Cfo Beyond
Cfo Beyond
Cfo Beyond
In this report
The basis of the study Executive summary 2 4
14
19 20 22 24
Possibilities post-CFO
CFO to CEO From listed to private equity Non-executive directorships post-CFO
26
29 32 34
Leading CFOs and beyond: where did they go next? Survey demographics The CFOs role Contacts and other CFO titles
We looked at:
1 The survey was conducted by the Economist Intelligence Unit. See page 56 for further detail on survey demographics.
2 The research was based on data from BoardEx, a global online database holding biographic information on executives based on publicly available information.
In 2002
just over a third of top tier CFOs had non-executive roles. Ten years on, nearly half have them.
Executive summary
1
In our earlier study, The DNA of the CFO,3 we showed that most finance leaders see their job as a career destination and not a staging-post to the job of CEO. It is a paradox, therefore, that unprecedented demand for their unique skill-set outside of the finance role both as a complement to their serving position and as an onward transition makes them arguably the individual with the most career options in the corporate hierarchy. Not all will be drawn by this interest in their skills for roles outside of the top finance job. Many will understandably consider the job to offer all the opportunity and interest that they need. And yet, more and more CFOs are exploring the options open to them, and many are using the experience of these additional roles to enhance their performance as CFO. This study, in our series that focuses on what it is to be a CFO, looks at some of the possibilities and pathways open to CFOs today. We explore the options for CFOs to take on non-executive directorships on corporate, charitable and cultural boards, as an addition to their finance role. We cover the opportunities for CFOs to transition to the role of chairman, CEO and to move from public to private ownership. We look back at how the careers of the leading CFOs from 2002 have unfolded over the past decade, and we look forward to how board composition will evolve in the decade to come. This is for CFOs who are interested in the experiences of others within their community, and for future finance leaders who need to plan now for a career in the long term and the broadest sense. The future of the finance leader has never been so full of possibility.
As companies grapple with the aftermath of the financial crisis and a two-speed global economy, they want leaders who can provide comfort and confidence in an uncertain world. The CFO is arguably best placed to provide it.
3 The DNA of the CFO: a study of what makes a chief financial officer, Ernst & Young, 2010.
Executive summary
The appetite of shareholders and boards for CFOs to serve on corporate boards is big, and getting bigger.
growth markets, analytics and social media, as structural shifts in the global economy and ever greater use of technology impact business practice. And, as boards become more diverse in terms of gender, background and experience, opportunities will open for some, while for the 5560 year old male that typically dominates boards today, gaining access to the boardroom may become more competitive.
While in an executive capacity, CFO remains a destination role for the majority most consider some kind of role beyond CFO
Our earlier study, The DNA of the CFO,4 found that the majority of CFOs either intend to remain in their current role or move to another CFO role. Our findings for this report are consistent with this. We found that, after a decade, 62% of those who were large-company group CFOs in 2002 are either still CFOs or left the role as their last executive post. Only 15% have transitioned to the role of CEO or CEO and chairman, 4% to chairman and 3% to COO. However, 82% of the CFOs we surveyed for this study expressed an interest in some kind of role post the job of CFO, which either means that more will pursue executive options outside of the CFO domain in the future, or, more likely, explore non-executive or non-corporate roles. What is evident is that for most, the skills they hone as CFO will be used in some capacity. As well as addressing the transition to a non-executive position, this report will look at what it takes to transition to the role of CEO, chairman, and from public to private ownership as a CFO of a PE portfolio company.
5. Build your personal profile 6. Gain international experience 7. Dont get stuck at headquarters 8. Start planning early
We explore these in more detail on page 41-42.
4 The DNA of the CFO: a study of what makes a chief financial officer, Ernst & Young, 2010.
79% 00%
of CFOs agree that their financial expertise means they are more in demand than ever Text gets inserted here for board-level roles.
The language of boards is the language of finance and value. Its a very easy environment for a CFO to fit into
David Grigson, Chairman of Trinity Mirror and former CFO of Reuters and Emap
It isnt news to report that CFOs make good candidates for the board. But what is interesting is the extent to which the demand for both serving and former CFOs to take on board roles is increasing. In the current economy, shareholders, boards and regulators want board members who have the right skills, perspective and judgment. And, the CFO is uniquely qualified for the job.
The knowledge and experience that CFOs possess is highly relevant to the oversight role that boards perform. The language of boards is the language of finance and value, says David Grigson, Chairman of Trinity Mirror and former CFO of Reuters and Emap. Its a very easy environment for a CFO to fit into and make a contribution, because the conversation is all about how the company can deliver something that will be beneficial to shareholders. This is the kind of value equation that CFOs are constantly calculating. The demand for both current and former CFOs on boards has increased dramatically in recent years. Seventy-nine percent of the 800 finance leaders surveyed for this report agree that CFOs financial expertise means they are more in demand
than ever for board-level roles. A similar proportion agree that the CFOs skills and experience make them highly transferable into roles beyond finance. Our research into changes to board composition shows that the representation of both current and former CFOs on boards has increased significantly over the past decade. In 2002, just 8% of board members at the 347 companies studied were either serving or former CFOs. A decade later, that share has climbed to 14%. The difference is even more striking for specific board positions: in 2002, just 19% of audit committee chairmen were either serving or current CFOs; by 2012, the proportion has risen to 41% (Chart 1).
Chart 1. Percentage of boards comprised of either serving or former CFOs, 2002 and 2012
8 Serving or former CFOs on boards 14
18
19
41
14
2002
2012
10
Finance skills alone do not necessarily make someone a good board director, but financial expertise is desperately needed.
Andrew Kakabadse, Professor of International Management Development, Cranfield University School of Management
1. Changing regulatory requirements 2. Challenging macroeconomic environment 3. Expanding breadth of the CFO role
1. Changing regulatory requirements make finance experience desirable, if not mandatory
In many countries, changes to the regulatory environment enacted since the corporate governance scandals at the beginning of the century have increased the demand for finance expertise on boards. For example, since 2003, public companies listed in the US must disclose whether they have at least one financial expert independent of management on their audit committees. If they do not have this expertise in place, they have to explain why. In the UK, the Corporate Governance Code states that the board should satisfy itself that at least one member of the audit committee has recent and relevant financial experience. Likewise, in Brazil, the Comissao de Valores Mobiliarios (CVM) states that at least one member of the audit committee should have recognized expertise in matters of corporate accounting. In Australia, the 2011 Centro case served as a reminder for boards of their obligations in respect of financial reporting. When it comes to the financial report, directors must review, understand and challenge the financial statements and be satisfied that they are consistent with their knowledge of the business, says Tony Johnson, Assurance Managing Partner at Ernst & Young Australia. A board member with deep and broad finance experience, like that of a CFO, can offer valuable insights and play a leadership role in driving board effectiveness.
3. The increasing breadth of the CFO role has made them more valuable to boards
Perhaps most importantly, the evolution of the CFO role over the past decade has significantly broadened the contribution that finance leaders are able to make to these board positions. As we explored in The DNA of the CFO series, the modern finance leader has a broad and complex role, encompassing strategic contribution, business partnering, internal and external stakeholder management, as well as operational responsibilities far beyond the core technical and financial capabilities that once characterized the role.5
5 Our three The DNA of the CFO reports look at what makes a modern CFO around the world. The DNA of the CFO: a study of what makes a chief financial officer, Ernst & Young, 2010, focused on EMEIA. Views. Vision. Insights: The evolving role of todays CFO, Ernst & Young, 2012, focused on the Americas. The DNA of the CFO. Shifting up a gear: From corporate finance to corporate strategy, Ernst & Young, 2012, looked at CFOs in the Asia-Pacific region.
11
Boards no longer recruit CFOs because they are reporting experts, says Mr. Johnson. They want someone who can bring a strategic perspective to finance, whether that is related to capital, M&A or an investment analyst view of the world. If there was a CFO who became a finance leader just because they had the best knowledge of accounting standards, then that would not be the person that people are looking for to go on a board.
In some respects, CFOs may be better placed than CEOs to fulfill non-executive roles, because they are more accustomed to taking an analytical, challenging approach to decisionmaking. If youre a deal junkie or someone who wants to make every decision going, then youll probably find a non-executive role very frustrating and your board colleagues will be driven mad by you, says Mr. Grigson. Youre not actually there to make decisions. Youre there to challenge, offer support and provide oversight so that management are going about their role in the right way.
Chart 2. How suited do you think CFOs are to take on the following non-executive roles at organizations other than the one they work for? (percentage)
Not suited
Member of audit committee Member of risk committee Member of remuneration committee Non-executive chairman Member of nomination committee 12 56 6 6 8 9
Suited
81 77 72 66
12
There is massive demand for people with CFO-type experience versus very little supply.
Keith Pogson, Managing Partner for Financial Services, Asia-Pacific, Ernst & Young
The audit committee role is the most obvious fit for the CFO
Unsurprisingly, CFOs think that they are most suited to the role of audit committee member: 81% of our respondents say that finance leaders are a good choice for this particular job. Regulatory requirements will often demand that at least one member of the audit committee is a financial expert, but there are a variety of other reasons why boards and nomination committees are turning to current and former CFOs to fulfill these roles. Accounting standards are moving at an incredibly rapid rate, investor activism is on the rise and companies face an extremely complex risk and regulatory environment. All of these trends increase pressure on audit committee members and make it more difficult for those with a non-finance background to perform the role. If you have an audit committee chair who does not have the right knowledge and background, then there is a danger that they will not do enough to provide the right checks and balances, and a risk that the CFO will simply run rings around them, says Steve Hare, Head of the Portfolio Support Group at Apax Partners. On the other hand, if you have an audit committee chair with current knowledge, then they clearly have insights into where the key judgments are likely to be made and where adjustments are required. A good audit committee chair is someone who the CFO can consult and seek advice on complex issues. The audit committee role can also be considered a stepping stone to a bigger board position. As an audit committee
member, your experience and independence is highly valued, says Kees Storm, Chairman of the Supervisory Board of KLM and Anheuser-Busch InBev, Vice-Chairman of Unilever, and a member of the Supervisory Board of AEGON. Once you have fulfilled that role, you may well find that you are asked to take on a bigger role on the board, such as the senior independent director or chairman.
13
67%
of CFOs have taken on, or would be willing to take on, a voluntary or non-executive role.
14
You go on boards for three reasons. The intellectual capital, which is what you learn; the social capital, which is who you meet; and the creative capital, which consists of the ideas and concepts that you can find out about and bring back to your own company.
Susan Stautberg, President of PartnerCom Corporation
The pressures of a CFOs day job make it extremely challenging to fit external roles into the schedule. Yet, despite the obvious constraints, part-time positions can bring powerful professional and personal benefits for those who can find a way to juggle their responsibilities. For this multitasking to work, CFOs need to choose additional roles carefully, and ensure that any extra responsibilities are relevant either to their core CFO position or their long-term career development.
15
In general, CFOs surveyed for this report have a strong appetite for supplementary jobs. Just over one-quarter of respondents have already taken on one or more part-time, voluntary or non-executive positions in addition to their CFO position, while a further 40% say that they would be interested in doing so (Chart 3). Unsurprisingly, more senior CFOs are more likely to have a supplementary position: almost one-third of group CFOs have already taken on part-time roles, compared with 24% of regional and divisional finance leaders. Our research into 347 of some of the worlds largest company CFOs shows that, between 2002 and 2012, the likelihood of a serving CFO holding a non-executive role alongside their core position has increased significantly: in 2002, 36% of serving CFOs held a non-executive position; by 2012, this proportion has increased to 46%. And, although the audit committee has remained the most likely destination for large-company CFOs, the number of CFOs taking on a broader range of roles including sitting on the remuneration committee or serving as non-executive chairman has also grown (Figure 1).
Chart 3. Have you taken on, or would you be willing to take on, one or more part-time, voluntary or non-executive roles, as an addition to your current CFO position? (percentage)
27
40
33
Figure 1. Proportion of serving CFOs at the largest companies with non-executive roles in 2002 and 2012
Class of 2002
Breakdown*
8% non-executive chairman 30% audit committee
Class of 2012
Breakdown*
17% non-executive chairman 36% audit committee
46% hold
11% nomination committee
* Breakdown includes the top four most popular types of non-executive director roles. Others include risk committee and policy committee Source: desktop research into 347 large-company CFOs
16
A CFO who is established in the role can derive real benefit from lifting their head out of their organization and thinking hard about the issues that face another company.
David Grigson, Chairman of Trinity Mirror and former CFO of Reuters and Emap
Chart 4 shows some interesting regional variations. In every country or region, except Scandinavia, CFOs from the class of 2012 are more likely to hold a non-executive directorship compared with the class of 2002.
Chart 4. Serving CFOs with non-executive directorships in 2002 and 2012 (percentage)
Germany
45 60 63 71
France
17
Australia
60
UK
32 43
46
49
US
10 33
China
Scandinavia
17
30
Class of 2002
Class of 2012
17
CFOs are split on whether they should take on part-time roles while serving as CFO
There is division among finance leaders over whether or not it is appropriate for them to take on supplementary roles, as shown in Chart 5. The challenge, it seems, is that while most CFOs recognize that these roles bring a variety of benefits, there are also barriers that make it extremely difficult for them to accommodate these additional roles.
responsibilities outside that CFOs role? Chart 5. Do you agreeof their main should not take on part-time responsibilities outside of their main role? Chart 5: Do you agree that CFOs should not take on part-time
Disagree
Agree
40%
42%
Neutral
18
... if you dont have deep sector expertise, then that gives you permission to ask the more fundamental questions because youre not embarrassed if you dont understand something.
Steve Hare, Head of the Portfolio Support Group, Apax Partners
That will help them enormously in their current role, as well as bringing their knowledge and experience into the non-executive board context. Faisal Al-Hajri, CFO of the Qatar Foundation, also agrees and points to the wide range of new knowledge that finance leaders can collect in part-time roles as a key benefit. You get to look beyond the purely financial and think more strategically about a different organization, he explains. You can also use these roles to play a broader role in society or the community. For divisional CFOs, who may be one step removed from group level decisions, experience on a board can provide extremely valuable insight that they may be unable to secure in their day-to-day operational role. As a divisional CFO in a large company, you may not have to deal with the issues that take place at head office, such as funding, no matter whether debt or equity, because that is the responsibility of the group CFO, says Michael Sen, CFO for the Healthcare Sector at Siemens. By taking on a board directorship at a smaller company or sitting on the audit committee, you gain exposure to those decisions and that can be useful experience for a future role in a group CFO position.
Understanding board dynamics from the other side is the principal benefit
According to survey respondents, the most important benefit to becoming a non-executive director is the opportunity to gain general management and board-level experience (Chart 6). Most CFOs spend a lot of time engaging with their own board members, but, often, it is only by sitting on the other side of the table that they understand fully the challenges and dynamics of the boardroom. Professor Kakabadse agrees with these findings and considers it a good idea for any top-serving executive to have one non-executive board position in addition to their full-time job. It exposes them to boards and provides experience of how governance requirements need to be handled, he says.
Chart What are the benefits for a serving CFO in becoming a non-executive director? (percentage) Chart 6:6. What are thebenets for a serving CFO in becoming a non-executive director? (percentage)
Opportunity to gain general management or board level experience Opportunity to gain exposure to another company or industry Opportunity to get a different perspective on running an organization Opportunity to demonstrate suitability for leadership roles beyond nance Opportunity to leverage the non-executive director experience to benet my main CFO role A means to stretch or diversify a business career without the pressure of executive responsibilities
75 65 62 58 53 51
19
Beyond cross-pollination of ideas and concepts, exposure to new corporate cultures can also be useful. Dealing with a different set of management or board dynamics helps CFOs to develop soft skills critical to success. If you talk to board directors about the style of boards and the way they work, youll find that no two are exactly the same, says Mr. Pogson. Understanding how those cultures differ, and why, can be very valuable, because you start to appreciate how problems and challenges can be solved in different ways.
20
Until they have been through a crisis as a non-executive director, many people dont appreciate just how much additional time may be required, particularly during a crisis situation.
Chris Pierce, CEO, Global Governance Services
Chart 7. What would you say are the biggest challenges a serving CFO faces in taking on non-executive director positions as a part-time responsibility? (percentage)
Risk of over-stretch by taking on non-executive director roles Risk of conicts of interest between CFO and non-executive director role CFOs lack strong networks needed to be considered for non-executive director roles Tendency to overstep their non-executive director responsibilities as an independent advisor and sounding board Lack of condence to take on the role Doesn't have the right skills to take on role successfully 18 38 37 27 48 60
Certainly, there is a mismatch between the expectations of Walker and the amount of time that CFOs say they could allocate to a part-time position: more than half of our respondents estimate that they could only spare five hours or less per week (Chart 8), and yet the Walker recommendations correspond to at least that.
Chart 8. How many hours a week do you think is the maximum that a CFO can afford to spend on a part-time role, in addition to their main responsibilities?
Between 1020 More than 20
4% 1%
None
2%
Less than 1
5%
Between 510
38%
Between 25
50%
21
Other executives may be wary of the impact of your external role on your day job
Concerns about time commitment mean that some companies are reluctant to let their finance leaders take on external positions. Some firms even request that any fees earned by the non-executive should be paid to the company, to ensure that external positions have direct business relevance. But our research mostly suggests there is general support for the idea that CFOs should consider external roles. Sixty percent of respondents agree that other C-level executives in their organization are very supportive of leadership team members taking on part-time roles, while only 11% disagree (Chart 9). It is also notable that those who have already taken on a part-time role are much more likely than those who have not to say that their C-level peers are supportive of their decision.
Chart 9. Other C-level executives in my organisation are very supportive of members of the leadership team taking on part-time roles
Disagree
external role. This is particularly true when taking on a role as audit committee chair any subsequent financial difficulties or accounting irregularities could damage the CFOs reputation and career prospects.
11%
Neutral
29%
Agree
60%
22
The first priority is to do your homework on the board... You need a good feel for who the other board members are and must be honest with yourself about whether you could fit in.
Carl Berquist, Executive Vice-President and CFO, Marriott International
questions about the expectations of the role, to ensure that it is appropriate both for them and their career. The first priority is to do your homework on the board you are thinking of taking a position on, because you dont want to learn once you are there, says Mr. Berquist, Executive Vice-President and CFO of Marriott International. You need a good feel for who the other board members are and must be honest with yourself about whether you could fit in. The type of role that the CFO is being asked to fulfill will also make a difference. A role as an audit committee member may be suitable, but a position as chair of the audit committee will be more challenging, because of both the time pressures and professional risks associated with the role. As Mr. Pogson explains, I am not sure youd want to be the chairman of the audit committee if youre a serving CFO, because your credibility will be connected to the performance of another organization which is probably a step too far.
governance experts suggest that, as a general rule, this should be the limit. Our survey respondents, however, think that it is possible to do more, with one-third claiming that serving CFOs could take on three or more non-executive roles (Chart 10).
Chart 10. What is the maximum number of non-executive roles Chart 10: What is the maximum number of non-executive that you you think a serving CFO should roles thatthink a serving CFO should take on? take on?
None
4%
1 3 or more
21%
32%
Mr. Pierce argues, however, that it makes little sense to think in terms of number of board positions or for regulators to apply a cap because the demands of each role vary so widely. Applying a cap is a very crude approach, because the workload requirements for sitting on an NGO board, for example, are going to be completely different from a listed companys board, he says. It is now regarded as good practice for the chairman to make the expectations very clear in a letter of appointment, so that directors have a clear understanding of what time commitment will be expected of them. Serving CFOs can then make the right decision about how many positions to hold, based on what is required.
If you can bring value to a board, you will take value too
Ultimately, the decision over whether to take on an external role depends on two key questions: whether the position will add value to the CFOs career, personal development and core job; and whether they can make a valuable contribution to that part-time position. If the answer to either question is yes, the CFO owes it to themselves and their company to at least consider the appointment. It will not always be appropriate for a CFO to hold an external position, but those who do will very often find that the experience is a highly rewarding one.
CFO and beyond The possibilities and pathways outside finance 23
Chart 11. Which of the following part-time, voluntary or non-executive roles, would you be most interested in taking on as an addition to your current CFO position? (percentage)
Trustee or board member of a charity or cultural institution Non-executive director in other companies in the same sector Non-executive director in other companies in another sector
17
35
19
24
11
32
Mentoring role
15
26
11
27
10
26
25
11
18
20
24
By spending time on the board of a very different institution, you gain a much better understanding of how groups work and how decisions get made.
Ritchy Drost, CFO for European Broadband Operations at Liberty Global
For Kevin Farr, CFO of Mattel and Chairman of Mattel Childrens Foundation, this is a valuable way to position the company as a responsible corporate citizen. Its important for the company to be recognized for the fact that we give back to the communities in which we work and live. This has a positive social impact and is also good for the personal fulfillment of those involved with this work.
Spending time on the board of a charitable body can also provide younger CFOs, in particular, with valuable boardroom experience and the opportunity to network with other business leaders. You get good experience of how boards interact and experience of how the board role differs from the executive one, says Mr. Berquist. That can be useful knowledge that may well help you secure a non-executive position on a corporate board in the future.
Chart 12. What has motivated you/would motivate you to take on to take on a part-time,non executive role Chart 12: What has motivated you, or would motivate you, a part-time, voluntary or voluntary or non-executive role alongside your current CFO positions? (percentage) alongside your current CFO positions? (percentage)
Gaining broader knowledge and experience of business Utilizing my skills and expertise towards making a contribution to society in a part-time or voluntary capacity Broadening knowledge or experience of nancial issues and subjects relevant to the CFOs role Improving knowledge of the industry, market conditions and regulatory environment Improving soft skills, e.g., communication and inter-personal skills Utilizing my skills and experience to benet younger management talent and give back to the business community Personal fulllment/satisfaction and to broaden networks Gaining better understanding of what drives different stakeholders Gaining better awareness of career options 39 52 58
63
58
51
49
48
47
23
Other
25
82%
of CFOs would consider another role either partor full- time after fulfilling their goals as CFO.
26
Possibilities post-CFO
The CFOs role involves coordinating the senior management team and encompasses group skills rather than leadership for the sake of leadership. Those skills are also very important for the chairman.
Chris Pierce, CEO, Global Governance Services
Finance professionals who reach the CFO position have achieved extraordinary success and, for most, this is the pinnacle of their executive career. But once they have met their CFO ambitions, many are open to answering the demand for their skills and experience in a new sphere, either in an executive or non-executive capacity. For this considerable proportion of CFOs, there is no shortage of options.
27
Possibilities post-CFO
A substantial 82% of survey respondents said that they would consider another role after fulfilling their CFO goals. When asked why, the majority cited the opportunity to broaden their skills and experience, and to apply the knowledge they have gained as CFO in other roles (Chart 13).
Chart 13. What would motivate you to take on a part- or full- time role after serving as a CFO? (percentage)
Broadening range of skills and experience Using skills and experience gained as CFO in other roles 61 60
Leading an organization in another role such as CEO or chairman Doing something more in line with personal interests, e.g., a hobby or a pursuit unrelated to the corporate world Contributing more to public service or socially useful work
53
45
46
40
Improving earnings Working in an environment which allows greater autonomy and the opportunity to be entrepreneurial and develop own venture Using skills and experience to gain personal equity in a private company
39
37
37
28
Sixty-two percent of the 347 large-company group CFOs in role in 2002 are either still CFOs today or the job was their last executive post.
CFO to CEO
Our The DNA of the CFO series found that the vast majority of finance leaders in EMEIA and Asia-Pacific see CFO as a destination in its own right; only 10% and 13% of respondents respectively harbored the ambition to become CEOs. Interestingly, this contrasted with the findings from the Americas study, where those CFOs interviewed were more likely to express a desire to move to the CEO role. This desire to be a CFO first and foremost is further supported by the leading CFOs we researched for this study. Sixty-two percent of the 347 large-company group CFOs in role in 2002 are either still CFOs today or the job was their last executive post. Of the remainder, only 15% have become either CEO or CEO and chairman, 4% chairman and 3% COO. A further 16% had moved on to a variety of other executive roles, including deputy CEO, regional managing director and CIO (Figure 3).
2002
62% CFO 12% CEO
3% COO
Possibilities post-CFO
While CFO to CEO is still a transition for the minority, as with non-executive roles, there are signs that financial expertise is becoming more valued as an attribute in CEOs. Research from recruitment firm Crist Kolder, shows that between 1999 and 2011 the proportion of CEOs who have financial DNA which refers to experience in any finance capacity in Fortune 500 and Standard & Poors 500 companies, has risen from 22% to 33% (Chart 14). Chart 14. Financial experience of newly named CEOs between 1999 and 2011
2011 Fortune 500 and S&P 500 companies
45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 1999 %
The reasons CFOs are being increasingly valued in the CEO position are not dissimilar to the reasons they are being sought for non-executive director roles. First, many companies now face more significant regulatory challenges than at any time in living memory, and shareholders want confidence that the management team understands the implications of these pressures. In general, more heavily regulated sectors are more likely to have CEOs with CFO experience: energy and financial services companies are most likely to have former finance leaders in the CEO position, according to Crist Kolder (Chart 15).
Chart 15. Percentage of CEOs with CFO experience by industry between 1999 and 2011
2011 Fortune 500 and S&P 500 companies
30 %
25
20
15
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
10
0
Technology Retail Consumer Healthcare Services Industrial Financial Energy 6.3 10.8 13.9 17 19.8 21.4 22.6 25.2
30
While CFO to CEO is still a transition for the minority, as with non-executive roles, there are signs that financial expertise is becoming more valued as an attribute in CEOs.
A corollary of this is that, in general, it is less common for CFOs to make the transition to CEO in industries that are very dependent on marketing or have a large public profile. For instance, in sectors such as consumer goods and retail, CEOs tend to come from a customer-facing background, perhaps having served as a chief marketing officer. Second, the external environment has forced many companies to spend the past few years focusing on cost management, efficiency and managing risk all core CFO activities. In the absence of growth opportunities in many developed economies, these bottom-line improvements have become a key source of
value, leading a growing number of companies to lean toward appointing a former CFO to the top position. Third, the CFOs evolving role makes them more capable of making the transition to CEO. Taking on strategic responsibilities, building broader commercial experience and working on their leadership abilities, means CFOs are much stronger candidates for the job. Our survey respondents cited the need to gain experience in developing business strategy and leading operations as the top priority if considering CEO as the next stage in their career (Chart 16).
Chart 16.If you were toto consider a CEO for the next stage of your of yourwhich of the following skills and experience would you Chart 17: If you were consider a CEO role role for the next stage career, career, which of the following skills most like to develop further most current role as further in your current role as CFO? (percentage) and experience would you in yourlike to developCFO? (percentage)
Senior level experience in developing business strategy or leading operations Communicating and inuencing a wide range of internal and external stakeholders Senior level experience in leading M&A transactions Experience in a non-executive role 31 38 40
61
27
International experience
Deep industry or sectoral expertise Launching a new product or service or launching operations in new market 14
31
Possibilities post-CFO
A second danger is that, having become CEO, a former finance leader is unwilling to let go of their previous financial responsibilities. This not only undermines the new CFO, but can also have broader implications. If you have a CEO who talks like a CFO, then the whole organization and the markets can lose confidence in the company, says Bhavesh Shah, Vice-President, Asia-Pacific at Johnson & Johnson. When you move out of the finance function, you need to be very careful not to step on the new CFOs toes, because that will undermine not only his role but also the value that you bring to the company.
32
If you have a CEO who talks like a CFO, then the whole organization and the markets can lose confidence in the company.
Bhavesh Shah, Vice-President, Asia-Pacific at Johnson & Johnson
company you get to avoid the public scrutiny, and that means that you are able to build a business for the longer term without people worrying about quarterly reporting, he explains. But you replace that with a lot of pressure from the PE house to justify operational decisions, for example the requirement to produce detailed analysis before you are able to deploy capital expenditure. And some people find that scrutiny very intrusive. When recruiting a CFO to a portfolio company, PE houses are typically looking for a very specific combination of skills and capabilities. Candidates need deep technical financial knowledge because, when stepping into the role, they are likely to acquire complex financing and lending arrangements. At the same time, a good PE CFO also needs to have broader strategic vision, and the ability to handle large M&A transactions and lead integration efforts. Candidates who combine both of these capabilities are rare. CFOs from smaller companies may be closer to the numbers because the finance function is smaller and less specialized, but they are less likely to have experienced large-scale M&A and integration. Equally, listed-company CFOs may have the big-picture strategic vision, but most will have long since stepped back from the more technical aspects of the role. People from a PLC background are used to having a team of people who do the numbers, says Caroline Ross, Director of Ernst & Youngs Private Equity Key Executive Program, which connects candidates with those looking to fill executive roles in the PE sector. Youre not necessarily going to have that in a private equity-backed business.
That takes a certain type of CFO who is comfortable with stress, who can identify where problems are and then fix them. In other cases, the asset may be in better shape but the PE house will have a specific improvement goal in mind, such as investing internationally or creating new routes to market. In those situations, a business partnering CFO who can help to effect that change will be in demand. When a PE company acquires a business, it will often replace the incumbent CFO with someone who has PE experience. This begs the question of how CFOs from listed companies gain the initial experience necessary to position themselves for these roles. It can be difficult to get into the club in the first place, but, once you are in, you do find that people move between jobs and across different sectors, says Ms. Ross, who suggests that interim roles in PE can be one way to gain the necessary experience. Sector experience can be less important than knowing how to operate in a highly leveraged private equity environment.
The nature of the asset will determine the right CFO for the job
In addition, a PE house will be seeking specific experience in a portfolio CFO that will depend on the nature of the asset. Often, the company will be in a turnaround situation, so the new CFO will be required to make quick decisions and turn a loss into a profit. CFOs at a turnaround company need to be robust, quick and able to make difficult decisions, says Ashley Whipman, a Director of Robert Half Management Resources.
33
Possibilities post-CFO
With the days of large leveraged deals now in the past, and the returns from PE less certain, CFOs also need to consider carefully the risks of making the jump. The success of a PE deal now depends less on financial leverage and much more on operational improvements, but these can be difficult to achieve. You can end up in something that goes nowhere, with the added problem that you have your name associated with that, says Ms. Ross. Its an exciting environment and, if it goes well, you will do very well financially, but you have got to have that tolerance of risk.
Chart 18: Percentage of former CFOs in non-executive director positions, 2002 and 2012 Chart 17. Percentage of former CFOs in non-executive director positions, 2002 and 2012 (percentage)
19 Former CFO audit committee chairman 9 Former CFO chairman 6 Former CFO remuneration committee chairman 7 Former CFO nomination committee chairman 7 Former CFO non-executive director 12 13 13 18
35
2002
2012
34
CFOs at a turnaround company need to be robust, quick and able to make difficult decisions. That takes a certain type of CFO who is comfortable with stress, who can identify where problems are and then fix them.
Ashley Whipman, Director of Robert Half Management Resources
At a country level, the changes are even more striking. In the UK, the proportion of audit committee chairmen who are former CFOs has doubled from 35% to 71%, while the US has gone from 13% to 35% (Chart 18). Chart 18. Proportion of audit committee chairs at 347 of the worlds largest companies who are former CFOs in 2002 and 2012
35 UK 26 43
71
Germany 13 US 19 Global
35
35
27 29 France 11 Australia 13 24 28
Scandinavia 6 11
2002
2012
35
Possibilities post-CFO
36
Once they go plural, we tend to see that those non-executives who were formerly CFOs will look for a collection of roles that include one FTSE 100, one FTSE 250, one smaller business, and something in the charitable or public sector.
Richard Emerton, Managing Partner, Board and CEO Services, EMEA, Korn/Ferry
37
55%
38
You need to have a destination in mind and be practical about what is required... to get there.
Lawrie Tremaine, Executive Vice-President and CFO, Woodside
Those who are interested in the opportunities open to them as a complement to their current role or as an onward step, need to plan ahead. While CFOs are in demand for roles beyond finance, competition for the top board positions is fierce and getting fiercer. As regulatory requirements heighten, younger candidates join the fray, and board expectations increase, career planners will win over opportunists for a place on the shortlist.
39
You need to have a destination in mind and be practical about what is required to develop the skills and experience you need to get there, says Lawrie Tremaine, CFO of Woodside, Australias largest independent dedicated oil and gas company. That means taking a proactive approach to figuring out what is lacking on your CV and then going out to get it. It never ceases to amaze me just how many people do not have that plan in place and abdicate responsibility for their own career development. The 61% of CFOs with only a short-term plan or no plan at all suggests that many finance leaders are opportunistic in their career approach (Chart 20). However, its likely to be the long-term planners who are appointed to boards, having acquired depth and diversity in the skills and experience they can offer.
Agree
79
64
53
Chart 20. Correlation between the tendency to career plan and part-time roles
In general, how would you describe your approach to planning your career? (percentage) I have a very clear, long-term plan of how I would like my career to proceed I have a clear plan, but only over a relatively short-term period I do not have a clear plan of how I would like my career to proceed
39 41 20
I haven't yet, but would be interested in doing so 29
55
34
31
46
45
16
20
24
Have you taken on, or would you be willing to take on, one or more part time, voluntary or non-executive roles, as an addition to your current CFO position? (percentage)
Any search firm is going to Google you, and will want to see that you are out and about and well-known.
Susan Stautberg, President, PartnerCom Corporation
3. Build networks
In recent years, boards have taken a more transparent and independent approach to recruiting directors. But nevertheless, to be considered for directorship roles, it still helps to have the right contacts among senior business leaders. CFOs should nurture these networks through trade associations, conferences, industry meetings and part-time roles. Word of mouth is still a significant factor that will determine whether or not you are on a list for a board appointment, says Mr. Johnson.
41
Entertainment Network. You have to be a good business partner for the CEO and COO of the company, broaden your horizons and look beyond the numbers.
42
43
Diversity on boards
In recent years, boards recruitment processes have become more rigorous, driven by a need to demonstrate greater transparency and strong governance practice. As Mr. Emerton from Korn/Ferry comments: Most boards now take a systematic approach to considering the challenges the management team will face over the next few years, and the types of experience sthey need around the board table to help management meet those challenges. Boards are now under great pressure to increase the diversity of their composition and particularly gender diversity. Although some progress has been made on this, it has been frustratingly slow. In 2002, 89% of the board members of the 347 large companies researched for this study were male. A decade later, this share has only shrunk to 79% (Figure 4). least 40% of their board seats for women, although a vote on these proposals was postponed in October 2012. Quotas certainly have a noticeable impact on increasing boards gender diversity. Norway now has the largest percentage of female board members in the world at 36%, compared with just 4.5% in Italy and 2.3% in Portugal. Nevertheless, quotas remain controversial and many corporate governance experts worry that boards may become less effective because individuals are chosen due to their gender rather than their talents.
Beth Brooke, Global Vice Chair of Public Policy at Ernst & Young, recommends a self-regulatory approach, whereby companies set their own aspirational targets that are both stretching and appropriate for their circumstances, and then publicly report their progress against them. This can then be Figure 4: Proportion of on boardsboards of large347 combined with board-level mentoring and sponsorship as well men on of the 347 the Figure 4. Proportion of men large companies researched, 2002 and 2012 as networking and training to accelerate the rate at which companies researched, 2002 and 2012 women attain board positions. One of the obstacles women face as they seek senior management or board positions is the 2002 2012 absence of proactive support and mentoring from members of company boards, she says. Therefore, senior leaders, both male and female, need to personally sponsor women by reaching out on their behalf and recommending them.
79%
male
Gender balance is just one aspect of the diversity debate. Boards need to hear different points of view, and that means that they need representation that is multi-gender, multiethnic, multi-institutional, multi-national, multi-regional and multi-generational, says Ms. Stautberg. You need people on boards who reflect the diversity of the customer and employee base, because you cant compete if you operate in an echo chamber where everyone thinks alike.
Diverse representation also improves the chances of diverse thinking. As Andrew Hobbs, Associate Partner in Ernst & Youngs Regulatory and Public Policy practice, explains, The Some countries have introduced quotas for women on boards board should not always be a comfortable place. For a board to in order to fast-track change. In 2003, Norway introduced a be effective, you need to create an environment where people Source: desktop research into 347 large company CFOs requirement for companies to have boards with at least 40% can independently challenge decisions. By ensuring that you female membership. Other European countries, including have diversity on boards, and a way for people to express that France, the Netherlands, Italy, Belgium and Spain have followed diversity, companies are much more likely to reduce the suit with similar legislation. The European Commission is also homogeneity that can hamper effective decision-making. proposing new rules that will require companies to reserve at
Source: desktop research into 347 large-company CFOs
44
You might start to see adversarial groups that normally would oppose the organization, or may have radically different views, joining the advisory board.
Andy Hines, Lecturer and Executive-in-Residence at the University of Houstons Graduate Program in Futures Studies
45
CFO to CEO From listed to private equity Non-executive directorships post-CFO Becoming a non-executive chairman
46
E
M
Co m
nal
Trus tin g
th e
nu
E
rs
be
DEV
EL
UT
ION
1
Providing insight
Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Getti
h our ng y
i se ou
We believe there are six main elements to the role of the CFO, which are described in further detail on pages 58 to 61. We asked the CFOs we surveyed which of these aspects of the CFO role were most important to master, as preparation for the onward journey to other executive and non-executive roles. The findings are shown in the following pages.
EN
ABLEMENT
n Fu
di
47
CFO to CEO
We asked survey respondents, as well as the CFOs we interviewed, which aspects of the CFO role are most important to master, as preparation for the onward journey to other roles. For the transition to CEO, there are two aspects that stand out as being especially crucial.
1|
2|
Respondents highlighted the need to take a commercial view in partnership with the business, provide robust but constructive challenge to stakeholders and possess a deep knowledge of the business, its products and services.
Moving to the CEO position requires a CFO who can translate corporate goals into strategy, develop a workable execution plan, and be able to build trust, motivate and engage the workforce.
Survey question: How important do you think the following elements of your current role will be to enable you to perform the CEO role?
How important do you think the following attributes of your current role will be to enable you to perform the CEO role? (percentage)
47%
he ot g t ce tin etpla a ic rk un a m m
rnal exte
Trus tin g
66%
th e
nu
be
rs
Co m
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound nancial criteria 1 Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
58%
46%
43%
Getti
our ng y
ho
40%
n Fu
ng
di
Christophe de Margerie
Chairman and CEO of Total
2010present Chairman and CEO, Total 20072010 CEO, Total 20022007 President of Exploration & Production division, Total 20002002 Senior Executive Vice-President of Exploration & Production division, TotalFinaElf 19992000 President of the Exploration & Production division, Total 19951999 President, Total, Middle East 19901995 CFO, Total, Middle East
20082010 Chairwoman, US India Business Council 2007present Chairwoman and CEO, Pepsico Inc 20062009 Non-Executive Director, Federal Reserve Bank of New York 20062007 President & CEO, Pepsico Inc 20022007 Non-Executive Director, Motorola Solutions Inc 20012006 President & CFO, Pepsico Inc
19962001 Senior Vice-President Corporate Strategy, Pepsico Inc 19861996 Vice-President & Division Director, Motorola Solutions Inc
CFO to CEO
19691989 Various executive positions in finance & operations, Mobil Group 19791989 Various positions at Chase Manhattan Bank in New York, Paris, Milan and Rome 19891994 International Treasurer, Renault Credit International 19941999 Investor Relations, Renault 19992002 Deputy General Manager, Investor Relations and Financial Strategy, Nissan Tokyo 20022004 Vice President, Global Communications and Investor Relations, Nissan Tokyo 20042006 Senior Vice President in charge of Administration and Finance, Nissan Europe 20062009 Senior Vice President in charge of Administration and Finance, Nissan North America 2009present Chairman and CEO of Renaults captive sales finance unit, RCI Banque 2010present CFO of Renault group 19891991 In charge of Finance, Mobil Oil Group, Europe 19911993 Head of Accounting, Finance & Control Department, Montecatini 19931996 Finance Director, Montedison SPA 19961998 CFO & General Manager, Ferrovie dello stato 19971998 Non-Executive Vice-President, Eurofima 19981999 CFO & General Manager, Telecom Italia 19992005 CFO, Enel 2005present CEO, Enel 2006present Non-Executive Director, Member of Audit Committee, Barclays 2006present Non-Executive Director, Member of Audit & Finance Committees, AON 20082011 Vice President, Union of the Electricity Industry
Fulvio Conti
CEO, Enel
Dominique Thormann
Group CFO Renault and CEO of RCI Banque
The career paths of leading CFOs former and serving illustrated on the following few pages are based on information provided by the individuals themselves or from BoardEx data. BoardEx is a global online database holding biographic information on executives based on publicly available information (e.g., annual reports and regulatory filings). Where possible, this information has also been verified with other credible online sources, such as company websites. Each profile highlights key appointments and is not intended to be comprehensive. Every care has been taken to ensure the accuracy of the information displayed here, at the time of going to press.
49
1|
2|
The PE environment requires individuals with a very strong commercial grasp of the business, and the ability to challenge high-level strategic concepts with a robust analysis of the financial case for each decision.
CFOs who move into a PE environment require a deep knowledge of the more technical aspects of finance, and an ability to deal with highly complex lending arrangements. Being all over the numbers and having the ability to derive insight and analysis from them is critical.
Survey question: How important do you think the following elements of your current role will be to enable you to perform a role as an operating partner or a strategic advisor to a PE firm?
Co m
30%
th e
nu
be
rs
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound nancial criteria 1 Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
32%
45%
29%
ng Getti
r you
ho
36%
n Fu
ng
di
Steve Hare
Head of Portfolio Support Group, Apax Partners
Robbie Barr
COO, Terra Firma
19781982 Accountant, KPMG Thomson McLintock 19821986 Various positions, Procter & Gamble 19861994 Various positions, Dixons Retail 19941997 Financial Director, Dawson International 19972002 Group Finance Director, Elementis 20022006 Group Finance Director, Alliance Unichem
19801983 Auditor, PwC 19831985 Auditor, Investment AB Skrinet 19851991 Controller, Securitas AB 19912007 CFO, Securitas AB 20062008 Non-Executive Director, Loomis Cash handling services 2007present Non-Executive Director, Swedish Chamber of Commerce 2008present Non-Executive Director & Chairman, Broadcast Text International 2008present CFO, Capio AB 2011present Non-Executive Director, Poolia AB, Member of Remuneration Committee
20032008 Non-Executive Director, Mitchells and Butlers, Chair of Audit Committee and Member of Nomination, Remuneration and Property Committees 20072008 Non-Executive Director, Alliance Boots Holdings
51
1|
2|
Although boards will expect a range of skills and capabilities among their members, CFOs stand out for their ability to challenge management decisions and ensure that they are made with the appropriate financial rigor.
Finance is the universal language of corporate boards, so the CFOs ability to analyze, dissect and challenge financial information is vital to the non-executive director role.
How important do you think the following attributes of your current role will be to enable you to perform a role as non-executive director? (percentage)
Survey question: How important do you think the following elements of your current role will be to enable you to perform a role as nonexecutive director?
Percentage of those who believe these elements are very important
26% 49%
Trus tin g
Co m
th e
nu
be
rs
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound nancial criteria 1 Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
24%
37%
24%
ng Getti
r you
ho
33%
n Fu
ng
di
Birgitta Kantola
Non-executive directorships
Richard Wallman
Non-executive directorships
2010present Member of the Board and the Audit Committee, Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken AB 2009present Member of the Board, Nobina AB 20082012 Member of the Board, NasdaqOMX 2005present Member of the Board and Chairman of the Audit Committee, Stora Enso 2001present Managing Partner, Birka Consulting AB 19952000 Vice-President and CFO, Member of the Management Group, International Finance Corporation (IFC) 19881995 Executive VicePresident and Head of Finance, Nordic Investment Bank (NIB) 19871988 Financial Operations Officer, International Finance Corporation (IFC)
2011present Non-Executive Director, Member of Strategic Planning Committee, Charles River Labs 2008present Non-Executive Director, Bausch & Lomb 2007present Non-Executive Director, Chair of Audit Committee, Member of Executive and Finance Committees, Convergys Corp 20032009 Non-Executive Director, Member of Audit and Compensation Committees, Lear Corp 20032007 Non-Executive Director, Chair of Audit Committee & Member of Finance and Compensation Committees, Avaya 20022012 Non-Executive Director, Chair of Compensation Committee, Ariba Inc 19952003 CFO, Honeywell International 19941995 Vice President & Controller, IBM 19931994 Assistant Controller, IBM 19741993 Various positions, Ford Motor then Chrysler
20042007 Non-Executive Director, Virgin Australia Holdings 19941998 Chairman and CEO, Renault Vehicles Industries 2005present Non-Executive Director, Chair of Audit & Risk Committee, Member of Nomination Committee, Seek 19982004 Executive VicePresident & CFO, Renault SA
2007present Non-Executive Chairman, Virgin Australia Holdings, Chair of Nomination Committee, Member of Audit & Risk, Remuneration, Safety & Risk Committees
20052009 Independent Board Member, Postnl NV 20072012 Non-Executive Director, Chair of Audit & Risk Committee, Member of Nomination & Remuneration Committee, Whitehaven Coal 20092011 Vice Chairman, Postnl NV 2009present Non-Executive Director, Chair of Audit & Risk Committee, Member of Nomination Committee, Transurban Group 2011present Vice Chairman, TNT Express NV 2009present Non-Executive Deputy Chairman, Chair of Health Safety & Environment and of Nomination and Remuneration Committees, Member of Audit Committee, Grange Resources
Shemaya Levy-Chocron
Non-executive directorships
Neil Chatfield
Non-executive directorships
53
1|
2|
Deep commercial knowledge of the business and the ability to identify risks associated with the business proposition are critical to the chairman role, as is the need to communicate clearly the financial implications of any strategic decision.
Core to the chairmans role is the ability to ensure cohesion among board members, and communicate clearly with external stakeholders, and particularly investors.
Survey question: How important do you think the following elements of your current role will be to enable you to perform a role as chairman?
76% 54%
rnal exte he ot e gt c tin pla ca e t ni a r k u m m Representing the
Trus tin g
th e
nu
be
rs
Co m
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound nancial criteria 1 Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
47%
50%
30%
Getti
our ng y
ho
43%
n Fu
ng
di
David Grigson
Chairman, Trinity Mirror
Alessandro Pansa
Non-Executive Chairman, Ansaldo STS
2012present Chairman, Trinity Mirror 2010present Senior Independent Director, Ocado Group 2010present Chairman, Creston 2009present Non-Executive Director, Standard Life 2007present Director/Trustee, Dolma Development Fund 20002008 CFO, Reuters Group 19892000 CFO, Emap
2011present COO/CFO and General Manager, Finmeccanica 2005present Non-Executive Chairman, Ansaldo STS 20042011 CFO & Co-general Manager, Finmeccanica 20012004 CFO, Finmeccanica
19992001 Partner & Managing Director, Lazard & Co 19931999 Senior Partner, Vitale Borghesi
19891993 Various positions in Investment Banking Division, Banca Euromobiliare 19871989 Various positions Study, Economics and Planning Division, Credito Italiano
19761978 Finance Director, KSH 19932002 Chairman of the Executive Board, AEGON 2002present Member of the Supervisory Board, AEGON
2003present Member of the Board of Directors, Baxter International 2004present Chairman of the Supervisory Board, KLM 2011present Vice-Chairman and Senior Independent Director, Unilever 2012present Chairman of the Board and Member of the Audit Committee, Anheuser-Busch InBev
Kees Storm
Chairman of the Supervisory Board, KLM and Chairman of Anheuser-Busch InBev
Thomas OStaggs
Non-Executive Chairman, Walt Disney Parks & Resorts Online
55
Survey demographics
One of the sources for this report was a survey of 800 CFOs world-wide. The following charts show the profile of these CFOs and the organizations they represent.
48 56
Job title
Job title
type
25 % 23 %
Privately owned
Mid cap 19 % Small cap 16 % Private-equity backed 9% Partnership 1% Family owned 1% Other 6%
Group CFO/FD
36%
Regional CFO/FD
59%
Divisional CFO/FD
5%
Sector
Sector
11% 9% 9% 8% 7% 7% 7% 7% 6% 6% 6%
25 %
Automotive Banking Oil and gas 12 % Media and entertainment 9% 7% Real estate Technology Telecoms Insurance
$
6%
$
$100m to $500m to $499.9m $999.9m $1b to $4.9b $5b to $9.9b
$
$10b to $19.9b
$20b or more
Geography of company HQ
14%
Belgium
Brazil
India
Australia
Nordics
France, Luxembourg
UK and Ireland
Hong Kong
Canada
Netherlands
Singapore
US
57
50 58
Co m m
DEV
UT
EL
ION
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your organization
1
Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
i nd Fu
ng
strat egy
n ei us ho
d or
EN T ABLEMEN
er
59
Core skills
Taking a commercial view in partnership with the business Identifying commercial, financial and economic risks from business propositions Establishing profitability of business propositions Providing robust but constructive challenge to business stakeholders Communicating clearly the financial implications of proposals
Core knowledge
Knowledge of the organizations business Detailed knowledge of products/service lines Awareness of the market and commercial environment Knowledge of investment appraisal Knowledge around approaches to profitability analysis
Key experiences
Business case appraisal Benefits tracking and realization Experience in pricing and profitability analysis Cost management Planning and forecasting
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer/Chief Operating Officer Business unit heads Heads of key support functions: Risk, IT, Operations, HR, Marketing and Sales Finance business partners Audit Committee
Co m m
1
Providing insight
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your company Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by CEO
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
strat egy
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
d or
Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
er
Co m m
nd Fu
ent of business st rate elopm gy Dev
Co m m
in g
Core skills
Communicating financial information effectively Assessing drivers of profitability Identifying and communicating areas of risk Forecasting future performance based on knowledge of past performance Identifying corrective action where required
Core knowledge
Knowledge of the organizations business Detailed knowledge of products/service lines Awareness of market trends, risks and issues Knowledge of key performance indicators (KPIs) in relation to the strategic plan Business performance management Knowledge of competition performance
Providing insight
Tru stin gt he nu m b
s er
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound financial criteria
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your company
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by CEO
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
2
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
d or
er
in g
Providing insight and analysis to support the CEO and other senior managers
Key experiences
Financial planning and reporting Accounting and reporting for projects and other non-recurring initiatives Experience in identifying non-financial drivers of financial performance Experience of identifying issues and corrective actions Operating at Executive level Markets trends analysis
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer/Chief Operating Officer Business unit heads Heads of key support functions: Risk, IT, Operations, HR, Marketing and Sales Finance business partners Strategy Director Corporate Development Officer
nd Fu
ent of business st rate elopm gy Dev
strat egy
Core skills
Leadership skills to drive through change in finance Setting and communicating the vision and strategy for finance Able to engage with business stakeholders to determine the appropriate role for finance Bringing together disparate stakeholders within finance and the business Sponsoring delivery of major change in the finance function
Core knowledge
How finance should be organized to deliver value to the business Understanding of finance processes and implications for the operating model The components of the finance operating model and the interdependencies Finance systems and implications for change Drivers of cost and value in finance
Tru stin gt he nu m b
s er
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your company
1
Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by CEO
in g
strat egy
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
er
nd Fu
Key experiences
d or
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer Business unit heads Heads of key support functions: IT, Marketing, Risk, Operations, HR Senior finance managers Business unit finance teams
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
Delivery of major change in finance Finance process improvement Designing changes to finance operating models Involvement with delivery of finance systems Engaging with internal customers around service delivery transformation
60
Core skills
Funding the organizations operations Prioritizing investments Developing strategic plans to achieve corporate goals Understanding the key value drivers Turning strategic plans into operational plans and targets (including defining KPIs) Designing the implementation program Monitoring progress against strategy
Core knowledge
Capital management Project financing Financial risk management Operational risk management Strategic and operational planning Performance management systems Program management Change management
Tru stin gt he nu m b
s er
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound financial criteria
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your company
1
Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by the CEO
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
d or
er
Key experiences
Involvement in determining funding requirements Securing funding for operations and major projects Management of working capital Implementing financial risk management strategy e.g., interest rate, foreign exchange and market risk Developing strategic plans Managing large and complex improvement/ change programs Managing a merger or acquisition
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer/Chief Operating Officer Business unit heads Risk Director Operations Director External funding providers Key investors Treasurer
Co m m
strat egy
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
d or
er
Co
strat egy
n ei us ho ur g yo Gettin
d or
er
nd Fu
in g
strat egy
Core skills
Translating corporate goals into a clear strategy Identifying financial and risk issues in relation to corporate strategy Delivering a workable strategic plan within known constraints Creativity/ability to think out-of-the-box/ conceptually strong Analyzing portfolio of opportunities Visionary/a story teller/ability to build trust and motivate people Effective communication of financial and risk issues to C-suite colleagues Providing robust financial challenge at C-suite level
Core knowledge
Strategic and operational planning Knowledge of the organizations business Detailed knowledge of products/service lines Business model design Scenario planning Good overview of the industry structure and challenges Strategic frameworks and theory Awareness of the market and commercial environment Aware of industry and organization risk profile Awareness of IT as an important business enabler
Tru stin gt he nu m b
s er
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound financial criteria
5
nd Fu
in g
1
Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
Providing insight
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by CEO
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
Key experiences
Strategy development Development and implementation of business plans Monitoring achievement of plans and targets and taking corrective actions where required Operational and financial risk management Product and market development
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer Chief Operating Officer Business unit heads Chief Information Officer Risk Director Marketing Director HR Director Strategy Director Corporate Development Officer
Core skills
Clear communication of performance Perspectives on organizations performance relative to main competitors Detailed knowledge about main value drivers/key KPIs and initiatives to improve them Positive communication around management of key risks Taking a forward looking view Anticipating and responding to questions from media, analysts and investor community Responding positively to issues raised by industry regulators
Core knowledge
Knowledge of the organizations business and deep insight into the industry Detailed knowledge of products/service lines Awareness of the market and commercial environment Awareness of impact of local regional and global economies on financial performance Accounting technical knowledge to supervise Financial Statements
6
Developing and defining the overall strategy for your company
Tru stin gt he nu m b
s er
Ensuring business decisions are grounded in sound financial criteria
1
Providing insight and analysis to support CEO and other senior managers
Key experiences
Preparation of financial information for external publication and communication to the capital markets Dealing with parties external to the organization Engaging with media Managing relationships with external auditors Managing resolution of key accounting and control issues
Key relationships
Chief Executive Officer Chairman Executive and non-executive boards Other key governance committees e.g., audit, remuneration External auditors Media and Investor Relations Regulators
Providing insight
4
Funding, enabling and executing strategy set by CEO
3
Leading key initiatives in finance that support overall strategic goals
nd Fu
in g
61
2012
Finance forte
The future of finance leadership
62
1109EDA017_CFO_thought_leadership_square_v7.indd 1
29/10/2010 15:40:28
Vol. 1
Vol. 2
Vol. 3
Drought or drowning?
Cash challenges for CFOs at both ends of the liquidity spectrum
Drought or drowning?
Cash challenges for CFOs at both ends of the liquidity spectrum
Drought
Drowning
Vol. 4
Drought or drowning?
Cash challenges for CFOs at both ends of the liquidity spectrum
63
Contacts
For further information about any of our CFO reports, or on our broader program of investment in CFOs, please go to www.ey.com/cfo or contact:
Emma Dowding
CFO program lead for Europe, Middle East, India and Africa (EMEIA) +44 20 7980 0152 [email protected]
Robert Brand
CFO program lead for the Americas +1 201 872 5692 [email protected]
Sarah Buerckner
CFO program lead for Asia-Pacific +852 2846 9888 [email protected]
64
65
About Ernst & Young Ernst & Young is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services. Worldwide, our 167,000 people are united by our shared values and an unwavering commitment to quality. We make a difference by helping our people, our clients and our wider communities achieve their potential. Ernst & Young refers to the global organization of member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. For more information about our organization, please visit www.ey.com. 2012 EYGM Limited. All Rights Reserved. EYG No. AU1333
In line with Ernst & Youngs commitment to minimize its impact on the environment, this document has been printed on paper with a high recycled content. This publication contains information in summary form and is therefore intended for general guidance only. It is not intended to be a substitute for detailed research or the exercise of professional judgment. Neither EYGM Limited nor any other member of the global Ernst & Young organization can accept any responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from action as a result of any material in this publication. On any specific matter, reference should be made to the appropriate advisor. The views of third parties set out in this publication are not necessarily the views of the global Ernst & Young organization or its member firms. Moreover, they should be seen in the context of the time they were made. ED None EMEIA MAS E158.0912