Scribd
Upload
44 views2 pages

A Case Study On How Performance Based Design Became A New Approach To Determine Fire Protection Strategies

Knowledge Universe - Manufacturing - Benchmarking - Performance Based Design Brings Better Engineering Into Fire Protection

Uploaded by

Basil Oguaka
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
44 views2 pages

A Case Study On How Performance Based Design Became A New Approach To Determine Fire Protection Strategies

Knowledge Universe - Manufacturing - Benchmarking - Performance Based Design Brings Better Engineering Into Fire Protection

Uploaded by

Basil Oguaka
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

12/14/2015

TheManageMentorKnowledgeUniverseManufacturingBenchmarkingPerformanceBasedDesignBringsBetterEngineeringIntoFireProtection(PartI)

||Home||KnowledgeUniverse||KMailerUniverse||KlinksUniverse||JargonUniverse||KQueryUniverse||

PerformanceBasedDesignBringsBetterEngineeringIntoFireProtection(PartII)
Acasestudyonhowperformancebaseddesignbecameanewapproachtodeterminefireprotection
strategies
AmajormanufacturingcompanyintheUShasdecidedtodesignfireprotectionfeaturesforitslarge
building.Notcompletelyconvincedwiththetraditionalprescriptiveapproach,thecompanydecidedtotry
aperformancebasedapproachtoevaluateinvestmentsinfiresafetystandards.
Thefirststep,whenimplementingtheperformancebasedfireprotectiondesignistosetupfiresafety
goalsandobjectives.Thescientificengineeringalternativesshouldthenbemeasuredagainst
predeterminedgoalsandobjectives.Thebuildingconstructor,theownerofthemanufacturingcompany,
HartfordSteamBoiler(HSB)ProfessionalLossControlconsultantsandtheAuthorityHavingJurisdiction
(AHJ)togetherestablishedgoals,objectivesandwaystoevacuatepeopleinthebuildingduringafire.
Forsafeevacuationofthebuildingoccupantsduringafire,thelocalbody,AuthorityHavingJurisdiction
(AHJ)recommendedautomaticsmokeandheatventsinthebuildingroofandalsoontheroofof
enclosedcorridors.Iftheengineeringteamcouldprovethatduringafireinthebuilding,withinthe
required15minuteperiodforevacuation,theresultingsmokelayerwouldnotcomewithin7feetofthe
floorlevel,thereisnoneedtoprovidesmokeandheatventsorenclosedcorridorsinthebuilding.
Theengineeringteamthensetupcrediblefirecircumstancesusingasimulationmodel.Heatreleaseand
firegrowthratesofbuildingmaterialstobeusedinthedesiredgeometryofthebuildingwererecorded.A
computerbasedfiremodelsuccessfullyevaluatedtheexpectedsmokefillingtimesinthebuilding.The
worstcasescenarioswereanalysedanda15%safetyfactorwasalsoapplied.
Thequantitativeanalysisofperformancebasedfireprotectiondesignrevealedthatthelifesafety
standardsinthemanufacturingbuildingscouldbemetwithoutadditionalconstructionrequirements.
Accordingtotheestimates,duringthe15minutetimerequiredforevacuationduringafire,thesmoke
layerwouldbeapproximately19feetabovethefloorlevelofthebuilding.Thisismuchhigherthanthe
minimumrequirementof7feetabovethefloorlevel.
Sincethesimulationsoftheperformancebasedmethodsensuredthatthebuildingoccupantscouldbe
safelyevacuatedduringafirewithouttherequirementofsmokeandheatventsorenclosedcorridors,the
http://www.themanagementor.com/kuniverse/kmailers_universe/manu_kmailers/bp_performance2.htm

1/2

12/14/2015

TheManageMentorKnowledgeUniverseManufacturingBenchmarkingPerformanceBasedDesignBringsBetterEngineeringIntoFireProtection(PartI)

AHJwassatisfiedandapprovedthisapproach.Hence,themanufacturingcompanyhasimplemented
performancebaseddesignandanalysismethodsforitsfireprotectionequipment.
Whentherisksarehigh,performancebaseddesignisapotenttoolfordecisionmaking.
Inthecaseofhighhazards,unusualshapedbuildingsorcomplexindustrialoccupancies,performance
baseddesignisapowerfulapproachtoestablishfireprotectionstrategies.Whenaplanthasbudget
constraints,thisapproachhelpstooptimisetheinvestmentsinfireandexplosionlosscontrol.While
makingcosteffectivedecisions,theplantownershouldbeinformedaboutthefireandexplosionrisks
duringplantoperationsandknowhowdependabletheinstalledfireprotectionsystemscanbe.The
mangersattheplantshouldbeeffectivelycommunicatedabouttheexpectedlevelofrisk.Therefore,
performancebasedapproachisalsocalledriskinformedanalysis.Theperformancebasedapproach
providesameansforquantifyingtheprobabilityofapotentiallossincaseoffireanditseffectssuchas
lifesafetyexposure,propertydamageorbusinessdisruption.Riskrankingallowstheselectionofoneor
manyoftheriskreductionalternatives.
Wiseinvestmentscanbemadeinoneoftheriskreductionalternativesbyassigningandfocusingthe
limitedresourcesofaplantonspecificareasofconsiderablerisk.Acasestudyontheapplicationofrisk
informedanalysistoalargeelectricpowergenerationfacilityisdiscussedinthenextarticle.
RelatedReading
Quantifyingrisk,Holmes,W.,ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer.

KMailerUniverse

Index

Top

Board
BoardofDirectors|Advisoryboard|Partners|Offices|Team|Joinourteam|Press
PrivacyPolicy|Disclaimer|Copyright|Contactus
Copyright2003C&KManagementLimited

http://www.themanagementor.com/kuniverse/kmailers_universe/manu_kmailers/bp_performance2.htm

2/2

You might also like