Workout No. 5 (Assessment of Road Safety) : 15 MARCH 2016
Workout No. 5 (Assessment of Road Safety) : 15 MARCH 2016
5
(ASSESSMENT OF ROAD
SAFETY)
15 MARCH 2016
Problem 1
In planning for highway improvements in a particular region, the traffic accidents have to be
analyzed to give priority to those hazardous or accident-prone locations. The table shows the twenty
sections considered for analysis. Sections marked with an asterisk (*) have almost similar
characteristics in terms of physical and traffic conditions. Among other marked sections, which would
you consider hazardous at 95 percent level of confidence?
Use:
a. Classic statistic method
b. Rate quality control method
Sectio
n
1*
2
3
4*
5
6*
7
8
9
10*
11
12
13
14*
15*
16
17*
18
19
20
Length,
km
20
35
40
20
50
40
30
50
30
50
20
25
29
30
28
35
42
38
28
31
Daily
volume
30,000
32,000
28,000
29,000
31,500
28,600
28,000
31,000
31,600
30,000
32,000
31,000
32,000
28,000
29,400
31,500
28,600
28,300
32,100
33,100
No. of
accidents
50
85
45
35
50
63
35
42
25
48
55
52
54
37
70
38
63
29
56
43
a.
Section
Xi
X + ks
22.83
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
20.79
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
11.01
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
16.53
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
8.70
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
15.09
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
11.42
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
7.42
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
7.23
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
10
8.78
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
11
23.54
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
12
18.38
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
13
15.94
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
14
12.07
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
15
23.30
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
16
9.44
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
17
14.37
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
18
7.39
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
19
17.07
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
20
11.48
14.14
1.96
5.51
24.93
Hazardous or
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
b.
Y +1.96
.5
Y
1
+
2Vi
2V i
( )
Section
Yi
1
2
22.83
20.79
14.14
14.14
1.96
1.96
19.35
17.91
11.01
14.14
1.96
17.91
16.53
14.14
1.96
19.44
8.70
14.14
1.96
17.30
15.09
14.14
1.96
17.86
11.42
14.14
1.96
18.51
7.42
14.14
1.96
17.33
7.23
14.14
1.96
18.24
10
8.78
14.14
1.96
17.38
11
23.54
14.14
1.96
19.17
12
18.38
14.14
1.96
18.70
13
15.94
14.14
1.96
18.29
Hazardous or
Not
Hazardous
Hazardous
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
14
12.07
14.14
1.96
18.51
15
23.30
14.14
1.96
18.56
16
9.44
14.14
1.96
17.94
17
14.37
14.14
1.96
17.77
18
7.39
14.14
1.96
17.99
19
17.07
14.14
1.96
18.36
20
11.48
14.14
1.96
18.08
Not
Hazardous
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Not
Hazardous
Problem 2
The five-leg roundabout shown below was the scene of 850 accidents in 2004. The annual average
daily traffic is shown in the corresponding route OD table. Determine the accident rate of the
roundabout.
A
B
C
D
E
A
9,040
12,000
450
B
9,000
1,400
400
100
C
11,000
890
910
D
8,500
2,600
2,500
TOTAL TRAFFIC=66310
accident rate=
1,000,000 x no . of accidents
365 x TOTAL TRAFFIC
accident rate=
1,000,000 x 850
365 x 66310
E
500
5,800
1,220
-