Biological Treatment Solid Hazardous Waste
Biological Treatment Solid Hazardous Waste
Biological Treatment Solid Hazardous Waste
ABSTRACT
Continuing with the treatment of solid
and hazardous wastes, this module
looks at methods employed in
biological treatment of these wastes.
IITM-EWRE
Solid and Hazardous Waste
Management
Acclimatization/ Adaptability: This refers to how well the microbial population can adapt to the presence
of contaminants in their nutrient media. It depends on a survival of the fittest strategy. Only when the
micro-organisms adapt to the contaminant, they start secreting enzymes which will eventually break
down the contaminant. For e.g., microbes need to adapt to long chain polyaromatic hydrocarbons if they
are to be used to break down crude oil in an oil spill site.
Composting
Composting is the controlled, aerobic, biological conversion of organic wastes into a more complex stable final
product having a number of beneficial uses most commonly for agriculture and landscaping.
As an aerobic process, composting is dependent on the growth of microorganisms like bacteria, fungi,
actinomycetes, protozoa. Bacteria have the most significant effect on decomposition they are the first to form
colonies in the pile, and begin to break down substances which can decompose readily (sugars, carbohydrates).
Nitrogen fixing bacteria are also present in the pile, and these bacteria will fix atmospheric nitrogen for
incorporation into cellular mass (during cell synthesis). Fungi play an important role in composting as the pile
begins to dry up, as they can tolerate low moisture conditions and have lower nitrogen requirements than
bacteria. Actinomycetes which are present in soil and sediments naturally can decompose aromatics, steroids,
phenols, and slightly larger organic compounds. Macroorganisms such as earthworms, mites, nematodes,
beetles move within the pile foraging for food and thus reduce the volume of the composting pile. Carbon and
nitrogen are required for the metabolic processes of the microbes.
Carbon is available from the waste content, and nitrogen is made available to the bacterial population from the
atmosphere. The ideal C:N ratio is ~25:1. The principal factors affecting composting are nutrient levels, aeration,
moisture, temperature, pH, size of feedstock particles. Suitable temperature range for composting is 28-55oC.
Stages of composting are correlated with the pH of the pile. During the initial stages of decomposition, the pH
is acidic (~5.0); but as the acids are decomposed, pH is as high as 8.5.
The optimal amount of water to be added to a compost pile is:
=
+ 100
+
Where Mp is the moisture content when composting starts (%), Ms is the moisture content of the solids present
(%), Xs is the mass of the solids on wet basis (tons), and Xw is the mass of water (tons).
Consider the decomposition of a glucose molecule in a compost pit:
Aerobic decomposition: C6H12O6 + 6O2 6CO2 + 6H2O + Energy
Anaerobic decomposition: C6H12O6 2C2H5OH + 6CO2 + 6H2O
Degradability of organic waste is described by this stoichiometric equation:
CaHbOcNd + 0.5(ny+2s+r-c)O2 nCwHxOyNz + sCO2 + rH2O + (d-nz)NH3
Where = 0.5[ 3( )], = and =
2
Bioremediation
Bioremediation is the utilization of microorganisms to break down organic contaminants present in soil,
groundwater, and sludge. To stimulate microbial activity, bioaugmentation or biostimulation is done.
Bioaugmentation is the introduction of microorganisms to the contaminated site, if the existing concentration
of microorganisms is too low to be effective. Biostimulation is the addition of nutrient media or electron donors/
acceptors so as to favour microbial growth. Bioremediation may be performed ex-situ or in-situ. In-situ
processes treat the contaminants at the site where they are present, without removal to a different site. Ex-situ
processes involve relocation of contaminated site to a designated treatment area.
Biological processes are usually implemented at a lower cost as compared to physicochemical treatment
processes. Contaminants are destroyed completely in most cases. Sometimes, more toxic by-products are
generated (TCE to vinyl chloride). These contaminants may become mobilized, especially in ground water. To
remediate such a site, bioremediation will be performed above a low permeability soil layer, and groundwater
monitoring wells will be placed downgradient of the remediation area. At times, it becomes necessary to extract
groundwater and treat it ex-situ. Contamination occurs in different zones, as shown in the diagram below. The
unsaturated zone is also referred to as the vadose zone. It is the portion of subsurface above the water table.
Remediation with the help of microbes can be of two types: anabolic and catabolic. Catabolism is the generation
of energy from the degradation of organic contaminants. Bonds which are easily broken contribute to more
energy being released. Anabolism is the synthesis of new microbial cells. fs and fe are the fractions of substrate
(electron donor) going to cell synthesis and energy generation respectively.
+ = 1
fs and fe depend on the type of microbes present, as well as the nature of contaminant. If these fractions are
known, it is possible to construct a complete balanced equation for the redox reaction which takes place. Thus,
we need three components to write the overall reaction:
1. Electron donor half reaction (Rd)
2. Electron acceptor half reaction (Ra)
3. Cell synthesis half reaction (Rcs)
Overall reaction: = +
4
Growth kinetics
A laboratory study of a microbial culture shows five unique phases:
Inhibition:
Inhibitory growth occurs when the substrate becomes toxic to the microbial population, i.e., the concentration
of one or more of the contaminants present is higher than the maximum concentration that can be tolerated
by the microorganisms. Inhibition can also be caused by high concentration of inorganic compounds (metals),
presence of antibiotics produced by other competing microbial populations, or presence of protozoa. Factors
that affect growth rate are: population density, presence of toxins, availability of food, temperature, pH, light,
disease.
Where dX/dt is the growth of the biomass w.r.t time (mg/L min), is the growth rate constant (min-1) and X is
the biomass concentration (mg/L).
When integrated:
= , where Xo and Xt are biomass concentrations at the start of the reaction and at a time t respectively.
Due to the difficulty in measuring rate of equation, a model equation was developed. This is called Monod
growth kinetics, which allows us to calculate the maximum growth rate.
=
Where m is the maximum growth rate constant (min-1), S is the limiting nutrient concentration (mg/L), Ks is the
half saturation constant or the nutrient concentration when =0.5m (mg/L).
The above equation does not take into account the natural death or decay of microorganism. The modified
equation is as follows:
=
+
Where kd is the endogenous decay rate constant (min-1).
If all of the food available to the microorganisms were converted to biomass, the rate of substrate utilization
(dS/dt) would equal the rate of biomass production (dX/dt). Due to the inefficiency of the process, the rate of
substrate utilization will be greater.
1
= .
Where Y is the fraction of substrate converted to biomass. It is also known as the Yield Coefficient.
Combining equations
= , = . , = +
1
= .
+
The objective of bioremediation is to ensure that the hazardous organic substance (carbon source) is the
growth-limiting nutrient. Apart from target substrates, microorganisms require nitrogen, phosphorus, and
micronutrients such as sulphur, potassium, calcium, magnesium, nickel, iron, copper, zinc, and various vitamins.
The minimum amount of micronutrients present should be 1-100 g/L.
0.7
)
0.45 = 0.074 1
6
ln (
Monod kinetics: =
= .
+
7.5 + 6
= 0.074
= 0.167 1
Example: Write a balanced reaction for the aerobic biological conversion of acetate to cells using NH 3 as the
nutrient source.
Given:
= 0.41, = 0.59
1
2 + 20 3 + 20 4+ + + + = 20 5 7 2 + 20 2
Solution:
= 0.1032 + 0.41 + + 0.41 0.2052
= 0.1182 + 0.02953 + 0.02954+ + 0.59 + + 0.59 0.02955 7 2 + 0.26552
= 0.1253 + 0.3752 0.1252 + 0.1253 + + +
= +
= 0.1253 + 0.02954+ + 0.1032 0.02955 7 2 + 0.09552 + 0.0953 + 0.0072
Example: What is the theoretical oxygen demand of this organic compound in an aerobic system?
C6H6O + 7O2 6CO2 + 3H2O
Solution:
1 mole of phenol (MW 94 g) requires 7 moles of O2 (MW 32 g) from the balanced equation.
Therefore, oxygen demand of phenol is
224
94
2
= 2.38
In-situ bioremediation
In-situ bioremediation is the remediation of soils and/or groundwater utilizing naturally occurring
microorganisms in order to biologically break down contaminants present. The media is not removed from its
location. The development of microbial culture within the site can be brought about with oxygen (aerobic) or
without oxygen (anaerobic or anoxic). The advantages of an in-situ treatment system are: ideal for small
operational sites, minimal intrusion to above-ground structures. However, it is not suitable for sites with free
phase contaminants.
In-situ bioremediation of soil involves supplying of oxygen and nutrients to the soil. Two such methods are
bioventing and injection of hydrogen peroxide. Bioventing systems deliver air from the atmosphere to the soil
above the water table through injection wells placed in the contaminated area. Injection of H 2O2 on the other
hand, delivers H2O2 which in turn stimulates microbial activity and helps speed up the biodegradation process.
Injection of H2O2 is done only in instances when the groundwater is already contaminated. Generally, an in-situ
groundwater bioremediation system will consist of an extraction well to remove groundwater, an above-ground
treatment system, and an injection well in order to return the treated groundwater to the subsurface. If soil and
groundwater are both contaminated, a single treatment system would be sufficient.
Fig. 8: Aerobic bioremediation of contaminants microbes take in oil, oxygen, nutrients while releasing gases and water
Source: http://www.epa.gov/tio/download/citizens/a_citizens_guide_to_bioremediation.pdf A Citizens Guide to Bioremediation1.
Oxygen is usually a limiting factor in the progress of these reactions. At times, oxygen content in the media is
enhanced by supplying oxygen externally. The process of supplying oxygen to the unsaturated zone is called
bioventing. This method is used to treat contaminants such as benzene, toluene, acetone, phenol,
chlorobenzene. It can take a long time (few years) for a contaminated site to be completely treated by
bioventing. The process of supplying oxygen to the saturated zone is called biosparging. The success of
biosparging depends on permeability of soil and the degree to which contaminants are biodegradable. This
method is used to treat byproducts of petroleum refining which the soil layer has absorbed.
This refers to the reduction of compounds such as PCE (perchloroethylene). It is a synthetic compound used in
degreasers, spot removers and dry cleaning. In PCE, the oxidation state of carbon is +2. It is difficult to oxidize
PCE. Hence, other compounds should be added, as an electron donor. A suitable electron donor must be found,
which would supply electrons and act as a carbon source. Some electron donors used are acetate and ethanol.
Care has to be taken if the contaminant is the electron acceptor: there must not be interferences posed by other
compounds present in the system. It has been observed that chitin is the most successful electron donor for
reductive dehalogenation. Since chitin is a complex compound, it does not get degraded easily. Hence, there is
no competition from microbes feeding on chitin, as their population will grow slowly. Otherwise, clogging is
seen. Thermodynamically, the reaction with chitin is not very favourable, even though it proceeds to degrade
the halogenated compound. However, it is maintenance-free, which is why it is preferred. Chitin is a good source
of carbon and nitrogen, and can be procured from shrimp shells.
Mechanism of dehalogenation of organic compounds:
10
~100 m2
Two unskilled workers
1.2 kL/ton/day
~INR 16,00,000 for 1 ton/day capacity plant
3 phase AC
Cometabolic bioremediation
This is also known as incidental metabolism. Microorganisms while degrading one contaminant, produce an
enzyme or cofactor that will in turn degrade another contaminant as well. Cometabolic bioremediation can be
aerobic or anaerobic. In aerobic cometabolism, the contaminant is oxidized by an enzyme or cofactor produced
during degradation of another contaminant with oxygen. In anaerobic cometabolism, the contaminant is
reduced by an enzyme or cofactor produced during degradation of another contaminant. There is no energy or
carbon benefit to the microorganisms in cometabolism. Chlorinated compounds like TCE, DCE, VC,
trichloroethane, chloroform, dichloroethane are known to be oxidized cometabolically under aerobic
conditions. The presence of a suitable substrate is necessary for cometabolic bioremediation. The electron
donors in aerobic cometabolic oxidation include methane, ethane, propane, butane, toluene, phenol and
ammonia. For e.g., methane is oxidized to methanol, and during this process methyl monooxygenase is
produced. This enzyme is non-specific, and can degrade many more substrates, thus contributing to degradation
of contaminants. At times, however, some intermediate products may inhibit microbial metabolic activity.
11
Ex-situ bioremediation
Ex-situ bioremediation is a biological treatment process in which contaminated soil is excavated and placed in a
lined above-ground treatment area. Usually, this setup is aerated, to enhance biological degradation of
contaminants. Nutrients and/or microbial cultures are added depending on the availability of each and rate of
degradation.
Bioreactors
Contaminants in extracted groundwater come into contact with microorganisms in attached or suspended
growth biological reactors. In suspended systems (e.g., activated sludge treatment), contaminated groundwater
is circulated in an aeration basin. In attached systems such as rotating biological contactors and trickling filters,
microorganisms are populated on an inert support matrix. Bioreactors are a long term solution. The limitations
of this technology are cost, and the proper disposal of hazardous sludge (in case of treating wastewater from
crude oil refineries). The pollutants treated using bioreactors include VOCs, fuel hydrocarbons, any large organic
compound which is biodegradable.
12
Slurry phase bioreactor is an ex-situ treatment technology for excavated soil. Stones and rubble are first
separated from the soil. The soil is then mixed with water to a specific concentration (which depends upon
concentration of contaminants, predicted rate of biodegradation, and physical properties of the soil). Typically,
a slurry contains 10-30% solids by weight. The slurry is transferred to a reactor and mixed with oxygen and
nutrients. pH is maintained by addition of acid or alkali if need be. Microorganisms are also added if a suitable
population is not present naturally. When biodegradation is deemed complete, the slurry soil is dewatered
(using clarifiers, pressure filters, vacuum filters, sand drying beds or centrifuges). Slurry phase bioreactors are
usually used to treat VOCs, PCBs, halogenated compounds found in pesticides. Some of the limitations posed
by this treatment method are: disposal of non-recycled wastewater is haphazard, dewatering of soil in the final
stage may prove to be expensive.
Design criteria:
Slurry phase bioreactors are operated as batch reactors. Hence, the time required for treatment of waste is an
important design consideration.
ln(
, where
Co and C are the initial and design concentrations of the contaminant (in mg/kg), k is the first order decay
constant (day-1), and t is the time requirement (in days).
Example: A stockpile of 300 m3 of soil contaminated with 3600 mg/kg xylene requires treatment to 100 mg/kg
concentration. Pilot studies document first order kinetics with a reaction rate of 0.03 day -1. What is the time
required for degradation of xylene to desired level of concentration?
Solution:
Using the design equation given above:
=
ln(
ln(
100
)
3600
0.03
= 119
13
Appendix
Half reactions for biological systems
Source: Thermodynamics and Stoichiometry.
http://ocw.usu.edu/Biological_and_Irrigation_Engineering/Biochemical_Engineering/BIE_5810__thermodynamics.pdf
Accessed on August 19, 2014.
15
16
References
1. A Citizens Guide to Bioremediation. USEPA Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response.
http://www.epa.gov/tio/download/citizens/a_citizens_guide_to_bioremediation.pdf Published September
2012. Accessed on 19 August 2014.
2. Introduction to Microbiology. http://web.deu.edu.tr/atiksu/ana52/aryen4.html Accessed on August 19, 2014.
3. Bioremediation: Overview. Contaminated Site Clean-up Information: USEPA. http://cluin.org/techfocus/default.focus/sec/Bioremediation/cat/Overview/ Updated February 24 2014. Accessed on
August 19, 2014.
4. Remediation Technologies Screening Matrix and Reference Guide, Version 4.0. FRTR.
http://www.frtr.gov/matrix2/top_page.html Accessed on August 20, 2014.
5. Constructed Treatment Wetlands. USEPA Office of Water.
http://www.epa.gov/owow/wetlands/pdf/ConstructedW.pdf Published August 2004. Accessed August 20, 2014.
6. Michal D. LaGrega, Phillip L. Buckingham, Jeffrey C. Evans. Hazardous Waste Management: Second Edition.
Environmental Resources Management: Waveland Press, Inc. (2010).
7. Judith L. Sims, Joseph M. Suflita and Hugh H. Russell. Reductive Dehalogenation of Organic Contaminants in Soils
and Groundwater. http://www.epa.gov/superfund/remedytech/tsp/download/reddehal.pdf USEPA
Groundwater Issue. Published January 1991. Accessed on 22 April 2015.
17