Assessment Tool Matrix-Final Final-Draft KD
Assessment Tool Matrix-Final Final-Draft KD
Company Name, Address, Phone URL Commercial Product name(s) Product Description Free
Valve Types Relief=R Bypass=B Re-Circ=RC Throttle=T The FIRSTVUE Valve Sizing Program identifies control valve package best suited to each set of service conditions. Use FIRSTVUE's powerful valve selection features to specify either a single control valve or hundreds with minimal effort. As a bonus, FIRSTVUE offers Export/Import capabilities for taking advantage of plant engineering, design and maintenance programs such as Intergraph Corporation's INtools and Instrument Data Manager (IDM). FIRSTVUE also allows the Export and Import of data from most other data management systems via Comma Delimited Text Files and a simple mapping function. Variable Fluid Properties
Yes
Fluid Properties
Optimum Pumping System Transient Modeling Operating Point Support (New System)
Water Hammer
Valve Analysis
www.aft.com
AFT Fathom
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Flow of Fluids 4529 Intelco Loop SE Lacey, WA 98503 Tel: (360) 292-4070
www.flowoffluids.com
Flow of Fluids
No
69 Pipe Tables and valves & fittings table Yes, a table of 250 Yes, Energy Costs, fluids is included or supplied / Custom Fixed Speed vs. tables can easily be create a custom fluid VFD, and Lifecycle table for any made / All Network Cost Newtonian fluid configurations supported
Yes
No
No
25 pipe segments
No
Yes. Flow Control Valves, Pressure Yes, 90+ pump manufacturers digital Reducing Valves, catalogs are freely and Back Pressure Valves. Determines available for both valve position download and choked flow
www.eng-software.com
PIPE-FLO Professional
No
69 Pipe Tables and valves & fittings table Yes, a table of 750 Yes, Energy Costs, fluids is included or supplied / Custom Fixed Speed vs. tables can easily be create a custom fluid VFD, and Lifecycle table for any made / All Network Cost Newtonian fluid configurations supported
YES
NO
No
Yes. Flow Control Valves, Pressure Yes, 90+ pump manufacturers digital Reducing Valves, catalogs are freely and Back Pressure Valves. Determines available for both valve position download and choked flow
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes
Performance Curve
System Curve
Fluid Properties
Motor Data
Multi-Pump Operation
www.aft.com
AFT Fathom
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Department of Energy Industrial Technologies Program (ITP) www.eere.energy.gov/industry Room 5F-065, MS EE-2F Under best practices tools 1000 Independence Ave, SW Washington, DC 20585" 800-342-5363
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
www.eng-software.com
PIPE-FLO
No
Yes
Yes
Yes, a table of 750 Yes, Energy Costs, fluids is included or Fixed Speed vs. create a custom fluid VFD, and Lifecycle table for any Cost Newtonian fluid
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes, 90+ pump manufacturers digital catalogs are freely available for download
www.pump-flo.com
PUMP-FLO
PUMP-FLO, the Web-based version, is a free source for pump selection on the Internet, offering over 75 pump manufacturers catalogs on-line. Make a pump assessment by using the Total Head Calculator to determine your system requirements, then enter your search criteria. From the list of pumps that match your search, view a detailed, dynamic pump curve and all the manufacturers design Yes -PUMPnotes before requesting a quote, all from the FLO.com same Internet portal.A desktop version of No - PUMPPUMP-FLO is also available for purchase. It FLODesktop includes access to over 90 pump manufacturers' catalogs, provides the same Total Head Calculator to analyze your pump's requirements and dynamic pump curve with manufacturers' design notes. In addition, the desktop version includes a cost calculator to determine Energy Cost, Fixed Speed vs. VFD operational cost, and Life Cycle Costs. There is a free 21-day download available
PUMP-FLO Desktop is a desktop application which provides an easy user interface for making your pump selection assessment. Size your pump using the Total Head Calculator tool, search from a database of 90+ pump manufacturer's catalogs and make a pump assessment using the dynamic pump curves and additional manufacturers' documentation all supplied within the digital catalog. A cost calculator is included to determine Energy Cost, Fixed Speed vs. VFD operation, and Life Cycle Costs.
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
www.pump-flo.com
PUMP-FLO Desktop
No
Yes
Yes
Yes, a table of 125 Yes, Energy Costs, fluids is included or Fixed Speed vs. create a custom fluid VFD, and Lifecycle for any Newtonian Cost fluid
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes, 90+ pump manufacturers digital catalogs are freely available for download
Flow of Fluids 4529 Intelco Loop SE Lacey, WA 98503 Tel: (360) 292-4070
www.flowoffluids.com
Flow of Fluids
Flow of Fluids Premium simulates the operation of small piping systems transporting liquids and can handle compressible systems (given certain limitations) under a variety of expected operating conditions. It provides accurate and fast results for series, branching, and looped systems (both open and closed) with up to 25 pipelines. Flow of Fluids comes with an extensive set of pipe tables, valve & fittings, a fluid database containing 250 fluids, as well as access to 90+ pump manufacturer's electronic catalogs to ensure you select the correct pump for your system. It's easy to understand user interface and extensive tutorials gets you creating professional looking analysis reports and P&ID looking schematics in no time.
No
Yes
Yes
Yes, a table of 250 Yes, Energy Costs, fluids is included or Fixed Speed vs. create a custom fluid VFD, and Lifecycle table for any Cost Newtonian fluid
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes, 90+ pump manufacturers digital catalogs are freely available for download
www.intelliquip.com
Intelliquip Selector
The Intelliquip Selector is designed to deliver equipment selections optimized to meet or exceed those achieved by your most experienced product application engineers, while accurately producing customized datasheets, predicted performance criteria, and product options that may be certified for manufacture.
Commercially Available
Yes
Yes
Yes, full Hydraulic Institute and Europump life cycle cost calculator included. Automatically prepopulated with selected pump's Yes, pump characteristics. manufacturer specific Allows full comparison of fixed speed versus variable speed energy costs and multi-speed curve generation
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Pump System Improvement Modeling Tool (PSIM) is a FREE educational tool focused on helping you better understand the hydraulic behavior of pumping systems. With the challenges of today's marketplace, your fluid handling systems must be both cost effective and energy efficient. It is essential that users evaluate the total pump system in their design. PSIM models systems with up to 12 pipe runs.
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Pumping Machinery LLC 2977 Four Oaks Drive, Atlanta, GA 30360 770-310-0866
Pump Performance Estimator is a quick, simple and effective tool to estimate a typical expected efficiency from a centrifugal pump, based on flow capacity, head and operating speed. The Performance Estimator is based on specific speed, Pump Performance Estimator not the actual pump performance curve. & Pump Energy Savings Pump Energy Savings Evaluation matrix is a Evaluator program to evaluate energy savings due to pump operating off-BEP point. Depending on a pump size, these energy savings could be significant, and would allow engineering to evaluate corrective measures to improve system performance QPCalc can be used for quickly calculating the pressure drop in a pipe segment. Valves, fitting and custom pressure drop devices can be included. You can use QPCalc to determine pressure drops in plant piping consisting of pipe segments, block valves, control valves, filters, strainers etc. All Kfactors and equivalent lengths of valves, fittings and custom devices are included in a built-in database. No more charts, graphs or nomograms to use! Various pressure drop formulas, such as ColebrookWhite, Moody, Hazen-Williams, MIT, Miller and T.R. Aude equation are included. QPCalc also calculates the horsepower required for a given flow rate.
PUMPCALC analyzes centrifugal pump performance for single and multiple pumps. Performs Viscosity Correction using Hydraulic Institute method. Predicts the performance of a centrifugal pump at different impeller diameter and speeds. Uses the affinity laws for centrifugal pumps. Models pumps in series and parallel configurations. Calculates the system head curves for a pipeline or uses system curve data input to determine the point of intersection of the combined pump curve and system head curve.
Yes
No
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
QPCalc
No
No
No
Yes
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
PUMPCALC
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
www.unicade.com
C-Max
The C-MAX software program is specifically developed for industrial and large commercial systems design, engineering, energy efficiency program analysis and life cycle cost evaluation. CMAX is designed for consulting engineers, design professionals, process engineers, plant engineers, and energy engineers
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
No
Vogel Software Vogel Software GMBH Hofmhlenstrae 4 D-01187 Dresden PH: +49/351/89951-0
The comprehensive business software solution for the pump industry. From the selection and configuration of the perfect fitting pump, via quote generation, up to workflow automation and sales analysis.
No
Motor Tools
Baldor/Dodge/Reliance 6040 Ponders Court Greenville, SC 29615 864-297-4800 www.baldor.com (under support; energy savings) This program compares the energy saving potential between motors and drives with various energy BE$T Baldor Energy Savings efficiency ratings then selects the "best choice" for overall savings. BE$T may also be used in Tool conjunction with a PDA to conduct a plant survey of motors. MotorMaster+ International includes many of the capabilities and features of MotorMaster+; however, now you can evaluate repair/replacement options on a broader range of motors, including those tested under the Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE) standard, and those tested using International Electrical Commission (IEC) methodology. With this tool you can conduct analyses in different currencies, calculate efficiency benefits for utility rate schedules with demand charges, edit and modify motor rewind efficiency loss defaults, and determine "best available" motors. The tool can be modified to operate in English, Spanish, and French Yes
Efficiency
Power Factor
Load Profiles
VFD Capability
Service Factor
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Department of Energy Industrial Technologies Program (ITP) Room 5F-065, MS EE-2F 1000 Independence Ave, SW Washington, DC 20585" 800-342-5363
MotorMaster+ International
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Efficiency
Power Factor
Load Profiles
www.tcotoolbox.com
Hydraulic Institute 9 Sylvan Way Parsippany, NJ 07054 973-267-9700 Europump: Daimant Building, 5th Fl. Boulevard A Reyers 80 B1030 Brussels, Belgium +32 2 706 82 30
www.pumps.org (Under energy savings;Life This downloadable spreadsheet in excel enables the Life Cycle Costing Calculator cycle cost executive summary) user to make life cycle cost calculations. www.europump.org
Yes
www.aft.com
AFT Mercury
AFT Mercury, powered by IntelliFlow, is the first software product to offer the piping systems engineer intelligent, automated sizing of system piping, ducting and components to achieve this goal. With comprehensive system modeling capabilities, a flexible graphical interface and an advanced optimization engine, AFT Mercury with IntelliFlow is nothing less than new technology that will allow you to effect significant cost savings on your piping systems
No
Barringer & Associates, Inc 8003 Pine Cup Humble, TX, 77346-1740
This downloadable spreadsheet in excel enables the user to make life cycle cost calculations. The spreadsheet will help you obtain the important metric called net present value (NPV).
Yes
Energy Efficiency
www.fluidsealing.com
Seal Life Cycle Cost Estimator sealing solutions on a comparative basis to assist in
decision-making when specifying capital projects or upgrading existing rotating equipment technology.
Yes
Yes
Other Tools
Getting Started & Cataloging
Basic Pump Systems Assessment Guide & Pump System Pre-screening Form
This guide is to outline the process of a basic pump system assessment. An assessment identifies a few pump systems that could be investigated further for cost-effective system improvements. It uses the Prescreening Form (excel spreadsheet) to catalogue all pump systems at the site so that additional systems can be reviewed later under different conditions (e.g., higher cost of energy, additional resources).
Yes
*** Many vendor websites have their own tools specific to their products. If you are working with a specific vendor, you may wish to review their website or