0% found this document useful (0 votes)
57 views16 pages

Pres 64 Leendertz

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1/ 16

5th International Symposium on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

INTERACTION EFFECT OF TRAFFIC LOADS AND BRIDGE DETAILS SUSCEPTIBLE TO FATIGUE


Centre of Public Works, The Netherlands
[email protected], [email protected]

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Fatigue interaction effects


Contents
1. Introduction 2. Principles Fatigue resistance Load effects Fatigue life calculations 3. Traffic loads Axle loads Lorry loads 4. Example 5. Conclusion
2

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

2.1 Fatigue resistance


10

Stress quotient

S-N line (steel)

Constant amplitude limit

Cut-off limit
0,1

1,00E+04

1,00E+05

1,00E+06

1,00E+07

1,00E+08

N (cycles to failure)

ni Di = Ni

D = ( D1 + D2 + D3 + .......Dn )

1,00E+09

Fatigue Classification

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

2.2 Load effects

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

2.3 Fatigue life calculations


Equivalent nr of cycles for 150 kN axles
neq ,a ,150 1 + n2 2 + n3 3 + n4 4 + ........ = n1 a ,150 a ,150 a ,150 a ,150
3 5 5 5 5 14 13 12 11 + ....etc. + n14 + n13 + n12 n11 D D D D 3 3 3 3

D + a ,150

Equivalent nr. neq of cycles for C, Cumulative damage of axles Da, Number of axles to failure Na

neq ,C

a ,150 = neq ,a ,150 C

Da =

neq ,C 2x106

2 x10 Na = neq ,C

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

3 Traffic loads

Exceedance probability axle loads Measurements at Moerdijk Bridge 1998, 2004 and filtered measurements 2004
6

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

3 Traffic loads ctd.

Exceedance probability Lorry loads Measurements at Moerdijk Bridge 1998, 2004 and filtered measurements 2004
7

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

3.1 Axle loads


Axle load (kN) 210 200 190 180 170 160 150 140 130 120 110 90 80 70 50 30 10 Weighted average EN 1991-2 FLM4 P/150 Fraction Moerdijk 1998 P/150 Fraction 1.400 0 1.267 1.133 1 0.933 0.867 0.800 0.600 0.533 0.467 0.121 0.036 0.072 0.024 0.458 0.048 0.241 1 0.867 0.067 0.600 0.467 0.333 0.200 0.067 73 kN 0.0001 0.0002 0.0002 0.016 0.067 0.136 0.339 0.379 0.272 0.059 1.25 x Moerdijk 1998 P/150 Fraction 1.75 0 1.584 1.416 1.25 1.083 0.917 0.750 0.583 0.417 0.250 0.083 91 kN 0.0001 0.0002 0.0002 0.016 0.067 0.136 0.339 0.379 0.272 0.059

97 kN

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Fatigue life (nr. of axles)

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Relation between fatigue life for Moerdijk 1998 and 1.25 Moerdijk 1998 (axles)

10

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Lorry loads and distributions


Silhouette FLM4 Fraction Equivalent load (kN) 0.20 200 0.05 310 390 450 Moerdijk P/490 Fraction Maximum load (kN) 0.41 0.17 190 0.63 0.03 265 0.06 370 0.80 0.08 390 0.05 465 0.92 0.03 470 0.03 535 0.03 290 0.12 370 1 0.35 460 0 365 0.01 445 0.04 535 386 kN Effective load (kN) 145 202 282 297 354 356 408 221 282 350 277 339 408 294 kN P/490 0.30 0.41 0.58 0.61 0.72 0.73 0.83 0.45 0.58 0.71 0.57 0.69 0.83

-- -- -- 0.15 ----- ----- ----- 0.10 ----- ---- ---- 0.50 ---- ---- ---- ---- Weighted average

490

447 kN

11

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Numbers of lorries until failure

12

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Relation between fatigue life of Moerdijk 1998 and 1.25 Moerdijk 1998 (lorries)

13

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

3.3 Conclusions traffic load increase


Locations with low stresses show a long fatigue life but are relatively highly susceptible to increase of traffic loads 1.25 x axle/lorry load fatigue life reduction to 0.02

Locations with higher stresses show a short fatigue life but are relatively less susceptible to increase of traffic loads 1.25 x axle load 1.25 x lorry load fatigue life reduction to 0.5 fatigue life reduction to 0.8

14

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

4 Example

Stress interval bottom flange = 60N/mm2 Detail class parent material 140 N/mm2 SQ = 0.3 (max veh. Load SQ 0.8): No fatigue 1.25 x SQ = 0.54: 8.7 x 108 Lorries Detail class attachment 75 N/mm2 SQ = 0.6: 1.25 x 108 Lorries or 100 years Moerdijk 1998 traffic 1.25 x SQ = 0.75: 3.6 x 107 Lorries or 29 years Moerdijk 1998 x 1.25 traffic
15

5th International Conference on Weigh-In-Motion HVParis 2008, May 19-22 2008

Fatigue interaction effects


5 Conclusion A moderate increase of loads can cause a severe reduction of the fatigue life 6 References
EN 1991-2, EC 1: Actions on structures Part 2 Traffic loads on bridges EN 1991-1-9, EC 3: Design of steel structures Part 1.9 Fatigue MoT NL, Final report axle load measurements Moerdijk 1998, IBR-98-47 TNO report General probabilistic considerations for reliability and modelling of traffic loads for road bridges, 98-CON-R1813
16

You might also like