Up in smoke?

Threats from, and responses to,

the impact of global warming
on human development
Foreword by R K Pachauri, Ph.D
Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
 Contents

Foreword 1

Summary and recommendations 2

Up in smoke: human development

and climate change 4

Warming up: threats from, and responses to,

climate change 8
Food 8
Water 8
Health 13
Photo: Marcelo Alves
Energy 13
Disasters 18
Environment 22
Livelihoods 25

Global issues 29
Why women suffer most from global warming 29
Trade and climate 29
The movement of people 30
Learning from history 32

Endnotes 35
Foreword

The need for informing the public on the gravity of the impacts of climate
change on human existence across the globe has never been greater.

I am indeed happy to see a document of this nature being released to the public, security becoming acute. Not only would the decline in yields affect human
given the enormous importance of climate change and its influence on all forms consumption and nutrition of the population dependent on such agriculture, but
of life on this planet. The need for informing the public on the gravity of the consequent reduction in income levels would also limit the ability of people to
impacts of climate change on human existence across the globe has never been buy food from the market. The impacts of climate change on human health are
greater. What is particularly noteworthy is the fact that this document is being also well documented, and the World Health Organization for instance has been
released at an event that benefits from the presence and support of a large looking at this problem in some depth in recent years. The Third Assessment
number of NGOs involved essentially in development activities. Climate change Report of the IPCC has also highlighted the adverse effects of climate change on
requires full understanding of its implications for development and, therefore, this human health, and the Fourth Assessment Report would contain growing
document assumes great significance, since reading it would help to define how knowledge and evidence in this field available now.
development policies and actions should and must reflect the reality of climate
change today and the prospects of climate change in the future. All of these impacts of climate change have a direct impact on development,
particularly for the poorest sections of human society. It is, therefore, encouraging
Most notable as a major issue of concern is the nexus between climate change that organizations involved in development activities are taking a comprehensive
and the widespread prevalence of poverty in the world. As the Third Assessment view of climate change and its relationship with development strategies. Given
Report (TAR) of the IPCC clearly indicates, “The impacts of climate change will fall that the inertia of climate change would result in impacts continuing for centuries
disproportionately upon developing countries and the poor persons within all in the future, irrespective of the mitigation efforts that global society is able to
countries, thereby exacerbate inequities in health status and access to adequate mount in the near future, adaptation to climate change would have to become a
food, clean water and other resources.” Take for instance the plight of poor part of development activities particularly amongst those who are the most
farmers in the tropical and subtropical areas of the world. A large number of them vulnerable. We must, therefore, understand the enhanced challenge posed by the
are dependant on rainfed agriculture and are barely able to achieve a subsistence impacts of climate change to development planning. It is unlikely that
level of existence. Variations in precipitation levels, degradation of soil quality and development can by any means be made “climate proof”. But integrating the
increased frequency of extreme weather conditions could make the lot of poor impacts of climate change in the form of adaptation measures within
peasants far more difficult than it is currently. development strategies can certainly minimize the cost of such impacts and
ensure that those who are vulnerable are able to improve their livelihoods through
Climate change would also have a significant impact on the availability of water in the exercise of knowledge and foresight in this area.
several regions of the world. This would happen as a result of the melting of
glaciers on the one hand and changed patterns of precipitation on the other. In R K Pachauri, Ph.D,
those regions where agriculture is dependent entirely on rainfall, reduced levels of Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)
precipitation would only add to already increasing stresses in the availability of Director-General, TERI (The Energy and Resources Institute)
water for agriculture as well as human consumption. Decline in agricultural output
in areas that depend on rainfed irrigation would lead to the problem of food

Up in smoke? 1
Summary and recommendations
This report represents an unprecedented coming together of leading protection, and conservation of forests and other ecosystems – represent effective
environmental and development organisations with decades of experience ways for threatened communities to adapt.
working with poor communities across the world. We fear that global warming
could threaten attainment of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and even If they are replicated and scaled-up, small-scale renewable energy projects
reverse human development achievements. This report is an expression of our promoted by governments and community groups can help both to tackle poverty
common concern and a call for urgent action from governments. and reduce climate change. This will require political commitment and new funds
from governments in all countries, and a major shift in priorities by the World Bank
Global warming is already happening. The impact of global warming is being felt and other development bodies.
most by the world’s poorest people, as many of our case studies make clear. Food
production, water supplies, public health, and people’s livelihoods are all being There must be substantial and genuine reductions in greenhouse gas emissions
damaged and undermined. Global warming threatens to reverse human progress, by the principal consumers of fossil fuels, led by the governments of the
making the MDGs for poverty reduction unachievable. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The need and
opportunity for new models of development must apply in developed countries as
To stop it running out of control – for example by global average temperatures well as in less-developed countries.
rising beyond 2°C above pre-industrial levels – cuts in emissions of greenhouse
gases by industrialised countries in the order of 60–80 per cent (relative to 1990 Poverty causes insecurity and vulnerability and reduces people’s ability to cope
levels) by the middle of this century are essential, far beyond the targets of the and to adapt. Today, humanity faces the intertwined challenges of obscene levels
Kyoto Protocol. A truly global solution to stop dangerous climate change is also of poverty and a rapidly warming global climate. There is no either/or approach
unavoidable, one that will need to be fair and based on human equality. possible; the world must meet both its commitments to achieve the MDGs and
tackle climate change. The two are inextricably linked.
As well as new resources needed to mobilise efforts to stop global warming,
developing countries need much more money to adapt to the climate change that The current and historical greenhouse gas emissions of rich, industrialised
is already happening, and the warming that is already built into the earth’s climate countries have far exceeded their per-capita share. Poor people and poor countries
over the coming decades. are least responsible for climate change and yet, due to their vulnerability, are
affected most by the consequences. Rich countries have an obligation to take a
In the face of global warming, new models of development and nature lead in climate change mitigation and adaptation, and to bear an equitable burden
conservation will be needed which are climate proof and climate friendly.1 In of the associated costs.
2002, the Red Cross’s World Disasters Report called for a new development
model in the face of the challenges of global warming, in which risks are The environmental and development community, like the rest of humanity, is faced
proactively assessed, prioritised, and reduced. Every policy decision at every level with three overarching challenges:
must pass the test of whether it will increase or decrease vulnerability to the
effects of climate change. From now on, planners must view all development 1 How to stop and reverse further global warming.
decisions through the lens of risk reduction. Crucially, communities at risk must be
at the centre of this planning process if it is to succeed. 2 How to live with the degree of global warming that cannot be stopped.

As well as action from above, governments must also facilitate grassroots, 3 How to design a new model for human progress and development that is
community-based approaches to reducing harm from extreme weather events, like climate proof and climate friendly and gives everyone a fair share of the natural
those described in this report. In our experience, these practical examples – resources on which we all depend.
including seed banks, water management, disaster relief, storm and flood

Up in smoke? 2
A cow in Zimbabwe dies from lack of food and water (Photo: ITDG/Zimbabwe)

We suggest that urgent priorities should include:
Disaster awareness campaigns with materials produced at community level
and made available in local languages.

A global risk assessment of the likely costs of adaptation to climate change in
poor countries.
Co-ordinated plans, from local to international levels, for relocating threatened
communities with appropriate political, legal, and financial resources.

Commensurate new funds and other resources made available by
industrialised countries for poor country adaptation, bearing in mind that rich- In addition to these, as organisations striving to improve human well-being in the
country subsidies to their domestic, fossil-fuel industries stood at $73 billion face of enormous challenges, we will:
per year in the late 1990s.2

Work toward a collective understanding of the threat.

Effective and efficient arrangements to respond to the increasing burden of

Share the best of our knowledge about how to build human and ecosystem
climate-related disaster relief.
resilience and live with the degree of global warming that is now unstoppable.

Development models based on risk reduction and incorporating community-

Do everything in our power to stop dangerous climate change and help bring
driven coping strategies in adaptation and disaster preparedness.
about a global solution that is fair and rooted in human equality.

Up in smoke? 3
Up in smoke: human development and climate change
Global warming is happening. The impacts are already being felt most by the most “Some ecosystems will be irreversibly damaged or lost.” It will certainly result in
vulnerable – the world’s poorest people and countries. The organizations that have much more flooding in low-lying areas, declines in food production, an increase in
come together to produce this report fear that without the necessary urgent and disease, and the extinction of plants, animals, and entire ecosystems. There are
radical action by governments, many of the gains of human development are now also fears that temperature rises beyond 2ºC may trigger runaway global warming
in jeopardy and may be reversed. Furthermore, the chances of attaining the MDGs and that temperature rises on this scale already compromise the precautionary
by 2015 – the world’s minimum commitment to ending the worst of global poverty, principle.3 But there is a danger that without radical short-term action to shift onto
hunger, ill health, and disease – will be seriously reduced. a low-carbon path, the option of even limiting the temperature increase to 2°C will
disappear well within the next two decades.
According to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change (IPCC), the global average surface temperature has increased Making development climate proof and climate friendly
over the 20th century by about 0.6°C. The panel says that “There is new and While the internationally agreed precautionary principle and sheer common sense
stronger evidence that most of the warming observed over the last 50 years is demand that the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere needs to
attributable to human activities.” It also concludes that the combustion of fossil be held at a level below that which will lead to a 2°C rise, global warming is
fuels is mostly to blame. The IPCC climate models project that global average already having disastrous effects on people and ecosystems around the globe.
surface temperature will increase by 1.4°C to 5.8°C by 2100, depending largely on
the scale of fossil-fuel burning. The projected rate or speed of change is probably The need to tackle global warming has to be addressed now – not the day after
without precedent during at least the last 10,000 years. tomorrow. Whether our expertise is environment, development, or social and
economic affairs, we recognise that global warming presents a challenge much
But things could be getting worse. Work done by the UK’s Hadley Centre, bigger than any or all of us. The poor people we work with, and the ecosystems in
incorporating so-called environmental feedback mechanisms such as forests dying, which they live and on which they depend, will bear the brunt of its impacts.
suggests that “The rise in global mean surface land temperature between 2000
and 2100 is around 3°C greater… compared to the previous model estimates.” The kind of devastation caused by Hurricane Mitch that hit Central America in
More than 180 nations, including the United States, Australia, and Russia signed up 1998 or the 2004 floods in Bangladesh and India shows that an acute danger now
to, and ratified, the 1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change exists for many of the slow, hard-won gains in human development of the last few
(UNFCCC). Under Article 2 of the Convention they are committed to “Achieve decades: in places, these could be swept away in a matter of hours. The frontline
stabilisation of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that experience of many of us working in international development indicates that,
would prevent dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system.” It already, many of the communities we work with have to combat more extreme
said that “such levels should be achieved within a time-frame sufficient to allow weather conditions – droughts, floods, typhoons. These people have to adapt now.
ecosystems to adapt naturally… to ensure that food production is not Likewise, species, habitats, and systems that have evolved over geological time
threatened…” On current projections this objective is unlikely to be met. are at risk of extinction or severe disruption this century.

Past and current emissions mean that an increase in temperature of 1°C to 1.5°C is The organisations that have come together to produce this report all believe it is
inevitable. Yet the increase of 0.6°C that has already occurred is having a severe feasible and achievable to improve human well-being in ways that are
impact on global ecosystems and especially on poor people. To avoid the most environmentally sustainable. Together we have practical expertise applied in
serious impact of global warming and climate change, we need to ensure that partnership with local organisations around the world, ranging from growing food,
global mean temperature is limited to a 2°C increase above pre-industrial levels, as to piping clean water and improving sanitation, to building and running schools
agreed by the UK Government at the European Council conclusions of May 2003. and health centres, and making sure that homes have light and power. In addition
to our call for action, Up In smoke? builds on our experience in the struggle for
Temperature rises beyond 2°C are, according to the IPCC, likely to result in human development and allows us to deliver a range of insights into what is at
reduced crop yields in most tropical, sub-tropical, and mid-latitude regions and threat, and what we might be able to do about it.

Up in smoke? 4
It is clear to all of us that from now on, a critical test for all development projects and and many atoll islands of the South Pacific and Indian Oceans face a bleak future.
policies should be: Are they increasing or decreasing human vulnerability in the face So too do the long stretches of low-lying coasts in Western Africa from Senegal to
of global warming? But this test is not just a concern for groups directly engaged in Angola, in South America from Venezuela to Recife in Brazil, almost the entire US
environmental and development work. It must also apply to governments, financial seaboard, and much of the coastlines of Indonesia and Pakistan. Particularly
institutions, the private sector, and individuals everywhere. Increasingly, what all of us vulnerable parts of the world, like the South Pacific, have seen a 65-fold increase
do will have to be both climate proof and climate friendly. in the number of people affected by disasters in the last 30 years.5

The new vulnerability Storms, floods, drought, heat waves, and atmospheric pollution due to forest fires
Globally, several environmental, economic, and political trends are coinciding and now have acquired regional dimensions. During the 1990s and early 21st century
contributing to rising instability that exposes people and biodiversity to greater many of these effects have filled our televisions screens. In Central America,
risks and vulnerability than ever before. Without a new agenda explicitly focused to Hurricane Mitch destroyed much of the infrastructure of Honduras and devastated
reduce vulnerability, we could face a major reversal of human progress. parts of Nicaragua, Guatemala, Belize, and El Salvador.

In the global market place, the incremental removal of controls on the movement In Asia, serious floods affected Nepal, India, China, Vietnam, Cambodia, and
of finance and goods has introduced a new era of economic volatility. Low, Bangladesh. In summer 2004, two-thirds of Bangladesh, along with much of
unstable prices destroy earnings and the ability of poor, commodity-dependent Assam and Bihar in India, was under water, with over 50 million people affected
countries – already constrained by the burden of debt and structural adjustment and tens of thousands suffering from diarrhoea as sewage mingled with the flood
policies – to invest in development. Financial volatility wrecks the livelihoods of waters. A similar devastating flood occurred only six years ago, in 1998. The main
millions. But of all the new threats, it is the many dimensions of global warming monsoon rice crop has been severely damaged and some 20 million people are
that are least analysed for their impact on efforts to improve human well-being. likely to need food assistance for at least part of the next 12 months.

Global warming, and its predominant cause – the rate at which humanity is Drought has been more damaging to households in Southern and Western
burning fossil fuels – is making us look anew at how the world works. It asks Afghanistan than the protracted conflicts there.6 In 2001, the Tigris and Euphrates
fundamental questions about whether, and how, we will achieve human rivers in Iraq also dropped to about 20 per cent of their average flow.7 Drought and
development; about how the global economy can run within the environmental erratic rainfall provoked food crises in most countries in Southern Africa and in
limits of the planet’s life support system; and about the obligations between rich Ethiopia and Eritrea. Economic injustice – for example, the historically low world
and poor people, within and between countries. prices for coffee – has combined with drought to produce a crisis for small
farmers, farm workers, and their families.
The IPCC says that as a result of human activities, atmospheric concentrations of
greenhouse gases are rising and with them, global temperatures. In addition to The rate of climate change and the impact of increased sea level and other
increases in temperature, global warming results in more extreme weather associated changes are difficult to quantify. What is clear is that unless we act now
patterns: more rain, longer dry spells, stronger and more violent storms, more fires, to effectively combat climate change, in a best-case scenario things will get
and the spread of tropical diseases.4 None of these impacts respect national gradually worse for many poor countries. Some wealthier countries might even
boundaries. Taken together, their effect is to create more instability in atmospheric experience short-term benefits, though soon outweighed by medium-term costs.
processes. Ironically, while the developed nations of the world produce the But there are also serious catastrophe scenarios in which sudden changes occur,
majority of greenhouse gases, the burden of impact will be more severe on feeding off each other, resulting in a runaway change to the climate.
developing countries whose populations are poorer and therefore more vulnerable
and less equipped to deal with extreme weather events. Even though the ultimate consequences on human lives and livelihoods cannot
be precisely quantified, they will impose a far greater burden on the poor than on
So-called hydro-meteorological disasters driven by global warming – floods, the rich.8 The Financial Initiative of the United Nations Environment Programme
storms, and droughts – present the most widespread direct risk to human (UNEP) recently calculated that the economic costs of global warming are
settlements. Flooding and landslides pushed by heavier rainfall and, in coastal doubling every decade. The cumulative number of people affected by disasters
areas, sea-level rise, will become increasingly common. With sea levels set to rise rose to two billion in the 1990s, up from 740 million in the 1970s. Virtually all are
by up to nearly one metre in the coming century, heavily populated areas of low- concentrated in poorer countries.
lying land, such as Southern Bangladesh, the Nile delta, parts of Eastern China
Up in smoke? 5
Regions that are already least secure in their food production, like Sub-Saharan
Africa, stand to be worst affected by global warming, as wet areas become wetter Heads of State and Government, gathered at the UN in September 2000,
and dry areas become drier. declared: “We will spare no effort to free our fellow men, woman and children
from the abject and dehumanising conditions of extreme poverty.” The MDGs
Halving the proportion of hungry people by 2015 – one of the key MDGs – could are the minimum goals that the world community committed itself to achieving
become a mirage unless the temperature rise can be capped, and unless by 2015. The MDGs are:
resources are provided by the prime causers of man-made climate change to
enable the societies which will suffer most to adapt. 1 Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger.
 Reduce by half the proportion of people who live on less than a dollar
The other MDGs are equally threatened. Ambitious reductions in child and a day.
maternal mortality will be hampered by the unpredictable spread of diseases,  Reduce by half the proportion of people who suffer from hunger.
destruction of property, and contamination of water supplies that go hand in hand
with a warming and volatile atmosphere. Achieving universal primary education 2 Achieve universal primary education.
will be undermined. Time spent finding and fetching (often unsafe) water is already  Ensure that all boys and girls complete a full course of primary schooling.
a major reason why girls in particular fail to go to school. The pressures of poverty
that keep children away from the classroom will be reinforced by global warming, 3 Promote gender equality and empower women.
the number of environmental refugees and displaced people will grow, and  Eliminate gender disparity in primary and secondary education,
infrastructure like schools be damaged by weather extremes.9
preferably by 2005, and at all levels by 2015.
Impacts on the natural biological systems upon which so many poorer people 4 Reduce child mortality.
depend are also potentially catastrophic. As the IPCC’s latest assessment report
 Reduce by two thirds the mortality rate among children under five.
says “Ecosystems and species are vulnerable to climate change and other stresses
… some will be irreversibly damaged or lost.”10 Based on studies of plants and
5 Improve maternal mortality.
animals in Australia, Brazil, South Africa, Europe, and Mexico, covering about 20 per
cent of the world’s land area, a recent paper in Nature concluded “We predict that  Reduce by three quarters the maternal mortality rate.
15 to 37% of species in our sample of regions and taxa will be “committed to
extinction” as a result of mid-range climate warming scenarios for 2050.”11 6 Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases.
 Halt and begin to reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS and halt and begin to
Not only do many people depend on biological systems for their day-to-day reverse the incidence of malaria and other diseases.
existence, they can be a source of significant income. Many poorer countries
depend heavily for foreign currency on their national parks and reserves. Other 7 Ensure environmental sustainability.
consequences are intangible; for example, the national flower of South Africa, the  Integrate the principles of sustainable development into country
King Protea, is likely to become extinct in the wild. policies and programmes; reverse loss of environmental resources.
 Reduce by half the proportion of people without sustainable access to
As climate change pushes the world towards more extreme weather, more and safe drinking water and basic sanitation.
more people will be exposed to recurrent disasters during their lives. Investment in  Achieve significant improvement in the lives of at least 100 million slum
development is frustrated if it is destroyed by extreme weather events.
dwellers, by 2020.
Development plans and investment must be conceived in the light of increasingly
unnatural hazards – and the challenge of the new vulnerability. From now on 8 Develop a global partnership for development.
‘development’ will only be worthy of its name if it succeeds in being both climate
 A range of commitments by northern countries to address trade
proof and climate friendly.
imbalances, debt, aid and development financing, and intellectual
property rights.
(Sources: www.un.org/millenniumgoals/ or www.developmentgoals.org )

Up in smoke? 6
 Climate change and Africa:
drought in Northwest Kenya12
Africa already has a highly variable and unpredictable climate. Global warming is
making that worse. In the Sahel, there has been on average a 25 per cent
decrease in annual rainfall over the past 30 years – consistent with climate
change models. This is nowhere more apparent than in the Turkana region of
Northwest Kenya – 2,000 miles of some of the most inhospitable territory known
to humankind.

Nevertheless, the Turkana tribe who live there are nomadic pastoralists whose
way of life is well suited to the harshness of this land. They are skilful and adept
at seizing every opportunity. By being constantly on the move they search out
the few watering holes and available pasture on which to graze their cattle,
camels, donkeys, sheep, or goats during the long dust-dry nine months
between one wet season and the next. The wet season, or akiporo, may arrive
any time between March and June.

But it has been many years since the akiporo has been sufficient to allow the
full regeneration of pasture and to refill the watering holes. Anna Nangolol Photo: Gary Iveson, Oxfam
(pictured) lives on the banks of what was once a large river (from which she
derives her name – nangolol means born at a river) but which, she says, has Oxfam member of staff with a disability. It was then just four years before the
not seen water since around April 2003. She sees the current drought as being current drought, Kichutanak, began in 1999 – and continues to this day.
the same one as when the name was given back in 1999: Kichutanak, meaning
‘It has swept everything, even wild animals’. The Turkana nomadic lifestyle has evolved over centuries and is sufficiently
flexible for people to survive a poor rainy season, using up some of their
“This drought has been very bad,” explains Anna. “Past droughts have been livestock bank in the expectation that the following year’s rains will replenish
short and rains have come. This one seems never to finish and our goats and their stock. But this superbly balanced and well-adapted way of life is under
cattle are not multiplying. Even if the rains do finally come now, it will take a terrible stress. By late 1999. international aid agencies were supplying 1.7 million
long, long time for us to get back all of our animals.” people in 21 districts of Kenya with emergency food. By the summer of 2004
that had expanded to 2.2 million people, with the warning that 3.3 million people
Anna Nongolol’s impression of the severity of the current drought is backed up will need food if the short rains due from October–December 2004 are as
by statistics. More prolonged droughts are occurring at a higher frequency. Over disastrous as the previous rains have been.
the past 40 years there have been five major droughts in Turkana. Rains were
sporadic and inconsistent in 1960 – the year called Namotor, meaning ‘bones The nomads of Turkana are paying with their lives and their way of life for the
exposed/emaciated’. 1970 was Kimududu, meaning ‘the plague that killed profligate consumption of fossil fuels by others. Everything must be done to cut
humans and livestock’. Again this lasted only until the following rainy season. emissions to stop global temperatures rising even further – and the North also
Nine years later the drought of 1979-80 spread across two years. It was named has a responsibility to provide the funds needed for immediate, ongoing, and
Lopiar, or ‘sweeping/cleaning everything away’. There was then a gap of 12 sufficient relief aid so that when the rains do eventually come, there will still be
years before the prolonged four-year drought of 1992-95, called Longuensil, a Turkana people to greet them.
meaning ‘when the man with no legs from Oxfam came’, a reference to an (Source: Oxfam)

Up in smoke? 7
Warming up: threats from, and responses to, climate change
This section shows the pervasive impacts of global warming on vulnerable people Water
around the world. It highlights the challenge of making human development both The world is already facing a serious water crisis which global warming is making
climate proof and climate friendly. far, far worse. Already 1.2 billion people lack access to safe water and 2.4 billion
lack access to basic sanitation. In the 100 years between 1900 and 2000, global
Cases of human vulnerability to global warming are balanced with examples of consumption rose six-fold, or twice the rate of population growth. The Stockholm
best practice from different organisations that show how we can begin to combat Environment Institute has estimated that by 2025 the proportion of the world’s
the effects of climate change. Some case studies could be examples of either population living in countries of significant water stress will increase from
threats or responses to more than one issue, such as health or growing food. But approximately 34 per cent (1995) to 63 per cent – some six billion people, the
they appear under only one heading to avoid replication. All development issues same number of people as are currently living on Earth. And that figure is based
tend to cross the boundaries between different disciplines. upon only a moderate projection of climate change.16

Food Global warming is exacerbating water stress by changing rainfall patterns, river
There are now at least 815 million chronically malnourished people in the world; flows, lake levels, and groundwater recharge. In some places water sources are
95 per cent of them in developing countries. Inequitable access to food is a major becoming more depleted; other areas are being hit by floods. Globally, river basins
factor in fuelling world hunger, but global warming is also undermining food and wetlands – where most of the world’s populations live – are becoming
security. Africa’s hungry are especially threatened by weather-related disasters. damaged and less able to provide the conditions and processes that provide a
water supply of adequate quality and quantity to ensure sustainable development
During the Mozambique floods in 2000 (the worst for 150 years), the lowlands of and maintain vital ecosystems. Fisheries are becoming depleted and degraded.
the Limpopo river were inundated for up to three months. While short-term Food security is eroded as it becomes increasingly difficult to obtain good
flooding can benefit some crops like rice, the 2000 floods lasted so long that, harvests.17
according to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (UNFAO), they
led to a wipeout of the plant resources that local people relied on. Stored food, It has been estimated that a 2°C to 3.5°C increase in temperature in India could
seed reserves, and all field crops were destroyed, forcing farmers to find fresh result in a decline in farm revenues of 9 to 25 per cent.18 Both drought and floods,
seed from far away. in different ways, favour the spread of water-borne diarrhoeal diseases, as well as
diseases such as malaria and dengue.
The region’s people and its economies are highly vulnerable to both flood and
drought. Records since 1900 show that Africa’s annual rainfall has been
decreasing since 1968, “possibly as a result of global warming due to man-made
emissions” says the UN Environment Programme.13 For every 1°C rise in night-
time temperatures there is at least a 10 per cent fall in rice production according to
the International Rice Research Institute, based in the Philippines.14

Agriculture in Sub-Saharan Africa – of which up to 90 per cent is rainfed – accounts

for 70 per cent of the region’s employment and 35 per cent of its gross national
product (GNP). While many farmers have successfully adapted to slow changes in
the region’s climate, the level of unpredictability which global warming introduces
may overwhelm their capacities to cope. Crop yields in Sub-Saharan Africa are
projected to fall by 20 per cent under global warming. Tropical and subtropical areas
will be hardest hit – precisely those countries already suffering from food
insecurity.15

Up in smoke? 8
Lo-tech answers to farms hit by floods and droughts

We are all dependent on agriculture to meet one of our most basic needs: food. Many of the world’s poorest people living
in rural areas are directly reliant on agriculture for both their food and their livelihoods. But agriculture is particularly
vulnerable to the vagaries of the weather. It is not only that hay must be made while the sun shines, but seeds must be
planted when the rains come – so the rain must come. Whether it brings increasing floods and storms or worse drought,
climate change will create havoc for poor farmers, jeopardising their livelihoods and threatening their food security.

For this reason it’s essential to promote the
Check dams are small, stone or concrete dams Support and organisation is as vital to sustainable
knowledge and methods which enhance the usually constructed across watercourses and also agriculture as more appropriate techniques and
resilience of small-farmer agriculture and food designed to delay the flow of rainwater so it has practices:
production. time to soak into the earth and replenish the
groundwater table while keeping adjacent land
Agricultural research at a local level through
Many techniques for sustainable agriculture relate moist. formal institutions and local development
directly to difficult climatic conditions. They deal with organisations which work directly with farmers is
both water scarcity and over-abundance, typical of
Tanks – in India and elsewhere larger dams or essential to develop crop varieties and improve
tropical countries with seasonal, often unreliable, bunds were traditionally built to create ponds or farming practice.
rainfall patterns: ‘tanks’ to store water. Water seeps from these
ponds into fields of crops and every so often the
Demonstration, training, and extension services

Contour bunding involves constructing low pond is de-silted and the silt used as a fertiliser. to promote these new crops and techniques to
mounds, embankments or ‘bunds’ of earth or Although there has been a decline in these farmers are another part of the equation.
stones along the contour of a field to catch the ponds, there are some places where they are
rain when it falls so that it has time to soak into being revived.
Microcredit – as farmers need access to credit
the ground rather than run off and be lost. The for tools, seeds, and transport and as mainstream
bunds may be planted with vegetation to help fix
Compost from animal manure and rotting banks have usually proved inaccessible, local
them, as well as to help delay the rainwater. A vegetation can be churned into soil, adding community finance organisations are now
number of bunds may be spaced at intervals nutrients but, equally importantly, helping to hold widespread.
across the field or, if the field is small, only along moisture, benefiting crops for longer.
the lowest edge. The bunds can also help
Combining credit with grain banks – the
prevent valuable soil being washed away.
Pit planting – as compost is usually scarce, rather community storage of food grains – helps avoid
than spreading it across the whole field farmers poor farmers having to sell their produce quickly

Gully plugging – the placing of piles of stones may chose pit planting which involves digging a and cheaply, enabling them to sell later when
across a gulley – can prevent gullies caused by pit for each plant – usually fruit trees or bushes – prices may be higher. Such grain banks can also
heavy tropical rains getting worse and even help and adding the compost to the soil as it is dug in. serve to enhance community food security. Seed
‘cure’ them as soil builds up behind the ‘plug’. banks meanwhile are set up as a way of saving
seeds for next year’s planting.

(Source: Christian Aid)

Up in smoke? 9
Strengthening community resilience by conserving local seeds

Long periods of drought are becoming more common in much of Sub-Saharan Africa, and are predicted to become more
widespread as a result of global climate change. The Tharaka District lies in the arid and semi-arid area of North-central
Kenya. Soils are acidic, of low fertility, and rainfall is unreliable and below 600mm. The main crops are sorghum, millet,
cowpeas, green grams for food, and cotton as a cash crop. Farmers have sustained their livelihoods by selecting seed
from varieties that yield best under difficult conditions to plant the following season. Poor farmers do not have the cash to
buy new seed from merchants, and the commercial varieties are often less suitable for drier conditions.

In the past, communities could rely on a few farmers in Zimbabwe and

who would produce seed and save enough to decided to
supply others when their crops failed due to drought introduce the idea
or because they had been forced to eat their into the Tharaka
precious seed stock. But recurrent drought District where locals
undermined these traditional seed-storing and now run them. Each
sharing practices and led Intermediate Technology year the number of
Development Group (ITDG) East Africa to run a exhibitors, crops
programme to improve seed security in Tharaka from and varieties of
1994 until 2000. The programme focused on seeds displayed
conserving local plant genetic resources through increases; an
seed bulking, seed banking, and seed shows. important benefit is
the renewed belief
To establish a seed bank, seed must first of all be Wendo Wa Musyi Self-help Group, Kathekani. The 16 group in the values of
members agree criteria for selecting seed for the community-run
‘bulked’ – produced in sufficient quantity for enough seed bank. They check on maturity (early maturing preferred),
traditional crop
to be available for storage. Training on the managing growth vigour, whether they are pest and disease free and true to varieties, especially
of plots for seed bulking took place before training type. Seeds are then extracted, sorted in terms of size and quality, by younger farmers.
on managing seed banks in which to store the and stored. At planting time, group members can withdraw a
bulked seed. Each member of a seed bank group is portion of the seed they’ve banked in their group store. Showing Despite these Maragwa Seed Show 1998. A
members of the farming group harvesting grass seed. woman farmer exhibiting the many
required to deposit two portions of at least 1kg of examples of local
different seed varieties that she
seed of each variety they grow: one portion for their progress, the uses.
own use, one for the group. At planting season, conservation of local plant diversity. Since forming in importance of
members withdraw part of their own deposit; the 1997, one group has expanded its collection from 57 farmer-led conservation of agricultural biodiversity is
group uses its portion for income generation or for to 140 varieties of local crops. not appreciated in many countries. Many agricultural
issuing to members wanting to try different varieties. departments still view the cultivation of traditional
A committee ensures that all seed entering the bank Seed shows enable farmers to sell or exchange varieties as backward and unproductive while policy-
is of top quality: clean, dry, pest free and mould free. surplus seeds, to obtain new seed varieties, and to makers need to be influenced so that governments
By ensuring access to seeds at the right time, the exchange and share information on the best crops also support seed banks.
seed banks have enhanced food security and for local conditions. ITDG first developed seed shows (Source: ITDG)

Up in smoke? 10
What hope for coping strategies? The Tuareg in the Sahel

Since 1990, local organisation JEMED has been working with the semi-nomadic Tuareg people in Niger to reduce their
vulnerability to drought. The Tuareg are well adapted to surviving in the Sahel’s dry, marginal land – if pastures fail in one
area they move on, taking everything with them. However, the great droughts of 1973 and 1984 decimated herds, and
subsequent droughts in 1993–4 and 1997–8 have thwarted recovery, and climate change means that already dry areas
are likely to get drier. The combination of droughts and the need to graze herds has had a devastating effect on the land,
causing famine and poor health.

Women bear the brunt of the famine. While men are ways. Each fixation point has a management to build up their assets in good years. Their recent
forced to leave their communities to search for new committee made up of, and elected by, members experience shows remarkable human endurance
pasture for their animals, women are left behind to of the local community. and adaptability, but a future of progressive global
try and feed their families, foraging for fruit, warming may well push them beyond their abilities
borrowing from neighbours, and also going to find The first step is to build wells. In 2002, JEMED to adapt and cope.
work. When the food runs out, the Tuareg are forced assisted three communities to dig a 95-metre-deep (Source: Tearfund)
to sell more of their animals – which represent their well at three points, providing water for all human
only wealth and long-term security. and animal needs in each community. This directly
benefits 390 families, accounting for about 2,000
The Tuareg people reasoned that it was better to people. Another 750 more people who pass through
make some changes and adjustments now, and also benefit. At each point, cows are loaned to the
lose only some of their traditions, than do nothing neediest families to help them re-establish their
and lose their whole way of life. At their request, herds. This results in an increased milk supply, which
JEMED has been helping communities establish improves health. The produce from the herds can be
‘fixation points’ to enable them to survive the sold to provide a small income.
changes that desertification and increased
population have brought. These do not settle people JEMED has also helped communities conserve
permanently, but build on a tradition that the Tuareg scarce rainwater by forming a low dike of stones
would spend part of each year camped in a across valley contours. When the rains come, the
particular place. stones slow the flowing streams, causing water to
sink deeper into the soil. Behind the dykes, the
The fixation point helps the community better Tuareg have been able to plant wild wheat. In
manage and use the resources of the surrounding Intikikitan, an established dyke has increased
area and protect them from encroachment by moisture levels to the extent that plant species not
farmers. Fixation points also enable communities to seen for half a century have returned.
develop a social infrastructure and education,
training, health, and agricultural projects, while These measures mean thousands of Tuareg families
keeping hold of many of their traditional pastoral are more prepared to face and survive drought, and

Up in smoke? 11
Climate change and the water crisis in central Asia

Global warming could tip the former Soviet states of central Asia into conflict with each other over access to water.
Meanwhile, for ordinary people, it is already worsening their many difficulties.

In the summer of 2004, Tajikistan was hit by serious what was an already dilapidated infrastructure.
floods and landslides. Half the capital, Dushanbe, was Deforestation adds to flooding problems, and
without safe water, and the only road between Tajikistan suffered a civil war, which further damaged
Dushanbe and Khujand, the second city, was cut infrastructure. Now, nearly a quarter of the population
along 25km, with many bridges also swept away. uses irrigation channels – contaminated by farm
Economic damage was severe. In 2000/2001, in chemicals – as its main source of drinking water.
response to the worst drought in 74 years, Oxfam Meanwhile, far downstream, the Aral Sea continues
began working in Tajikistan, the poorest of the five to shrink, exposing the fertiliser and pesticide dust
new nations. In the most affected area, 200 hand washed into it from Soviet cotton fields and creating
pumps were installed to alleviate water shortages for a toxic wasteland for people living on its shores.
some 9,000 people. The background to the drought is
a general increase in average annual temperatures of But global warming could be what precipitates a
between 0.7°C and 1.2°C; partly because of this crisis, tipping people over the edge just as it
increasing aridity, Oxfam is extending its development threatens to in other places around the world. In
programme, including introducing farmers to new particular, melting glaciers are causing grave
drought-resistant and less water-thirsty plants. Yet concern. Tajikistan generates 55 per cent of all the
paradoxically, because Tajikistan has a complex, water in the Aral Sea Basin – which it shares with
mountainous landscape, floods and landslides have four other countries; much of that water comes from
also become more frequent and more severe in other glaciers. Neighbouring Kyrgystan contributes another
areas. In 1998, such a flood swept away a pumping 25 per cent, yet the country’s glaciers have shrunk Shibanai village, Tajikistan, after 24 hours of heavy rain. The
station on the Qizil Soo (Red) river, depriving some by 35 per cent in the last 50 years. Kazakhstan’s drainage canal has silted up. When it rains, blockages increase the
7,000 people in six villages of clean water. Oxfam capital, Almaty, depends on water from the fast- danger of burst banks and flash floods. Water is slowly seeping up
engineers are helping local people to renovate the shrinking Tien Shan mountain glaciers. the walls of the houses. Mosquitoes are attracted to the stagnant
puddles. Oxfam has paid for a mechanical digger to clear the canal.
pumping station, and are strengthening the riverbanks
to guard against another flood. In mountain valleys, melting increases the risk of
floods and landslides as glacial lakes burst. Oxfam has encouraged local civil society to begin to
Global warming is by no means the main cause of Downstream, it is likely to increase competition for debate how Tajikistan can manage its water
the region’s water problems, which are man-made in water. Many experts have pointed out how the resources fairly and efficiently and move away from
another way. In theory, there should be plenty of regional water-sharing systems, once closely woven cotton-dependency, so that ordinary people obtain
water for all. The central Asian countries are locked together by Soviet design and management, have the safe water they are entitled to and the country
into an unsustainable spiral of expanding water- unravelled, and must be managed by five fractious develops equitably and sustainably. At the same
intensive cotton farming, and have inherited what and poverty-stricken new countries (and also time, dialogue will need to encompass Tajikistan’s
were already hopelessly inefficient and wasteful Afghanistan) that have shown relatively little neighbours so that water becomes a source of
irrigation systems. Now that Soviet subsidies have willingness to co-operate, each wanting more water peace and not of conflict.19
dried up, there is no longer the money to maintain for national development. (Source: Oxfam)

Up in smoke? 12
Health its less-developed and poorly funded healthcare infrastructure. But there is another
As global warming increases, it becomes clearer that it will lead to serious impacts social cost connected to the current energy system that drives global warming: It
on human health around the world. These effects will be direct and indirect. results directly from the burning of fossil fuels.
Indirect effects will happen because of the close relationship between climatic
conditions and insects and rodent populations. This in turn will affect diseases Strong evidence comes from large US studies and points to global implications.
such as asthma, as well as increase the range of vector-borne parasitic diseases According to researchers at Harvard University’s School of Public Health,26 air
like malaria and leishmaniasis. Food-borne diseases are likely to increase as a pollution from combustion processes that produce ultra-fine particles from cars,
result of warmer temperatures. Water-borne diseases may also increase because lorries, and power plants, is killing roughly 60,000 Americans each year. This
of extra demands on diminished water supplies, which will in turn increase the risk represents about three per cent of all US deaths every year. Every combustion
of contaminated supplies reaching the public. source is contributing to the death toll; none is benign, including incinerators;
cement kilns; soil burners; flares and afterburners; industrial and residential
According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), UNEP, and the World heaters and boilers; cars; buses; trucks; and power plants.
Meteorological Program, at least 150,000 people die unnecessarily each year as a
direct result of global warming.20 Warmer and wetter conditions could trigger Such direct impacts increase or decrease in proportion to our use of fossil fuels.
unprecedented levels of disease outbreaks in both humans and the natural world, The Working Group on Public Health and Fossil Fuel Combustion compared the
and undermine the MDGs to reduce child mortality; improve maternal health; and health impact of two carbon emission scenarios, a ‘business-as-usual’ scenario
combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases. Every year, nearly 11 million young based on trends in energy consumption forecast by the IPCC, and a ‘climate-
children die from mainly preventable illnesses.21 The impact of climate change on policy’ scenario where developed and developing countries undertake significant
water supplies is likely to increase cases of diarrhoea, which claims the lives of reductions in carbon emissions.27
nearly two million children every year.22 Malaria, which is already the second
leading cause of death in the world for 5–14-year-olds, is expected to reach Adoption of the climate-policy scenario was estimated to avoid 700,000 premature
unprecedented levels because of climate change.23 It has been estimated that deaths each year as a result of reduced particulate pollution with the greatest
260 to 320 million people are likely to find themselves living in areas with potential effect in developing countries. These benefits are cumulative, so that over a 20-
malaria infestation by the year 2080. This will lead to increased expenditure for year period, adoption of climate policies could avoid a total of eight million deaths,
poor countries. Climate-change-related disasters can also drain public resources globally including 6.3 million in developing countries. A subsequent World Bank
for health care. study modelled particulate health impacts for China. Under a business-as-usual
scenario, it predicted 600,000 premature deaths, more than five billion restricted
Variations in extreme weather typically associated with the El Niño cycle are likely activity days, 20 million cases of respiratory disease, and an annual health cost of
to become more common and more intense. El Niño, a natural phenomenon, is $98 billion by 2020.
associated with warming sea surface temperatures across the central and eastern
equatorial Pacific Ocean. The last strong cycle of El Niño was in mid-1997 and Energy28
continued through 1998; it had a major global impact. Estimates of global loss For years, the superpower politics of the Cold War blocked efforts to end global
range from US$32 billion upwards.24 Across the Pacific, climate change may poverty. Today the hot war of energy economics and global warming presents an
create more permanent El Niño-type conditions. Spending on health care in enormous obstacle.
Bolivia, Chile, Ecuador, and Peru fell by 10 per cent, due to the fall in GNP after the
El Niño cycle in 1982–83. El Niño also has a dominant, but poorly understood, We know that climate change already affects the poorest people in the poorest
influence on climate patterns in Africa.25 countries. We also know that from Nigeria to the Middle East and Latin America,
the extractive industries leave behind them a wake of corruption and conflict.
Direct effects will include heat stress, with associated cardio-vascular effects, as
well as the physical and psychological impact of storms, floods and other extreme But now there is another big problem. A considerable body of evidence indicates
weather events. Even in wealthy France, there were thousands more deaths above that we are living on the cusp of the so-called ‘Hubbert Peak’ of oil production. If
the seasonal average during the summer of 2003 following a particularly powerful so, it means that the $40-per-barrel and more oil price spikes of 2004 will be just
heatwave. These effects will be especially powerful in the developing world, with the first tremor of an impending earthquake in the economic Richter scale. The

Up in smoke? 13
point at which global oil production peaks and begins its decline coincides with But renewable energy technologies are much more than mere potential as a set of
endlessly rising demand. The result depends on whether that decline is long and awards for best practice, run by the Ashden Trust, show. From saving the sight and
slow – or short and rapid; if the latter, then the chances of global economic chaos lungs of urban street traders and home cooks by using solar lanterns and eco-
are high. stoves, to solar powering communication systems for flying doctors in the
rainforest and getting electricity to remote mountain and island communities –
Some mistakenly think that declining oil reserves means that climate change will renewables are already delivering human well-being in some of the most difficult
solve itself: the problematic fossil fuels will simply run out, so end of problem. human circumstances. They also inoculate against the economic, environmental
Unfortunately there are more than enough fossil fuels left – especially coal – to and political shocks linked to fossil fuels.
trigger catastrophic warming.
One major obstacle remains, however, to the mainstream uptake of renewable
Following the 1979 oil price shock, rich countries’ fear of inflation created a triple energy in the developing world where they attract only one to three per cent of
blow for their poorer relations: falling demand, export price collapses, and sky-high energy investment. Highly polluting fuels, like brown coal, are plentiful and cheap.
real interest rates which laid the foundations of a massive debt crisis. Bad as it A global framework with major incentives is needed to encourage the shift, and
was, there were ways out then that, today, due to climate change and the Hubbert forego growing dependence on oil and coal.
Peak, will no longer be available.
For this revolution to happen there has to be a managed withdrawal from fossil
Fossil fuels collectively account for about four-fifths of the global primary energy fuels towards the uptake of cleaner low-carbon technologies – one that gives
supply. Oil makes up over 40 per cent of our energy consumption. Without developing countries their equitable per-capita shares of the remaining carbon
intervention, the International Energy Agency (IEA) predicts “A future in which cake that it is still safe to burn. The type of framework which will best do this is a
energy use continues to grow inexorably (and) fossil fuels continue to dominate matter of debate. For example, there is the ‘contraction and convergence’ scheme
the energy mix.” But the dominance of dirty energy is not a natural state or a proposed by the Global Commons Institute. It works in stages: agreeing a
rational economic choice. It’s largely the consequence of massive, perverse precautionary concentration target for greenhouse gases; setting an emissions
subsidies poured into coal, oil, and gas, and the failure to internalise the cost of budget to reach it, assuming that everyone in the world has an equal entitlement
their environmental damages. Good estimates put the global scale of subsidies, to emit; and then politically negotiating both the period of time and rate with
including the OECD at a minimum of $235 billion per year. The share of energy which the target is met and equal entitlements are achieved. In the process of
research money going into renewables stood at just over eight per cent after the shrinking and sharing greenhouse gas emissions, spare entitlements can be
1970s oil shocks yet, as awareness of climate change grew through the 1990s, it traded to generate income for ‘under-emitting’ countries.
fell to just over seven per cent. As recently as 2003, fossil fuel projects
represented 86 per cent of the World Bank’s spending on energy, and renewables Another approach is the Climate Action Network (CAN) framework. It promotes a
represented just 14 per cent. multi-track approach for mitigation and adaptation. Based on the Kyoto framework,
it calls for industrialised countries to act first in meeting their obligations to reduce
The situation is absurd because renewable energy is super-abundant. It provides a emissions, to help fund development of clean technologies in developing
triple win for human development and an exit strategy from the multiple problems countries as well as the adaptation needs for the more vulnerable countries. It is
of fossil fuel addiction. Globally, renewables account for about 13 per cent of based on a combination of factors for equity and fairness – including per-capita
energy supply, although some of the cleanest forms, including solar, wind, emissions, ability of a country to pay, and historical responsibility in allocating
geothermal, and tidal currently account for less than a quarter of that. They have emissions targets and choosing approaches to mitigation.29
the potential, however, to meet all human energy needs. Small- and medium-scale
applications are particularly well-placed to improve the lives of the 1.6 billion Any framework that builds on the current Kyoto Protocol will have to deal with the
people globally who have no access to electricity, four-fifths of whom live in rural sense of historical injustice about rich countries’ ecological debts, or the dawn of
areas often remote from ailing national grids. The theoretical potential of the main renewables will be derailed.
clean renewable sources is over two million times greater than current use. Even
the more limited technical potential means that, according to research for the
Bonn 2004 International Conference on Renewable Energy, we could increase
uptake by a factor of 120.

Up in smoke? 14
Extracting the World Bank from fossil fuels

International Financial Institutions (IFIs), such as the World Bank, have long been criticised for their failure to deliver on
poverty alleviation, development, and environmental protection. Controversies surrounding these institutions’ involvement in
the oil, mining, and gas sectors led the president of the World Bank, James Wolfensohn, to commission an independent
review. Questions were being asked about whether investments in oil, mining, and gas met the World Bank’s overarching
stated objective of poverty alleviation. This resulted in the World Bank Extractive Industries Review (EIR).

Taking three years, the EIR concluded in December prior, and informed consent of affected communities,
2003 following consultations with multinational respect for human rights, and the protection of
corporations, national governments, affected internationally established no-go zones in areas of
communities, and civil society representatives. The armed conflict and sites of high spiritual or scientific
task was to assess the poverty alleviation potential value, must be pre-requisites.
and consistency with sustainable development
principles of World Bank investments. The EIR recognises climate change as an issue that
will affect the world’s poor the most. Using public
Such a spotlight exposed many problems. On money to subsidise projects managed by
average, 80 per cent of the energy produced by multinational fossil fuel energy giants, where the vast
World-Bank-financed extractive-industry projects are majority of energy is exported, is a fatally flawed
exported to the rich industrialised countries. strategy for poverty alleviation, more often leading to
The financial revenues obtained by the host country conflict and corruption. The EIR therefore
are minimal and project benefits very rarely reach recommended that the World Bank should stop
those on the ground. According to Archbishop financing oil and coal projects by 2008.
Desmund Tutu, the consequences of these projects,
particularly for indigenous peoples and local IFIs often provide the essential economic guarantee
communities are too often “war, poverty, climate and public legitimacy that allow extractive-industry
change, greed, corruption, and ongoing violations of projects to go ahead. So when the World Bank
human rights”.30 announced in August 2004 that it was not going to
implement the EIR in full, it was a huge blow to
The EIR concluded, that in the vast majority of cases, sustainable development.
World Bank extractive-industry investments had not (Source: Friends of the Earth)
alleviated poverty and had failed to promote
sustainable development. The review, and a parallel
report of the World Bank’s own evaluations
department, concluded that in countries with weak
governance, extractive-industry lending is not a
suitable use of World Bank funds, failing the Bank’s
stated mission. The EIR also concluded that free,

Up in smoke? 15
Community hydropower in Kenya changes energy policy

Two community hydropower schemes in remote areas of Mount Kenya, Kathama and Thima, between them serve over 200
households. The projects provide lighting, radio and telecommunications for the households, income generation from
chicken farming – electric lighting provides warmth, increasing productivity – and a means to charge batteries. By replacing
kerosene wick lamps, cutting the need for 18 tonnes of kerosene each year, the equivalent of 42 tonnes of carbon is saved.

ITDG East Africa, in collaboration with Nottingham The aim of the project was to demonstrate the
Trent University and the Kenyan Government, viability of small-scale community-managed
installed the schemes in association with local hydropower in Kenya, where less than four per cent
communities. The communities provided building of the population have access to the electricity grid.
materials, land for the turbine house, and labour and By directly involving the Kenyan Ministry of Energy
financing towards the scheme. They also manage, from the start, the successful implementation of the
operate and maintain the projects on their own. They project has influenced national policy and
pay monthly charges for power supply, and share contributed to the reform of Kenya’s new energy
their experiences with other communities across the policy and Electric Power Act.
country. The schemes have proven cost effective, as
households now pay less for a better quality of Usually, the key constraint to replicating and
lighting, and the project has been financially self- expanding such projects is a monopoly structure in
sustaining for the past three years. the power sector, prohibiting independent private
power producers. The project has demonstrated the Ndundu village, Thima, Kirinyaga district, is one such site. 160
From practice to policy – viability of micro hydropower in reaching households are able to light their homes from this scheme. View
developing appropriate technology communities far from the national grid, and the of power house and community members. Kinyua, trained in how
to maintain and manage the system says, “We did not believe it
These small-scale projects help develop an Government has now drafted policies recognising
was possible to make electricity from such a small stream but
appreciation of the practical problems associated the approach. The current project has been Ndundu Village had its best Christmas ever.”
with decentralised energy schemes and highlight the operating with special permission from the
policies needed to support them. In brief: Government, but other schemes are expected to
follow once the revised policy becomes operational.

The schemes have demonstrated that despite ITDG has received expressions of interest for new
being small scale they are operationally and small hydro schemes from over 60 communities.
technically viable. Estimates show that Kenya has about 3000MW
potential power from micro hydro.

They can contribute to developing national (Source: ITDG)
standards and codes of practice for low-cost, off-
grid, small hydropower schemes.

There is a need to build more local-

manufacturing capacity so that the turbines and
their components are readily available.
Up in smoke? 16
Seeing the cook for the smoke: climate, biomass cooking, and health31

More than a third of humanity, 2.4 billion people, burn biomass – wood, crop residues, charcoal, and dung – for cooking
and heating.32 Biomass energy accounts for approximately 80 per cent of the current global renewable energy supply.
About half of the population in developing countries relies on biomass energy; in Africa, this rises to 73 per cent.

Traditional biomass fuels have significant drawbacks. as methane – which have a greater greenhouse
Burnt on open fires and rudimentary stoves, the potential than carbon dioxide. However, biomass
smoke produced from these fuels is the fourth energy can be a clean, affordable and
greatest risk factor for death and disease in the environmentally friendly source of energy if it is used
world’s poorest countries. It is linked to 1.6 million in an efficient and effective manner. A combination of
deaths per year.33 The smoke makes lungs solutions will be required to meet the differing needs
vulnerable to illnesses like pneumonia and chronic of diverse communities while minimising the
obstructive pulmonary disease. In addition, rural environmental impact, as demonstrated below.
women and children spend a significant portion of
their time gathering and collecting biomass fuel for Experience in Sudan, Kenya, and Nepal
cooking and space heating. What can be done? Working with communities to select solutions that
suit their own needs, ITDG is collaborating with
Billions of people would lead a healthier life if their partners in three different locations to help beat
exposure to high levels of smoke was reduced. Public indoor air pollution. In each place the choice of
awareness of the health risks of smoke is a crucial technology was influenced by culture, cost,
first step. The most effective way to reduce smoke in geography, access to fuel, and climate.
the home is to switch to a cleaner fuel, such as liquid Reducing indoor smoke with a combination of an
petroleum gas (LPG), kerosene, or modern biofuels, In the displaced person’s settlement in Kassala, improved stove, smoke hood and eaves space in
such as biogas. However, the vast majority of people Sudan, the community identified LPG as an West Kenya (photo: Nigel Bruce/ITDG).
at risk are too poor to change to a cleaner fuel, or appropriate solution once microfinance was made
have no access to modern fuels. In these homes, the available to cover the initial cost of the stove. The
answer will be to reduce exposure, by using cleaner, scheme is popular, and already others outside the In the cold, mountain village of Gatlang in Nepal,
more efficient, and better-ventilated stoves. project are using the ‘revolving-fund’ credit system to solutions have been more difficult to identify, as
buy stoves. Fuel costs are much lower for LPG than energy is needed to heat the house as well as to
Cleaner fuel and climate change for charcoal and wood in Kassala, so repayments cook the food. It is remote, making LPG or kerosene
Traditional biomass fuels have a complex relationship can be offset by reduced fuel costs. unavailable. Home insulation has been chosen for
with climate change. Using solid biomass fuel usually retaining room heat whilst reducing the need to burn
produces higher greenhouse gas emissions per meal In the communities around Kisumu town in Kenya, fuel wood for space heating. Smoke hoods are
than fossil fuels, kerosene and LPG, even where the wood fuel is much cheaper than LPG and is often currently being developed, along with improvements
biomass fuel is harvested sustainably.34 This is due free, so most households have elected to continue to the traditional stove to reduce fuel use.
to inefficient combustion of the biomass fuel using biomass. Smoke hoods and eaves spaces (Source: ITDG)
releasing products of incomplete combustion – such with fuel-efficient stoves are proving effective.

Up in smoke? 17
 The Solar Island Disasters
After a decade of UN conferences designed to end poverty and save the global
Six kilometres off the mainland in West Bengal, India lies sacred Sagar Island.
environment, disasters – driven or exacerbated by global warming – could spell
Although home to just under 200,000 people spread over 43 villages, each
out the end of human development for the poor majority, and perilous political and
year in January more than one million visit on pilgrimage for the Gangasagar
economic insecurity for the rest of the world.
Mela festival. But Sagar Island is now becoming the focus for a new kind of
pilgrimage, one where people are travelling to see how medium-scale solar The number of people affected by disasters – a definition that includes being
power is meeting the needs of thousands of people who, like millions of physically injured or made homeless – has grown enormously. According to the
others, are unable to access energy from national grid. World Disasters Report, published by the International Federation of Red Cross
and Red Crescent Societies, it is up from 740 million in the 1970s to over two
Beginning in 1996, the West Bengal Renewable Energy Development Agency billion in the last decade. The figure includes a kind of double counting as some
now operates nine stand-alone solar photovoltaic power plants that provide people are repeatedly affected, but this merely emphasises how increasingly
grid-quality electricity. The Agency works in co-operation with rural energy difficult it is for people and communities to recover. Reported economic losses
development co-operatives formed by the beneficiaries of the power supply, have increased five-fold from $131 billion in the 1970s to $629 billion in the 1990s.
an original feature of initiative. Over 1,600 families also benefit from solar And the number of reported disasters rose three times from 1,110 to 2,742 in the
powered home lighting systems and 58 shops and businesses are getting same period. The South Pacific has seen a 65-fold increase in the number of
stable power supplies. Before solar power, arrived the island depended on people affected by disasters in the last 30 years.
expensive and inadequate diesel generators. More recently a wind/diesel
hybrid power plant has been added to the energy mix. Massive disruption to the earth’s hydrological cycle means that millions will
become trapped between the extremes of floods and droughts. Global average
The solar ambitions of Sagar Island are bold. Importantly, the initiative to set up rainfall is projected to increase during the 21st century and sea levels are
expected to rise by up to one metre.36 As a result, the IPCC predicts that there will
the power plants comes from the local village government Gram Panchayet
be a “widespread increase in the risk of flooding for many human settlements”.37
level. Apart from bringing electricity to homes the mini-grids also aim to power
Indeed, according to the IPCC, flooding and landslides pose “the most widespread
schools and health services. The project also integrates power with water direct risk to human settlements from climate change”.38 It’s estimated that by
supply systems bringing drinking water to the island’s homes. Jobs have been 2025 over half of all people living in developing countries will be highly vulnerable
created directly and the local economy has benefited as new lighting and to floods and storms.39
power allows local businesses, markets and home workers to work more
cleanly, efficiently and safely outside daylight hours. But the IPCC also predicts that as a result of global warming, there will be
increased droughts during the 21st century. Most mid-latitude continental interiors
Gon Chaudhuri, the award-winning, dynamic director of the Agency,35 will be hit by droughts occurring with El Niño-type events.40 It also predicts that
emphasises that local people fully understand and promote the radical climate change will lead to “decreased water availability for populations in many
environmental improvements that solar brings, “Sagar Island has its unique water-scarce regions, particularly in the sub-tropic”.41 Not only will water become
ecosystem. It falls under the Sunderbans delta. Diesel power generation is scarcer, but the quality of available water will deteriorate.
responsible for environmental degradation not only in Sagar Island but in the
entire delta zone. Solar energy is totally eco-friendly. There are no emissions Food chains are increasingly likely to be disrupted in sudden and unexpected
and no sound pollution from solar PV. Local people are now very concious ways. For example, climate change has led to the warming of the North Sea and a
about the protection of the environment of ‘Solar’ Island.” Chaudhuri is unlikely change in its plankton – microscopic plants and animals upon which all higher
to stop until everyone on the island has access to a solar mini-grid. sea life depends, directly or indirectly. Apparently, as a result of these changes,
populations of small fish known as sand eels – the prey for both larger fish and
(Source: The Price of Power, nef) birds – have collapsed, as have seabird populations off Northern Scotland. This
type of event is likely to occur more frequently affecting both people and wildlife.

Up in smoke? 18
More disasters related to global warming seem inevitable. How the international
community responds to them will be vital. And following on from immediate
Improve access to resources for the poorest, such as microcredit, land,
response, intelligent recovery from disaster is an important strategy to reduce livestock, and farm inputs. This will not necessarily be solved by more foreign
vulnerability the next time a flood or drought strikes. direct investment, which – because of higher-than-usual demands for returns –
can drain resources from poor, high-risk economies.
The ecology of disaster recovery42
Recovery for whom, or of what, is the question that hangs over any effort towards
Strengthen democracy to improve recovery planning and efficiency, through:
post-disaster reconstruction. What is the end in mind when designing an economic stakeholder councils, citizens’ juries, and local micro/small business alliances
reconstruction plan? Is it targeted towards creating maximum resilience and for participatory planning from the pre-disaster phase through to relief and
sustainable livelihoods in the disaster-affected area? Or is its prime aim re-gearing reconstruction.
economic infrastructure to meet more abstract economic targets? Being clear about
objectives makes it more likely that appropriate strategies will be found.
Focus on community disaster resilience as the primary economic goal of
reconstruction rather than export-oriented production. Beware of the economic
Post-disaster economic reconstruction will only work if it takes an integrated and environmental vulnerability linked to dependence on a few cash crops.
approach respecting the subtle dynamics of communities’ economic, political, and Focusing only on export crops can displace local, community-serving activities.
cultural lives, and how these interact with the natural environment. It is more
important to ask people what they need to recover their daily lives, than to rush in
Create new resource-raising mechanisms: more grant finance, not tied aid,
foreign contractors to rebuild risks in the familiar shape of major engineering from rich countries; deeper debt relief; and legal compensation for the effects
works. Resilient, inclusive, and democratic local economies are the best of climate change are needed to compensate low, fossil-fuel-consuming
inoculation against the multiple risks wrought by disasters. countries for the ecological debt of industrialised nations.

A recipe for post-disaster economic recovery could include initiatives to:
Safeguard natural resources that buffer the elements. Prioritise conservation
efforts to protect natural buffers against climate-related disasters, for example,

Plan for climate change: Low-carbon development strategies are needed mangroves, forests, coral reefs, natural river deltas, etc.
everywhere to minimise the increasingly hostile greenhouse effect. Risk
reduction strategies must be built into disaster recovery plans. Lifting people out of poverty is the best way to reduce the number who have to be
lifted out of mud, floodwaters or drought when disasters strike. Investment in local-

Forge sustainable livelihoods through rebuilding diverse local economies to level economic recovery is better at creating disaster-resilient communities than
meet local needs as the foundation for human recovery. Maximise contributions investment which depends on dams, dykes, and concrete.
to the micro/small business sector, and minimise environmental impact.

Create employment, not just wage labour, to maximise long-term secure work,
self-help and self-employment. Ensure that the particular employment needs of
women are addressed, such as day care for children.

Set local procurement targets in disaster response to maximise local economic

recovery. Use grants and microcredit schemes to increase support to
micro/small businesses and co-operative enterprises. Ensure reconstruction
prioritises secure local employment as an immediate need.

Measure the effectiveness of reconstruction with a Local Multiplier Effect

ratio.43 This would be a new measuring tool to indicate real contributions of aid
and investment to the affected area and could help plug the economic leaks.
Aid interventions must not undermine incentives for local production or distort
markets by undercutting local producers.
Up in smoke? 19
Living with disasters in Bangladesh

In Bangladesh, extreme weather events have always been a fact of life; floods, typhoons, and river erosion endanger
human lives and affect livelihoods annually. Increasingly, the impact of these disasters is being exacerbated by global
environmental change. Scientists have warned that, through sea-level rise, 20 per cent of the land of Bangladesh may
eventually be under water. Already, typhoons and floods show increased severity.

ITDG has been working with flood-affected conservation and stocking initiatives. In one
communities to increase their resilience to these community, 48 people are managing a water area
environmental shocks using a process called that extends up to 24 hectares during the rainy
Participatory Technology Development. It involves season. Poor people have limited access to, and
communities identifying technological options, control over, natural water basins, but it is easier to
farmers and communities experimenting, followed by negotiate access to this type of small-scale or
self-assessment and reflection. medium-size water resource.

In communities severely affected by floods, the New research is being carried out on how to
technologies developed cover livestock, and crop and manage native fish with fish culture of larger edible
fish production. Where livestock is concerned, help species, and on the interaction between wild and
with managing feed and disease control during flood stocked species in semi-closed aquatic systems.
periods, and homestead rearing of poultry in pens has
improved the survival of household livestock. Long-term sustainability of this approach is ensured
A natural channel of the river is shown which has been modified
by earth embankments for use as a closed resource and
by training local people who provide technical
Growing vegetables at home is helped by digging catchment area for fish culture. The fish including carp will be support and farming inputs to their fellow villagers
pits and enriching the sandy soil with manure for available nine months of the year. This process involved and are paid by them for their services. So far, over
crops like chilies and gourds. Sticks mark pits during consensus building over access to the water for the poor. This is a 100 rural community-based workers are now selling
flooding. Training in how to grow trees and crops pilot project that ITDG is helping to develop and, if successful, their services to the community.
other physical barriers can be more simply erected using netting.
during flood periods enables people to be ready for (Source: ITDG)
planting-out when floodwaters recede. Another
initiative is developing water-resistant fruit trees by
grafting onto different flood-tolerant root stocks. Using cages suspended in floodwaters for fish
breeding enables the poorest people to benefit from
One technology with great potential is the natural resources. The production of cultivated
management of small seasonal ponds for native fish species rose by 50 per cent in one year. Wild fish
breeding alongside the rearing of stocked carp. production increased three-fold as a result of new

Up in smoke? 20
Shelter from the storm: cyclone protection in Bangladesh

In May 1997, a ferocious cyclone hit the Cox’s Bazar region in Southeast Bangladesh. It was the sort of extreme weather
event likely to become more common under global warming. The cyclone brought winds of 150 miles an hour and lasted
for over 10 hours, leaving a million and a half homeless, but only 100 died. It was more ferocious than the one in 1991
when 140,000 were killed, yet the death toll was small by comparison. This was due partly to the fact that the cyclone
struck during daylight and at low-tide. However, new cyclone shelters and people trained to alert their community of the
impending dangers were also key factors in saving lives.

The Christian Commission for Bangladesh (CCDB),

Gonoshasthaya Kendra and other NGOs supported
by Christian Aid had built a number of cyclone
shelters, mostly on stilts. Used as community
centres or schools in normal times, when the
cyclone struck they provided refuge to the whole
community. The low-lying island of Moheshkhali was
one of the areas worst hit by the cyclone. Most
villagers were left homeless but because of the
cyclone shelter all survived.

Other programmes to protect against cyclones and

flooding include building embankments and
homestead and community land raising. Local
organisations are supporting villagers with ‘cash-for-
work’ programmes where earth is moved to build up
platforms of earth, to rebuild homes, school
playgrounds or other communal areas at a higher
level, or so that large groups of people can take
refuge. The people living around the Bay of Bengal
are used to cyclones, but climate change is likely to
increase both the frequency and the intensity of
cyclones in the region.
(Source: Christian Aid)

Flood damage in Bangladesh (Photo: ITDG/Janet Boston)

Up in smoke? 21
Environment
Global warming is itself a defining environmental phenomenon for our time. But world’s land-based species. But industrial logging has resulted in the lands of
due to its complex nature, it has enormous implications for ecosystems the world indigenous peoples being overrun, forests being destroyed, and cultural
over. The first extinction due to climate change has probably already occurred: the traditions threatened.
golden toad of Costa Rica.44 Many believe that domino-like environmental effects
triggered by existing levels of climate change are already underway. For example, Worldwide, 80 per cent of original forest cover has been cleared, fragmented, or
as glaciers and ice shelves shrink, less heat is reflected back from the earth’s otherwise degraded. Forests have virtually disappeared in 25 countries; 18 have
surface. In some areas, warming also leads to forest die-back releasing more lost more than 95 per cent of their forests; and another 11 have lost 90 per cent.
carbon into the atmosphere. Both temperate and tropical forests are being cleared at the rate of 23 ha per
minute. The World Conservation Union recently calculated that about 12.5 per cent
Vitally, the web of life upon which our food chain depends – our biodiversity – is of the world’s 270,000 species of plants, and about 75 per cent of the world’s
under attack, from climate change, the pressures linked to the expansion of mammals are threatened by forest decline.
human settlements and the current paradigm of intensive agriculture using only a
few crop varieties. Often, the ecosystems that are under threat are also ones Large-scale industrial investments in timber extraction and plantation forestry do
essential for people’s livelihoods, or important defences against the hostile not have a known track record of contributing to sustainable development. To date
elements. The science journal Nature reported threats of extinction for up to over there is little scientific evidence that large-scale commercial logging can be
one third of land-based plant and animal species by 2050 as a result of climate conducted in primary forest in an environmentally sustainable manner and
change.45 Threats to coral reefs, with their high sensitivity to changes in sea deliver development benefits to local people. The IPCC showed that plantations
temperature, and their direct link to human livelihoods, provide one of the clearest can damage biodiversity if they replace trees with grassland, wetland, heathland,
examples, but there are many more. or shrubland habitats. But plantations of non-native or native trees can be
designed to enhance biodiversity by encouraging the protection or restoration of
A forest of loss natural forests.46
Forests play four major roles in relation to the climate.
In 2001, Governments at the 7th Conference of the Parties to the Climate Change

They currently contribute about one-fifth of global carbon emissions when cleared. Convention (COP7) put the final touch to the decision that allows forests to be
used as a ‘carbon store’ to help countries reduce their net emissions. These

They react sensitively to a changing climate when managed sustainably. projects are eligible for credits under the Kyoto Protocol’s Clean Development
Mechanism.

They produce wood fuels as a benign alternative to fossil fuels.
Friends of the Earth and others have campaigned to oppose the inclusion of

They have the potential to absorb about one-tenth of projected global carbon ‘carbon sinks’ into the Protocol. There are huge uncertainties and accounting
emissions into their biomass, soils and products, and store them, in principle, in problems involved. Furthermore, the faster a tree grows the more credits can be
perpetuity. gained. This is an incentive for large-scale industrial tree plantations which can
generate poverty and inequity, damage food security, deplete water and soil
While the UNFCCC mentions forestry only briefly, the Kyoto Protocol deals with it resources and slash biological diversity. Planting trees rather than reducing
explicitly. Article 2 mentions that industrialised countries shall “implement and/or emissions from fossil fuels will not save the global climate and will do little to
further elaborate policies and measures… such as… promotion of sustainable protect biodiversity.
forest management practices, afforestation and reforestation” in helping to limit
and reduce their greenhouse gas emissions.

About 350 million of the world’s rural poor and forest-dwelling indigenous
peoples depend on forests for their home, livelihoods, and energy supply. Forests
contain literally millions of types of flora and fauna, as much as 90 per cent of the

Up in smoke? 22
 The case for a ‘Climate Impact Relief Fund’
The principal agenda of Northern, industrialised countries at international
climate change negotiations has been to argue that all countries should have
responsibilities to reduce greenhouse gases. Acknowledging that these
mitigation responsibilities should take into account the different circumstances
that countries find themselves in, as enshrined in the so-called ‘principle of
common but differentiated responsibilities’ of the UN Framework Convention
on Climate Change.

Developing countries, in contrast, are generally more concerned with the

gap in historical responsibility for climate change between rich and poor
countries and the unfair burden of climate change impacts, which fall heavier
on the poor.
Raised well in Northern India (Photo: Tearfund/Caroline Indy)
To bridge the divide, Benito Muller of the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies
proposes a multi-lateral Climate Impact Relief Fund (CIRF). Too few funds are
The Plantar forestry company in the state of Minas Gerais in Brazil has large available to help poor countries deal with crises, and when climate-related
monoculture eucalyptus plantations covering 23,100 hectares, to be used to disasters strike, the few funds that are available are often inequitably distributed
create charcoal to supply the pig iron and steel industry. The plantations were and arrive too late on the scene. The CIRF would collect contributions from
established at the expense of the existing mixed forestry and evicting local governments and other donors before rather than after disasters occur.
people. The company’s social, environmental, economic, and cultural impacts
were widely documented in recent research work carried out by the World Although many questions and more detailed operational practicalities about
Rainforest Movement which highlighted impacts such as appropriation of land this particular proposal remain outstanding, it is clear that the burden of
and eviction of inhabitants, depletion and contamination of water and soils, climate-related disasters is increasing and that the international community’s
deforestation, destruction of biodiversity, net loss of jobs, bad working response needs to become more efficient and equitable. The proposed CIRF
merits further exploration because:
conditions, loss of livelihoods, and risks to health, among others.47

It would be a concrete, achievable, short-term goal.
Burkina Faso’s unplanned use of forests led to the deterioration of all forest
areas around Ouagadougou, prompting a government decision to develop new
It could bring immediate benefits and reduce suffering for many people
management techniques. The project aims to develop a national programme for directly affected by climate change through more timely and efficient
the sustainable and integrated production of wood and non-wood forest delivery of relief aid.
products, particularly fuel wood and charcoal. In an area 150km around
Ouagadougou, 80,000 ha are being managed with the active participation of
It could add to and/or complement the drive to provide funds for
local people using simple techniques for silviculture. Supported by the UN adaptation to global warming, and prevention and preparedness.
Development Programme and the FAO, the Government of Burkina Faso has
introduced a planned and more rational approach to forest resources. This has
It builds on the existing specialist knowledge and expertise of emergency
resulted in resource conservation and protection, as well as a 50 per cent and humanitarian agencies.
income increase for local people, who are now able to fulfil urban demand for

It helps to promote global climate justice and equity with a tacit
fuelwood and charcoal. Plans are underway for the management of a further
recognition of the disproportionate burden of climate impacts on least
570,000 ha in Burkina Faso. Other Sahelian countries have expressed interest
developed countries.
in adopting similar programmes.48

Up in smoke? 23
Coral reefs cooked by warming climate

Coral reefs are vital to island and coastal communities that rely on them to support the fishing that provides their
livelihoods. They are also complex and have the highest biodiversity of any marine ecosystem. They provide important
services and direct economic benefits to the large and growing human populations in low-latitude coastal zones. The
natural habitat of coral reefs near the meeting between land, sea, and air can be a stressful environment. Reef organisms
have evolved ways to adapt and recover from such stresses over hundreds of millions of years.

However, recent global increases in reef degradation Predicting the future of reefs is difficult because significant step would be an international network of
and die-back suggest that both the rate and nature current environmental changes are causing a marine-protected areas to provide refuges for future
of recent environmental changes are exceeding the combination of surface ocean chemistry and generations of coral reef organisms. Yet, even with
capacity of coral reefs to adapt. This can lead to temperature conditions that have almost certainly such efforts, recent degradation of coral ecosystems
reefs being displaced by seaweeds and other non- never occurred in the evolutionary history of modern combined with future climate change will pose a
reef systems. Such ecosystem shifts are already well coral reef systems. Key uncertainties include the significant challenge to the global sustainability of
advanced in the Caribbean region, where two of the extent to which human activities will continue to alter coral reefs.49
major reef-building coral species have been the environment; how climate variability such as the (Source: IIED)
devastated by disease. In the Indo-Pacific region, frequency and intensity of El Niño Southern
repeated episodes of lethal ‘bleaching’ suggest that Oscillation (ENSO) events will change relative to
reefs cannot recover sufficiently between such global temperature; and the biological and
events. ecological responses of coral reef communities to
unprecedented future conditions. Although climate
This crisis is almost certainly the result of interactions change has the potential to yield some benefits for
between pressure from local human populations and certain coral species in specific regions, most of the
global climatic stresses. The former includes direct effects of climate change are stressful rather than
destruction, coastal habitat modification, beneficial. Continued climate change will almost
contamination, over-harvesting, and increased certainly cause further degradation of coral reefs,
nutrient and sediment build-ups. The latter includes which will be even more devastating in combination
rising ocean temperatures implicated in chronic with the continuing non-climate stresses that will
stress and disease epidemics, as well as mass almost certainly increase in magnitude and
coral-bleaching episodes and reduction in necessary frequency. Reef systems that are at the crossroads
calcium levels, which provides the building blocks of of global climatic and local human stresses will be
coral reefs. Increasing atmospheric CO2 levels can the most vulnerable.
also inhibit calcification. These stresses may interact
with each other and exacerbate other stresses like Research into adaptation and recovery mechanisms
disease and predation. As with many ecosystems, it and enhanced monitoring of coral reef environments
is difficult to separate the effects of global climate will help us to learn from and influence the course of
and local, non-climate impacts. events rather than simply observe the decline. A

Up in smoke? 24
 Nature conservation in Southern Africa Livelihoods
It is in the area of livelihoods that many of the threats from, and responses to,
Sub-Saharan Africa arguably has the most spectacular wildlife in the world. Not global warming come together. Without stopping global warming it is clear that the
only is the myriad of species important in its own right but the parks and nature viability of millions of people’s livelihoods will be undermined; without significant
reserves provide employment and are one of the main sources of tourism and new resources, millions of others won’t be able to adapt to changes that are
hence foreign currency in many African countries. Yet climate-induced changes already happening.
in species’ ranges pose challenges for so-called site-based nature conservation.
Entire species or ecosystems may move away from protected areas. Food, health, water, energy, and more, are all elements of livelihoods. How they
are affected by global warming and how people adapt, will determine the future
BirdLife International, a worldwide partnership of more than a hundred national
for human progress. Threats range from the loss of a home in a flood or storm, to
conservation organisations, is working with the UNEP World Conservation
the loss of the land on which it is built through sea-level rise. Health too is under
Monitoring Centre and the Universities of Copenhagen and Durham to provide
threat: Areas that were once free of malaria may suddenly become susceptible as
practical ideas that will help to maintain the function of BirdLife’s Important Bird
local climates change and safe drinking water may become harder to get.
Area (IBA) network in Sub-Saharan Africa as the climate changes.
Similarly, livelihoods built for generations on particular patterns of farming may
The project ascertains the ranges of threatened species through local networks of
become quickly unviable. But, somehow, communities will have to cope as best
observers. Species likely to be strongly affected by climate change include Iringa
they can. Whilst runaway climate change will pose a threat to human civilisation
Akalat of the Tanzania–Malawi montane forest and Short-legged Ground-roller of
matched only perhaps by that of nuclear war, for the immediate future, taking the
the East Malagasy wet forests. Models of future climate change are then used to
right approach can prevent a crisis becoming an irretrievable disaster.
predict where species’ habitable areas will be in 2100, and hence where each bird
species range might move to. Next, the physical and human geography of the
region is examined to assess whether each species will be able to reach its new
range, and whether there will be suitable habitat within the new range. Finally, the
new species’ ranges are superimposed on the existing IBA network, and the
impact of climate change on the function of the network determined.

Early results suggest that African species may undergo major range shifts
following climate change, as is shown below for the Cape Longclaw.

The current ‘climate envelope’ of Cape The predicted range of Cape longclaw in
longclaw 2070, based on climate modelling Cycling along the bank of the swollen Surhob (Red) River, Tajikistan, after heavy rain. Climate change,
glacier melt and deforestation are likely to increase the power of rivers like this during the winter, but
(Source: RSPB)
reduce flow at other times. (Photo: Oxfam)

Up in smoke? 25
The real value of mangroves: ‘no-regrets’ adaptation in Fiji

Fiji is already vulnerable to extreme climatic events such as cyclones, floods, and droughts. The costs of storm surges can
account for a noticeable share of annual GDP. Coastal resources are the highest priority in terms of certainty, urgency, and
severity of impact, as well as importance.

Fiji receives around US$30 million in aid annually. Department of Lands gives only a fraction of the
Between 23–36 per cent of development assistance value to mangroves, as low as one-twentieth,
by aid amount and or 19–23 per cent of donor compared to the values assessed by other groups
projects by number are in sectors potentially affected using methods that take into account a range of
by climate-change risks. Several donors have been services provided by the mangroves. Another reason
actively involved in efforts to assess Fiji’s for the continued loss is the mismatch between the
vulnerability to climate change. However, aside from mangrove ecosystem and the property-rights regime.
climate-specific projects, donors and the In Fiji, a traditional clan, or mataqali, has communal
Government have failed to make climate risks a claim over the physical resources and the
central consideration in their development work. environment, including mangroves. However, the
Government has limited the amount of
Coastal mangroves highlight the problem. compensation paid for loss of mangroves for
Mangroves protect against coastal erosion and storm reclamation purposes.
damages, but are themselves vulnerable to sea-level
rise and would need to migrate shoreward with the ‘No-regrets’ adaptation in Fiji, will therefore require
rising inter-tidal zone as sea level rises. Pressures on greater policy coherence between climate change
these land areas from competing land uses, such as and development policies – appropriate value
agriculture, tourism, and housing, militate against attached to mangroves would be one such example.
their conservation, which benefits fishing There is also a need for a coastal management plan
communities and the environment. that prioritises mangrove conservation, requiring
development to be set back from the high water line
Conservation of mangroves is a ‘no-regrets’ to allow mangroves to move and spread. To be
adaptation given the wide range of other benefits successful, local communities need to be involved in
they provide to local communities. These include these processes.50
their role in fisheries, reef protection, stabilisation of (Source: IIED)
coastlines, timber supply, and medicinal uses.
However, mangrove cover is being lost in Fiji. One
reason for this is the significant undervaluation of
mangroves, which encourages their clearing for
development. The method typically used by the

Up in smoke? 26
Preparing for the flood: reducing damage in North India

Since 2002, Tearfund local partner organisation Discipleship Centre (DC) has been working with five villages in Bihar,
North India, to reduce their vulnerability to flooding. The villages are poor and geographically isolated. Government aid
programmes do not reach them. For three months of every year, they are subject to monsoon floods which destroy lives,
livestock, houses, and property.

Before DC’s programme began, the people had no safe drinking water when flood
safe route out of the five villages to escape rising levels rise.
flood waters. With no unity within or between
villages, everyone looked after themselves, rescuing These measures have proved
possessions, livestock, and people in a haphazard, effective in saving lives and
disorganised manner. Boats for rescue purposes had property. The monsoon floods in
to be hired from local landlords, or banana stems 2003 were severe but no lives were
were floated on the water as makeshift rafts. The lost to drowning or flood-related
flood waters submerged and clogged hand pumps illness, and very few livestock
so that the villagers had no safe water and were perished. The villagers frequently
forced to drink from the river. Flood-related diseases comment on the difference the
were common. measures have made to their lives:

The people wanted to improve their situation so “In the past we all used to dread
DC mobilised each village to form a Village the flooding season… because
Development Committee (VDC) and four teams of we did not know if we would
volunteers which were trained in flood preparedness. survive. Now we have peace
The committees oversee the teams, which are because all the people know Trained volunteers in Bihar (Photo: Tearfund/Caroline Irby)
responsible for early warning and evacuation, they can save themselves.”
management of boats, resource mobilisation, and
care of the vulnerable. The teams have a recognised The project has had other unexpected benefits. The There is a strong emphasis on community
uniform and meet on a regular basis to learn first aid rescue boats are generating income through being mobilisation and use of local knowledge in the flood
and practice evacuation procedures. hired out for other purposes, and the raised programmes. With a small amount of outside
embankment is providing a valuable connection to assistance, the villagers are better able to cope with
DC mobilised the village communities to build the main road for trading. The villagers have learnt the floods they have lived with all their lives. As one
raised embankments to connect the villages to the value of community co-operation, and developed villager commented “We could have done this 50
each other and to the main road, providing an confidence and leadership skills. They are more years ago but no-one showed us how.”
escape route during the flood season. Culverts were aware of their needs and their potential to meet (Source: Tearfund)
built to reduce water pressure, and tube wells with these needs, and as a result are now collecting
raised hand pumps were constructed to guarantee money for a school.

Up in smoke? 27
Living with climate change in South Africa and Mozambique

Climate data for Africa for the last 30–40 years shows global warming has taken a firm hold. If current trends continue,
climate models predict that by 2050 Sub-Saharan Africa will be warmer by 0.5°C to 2°C and drier, with 10 per cent less
rainfall in the interior and with water loss exacerbated by higher evaporation rates. There will be more extreme events such
as drought and floods, and the seasonal patterns will shift.

What is important is that these changes are on people’s lives. The research is now in its second
happening right now, and already people are having phase and will be completed next year.
to learn to live with the consequences across the
whole of the Sahel, the Horn of Africa, and Southern Professor David Thomas said, “What we’re seeing is
Africa. Food security may become increasingly that people’s responses are complex and dynamic –
difficult to achieve and humanitarian crises may they are not helpless in the face of these major
be exacerbated. changes. It looks as though the communities that
are most able to cope are those which are most co-
With support from Oxfam and Save the Children, operative and with the strongest social institutions.
ADAPTIVE researchers at Sheffield University, funded They are able to innovate and experiment in the
by the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change, are co- face of change, as well as drawing on traditional
ordinating a major research programme to find out knowledge and networks.” Dr Chasca Twyman
just what strategies people are using to cope with added “but other communities are doing much less
changing environments. They are taking an in-depth well, and even with those that are more successful,
look at life in three districts in the Republic of South we don’t know whether they will continue to be able
Africa and one in neighbouring Mozambique. to cope with such serious stresses.”

Following statistical analysis of climate data trends The aim of the research is to help local and regional
by the Climate System Analysis Group at the governments, policy-makers, and non-governmental
University of Cape Town, the first phase of research organisations like Oxfam and Save the Children,
has involved working in areas that have already understand how communities adapt, and what kinds
experienced significant changes in climate over the of assistance will be most effective in the face of
last 30 years, within many people’s lifetimes. In current and predicted climate changes.51
Lehurutshe, people are seeing an increase in regular (Source: Oxfam)
periodic droughts; in Dzanani, farmers are
experiencing a more general, significant drying trend
with more pervasive drought; in Uthukela, rural
households have experienced increasing intensity
and variability in rainfall and seasonality; and in
Manjacaze, Mozambique, extreme weather patterns
with floods and droughts are having a severe impact

Up in smoke? 28
Global issues

Why women suffer most from global warming52 areas where gender is likely to be an important factor. Opportunities to direct
Despite their minimal, per-person contributions to greenhouse gas emissions, the climate funds towards women’s real needs have not yet been taken up.
impacts of climate change will disproportionately affect people living in poverty in
developing countries. It’s here where the damage will be highest and where The Global Environment Facility and the Clean Development Mechanism of the Kyoto
people have the lowest capacities to cope. About 70 per cent of the 1.3 billion Protocol could play a role in promoting sustainable development in a way that does
people in the developing world living below the poverty threshold are women, yet not disadvantage women. Special attention also needs to be paid to the opportunities
gender issues receive little attention in the climate change debate. arising from investment in adaptation, which to a large extent involves land-use
solutions in rural areas. This is a key sector as women account for almost 80 per cent
Vulnerability to the hazards of climate change depends on things like wealth, of the agricultural sector in Africa. The dependence of women on biomass energy
technology, education, information, skills, infrastructure, and management means that they should also be involved in projects promoting the diversification of
capability. Women often have less access to these resources than men, increasing energy resources. Further still, women’s knowledge on local adaptation is a resource
their sensitivity and exposure to climate shocks and limiting their ability to cope well worth documenting and building on.
and recover from shocks when they arrive. Gender-related inequalities are
particularly pervasive in the developing world. A better understanding of how poverty in general, and women in particular, are
affected by climate change is needed to influence all efforts to adapt to climate
Women who have to find food for their families will find it more difficult if climate change. Much more human capacity is needed to ensure that those entrusted with
change lowers rainfall and increases drought in their home area. If fish populations are policy development and project work incorporate gender issues. We must continue
subsequently affected by salinity in freshwater systems, one of the primary sources of to listen to the voices of these people over the roar of wealthier countries driving the
protein relied on by women will be at risk. Changing weather patterns could also affect debate in order that the consequences of climate change should not lead already
farming activities such as paddy cultivation in Asia, and cash crops such as cotton and marginalized and vulnerable sections of society into further deprivation.53
tea, the cultivation of which employs many women. Following extreme events such as
storms and floods, the burden of devastation falls primarily on women who must keep Trade and climate54
the family together. Fossil-fuel-dependent global transport networks have grown in tandem with the
trade they help facilitate. And whilst the benefits to poor countries from trade
Ensuring greater gender equality will benefit society as a whole and help promote liberalisation remain the subject of intense academic debate, the economic costs
sustainable development. However, getting gender issues into debates on climate of climate change continue to rise inexorably. International trade is linked to ever-
change and sustainable development is happening piecemeal, extremely slowly, rising greenhouse gas emissions. Between 1950 and the mid-1990s, while total
and often as an afterthought. This is in part due to the lack of participation by world output grew by a factor of five, exports went up by over 14 times. Global
women in decision-making at all levels. This must change, because climate- trade in goods and services grew twice as fast as GDP during the 1990s, and,
change policies will be unsuccessful if women have no opportunity to influence according to the World Bank, the faster rate of growth is a trend likely to continue.
decision-making, build their capacity, lower their vulnerability, and diversify their
income sources. The significant dynamic of this process has been the globalisation of production
and distribution inside multinational businesses. Globalised production within the
The international response to the implications of climate change has largely subsidiary networks of transnational corporations saw components and parts
focused on mitigation (reducing greenhouse gases), and given less attention to making up one third of all trade in manufactured goods by the early 1990s, to a
adaptation (dealing with the adverse impacts of climate change) and the social value of $800 billion. But much international trade lives in a bubble. International
implications of climate change. Neither the UN Framework Convention on Climate aviation and marine fuels are immune from any kind of taxation that would indicate
Change nor the Kyoto Protocol mentions the words ‘poverty’ or ‘deprivation’, let and internalize the real environmental cost of freight and shipping. Greenhouse
alone ‘gender’ or ‘women’. In addition, there has been an absence of discourse on gas emissions from international freight are also exempt from the emissions

Up in smoke? 29
reduction targets set for rich countries to meet under the Kyoto Protocol of the UN
Displacement of local, community-serving economic activity
climate change convention. The transport networks underpinning the movement of

Loss of common property rights in the shift to export led activity
goods are hugely subsidised and their contribution to global warming escapes
international agreements to control greenhouse gases. As well as the free ride for
Social instability resulting from structural economic changes
international marine and aviation bunker fuels, most of the increased demand for

The failure and obstruction of policies designed to mitigate:
freight transport in developing and transition economies is for high-polluting road
transport, and it is growing at up to double the rate of GDP. Environmental impact
Land use conflicts
The impact of climate change will have disproportionately negative impacts on Deforestation, and
developing countries. A dramatic picture of the impact of greenhouse gas emissions
and climate change comes from projecting forward the trend of the last few decades Perverse incentives for resource depletion
of rising economic costs linked to ‘natural’ disasters. Using historical data from
reinsurance giant Munich Re and assuming that current trends were to continue, by The movement of people: environmental refugees –
shortly after the middle of this century – in 2065 – the economic costs of natural the case for recognition56
disasters and an increasingly volatile climate would exceed total world output. Hysteria often walks in the footsteps of refugees and immigrants. In Europe, barely a
day passes without scare stories of crime, fraud, and intolerable burdens placed on
Economic considerations about which patterns of trade bring real benefits to public services. It seems irrelevant that the well-documented reality is that immigrants
different trading partners, coupled with the carbon constraints suggested by global always have made, and continue to make, a vital contribution to Europe’s economy.
warming, both point to the need for new models of trade. The specific
circumstances for a poverty and climate ‘win-win’ scenario need to be worked out. But amidst the irrational fear is a deeper irony. It is now the case that numbers of
Trade will always be an important part of the global economy. But the picture of refugees could be about to increase dramatically over coming years as a direct
who trades what with whom, and how, will have to change if the poorest countries result of the way that the rich global elite lead their lives.
are to benefit and the climate is to be protected
Global warming, more than war or political upheaval, stands to displace many
There is still enormous pressure on poor countries to liberalise their trade regimes millions of people. And climate change is being driven by the fossil-fuel-intensive
but for poor countries who depend heavily on selling primary commodities, lifestyles that we enjoy so much.
increased supply and availability to the rest of the world has meant a long-term
downward trend in the prices they receive for their goods. Several other factors Environmental refugees are already with us. They are people who have been forced
reinforce this trend including corporate consolidation of the marketing chains – for to flee their homes and even cross borders primarily because of environmental
example in coffee – and macro-economic policies pushed by international finance factors such as extreme weather events, drought, and desertification.
capitalists leading to widespread deflation in rural economies.
There are probably more of them already than their ‘political’ counterpart – 25
There are other problems to do with international trade that receive less attention. million environmental refugees in the mid-1990s, according to Oxford academic
In the international trading system poor countries have to run faster to stay still, Norman Myers, compared to around 22 million conventional refugees at the same
whilst at the same time putting greater pressure on their natural-resource base and time. By 2050, mostly due to the likely effects of global warming, there could be
the global ecosystem. A study of the more immediate environmental impacts of over 150 million.57
trade liberalisation in developing and transitioning economies by the UNEP
concluded that there were “serious negative environmental, and related social, The effects of this scale of population movements will be highly destabilising to the
impacts of expanded trade activity”.55 These included: global community unless they are carefully managed. Without action, the countries
least responsible for creating the problem – poor developing nations who already

Land degradation are the major recipients of refugee flows – stand to carry the largest share of
additional costs associated with environmental refugees. As a consequence of

Water pollution
global warming, Bangladesh, one of the poorest countries in the world, expects to

Biodiversity loss have around 20 million such environmental refugees in the coming years.

Up in smoke? 30
Although they do not confer any legal status, the UN’s Guiding Principles on Internal
Displacement are a widely used tool that consolidates existing principles of human The Churches and climate change
rights and international humanitarian and refugee law. It then applies these principles “Here on the small island atoll of Kiribati, the impacts of human-induced climate
to the needs of people forced to leave their homes but remaining within their change are already visible. The sea level is rising. People’s homes are vulnerable
countries of origin – including as a result of natural or human-made disasters such to the increasingly high tides and storm surges. Shores are eroding and the coral
as climate change.58 But, in certain circumstances, however, the suggestion that the reefs are becoming bleached. The water supplies and soil fertility are being
solution must lie purely at the national level could be absurd, since the national level threatened by the intrusion of salt water. Weather patterns are less predictable,
may be under water. According to one study, at least five small island states are at posing risks to fisher-folk and farmers.”
risk of ceasing to exist. There are several serious unanswered questions. What will These words introduced the Otin Taai declaration, produced by the Pacific
happen to the exclusive economic zones of such countries and what status and Churches’ Consultation on Climate Change which met on the small island state
identity will their populations have? Where whole nations become uninhabitable, of Kiribati during March 2004. The consultation involved 50 representatives of the
should they have new sovereign lands carved out for them in other states? Without Pacific Conference of Churches from Kiribati, Nauru, French Polynesia, Niue,
proper environmental refugee status, will the world have to create lots of new little Marshall Islands, Solomon Islands, Fiji, Tuvalu, Vanuatu, Tonga, Samoa, American
Israel’s for the environmentally displaced? Or would they become the first true, World Samoa, New Caledonia, Papua New Guinea, and the Cook Islands. Otin taai,
Citizens? If there is no state left, how can the state protect its citizens? pronounced osin tai, means sunrise, a symbol of hope in the Kiribati language.
Kiribati is not alone in its plight, according to the declaration. Many other island
Sea-level rise in the range expected by the IPCC would devastate the Maldives. nations in the Pacific are experiencing similar impacts of human-induced climate
Without real international legal protection, their people could become potentially change, affecting about seven million people. The signatories promised to
resented minorities in Sri Lanka, itself threatened, or India, with enormous dedicate themselves to engaging Christian Churches internationally in education
problems of its own. On the small South Pacific island of Tuvalu people already and action on the issue. Church-related specialised ministries for emergency-
have an ad hoc agreement with New Zealand to allow phased relocation. Up to 10 response, development, and advocacy were called upon to integrate climate
million could be displaced in the Philippines, millions more in Cambodia, Thailand, change and adaptation projects into their policy development, education, and
Egypt, China, across Latin America, and the list goes on. advocacy. Churches were also asked to encourage companies that are major
producers or consumers of fossil fuels to support a transition towards less
Creating new legal obligations for states to accept environmental refugees would be carbon-intensive economies, reduced energy usage, and the development of
one way to ensure that industrialised countries accept the unintended cleaner, renewable energy sources.
consequences of their fossil fuel intensive lifestyle choices. Just as the 1951 Geneva
Refugee Convention provides protection for people fleeing persecution, a new Over the past few years Dr David Hallman, of the World Council of Churches’
international treaty could address the current gap in the international legal system by Climate Change Programme, has challenged inaction by the US Government over
conferring special status and rights on environmental refugees, forced to flee their the issue. In the US itself, the Catholic Bishops’ Conference issued a statement in
country of origin either because it no longer exists or cannot meet their needs due to 2001, Global Climate Change: A Plea for Dialogue, Prudence, and the Common
the scale of climate change impacts. Good, in which they stated that the level of scientific consensus on global warming
obligated taking action to avert potential dangers. “Since our country’s involvement
Numerous poor countries already cannot afford to meet the basic needs of their is key to any resolution of these concerns,” it said, “we call on our people and
people. Without status, environmental refugees could be condemned by a global government to recognise the seriousness of the global warming threat and to
develop effective policies that will diminish the possible consequences of global
problem to a national economic and geographical lottery, and to the patchwork
climate change.” The Bush Administration was urged to undertake initiatives for
availability of resources and the application of immigration policies. There is a wide
energy conservation and the development of renewable energy. US citizens were
acceptance that current national policies would not be remotely capable of
asked to reflect on their lifestyles as ‘voracious consumers’ and consider living more
handling the scale of the problem. Environmental refugees need recognising, and
simply. In the UK, Christian Ecology Link’s Operation Noah has asked
the problem needs managing before it manages us.
congregations to sign a Climate Covenant petitioning the Government to respond.
On 5 July 2004, the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Rowan Williams, endorsed
remarks made by Sir David King, the government’s chief scientist, describing
climate change as “a weapon of mass destruction”.
(Source: Columban Faith and Justice)

Up in smoke? 31
Learning from history
“History teaches nothing, but only punishes for not learning its lessons” Today, the danger is that the imperatives of trade liberalisation are once again
Vladimir Kluichevsky, Russian medievalist being put before food security and the need to build disaster-resilient economies.
As peasants and farm labourers became more exposed to natural disasters from
History shows that the right kind of resilient economy is the ultimate disaster 1850 onwards – a period when their local economies were violently incorporated
preparedness tool, and that the wrong kind of economic structure significantly into world markets – there were dramatic consequences.
exposes people in poverty to unstable climatic conditions.
Thirty one serious famines happened in 120 years of British rule of India. Only
In Late Victorian Holocausts: El Niño Famines and the making of the Third World 17 famines were recorded in the previous 2,000 years. For Davis the experience
author Mike Davis looks at the experience of 19th century India, China, and Brazil represents “a baseline for understanding the origins of modern global
as a parallel for contemporary development dilemmas. inequality...how tropical humanity lost so much economic ground to western
Europeans after 1850… (and) goes a long way to explaining why famine was able
According to Davis the “forcible incorporation of smallholder production into to reap such hecatombs in El Niño years.”
commodity and financial circuits controlled from overseas” fundamentally
undermined food security, and left millions of people exposed to famine during Similar patterns repeating themselves today around the world suggest that history
El Niño cycles. is punishing us for not learning its lessons.

Indian peasants in general had three practical safeguards against famine

conditions provoked by climate instability: domestic grain hoards; family (silver)
ornaments; and credit with the village money lender and grain dealer. Toward the
end of the 19th century all were lost under the changing balance of power in the
rural economy and the trade imperatives of the British Raj.

Davis maintains that under the British, “Between 1875 and 1900, years that
included the worst famines in Indian history, annual grain exports increased from
3 million to 10 million tons – an amount equivalent to the annual nutrition of 25
million people.”

Today, poverty, planning errors, and an increasingly unstable climate are all
increasing the vulnerability of marginalised people to so-called ‘natural’ disasters.
But, again, history shows that the impact of climate-related disasters can be
drastically reduced under different regimes.

Before the British took control of much of India, local Mogul rulers used a range of
policies to prevent famine taking hold. They relied on embargoes on food exports,
anti-speculative price regulation, tax relief, distribution of free food without a forced
labour counterpart; and ‘zealous’ policing of the grain trade in the public interest.

Although hard to visualise now, Davis speculates that prior to colonial re-
engineering of the majority world economies, “It is very likely that, in the middle of
the eighteenth century, the average standard of living in Europe was a little bit
lower that that of the rest of the world.”

Up in smoke
smoke? 32
 Canaries in the coal mine: The Risk Equation
small island states
Unsustainable development drives
The threats posed to Pacific islands by climate change are varied and far- disaster risk by exaggerating each of
reaching. But they have common vulnerabilities which hamper the ability to these factors:
mitigate and adapt to the negative effects of climate change. These are
problems that show in microcosm what is faced by many other countries. HAZARDS INCREASING: The unsustainable use of
Unprecedented changes in temperatures, sea levels, and weather patterns bring fossil fuels is warming the planet. The resulting
incalculable risks not only to the Pacific’s natural environment, but to economic change in climate is increasing the frequency and
development, health, food security, and public safety. Conventional development severity of weather-related hazards (e.g. floods,
is too often ‘disaster blind’ – it risks exacerbating the vulnerability of island droughts, windstorms) and expanding the range
nations and coastal communities to the volatility of world weather systems. of disease vectors.

The island nations of the Pacific are diverse in many ways, but they share
certain problems in the age of climate change:


VULNERABILITY INCREASING: Hazards only
become disasters when people get in the way.

Small physical size and (often) low elevation. Unsustainable development involves poor land use
(e.g. building on flood plains, unstable slopes, and

Wide geographic distribution and remoteness. coastlines) and environmental degradation (e.g.
bleaching of coral reefs, destruction of coastal

Proneness to ‘natural’ disasters. mangroves, deforestation of water catchments),
which are increasing vulnerability by putting

Rapid urbanisation and dense, growing populations. millions more in harm's way.

Increasing degradation of fragile environments. 

CAPACITY DECREASING: To cope with the effects

Limited natural, human and financial resources. of climate change, vulnerable communities need
enough skills, tools and money. Yet debt

Loss of traditional coping mechanisms. repayments, inequitable trade arrangements,
selective foreign investment, and the redirection of

Export-dependent, open economies. aid funds towards geo-strategic regions, mean that
the poorest and most vulnerable communities lack
the resources to cope. Meanwhile, the inexorable
Small island states cannot solve many of these problems alone. Political and
migration of millions from rural to urban areas – in
financial commitment from developed nations is needed. The IPCC points out the hope of finding work and avoiding disaster – is
that “small island states account for less than one per cent of global undermining traditional coping strategies. On top of
greenhouse gas emissions, but are among the most vulnerable of all this, disasters driven by global warming hit the most
locations to the potential adverse effects of climate change and sea-level vulnerable hardest, further undermining their
rise.” What is happening today to low-lying communities is a warning to capacities to cope with future disasters.
countless other regions around the globe. A stronger, realistic commitment
from the world’s richest, industrialised nations to reduce the risks posed by
climate change will prove in their best interests. It is long overdue.

(Source: The End of Development? nef)

Up in smoke? 33
Women in Zimbabwe picking leaves, the only food available (Photo: ITDG/Keith Machell)

Up in smoke? 34
Endnotes
1 ‘Climate proof’ does not mean to suggest that communities can be completely immunised 19 Tapping the Potential, improving water management in Tajikistan, UNDP National Human
against the impacts of climate change and variability; instead it refers to the need for increased Development Report 2003, and Central Asia: Water and Conflict, 30 May 2002, ICG Asia Report
resilience and reduced vulnerability to be at the heart of development work. 34, International Crisis Group, www.crisisweb.org.

2 Simms, A et al (2004) The price of power: poverty, climate change, the coming energy crisis, 20 McMichael et al, op. cit.
and the renewable revolution, (nef, London). 21 Human Development Report 2003 (UNDP, New York).
3 The precautionary principle suggests that when an activity raises threats of harm to human health 22 McMichael et al, op. cit.
or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause-and-effect
relationships are not fully established scientifically. One of the most important expressions of the 23 UNEP, Environmental Threats to Children.
precautionary principle internationally is the Rio Declaration from the 1992 United Nations
24 Estimates from UNEP, Munich Re & Swiss Re.
Conference on Environment and Development, also known as Agenda 21. The declaration states:
25 Environment and Societal Impacts Group (ESIG) at the National Centre for Atmospheric Research
“In order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach shall be widely applied by States
(NCAR); Centre for Ocean Atmospheric Prediction Studies.
according to their capabilities. Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of
full scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing cost-effective measures to 26 Dockery, DW et al (1993) Harvard University School of Health
prevent environmental degradation.”
27 Working Group on Public Health and Fossil Fuel Combustion, The Lancet 1997
4 McMichael et al (2003) Climate Change and Human Health – Risk and Responses, (WHO, UNEP,
WMO, Geneva). 28 Simms, A et al (2004) The price of power: poverty, climate change, the coming energy crisis,
and the renewable revolution (nef, London).
5. International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (2002) World Disasters Report
2002 (IFRC, Geneva). 29 CAN International (2003). A Viable Global Framework for Preventing Dangerous Climate Change
(2003) – Discussion Paper. www.climatenetwork.org)
6. Lautze, S et al (2002) Qaht -E-Pool - “a cash famine” Food insecurity in Afghanistan 1999–2002
(ODI, London). 30 Letter from Desmond Tutu and other Nobel Laureates to President Wolfensohn, www.eireview.org,
9 February 2004.
7 http://www.worldwaterday.org/2001/thematic/floods.html
31 Warwick, H and A Doig (2004) Smoke the killer in the kitchen: indoor air pollution in developing
8. Human Development Report 1998 (UNDP, New York); World Bank 2002. countries (ITDG Publishing).
9. International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (2002) World Disasters Report 32 The World Energy Outlook 2002 (International Energy Agency, Paris).
2002 (IFRC, Geneva); Simms, A and M Conisbee (2003) Environmental refugees: the case for
recognition (nef, London). 33 World Health Report 2002 (WHO, Geneva).

10. Watson, R et al (2001) Climate Change 2001: Synthesis report, summary for policymakers 34 UNDP (2000) World Energy Assessment: energy and the challenge of sustainability
(Cambridge University Press). (UNDP, New York).

11. Thomas, C et al (2004) "Extinction risk from climate change" in Nature, 8 January 2004. 35 Gon Chauduri won the Ashden Award for Sustainable Energy in 2003.

12 Source: Oxfam report by Gary Iveson and Climate Change and Poverty, DfID, June 2004. 36 IPCC (2001), Summary for Policymakers (A Report of Working Group 1 of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change) online at www.ipcc.ch
13. Africa Environmental Outlook 2004 (UNEP, Nairobi).
37 IPCC (2001), Summary for Policymakers Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation, and
14. The Guardian, 1 July 2004. Vulnerability online at www.ipcc.ch
15 This passage is based on The End of Development (2002) nef & BCAS. 38 International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, Global Warming (2001) magazine issue 2.
16 Cited in Dfid (2001) Addressing the Water Crisis. 39 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (2002) World Disasters Report
2002 (IFRC, Geneva); p 134.
17 Submission to CSD-12 from eight UK NGOs (BirdLife International, Care, Freshwater Action
Network, Green Cross, Oxfam, TearFund, WaterAid and WWF). 40 IPCC (2001), Summary for Policymakers (A Report of Working Group 1 of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change) online at www.ipcc.ch
18 Cited in Dfid (2004) Climate Change and Poverty.
41 IPCC (2001), Summary for Policymakers Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation, and
Vulnerability online at www.ipcc.ch

Up in smoke? 35
42 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (2001) World Disasters Report
2001 (IFRC, Geneva).
43 Sacks, J (2002) The Money Trail: Measuring your impact on the local economy using LM3
(nef, London).
44 Pounds, J et al (1999) 'Biological response to climate change on a tropical mountain' Nature, 398
pp 611-615.
45 Nature, January 2004, ‘Feeling the heat’.
46 IPCC (2002) Technical Paper V, Climate Change and Biodiversity.
47 WRM (2003) Certifying the uncertifiable: FSC certification of tree plantations in Thailand and
Brazil (World Rainforest Movement, Uruguay).
48 UNFAO.
49 Buddemeir, R et al (2004) Coral Reefs and Global Climate Change. Potential Contributions of
Climate Change to Stresses on Coral Reef Ecosystems. (Pew Center on Global Climate Change,
Virginia).
50 Agrawala, S et al (2003).Development and climate in Fiji: focus on coastal mangroves
(OECD, Paris).
51 The project understands ‘adaptation’ to mean the continuous adjustment of a system to moderate
impacts and the use of new opportunities to cope with the consequences. Adaptive capacity is
the ability of the society, household or individual to take advantage of new opportunities, thus
reducing their vulnerability to the harmful impacts of disturbance and change.
See: http://www.shef.ac.uk/adaptive
52 IIED.
53 Rachel Masika (ed.). Gender and Development. Oxfam. Vol. 10, No. 2. July 2002; Fatma Denton.
Point de vue. Bulletin Africain Bioressources no 14, October 2001.
54 Simms, A (2000) Collision Course: free trade’s free ride on the global climate (nef, London).
55 UNEP (1999) Trade Liberalisation and the Environment – lessons learned from Bangladesh, Chile,
India, Philippines, Romania and Uganda: A synthesis report, Geneva
56 Simms, A and M Conisbee (2003) Environmental refugees: the case for recognition
(nef, London).
57 Today the gap would be even greater as global warming drives greater displacement and
official refugee numbers go down. There are 17 million “people of concern” to UNHCR, including
10 million “refugees” (down from 13 million in 2000). Ref: UNHCR 2003.
58 See: http://www.reliefweb.int/ocha_ol/pub/idp_gp/idp.html

Up in smoke? 36
Rano Boymirzeova and Oimkol Amonova (front, with bucket) collect water from the river. Many communities in Tajikistan get their water from rivers or from drainage canals, often heavily polluted with agricultural
chemicals. Oxfam is rehabilitating a pumping station which will ensure clean water to five villages. (Photo: Oxfam)
Supporting organisations (The Working Group on Climate Change and Development)

new economics foundation, 3 Jonathan Street, London SE11 5NH, United Kingdom
This report was co-ordinated by IIED and nef with the Telephone: +44 (0)20 7820 6300 Facsimile: +44 (0)20 7820 6301
involvement of all the supporting organisations. E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.neweconomics.org
International Institute for Environment and Development
It was written and compiled by Andrew Simms from nef, 3 Endsleigh Street, London WC1H 0DD, United Kingdom
John Magrath from Oxfam, and Hannah Reid from IIED, with Tel: +44 (0)20 7388 2117 Fax: +44 (0)20 7388 2826 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.iied.org

contributions from the Working Group on Climate Change

and Development. Design: the Argument by Design – www.tabd.co.uk
Published by nef, October 2004 Registered charity number 1055254 ISBN 1 899407 92 8