Three Approaches To Measuring GDP
Three Approaches To Measuring GDP
Thenationalincomeaccountsarebasedontheideathattheamountofeconomicactivitythat
occursduringaperiodoftimecanbemeasuredintermsof:
1. Theamountofoutputproduced,excludingoutputusedupinintermediatestagesof
production(theproductapproach);
2. Theincomesreceivedbytheproducersofoutput(theincomeapproach);and
3. Theamountofspendingbytheultimatepurchasersofoutput(theexpenditure
approach).
Eachapproachgivesadifferentperspectiveontheeconomy.However,thefundamental
principleunderlyingnationalincomeaccountingisthat,exceptforproblemssuchasincomplete
ormisreporteddata,allthreeapproachesgiveidenticalmeasurementsoftheamountofcurrent
economicactivity.
Wecanillustratewhythesethreeapproachesareequivalentbyanexample.Imaginean
economywithonlytwobusinesses,calledOrangeIncandJuiceInc.OrangeIncownsand
operatesorangegroves.Itsellssomeofitsorangesdirectlytothepublic.Itsellstherestofits
orangestoJuiceInc,whichproducesandsellsorangejuice.Thefollowingtableshowsthe
transactionsofeachbusinessduringayear.
OrangeIncTransactions
WagespaidtoOrangeIncemployees
Taxespaidtogovernment
Revenuereceivedfromsaleoforanges
Orangessoldtopublic
OrangessoldtoJuiceInc
JuiceIncTransactions
WagespaidtoJuiceIncemployees
Taxespaidtogovernment
OrangespurchasedfromOrangeInc
Revenuereceivedfromsaleoforangejuice
$15,000
5,000
35,000
10,000
25,000
$10,000
2,000
25,000
40,000
Whatisthetotalvalue,measuredindollars,oftheeconomicactivitygeneratedbythesetwo
businesses?Theproductapproach,incomeapproach,andexpenditureapproacharethree
differentwaysofarrivingattheanswertothisquestion;allyieldthesameanswer.
1. Theproductapproachmeasureseconomicactivitybyaddingthemarketvaluesofgoods
andservicesproduced,excludinganygoodsandservicesusedupinintermediatestagesof
production.Thisapproachmakesuseofthevalueaddedconcept.Thevalueaddedofany
produceristhevalueofitsoutputminusthevalueoftheinputsitpurchasesfromother
producers.Theproductapproachcomputeseconomicactivitybysummingthevalues
addedbyallproducers.
Inourexample,OrangeIncproducesoutputworth$35,000andJuiceIncproducesoutput
worth$40,000.However,measuringoveralleconomicactivitybysimplyadding$35,000
and$40,000woulddoublecountthe$25,000oforangesthatJuiceIncpurchasedfrom
OrangeIncandprocessedintojuice.Toavoidthisdoublecounting,wesumvalueadded
ratherthanoutput:BecauseJuiceIncprocessedorangesworth$25,000intoaproduct
worth$40,000,JuiceIncsvalueaddedis$15,000($40,000$25,000).OrangeIncdoesnt
useanyinputspurchasedfromotherbusinesses,sotitsvalueaddedequalsitsrevenueof
$35,000.Thustotalvalueaddedintheeconomyis$35,000+$15,000=$50,000.
2. Theincomeapproachmeasureseconomicactivitybyaddingallincomereceivedby
producersofoutput,includingwagesreceivedbyworkersandprofitsreceivedbyownersof
firms.Asyouhaveseen,the(beforetax)profitsofOrangeIncequalitsrevenuesof$35,000
minusitswagecostsof$15,000,or$20,000.TheprofitsofJuiceIncequalitsrevenuesof
$40,000minusthe$25,000thecompanypaidtobuyorangesandthe$10,000inwagesto
itsemployees,or$5,000.Addingthe$20,000profitofOrangeInc,the$5,000profitof
JuiceInc,andthe$25,000inwageincomereceivedbytheemployeesofthetwocompanies,
wegetatotalof$50,000,thesameamountdeterminedbytheproductapproach.
3. Finally,theexpenditureapproachmeasuresactivitybyaddingtheamountspentbyall
ultimateusersofoutput.Inthisexample,householdsareultimateusersoforanges.
JuiceIncisnotanultimateuseroforangesbecauseitsellstheoranges(inprocessed,liquid
form)tohouseholds.Thusultimateuserspurchase$10,000oforangesfromOrangeIncand
$40,000oforangejuicefromJuiceIncforatotalof$50,000,thesameamountcomputedin
boththeproductandincomeapproaches.