0% found this document useful (0 votes)
77 views6 pages

Table ResultTestEvaluasiToolsKompresi

The document compares the performance of different file compression programs (7z, Izarc, Kgb, Alzip, etc.) in compressing different types of files (database, web folders, PDFs, images, etc.). It provides the original and compressed file sizes for each file type and compression program. Overall, the document finds that Winrar generally performs best with very high compression ratios, followed by 7z and Izarc, while WinAce and PowerArchiver show weaker performance.

Uploaded by

api-3809373
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
77 views6 pages

Table ResultTestEvaluasiToolsKompresi

The document compares the performance of different file compression programs (7z, Izarc, Kgb, Alzip, etc.) in compressing different types of files (database, web folders, PDFs, images, etc.). It provides the original and compressed file sizes for each file type and compression program. Overall, the document finds that Winrar generally performs best with very high compression ratios, followed by 7z and Izarc, while WinAce and PowerArchiver show weaker performance.

Uploaded by

api-3809373
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 6

TABLE COMPRESSING FILE TEST

Best File Test Report

Produk File Format


7z Database file (84.8 Kb) [13]
Website file folder (1.72 Mb) [13]
Pdf file format (68.1 Mb) [13]
Jpeg file format (4.86 Mb) [13]
Bmp file format (84.1 Kb [13]
Power point file format (468 Kb) [13]
Document file (216 Kb) [13]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1], & [6]
Izarc Database file (50.2 Kb)[7]
Website file folder (1.75Mb)[13]
Pdf file format (68.6 Mb)[4]
Jpeg file format (4.92 Mb) [5]
Bmp file format (84.1 Kb [13]
Power point file format (467 Kb) [13]
Document file (216 Kb) [13]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1], [6], & [9]
Kgb Database file (158 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (2.36Mb)[10]
Pdf file format (68.7 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (3.99 Mb) [10]
Bmp file format (69.2 Kb [10]
Power point file format (443 Kb) [10]
Document file (171 Kb) [10]
Execute file (9.54 Mb) [10]
Alzip Database file (129 Kb)[7]
Website file folder (2.61Mb)[8]
Pdf file format (68.6 Mb)[12]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [all archive format]
Bmp file format (94.5 Kb [8]
Power point file format (593 Kb) [8]
Document file (228 Kb) [8] & [9]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1], [6], [9], & [12]
Free Zip Database file (181 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.55Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.6 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1]
Bmp file format (101 Kb [1]
Power point file format (627 Kb) [1]
Document file (229 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.56 Mb) [1]
Winrar Database file (105 Kb)[2]
Website file folder (1.88Mb)[2]
Pdf file format (68.4 Mb)[2]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1&2]
Bmp file format (88 Kb [2]
Power point file format (505 Kb) [2]
Document file (228 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1]
Winzip Database file (126 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.08Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.1 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1]
Bmp file format (78.5 Kb [1]
Power point file format (528 Kb) [1]
Document file (220 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.74 Mb) [1]
Win Ace Database file (117 Kb)[11]
Website file folder (85 Bytes)[6]
Pdf file format (34.5 Mb)[3]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [3]
Bmp file format (90.5 Kb [8]
Power point file format (506 Kb) [11]
Document file (240 Kb) [3]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1], [6], & [9]
Power Archiver Database file (93.3 Kb)[13]
Website file folder (1.74Mb)[13]
Pdf file format (8.43 Mb)[3]
Jpeg file format (4.86 Mb) [13]
Produk File Format
Bmp file format (78.8 Kb [13]
Power point file format (513 Kb) [4]
Document file (248 Kb) [5]
Execute file (9.54 Mb) [8]

Worst File Test Report

Produk File Format


7z Database file (153 Kb) [1]
Website file folder (3.36 Mb) [1]
Pdf file format (68.5 Mb) [1], [4], [6], & [13]
Jpeg file format (4.97Mb) [13]
Bmp file format (89.1 Kb [1]
Power point file format (592 Kb) [1]
Document file(238 Kb) [1] & [13]
Execute file (9.72 Mb) [13]
Izarc Database file (158 Kb) [1] & [9]
Website file folder (3.33Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.7 Mb) [1], [3], [7], & [9]
Jpeg file format (4.98 Mb) [1], & [9]
Bmp file format (95.4 Kb) [1] & [9]
Power point file format (602 Kb) [3]
Document file (238 Kb) [5]
Execute file (9.66 Mb) [13]
Kgb Database file (281 Kb)[10]
Website file folder (3.30Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.7 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (4.98 Mb) [1]
Bmp file format (95.4 Kb [1]
Power point file format (595 Kb) [1]
Document file(228 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.55 Mb) [1]
Alzip Database file (154 Kb) [1], [9], & [12]
Website file folder (3.27 Mb) [1] & [9]
Pdf file format (68.7 Mb)[3]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb)
Bmp file format (100 Kb) [12]
Power point file format (679 Kb) [12]
Document file(240 Kb) [14]
Execute file (18.5 Mb) [3]
Free Zip Database file (181 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.55Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.6 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1]
Bmp file format (101 Kb [1]
Power point file format (627 Kb) [1]
Document file(229 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.56 Mb) [1]
Winrar Database file (158 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.33 Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.6 Mb) [1]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1&2]
Bmp file format (94.8 Kb) [1]
Power point file format (592 Kb) [1]
Document file(228 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.56 Mb) [2]
Winzip Database file (126 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.08Mb)[1]
Pdf file format (68.1 Mb)[1]
Jpeg file format (4.97 Mb) [1]
Bmp file format (78.5 Kb [1]
Power point file format (528 Kb) [1]
Document file(220 Kb) [1]
Execute file (9.74 Mb) [1]
Produk File Format
Win Ace Database file (158 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.31 Mb) [1] & [9]
Pdf file format (68.7 Mb) [1], [6]
Jpeg file format (4.98 Mb) [1], [6], & [9]
Bmp file format (96.4 Kb [6]
Power point file format (506 Kb) [11]
Document file(240 Kb) [3]
Execute file (9.6 Mb) [11]
Power Archiver Database file (149 Kb)[1]
Website file folder (3.29 Mb) [1]
Pdf file format (68.7Mb) [6], & [14]
Jpeg file format (4.86 Mb) [6] & [14]
Bmp file format (96.4 Kb) [6]
Power point file format (631 Kb) [7]
Document file (248 Kb) [4]
Execute file (9.70 Mb) [13]
Ket : [1] zip(deflate&deflate64), [2] Rar, [3] Lzh/Lha, [4] Bzip2, [5] Bziptar, [6] Gzip, [7] GzipTar
[8] Cab, [9] Jar, [10] Kgb, [11] Ace, [12] Alz, [13] 7z(PPMD,Lzma), [14] Bh.
DB : File database, Web : web file

Produk Winzip v 11 Winrar v 3.30


Http:\\www. winzip.com rarlab.com
Harga (sekitar) Shareware Shareware
Kinerja Baik Sangat Baik
Nilai total (70.66) B (76.43) A
Fungsionalitas
➢ Kualitas File Baik Baik
➢ Rasio Kompresi Biasa Biasa
➢ Waktu Pemrosesan Relatif Cepat Relatif Cepat
➢ Ukuran Target File User Defined User Defined
➢ Jumlah File error 0 0

Ergonomi
➢ Struktur Kompresi Step by step & Wizard Step by step & Wizard
➢ Pengoperasiaan Mudah Mudah
➢ Interface Menarik Menarik
➢ Help-File Brief Tutorial (Inggris) Concole Rar Manual (Inggris)

Dukungan Format
➢ Archieve Format ➢ Only Zip ➢ Rar & Zip
➢ Support Format ➢ RAR, BZ2, BZ, TBZ, TBZ2, ➢ 7Z, ACE, ARJ, BZ2, CAB, GZ,
TAR, gzip, UUencode, ISO, JAR, LZH, TAR, UUE, Z
XXencode, BinHex, and MIME
➢ Compressing Level
➢ Methods Defined
➢ Compressing Methods ➢ Methods Defined
➢ Super Fast,Enhanced
➢ Store, Normal, Fast,
➢ Format Impor Deflate,Bzip2,PPMD
➢ Ya Fastest, Good,Best
Compressing ➢ Ya
➢ Format Ekspor
➢ Ya
Compressing ➢ Ya
Produk Winzip v 11 Winrar v 3.30
Perlengkapan
➢ Encrypt& Decrypt ➢ Ya / Tidak ➢ Tidak Keduanya
➢ Convert Archieve ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Spanned Archive ➢ Ya ➢ Ya
➢ Virus Scanning ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Pilihan Bahasa ➢ Tidak (Only Inggris) ➢ Tidak (Only Inggris)
➢ Check Archieve Test ➢ Ya ➢ Ya
➢ Repair Archieve ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Set Password ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Retrieve Password ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Create SFX ➢ Ya ➢ Ya
➢ Protect ArchieveFor ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
Damage
Kelebihan Interface menarik, Interface Menarik, Terdapat Wizard, Protect
Terdapat wizard,Encrypt,UUencode,Test File Archieve From Damage, Set Password,
archive feature, Burn Zip Archive Into Cd / Repair, Convert, Virus Scan
Dvd, SFX Feature feature,benchmark&hardware test,SFX
feature,lock archieve feature, etc
Kekurangan Tidak gratis,keterbatasan format archive(only Tidak gratis,keterbatasan format archive(only
zip format),tidak ada virus scan feature,tidak zip&rar),tidak ada encrypt&decrypt
ada Decrypt feature-nya, tidak ada fasilitas feature,pemilihan bahasa tidak ada,level
repair,pemilihan bahasa tidak ada,level kompresi hanya ditentukan oleh
kompresi hanya ditentukan oleh metodanya,ada set password feature tetapi
metodanya,tidak ada Protect ArchieveFor tidak ada Retrieve Password feature-nya
Damage

Alzip v7.0 beta 1 7-z File Manager v 4.57 IZARC v 3.7


advert.estsoft.com 7z.org Izarc.org
ESTsoft Igor Pavlov Eula
Shareware Freeware Freeware
Sangat Baik Istimewa Istimewa
77.1 (A) 92.5 (A +) 97.5 (A +)

➢ Baik ➢ Baik ➢ Baik


➢ Cukup Signifikan ➢ Signifikan ➢ Signifikan
➢ Relatif Cepat ➢ Relatif Cepat ➢ Relatif Cepat
➢ User Defined ➢ User Defined ➢ User Defined
➢ 0 ➢ 0 ➢ 0

➢ Step by step ➢ Step by step ➢ Step by step


➢ Mudah ➢ Mudah ➢ Mudah
➢ Menarik ➢ Menarik ➢ Menarik
➢ Ya (inggris) ➢ Ya (inggris) ➢ Ya (inggris)

➢ Alz,zip,lzh,cab,jar,tar,tgz,bh ➢ 7z, bzip2,gzip,tar,zip ➢ 7z, bzip2,gzip,tar,zip,ace,arc,etc


➢ Alz,alx,zip,7z,ace,arc,arj,b64,bh, ➢ 7z,bzip2,gzip,tar,zip,rar,cab,arj,z ➢ 7z,bzip2,gzip,tar,zip,rar,cab,arj,z
bin,bhx,bzip2,cab,ear,enc,gz, ,rpm,cpio,deb,lzh,split,chm,iso, ,rpm,cpio,deb,lzh,split,chm,iso,
dan lain-lain compound,dan lain-lain compound,etc
➢ Normal,fast,faster,none ➢ Store,fast,faster,normal,ultra ➢ Super fast,fast,,normal,maksimal
➢ Defined archive format ➢ Deflate64,PPMD,bzip2,LZMA ➢ Deflate64,PPMD,bzip2,LZMA,
➢ No ➢ No ➢ Ya
➢ No ➢ No ➢ Ya

➢ Tidak keduanya ➢ Ya / tidak ➢ Ya untuk keduanya


➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ 24 Bahasa asing ➢ Lebih dari 30 pilihan bahasa ➢ Lebih dari 30 pilihan bahasa
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
Alzip v7.0 beta 1 7-z File Manager v 4.57 IZARC v 3.7
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Ya ➢ Ya ➢ Tidak
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
Interface menarik,support virus Gratis,interface cukup menarik,relatif Gratis,interface menarik,relatif
scan,create SFX,banyak pilihan bahasa,set cepat,full compatible zip archieves,support cepat,support virus scan feature,banyak
password,retrieve lost new processor&operating system seperti format archieve yang di support ,convert
password,repair,multi volumes,etc core2duo&windows vista image,encrypt&decrypt
Tidak gratis,tidak ada Tidak ada fasilitas set password,tidak ada Tidak ada fasilitas set password,retrieve
encrypt&decrypt,not support fasilitas repair archieve,tidak ada virus password,Sfx feature,protect archieve,not
export&import archive format,methods scan feature,tidak ada sfx wizard,not protect archive format
Defined archive format protect archive format

WinAce v 2.69 KGB Archiver 2 Beta Power Archiver 2007


winace.com kgbarchiver.sourceforge.net
Ace compression software&e-merge Free Software Foundation, Inc ConexWare
Gmbh
Shareware(29 Euro) Freeware Shareware($19.95)
Sangat Baik Cukup Baik Sangat Baik
87.93 (A) 50.17 (C) 84.34 (A)

➢ Baik ➢ Baik ➢ Baik


➢ Signifikan (defined file format) ➢ Sangat signifikan ➢ Signifikan
➢ Relatif cepat ➢ Defined by format file&methods ➢ Relatif Cepat
➢ User defined ➢ Defined by methods ➢ User defined
➢ 0 ➢ 0 ➢ 0

➢ Step by step ➢ Step by step ➢ Step by step & wizard


➢ Dapat melakukan perluasan ➢ Mudah ➢ Mudah
konfigurasi ➢ Cukup menarik ➢ Sangat Menarik
➢ Menarik ➢ Internet guide ➢ Brief tutorial (inggris)
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya (inggris

➢ Zip,Ace,jar,gziptar,tar,... ➢ Only zip & kgb ➢ Zip,7z,lha,cab,bh,tar


➢ Only zip & kgb ➢ Zip,7z,lha,bzip2,bh,cab,gziptar...
➢ Zip,Ace,jar,gziptar,tar,... ➢ Min,weak,very ➢ Max,normal,fast,faster,none
➢ Max,fast,superfast,good,store,
weak,normal,medium,above
normal
medium,good,very
good,extreme,max
➢ Defined by format archive
➢ PAQ 1 – 7 ➢ Defined by format archive
➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak

➢ Ya ➢ Tidak keduanya ➢ Ya / tidak


➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak (only english) ➢ 5 pilihan bahasa ➢ Tidak (Only english)
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Ya
➢ Ya ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak ➢ Tidak
➢ Ya ➢ Ya ➢ Ya
Interface cukup menarik,protect file Gratis,interface menarik,hasil kompresi Interface sangat menarik, set password
archieve from damage, virus scan feature sangat signifikan support, repair feature, encrypt feature,
,convert archive,lock archive relatif cepat, hasil cukup signifikan,batch
archive,multi extracting,SFX wizard
WinAce v 2.69 KGB Archiver 2 Beta Power Archiver 2007
Tidak gratis,tidak ada wizard Membutuhkan spesifikasi komputer yang Tidak gratis,tidak ada virus scan
feature,sebagian feature-feature diatas bisa tinggi sehingga pada saat testing tool feature,set password,retrieve
diaktifkan setelah registered,tidak ada compressing kami hanya bisa password,tidak ada pilihan bahasa
pilihan bahasa menggunakan pada level good yang
membutuhkan consumptive memory
sebesar 145Mb, pada level very good
sampai max membutuhkan consumptive
memory diatas 261Mb sehingga pada
kompresi file pdf kami menggunakan
format archive zip.Itu semua dikarenakan
pada format achive berupa kgb
membutuhkan waktu yang lama diatas 5
jam ,relatif lamban,hanya mendukung 2
format kompresi (zip&kgb),tidak ada virus
scan feature,protect damage,repair,test,etc

You might also like