Perfect Substitutes and Perfect Complements
Perfect Substitutes and Perfect Complements
c Y
YY
Two goods are said to be perfect substitutes of each other, if they can be used in place
of one another with equal ease to satisfy consumer want. In case of perfect substitutes,
one good can be substituted for the other good in a constant proportion. In other words,
the consumer is willing to give up the same amount of one commodity to obtain each
additional unit of other commodity. Here, the marginal rate of substitution between two
goods is constant and the i ndifference curve is, therefore, linear (Fig. (a)) with zero
curvature meeting b0& axis. Y
Y
3
Y
YY
YY
In this figure, Y 1 Y2=Y2 Y3=Y3 Y4 and X 1 X 2=X2 X3=X3 X 4. Therefore, the consumer is
prepared to part with equal quantities of commodity' Y' to obtain each additional unit of
commodity 'X'. However, such perfect substitutes are only of theoretical interest. In real
life, goods are imperfect substitutes to each other. Perfect substitutes, f or all practical
purposes, can be considered as one good. Y
Now, we consider the case of perfectly complementary goods, which are also consumed
together in fixed proportions. Marginal rate of substitution (MRS) between such goods is
zero. There is no | possibility of substitution between perfect complementary goods. A
consumer wants fixed quantities of j both the commodities (say, left and right shoe) to
give him some satisfaction. The satisfaction level j cannot be maintained by the addition -
of some units of 'X' commodity at the expense of some units of commodity 'Y¶ The rate
of substitution in this case will be infinite. In other words, the addition of one extra unit
of 'X' will be at the cost of infinite units of' Y' so as to maintain the same amount of
satisfaction. Y
The indifference curve for perfect complements will be right-angled or L-shaped, kinks ('
A','B' or 'C') showing the strict proportion in which the two complementary commodities
are used (Fig. (b)). Here, mere increase in number of units of commodity 'X' or 'Y' will
make the total satisfaction unaltered. The satisfaction level can be raised by
simultaneous increase in the number of units of the two commodities in fixed
proportions, in which case the consumer will reach at a higher L -shaped indifference
curve. It is important to note that the indifference curve analysis breaks down in the
case of perfect complementary goods, as there is no possibility of substitution between
such goods. Y