptualize the proces of selecting and implementing curricular adaptations. It should be used as a tool for a team in determing an individual students needs.
Identify the students individual educational goals and objectives to be emphasized during general education activities

v
Articulate the expectations for the students performance in general education activities

v
Determine what to teach As a team, determine the content of the general education activity, theme or unit study

v
Determine how to teach As a team, determine if, without modification, the student can actively participate and achieve the same essential outcomes as non-disabled classmates. If the student cannot achieve the same outcomes...

v
Select of design appropriate adaptations Select instructional arrangement Select lesson format Employ student-specific teaching strategies Select curricular goals specific to the lesson

v v

Engineer the physical and social classroom environment

Design modified materials

Select natural supports and supervision arrangements

If the above adaptation strategies are not effective, design an alternative activity

v
Evaluate effectiveness of adaptations

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

17

A Curricular Adaptation and Decision-making Model

Examine the Structure of the Instruction
1. Can the student actively participate in the lesson without modification? Will the same essential outcome he achieved? 2. Can the students participation he increased by changing the instructional arrangement? From traditional arrangements to: Cooperative groups Small groups Peer partners Peer or cross-age tutors 3. Can the students participation be increased by changing the lesson format? Interdisciplinary/thematic units Activity-based lessons, games, simulations, role-plays Group investigation or discovery learning Experiential lessons Community-referenced lessons 4, Can the Students participation and understanding be increased by changing the delivery of instruction or teaching style?

Examine the Demands and Evaluation Criteria of the Task

5. Will the student need adapted curricular goals? Adjust performance standards Adjust pacing Same content but less complex Similar content with functional/direct applications Adjust the evaluation criteria or system (grading) Adjust management techniques

Examine the Learning Environment

6. Can the changes he made in the classroom environment or lesson location that will facilitate participation? Environmental/physical arrangements

18

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

Social rules Lesson location

Examine the Materials for Learning

7. Will different materials be needed to ensure participation? Same content but variation in size, number, format Additional or different materials/devices Materials that allow a different mode of input Materials that allow a different mode of output Materials that reduce the level of abstraction of information

Examine the Support Structure

8. Will personal assistance be needed to ensure participation? From peers or the general education instructor? From the support facilitator? From therapists? From paraprofessionals? From others?

Arrange Alternative Activities that Foster Participation and Interaction

9. Will a different activity need to be designed and offered for the student and a small group of peers? In the classroom ln other general education environments In community-based environments

From. Udvari-Solner, A. (1994). Curriculum Adaptations Project.

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

19

Curriculum Adaptations
It is important to correlate adaptations with the IEP. In other words, we are not adapting for adaptations sake but, to meet the students needs as identified on an IEP. a. Curriculum as is. This is the type we forget most frequently. We need to constantly be looking at the general education curriculum and asking if the students on IEPs may gain benefit from participating in the curriculum as is. We need to keep in mind that incidental learning does occur. Curriculum as is supports outcomes as identified in standard curriculum. b. Different objective within the same activity and curriculum. The student with an IEP works with all the other students in the classroom participating in the activity when possible but, with a different learning objective from the other students. This is where the principle of partial participation fits. Examples include. A student with a short attention span staying on task for 5 minutes. Using a switch to actis ate a communication device to share during a class discussion. Expressing ones thoughts by drawing in a journal instead of writing. Holding a book during reading time. Understanding the effect World War II has on the present rather than knowing the names and dates of key battles. c. Material or environmental adaptations. The material or environmental changes are utilized so that participation in the general education curriculum by the student with the IEP may occur. Examples include: 5 spelling words from the weekly list instead of the standard 20. Completing a cooking assignment by following picture directions rather than written directions Changing the grouping of the class from large group to small groups (possible with the additional support staff). Changing the instructional delivery from lecture to the cooperative learning format Using a computer to write an assignment instead of paper and pencil. Reading a test to a student. Highlighting the important concepts in a textbook. Having the student listen to a taped textbook. Using enlarged print Using an assistive technology device Using visual cues such as picture and/or word schedules for those who have difficulty staying on task. Using a note taking guide listing the key concepts during a lecture. Move in this direction only when necessary

20

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

d. Providing Physical assistance. Assistance from another person may be needed for a student to participate in a classroom activity. If possible, it is better to use natural supports (peers) as these will be the people always present in the student life. If the use of peers is not possible, then either the support teadcher, the paraprofessional, the classroom teacher, the classroom aide, or a parent volunteer may provide the assistance. Most peers and staff will need training in the correct way of providing physical assistance. In addition, we need to keep in mind the principle of partial participations. Examples include: Starting a computer for an student with an IEP to use. Guiding a hand during handwriting. Assisting in activating a switch. Completing most of the steps of an activity and having a student with an IEP do the remainder Pushing a student in a wheelchair to the next activity. e. Alternative/substitue curriculum. This is sometimes referred to as functional curriculum as it usually involves the acpuisition of life skills. The decision to use alternative/substitute curriculum is a major change and needs to be reflected on the IEP. This decision should be carefully made after weighing all of the pros and cons of using an alternative curriculum. The alternative curriculum may or may not take place in the general education classroom. Examples include: Community-based instruction (which all students may benefit from!) Learning job skills in the school cafeteria. Learning how to use a communication device. Doing laundry for the athletic department Learning cooking/grooming skills at the home.

Move in this direction only when necessary

Overlap does occur among the five types of curriculum adaptations.

McFee, K. & Torrey, Z. (1992-1995). ABCs of inclusion. A VI-B project awarded to HPEC by the Kansas State Board of Education.

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

21

Nine Types of Adaptions

Input Adapt the way instruction is delivered to the learner. For example: Use different visual aids; plan more concrete examples; provide hands-on activities; place students in cooperative groups.

Output Adapt how the learner can respond to instruction For example: Allow a verbal vs. written response; use a communication book for students; allow students to show knowledge with hands-on materials.

Time Adapt the time allotted and allowed for learning, task completion or testing. For example: Individualize a timeline for completing a task; pace learning differently (increase or decrease) for some learners.

Difficulty Adapt the skill level, problem type, or the rules on how the learner may approach the work. For example: Allow a calculator for math problems; simplify task directions; change rules to accommodate learner needs.

Level of Support Increase the amount of personal assistance with specific learner. For example: Assign peer buddies, teaching assistants, peer tutors or crossage tutors.

Size Adapt the number of items that the learner is expected to learn or compete. For example: Reduce the number of social studies terms a learner must learn at any one time.

Degree of Participation Adapt the extent to which a learner is actively involved in the task. For example: In geography, have a student hold the globe, while others point out the locations.

Alternate Goals Adapt the goals or outcome expectations while using the same materials. For example: In social studies, expect one student to be able to locate just the states while others learn to locate capitals as well.

Substitute Curriculum Provide the different instruction and materials to meet a learners individual goals. For example: Individualize a timeline for completing a task; pace learning differently (increase or decrease) for some learners.

From: Ebeling, D.G. , Ed.D., Deschenes, C., M.Ed., & Sprague, J., Ph.D. (1994). Adapting curriculum and instruction The Center for School and Community Integration, Institute for the Study of Developmental Disabilities.

22

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

Adaptations

ADAPTATIONS
Instructional Adapt how it is taught and how learnign is demonstrated

Curricular Adapt what is taught

Ecological Adapt the settingwhere, when and with whom

Supplementary Add social, communication, study or processing skills to general curriculum

Simplified Change level of difficulty or include fewer objectives

Alternative teach functional skills plus embedded social, communication and motor skills

Instructional stimulus or input Difficulty/amount Modality Format/materials

Student response or output Difficulty/amount Modality Format/materials

When Adapt the place

Where Adapt the schedule

Who Adapt staffing, grouping

Stages of Adaptations

Stage 1 General Adaptations Blueprints or formats for adapting predictable activities and routines

Stage 2 Specific Adaptations Time-limited adaptations for a particular lesson, activity or unit

From: Janney, R., Ph.D., and Snell, M., Ph.D. (2000) Modifying Schoolwork; Baltimore, MD; Paul H. Brooks Publishing Company

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

23

Creating Ways to Adapt Familiar Lessons - Elementary

1. Select the subject area (and grade level) to be taught: reading math science social studies Grade Level: ........................ 2. Select the lesson topic to be taught (on one day): 3. Briefly identify the curricular goal for most learners: By the end of this class, most students will know ......................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4. Briefly identify the instructional plan for most learners: As teacher, I will .............................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................... 5. Identify the name(s) of the learner(s) who will need adaptations in the curriculum or instructional plan: ......................................................................................................................................................................... 6. Now use Nine Types of Adaptations as a means of thinking about some of the ways you could adapt what or how you teach to accommodate this learner in the classroom for this lesson. writing music health P.E. art

Input

Output

Time

Difficulty

Level of Support

Size

Degree of Participation

Alternate Goal

Substitute Curriculum

Center for School & Community Integration, Institute for the Study of Developmental Disabilities, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN

24

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

SAMPLE FORM

Creating Ways to Adapt Familiar Lessons - Elementary

1. Select the subject area (and grade level) to be taught: reading math science social studies writing music health P.E. art 4 Grade Level: ........................ 2. Select the lesson topic to be taught (on one day): Vocabulary comprehension 3. Briefly identify the curricular goal for most learners: By the end of this class, most students will know the meaning of new vocabulary works from their story. ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4. Briefly identify the instructional plan for most learners: As teacher, I will ask students to complete ......................................................................................................................................................................... a matching activity in which they match words and definitions on paper. The students will also choose one word and write a sentence using the word on the bottom of their paper. 5. Identify the name(s) of the learner(s) who will need adaptations in the curriculum or instructional plan: Kim 6. Now use Nine Types of Adaptations as a means of thinking about some of the ways you could adapt what or how you teach to accommodate this learner in the classroom for this lesson. Input
Place students in cooperative groups and divide the task between group members. Each member teaches their vocabulary work to team members.

Output
Allow the student to record all or part of the assignment on tape.

Time
Ask the student to complete the assignment at home and return it the next day.

Difficulty
Select different vocabulary words for the student to learn; words that are less difficult or in some cases more difficult.

Level of Support
Ask a classmate, peer tutor or teaching assistant to assist in completing the assignment.

Size
Select fewer (or more) words for the student to learn, but leave the assignment the same as for other students.

Degree of Participation
Ask the student to check classmates definitions against as answer key.

Alternate Goal
Set the goal as being to write the words only, or being able to pronounce the words, or just listening to the words and definitions.

Substitute Curriculum
Choose a different story for the student to read and identify one or several words the learner needs to know.

Center for School & Community Integration, Institute for the Study of Developmental Disabilities, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

25

Creating Ways to Adapt Familiar Lessons - Secondary

1. Select the subject area (and grade level) to be taught: math science history literature business Grade Level: ........................ 2. Select the lesson topic to be taught (on one day): 3. Briefly identify the curricular goal for most learners: By the end of this class, most students will know ......................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4. Briefly identify the instructional plan for most learners: As teacher, I will .............................................. ......................................................................................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................... 5. Identify the name(s) of the learner(s) who will need adaptations in the curriculum or instructional plan: ......................................................................................................................................................................... 6. Now use Nine Types of Adaptations as a means of thinking about some of the ways you could adapt what or how you teach to accommodate this learner in the classroom for this lesson. Input Output Time P.E. fine arts health

Difficulty

Level of Support

Size

Degree of Participation

Alternate Goal

Substitute Curriculum

Center for School & Community Integration, Institute for the Study of Developmental Disabilities, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN

26

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

SAMPLE FORM

Creating Ways to Adapt Familiar Lessons - Secondary

1. Select the subject area (and grade level) to be taught: math science history literature business Grade Level: ........................ 10 P.E. fine arts health

2. Select the lesson topic to be taught (on one day): Concept comprehension 3. Briefly identify the curricular goal for most learners: By the end of this class, most students will be able to define and explain the relevance of five concepts from their text chapter. 4. Briefly identify the instructional plan for most learners: As teacher, I will ask the students to read the chapter, identify five key concepts and write a short paragraph describing each concept they have chosen. 5. Identify the name(s) of the learner(s) who will need adaptations in the curriculum or instructional plan:
John

6. Now use Nine Types of Adaptations as a means of thinking about some of the ways you could adapt what or how you teach to accommodate this learner in the classroom for this lesson.

Input
Provide a review of the chapter prior to having the student complete the written work.

Output
Allow the student to use a tape recorder to dictate the assignment instead of having to write the answers.

Time
Allow the student an extra day to complete the task either in study hall or at home.

Difficulty
Identify the key concepts for the student but keep the remainder of the asssignment the same.

Level of Support
Place the students in cooperative groups to complete this assignment. Group members can assist the student with reading or writing.

Size
Select fewer or more concepts for the student to learn, but leave the assignment the same as for other students.

Degree of Participation
Ask the student to pick out related books from the library that will provide supplementary information for classmates.

Alternate Goal
Set the goal as being to write the key concept words only, or being able to pronounce the words, or just listening to the words and descriptions.

Substitute Curriculum
During this lesson the student can work on keyboarding skills in the computer lab.

Center for School & Community Integration, Institute for the Study of Developmental Disabilities, Indiana University, Bloomington, IN

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

27

(Elementary)

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999

28

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

SAMPLE FORM

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

29

SAMPLE FORM

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999

30

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

SAMPLE FORM (Secondary)

Academic Unit Lesson Plan

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

31

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999

32

TOOLS FOR TEACHERS

SAMPLE FORM

Curriculum Modifications & Adaptations

PEAK Parent Center, Inc. 1999