European Lamp Companies Federation, The European Lamp Industry's Strategy For Domestic Lighting
European Lamp Companies Federation, The European Lamp Industry's Strategy For Domestic Lighting
European Lamp Companies Federation, The European Lamp Industry's Strategy For Domestic Lighting
Background
On 1 March 2007, the European Lamp Companies Federation (ELC) announced the first-ever joint industry commitment to support a government shift to more efficient lighting products for the home. Shortly after, under the German Presidency, on 9 March 2007, EU Heads of State called for the European Commission to rapidly submit proposals to enable increased energy efficiency requirements for incandescent lamps and other forms of lighting in private households by 2009. Proposals will take the form of Implementing Measures under the European Unions EUP Directive. On 5 June 2007, the GE, Havells Sylvania, OSRAM, Philips and other members of the ELC announced their detailed proposals to the European Commission for binding minimum energy efficiency requirements for domestic lighting. These proposals, if adopted by the European Union, would lead to the phase-out of the least efficient lamps in the home from the European market by 2015. For more information on the proposals see The ELCs proposal for domestic lighting, available to download on: www.elcfed.org Following discussions with the media, end consumers and European and national policy makers, this paper attempts to answer a number of frequently asked questions on the issue of domestic lighting. This list is of course not exhaustive, if you have any further questions or issues you would like to raise, please contact: [email protected]
elc federation - Created in 1985, the European Lamp Companies Federation (ELC) is both the forum and the voice of the lamp industry in Europe. It represents the leading European lamp manufacturers, which collectively directly employ 50,000 people, and account for 95 percent of total European production, with an annual turnover in Europe of 5 billion. From the outset, ELC objectives have been to promote efficient lighting practice for a sustainable environment and the advancement of human comfort, health and safety. To this end, ELC monitors, advises and co-operates with legislative bodies in developing European Directives and Regulations relevant to the European lamp industry.
For the lamp industry, the switch to energy efficient lighting has always been seen as an evolution and not a revolution. The ELC and its member companies have promoted energy efficient CFLis (Compact Fluorescent Lamps with an Integrated ballast or commonly known as energy savers) for more than 25 years. In addition the ELC works closely with the Commission to help advance proposals for minimum energy efficiency requirements for lamps under the EUs Directive on the eco-design of energy using products (EuP). In line with the Commissions first priorities for EuP Implementing Measures, the ELC has concentrated its efforts on street and office lamps first. These are the products with the biggest potential savings in the short term and it is easier to identify and influence the purchasers. The ELC fully supports the call from EU Heads of States to adopt minimum energy performance standards for street and office lighting under the EUP Directive by 2008. Work on lighting in the home is much more complex for a number of reasons including the size of the market concerned; the availability of practical replacements for some specialist lamps; poor market surveillance; the difficulty of changing the habits of domestic purchasers; and also production capacities. Requirements for domestic lighting must therefore be realistic in terms of timings for industry, the supply chain and consumers.
Equally, the ELC supports the Commissions timescale of 2009 for setting energy performance requirements for energy inefficient lamps in the home under the EUP Directive. We have committed to work with the European Commission, who commenced its own study for an Implementing Measure on domestic lighting in the home in June 2007, to develop ambitious minimum energy performance requirements for domestic lighting. We have proposed a time-phased approach to the European Commission, starting with highest wattage lamps and gradually covering lower wattages. This ensures the availability of practical energy saving alternatives in all domestic applications and is realistic for the businesses that must adapt to significant changes in production and supply. It would therefore deliver huge environmental and energy saving benefits while safeguarding the interests of consumers, employees and Europes lighting supply chain.
The 8-year phase-out proposal is designed to ensure that supply of efficient cost-effective products can satisfy demand, development and innovation. We have a responsibility to ensure that consumers are not faced with empty shelves.
The ELC proposal does not affect all domestic lamps. The initiative calls on the EU to apply binding minimum energy efficiency requirements, supported by strict market surveillance, for Edison and Bayonet cap lamps1 as early as 2009. These lamps are mostly incandescent.
The ELCs domestic lighting proposal has a number of phases, starting with highest wattage Edison and Bayonet cap lamps (>100W) and gradually covering lower wattages (25W). For each phase, there would be minimum efficiency specifications based on an energy efficiency classification and on luminous efficacy or lumens per watt. For each wattage category, manufacturers are calling for requirements to become more stringent over time. All lamps that do not carry the EU Energy Label are not in the scope of this proposal. Proposals to tackle reflector lamps, which make up 15% of the incandescent lamp market, are being also prepared. To ensure continued quality and cost effectiveness for Europes consumers, all lamps placed on the EU market should also have to have a minimum lifetime of 1000 hrs and comply with relevant IEC and CEN standards.
Your proposal targets 25W lamps and above only. What about those lamps under this wattage?
The majority of the lamps under 25W are classed by our member companies as either specialty lamps or lamps that have a limited environmental impact.
The majority of the lamps under 25W are classed by our member companies as either specialty lamps or lamps that have a limited environmental impact. These lamps have a lower environmental impact due to their power (lower energy consumption), frequency of use (mainly colored lamps, lamps in fridges, ovens and decorative lighting) and their market size (currently they represent 3% of the market). Furthermore, cost-effective, energy efficient alternatives for many of these lamps are not yet available on the market. We are currently working on scenarios and proposals for this category.
1 What is a Bayonet cap? With its familiar push and twist action, bayonet cap (also known as BC or B22d) is used on most regular light lamps, mainly in Great Britain and France. It is 22mm diameter and with two locating lugs. The small bayonet cap (SBC or B15d) is very similar but only 15mm across. Although generally used for mains voltage lamps, the SBC fitting can also be found in a very small number of specialist low voltage halogen lamps. There are also many other BC variants including the 3-pin BC, B22d-3 sometimes used on Fireglow lamps but perhaps more commonly on High pressure mercury lamps for industrial applications. The BY22d is used on some low-pressure sodium (SOX) lamps. What is an edison cap? Named after the pioneering inventor Thomas Edison, the Edison Screw or ES lamp fitting is used worldwide in a vast range of applications. The most popular ES or E27 fitting is 27mm diameter and is widely used in Europe. The US has a slightly smaller lamp cap type E26. The Small Edison Screw (SES or E14) is often used for smaller decorative fittings, chandeliers, and appliance lamps predominantly in the UK and Europe. The Candelabra Edison Screw (CES or E12) is most frequently used in the US and Canada, especially for candle lamps. The Miniature Edison Screw (MES or E10) fitting is sometimes used in large chandeliers containing perhaps dozens of small lamps.
What percentage of lamps on the European market is energy efficient and what percentage is inefficient?
One third (33%) of all lamps currently installed in the European Union are energy efficient. Two thirds (66%) of all lamps currently installed in the European Union are energy inefficient.
Yes, the setting of minimum energy performance standards is something that is generally considered important. Several governments worldwide have also recently announced plans to put legislation in place to eliminate the least efficient domestic lamps, including energy inefficient incandescent lamps, from the market over time. However, geographic and cultural differences have to be taken into account. Therefore the ELC is working closely with its international colleagues in America, China, Australia and Japan, to exchange best practice and learning, particularly on how to support and inform consumers.
10 Do you agree with recent calls from the governments of California and
Australia to phase-out ALL incandescent lamps?
The governments of California and Australia have not called for the phase-out of all incandescent lamps. Like the EU, they will be working on developing energy efficiency standards for lamps. It is clear that the consequence of setting strict minimum energy efficient standards for lamps under legislation like the EUs Eco-Design of Energy Using Products Directive (EuP) will lead to the phase out of the least efficient lamps from the market place. The ELC supports the efforts by its global colleagues to develop energy efficiency standards for lighting but one should be realistic in terms of timings for industry, the supply chain and consumers.
17 Which CFLi lamp should I buy to replace a 60-, 75-, 100- or 150-watt
regular lamp?
The ranges below provide wattage equivalents (that produce the same amount of light) for regular incandescent and CFLi lamps. 25 watt incandescent lamp 40 watt incandescent lamp 60 watt incandescent lamp 75 watt incandescent lamp 100 watt incandescent lamp > 100 watt incandescent lamp = = = = = = 5-7W CFLi 7-9W CFLi 11-15W CFLi 15-18W CFLi 20-23W CFLi 23W CFLi and above
Along side this range of CFLi lamps there is also a range of energy saving Halogen lamps available. These lamps provide high quality, brilliant light. Additional ranges are currently in development.
from reputable manufacturers render a light quality which approaches very closely that of incandescent lamps.
Rendering Index (CRI) expresses the level to which colours are represented in its natural form i.e. as if lit by sunlight, where an incandescent lamp has a CRI of 100, good quality energy savers typically have a CRI value between 80-85. The CRI of 80-85 is appropriate for most domestic applications and is similar to the quality of light used in shop display lighting.
The latest generations of cflis offered by the major manufacturers are no longer very large.
25 CFLis flicker with a stroboscopic effect. Ive heard they switch on and off
50 times per second. Do they cause medical problems such as epileptictype fits, mental disturbances?
CFLis give a constant, flicker free, non-stroboscopic light. They operate at high frequency through their electronic controller at between 30,000-50,000 hertz (normal mains voltage cycles at just 50 hertz or cycles per second). A small number of cases have been reported by people who suffer from reactions to certain types of linear fluorescent lamps. In the majority of these cases, the lamps in question were used in offices, restaurants (in certain European countries) and in limited places in domestic households (such as kitchens and garages)
and were almost certainly triggered by OLD technology which operated on a conventional (Copper-Iron) ballasts with a low frequency (<50Hz mains frequency); this is not the case with new energy efficient linear fluorescent lamp technology which unlike earlier energy efficiency technologies, operates on high frequency drivers (for example, certain fluorescent lamps operate on 50kHz or 50,000Hz). The above health related problems can be therefore avoided if consumers opt for new technologies such as integrated energy savers (CFLi) in households and other sources using high frequency drivers (e.g. linear fluorescents and HID) in other applications (such as offices, restaurants etc).
26 Is there any danger that the light intensity of energy saving lamps
would damage my retina?
Energy saving lamps do not present any risk to the retina. Studies have examined the effect of lights on the retina and concluded that looking at energy saving lamps does not damage the eye. The eye naturally protects itself from excessive light and a natural aversion mechanism prevents it from being exposed to light that is too intense. Sometimes, eyes can be particularly sensitive to blue light, which is present in many energy saving lamps. It is then recommended that people with this sensitivity use yellow filters to soften the light colour. Today, many energy saving lamps are available in soft colours, which are more comfortable for the eye. The light exposure resulting from a fluorescent light source for general lighting is less than the typical exposure experienced outdoors.
27 What about those who suffer from light sensitivity or Lupus sufferers,
for whom a ban on normal incandescent lighting would result in a total disruption of normal everyday life?
People affected from light sensitivity or lupus sufferers (a chronic autoimmune disease of which sensitivity to ultraviolet light is a key symptom) could be affected by either the intensity of the light (i.e. the lumens of the lamp), the spectral property of the light (particularly when the light contains more blue) or when a lamp radiates a small amount of ultra-violet (UV) light. There is a small amount of UV generated by fluorescent lights (such as CFLis). But this is fractional if you compare this to natural daylight. For the many energy savings lamps (such as CFLis) that do generate higher quantities of UV and blue light, filters are now used to reduce radiation. LED lamps can emit a range of colors (green, red and blue) and can emit white light by combining red, blue and green LEDs or a LED with a phosphor similar to the ones used in general tips for people who are sensitive to light
If you suffer from a special light sensitivity do not expose yourself directly to the light source. Use indirect light via a white surface, as, in many cases, during reflection UV-radiation will be absorbed (depending of course of the type of surface and material/paint used). Special covers can be used to fully filter the last bits of harmful radiation from the lamps. For example, Plexiglas or special glass UV filters will filter most of the UV light. Use yellow filters to filter the blue light. When filters are no option, mains voltage halogen lamps are an acceptable alternative. Due to the UVfiltering quartz of the burner, these lamps have UV output levels that are similar to incandescent lamps. Reduce the dose (time of exposure, quantity) of light by dimming the lights when possible. Use light sources with a warm color tone (low correlated color temperature); they contain the lowest quantity of blue light.
fluorescent lamps. The whiter the lamp is, the more blue (and possible UV) is radiated. Negative reactions to LEDs therefore are probably due to the use of LED lamps with a very white color tone, thus containing a lot of blue. It is important to note that LED technology is still in the very early stages of development, and as such there is a strong possibility that lamps will be made with a certain spectral composition in the future, hence alleviating some of these initial problems.
DISPOSING OF CFLis
cflis are safe to use in your home. no mercury is released when the lamps are in use and they pose no danger to you or your family when used properly.
33 What do I do with a CFLi when it burns out? What is the proper disposal
procedure?
In Europe, all CFLi lamps have to be disposed as special waste under EWC Code 20 01 21-Fluorescent tubes and other mercury-containing waste. Furthermore, as part of its obligations under the EUs WEEE Directive3, the European lighting industry has set up a European-wide recycling infrastructure for all gas discharge lamps (including CFLis), capable of recycling mercury, as well as other metals, glass, etc. All CFLi lamps are provided with the crossed-out wheeled dustbin logo, indicating that consumers should deposit the product separately, making use of the existing, local waste depots.
2 RoHS is the acronym used to refer to the European Union (EU) Directive 2002/95/EC on the Restriction of the use of certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment. 3 Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Directive 2002/96/EC
For more information about the WEEE directive and to contact your national ELC member partner see http:// www.elcfed.org/2_health_environment.html#weee
disposing of cflis
Follow these guidelines to dispose your CFLi properly: Like paint, batteries, thermostats, and other hazardous household items, CFLis should be disposed of properly. Do not throw CFLis away in your household garbage if better disposal options exist. If your local waste management agency offers no other disposal options except your household garbage, place the CFLi in a plastic bag and seal it before putting it in the trash. If your waste agency incinerates its garbage, you should search a wider geographic area for proper disposal options such as your local tip. Never send a CFLi or other mercury containing product to an incinerator.
safety, including the Low Voltage Directive (LVD)5 and Electromagnetic Compatibility equipment directive (EMC)6. This legislation covers design, manufacture, and how the lamps are marketed. Energy saving fluorescent lamps or their lamp packaging have carried a CE-Mark since January 1998. The general product safety directive (GPSD) 2001/95/EC guarantees that lamps available in the EU are safe for consumers to use. The onus is on manufacturers to ensure that their products meet the general safety requirement. In addition, they must provide consumers with all necessary information about their products. They must also take any necessary measures to avoid threats (e.g. withdrawal of their products from the market). The Lamp Industry also supported the creation of ICSMS (www.icsms.org), the internet-based Information and Communication System for cross-border Market Surveillance. This database ensures that information is exchanged and relevant authorities carry out joint operations in market surveillance. The eu directive on the protection of workers from risks associated with physical agents7 artificial optical radiation focuses on exposure to artificial light. The Directive sets limits for the exposure of workers to UV. The limits are based on the recommendations of independent experts at the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP). Based on these limits, a standard for lamps and lamp systems has been formalized, IEC 62471(2006). Lamps from ELC Member Companies comply with this standard.
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS
committed to, and responsible for, ensuring that high quality and safety standards of their products are met. Energy saving lamps are safe.
CONTACT US
Secretary-General ELC Federation asbl/vzw Diamant Building Boulevard Reyers 80 B-1030 Brussels, Belgium [email protected] T: +32 (0)2 706 86 08 F: +32 (0)2 706 86 09 www.elcfed.org
Our members:
Aura Light AB www.auralightgroup.com BLV Licht- und Vakuumtechnik GmbH www.blv-licht.de G.E. Lighting Europe Ltd www.gelighting.com NARVA Lichtquellen GmbH www.narva-bel.de OSRAM GmbH www.osram.com Philips Lighting BV www.lighting.philips.com Havells Sylvania www.havells-sylvania.com
08/06