The Reading Matrix Vol. 6, No. 1, April 2006
The Reading Matrix Vol. 6, No. 1, April 2006
Abstract
_________________
The paper is based on the conviction that stories, apart from being every
young child’s bedtime friend, can become every young learner’s school time treasure.
Moving within the context of English language teaching in Primary schools in
Greece through a compulsory course book (Fun Way series), the paper identifies a
mismatch between what is considered as good primary practice and what is realized
in practice through the use of stories inside the course book. A parallel, story based
syllabus is developed, which aims to cater for the problems conceived, and the theory
behind it is presented in order to justify the selection of both the framework and the
materials. Andrews (2000:3) uses the term “framework” to ‘refer to a diagrammatic
representation of a course outline or plan’ and this is also the view of “framework”
adopted in this paper. The paper also analytically presents seven teaching sessions
within the framework and alternative assessment for one. The framework will be
presented and evaluated in relation to the theories about how children think and learn
and about acquisition/learning of L1 and L2. Suggestions will be made for improving
and further developing the framework.
_______________
taught within the State school system also. The lessons come in 50-minute periods
three times a week. The teacher of English does not teach other subjects and uses an
ELT syllabus for which the textbook is the main provider and very often the only
resource. The materials used for instruction is the series Fun Way (1, 2, 3 for the 4th,
5th, 6th grades respectively) which consist of a Student’s book, a Workbook, a
Teacher’s book and an audio cassette. The books are written by Greek authors. They
are provided to the students by the State; the teachers cannot substitute Fun Way with
a different course book, but are not restricted to the use of extra material, provided
they find the resources to generate or reproduce it. Two years ago the innovation of
teaching English language to students of the third grade (8 year olds) was introduced
and teachers can choose for this class a course book from a list of approved books
published by ELT Publishing Houses.
structure and developing grammar drills. The story-based approach is not normally adopted
in private language schools either.
Teaching children of this age is not easy, but it is certainly challenging. Brewster
insists that one of the seven main features of good primary practice is ‘reading literature for
enjoyment, responding to it critically and using that reading for learning’ (1991:5).
However “comforting” it might be for the teachers to be ‘in charge of the proceedings’
(Skehan 1996:17) with a traditional model of teaching, they should not ignore that stories
are made for children and that young learners are also children. An area, therefore, which is
less developed, is the possibility of using children’s stories for the production of a wide
variety of language and learning activities. These can lay the foundations for the
development of more positive attitudes towards the foreign language and language
learning.
work of Wood (1998) and the edition of Teaching English to children by Brumfit, Moon
and Tongue (1995).
This story-based syllabus places a lot of attention to the development of areas which are
rather neglected in the main syllabus for the class. An area that can prove a source of
wealth for our learners is that of “learning to learn”. Ellis insists that ‘in order to develop
an awareness of learning and learner responsibility, learning-to-learn should be built into
the curriculum in an explicit and systematic way’ (Ellis, 1991:191). Learners can be guided
to reflect on the process of learning even if they are young. Students of the age of 8-10 are
beginning to develop greater self-awareness and can take responsibility of their learning.
Small scale Portfolios, simple questionnaires or learners’ diaries can be designed to
increase the students’ metacognitive awareness and could also serve as ways of alternative
assessment/evaluation of both the students’ achievements and the program’s effectiveness.
The parallel syllabus makes an effort to link the stories with cross-thematic learning. There
are many areas in the curriculum where links can be made. Telling the time, counting,
numbers, shapes, relate to Mathematics; the life cycle of animals, outer space,
understanding the passing of time relate to Science; food, Nature relate to Environmental
Education; action songs and games relate to Physical Education.
The story-based syllabus can raise cultural awareness issues. A carefully selected
story can give information about life in the target language. In this syllabus Spot’s birthday
and Meg and Mog inform about birthday celebrations and Halloween in the target language
culture. Discussions can be held (probably in the mother tongue), projects and surveys
among other community members of the target culture can be arranged. In this way
learners become aware that learning can be an experience of their everyday life, which is
not confined to the school environment only.
The lesson plans illustrate in practice the use made of each story.
Activities Interview: Ss find out peers’ birthdays, list them as for Bingo game, party games: action games,
each month and closest birthdays Simon says…, find the treasure
Sing ‘Happy Birthday’
Prepare birthday party (decide on number of people for
the party, make invitations, make preparations for food,
drinks0
sake but have a target. Children can thus store new knowledge more easily and retrieve it
when they find themselves in a similar context.
The different activities for each session act as a guide for the organization of
individual/pair/group work. Children’s stages of development, according to Piaget, play an
important role in how they learn. The target group for the sessions exemplified have just
gone beyond the beginnings of the “operational stage” (where the social instinct starts
developing) and which occurs ‘towards the age of 7 or 8’ (Wood 1998: 28, see also Brumfit
1991:2). These learners are now at the stage where in Vygotsky’s view, ‘speech comes to
form the higher mental processes which are culturally formed in social interaction’
(Brewster 1991:3). Therefore, in order to follow the children’s conceptual development, the
teacher must provide for alternative organizational patters for her class. Not all children
develop at the same speed and it is certain that each child has a different style in learning
and a unique personality.
The different stages were designed with Halliwell’s suggestion in mind that
‘children cannot concentrate on one thing for a long period and lessons should, therefore,
be divided into series of activities lasting no longer than 5 or 10 minutes’ (Halliwell
1992:27). The projects and surveys suggested may last much longer. Students can work
alone or in groups outside the school in their free time; this reinforces the idea that learning
English is not restricted to the classroom environment but connects to their everyday life.
The pictures have a central role to play in the story-based syllabus and the learning-
to-learn process. They can be a stimulus for forming hypothesis, predicting, sequencing and
exercising memory. Words are better associated with pictures. In addition, a story is more
memorable if it can be related to a sequence of pictures. This quality of theirs makes
pictures a useful tool for the design of activities, especially oral or written ones. They can
help in practicing speaking and writings skills: the story can be reconstructed orally or on
paper (guided tasks) with the help of key-visuals from the storybook. Moreover, they can
provide high face and content validity as stimuli for pure writing or speaking tasks in a
conventional testing situation (if the teacher chooses this kind of assessment).
• evaluate the story-based syllabus and the teaching material and make
adaptations/developments
It can be of value for the learners:
• they have a concrete image of their areas of achievements/weaknesses
• they can gain self-esteem when they see the number of things they have achieved, even
if this is small (“something is better that nothing”)
Parents may also benefit in that they get more involved with their children’s life in school
when they are allowed to participate in one way or another (for example, help their children
with out-of-school projects). They can also be in a position to evaluate their child’s work in
a more objective way.
Conclusion
A story-based framework of teaching and learning can become a very powerful tool
in the hands of a teacher. A well-organized story session can intrigue the students and make
them want to explore many features of the language. As teachers, we want to make our
students autonomous, lifelong learners. We will have made a large step towards this aim if
we make them learn consciously and assume responsibility for their learning.
35
References
Brewster, J., (1991), «What is good primary practice?» in Brumfit C, Moon J, Tongue R
(eds) Teaching English to Children. From Practice to Principle, edition published by
Longman Group Ltd, 1995
Brumfit C., Moon J., Tongue R. (eds) (1991) Teaching English to Children. From Practice
to Principle, edition published by Longman Group Ltd, 1995
Ellis, G. & Brewster, J., (1991), The Storytelling Handbook for Primary Teachers, Penguin
ELT Curriculum Design Committee, (1997), The Comprehensive 6-year Curriculum for
the Teaching of English, Pedagogical Institute, Athens, Greece
Halliwell, S., (1992), Teaching English in the Primary Classroom, UK, Longman
Little, D. & Perclova, R., (2000), The European Language Portfolio: a Guide for teachers
and teacher trainers, document number DGIV/EDU/LANG (2000) 28, Modern Languages
Division, Strasbourg, Council of Europe.
Skehan, P., (1996), «Second language acquisition research and task-based instruction», in
Challenge and Change in Language Teaching, Jane Willis & Dave Willis (eds),
Heinemann, pp. 17-30.
Wood, D., 1998), How Children Think and Learn, U.K., Blackwell
Storybooks
Hill, E., (1980), Where’s Spot, first published by Heinemann Ltd, this publication by Puffin
Books, Harmondsworth, 1985
Hill, E., (1982), Spot’s Birthday, first published by Heinemann Ltd, this publication by
Puffin Books, Harmondsworth, 1985
36
Nicoll, E. and Pienkowski, J., (1972), Meg and Mog, first published by Heinemann Ltd,
this publication by Puffin Books, Harmondsworth, 1975.
Course book
Pedagogical Institute, (2004), Fun Way 1, ΟΕDΒ, Athens
Ntinou Loukia is a teacher of English in primary schools in the city of Volos, Greece. For
the present year she has been detached at the University of Thessaly, Department of Human
Sciences, to organize the Laboratory of European Literature. She holds a BA in English
Language and Literature and a Masters of Education Degree in Teaching English to
Speakers of Οther Languages (M.Ed. in TESOL). She has participated in a number of
teacher training programs organized by the Council of Europe and seminars conducted in
Greece and Europe. She has published articles in Greek and American journals and has
made presentations in seminars and Congresses. Her main field of interest is innovative
ways in the teaching of English Language to young learners and specializes in teaching the
language through stories. Her second field of interest is using educational technology in
promoting collaboration between schools and their students.
37
APPENDIX
38
I can …….
8 Say
Date
Furniture
Date
Use
Words for prepositions
things
Date
Date
Act out my
mum looking
for me!
Date
Ι can sing
I can …….
Write
Furniture
Date
Words for
Ask questions things
with “Is……?”
Date
Date
Use
prepositions
Date
I can …….
Understand
Read
The story
Τον διάλογο στη σελ. 13
How do I feel?
Date
My “score” :
Date Date
Date