Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners

Differentiation is
a teachers response to a learners needs. (Tomlinson)
customizing instruction so every individual experiences continuous learning. (Kingore)

Guiding Principles of Differentiation:

-

Respectful work for all learners.

A,B,C & 1, 2, 3: Teachers can differentiate content, process, & product, according to a
students readiness, interest, & learning style.
Assessment & instruction are inseparable.
Assessment before, during, & after instruction is critical for making appropriate
modifications for gifted learners.
Focus on the essentials.
Modification of content, process, and products.
o Content = what is taught and how students access information.
o Process = how a student makes sense of or comes to understand the information,
ideas, and skills that are that the center of the lesson.
o Product = assessment or demonstration of what students have come to
understand & know.
Replacement tasks should be respectful works that serve a purpose (not busy work).

Recognizing the Needs of Gifted Learners:

Gifted learners are often characterized by
their ability to process information quickly.
their ability to make connections within and among disciplines.
the pace at which they learn.
the depth of their understanding.
the variety of interests that they hold.
Gifted learners need differentiated content, process, product, & affectives.
What it takes to teach gifted learners well begins with the premise that each child should come to school to stretch and
grow daily. It includes the expectation that the measure of progress and growth is competition with oneself rather than
competition against others. It resides in the notion that educators understand key concepts, principles and skills of
subject domains, and present those in ways that cause highly able students to wonder and grasp, and extend their
reach. And it envisions schooling as an escalator on which students continually progress, rather than a series of stairs,
with landings on which advanced learners consistently wait.
- National Association of Gifted Children

Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers

Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

Page 1

Assessment & Mastery:

When all kids have the same answers, I have no clue what they really know. Kingore
Keep in mind: Mastery does not equal perfection.
Ideas for Assessing Readiness:
Individuals: pretests for volunteers, most difficult questions/items first, exit tickets
Whole Group: individual response boards, Four Corners, Topic Talk, Name Cards/sticks
Pretests: Dont reinvent the wheel end of chapter/skill tests work. Set a goal for mastery to
qualify for Compacting (usually 80-85%) to be verified with admin. Plan for grading issues.

How to teachers make it all work?

~ Start small - but start somewhere! Differentiation for small blocks of time. Use anchor activities.
~ Grow slowly but grow! Try creating one differentiated lesson per unit, one project per semester, etc.
~ Give structured choices more often.
~ Step back and reflect.
~ Talk w/ students regularly to get input.
~ Give thoughtful directions.
~ Work together with colleagues.
~ Bring principals and parents on board.
~ Continue to empower students (dont do things for them that they can do for themselves)

Student Management:
Remember, student choice is a powerful motivator.
The Three Magic Rules:
(Winebrenner, 2001)
1. Dont bother anyone else while youre working.
2. Dont call attention to yourself or the fact that youre doing something different its no big deal.
3. Work on activities youve chosen or been assigned.

Effective teaching is responsive teaching.

- Tomlinson

Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers

Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

Page 2

When I differentiate instruction for

Gifted learners, what should I be doing?

Pace Delivery -- Product -- Process (Depth & Breadth)

Change the Pace:
pre-testing Curriculum Compacting
tiered activities
most difficult first
alternate assignments
learning contracts
Independent Study
Learning Centers

Change the Delivery/Content:

mini-lessons
different resources
Curriculum Compacting
open-ended questions
teacher conferences reading journals

Independent Study
previewing resources

Change the Product:

choice boards
Tic Tack Toe menus
RAFT (role, audience, format, topic)
game show menu
student choice options
game creation
technology-based products: websites, Wikis podcasts, movie making

Change the Process - Add Depth:

tiered activities
curriculum ladders

open-ended activities
higher-level questions
student experts
increase complexity
decrease structure

Change the Process - Add Breadth:

Tic Tack Toe menus
your own idea options
case studies

interdisciplinary units
orbital studies
choice boards
RAFT assignments
role plays

Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers

Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

simulations
interest centers

Page 3

Gifted Differentiation: Definitions

Anchor Activities Provide student with relevant, meaningful activities that can be completed independently. Level to meet
different student needs. Used as a management tool for early finishers and small group instruction.
Activity Menus Integrate student choice, different levels of thinking, & multiple intelligence. Menu might focus on a
concept/topic or can cross subject areas. Example: Tick Tack Toe
Flexible Grouping Gifted students are not necessarily gifted in everything. Flexible grouping allows for students to move in
and out of groups based on need, ability, interest, etc.
Peer Teaching Use sparingly. Guiding principles: Every student deserves the opportunity to work with intellectual peers on
appropriately challenging tasks. Gifted students are not always the best teachers Peer teaching is most appropriate for
students who have just gotten a concept not for a student who has already mastered it.
Cubing Allows you to guide student thinking in multiple directions and to differentiate process and product for students of
varying abilities. Dont have time? Consider using think dots correlate activities and questions with the number of dots on
each side of a regular die.
Curriculum Compacting Great way of finding time for enrichment and extension. Guided by demonstration of mastery. Allows
students to substitute projects and activities that more appropriately meet their learning needs. Pre-asses to find out what the
student already knows and what they still need to learn. Document to show mastery. Teach remaining skills in whole/small
group or independently. Provide a replacement activity: extension activity, learning centers, independent projects, subject
acceleration, mentorships. Compacting is especially useful for skill-based areas (math, spelling, grammar, reading strategies,
etc.). Grades should come from pre-assessment (grade level work). Use a learning contract to provide structure.
~ Learning contracts usually feature: 1. A list of content covered in a unit with indicators identifying concepts not mastered
during pretest. 2. Student joins class for direct instruction during those lessons. 3. Extension options (include student ideas)
4.Working Conditions. 5. Signatures at bottom.
Independent Study Use connections to real world problems, student interaction, & depth of content. Topic may be related to
class subject or interest-based. Use a pre-made form to guide project development. Involve media specialist in resource
selection. Note: Be aware of work habits: time management, organizational skills, research, etc. Not all Gifted kids are good
independent workers.
Multilevel or Tiered Activities/Lessons open-ended activities allow students to naturally work at various ability levels. Tiered
activities have two or more levels of difficulty/complexity in regard to content, process, and/or product. Levels assigned based
on data from pretesting. Students must have understanding that not everyone needs the same thing. Each tier must have
motivating and challenging activities that are appropriate for student needs. Samples: paper chain, story map, timeline, Top 10
List, I am character traits, experiments, etc.
Learning Centers Centers may be permanent or temporary (country of the month, author study, art technique, reading topic.
Share with other teachers throughout the year (saves time and money). Making centers work task card w/ brief, clear
directions. Center logs, assignment/choice boards.
Accelerated Learning case by case. Prior approval. Attend class w/ next grade level. Most effective strategy for gifted
learners.
Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers
Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

Page 4

Readiness-Based Adjustments

Abstract Complex Transformational Multi-facets Great Leaps

Open Independence Slow & Deep

Readiness-based adjustments can be created by teachers offering

students a range of learning tasks developed along one or more of the
following continua:
Concrete to abstract. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that involve
more abstract materials, representations, ideas, or applications than less advanced peers.
Simple to complex. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that are more
complex in resources, research, issues, problems, skills, or goals than less advanced peers.
Basic to transformational. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that require
greater transformation or manipulation of information, ideas, materials, or applications than less
advanced peers.
Fewer facets to multi-facets. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that
have more facets or parts in their directions, connections within or across subjects, or planning
and execution than less advanced peers.
Smaller leaps to greater leaps. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that
require greater mental leaps in insight, application, or transfer than less advanced peers.
More structured to more open. Learners advanced in a subject often benefit from tasks that
are more open in regard to solutions, decisions, and approaches than less advanced peers.
Less independence to greater independence. Learners advanced in a subject
often benefit from greater independence in planning, designing, and selfmonitoring than less advanced peers.
Quicker to slower. Learners advanced in a subject will sometimes benefit from
rapid movement through prescribed materials and tasks. At other times, they may
require a greater amount of time with a given study than less advanced peers so that they may
explore the topic in greater depth and/or breadth.

Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers

Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

Page 5

References
Further Reading:
The Dos and Donts of Instruction: What It Means To Teach Gifted Learners Well
http://www.nagc.org/index.aspx?id=659
Meeting the Needs of Gifted Students: Differentiating Math and Science Instruction
http://educationnorthwest.org/webfm_send/755
Reading Instruction for the Primary Gifted Learner
http://www.bertiekingore.com/readinginstruction.htm

Available for Check-Out from Miss Kelly:

Teaching Gifted Kids in the Regular Classroom

-- Susan Winebrenner

Teaching Young Gifted Kids in the Regular Classroom

-- Sumtny, Walker, Meckstroth

References:
Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners
http://www.slideshare.net/drummosh/differentiating-instruction-for-gifted-learners
Doing Differentiation
http://www.slideshare.net/Renegarmath/doing-differentiation
Differentiation for High Ability Learners
http://www.slideshare.net/acoleman/differentiation-for-high-ability-learners-presentation
Differentiating Instruction For Advanced Learners In the Mixed-Ability Middle School Classroom
http://www.kidsource.com/kidsource/content/diff_instruction.html
Prufrock Press Podcast: Gifted Differentiation (22 minutes)
http://resources.prufrock.com/GiftedEducationBlog/tabid/56/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/392/
Default.aspx

Differentiating Instruction for Gifted Learners: A Resource for Classroom Teachers

Deirdre Kelly, Lake Sybelia Elementary September, 2011

Page 6