C4 Processing Options
C4 Processing Options
C4 Processing Options
Presented at:
INTRODUCTION
The future of our industry will be shaped by product flexibility, low capital investment
and energy efficiency of larger capacity plants. Steam cracker and FCC unit owners
are striving to increase the value of their orphaned C4 streams. ABB Lummus Global
offers a full range of technologies to process these C4 streams into value-added
products. New innovative technologies expand the processing choices, including
ethylene/butene metathesis for propylene production, C4 self-metathesis that
produces ethylene, propylene and hexene-1 and catalytic distillation/hydrogenation
for C4 diene removal and hydroisomerization.
This paper reviews the commercially proven C4 processing technologies in the ABB
Lummus Global portfolio, discusses how they work, their advantages, and the
applications that provide the best fit.
Table 1
wt% of C4 stream
600 kta Steam Cracker
Butadiene
50
--
Isobutylene
25
15
n-Butenes
15
37
Butanes
10
48
240,000
360,000
TOTAL, mta
-1-
Isobutylene
C4 LPG
Butadiene
Maleic Anhydride
Isobutane
The portfolio of C4 processing steps offered by ABB Lummus Global is:
C4 Processing Step
Technology(s)
- C4s
Lummus Global)
Selective Hydrogenation
CDHydro ; BASF
Total Hydrogenation
Dehydrogenation
Etherification
CDMtbe, CDEtbe
CDIB
Selective Hydrogenation/Etherification
CDEtherol
Butadiene Extraction
BASF
ISOMPLUS (Lyondell/CDTECH)
Paraffin Isomerization
Maleic Anhydride
The entire ABB Lummus Global technology portfolio is depicted in Figures 1 and 2.
The entire CDTECH1 technology portfolio is depicted in Figure 3.
CDTECH is a partnership between ABB Lummus Global and Chemical Research and Licensing, a
CRI subsidiary. CDMtbe, CDEtbe, CDEtherol, CDHydro, CDIB and ISOMPLUS are all
processes developed and commercialized by CDTECH.
1
-2-
C4 PROCESSING TECHNOLOGIES
Metathesis Olefins Conversion Technology
The Olefins Conversion Technology (OCT) from ABB Lummus Global reacts nbutenes with ethylene to produce polymer grade propylene. This technology, which
has been in commercial operation since 1985, gives the olefin producer added
flexibility to balance ethylene and propylene production depending on market
conditions.
Two chemical reactions take place in the single fixed-bed reactor (Figure 4):
propylene is formed by the metathesis of ethylene and butene-2; and butene-1 is
isomerized to butene-2 as butene-2 is consumed in the metathesis reaction.
This technology can be used with a variety of C4 streams including the mixed C4s
produced in steam cracking, raffinate C4s from MTBE or butadiene extraction, and
C4s produced in FCC units. The ethylene stream can vary from dilute ethylene
typical from an FCC, to polymer-grade ethylene.
through the system as inerts. This feed flexibility allows the producer to take
advantage of many lower-valued feed stocks.
Figure 5 is a simple process flow diagram of the Lummus OCT process. Fresh C4s
plus C4 recycle are mixed with ethylene and sent through a guard bed to remove
trace impurities from the mixed feed. The feed is heated prior to entering the vapor
phase reactor where equilibrium reaction takes place. The per-pass conversion of
butylene is greater than 60% with overall selectivity to propylene exceeding 90%.
The reactor is regenerated on a regular basis.
Reactor effluent is sent to the ethylene recovery tower where unreacted ethylene is
recovered and recycled to the reactor. The C2 tower bottoms are processed in the
C3 tower to produce propylene product and a C4 recycle stream. Purge streams
remove non-reactive light material and C4s and heavier materials.
-3-
In their November 30, 2001 Monomers Market Report, Chemical Market Associates,
Inc. (CMAI) evaluated the relative capital investment required to produce propylene
from various technologies. They range from the capital-intensive route of FCC units
and steam crackers to the low cost of a propylene/propane splitter. As shown in
Figure 6, metathesis is the lowest capital cost route to produce propylene.
The OCT from ABB Lummus Global can also be utilized in butenes self-metathesis
mode to produce ethylene, propylene and hexene-1. This does not use ethylene as
feed to the reactor system. A semi-works self-metathesis unit is under construction
at Sinopecs Tianjin ethylene plant, and will be started up in early 2003.
Selective Hydrogenation
ABB Lummus Global offers two selective hydrogenation processes that can be used
to convert butadiene to normal butenes. The choice depends on project-specific
parameters such as butadiene content, and whether the project is a retrofit or a
grassroots design.
CDHydro Process
This is a technology developed by CDTECH in which hydrogenation and
distillation take place in single unit operation. It has various applications for C3,
C4 and C5 processing.
-4-
3. Mercaptan compounds react with diolefins, forming heavy olefinic sulfides that
exit in the bottoms. The distillate is sulfur-free.
4. The heat of reaction is used to displace a portion of the reboiler duty. This
reduces energy costs.
5. Dimers, gums and sulfides are much heavier than the surrounding
components. These materials are easily separated down and away from the
catalyst zone. In addition, clean reflux flows over the catalyst zone washing
the catalyst beds. These characteristics lead to more stable operation and
improved catalyst life.
BASF Selop
This is a fixed bed technology developed for steam cracker C4 feeds with high
butadiene concentration.
Antwerp in 1993.
Optimization of the
hydrogen flow is achieved by setting the hydrogen feed rate proportional to the C4
-5-
feed flow and correcting for the changes in the butadiene content in both the C4
feed and the reactor outlet streams.
Total C4 Hydrogenation
ABB Lummus Global offers its own fixed bed hydrogenation technology for total
saturation of steam cracker C4s for pyrolysis feed, LPG, or n-butane feed
applications.
This well-proven technology offers a unique system for self-balancing reaction heat
removal and a low recycle rate. Changes in heat release due to changes in feed
composition or flow rate cause a corresponding change in vapor generated. Since
condensed vapors are totally recycled, the system adjusts to the new conditions by
automatically changing the recycle quantity.
This design approach results in lower catalyst requirement, long cycle times between
regeneration, and a catalyst life of 5 years or longer.
Butane Dehydrogenation
ABB Lummus Global is the licensor of CATOFIN and CATADIENE technologies.
CATOFIN converts isobutane to isobutylene while CATADIENE converts n-butane to
butadiene. These mature technologies have been utilized in industry for decades,
with improvements being made continuously.
The CATOFIN process uses fixed-bed reactors with a catalyst that has been
selected to optimize the complex relationship among conversion, selectivity and
energy consumption.
-6-
CATOFIN process is greater than 90%. The entire reactor sequence is computer
controlled and requires no operator input. On-stream efficiencies of 98+%, excluding
biannual turnarounds of 2-3 weeks, are routinely achieved.
The compressor discharge is cooled, dried and routed to the low temperature
recovery section to reject light ends. The low temperature section off-gas, which is a
hydrogen-rich gas, can be sent to a Pressure Swing Adsorption (PSA) Unit to purify
the hydrogen. Recovered liquids from the low temperature recovery section, along
with the effluent flash drum liquid, are fed to distillation facilities and/or an MTBE
synthesis unit for product recovery.
Etherification
The CDMtbe and CDEtbe (Figure 10) technologies licensed by CDTECH convert
isobutylene to MTBE and ETBE using methanol and ethanol respectively. These
catalytic distillation processes have design options for 99.9% conversion. CDTECH
etherification technology continues to capture the majority of projects for these
products.
-7-
MTBE Decomposition
Isobutylene purity in excess of 99.9% can be produced from MTBE using the
CDTECH CDIB technology (Figure 11). This fixed bed process uses a proprietary
acidic catalyst to decompose commercial grade MTBE feed to high purity
isobutylene and commercial grade methanol.
Commercial MTBE feedstock is first fractionated to remove light ends and heavies.
The high purity MTBE is fed to the decomposition reactor where MTBE is converted
to isobutylene and methanol.
steam.
Fractionation of the aqueous stream recovers wash water, MTBE for recycle and
methanol.
(including MTBE for recycle) and light ends, leaving high purity isobutylene product.
-8-
Selective Hydrogenation/Etherification
CDEtherol technology offered by CDTECH processes C4 streams from refinery
units to produce MTBE. The technology, can accomplish selective hydrogenation of
low butadiene
isomerization.
concentration
streams,
etherification,
and
butene-1/butene-2
Butadiene Extraction
The evaporated crude C4 stream enters the first column, the main-washer, at the
bottom of the tower.
butadiene and the acetylenes out of the C4-cut. This solution is pumped to the top of
the rectifier. The acetylenes are removed in the after-washer column, where they
are dissolved in NMP at the bottom. The top product of the after-washer is the crude
butadiene. This stream will finally be distilled to meet product specifications.
-9-
Paraffin Isomerization
ABB Lummus Global offers its own isomerization technology for efficient conversion
of n-butane to isobutane. A main application is in field butane-based MTBE plants
where isobutane is produced as feedstock for the dehydrogenation unit.
The
- 10 -
This process, which utilizes an AKZO/TOTAL catalyst, has been utilized in many
projects representing more than two million MTA of isobutane production. The first
plant came on stream in 1995 as part of an ABB technology package of
ISOM/CATOFIN/CDMtbe to produce MTBE.
The ALMA process produces high purity, superior quality maleic anhydride from nbutane. Jointly developed and licensed by ABB and Lonza SpA, the ALMA process
combines the unique features of a fluid-bed reactor with that of a non-aqueous
recovery system. This modern processing combination results in savings in capital
investment and a product that surpasses the rigorous performance specifications of
various end-use markets.
- 11 -
The BASF Fina Petrochemicals steam cracker in Port Arthur, Texas produces over
950,000 metric tons per annum (MTA) ethylene and over 544,000 MTA propylene.
An OCT unit is under construction that will add more than 300,000 MTA additional
propylene, increasing the propylene-to-ethylene ratio (P/E) from 0.57 to 1.0.
this option reduces the quantity of hydrogen available for product sales. A more
economic variation of Case 2 is to selectively hydrogenate the butadiene to
butylenes to produce metathesis feed. This is shown in Case 3. The
propylene/ethylene product ratio increases from 0.55 for Cases 1 and 2 to 0.94 for
Case 3. This option requires more naphtha feed but 73% of the incremental naphtha
feed is converted to propylene via metathesis. The IRR improves by 3 5%
depending upon product price scenarios.
Table 2
1
Stand-alone
Steam Cracker
Exported C 4s
Stand-alone
Steam Cracker
No Exported C 4s
Steam Cracker
integrated with
an OCT Unit
Feedstock, kta
Naphtha Feed
2088
1810
2213
389
393
437
PG Ethylene
760
760
760
PG Propylene
418
418
713
Mixed C 4s
263
Pygas
196
181
235
60
56
66
2088
1810
2213
+403*
Products, kta
Fuel Oil
Acid Gas
Total
+295*
Table 3 illustrates different naphtha steam cracker options that produce an overall
P/E ratio of 0.65. In Case 4, the P/E ratio is controlled by the cracking severity; the
0.65 P/E ratio represents a typical low severity operation on naphtha feed. In Case 5,
the severity is increased and the OCT unit is added to react butylenes and ethylene
to attain the same 0.65 ratio. A range of values are shown in Case 5 to reflect the
- 13 -
Table 3
Feedstock
Naphtha Severity
P/E
Naphtha Feedrate
C3- from OCT
TIC
Gross Margin
Net Margin
Energy
BD
Benzene
Pygas
Case 4
Naphtha
Low
0.65
Base
-Base
Base
Base
Base
Base
Base
Base
Case 5
Naphtha
High
0.65
2 - 5% lower
15 - 28%
5 - 8% reduction
<1 - 3% improvement
2 - 6% improvement
8 - 9% lower
17% less
25 - 50% more
<2 - 12% less
Since the OCT unit produces propylene, the steam cracker can operate at higher
cracking severity while maintaining the same overall P/E ratio. The higher cracking
severity processes less feed and produces less by-products, resulting in a smaller
ethylene plant. Since the ethylene plant is the major cost and energy component, the
overall result is that the steam cracker/OCT unit combination outperforms the low
severity steam cracker. The addition of the OCT unit to the steam cracker improves
capital and operating expenses as compared to larger plants operating in the
traditional low severity range.
In addition to the advantages discussed for grassroots complexes, the OCT unit can
also be used as an effective debottlenecking tool. It can be applied to plants
currently operating at low severity and looking to increase capacity without sacrificing
P/E ratio or for plants operating at high severity and looking to debottleneck for
higher capacities and P/E ratios.
- 14 -
The crude C4s can be totally hydrogenated to C4 LPG using ABB Lummus Global
technology.
ABB Lummus Global has a patented low cost low-pressure-recovery (LPR) flow
scheme for ethylene recovery in cat cracking units that does not sacrifice reliability,
flexibility or safety. In this process, typically greater than 95% of the ethylene is
recovered from the FCC off gas stream that is normally used as fuel gas.
Adding the LPR unit results in simple payouts typically less than two years, with
excellent returns over the historical range of ethylene prices. LPR upgrades ethylene
- 15 -
in FCC offgas from fuel value to product value. Most refineries with operating FCCs
have the infrastructure in place for handling propylene product but not ethylene
product. So the LPR process can also be used to recover ethylene for further
processing via metathesis with refinery C4s to maximize propylene. The LPR/OCT
combination further improves the economics over the LPR unit alone.
The Figure below illustrates the IRR over a range of product values for ethylene
recovery only and propylene production via LPR/OCT. Adding the OCT to the LPR
unit increases IRR 10 to 20% even after considering that historically propylene price
ranges 0.8 to 0.85 of ethylene price. This is because the major feed in producing
propylene is butylene, which is significantly lower in price than either ethylene or
propylene. The OCT unit combined with FCC maximizes high propylene production
flexibility.
Propylene
Ethylene
Ethylene Recovery from
Refinery Offgas. No OCT unit
300
350
400
450
500
550
600
650
If ethylene is not
- 16 -
ISOMPLUS technology can greatly increase MTBE production beyond the amount
based on the isobutylene content of the FCC C4s.
ALMA maleic anhydride technology offers an additional option to produce these high
value-added products.
Saturated C4s from natural gas liquids can be processed into isobutane, isobutylene,
MTBE (or ETBE), or butadiene, as depicted in Figure 18.
Using the paraffin isomerization technology from ABB Lummus Global, C4 LPG or nbutane can be isomerized to isobutane. Isobutane is dehydrogenated to isobutylene
using CATOFIN technology. The isobutylene can be etherified with methanol or
ethanol using CD Mtbe or CDEtbe technology to supply the markets for MTBE and
ETBE. In situations where butadiene shortfall exists, CATADIENE can be used to
produce butadiene.
- 17 -
SUMMARY
Product flexibility, low capital investment and energy efficiency of larger capacity
plants will shape the future of the olefins industry. The choice of C4 processing
technology requires optimization for the individual site requirements to maximize
return on investment.
www.abb.com/lummus.
- 18 -
REFERENCES
Lummus Claims Recovery Package Cuts Costs, Raises Coproduct Value
Chemical Week February 27, 2002
Stephen J. Stanley, interviewed by Andrew Wood Chemical Week
Capital Investment for Propylene Production
CMAI November 2001
Metathesis: Refinery and Ethylene Plant Applications
The 1st Asian Petrochemicals Technology Conference, Taipei, May 22-23, 2001
Steven I. Kantorowicz and Ronald M. Venner ABB Lummus Global
Innovative Technologies for Capacity Expansion and Product
Flexibility of Steam Crackers
The 11th Ethylene Conference, Maoming, PRC November 20-23,2000
Steven I. Kantorowicz ABB Lummus Global
JV Builds Worlds Largest Single Train Olefins Plant
Oil & Gas Journal September 20, 1999
Thi Chang Oil & Gas Journal
Low Pressure Recovery of Olefins from Refinery Offgases
Lummus 8th Ethylene Seminar
Frank D. McCarthy and Aivars E. Krumins
Olefins Conversion Technology
Lummus 9th Ethylene Technology Seminar
S.M. Edwards
Propylene Options
EEPC HSE Conference 2000
Aivars E. Krumins
Ethylene
Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology 4th Edition
K.M. Sundaram, E.F. Olszewski and M.M. Shreehan
- 19 -
Figure 1
Polyethylene
LPG
Olefins
Naphtha
Ethylene
Ethylbenzene
AGO/VGO
OCT
C6-C8s
C4s
Benzene
Butanes
Propane
Dehydrogenation
Polystyrene
Expandable
Polystyrene
Polypropylene
Propylene
Hydrodealkylation
Propane
Styrene
Cumene
Phenol
Butadiene
Extraction
MTBE
Propylene
Isomerization
Butane
Dehydrogenation
Maleic
Anhydride
Aromatics
Saturation
- 20 -
Isobutylene
Bisphenol- A
Figure 2
Crude
Unit
C5/C6 Isom.
Methanol
Ethanol
Hydrogen
Plant
Butane
Isomerization
Unsat
Gas Plant
Hydrogenation
(R)FCC
FCC Gasoline
HDS
Ethylene
Plant Feed
Vacuum
Unit
Hydrocracking
RDS
Thermal Gasoil
Conversion
MTBE
ETBE
Isomerate
Naphtha
Middle Distillates
Butane
Dehydrogenation
Naphtha
Jet
Diesel
Visbreaking &
Deep Thermal
Conversion
Isodewaxing
LC-FiningSM
Delayed Coker
- 21 -
TAME
TAEE
Methanol
Ethanol
Needle Coker
VRDS*
ISOMPLUS
Hydrofinishing
Figure 3
Etherification
---MTBE
---TAME
---ETBE
---TAEE
---BTBE
---Acetylenes
---Diolefins
---Aromatics
---Olefin Isomerization
---Olefin Saturation
---AMS
Alkylation
Hydrodesulfurization
---LSR Naphtha
---Reformer Feed
---Kerosene
---Diesel
---FCC Gasoline
---Ethylbenzene
---Cumene
Other
---Sulfur reduction
---Mercaptan reduction
---Acrylamide
- 22 -
---Iso-octene
---Iso-octane
Figure 4
Ethylene + 2-Butene
1-Butene
2Propylene
2-Butene
Ethylene
Pretreatment
Preheat
Reactor
Butylene
Ethylene/Butylene
Recycle
Unreacted
C2 & C4
Product
Fractionation
Gasoline
Propylene Product
Figure 5
Metathesis Reactor
Ethylene Column
Propylene Column
Recycle Ethylene
Lights Purge
Ethylene Feed
Propylene Product
C4 Feed
C4 Recycle
No Superfractionators Required
- 24 -
Figure 6
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
FCC
Naphtha
Steam Cracker
FCC +
ZSM-5
Propane Dehyro
- 25 -
Metathesis
Splitter
Figure 7
CDHydro Tower
Hydrogen Vent
Reflux + Heat of Rx
Hydrogen
Tower
Feed
Net Overhead
Catalyst
Zone
Net Bottoms
- 26 -
Figure 8
Total C4 Hydrogenation
Reactor
Stabilizer
MP
Steam
Offgas
CW
Offgas
LP
Steam
CW
H2
CW
C4 feed
C4 LPG
- 27 -
Figure 9
REACTOR ON
PURGE
REACTOR ON
STREAM
AIR
REACTOR ON
REHEAT
FUEL
EXHAUST AIR
STEAM
STEAM
ISOBUTANE
C4 RECYCLE
FROM MTBE
SYNTHESIS
FUEL GAS
LOW TEMP.
SECTION
COOLER
DEPROPANIZER
COOLER
FLASH DRUM
PRODUCT
COMPRESSOR
ISOBUTYLENE TO
MTBE SYNTHESIS
- 28 -
Figure 10
Catalytic
Distillation
Tower
Methanol/Ethanol Methanol/Ethanol
Extraction
Recovery
C4 Recycle to
Dehydrogenation
Unit
Methanol/Ethanol
C4s Methanol/Ethanol
Water
MTBE/ETBE Product
- 29 -
Figure 11
CDTECH - CDIB
Isobutylene Unit Integrated With MTBE Unit
MTBE
Topping
Column
MTBE
Tailing
Column
Isobutylene
Reactors
Crude
Isobutylene
Column
Methanol
Extraction
Column
Isobutylene
Lights
Column
C4's/C5's
MTBE Feed
Isobutylene
Methanol/Water To MTBE Unit
MTBE/Methanol To MTBE Unit
Heavies
- 30 -
Figure 12
ISOMPLUS
C4 Skeletal Isomerization Process
Heater
Compressor
Heavy Ends
Column
Reactor
MTBE Raffinate
C5 +
- 31 -
Figure 13
Maleic Anhydride
HP Steam
Tail Gas*
Steam
Drum
Light
Ends
Column
Pure Maleic
Anhydride
Catalyst
Fines
Recovery
Product
Column
Absorber
n-butane
Light Ends*
Fluid
Bed
Reactor
Stripper
Air
Solvent
Purification
- 32 -
Aqueous Effluent
Figure 14
Butadiene
Extraction
Steam
Cracker
C4s
Raffinate 1
Selective
C4 Hydro
Reactor 1
Selective
C4 Hydro
Reactor 2
~
Hydrogen
~
Hydrogen
Total
Hydrogenation
Hydrogen
DIB
Propylene
OCT
Raffinate 2
MTBE
Ethylene
~
MTBE
C4 LPG or
Recycle
to Ethylene Plant
Heaters
OSBL or
Recycle to
Ethylene Plant
C4+ Purge
Heaters
Isobutene,
Isobutane &
1-Butene
Butene-1
Recovery
- 33 -
MTBE
Decomposition
Butene-1
Isobutylene
Figure 15
Low
Severity
1.2
1
0.8
C3-/C20.6
Ratio
0.4
0.2
0
Max C2-
+OCT
Max C3-
+OCT
Figure 16
FCC Propylene
OCT Results
30
25
Propylene
Yield
Wt%
20
15
10
0
FCC
FCC ++
- 35 -
SCC
+ OCT
Figure 17
Butene-1
Recovery
Butene-2
FCC
C4s
Selective
C4 Hydro
Reactor 1
MTBE
OSBL or
Recycle to
Ethylene
Plant Heaters
Butene-1
Selective
C4 Hydro
Reactor 2
C4+ Purge
OCT
Propylene
Skeletal
Olefin
Isomerization
FCC
Offgas
Contaminant
Removal
Low
Pressure
Recovery
Ethylene
Fuel Gas
C3+ to OSBL
or Recovery
in OCU
- 36 -
Figure 18
Isobutane
Methanol
C4 LPG
Paraffin
Isomerization
Dehydrogenation
(CATOFIN)
MTBE
Etherification
Isobutane
n-Butane
Dehydrogenation
(CATADIENE)
- 37 -
Butadiene