Retailing NOTES MBA
Retailing NOTES MBA
Retailing NOTES MBA
Arun Chandran
Dhanesh.V.D
Sajith Nair
Sudeep.K.M
Vipin.V.V
INTRODUCTION OF RETAILING
Definition and scope of Retailing
The word ‘retail is derived from the French word ‘retailer’
, meaning cut a piece off or ‘to break bulk’. In simple terms, it implies a firs
t-hand transition with the customer.
Retailing involves a direct interface with the customer and the coordinat
ion of business activities from end to end, right from the concept or design sta
ge of a product or offering, to its delivery and post delivery service to the cu
stomer. The industry has contributed to the economic growth of many countries an
d is undoubtedly one of the fastest changing and dynamic industries in the world
today.
Retailer
A retailer is any business organization that derives more than half of
its sales from retailing. For example, retailing occurs when you purchase gasol
ine at a service station, movie tickets at a theater, or clothing at a departmen
t store. Your local hairstyling salon, your favorite restaurant, and The Gap and
Banana Republic stores at the regional shopping center are retailers. Their suc
cess or failure is ultimately determined by how well they serve you and other co
nsumer like you.
Manufactures
Manufactures business whose primary economic role is the production o
f goods.
Wholesaler
Wholesaler, which acts as market intermediaries between producers a
nd end users of products and services, may engage in retailing activities by sel
ling directly to consumers.
2. Integrated Marketing
When all the departments of the company work together to serve the customer’s in
terest or needs, the result in integrated marketing
Examples of Integrated Marketing
The marketing Vice President of a major European airline wants to increase the a
irlines traffic share. His strategy is to build up customer satisfaction through
providing better food, cleaner cabins, better-trained cabin crews and lower far
es; yet he has no authority in this matters. The catering department chooses foo
d that keeps down food costs; the maintenance department uses cleaning services
that keep down cleaning costs, the human resource department hires people withou
t regard to whether they are naturally friendly, the finance department sets the
fares. In such a way that the Vice President of marketing creates an integrated
marketing mix.
The theory of the wheel of retailing can be understood by taking the examples of
department stores which started as low-cost competitors to the small retailers;
they developed and prospered; then they were severely undercut by supermarkets
and discount warehouses.
This theory does not explain the development of retail in all markets. In less d
eveloped markets, introduction may not necessarily occur at a low price, there,
introduction may occur at a high price.
Accordian Theory
Hollander was a key observer of retail evolution and he used the analogy of an o
rchestra comprised exclusively of accordion players to describe the dynamically
shifting retail structure.
This is so called ‘accordion’ effect describes how general stores moved to speci
alized stores, but then widened their range of merchandise again, as new classes
of product were added. Hollander suggested that the players either have ‘open a
ccordion’, representing general retailers with broad products ranges, or closed
‘accordions’ thus indicating a narrowing of the range, focusing on specific merc
handise. He suggested that at any point in time, one type of retailer would outn
umber the other, but that the situation would continually change the arrival and
departure of different stores. This analogy illustrates the complexity of the r
etail scene, and the way different attitudes to successful retailing will come i
n and go out of fashion at different times. The Accordion theory and the Wheel o
r Retailing is known as the cyclical theories of retail evolution.
Conflict Theory
Conflict s will always exists between operators of similar formats or within bro
ad retail categories. It is believed that retail innovation does not necessarily
reduce the number of formats available to the consumer, but leads to the develo
pment of more formats. Retailing thus, evolves through a dialectic process, i.e,
the blending of two opposites to create a new format. This can be applied to de
velopments in retailing as follows;
(a)”Thesis”: Individual retailers exists as corner shops all across the country
(b) “Antithesis”: A position opposed to the thesis develops over a period of ti
me.
These are the department stores. The antithesis is a challenge to the thes
is.
(c) “Synthesis”: There is a blending of the thesis and the antithesis. The resul
t is a
Position between the “thesis” and t he “antithesis”. Supermarkets and hypermarke
ts thrive. This “synthesis” becomes the “thesis” for the next round of evolution
.
We can classify the different approach to quality management into two categories
: first, the product-attribute approach; second, the consumer oriented approach
(Gilbert and Joshi, 1992). The product- attribute approach is based upon trying
to match the product’s conformance to standardized requirements which have been
set by reference to what company managers think the failure point to be. Product
- attribute approaches rely on trying to control the company’s output by using a
nd internal standard –setting perspective. This relies on an inward- looking and
trading-led management style, rather than a marketing-led approach.
It would seem more appropriate to adopt a consumer- oriented approach which reco
gnizes that the holistic process of service delivery has to controlled by taki
ng into consideration the expectations and attitudes of retail customers. If the
starting point for management is the understanding of how quality is judged by
customers then the perception processes of this judgment, as to whether a servic
e is good or bad, can be managed. Gronroos is a leading author who has defined t
his concept.
THE GRONROOS MODEL OF PERCEIVED QUALITY MANAGEMENT
Gronroos (1982) developed a model, which is a form of gap analysis to explain wh
at he calls the ‘missing service quality concept.’ The model (Figure) focuses ma
inly on the construct of image which represents the point at which a gap may occ
ur between expected service and perceived service. Grnroos allows us to be aware
of the ways that image is created from the aggregation of different aspects of
technical and functional variables. By following his model of different inputs w
e are alerted to the fact that we should not reduce quality to a simplistic desc
ription of itself but that we should try to understand the full range of inputs.
This is because to speak simply of quality gives the manage “no indication of w
hat aspects of the whole retail experience should be controlled. Gronroos argues
the function and range of resources and activities includes what customers are
looking for, what they are evaluating, house service quality is perceived, and i
n what way service quality is influenced. Gronroos defines ‘perceived quality’ o
f the service as dependent on two variables: experienced service and perceived s
ervice, which collectively provide the outcome of the evaluation.
Gronroos distinguishes between technical quality and functional quality as the c
omponents of the service image delivery:
1. Technical quality – refers to what the customer is actually receiving fr
om the service. This is capable of objective measurement, as with tangible goods
.
2. Functional quality – refers to how the technical elements of the service are
transferred or perceived. We know that a customer in a restaurant will not only
evaluate the quality of the food consumed, but also the way in which it was deli
vered (the style, manner and appearance of the staff or the ambience of the plac
e itself). Figure shows that he management can influence the attitudes, behavior
s and general service mindedness of personal.
The Parasuraman, Zeithamal and Berry model
Parasuraman et al. (1985) have also developed a model of service quality, which
claims that the consumer evaluates the quality of a service experience as the ou
tcome of the difference (gap) between expected and perceived service (Fig). The
model highlights the main requirement for a service provider delivery the expect
ed service quality. From the model five gaps may be identified that could lead t
o unsuccessful service delivery. By understanding this model, it is possible to
provide greater management control over retail customer service relationships. T
his should lead to an improved realization of the key points at which the market
er can influence the satisfaction of the consumer. The marketer is then in a bet
ter position to be able to reduce or close the gaps.
Gap 1: Ignorance of the customer’s expectations
This is the gap between consumer expectation and management perception. The gap
may result from a lack of understanding of what consumers expect from a service.
The literature confirms this disparity by revealing that what providers perceiv
e as being important to consumers is “often different from what consumers themse
lves actually expect. The gap may relate to a lack of communication or feedback
from customers or an unpreparedness to address important changes, which are requ
ired.
In the early 1990s, Sears failed to realize that customer buying habits had chan
ged and the company retained its traditional catalogue when the customers had em
barked upon different modes of shopping. In the modern marketplace there is a ne
ed for responsive and adaptive adjustment to the service provision, based upon f
eedback from staff at all levels in the company. In addition, good relationship
marketing programmes should also help in the reduction of customer and “company
problems – arising from different expectations of what constitutes of what const
itutes an ‘appropriate’ service.
MODULE-II
Ajith.P
Jayadeva Krishnan
Pillai Prajith Ramachandran
Ratheesh.R
Vimal Dev.
RETAIL PROMOTION
Retailers communicate to their customers on a continuous basis through t
he store atmosphere, the products and services, promotional literature, advertis
ing and other promotional means. Retail promotion is the descriptive terminator
the mix of communication activities which retail companies carry out in order
to influence those publics on whom their sales depend. Retailing promotion will
have the main objective of influencing consumer perceptions, attitudes and behav
iour in order to increase store loyalty, store visits and product purchase. How
ever, the important groups which need to be influenced are not simply the target
market group of current and potential customers. There is a need to influence
trade contracts such as agents and suppliers as well as opinion formers such as
journalist and writers. Even local, national and international politicians and
important professional groups may need to be influenced.
ADVERTISING
The term advertising includes any paid form of non-personal communicatio
n through the media about a product, that has an identified sponsor. The use of
payment differentiates advertising from public relations for which no payment i
s made for the time or space to convey a message. The media may include telepho
ne directors, guides, newspapers, magazines, radio, television, direct mail, Web
pages and billboards. It is normally associated with mass communication, where
a broad target market is to be contracted.
Advertising is used to achieve a whole range of objectives which may inc
lude changing attitudes or building image as well as achieving sales. Advertisi
ng is often described as above the line promotion with all other forms of promot
ion being termed below the line. The difference between above and below the li
ne is simply academic now as the emphasis is on both areas, for example sales pr
omotion and advertising, working together to achieve the greatest impact.
Moreover, in decisions over communication plans, it is the cost-effectiv
eness that matters most. The use of different combinations of what has traditio
nally been known as above and below the line has blurred the meaning of the term
s and there are may promotional strategies which can be seen to erase the line,
or, as it is known, pass ‘through the line’; With direct mail being used to bui
ld awareness and TV being used to sell products direct to the consumer, there is
a great deal more flexibility in the use of different promotional mediums.
Communication theorists have proposed several models to explain the way
advertising works and each have some similarity. One model known as the DAGMAR
model (Defining Advertising Goals for measured Advertising Results) describes th
e sequence of stages through which the prospective customer has to move:
• Unawareness;
• Awareness;
• Comprehension of the offer;
• Conviction;
• Action
Through advertising, the retailer will make the potential customer aware of the
store and its range of offer. As part of the advertising communication process,
information has to be clearly transmitted so it can be decoded and comprehende
d properly. The process is then to make the offer credible so that the potentia
l customer can be moved to a favourable attitude to the store or product. The a
ct of purchase may then follow.
Advertising has the potential to affect a large number of people simul
taneously with a single message. The secondary effect of of advertising is pers
onal communication among consumers. This is known as the two-step flow of comm
unication. The first step in the process is the communications flow from media
to opinion leaders- the individuals whose attitudes, opinions, preferences and
actions affect others. The second step is word-of-mouth communications from opi
nion leaders to others (followers). This communication can occur through person
al conversation between friends or with work colleagues based upon communication
about the store or its offers. It can also occur through non-verbal communica
tions when someone displays news bought merchandise in their home or by means of
the labels on or in their clothes. One implication of the need to achieve as mu
ch benefit s possible from the two-step model is the requirement to reach and in
fluence opinion leaders.
Types of advertising
Product advertising
Product advertising is aimed at enticing people to the store in order to
consider specific merchandise. Product advertising will feature the promotion
of merchandise that is new, exclusive, and superior in aspects of quality and de
sign as well as creating awareness of complete assortments or special merchandis
e events. It is aimed at creating awareness of the product, its availability an
d benefits.
Markdown event advertising.
This is used to create some excitement about a special period of lower c
ost offers for products. It is likely to be more successful if the reduction is
believed to be part of a genuine sale of products which in the past had been fa
irly priced.
Institutional advertising
This type of advertising is used to sell the store or shopping mall as a
pleasing place to shop. With the use of institutional advertising, the store a
ttempts to reinforce the image of one or more of the following: a leader in fash
ion, fair prices, wide merchandise selection, superior service or quality, a lei
sure experience of somewhere to en joy visiting. There is now a trend to a adver
tise a shopping center rather than individual outlets. The communication emphas
is is on the available range of shops, case of parking or other consumer benefit
s. The frequency of this type of advertising increase at peak demand times such
as Christmas.
Co-operative advertising
This is used where manufacturers fund part of a promotion by supplying
leaflets or advertising material for use by the store. The store can add its o
wn address to ready prepared printed material and carryout mail drops or other m
ethods of distribution. Alternatively a manufacturer may agree share equally the
costs of an advertiseing campaign. Manufacturers are keen to have their brand
s stocked and sold’ therefore; they often enter into joint advertising schemes w
ith retailers. Co-operative advertising may involve a combination promotions ma
y well extend to agreements to provide joint branded window display material and
point of sale material.
Retail promotion in relation to that of manufacturers
There are differences between retailer and manufacturer advertising stra
tegies. Retail advertising is often based upon short-term objectives with the e
mphasis on value or price of the products on offer. This is unlike manufactu
rers’ approaches; they often attempt to build favourable attitudes to improves t
he image of the brand or organization over in extended period of time, Where
as a manufacturer will need to create awareness of its brand across major market
areas, a retailer may have more geographically concentrated target markets. Th
erefore, a retailer has to take into account local habits, conditions of the mar
ketplace, availability of local media and have a clear idea of the housing areas
where potential customers are living.
The expense of some forms of advertising is excessive-for example TV adv
ertising is extremely expensive due to production as well as transmission costs
– and therefore only the larger companies or franchisers will use this medium.
The alternative use of direct marketing is often a more cost –effective form of
promotion for smaller more geographically dispersed retailers.
Push versus pull strategy
The promotional decisions have to consider whether the company chooses a
push strategy or a pull strategy or a balance of the two. A push strategy invo
lves pushing the consumer through the channel (see fig. 5.9 (a). As retailing
is a channel service this approach is unlike that of more traditional forms of p
roduct marketing as it is the channel service which is promoted. Then pull strat
egy is where marketing promotion activities are targeted to the consumer to indu
ce them to buy the retailer’s merchandise or service (see Fig. 5.9 (b)) Retailer
s may enter third parry agreements for promotion whereby by cost of the promotio
n is shared between the retailer and the manufacturer to encourage more sales of
the manufacturer’s product.
Promotes the benefits of the store and channel
Retailer Customer
(a) Push strategy
(b) Promotes the benefits of produ
cts Customer
(c) Pull strategy
With the growing use of relationship marketing and the compilation of customer d
atabases, retailers have been concentrating more on push rather than pull strate
gies. Companies are increasing their efforts to select the most appropriate tar
get groups to direct offers at. This allows marketing programmes to be more fin
ely targeted, with literature for sale periods, special events or offers being t
ailored to suit the individual customer group.
SALES PROMOTION
Sales promotion involves any paid non-personal marketing communication a
ctivity; other than advertising, which offers an incentive to induce a desired r
esult from potential customers, trade intermediates, or the sales force . This
is sometimes referred to by the term sales incentive. Sales promotion campaigns
will add value to the product because the incentives will generally not accompa
ny the product but will typically be offered as mail drope or as coupons to be c
ut from newspapers, etc. It is usual for a sales promotion campaign to be used
as a temporary offer to the customer in order to stimulate an immediate response
. For example, free samples or money-off vouchers and offers are frequently use
d in sales promotion campaigns for brands or companies which need to improve dem
and at certain periods. Included in these campaigns are displays, contests, swe
epstakes, coupons, frequent user (loyalty) programmes, prizes, samples, demonstr
ations, referral gifts and other limited duration selling efforts not included i
n the other techniques-see summary of types of sales promotion below. Most inc
entives are planned to be offered on a short-term basis only.
Sales promotion is often used in combination with other promotional too
ls in order to supplement the overall effort. However, it has to be remembered
that it is sometimes difficult to terminate or change special promotions withou
t causing adverse effects. Loyalty programmes are an example of this (see follo
wing section on relationship marketing) A sales promotion for series of promoti
ons) also has to take account of the likely effect it may have on the image of t
he brand or outlet due to the negative perception change which may occur due to
association with banal and frivolous promotions.
To evaluate a sales promotion the retailer should consider.
• the cost of the promotion in employee time, as well as for the cost of a
ny merchandise, giveaway items or promotional literature’
• the increase i8n sales and profit, or improvement in awareness, based up
on the campaign;
• whether the campaign had secondary effects of switching demand from othe
r retailer products;
• whether there were any additional sales outside of the promotion, due to
customers being attracted to the store.
It is not always way to isolate the above effects from other factors, but it is
always important to make some assessments of the benefit of different types of p
romotion.
RELATIONSHIP MARKETING –LOYALITY SCHEMES
The retail marketplace is maturing and due to a slow down in growth is becoming
more competitive. Against the backdrop, retailers seek different ways of improv
ing sales and profits. In order to address these problems retailers are adoptin
g relationship marketing (RM) schemes based upon loyalty cards which aim to:
• build greater customer loyalty and retentions
• develop methods of creating longer-term relationships
• Lead ultimately to increased sales and profits
RM has been defined by Gronroos (1990, 1991, 1994) who has consistently argued f
or the importance of ensuring that relationships with customers should be contin
uously developed.
Marketing is to establish, maintain and enhance relationships with customers and
other partners, at a profit so that the objectives of the parties involved are
met. This is achieved by a mutual exchange and fulfillment of promises.
Gronroos argues that all marketing strategies lie on a continuum ranging
from transactional to relational marketing, where relationship marketing can be
judged in terms of measures of customer retention rather than market share. Ch
ristopher et al. (1996) have developed the ideal of a ladder whereby relationshi
ps, develop as part of growing custo9mer loyalty (see Fig. 5.10)
The RM process helps to advance relationships to higher levels until adv
ocates status is achieved. This is where the customer as advocate is not only
loyal but also champions the company the employees and service to others. RM s
hould not be confused with band loyalty based upon commitment to the produce RM
is a far more complex and wider alliance and association.
The rationale for RM is that it makes business sense to focus on long
term financial benefits which may accrue once a customer has been won for the fi
rst time. This is because it has been estimated it is five to ten times more
expensive to recruit a new customer than to retain an existing one. This is bas
ed upon the estimated cost of prospecting, advertising and selling, commission,
product samples, credit checking administration and database management. The tr
ue value of retaining customers is that it enables the costs of conversion of th
e prospect to the set against the revenues earned over the longer term. Sales a
nd profits improve in direct proportion to the longer a relationship lasts.
RM requires the effective acquisition and reaction of customers for the
building of a more efficient operation and, ultimately, a stronger competitiv
e position. Acquisition is based upon the traditional approach to marketing wit
h the identification of customer needs, development of a retail offer to satisfy
those needs, and then the targeting of prospects. The movement from acquisitio
n through a retention is checked in the following.
Acquisition:
• current methods used to acquire customers from prospects, which then req
uire effective retention. (Customers must be given an incentive to part with th
eir personal information and be recruited to any scheme.
Retention
• identify more about customer through database analysis;
• improve and make the retail/offer/service more attractive;
• inform to build customers’ knowledge of the company;
• tempt customers through special targeted offers to purchase more regular
ly, try different products, etc.
• retain the customer by developing and delivering different forms of loya
lty schemes and rewards;
• higher patronage should provide increased customer value to company, wh
ich should result in higher profits and the ability to make increased investment
in further acquisition of new members to the scheme.
The foregoing process can be viewed as an increasing outward spiral which places
the company in stronger and stronger position.
Incentivesed relationship marketing has become more prominent during the 1990s
following the launch of loyalty card schemes. The customer is rewarded for the
ir loyalty through the collection of points which entitle them to money oft prod
ucts, free items and other incentives such as Air Miles or charity donations. It
would be useful if we were to define loyalty: Loyalty is
A state of mind which predisposes an individual toward a particular reta
iler and leads to a higher than normal proportion of expenditure to be devoted t
o the retailer’s offers.
Relationship marketing or loyalty schemes have a number of benefits for the reta
iler.
1. The retailer can accurately track the purchasing habit of large numbers of lo
yalty scheme members and this enables the acquisitions of important data which
can be utilized for planning and promotional purposes.
2. A good scheme will lead to repeat purchases through targeted incentives and b
enefits to visit the retail outer and make purchases.
3. The scheme will act as a promotion for new customers and they’ in turn, can t
ell others about their experience.
4. The customer may be willing to pay higher prices if the scheme enhances the
purchase experience.
5. Customers will not take as much notice of alternative offers and promot
ions if they are already linked into a worthwhile loyalty scheme.
PERSONAL SELLING
Personal selling is an attempt to gain benefit through face to face or tel
ephone contact between the seller’s representative and those people with whom th
e seller wants to communicate. This may be based upon sales activity in-store,
evening calls to try to sell services or products, or sales calls by paid salesp
ersons either to companies or to private individuals. The importance of persona
l selling differs among retail businesses on the basis of the type of merchandis
e offered. A retailer offering low-risk, low price goods, which are promoted, n
eed only employ sales staff who can complete the transaction and deal with minor
enquiries. The typical information required will be the current policy non red
uctions or special offers, guarantees or possible methods of payment. While the
demanour of the staff in this situation is important, there is little sales neg
otiation skill required to conclude the transaction. However, it should be no
ted the trends is toward retailers reducing the number of sales personnel by off
ering greater self-selection of products in order to save on sales staff costs.
In a store where there are highly priced or more complex items for sale the con
sumer has to cope with not only finding a salesperson to relate to but also one
who has expert information. Such retail sales employees are often viewed as o
rder takers but they should be viewed as order procurers. This is because
for higher risk purchases customer, utilize and seek out expert advice and he
lp. Situations where it is important to have trained staff are:
• where the item hasto be made to fit the customer’s specific requirements
, for example a wedding dress or made-to-measure clothes;
• where the product is technically complex and the range is wide. For exa
mple a computer or a video camers;
PUBLIC RELATIONS
Public relations is non-personal communication which changes opinion or
achieves coverage in a mass medium, which is not paid for by the source. The co
verage could include space given to a press release or favourable editorial comm
ent. Public relations (PR) is important not only in obtaining editorial coverag
e, but also in suppressing potentially bad coverage. A company which has good l
inks with the media is more likely to have the opportunity to stop or moderate n
ews which could be damaging to the company. Consumer affairs television progra
mmes quite often berate retailers for poor service or dangerous products. More
recently, the use of cheap child labour in the production of merchandise for Wes
tern markets has become a newsworthy subject. This all requires sensible public
relations reaction in order to retain a positive image for the retail company a
nd industry.
The major benefit of PR is that it can promote and enhance a company’s i
mage. This is very important for service-based companies which are reliant on
a more tangible positive image in order to be successful. RR is highly credi
ble form of communication as people like to read ‘news stories’ and will beli
eve them to be less biased than information provided in advertisements. However
, editorial decisions over what is communicated will mean control over the messa
ge, its timing, placement and coverage is out of a company’s hands.
PR activity can either be planned or unplanned. Planned activity means
the retailer attempts to retain control over the activity and news release. Wi
th unplanned activity, the retailer simply reacts in the most beneficial way to
the chance of some publicity or to suppress a negative news item. Planned publ
icity will involve sending press releases and photographs to the media (trade p
apers, local and national press, radio and television), organizing press confere
nces for more newsworthy events, sending letters to editors of journals or local
newspapers, organizing different creative ‘stunts’ to acquire the right tone of
media coverage, and making speeches 9or writing articles) on informed retail is
sues in order to be perceived as a well-informed company. The media are interes
ted in their own circulation, listening and viewing figures and therefore, to be
successful all PR has to be newsworthy and of benefit to media interests. New
and unusual information on new products or technology, expansion and development
plans, human interest stories about staff and their achievements – all written
up and complemented by photographs- may be placed in trade and local press.
OTHER IMPORTANT PROMOTIONAL TOOLS
Within the field of promotion, there is the important area of visual mer
chandising. Advertising may encourage consumers to visit the store but the reta
iler’s display may make the difference between making a sale or not. The use of
visual merchandising includes visual materials and window displays used in reta
il outlets to stimulate sales. Visual merchandising is non-personal in-store pr
esentation and exhibition of merchandise, along with printed forms of communicat
ion. The approach is to :
• ensure maximum product exposure.
• Provide displays which enhance product appearance and create interest;
• Provide sales and product information such as display cards and posters;
• Allow for storage and security pf stock;
• Generate additional sales through impulse purchases or by reminding the
consumer of what is on offer based upon a message which is directly related to t
he product.
It retailers rely on self-service of items then a selection display such as th
ose found in greetings card or music shops is required. Selection displays are
generally open to facilitate easy browsing and inspection. Retailers use selec
tion displays to exhibit their everyday assortments of convenience or shopping g
oods. Effective use of this approach requires a logical grouping of the merchan
dise by its usage. Ease of selection through uncomplicated, well-organised arr
angements will increase sales. There are also special displays which are placed
in well-exposed locations to bring some interest to the store. These can offer
a dramatic impact by the use of display equipment and merchandise. Point-of pu
rchase displays are a particular type of special display which will be on the co
unter, in the store window or other relevant places. The visual display may inc
lude banners, counter, in the store window or other relevant places. The visual
display may include banners, counter cards, end-aisle stands, video -screen di
splays, floor-stand displays and shelf extenders.
There is a growing use of sponsorship and direct marketing which do not
comfortably fit into the other four promotion categories (See Fig. 5.12) . spons
orship is treated much more seriously today, with sponsors adopting sophisticate
d planning, selection and evaluation procedures for their sponsorship programmes
.
Direct marketing is being used more extensively by a range of direct sel
l companies as a means of utilizing a retailer’s loyalty scheme’s database addr
ess list. The main method is direct mail which a postal communication by an id
entified sponsor. This is being expanded into database marketing based upon rel
ationship marketing principles and an increasing use of telephone sales campaign
s. Direct methods of contracting prospective customers are used to :
• encourage store visits from new customers;
• increase sales when there is a unique or special merchandise offer to b
e made;
• take full advantage of using the information from one department to cros
s sell other aspects of the store or its services’
• build loyalty programmes in order to retain customers and increase reven
ue;
• improve the image and competitive position of the store in relation to
the competitors;
• send out special offers for low season or sales periods in order to incr
ease in-store traffic and sales. There is often resistance to too much direct
mail as it is often associated with ;junk mail’ Good direct marketing selects th
e target carefully and provides the correct offer.
CHARACTERISTICS OF PROMOTION
Each of the promotional elements discussed above has the capacity to ach
ieve a different promotional objective. While personal selling has high potency
for achieving communication objectives only a relatively small number of peopl
e can be contracted. Therefore, advertising is a better method of reaching a hi
gh number of people at low cost. Public relations is more credible than adverti
sing but there is more control over what is communicated through advertising mes
sages and these messages can be repeated on a regular basis. When it is diffic
ult to raise advertising budgets, public relations is a lower cost alternative b
ut it is difficult to control the timing and consistency of PR coverage. Sales
promotions, such as leaflet drops which offer retail price discounts may produce
an initial trial for a product- for instance, the purchase of a product which i
s being launched into the market- but this type of promotion is most suitable if
used only for a short term period.
Each part of the promotions mix has its own strength and weakness. Whil
e this may include the factors of cost, ability to target different groups, and
control, there are other important considerations. Figure 5.12 indicates the re
lative strengths of each of the four form of promotion: advertising, personal se
lling, PR and sales promotion. They are compared on the basis of the level of aw
areness of the communication and its comprehension, as well as whether it can b
uild conviction and succeed in creating action.
PLACE –SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
The special characteristics of retail business and the emergence of maj
or retailers in the marketplace have led to specific forms of distribution or ch
annel service. Prior to consumption, the retail product has to be both available
and accessible. This requires a supply chain distribution system. A distribut
ion system is the channel used to bring items to the place of sale, or the means
by which a retail supplier gains access to the potential buyers of the product.
More recently the efficiencies of supply chain management linked to TT have m
ade major differences to the effectiveness of retailers and their overall profi
tability. (Read chapter 10 in order to understand the way IT has changed the wh
ole field of distribution logistics). With the ever- growing size and dispersal
of retail operations, controlling merchandise as part of store operations has b
een of paramount importance. This goes beyond an administration system ; mode
rn supply chain management can achieve competitive advantage through shorter lea
d times for restocking, reduced inventory size and costs, improved management i
nformation and greater overall control.
Retailing cannot be divorced from an understanding of the supply chain a
s the following retail definition from Davies (1993) indicates:
The management of resources to supply the product and service needs of
the end- consumer, encompassing the supply chain of any physical products and th
e exchange processes involved.
The supply chain includes all the activities and exchanges involved in e
xtracting processing, manufacturing and distributing goods and services from raw
materials through to the end consumer. Supply chain management requires a holi
stic view of these activities and an innovative approach to their organization,
in order to meet customer needs with the greatest efficiency.
CHANNELS AND CHANNEL FLOWS
There are different supply chain structures based upon extended, limited
and direct channels. The discussion of supply chain management here will conce
ntrate on the extended channel of retail distribution as this is the most preval
ent. An extended channel is where the manufacturer, wholesaler and retailer pro
vide a chain of facilitating services in order to sell the right product to the
final customer. The limited channel is when a retailer work directly with the pr
oducer and, therefore, can eliminate the wholesaler and the extra costs of this
part of the chain. The retailers of furniture, white goods, electrical goods, a
nd so on quite often deal direct with the supplier and create limited supply cha
nnels. The final alternative is the direct channel. In this case the product i
s sold direct by either the producer or retailer. By using different direct sa
les marketing promotions such as direct mailing, Internet services, telephone s
ales techniques etc. The channel is kept direct and the extra charges and commi
ssions are thus eliminated. This allows some of the saving to be passed on to
the customer who will purchase on the basis of lower price. It is important to
realize that whatever part of the chain is eliminated, some of the functions o
f that link in the chain have to remain. Even if the retailer were to be dispe
nsed with, some of the retail functions have to remain in order to achieve a tra
nsaction.
Within ay of the different types of channel the flow is not restricted t
o physical goods alone. Other types of flow of equal importance in ensuring the
channel is successful are as follows:
Physical flow: the movement of goods and method of transport, from one part of t
he chain to another.
Ownership flow: the transfer of title for ownership/usage from one channel membe
r to another. This is important for legal aspects of delivery, damage and stora
ge by the producer and intermediary as well as for the final customer;
Service flow:- if services are rendered as part of the process or the end produc
t is a service or mainly service based, it is necessary to ensure all the char
acteristics of the services are fully understood;
Information flow”- there is a need for timely and accurate two-way information b
etween all channel members;
Payment flow:- there is a necessity for agreed payment transfer terms based upon
service rendered or goods delivered.
Promotion flow:- a flow of communication material needs to be used to influence
both trade partners and consumers. The objectives of the promotion will be to
produce a positive attitude and image for the retailer.
With the extended channel, the distribution of goods (‘inventory’) by retailers
to consumers is achieved through the movement of goods to and from stockholding
points (normally warehouses) and then on to points of purchase (stores). In mar
keting terminology this part of the marketing mix is referred to as ‘place’ but
the stages involved in this chain may be referred to as ‘distribution and wareh
ousing’ or, more aptly, as ‘logistics’ and ‘supply chain management’. In the mo
dern competitive marketplace, retailers need to achieve high levels of customer
satisfaction and service but at acceptable costs. This has led to the developme
nt of increasingly sophisticated distribution systems to ensure optimum service
for the supply of goods to the customer. According to Davison (1995), large hig
hly complex and often computerized warehouse facilities may handle several milli
on cases per week (or in excess of 10-15 million worth of stock). Computerise
d stock management and information system (for example Tesco’s Dallas, Sainbury
’s BRS, Safeway’s SM3, etc) which link retailer communications direct to suppli
ers have been developed (for example Tradenet) and transportation is subject to
computerized control systems (for example ‘paragon’). These comprise sophistic
ated logistics systems which have become not only a means of managing the supply
) of goods to the customer but are key strategic tools.
Many retailers benefited from the introduction of new logistics systems
in the 1980s through increasing market share or increasing profitability. Compa
nies which have benefited from such policies are generally those which no longer
consider distribution and warehousing as purely a support function or an operat
ions’ headache. Rather than simply a functional supply line, the use of retail
logistics is now a valued management area with its own operational and strategi
c objectives.
THE SUPPLY CHANNEL
The supply channel is the total process by which products reach the end
consumer as goods or services., Figure 5.13 indicates the components of the tr
aditional supply chain channel. Such a chain is an arrangement between paired
links, where the emphasis has to be on controlling and managing the relationshi
ps in order to move products through the process effectively. This should be
based on a marketing and business need for the chain to achieve.
* reduced inventory investment in the chain;
* improved customer service through its effectiveness
* developing of strong links, and hence a strong chain, in order to build
competitive advantage , and
* lower unit costs which can be used to price more competitively
As the whole chain is dependent on the way any two of these parts of the chain i
nteract there is always a question of whether the working relationships will be
good and provide the service and economics required. In practice, it is found
that the relationships are often ones of rivalry, mistrust and secrecy. None of
these is conductive to a retailer being able to provide any added value from t
he supply chain.
Competitive pricing
Competitive pricing is employed to match the market prices, of competitive reta
ilers. This is technique which requires knowledge of actual costs as matchin
g the prices of a more efficient retailer may lead to losses on particular items
. It is also required an understanding of the importance of the pricing policies
of the competition from a consumer perspective. Competitive pricing is reactiv
e rather than proactive form of pricing as a retailer with a strong brand image
does not necessarily need to march competitors offers.
Market penetration
Market penetration pricing is similar to competitive pricing but is adopted
when a company or brand wants to establish itself quickly in a market. Prices
are set below those of the completion in order to create high initial acceptance
for the company’s retails offers. A company selling fast moving consumer good
s FMCGs may use market penetration pricing in the first couple of years and
then, when the product becomes established, will slowly increase the prices. In
1996 there was all-out war between the food retailers and major oil companies
over the price of petrol, based upon various supermarkets trying to obtain a m
ajor market share. It is estimated the petrol price war of 1996 cost Tosco 30 m
illion and 2000 in depended companies were forced out of business. According to
an article in Super Marketing(1996),at the height of the price war the average
gross profits were only 0.03pa litter and these rose to 5.5p a lire when the w
ar subsided in July of the same year. The penetration strategy quickly establi
shed a 21.5 percent share of the petrol market in the UK for the combined super
markets.
Psychological pricing
This is sometimes referred to odd pricing. Retailers will often price prod
ucts below a round figure: changing a price from say 9 to 9.95 or 9.99 to fost
er the perception of the price as being that a which the customer is willing to
buy. Just as 9.95 may appear to be significantly less than 10, so a price of 48
8 may seem more on a 400 level than a 500 level. However, there is no conclusi
ve evidence that such pricing policies make any significant difference of prof
its.
Everyday low pricing
A number of retailers now adopt the strategy of everyday low pricing (EDL
P). This strategy stresses the use pricing policy with the continuity of prices
at a level between the normal own store price and the price or the deep disco
unt competitors. The term’ low’ does not mean ‘lowest’; it simply refers to a p
rice position, which is competitive and therefore, can remain stable. A number
of retailers who operate EDLP do not believe in markdown policies and sales but
attempt to generate all-year-round demand by setting the prices at the right lev
el. One of the most well known retailers to have adopted this strategy is toys
51 Us. EDLP is a strategy, which is open to large operators who have significan
t economics of scale and buying power.
EDLP can offer a number of benefits, as the following list
1. Perception of fairness. Many customers have become increasingly skeptic
al about the mark-up and mark-down strategies of retailers. There has been a tr
end by customers to wait for sale periods or to attempt to gent the best bargain
s by shopping around for promotions. EDLP allows retailers to withdraw from sal
e period pricing wars and to concentrate on creating a market position that impa
rts a perceptions of fairness of pricing.
2. Reduced advertising. The stable price policy of EDLPs eliminates the ne
ed for communication of sale or special price offer. Instead, the retailer can
use the budget to concentrate on improvement of image or the building of relatio
nship marketing schemes.
3. Improved customer service management. If the policy IS set to banish, s
ale period then the demand created is less seasonal and volatile, and sales staf
f are able to spend adequate rime in dealing with customers. This will improve
the customer’s perception of the level of service they receive. The lack of hi
gh demand sales period also has the benefit of allowing staff levels to remain r
elatively constant.
4. Reduced stock outs and improved inventory management. With more even de
mand for the products it is easier to control the stock situation. EDLP reduces
the large variations in demand and, therefore, periods of stock out when custom
ers may feel dissatisfaction with the retailer‘s service. Increased profit marg
ins. If a retailer can import to the customer an image of fair pricing then, al
though the prices may be generally lower, the overall effect can be to increase
turnover and consequently profitability.
EDLP has come major benefits to recommend it; it could not be appropriate for al
l retailers. Some retailers would find it difficult to maintain low prices for
a continuous period due to lack of economies of sale in buying or due to the com
petitive nature of their business. Also, retailers selling goods which have a s
trong fashion content are more likely to want to set initial prices at a high le
vel as this is good business practice. Fashion goods are often priced different
ly because if a subsequent sale is created for this type of merchandise, if ofte
n creates a high level of excitement. The motivation to purchase created from t
he sale enables the retailer to move a large amount of merchandise in a short pe
riod. Therefore, EDLP is not a sensible strategy for some retailers to adopt.
Factors affecting price sensitivity
As number of factors will affect the price sensitivity of products. Fro
m a marketing viewpoint a deeper understanding of price sensitivity assists with
an understanding of the different retail segments and the development of strate
gic planning. The main factors when considering retail pricing are listed below
.
Perceived substitutes effect
Buyers are more sensitive the higher the product’s price is in relation
to another product or substitute they could purchase. Therefore, the consumer m
ay choose a substitute or forgo the purchase if they believe the overall value i
s unacceptable. For example, local residents may avoid an area with higher pric
ed shops frequented by tourists who are unaware of the alternatives.
Unique value effect
Buyers are less sensitive to a product’s price the more they value any
of its attributes that differentiate it from competing products. For example, m
ay customers are loyal to Heinz or Nestle products because they perceive them to
offer superior benefits.
Importance of purchase effect
If the risk of the purchase increases then the price will not be the mos
t important aspect of the purchase. The occurs when the item is an important p
resent or when there is a need to purchase medicines. The greater the importanc
e of the product, the less price sensitive (more inelastic) the purchase will be
.
Difficult comparison effect
Buyers are less sensitive to price when they find it more difficult to c
ompare alternatives. This may lead to a demand for the more established brands,
or greater store loyalty, in order to reduce the perception of risk.
Price quality effect
A higher price may signal that the product is of superior quality. The result
may be less sensitivity to price. This is not a conclusive effect as it applie
s to some products, while others may generate different reactions. For example,
whisky at a higher price may signal improved quality but very few people would
think higher priced petrol offered any quality advantage.
Expenditure effect
Buyers become more price sensitive when the expenditure is larger, eithe
r in absolute money amounts or as a percentage of their income. This is most pr
evalent in low income households in which all expenditure is carefully controlle
d. This effect is also stronger and more likely to occur in times of recession.
Fairness effect
If the buyer believes the price falls outside a band of what would be ju
dged reasonable and fair then they becomes more price sensitive. With some type
s of products it is relatively easy to judge the offer of alternative brands and
products and therefore easy to switch demand to cheaper alternatives. At certa
in times alternatives are not easy to find. Consumers will perceive retailers,
or the brands they stock, to be ripping off’ customers if they exploit situatio
ns of shortage by being greedy. For example, street vendors are often seen to b
e selling drinks or ice creams at highly inflated prices when the temperature is
extremely high
.
CONCEPT OF SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
A supply chain is a network of facilities and distribution options, the
performs the functions of procurement of materials, transformation of these mat
erials into intermediate and finished products, and the distribution of these pr
oducts to the customers.
Supply chain management ensures a smooth and efficient flow, from raw ma
terial to finished goods, into the hands of the consumers. It is a concept whic
h has increasingly replaced the traditional fragmented management approaches to
buying, storing and moving goods. Supply chains exist in both service and manu
facturing organizations, although the complexity of the chain may vary greatly f
rom industry to industry and from firm to firm. It aims to integrate activitie
s across the entire merchandise flow, to achieve quick response in supplying pro
ducts and services to customers who need them. By doing this, production time c
an be set close to selling period, achieving better prediction of selling target
s. Figures 16.1 illustrate the flow of materials right from the stage of procur
ement, till they reach the retail store as finished products. This is the flow
of goods. On the otherhand, the information on the products purchased by the co
nsumer, flows back from the retail store to the various intermediaries, to aid t
he creation of the right product. This is the flow of information.
It is difficult to put down the value of the supply chain industry. How
ever , it is estimated that the global market size of the supply chain and logis
tics industry, is U$$3 trillion, which is a significant chunk of the global dom
estic gross product.
The estimated market size for supply chains globally, includes aspects l
ike trucking, warehousing, inventory costs, transaction costs and the administra
tion costs for these key elements. The importance of supply chain management in
India, can be gauged from fact that logistics cost constitutes 10-12 per cent o
f our GDP, It is estimated that over Rs. 1,00, 000 crore of the toal capital, i
s tied up in inventories in the industrial sector. This is close to 22 percent
of the aggregate industry sales2. Not long ago, retail stores existed to cater
to the needs of local markets. When one needed bread and eggs, one visited the
local grocery store. To buy garments, on simply, either bought fabric and had
it tailored or bought what was available in the market. Buying for the retail o
rganization was a much simpler task then. It meant dealing with a few products
and a limited number of suppliers. What existed at that time, was simple supply
chain, as illustrated in Fig 16.2 Managing this was fairly simple and easy for
the retailer.
However, as markets expounded and the retailer’s business grew, the numb
er of products offered by the retailer, also increased. While the number of sup
pliers increased, there was also an increased pressure on margins. Retailers ne
eded to think of ways of cutting costs, In order to be able to cut down on the
costs, it was necessary to integrate the complete supply chain.
Supply chain management today, links demand management , resource manag
ement, and supply management and hence, plays an important role in retailing. A
n extended supply chain is illustrated in Fig. 16.3
Today, retailers operate in a dynamic world. Customers’ buying habits a
re constantly changing and competitors are continually adding and improving thei
r product offerings. Demand changes mean a shorter life cycle for the company’s
products and inventory. The cost of holding inventory may restrict the company
from providing a reasonably priced product, as funds are tied up in inventory.
The number of suppliers to an organization may vary from a few hundred to thous
ands, depending on the range of products offered to the consumer. Sourcing, ven
dor management and logistics play a major role in getting the right product to t
he right place, at the right time and in the right condition. The second reaso
n, partially, is the increased national and international competition. Customer
s have multiple source to choose from, to satisfy their demands; locating the pr
oduct throughout the distribution channel for maximum customer accessibility, at
a minimum cost, becomes crucial. The third reason is the increasing pressure o
n the profit margins earned. Companies are becoming aware that they need to loo
k at the whole picture and not at the functional excellence of individual depart
ments, alone.
Lastly, it is a technology driven world today. Advances in technology e
nable companies to get sales, inventory and production data, across various loca
tions, not only within the country, but also internationally. Information is th
e key enabler of supply chain management.
EVOLUTION OF SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
In the 70s and early 80s, as cost pressures started to build up, most or
ganizations started to take a hard look at their operations, to see where they c
ould cut costs. Initially, the focus was on optimizing the levels of raw materia
l, work in progress and finished goods stored. Depending on the industry charac
teristics, different organizations started focusing on achieving efficiencies in
different areas, such as procurement, logistics, manufacturing, operations, etc
.
Out of these initiatives emerged various models for production and opera
tions control and management, such as the Just-In-Time inventory management mode
l, the total quality management (TQM) model, etc. these models focused on vario
us components of the supply chain, in isolation. Each one of them was oriented
towards the optimization of a sub-part of the system. However, soon, organizati
ons realized the need for taking an integrated look at the entire supply chain,
to optimize not individual parts, but the entire chain. From this emerged the d
iscipline now commonly referred to as Supply chain Management.
Early beginnings of the supply chain management initiative can be traced
to the apparel industry in USA. The textile industry in the USA faced intense
competition in the 1980s. The industry leaders came together and formed the Cr
afted with Pride in the USA council, in 1984. They commissioned a study on supp
ly chain analysis. This study found that the delivery time for the apparel supp
ly chain, from raw material, to the final consumer, was 66 weeks long 40 weeks o
f which were spent in warehouses or in transit. The long supply chain had resul
ted in major losses to the industry, due to the need for financing the inventory
and the lack of the right product in the right place, at the right time.
In order to overcome the problem., the strategy of quick Response (QR) w
as developed. The basic premise of quick response, is to share information. Re
tailers and suppliers work together, to respond more quickly to consumer needs,
by sharing information., the installation of the Point of sale (POS) scanning
systems and sharing of data through Electronic Data Interchange (EDI), became th
e new standard of the industry. The industry also adopted the Universal Product
Code (UPC). QR incorporates marketing information on promotions planned, disco
unts and forecasts into the manufacturing and distribution plant. It increases
the product availability and lowers inventory investments. It also helps in red
ucing logistics expenses. With QR systems,, retailers can negotiate a direct st
ore delivery system, in which the vendors supply floor ready merchandise to each
store, rather than to the distribution Centre (DC). The cost of the DC and tran
sportation can thus be eliminated.
The success of the QR initiative prompted a group of grocery industry le
aders in the USA, to create a joint industry task force, called the Efficient co
nsumer Response (ECR) working group. This group primarily, worked on identifyin
g opportunities to make the supply chain more competitive in grocery retailing,
worked on identifying opportunities to make the supply chain more competitive i
n grocery retailing. Studies commissioned by this group revealed that by expedi
ting the quick and accurate flow of information up the supply chain, ECR enabled
distributors and suppliers to anticipate future demand far more accurately than
the current system. A little change in the technology was required to improve
the performance, besides further development of the EDI and POS systems.
LOGISTICS:
The word logistics is derived from the French word ‘loger’ which means
to quarter and supply troops. Logistics has developed from the systematic plann
ing required when large number of troops and their equipment move, to that of th
e moving of large amounts of goods.
Christopher (1992) defined logistics as, Logistics is the process of str
ategically managing the Inocunement, movement and storage of materials, parts a
nd finished inventory through the organization and its marketing channels in
such a way that current and future profitability are maximized through the cost
effective fulfillment of orders.
In the last decade, there have been several well published logistics exe
rcises, internationally. The gulf war of 1991 as one of the largest, since Worl
d War II.
An integral part of supply chain management is logistics management. Th
e main objective of logistics management is to reduce inventory-holding costs an
d improve profits.
DISTRIBUTION LOGISTICS AND STOCK CONTROL:
The customer’s central expectation of retail service delivery is one of
availability. No amount of service enhancement or added incentives will effect
ively makeup for an empty shelf.
As a customer, the ultimate measure of a retail service is whether the g
oods or services are available as required. Modern retailing is underpinned by
a complex infrastructure that seeks to meet this central customer expectation.
All of this has its cost and, therefore, from a management perspective it will
be vital to deliver the retail service in an efficient manner.
This is becoming increasingly important as profit growth cannot be easi
ly achieved when sales growth is not high; such extra profit has to be gained fr
om improvements in productivity. The achievement of productivity gains is avail
able from a retail logistics system infrastructure which consists of several ele
ments.
RETAIL LOGISTICS
Many international retailers have built their successes on logistical pr
ocess. Speedy restocking of goods, elimination of poor settler, and promotion
of successes, also contribute to a clear sales advantage.
Logistics entails more than the mere traveling and distribution goods.
For without good information about sales and insight into customer needs. The fi
nest distribution center and transport capabilities are likely to send the wrong
products the wrong places at the wrong time. Effective logistics therefore, ne
eds an efficient information system, as well as good transport, distribution cen
ter and store handling capabilities.
A single recipe for success does not exist. A logistics system has to b
e built to suit the needs to the organization, keeping in mind the kind of produ
cts that the company retails and the competition prevailing. Fashion retailers
may need to focus of speed, discount retailers on cost. The needs of each are d
ifferent.
ALL OF THIS IS BASED UPON THE ASPECTS OF:
• transport
• Storage
• Inventory
The cost structure of each will be considered next, but at this stage it is impo
rtant to recognize the interrelationships that exist between the elements. A ho
listic perspective is essential management is to identify the optimal organizati
on and realize the greatest efficiency for the system as a whole . A ruthless
pursuit of cost savings within one element is flawed if the result is simply
to push a cost burden onto another.
A similarly holistic view is required of the supply chain in a vertical
sense, Porter’s value chain analysis (1985) recognizes that as well as seeking
to improve the internal linkages between the activities of the retailer, it will
be important to acknowledge the fit with the wider value adding system.
Retailer activity should strive to add value for the customer. This wi
ll not be realized if in seeking to pursue efficiency in the supply chain elemen
t under the direct control of the retailer, costs are simply pushed onto supplie
rs. The cost will remain in the system and will ultimately be borne by the cust
omer Managing retail logistics requires a vision of the supply chain ‘big pict
ure’. How could activities be organized or reorganized to take cost out of the
supply chain completely and deliver better value for customers at the same time.
Such an approach may see retailers taking on an additional cost burden to fac
ilitate a saving for suppliers and ultimately a net saving for the customer.
For example, when we think of some of the costs of inventory (see section below)
, we should be aware that all of the total distribution costs (see Fig.5.14) mus
t be considered in relation to each other. This will often involve various tra
de-offs, for instance between service levels and quality, or between margins and
investment in systems. As such, optimizing a logistics system is a difficult a
nd demanding task as each component of the system is affected by the level of i
nvestment the company is able to make in it. TDC allows retailers to extend the
ir control over the costs as well as supply of goods to the consumer. This requ
ires an understanding of the interaction of all parts of the logistics process.
These costs are discussed in the following sections.
TRANSPORT
Transport cost structures include substantial fixed cost elements, but p
erhaps include greater scope to adapt capacity to match volume . Centralising r
etails distribution has had the benefit of dramatically decreasing the number of
journeys made with less than full loads, thereby improving efficiency. The use
of composite distribution facilities, where the same vehicle handles merchandis
e categories requiring different storage regimes, has meant more frequent full-l
oad deliveries to stores. Computer software now supports route planning, using
interative programmes to identify the optimal schedules for each day’s deliverie
s and thereby achieving lower costs. In addition, retailers make use of back ha
ul, where the trucks make collections from suppliers rather than return empty to
the distribution center.
FACILITIES COST- WAREHOUSING
As already identified, retail logistics can be reduced to the areas of w
arehousing, transport, inventory and administration, each with its associated co
st structure. Facilities costs are taken as the capital and running costs assoc
iated with providing warehousing infrastructure and internal systems to store an
d pick stock. Warhousing has a high fixed cost element. The lack of flexibilit
y makes the initial decision to create warehouse capacity crucial. Spare capaci
ty represents wasted resource and short term measures to cope with insufficient
capacity will be expensive. Once created, the ability of the business to match
warehousing facilities to fluctuating demand will be strictly limited. This is
further accentuated if there is to be capital investment in automated merchants
handling equipment.
A regional distribution center (RDC) is usually located in a low cost
area. Such a center can handle a volume in excess of a million case of product
a week as recent advances in information system have had a huge impact on the ef
ficiency of the operation. It is the application of technologies such as electr
onic data interchange (EDI) that have facilitated a reduction of stockholding a
t both store and distribution center level. The extent of channeling of supplie
s through RDCs may be gauged by the examination of UK grocery retailers (see Tab
le 5.2) . Retailers such as Asda have moved from channeling 10 percent of their
supplies through RDCs in 1986 to over 80 percent now. Similarly, the competiti
ve change in Tesco’s position may be gauged from its major increase in usage of
RDCs.
Table 5.3 Changes in UK grocery retailers usage of RDCs. 1986-96
Retailer 1986 1993 1996
(Argyll) Safeway 40-80 95 95
ASDA 10 78 84
Co-op Retail 40-60 95 95
Co-op Wholesale 40-60 93 93
Wm Low 50 94 --
Morrisons 50 90 90
J Sainsbury 80 95 95
Tesco 40-60 95 95
Wait rosé 80 90 90
Average 1 92 92
Within an RDC, communication between the Warehouse Management system (WNS) and e
ach operative is by radio link, drastically reducing the amount of travel within
the center. The WHMS tracks the through put of merchandise and the activity o
f each operative. This can allow for individual piece-rares which replace team-
based bonuses. The wage bill is a major element within the cost structure of an
efficient distribution center,. Hence with the need to match the labour resour
ce with the volume throughput ‘annualised hours’ contracts are now commonplace.
This is not always a straightward task as warehouse staff are often unionized a
nd the union holds power. Development have to be carefully negotiated and this
has led to local agreements, often producing localized differences in working pr
actices and sometimes less efficiency.
THE COSTS OF INVENTORY
The first thing to note is that with steadily increasing sophistication
in many product categories – and this is particularly the case in retailing- the
cost of holding inventory have increased. This, coupled to the increasing conc
entration in retailing, means that the end consumer currently expects a wider ra
nge of products in smaller quantities. Irrespective of the type of inventory sy
stem used by the retailer, and regardless of set service levels, attitudes to di
stribution, etc. there will be costs incurred as a result of the maintenance and
replenishment of inventory.
COMPUTERISED REPLENISHMENT SYSTEMS (CRS)
The benefits of the new distribution systems are numerous and extend wel
l beyond inventory control and replenishment. The systems are becoming increasi
ngly important in the competitive environment of multiple retailing.
Sainsbury, Tesco and Safeway have almost 100 per cent of stores with EP
OS scanning. In the variety chain stores, BHS has been on full EPOS for several
years, their EPOS system being directly linked to their replenishment through c
entral distribution centers at Atherstone and Dundee. Marks and Spencer also ha
ve full EPOS and have implemented a computerized inventory system, ASR (Automati
c Stock Replenishment), from an initial investment of 78 million in 1988/89.
The perceived benefits of these systems for inventory are shared and are
simple: a reduction of stockholding through more accurate ordering and replenis
hment (which in turn gives better product availability to the customer and thus
maximizes sales). There is also the benefit of far more accurate sales data on
which improved decision making can take place. It can be readily seen that EPO
S may serve replenishment. By accurate data capture obtained via EPOS, forecast
ing (for example, on the basis of experimental smoothing) future merchandise re
quirements and inventory control is facilitated.
This enables both more accurate and economical buying. It also affords
greater control of stockholding through greater inventory, by the removal of the
human error associated with other forms of stock control.
MODULE-III
Arif.A.Samad
Christi Jacob
Siyad.A
Deepu.S
Ganesh.S
Hariprasad.
MERCHANDISING MANAGEMENT
Transfer title should be specified with the suppliers .several alternatives are
possible:
• The retailer take title immediately on purchase
• The retailer takes title when shipment is received
• The retailer does not take title until the end of the billing cycle ,whe
n the supplier is paid
• The retailer assumes ownership after merchandise is loaded onto the mode
o transportation
A consignment or memorandum deal can be made if a vendor in weak posit
ion and wants to persuade retailers to carry its items retailer to carry its ite
ms. In a consignment purchase, a retailer has no risk because title is not taken
; the supplier owns the goods until sold
In a memorandum purchase, risk is still low, but a retailer takes title on
delivery and is responsible for damages. In both options, retailers do not pay
for items until they are sold and can return items
Receiving and stocking merchandise: a firm physically receives and handle items
,which involves such varied tasks as receiving and storing goods ,checking and p
aying invoices ,price and inventory making ,setting up displays ,completing tran
sactions ,arranging delivery , processing return goods and damages ,and controll
ing merchandise .Distribution management is the key success
When orders are received, they must be checked for completeness and product cond
ition .invoice must also be checked foe accuracy .prices and inventory informati
on marked on merchandise. Supermarkets are estimate that price marking on indivi
dual items that price marking on individual items costs them an amount equal to
their annual profits and they look forward to the time when it shelf prices will
be largely sufficient in all markets .prices and inventory marking can be done
in a various ways .small firms may hand post prices and manually keep inventory
records.
Merchandise handling is not complete until the customer buys and re
ceive it from a retailer .this means order taking ,credit or cash transactions ,
packaging ,and delivery or pick up, automation has improved retailer performanc
e in each of these areas merchandise control involves evaluating revenues ,profi
ts ,turn over ,inventory shortages ,seasonality ,and costs for each goods / serv
ices
Category and item carried by a retailer .control is general achieved
by preparing inventory data, and then periodically conducting a physical invent
ory counts to check the accuracy of figures .the latter usually must be adjusted
to reflect damaged goods, pilferage, customer returns, and other factors
Parking Facilities
Parking facilities must not be overlooked in assessing a location. Most the of U
.S. retail stores built over the past 50 years include some provision for nearby
off-street parking. In many business districts, parking facilities are provided
by individual stores, cooperative arrangements among stores, and municipal gove
rnments. In planned shopping centers, parking facilities are shared by all store
s there. The number and quality of parking spots, their distances from store sit
es, and the availability of employee parking should all be evaluated.
It is hard to generalize about a retailer s needs for parking facilities becaus
e they depend on such factors as the trading area of the store, the type of stor
e, the portion of shoppers using a car, the existence of other parking facilitie
s, the turnover of spaces (which depend on the length of the shopping trip), the
flow of shoppers during the day and the week, and park¬ing by nonshoppers. A sh
opping center normally needs 4 to 5 parking spaces per 1,000 square feet of gros
s floor area, a supermarket usually requires 10 to 15 spaces per 1,000 square fe
et, and a furniture store generally needs 3 or 4 spaces per 1,000 square feet.
Transportation
The availability of mass transportation, access from major highways, and ease of
deliveries | must be examined in assessing a location and specific sites
In a downtown area, closeness to mass transit is important, particularly for peo
ple who do not own cars, who commute to work there, or who would not otherwise s
hop in an area with traffic congestion and limited parking. The availability of
buses, taxis, subways, trains, and other kinds of public transit must be investi
gated for any area not readily accessible by vehic¬ular traffic. Because most do
wntown shopping areas are at the hub of a mass transit network, they allow peopl
e from all over a city to shop there.
Locations dependent on vehicular traffic should be rated on the basis of their n
earness to I major thoroughfares. As mentioned in Chapter 9, driving time is a c
rucial consideration for many people. In addition, drivers heading eastbound on
a highway often do not like to make a U-turn to get to a store on the westbound
side of that highway.
The transportation network should also be studied for its ability to convey deli
very trucks to and from the store. Many thoroughfares are excellent for cars but
ban large trucks or can¬not bear their weight.
Store Composition
An area s store composition should be studied. How many stores are there? How la
rge are they? The number and size of stores should be consistent with the kind o
f location selected. A retailer interested in an isolated site would want no sto
res nearby; a retailer desiring a neighborhood business district would want to l
ocate in an area with 10 or 15 small stores.
Situation analysis
Situation analysis is a candid evaluation of the opportunities and
threats facing a prospective or existing retailer. It seeks to answer two genera
l questions. What is the firm’s current status? In mission, evaluating ownership
and management options, and outlining the goods /services category to be sold.
A good strategy anticipates and adapts to both the opportunit
ies and threats in the chaining business environment .opportunities are marketpl
ace openings that exist because other retailers have not yet not capitalized on
them. Ikea does well because it is pioneer firm in offering a huge selection of
furniture at discount prices. Threats are environmental and marketplace factor s
that can be adversely affect retailer if they do not react to them (and, someti
mes, even if they do). Single –screen movie theaters have virtually disappeared
in most areas because they have been unable to fend off the inroads made by mul
ti screen theaters.
A firm needs to sport trends early enough to satisfy customers and stay a head o
f competitors. A new retailer can adapt to trends more easily than existing firm
s with established images, ongoing leases, and spaces limitations. Small f
irms that prepare well can compete in a market with large retailers.
During situation analysis, especially for a new retailer or one
thinking about making a major strategic change, an honest, in –depth self –asse
ssment is vital. It is all right for person or company to be ambitious and aggre
ssive.
Organization al mission
An organizational mission is a retailer’s commitment to a type of
business and to a distinctive role in the market places. It is reflected in the
firm’s attitude towards consumers, employees, suppliers, competitors, governmen
t, and others.
One major decision is whether to base business a round the goods and services
sold or around consumers needs. A person opening a hardware business must decide
if, in addition to hard ware products, a line of bathroom vanities should be
stocked. A traditionalist might not carry vanities because they seem unconnected
to the proposed business. But if the store is to be a do –it-yourself home impr
ovement center. Vanities are logical part of the mix .That store would carry any
revenant items the consumer wants.
A second majored decision is whether a retailer wants a place i
n the market as a leader or a follower .it could seek to a unique strategy ,
such as taco bell becoming the first national quick serve Mexican food chain. o
r on it cold emulate the practices of competitors but do a better job in exec
uting them ,such as a local fast food Mexican restaurant offering five-minute
guaranteed services and a cleanliness pledge. A third basic decision involves m
arket scope. large chains often seek aboard customer base (due their resources
and recognitions ) .it is usually best for small retailers and startups to foc
us on a narrower customer base ,so they can compete with bigger firms that t
end not to adapt strategies as well to local markets .Sam goodly is a mall –b
ased s specialty music retailer offering a board product selection in a youthfu
l, consumer-friendly shopping environment .stores carry DVDs ,videos , audios
cassettes , music and movie videos.
Ownership and management alternatives.
An essential aspect of situation analysis is assessing ow
nership and management alternatives, including whether to form a sole proprietor
ship or corporation.
A sole proprietorship is an unincorporated retail firm ow
ned by one person .All benefices , profits, risk s, and costs accrue to that i
ndividual. it is simple to form, fully controlled by the owner ,operationally
flexible, easy to dissolve ,and subject to single taxation by the government.
A partnership is an unincorporated retail firm owned by
two or more persons, each with financial interest .partners share benefits, prof
its ,risks ,and costs .Responsibility and expertise are divided a among mu
ltiple principals ,there is a greater is greater capability for raising funds t
han with proprietorship ,the format is simpler to form than a corporation ,an
d it is subject to single taxation by the government .
A corporation is a retail firm is formally incorpor
ated under state law .it is legal entity a part from individual officers (or s
tock holders).funds can be raised through the sale of stocks, legal claims agai
nst individuals are not usually allowed, ownership transfer is relatively easy
,the firm is assured of long –term existence (if a founder leaves ,retires,
or dies) ,the use of personal managers is encouraged ,and unambiguous operat
ing authority is outlined .Deepening
On the type of corporation ,it is subject to double taxation (company earnings
and stock holder dividends),face more government rules ,can require a complex p
rocess when established ,may be viewed as impersonal, and may separate owner
ship from the management.
Goods and services category
Before a prospective retail firm can fully design a strategi
c plan, it selects a goods/services category the line of business –in which t
o operate. It is an advisable to specify both a general goods/services catego
ry and a niche with in that category. Jaguar dealers are luxury auto retailers c
atering to upscale customers. Wendy‘s is an eating and drinking chain known for
its quality fast-food with a menu that emphasizes hamburgers. Motel 6is a chai
n whose forte is inexpensive rooms with few frills.
Personal abilities
Personal abilities deepened on an individual‘s aptitude-the prefer
ence for a type of business and the potential to do well; education –formal lear
ning a bout retail practices and policies;and experience –practical learning a
bout retail and polices .
An individual who wants to run a business, like to use initiati
ve and has the ability to react quick to competitive developments will be suite
d to different type situation than a person who depends on others for advices
and does not like to make a decision s. the first individual could be an indepe
ndent operate ,in a dynamic business such as appear l; the second might seek pa
rtners or a franchise and stable business ,such as a stationery store. Some p
eople enjoy customer interaction; they would dislike the impersonality of a se
lf services operation .others enjoy the impersonality of mail-order or web retai
ling.
In certain fields ,education and experience requirement are specific
by law; stockbrokers ,real-estate brokers ,beauticians ,pharmacists, and optic
ians must all satisfy educational or experience standard s to show competency; f
or example ,real – estate brokers are licensed after a review of their knowl
edge of real –estate practices and their ethical character.
Finical resources
Many retail enterprises, especially new, independent ones, fail bec
ause the owners do not adequately project the financial resources need ed to ope
n and operate the firm. Novice retailers tend to underestimated the value of pe
rsonal drawing account ,which is used for the living expenses of the owner and
his or her family in the early ,unprofitable stage of a business .Because few
new ventures are immediately profitable, the budget must include such expendit
ures .in addition ,the costs of renovating an existing facility often are misca
lculated. Under funded firms usually invest in only essential renovation s .This
practices reduces the initial investments, but it may give the retailer a poor
image. Merchandise assortment, as well as the types of goods and services sold,
also affects the financial outlay. Finally, the use of a partner ship, corporati
on, or franchise agreement will affect the investment.
Time demands
Time demands on retail owners (or managers) differ significantly by goo
ds or services category. They are influenced both by consumer shopping patents a
nd by ability of the owner or manager to automate operations or delegate activit
ies to others.
Many retailers must have regular weekend and evening hours to serve ti
me-pressed shoppers .gift shops, toy stories, and others have extreme seasonal s
hifts in their hour’s .mail –order firms and those selling through the web, whic
h can process orders during any part of the day .have more flexible hours.
The owner may be the key service provider ,with patrons attacked by his
or her skills(the major competitive advantage).delegating work to other will l
essen consumer loyalty
Personal services are not easy to automate.
Due to limited funds, the owner and his or her family must often underta
ke all operating functions for a small retail firm. Spouses and children work in
40 percent of family –owned businesses.
In a business that operates on cash basic, the owner must be a round to
avoid being cheated.
Objectives
A after situation analysis retailer sets objectives ,the long –run and
short run performance targets it hopes to attain .this helps mold a strategy and
translates the organs zonal mission into action .a firm can pursue goals
related to one or more of these areas; sales profit ,satisfaction of publics ,
and image. Some retailers strive to achieve all the goals fully; others attended
to a few and want to achieve them really well. Think about this array of goa
ls for the Kroger.
Sales
Sales objectives are related to the volume of goods and service a retail
er sells. Growth, stability, and market share are the sales goals more often sou
ght.
Some retailer set sales growth as top priority. They want to expand their busin
ess. There may be less emphasis on short-run profits. the assumption is that inv
estments in the present will yield future profits .a firm that does well often b
ecomes interested in opening new units and enlarging revenues. Flower, managem
ent skills and the personal touch are sometimes lost with overly fast expansion.
Stability is the goal of retailers that emphasize maintaining their
sales volume, market share, price lines, and so on .small retailer often seek st
able sales that enable the owners to make a satisfactory living every year with
out downswings or upsurges. And certain firms develop a loyal customer following
and are intent not on expanding but on continuing the approach that attracted t
he original consumers.
Profit
With profitability objectives ,retailers seek at least a minimum profit
level during a designated period ,usually a year .profit may be expressed in
dollars or as a percentage of sales .for a firm with yearly sales of 55 millio
n and total 4.2 million .pre-tax dollar profit is 800.000 and profits as a per
centage of sales are 16percent .if the profit goal is equal to or less than 800
.00 ,or 16 percent ,the retailer is satisfied. if the goal is higher .the firm
has not attained the minimum desired profit and is dissatisfied.
Firms with large capital expenditures in land, buildings, and equipment often
set return on investment (R01) as goal .R01 is the relationship between profits
and the investment in capital items. A satisfactory rate of return is pre-def
ined and compared with the actual return at the end of the year or other peri
od .for a retailer with annual sales of 5 million and expenditures of 4 mil
lion ,the yearly profit is 1 million .if the total capital investment is 10
million ,R01 is 1 million /10million ,or 10percent per year .the goal must be
10 percent or less for the firm to be satisfied.
Satisfaction of public
Retailers typically strive to satisfy their public; stock holders,
customers, suppliers, employees and government. Stockholder satisfaction is goa
l for any publicly owned retailer .some firms set trained over the long run
and indicate good management rather than ones based on innovative id
eas that may lead to peaks and valleys in sales and profit .
Customer satisfication with the total retail experience is well –en
trenched goal at most firms now good supplier relation is also a key goal .re
tailers must understand and work with their suppliers to secure favorable
purchase terms, new products ,good return policies, prompt shipments ,and coope
ration . Cordial labor relation is another goal that is often critical to retail
er’s performances. Good employee morale means less absenteeism, better treatment
of customers, and lower staffing turnover
Image (positioning)
An image represents how a given retailer is perceived by consumers and o
thers. A firm may be seen as innovative or conservative, specialized or board –b
ased, discount-oriented or upscale. The key to a successful mage is that consume
rs view the retailer in the manner the firm intends.
Through positioning, a retailer devises its strategy I a way that projects an im
age relative to its retail category and its competitors and that elects a positi
ve consumer response. A firm setting women’s apparel could generally position it
self as an upscale or a discount specialty retailer, and if could specifically p
osition itself with regard to other retailers carry women’s apparel.
Two opposite positioning philosophies have gainsaid popularity in recent y
ears; mass merchandising and niche retiling .mass merchandising is a positioning
approach whereby retailers offer a wall-mart has a wide, deep merchandise mix w
hereas sports authority has a narrower, deeper assort.
in niche retailing , retailers identify specific customer segments and depl
oy unique strategies to address the desires of those segments rather than the
mass market nicking creates a high level of loyalty and shields retailers fro
m more convention competitors .babies”RU” appeals to parents with very young
children whereas Catherine’s stores has fashion for plus size women.
Selection of objectives
A firm that clearly sets its goals and devises a strategy to a ac
hieve them improves its chances of success. An example of a retailer with clear
goals and a proper strategy to attain them is papa john’s the nearly 3,000 -outl
et pizza chain
Identification of consumer characteristics and needs
The consumer group sought by a retailer is called the target m
arket .in selecting its targets market a firm may use one of tree techniques;
mass marketing, selling goods and services to a board spectrum of consumers; c
oncentrated marketing ,zeroing in on one specifics group; or differentiated m
arketing ,aiming at two or more distinct consumer groups, with different retai
ling approaches for each group;
Supermarkets and drugstores define their target markets broadly.
They sell a wide assortment of medium-quality items at popular prices. in contra
st, a small upscale men’s shoe store appeals to specific consumer group by of
fering a narrow, deep product assortment at above a average prices
Department’s stores are among the retailer seeking multiple ma
rket segments. They cater to several customers groups, with unique goods and ser
vices for each, apparel may be sold in a number of distinctive boutiques in the
store, also large retail chains frequently have division that appeal to differen
t market segments. Target
Corporation operates Marshall Fields (traditional department stores) for those i
nterested in low prices.
Overall strategy
The retailer develops an in depth overall strategy. This involves tw
o components; the aspects of business the firm can directly affect and those to
which the retailer must a d apt .the former are called controllable variables an
d the latter are called uncontrollable variables.
Controllable variables
The controllable parts of a retail strategy consist of the basic ca
tegories such as store location, managing a business, merchandise management and
pricing, and communicating with the customer.
Uncontrollable variables
The uncontrollable parts of strategy are composed of the factors such as consume
rs, competition, technology, economic condition, seasonality, and legal restrict
ions. Farsighted external environment and adapt the controllable parts of their
strategies to take in to account elements beyond the control.
SITUATION ANALYSIS
Situation analysis is a candid evaluation of the opportunities and threats facin
g a prospective or existing retailer. It actually means, being guided by an orga
nizational mission, evaluating ownership and management options, and outlining t
he goods and services category to be solved.
Opportunities are marketplace openings that exist because other retailer
s have not yet got capitalized on them.
Threats are environmental and market place factors that can adversely af
fect retailers if they do not react to them.
A firm needs to spot trends as early as enough to satisfy the customers and stay
ahead of competitions. A new retailer can adapt to trends more easily than exis
ting firms with established images ,ongoing leases and space limitations .small
firms that prepare well can compete in the market with large retailers.
During situation analysis, especially for a new retailer or one
thinking about the making a major strategic decision ,an honest,indepth self ass
essment is vital .
ORGANISATIONAL MISSION
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
Many retail enterprises, especially new, independent on
es ,fail because the owners do not adequately project the financial resource nee
ded to open and operate the firm. Novice retailers tend to underestimate the val
ue of a personal, join account ,which is used for the leaving expenses of the ow
ner and his or her family in the early, unprofitable stage of a business. Becaus
e few new ventures are immediately profitable, the budget must include such expe
nditures. In addition, the cost of renovating are existing facility often are mi
scalculated. Underfunded firms usually invest in only essential renovations. Thi
s practice reduces the initial investments, but it may give the retailer a poor
image.
TIME DEMANDS
Time demands on retail owners (or managers) differ significantly by goods or ser
vice category. they are influenced both by consumers, shopping pattern and by th
e ability of the owner or manager to automate operations or delegate activity to
others. Many retailers must have regular weekend and evening hours to serve tim
e- pressed Shoppers .gift shops, toy stalls, and other have extreme seasonal shi
fts in their hours. Mail- order firms and those selling through the web ,which c
an process orders during any part of the day, have more flexible hours. Some bus
iness requires less owner involvement, including gas stations with no repair ser
vices ,coin operated laundries and movie theaters. They emphasize on automation
,self service, standardization and financial controls ,lets the owner reduce the
time investment.
Intensive owner participation can be the result of several factors:
• Owner may be the key service provider, with patrons attracted by his or
her skills(the major competitive advantage.).Delegating work to others will less
en consumer loyalty.
• Personal services are not easy to automate.
• Due to limited funds, the owner and his or her family must often underta
ke all operating functions for a small retail firm. spouses and children work in
40% of family –owned businesses.
• In a business the operates on cash basis, the owner must be around to av
oid been cheated.
OWNERSHIP
• Independent
• Chain
• Franchise
• Leased department
• Vertical marketing system
• Consumer cooperative
Reference
Retail management a strategic approach written by Barry Berman,
And Joel R. Evans
MODULE-IV
Anu.R
Archana.V.Nair
Nelson Thomas
Niju.K.George
Nisha Das.
Electronic Retailing
This area is something like electronic mail order, but with extensions for capab
ilities similar to the home shopping networks as seen on television. There are a
small but growing number of electronic shopping malls populated with virtual st
orefronts. These malls are like the home shopping networks (but without the sale
s promotion people), and the storefront is like the product showcase and marketi
ng segments that fill the channel s broadcast time. However, the electronic mall
s are "non-linear" meaning one can go from any store to any other on-demand, whi
le the televised home shopping broadcast is presented in only a "linear" what-yo
u-see-now-is-all-that-is-available format. For example, the Internet Shopping Ne
twork mall allows shoppers to browse through directories of electronic stores, s
ervices, or products, and then proceed through the selected store s entry way. U
pon entering, one can browse the store s offerings using an electronic catalog o
r by perusing attention-grabbing multi-media product displays. For products that
are completely informational (e.g., electronic books, PC software, and computer
games, as well as certain banking and financial transactions, and travel arrang
ements), then shoppers are often allowed to interactively try out a demonstratio
n version of the product, much like that is normally done in conventional consum
er electronics stores. Interested customers can then arrange to purchase and "do
wnload" the product from the store over the Internet directly into their compute
r, or to receive a packaged version of the product via courier or postal deliver
y. As such, it is still relatively easy to become a developer of virtual real es
tate and electronic shopping malls, but commercial success will likely depend on
which retailers you can sign up to lease space in the malls, and what volume of
customer traffic you can generate and sustain. Perhaps both a conventional and
electronic marketing campaign will be essential to help promote customer awarene
ss and retailer offerings, together with promotional incentives aimed at Interne
t user segments. Beyond this, opportunities will likely emerge to make shopping
in an electronic mall more of an "entertaining" multi-media user experience, as
well as also more like a virtual reality experience, so that users can have fun
and be entertained while shopping.
E-TAILING MODELS
E-Tailing Business Models
Virtual merchants
Single-channel Web firms that generate almost all their revenue from
online sales.
Clicks and mortar
Companies that have a network of physical stores as their p
rimary retail channel, but also have introduced online offerings.
Catalog merchants
Established companies that have a national offline catalo
g operation that is their largest retail channel, but who have recently develope
d online capabilities.
Online Malls
A variation on the virtual merchant business model; they
generate revenue from “rents” and services paid for by retailers who sell under
the mall’s umbrella.
Manufacturer-Direct
Single or multi channel manufacturers who sell directly o
nline to consumers without the intervention of retailers.
Electronic auction
Proprietary auction site is an application of the supplier
-oriented market place. These sites are open only to approved customers. They ar
e designed to cement relationships between the company and its regular buyers. S
ellers can get rid of surplus goods, and business customers can realize deep dis
counts.
Electronic Bartering
Related to auctions and bidding, electronic bartering is
the exchange of goods and/or services without the use of money.
Electronic Data Interchange
EDI has been on the horizon for almost a decade. The ability of businesses to se
nd and receive standardized forms of product data and financial instruments has
long been viewed as a key capability for streamlining business to business trans
actions. However, there is at present very little EDI taking place over the Inte
rnet.
Why is this?
There are many reasons, including the following: First, m
ost current efforts for EDI are based on proprietary computer and communications
systems whose network connections are limited to established business partners.
Second, there is widespread belief that financial transactions over the Interne
t are insecure (they are), although the technical and administrative aspects of
this are likely to be resolved fairly soon. For example, privacy-assured and sec
ure transaction mechanisms are beginning to appear as products offered by compan
ies such as Netscape Communications Corporation. Third, most of the current EDI
support systems are "closed systems" that cannot be easily interconnected to eit
her existing or new product or financial data systems. For example, there is a g
reat deal of interest in using systems such as Lotus Notes over proprietary EDI
internetworks, but Notes currently lacks the openness needed to easily exchange
data with most existing database management, financial, or computer-aided produc
t design and manufacturing systems.
Thus, it seems that EDI of the kind being persued to date w
ill not support significant opportunities for new ventures on the Internet. Simi
larly, investments in current EDI approaches may not have a long period of usefu
lness in businesses that must expand or turnover their customer base with greate
r frequency.
BAR CODE
In 1949, N.J. Woodward filed a patent for a series of cir
cular symbols. These symbols were to be placed on every item in a retail superma
rket for the purpose of improving productivity and automating the checkout proce
ss. But, it was not until more than two decades later (1973) that the grocery in
dustry gathered to settle on some standard form of product identification. The e
nd result was the U . P.C. (Universal Product Code), a 12-digit number unique to
each product. From that initial meeting, an organization was created to standar
dize and implement the new concept.
The organization later became the UCC (Uniform Code Council
) and now oversees the labeling standards for more than 200,000 member companies
. Four years after the implementation of the U.P.C., the EAN (European Article N
umbering) system was created on an international scale. Derived from the U.P.C.,
the EAN-13 is one digit longer to accommodate country codes.
In 1968, Identicon Corporation created the 2 of 5 bar code s
ymbology for warehouse inventory and cargo handling. The name comes from the fiv
e bars per character, two of which are wide. Due to its low density, 2 of 5 caus
ed problems for manufacturers of bar code printers. In 1972, an interleaved vari
ation created by Interface Mechanisms (Intermec), resolved this issue by combini
ng two values into the same five bars, using the four spaces in between. This in
terleaving technique meant that a bar code could double the amount of informatio
n in the same space.
By 1981, Interleaved 2 of 5 became the accepted symbology for
U.P.C. retail multipack containers. The UCC developed the SCC-14 standard with
which the supplier uses the same data from its U.P.C. product labels and simply
adds a packaging indicator to designate cartons.
ONCOMING TECHNOLOGIES
There will be some great opportunities in storage. There wi
ll have ubiquitous storage within the next three years that will help the retail
ers truly drive anywhere-anytime-anything computing, which is very important for
the business. Wireless will continue to be exploited, and at some point cus
tomers will walk into one of the stores and use their own device on the networ
k there to accomplish whatever they want. An infrastructure that will enable suc
h a process has to be developed. Radio frequency identification is also exciting
, and there will be development in “cheap chips" which replace bar codes over ti
me, and will be able to intelligently drive the supply chain through what s on t
he shelf and what s in the back without the associates having to verify it.
Voice over IP will certainly take off and will lower costs
and help all from an infrastructure standpoint What it s like today when an as
sociate moves or transfers and you have to change the phones. They ll simply be
able to take the phone with them, plug it back in, and everything will be workin
g without any systemic changes.
Voice recognition s time will come in the next three. Voice recogniti
on technology can be used in distribution centers, and there are many more are
as where it s exploited, and it will eliminate the need for some of the mobile i
n stores and distribution centers today.
FUTURE OF CUSTOMER APPLICATION
From a development standpoint, the biggest opportunity is lever
aging information. In the future, the business will be simulated business with
an inductive model versus a deductive model to determine opportunities to max
imize sales before the actual event occurs.
There will also be a strategic initiative going on wit
h self-service. Self-service technology will be provided to all the salesm
en, prospective salesmen, customers and members, and to eliminate paper and pape
r forms. Having an associate portal and devices on sales floors will let custo
mers and members get product information, and let the sores do computer-assisted
selling.
IT AND RETAILING
With the increase in globalization of retailers both in
terms of their points-of-sale, as well as their points-of-supply, the Informatio
n Technology (IT) spend in the retail sector has increased considerably and play
s an increasingly important role in managing the complexity of retail operations
.
1.
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY’S INCREASED ROLE IN THEGLOBAL RETAIL INDUSTRY
At the turn of the twenty-first century, there were few g
lobal retail chains—most retail chains were local to countries. This has given w
ay to a globalized set of retailers such as Wal-Mart, Tesco, GAP, IKEA, and othe
rs. With the increase in globalization of retailers both in terms of their point
s-of-sale, as well as their points-of-supply, the Information Technology (IT) sp
end in the retail sector has increased considerably and plays an increasingly im
portant role in managing the complexity of retail operations. The increased IT
spending to be about 13 percent from 2000 through 2004. However, the correspon
ding growth in revenues for the retail sector has been at only about two percent
, translating IT costs to be a larger fraction of the overall cost base of the r
etail sector. This has resulted in considerable pressure on IT to deliver value
in the retail sector as well as closer scrutiny of the IT spend.
2.
CHALLENGES: RETAIL’S COMPLEXITY
RETAIL OPERATIONS ARE EXTREMELY COMPLEX
Much of the retail operations functionality is driven by customized point soluti
ons in areas such as merchandizing, supply chain management, in-store operations
, seasonality and promotions planning. This means the underlying IT systems to d
rive operations are equally complex.
Retail operations are inherently complex due to four factors:
a) Product complexity. The retail sector has a high degree of product complexity
, with the number of SKUs in stores running anywhere from the tens of thousands
to more than two hundred thousand, a high degree of seasonal and fashionable ite
ms, and a lack of standardization of product hierarchies.
b) Supply chain challenges. With so many different outlets and channels, multipl
e hands-offs, and high frequency of replenishment, developing and managing an ef
ficient supply chain remains one of the primary challenges in the retail sector.
c) Scale complexity. Retail operations are executed on an extremely complex scal
e. The U.S. retail sector alone deals with hundreds of millions of transactions
per day, driven by millions of customers who shop through tens of thousands of o
utlets.
d) Process complexity. The business processes that support this environment are
also inherently complex due to the multiple touch points across players in the v
alue chain (manufacturer, distributor, retailer, consumer), the coordination req
uired between the different planning cycles of each of these players, and geogra
phic dispersion. While third-party packages do exist for several functional area
s of the retail world, most retailers find that these packages either do not cov
er a broad enough functional footprint and/or they require a fair amount of cust
omization, as the ‘out of the box’ functionality seldom meets the retailer’s hol
istic needs.
KEY CHALLENGES IN MANAGING THE COMPLEX RETAIL IT LANDSCAPE
The retail sector faces challenges along four key dimensions:
a) IT cost and performance under pressure owing to the high growth in annual IT
spend in the retail sector (~13%) while revenues have grown much slower (~2%).
b) Lack of standards in a complex, highly customized IT environment leading to i
ntegration challenges, making changes and new functionality development cumberso
me and expensive.
c) High maintenance costs stemming from the high degree of customization and fra
gmentation of point solutions, many of which span different technology platforms
.
d) Poor data integrity, the result of systems fragmentation, point solutions, hi
gh degree of customization and lack of an underlying best practice architecture,
because there is no good practice standard, out-of-the-box solution that spans
the full retail space.
3. SIMPLIFYING A COMPLEX INDUSTRY: THE ROLE OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
IT systems are at the heart of retail operations and henc
e play a central role in alleviating pressure points in the retail sector. The c
onverse also holds true—retailers who do not manage their IT landscape effective
ly will find that, in time, the IT systems become part of the problem rather tha
n components of the solution. This is particularly true for IT systems in the re
tail sector; for example advanced planning and scheduling systems, inventory man
agement systems and merchandizing systems. Additional systems that share a cruci
al role in retail operations are the promotional and seasonality management syst
ems that, when leveraged effectively, can increase the top-linen revenues for th
e retailer.
There are two critical areas where IT can reduce complexity and improve results:
1. Functional retail areas
2. Data cleansing and architecture
FUNCTIONAL RETAIL AREAS
Merchandizing systems impact top-line revenues and need to
be configured, customized and managed effectively for the retailer to improve i
ts top line. To achieve this, retailers need to effectively mine large amounts o
f data and leverage this data to carry out effective forecasting, assortment pla
nning, and collaboration with its suppliers so that promotions and other merchan
dizing activities are effective and efficient. Supply chain systems are key from
a bottom line point of view as they play a key role in getting the right produc
t to the right place at the right time—which in turn impacts the inventory level
s and the rate of flow of products through the retailer’s stores, both of which
are significant components of the retailer’s cost of doing business.
DATA CLEANSING AND ARCHITECTURE IMPROVEMENT
Data cleansing, and thereafter, effective mining (via large
data warehouses) is fundamentally important in the retail space because so much
decision-making is based on data. If the data is bad, the effectiveness and effi
ciency of carrying out retail operations is hampered. This becomes particularly
crucial when the retailer is implementing new systems and a large data conversi
on effort is required—it becomes essential that the old data be effectively clea
ned, re-architected and made ready in the new system, so that the business funct
ions can make decisions effectively. .
MODULE-V
Aravind.M
Jayalekshmi.G
Rahul.V.R
Sreejith.K.B
Subhash.J.
INTERNATIONAL RETAILING
International retailing is defined as “all the activities involved in selling pr
oducts and services to final international consumers for their personal consumpt
ion”.
Retail internationalization has been defined as “the management of retail oper
ations in markets which are different from each other in their regulation, econo
mic development, social conditions, cultural environment and retail structures”
100
0
50
50
0
100
Total Customization approach:
An approach, based on differences among markets, in which the retailer develops
a unique retail mix for each country in which it operates.
Total Globalization:
An approach, based on similarities among markets, which emphasizes the complete
standardization of the retailer’s mix for all markets around the globe.
Product Offering
McDonald’s, which leans strongly toward globalization, found that in Mexico its
hamburgers were better received when served with chili sauce instead of ketchup.
Adding McBeer to its menu in Germany increased traffic and sales there. In Japa
n, the firm has added rice balls and the Teriyaki McBurger to better compete wit
h local fast-food chains.
PRICING
Consumer reactions to pricing policies vary greatly around the world. Discount o
r warehouse retailing is popular in the United States but beginning to catch on
in Japan. The average Japanese is heavily staffed, and consumers are likely to b
elieve that the sizable price or service reductions typical of discount stores r
eflect poorly on the quality of the store’s products.
FACILITIES
Retailers may also need to modify their stores layouts. Although Kentucky Fried
Chicken, Burger King, and many other retailers have taken steps to standardize t
heir facilities around the world, local considerations sometimes have forced the
m to alter their prototypes.
Rent levels and local retail practices also affect the way merchandise is presen
ted. High rents usually dictate grouping merchandise more closely on special fix
tures to display more merchandise per square foot. Yet in some nations, includin
g Canada and the United States, customers see closely packed merchandise as a si
gn of poor quality. In Japan, where customers value individualism, retailers put
only a few fashion items on the floor and keep the rest in the stockroom- a str
ategy that creates an impression of exclusivity.
PROMOTION
Promotion is the component of the retail mix that is most likely to be custom
ized from country to country. At the least, retailers must translate their adver
tising, signage, and sales presentations into the local language. In many instan
ces, however, modifications go far beyond translation. In France, children canno
t be shown in advertisements. In Germany, retailers cannot use the word best in
any advertisement, and comparative advertising of any sort(direct comparisons wi
th other retailers products and pricing) is illegal.
MEASURING RETAIL STRUCTURE
The structure of the retail environment generally refers to the nature and ch
aracteristics for the market.
Eg: The type of retail operation, the variety of retail offers, store location a
nd nature of ownership.
In terms of measuring the retail environment, levels of market concentration are
often used. Higher levels of concentration are associated with more developed m
arkets.
The retail industry developed, so multiple organizations begin to take market
share from traditional independent and co-operative retailers: thus a small num
ber of larger organization are taking a greater proportion of the market. Retail
structure development can be measured not just by the number of retail organiza
tion, but also the number of retail organizations, increases. As the market beco
mes more structured begins to decrease due to the fact that the size of the indi
vidual shops has increased, one store can serve a larger group of the population
.
More advanced
More traditional
2. Licensing agreements
Is a contractual agreement that occurs when a company transfers to a foreign ent
ity, usually another company, the right to use its individual property (patents,
technical knowledge or trademarks) in return for a royalty or other compensatio
n. The main benefits of establishing a licensing agreement are the ease and low
cost of entering a foreign market, and that it can be used to test a foreign mar
ket without the risk of capital loss should the market not be receptive to the m
anufacturer’s product. On the other hand, the greatest disadvantages to the lice
nsor are that a potential competitor is set up, there is a lack of control over
production and marketing, and there could be loss in flexibility since it is oft
en difficult to co-ordinate a licensee into a world-wide marketing plan..
3. Franchise
The problem with licensing is the loss of control over the marketing mix. A fran
chise helps overcome this problem because the exporter retains control over the
7P’s through the Franchise contract. The Franchisee makes a one off down payment
, often in excess of £250,000 for a fast food franchise. Then annual royalty pay
ments often tied in with sales turnover. There may even be further payments to t
he Franchiser or their suppliers for fittings and the supply of raw materials. O
f course the franchiser benefits from a ready made brand name and hopefully less
ens the possibility of market failure.
3.4 Joint Venture
This may be a mandatory requirement by the host government for the privilege of
market entry or it maybe a specific policy to share resources with a partner be
they finance, manufacturing, R&D or market knowledge. It takes place when an int
ernational company shares in the ownership and control of an enterprise in a for
eign country with the purpose of creating a local business. In other words, an i
nternational firm agrees to share capital and other resources with a single loca
l company in a common endeavor. Depending of the capital share of the internatio
nal company, joint ventures can be classified as majority, minority, or 50-50 ve
ntures.
3. 3.5 Strategic Alliance
Less restrictive and often more short term e.g. Rover and Honda, strategic allia
nces are often sought where no one company can gain the economies of scale, wher
e shared financial, market entry, R&D risks benefit both parties. These firms op
erate not simply by having subsidiaries in other countries but through a network
of relations with other companies to which they subcontract work. Although, the
re is often competition between these firms there is also collaboration. We are
seeing an increasing number of what are called "tri-polar alliances". An allianc
e has been established in the airline industry between British Airways in Europe
, United Airlines in the US and Cathy Pacific. And in telecommunications, an all
iance has been established between ATT in the US, Unisource in Europe and NTT in
Japan. These alliances are established in order to compete with other multinati
onals which have established similar alliances with other multinationals in Japa
n, Europe and North America.
3.6 Wholly owned production
This could be assembly only of components shipped in or full manufacture, althou
gh R&D capability is usually retained in the domestic market. The subsidiary cou
ld be a ‘Green field’ site or an acquisition. As the subsidiary matures it may b
e used to export to other markets in the region or even back to the domestic bas
e.
TYPOLOGIES OF INTERNATIONAL EXPANSION
Introduction
The term ‘ Retail Internationalization’ may seem clear enough, yet a number of c
omplexities underline it. Alexander (1997) has highlighted the varying condition
s that international players operate in, suggesting that retail internationaliza
tion is:
The management of retail operation in markets which are different from each othe
r in their regulation, economic development, social conditions, cultural environ
ment, and retail structures.
It is the process of a retailer transferring its retail operations, concept, man
agement expertise, technology and/or buying function across national borders.
TYPOLOGIES OF INTERNATIONAL EXPANSION
Terms such as global, international, multinational and transitional are often us
ed interchangeably and without much regard for the differences in implications.
While on one level they all suggest the movement of retailer into new markets, t
hey also imply differences in terms of the nature of international activity. Cla
ssifications of retailers have been determined partially by their direction of e
xpansion and market entry method. Salmon and Tordiman (1989) categories three ty
pes of international strategy:
Investment
Global
Multinational
INVESTMENT
Company often uses investment with diverse portfolios that are
seeking new growth opportunities and want to spread their risk of investment. At
tainting shares in a foreign company acquiring the entire company allows swift e
xpansion and may allow the transfer of know-how from the indigenous retailer. Un
like the other two classifications, it is strategy implemented by both retailers
and no retailers. It implies no real international marketing strategies, as the
companies are treated autonomously within the portfolio.
GLOBAL
Global retailers replicate a concept in a new market. Typically they have a str
ong brand such as Marks & Spencer, IKEA and Benetton. The replication of the ret
ail offer implies a standard global marketing strategy, which allows savings fro
m economies and efficiencies of scale due to the replication of factors such as
assortment, store designs and advertising. There is opportunity for vertical int
egration in terms of design production and distribution. However, the lack of au
tonomy as a result of centralized management structure requires and leads to the
development of excellent information ad communication system. Global retailers
are then likely to achieve the greatest rates of international expansion due pri
marily to efficiencies of operation.
MULTINATIONAL
With the third category, multinational retailers, the basic concept is unchanged
in the international transfer, but the offer is adapted to suit local condition
s, as exemplified by C&S. Although the concept is replicated, the marketing mix
is adapted to suit local demand. The store decor, services and pricing are simil
ar throughout the world, while the assortment and advertising are subject to loc
al determinants. The management structure is decentralized, providing operations
within different markets with a significant degree of autonomy. This is an impo
rtant source of the transfer of knowledge from one market to another, but the ph
ilosophy of adapting to local conditions means that there are few savings from e
conomies of scale on a global level. Although multinational retailers are se to
expand within the global arena, it is thought unlikely that such expansions will
be to the same extent as the global retailers.
There is great deal of importance with Salmon model in the position of a retail
er within the typology is dependent upon that level of local responsiveness and
the degree of benefits from integration. An example of a multinational retailer
is Vendex of the Netherlands. It employs a high degree of adaptation to the loca
l environment and subsequently has a few benefits from integration because it ha
s a variety of diverse retail formats. Global retailers are at the other extreme
. They provide the same offer in every market with limited, if any, change made
to suit different environments. This does, however, provide them with savings fo
rm of economies of scale, and example of this is The Body Shop.
DIRECTION OF EXPANSION
The direction of international expansion taken by retailer has received a good d
eal of attention in recent years. Much of the recent research on internationaliz
ations describes either the development of new markets or the invasion of homes
markets by foreign competitors. Burt (1993) suggested that the initial direction
of international retail expansion is primarily determined by three factors:
Cultural proximity
Geographical proximity
The stage of development of the retail market.
CONCLUSION
Retailers tend to move into markets that are geographically and culturally close
, and those that are less developed than their own. As they develop into experie
nced internationalists, they are more likely to move into more diverse markets.
Their choice of market entry strategy is dependent upon the types of operations,
the organizational structure and culture, and the nature of the host markets. T
oday the word is a much smaller place for the retailers. Any retailer that think
s retailing is a local business is, or soon will be, competing against a foreign
retailer that understands retailing is a global business. The internationalizat
ion of retailing is still a relatively recent phenomenon and it is suggested tha
t it is a process likely to continue to increase.