Scribd
Upload
142 views

Peer Review Worksheet

This document contains a peer review worksheet for a narrative essay. It asks the reviewer to evaluate various elements of the essay such as the title, introduction, story content, sentence structure, detail, dialogue, grammar, style, flow, and vocabulary. The reviewer is asked to mark up the essay directly and provide summaries of their thoughts on areas needing improvement and parts they enjoyed. Suggestions are requested to help the author strengthen the paper.

Uploaded by

carolynls55
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
142 views

Peer Review Worksheet

This document contains a peer review worksheet for a narrative essay. It asks the reviewer to evaluate various elements of the essay such as the title, introduction, story content, sentence structure, detail, dialogue, grammar, style, flow, and vocabulary. The reviewer is asked to mark up the essay directly and provide summaries of their thoughts on areas needing improvement and parts they enjoyed. Suggestions are requested to help the author strengthen the paper.

Uploaded by

carolynls55
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

PEER REVIEW WORKSHEET

Assignment: _Narrative Essay_ Reviewers Name: _____________________________ Hour: _____________ Date: __________________________ Paper Authors Name: _________________________ Papers Title: ________________________________________

CONTENT How well does the title describe the contents of the paper? Excellent How interesting is the title? Excellent How well does the introduction catch your attention? Excellent How well does the introduction introduce the topic? Excellent Summarize the story:

Good Good Good Good

Okay Okay Okay Okay

Needs Work Needs Work Needs Work Needs Work

Every story can be read at a deeper level. What is this story saying about life or humanity? What is this storys broader meaning?

Look at the essays sentence structure. Does the writer use all four sentence types? Mark them in the essay. Does the essay use vivid sensory details? Double Underline vivid sensory details in the essay. Mark places in the essay where the author can use more vivid details and summarize your thoughts below in 5-8 sentences.

Does the essay have enough detail? Does it make sense? Squiggly underline any parts of the essay that confuse you and summarize your thoughts below in 5-8 sentences.

Who would you say the audience for this story is? ___________________________________________________ Was the ending clear and meaningful? How could the author improve it?

How well does the conclusion tie the paper together? How well does the conclusion relate to the introduction?

Excellent Excellent

Good Good

Okay Okay

Needs Work Needs Work

PEER REVIEW WORKSHEET


How clear is the purpose of the paper? Excellent How well does the author use dialogue? Excellent What could the author do to improve the dialogue in the story? Good Good Okay Okay Needs Work Needs Work

Grammar and Style How is the authors use of vivid description? Excellent Are words or phrases repeated excessively? (mark in the essay also)

Good

Okay

Needs Work

Does the author use words correctly? (led vs lead, their vs there, effect vs affect)?

Are there parts of the essay that you had to read multiple times to understand? How well does the paper flow within the paragraphs? How is the flow between paragraphs? (transitions) Does the author use college-level vocabulary? Excellent Excellent Good Good Okay Okay Needs Work Needs Work

Comments: Summarize what the author did well. What were your favorite parts of this essay? (5-10 sentences)

Give the author 2-3 suggestions for improvement and explain how it would improve the paper. (5-10 sentences)

You might also like