Capital and Revenue
Capital and Revenue
Capital and Revenue
Structure
13.0 13.1 13.2 13.3 Objectives Introduction Need for Distinction between Capital and Revenue Capital and Revenue Expenditures
13.3.1 Capital Expenditure 13.3.2 Revenue Expenditure 13.3.3 Deferred Revenue Expenditure
Capital and Revenue Profits Capital arid Revenue Losses Some Peculiar Items Let Us Sum Up Key Words Some Useful Books Answers to Check Your Progress Terminal Questions/Exercises
13.0 OBJECTIVES
After studying this unit you should be able to: explain the importance of distinction between capital and revenue distinguish between capital and revenue expenditure describe the circumstances under which a revenue expenditure is to be capitalised distinguish between capital receipt and revenue receipt, capital profit and capital loss identify correctly whether an item h of a capital or revenue nature
13.1 INTRODUCTION
In the preceding unit you learnt about the basic concepts followed in determining profit or loss and the financial position of a business. In this connection, it is equally necessary to understand the distinction between capital and revenue. Without such clarity you cannot ascertain the correct amount of profit or loss made during an accounting period. In this unit you will learn about the need for such distinction and study how ro decide whether a particular expenditure or a receipt is of capital nature or of revenue nature.
Final Accounts -1
Sheet. As per rules, items of revenue nature are shown in the Profit and Loss Account and items of capital nature in the Balance Sheet. In other words, whether an item will appear in Profit and Loss Account or in the Balance Sheet depends upon the revenue and capital nature of the item. If any item is wrongly classified i.e., if any item of revenue nature is treated as a capital item or vice versa, the ascertainment of profit will be incorrect. For example, the revenues earned during an accounting year are Rs. 1,00,000and the costs shown are Rs. 80,000. The profit will work out as Rs. 20,000. On rechecking you found that a revenue item of Rs. 5,000 (an expenditure on repairs of machinery) had been treated as a capital item (added to cost of machinery) and hence not included. It means the actual costs are Rs. 85,000 and not 80,000. So the correct profit is Rs. 15,000. In other words, the profit worked out earlier was overstated. Thus, it can also be stated that if any capital expenditure is wrongly classified as revenue expenditure, it would result in an understatement of profits. Let us also illustrate this. Assume that a purchase of furniture worth Rs. 10,000 was wrongly passed through the Purchases Book treating it as purchases of goods on credit. This would result in the boosting of costs by Rs. 10,000 leading to an understatement of profits by Rs. 10,000 and also to an understatement of assets. As such the final accounts will not reflect the t r y and fair view of the affairs of the business. Thus you learn that wrong classification of items would lead to the wrong ascertainment of profit and also the financial position. Hence, it is necessary to determine correctly whether an item is of a capital or of a revenue nature. This distinction is also important from taxation point of view because capital profits are taxed differently from revenue profits.
3
4
Expenditure incurred, during the early years, on development of mines and land for plantations till they become operational. Cost of experiments which ultimately result in the acquisition of a patent. However, the cost of experiments which are not successful is treated as a deferred revenue expenditure which is written off within two to three years. Legal charges incurred in connection with acquiring or defending suits for protecting fixed assets, rights, etc.
When the benefit of expenditure is not likely to be available for more than one year, it is treated as revenue expenditure. Thus all expenses which are incurred during the regular course of business are regarded as revenue expenditures. These may be as follows:
1
2
Expenses incurred in day-to-day conduct of the business such as wages, salaries, rent, postage, stationery, insurance, electricity, etc. Expenditure incurred for buying goods for resale or raw materials for manufacturing. Expenditure incurred for maintaining the fixed assets such as repairs and renewals of building, machinery, etc. Depreciation on fixed assets. This can also be termed as revenue loss. Interest on loans borrowed for running the business. You should note that any interest on loan paid during the initial period before production commences, is not treated as revenue expenditure. It is treated as capital expenditure. Legal charges incurred during the regular course of business such as legal expenses incurred on collection from debtors, legal charges incurred on defending a suit for damages. etc.
3
4
5
Expenditure incurred on advertising campaign to introduce a new product in the market. Expenditure incurred on formation of a new company (preliminary expenses). Brokerage charges, underwriting commission paid and other expenses incurred in connection with the issue of shares and debentures. Cost of shifting the plant and machinery to a new site which may involve dismantling, removing and re-erection of the plant and machinery.
3
4
Let us take the case of expenditure on advertising campaign. It is not a routine advertisement and the amount involved is unusually heavy. Its benefit will not completely exhaust in one accounting year but will continue over two-three years. Hence, it is not proper to charge such expenditure to the Profit and Loss Account of one year. It is better-todistribute it carefully over three years. So, in the first year we can charge one-third of the amount spent to the Profit and Loss Account and show the balance in the Balance Sheet as an asset. In the second year again we can charge a similar amount to the Profit and Loss Account and show the balance as an asset. In the third year, we may charge this balance to the Profit and Loss Account. Every expenditure which is regarded as deferred revenue is treated in this way in the final accounts.
Illustration 1
State whether the following items of expenditure would be treated as (a) capital expenditure or (b) revenue expenditure or (c) deferred revenu: expenditure:
Final Accounts -1
i) Carriage paid on goods purchased Rs. 25 ii) Rs. 2,000 spent on repairs of machinery iii) Rs. 5,000 spent on white washing
i v ) Rs. 8,000 paid for import duty and cartage on the purchase of machinery from West Germany
v) Rs. 25,000 spent on issue of equity shares vi) Rs. 14,000 spent on spreading new tiles on factory floor vii) Rs. 4.000 paid as brokerage in connection with the purchase of land viii) Rs. 60,000 spent on construction of railway siding ix) Rs. 1,55,000spent on uniforms to staff x) A second hand machine was bought for Rs. 10,000 and an amount of Rs. 6,000 was spent on its overhauling.
Solution
i) It is a revenue expenditure as it is related to the goods purchased for resale. ii) It is a revenue expenditure as it relates to the maintenance of a fixed asset. iii) Same as no. (ii) iv) It is a capital expenditure as it is spent in connection with"the purchase'of a fixed asset. v) It would be treated as deferred revenue expenditure. It is a heavy amount incurred in connection with raising of capital for the company and so capitalised. Even under the Indian Companies Act and the Indian Income Tax Act this expenditure is allowed to be written off over a number of years. vi) It is a revenue expenditure as it is treated as a sort of repairs not leading to any increase in the earning capacity of a fixed asset. vii) It is a capital expenditure as it is incurred in connection with the purchase of land. viii) It is a capital expenditure as it is incurred on the construction of railway siding, a fixed asset. ix) It is a revenue expenditure. But, if the uniforms are meant for use over two or more years (woollen uniform) this expenditure can be treated as deferred revenue. x) It is a capital expenditure as it is incurred on making the newly bought second hand machinery operational.
ii) All items of revenue nature are shown in the .......................... (Profit and Loss Account/Balance Sheet) iii) If revenue expenditure is treated as a capital expenditure, it will result in ......................... of profits. (overstatement/understatement) iv) Any expenditure where the benefit is spread over a number of years is. ......................... expenditure. (capitalJrevenue) v) When a revenue expenditure is capitalised, it is called ......................... expenditure. (capitalldeferred revenue) vi) Any expenditure incurred in acquiring a right like goodwill or patent is treated as ......................... expenditure. (capitallrevenue)
State whether the following statements are True or False. i) Every expeliditure of large amount is a capital expenditure.
'
True
Fa1se
0
E l
ii) An expenditure incurred on acquisition of a fixed asset is a capital expenditure. iii) Cartage paid on the new machine is a revenue expenditure.
iv) Depreciation on fixed assets is a capital expenditure. v) Cost of goods purchased for resale is a revenue expenditure.
0
Capital and Revenue
0
0 0
U
vi) Heavy expenditure on advertising campaign is a deferred revenue expenditure. vii) Deferred revenue expenditure is essentially an expenditure of capital nature. viii) Expenditure incurred as preliminary expenses is a capital expenditure. . -
Final Accounts -1
Account to determine the trading result while the capital items are shown in the Balance Sheet to assess the financial position of the business. Check Your Progress - B State whether the following statements are True or False.
i) Expenditure is not the same thing as payment. True False
n
CI
0
[7
n
Li
ii) Capital receipts are the amounts received in the normal course of the business. iii) Capital profit is-shown in the Profit and Loss Account.
iv) Capital receipt is different from capital income.
V)
Revenue expenditure and revenue loss mean one and the same thing.
n
r 1
-71 I-$
Replacement of an Old Asset Quite often we sell an old asset and replace it by a new one involving heavy expenditure. For example, an old machine which originally cost Rs. 90,000 is replaced by a new and modem one costing Rs. 2,00,000. The old machine is sold for Rs. 15,000. The replacement cost thus amounts to Rs. 1,85,000. Now the question arises as to how much of this amount should be charged as capital expenditure and how much as revenue. For this purpose, you must know that the replacement involves two aspects: (a) cost of the new machine, and (b) loss on the sale of old machine. In this case the cost of the new machine is Rs. 2,00,000. This will be treated as capital expenditure because it results in the acquisition of a fixed asset. As for the loss on the sale of old machine, you have to first find out the depreciated value (book value) of the old machine. Assuming it to be Rs. 25,000, the loss on the sale of old machine works out to Rs. 10,000 (book value Rs. 25,000 - sale value Rs. 15,000). This will be treated as revenue loss and charged to Profit and Loss Account. However, if such loss is too heavy an amount, it can be treated as deferred revenue.
Let us take another case. An old machine which originally cost Rs. 90,000 is sold for Rs. 1,00,000 and replaced by a new machine costing Rs. 2.00,000. The book value of the old machine is Rs. 60,000. In this case, there is a profit of Rs. 40,000 (sale value Rs. 1,00,000book value Rs. 60,000). Will the whole amount of Rs. 40,000 be treated as revenue profit? No, the revenue profit in this case is only Rs. 30,000. Whatever amount is realised over and above the original cost is, as per rules, a capital profit. Thus we can say that (a) Rs. 2,00,000, being the cost of the new machine is a capital expenditure, (b) Rs. 30,000 is a revenue profit, and (c) Rs.10,000 is a capital profit.
Structural Alterations Sometimes, a few alterations are made to a building involving heavy expenditure. To decide whether it is a capital expenditure or a revenue expenditure, we have to find out the nature and purpose of the alteration made. For instance, where structural alterations are made to a building just to satisfy the local by-laws (e.g., additional emergency exits in a cinema hall) and they do not in any way add to the revenue earning capacity of that building, the expenditure involved is treated as a revenue expenditure. Similarly, where alterations are made to an existing fixed asset so as to put it in proper condition (e.g., reinforcement of roofing to prevent leakage of rain water), the cost incurred should be treated as revenue expenditure. But where alterations are made on a building with a view to get more rent, such cost can be capitalised. For example, if a cinema hall or a restaurant is renovated whereby it becomes more attractive resulting in m r e customers, the expenditure involved will be
'
Sometimes, repairs to a machine or a building may not be of a routine type and the amount involved is heavy. In that case it may be treated as a deferred revenue item and thus written off over a period of twoto three years. Cost of Shifting to New Premises Sometimes, the factory may be shifted to a more convenient location. This will involve dismantling the plant and machinery moving them to the new premises and re-erecting them. The expenditure so incurred does not result in the acquisition of any new asset and as such should be treated as revenue expenditure. But in view of the fact that the expenditure is of an unusual nature and the amount involved is heavy, it can be capitalised and thus treated as deferred revenue expenditure. Illustration 2 Would you treat the following as a capital or a revenue expenditure? State your reasons in each case. i) Rs. 7,500 spent on dismantling, moving and re-installing plant, machinery and fixturis. ii) Rs. 800 spent on removal of stock from old factory. iii) Some major alterations were made to a theatre at a cost of Rs. 3,00,000 which made it more comfortable and attractive. iv) Rs. 20,000 spent by a 1arge.factory in overhauling its plant which resulted in adding three years to its working life. v)
'
For the purpose of constructing a factdry building, some sheds costing Rs. 30,000 were built at site for the labour. They were demolished after completion of the construction work.
vi) An old machine, which stood in the books at Rs. 2,800 was found obsolete and hence sold for Rs. 800. A new machine was purchased at a cost of Rs. 10,000. Rs. 1,000 was spent on transportation and Rs. 800 on installation. vii) Rs. 8,000 was spent on experimenting a new product which was not successful. viii) Rs. 2,00.000 incurred in developing a new area for tea plantations. Solution i) Normally, expenses on transportation, etc. are revenue in nature. In view of the fact that expenditure incurred on shifting is of a non-recurring nature and involves a heavy amount, it can be treated as a deferred revenue expenditure.
ii)
I
I
Although expenses on transportation are treated as revenue, but this expenditure relates to shifting of stock to new premises. So it will be treated in the same way as item (a).
iii) As the amount spent on alterations made the theatre more comfortable and attractive, it is likely to result in increased collections. Hence, it shall be treated as a capital expenditure.
iv) The amount spent on overhauling the plant has increased the life of the asset. Hence, it will be treated as capital expenditure.
i
I
1
t
v)
Construction of temporary sheds for labour is necessary for the construction of the factory building and as such forms part of the cost of building. It shall be treated as capital expenditure.
vi) The loss of Rs. 2,000 (2,800 - 800) incurred on the sale of old machine shall be treated as a revenue loss. The cost of new machine, including transportation and installation costs, amounting to Rs. 1 1,800 shall be treated as a capital expenditure. vii) If the experiment was successful it could be treated as capital expenditure. Since it was not suc&ssful, the amount spent should be treated as deferred revenue expenditure. viii) It is a capital expenditure because it is incurred for the development of land for tea plantations.
I I
It is important to distinguish between capital and revenue because wrong classification of items leads to an incorrect ascertainment of profit and financial position of the business.
Flnal Accounts -1
When the benefit of an expenditure is available for a numberof years, such expenditure is treated as capital expenditure. When the benefit is limited to one year, such expenditure is treated as revenue expenditure. Sometimes, a revenue expenditure may involve an unusually large amount and its benefit may extend to future accounting years. Such expenditure is treated as a deferred revenue expenditure. Capital receipts are those receipts which either increase the liabilities of the business or represent sale proceeds of fixed assets. ~ e v e n u receipts, on the other hand, are those e receipts which are received in the ordinary course of business. Profits which are not earned in the regular course of business are capital profits while revenue profits represent the profits earned during the normal course of business. Losses that arise during the regular course of business are treated as revenue losses, while those which do not arise in the normal course of business are treated as capital losses.
13.11 ANSWERS TO CHECK YOUR PROGRESS A1 i) Profit or Loss, ii) Profit and Loss Account, iii) Overstatement, iv) Capital, V ) Deferred Revenue, vi) Capital.
2 i) False ii) True iii) False iv) False v) True vi) True vii) False viii) False.
I i) True ii) False iii) False iv) True v) False vi) True vii) False viii) True. 3
1
2
'
3 4
Exercises 1 State with reasons whether the following expenditures are of capital or revenue nature. a)
A second hand machine was bought for Rs. 10,000 and Rs. 400 was spent on its carriage and installation.
b) Rs. 800 spent as carriage on goods purchased. C) Rs. 2,000 spent on repairs to machinery. d) Rs. 20,000 spent for constructing an additional hall. e) Rs. 15,000 was spent for air-conditioning the office of the General Manager.
f)
A second hand truck was purchased for Rs. 30,000 and Rs. 10,000 was spent on overhauling and converting it into a delivery van.
Answers: (a), (d), (e) and (f) are capital expenditures; (b) and (c) are revenue expenditures.
State whether the following expenditures are capital or revenue. a) Legal expenses incurred in raising additional capital by way of shares and debentures. b) Brokerage paid in connection with the purchase of land. Taxes and insurance paid on factory premises. C) d) Expenditure in development of land for rubber plantations, e)
f)
Rs. 50,000 spent on an advertising campaign for a new product. Wages paid to own workers for manufacturing loose tools for use in the factory.
Answers: (a), (b), (d) and (f) are capital expenditures; (c) revenue expenditure; and (e) deferred revenue expenditure. 3 Explain how would you deal with the following: a) A sum of Rs. 25,000 was spent in overhauling the machinery. It increased the machine life by 5 years. b) Rs. 2,000 was paid to an architect for drawing up the plans for the proposed building. c) A sum of Rs. 800 was spent as legal charges for recovering dues from debtors. d) Rs. 15,000 was spent on putting up a wooden partition in the existing building. It resulted in enhancing the rents realisable. e) Rs. 500 was spent on shifting the office to new premises.
f)
Old furniture was sold for Rs. 500. Its book value is Rs. 1,500. New furniture costing Rs. 3,000 was bought for replacement.
Answers: (a), (b) and (d) are capital expenditures, (c) is revenue expenditure, (e) is deferred revenue expenditure, (f) Rs. 3,000 being cost of new furniture is a capital expenditure and Rs. 1,000 is a revenue loss.
Note: These questions and exercises will help you to understand the unit better. Try to write answers for them. But do not send your answers to the university for evaluation. These are for your practice only.