Differential Calculus
Differential Calculus
(x).
Look at the graph of the function y = f(x) in Figure 7. Three dierent tangent lines have
Figure 7: Tangent lines to the graph of f(x) drawn at three dierent points on the graph.
been drawn on the graph, at A, B and C, corresponding to three dierent values of the
independent variable, x = 0.5, x = 0.5 and x = 1.5.
If we were to make careful measurements of the slopes of the three tangents shown we
would nd that f
(0.5) 2.75, f
(x) depends on x.
In other words, f
is a function of x.
Terminology The function f
(x) or
df(x)
dx
f f
or
df
dx
y y
or
dy
dx
y(x) y
(x) or
dy(x)
dx
Exercise 2.1 (You will nd this exercise easier to do if you use graph paper.)
Draw a careful graph of the function f(x) = x
2
. Draw the tangents at the points x = 1,
x = 0 and x = 0.5. Find the slopes of these lines by picking two points on them and
using the formula
slope =
y
2
y
1
x
2
x
1
.
These slopes are the (approximate) values of f
(1), f
(0) and f
(0.5) respectively.
Exercise 2.2
Repeat Exercise 2.1 with the function f(x) = x
3
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 9
3 How do we nd derivatives (in practice)?
Dierential calculus is a procedure for nding the exact derivative directly from the for-
mula of the function, without having to use graphical methods. In practise we use a few
rules that tell us how to nd the derivative of almost any function that we are likely to
encounter. In this section we will introduce these rules to you, show you what they mean
and how to use them.
Warning! To follow the rest of these notes you will need feel comfortable manipulating
expressions containing indices. If you nd that you need to revise this topic you may nd
the Mathematics Learning Centre publication Exponents and Logarithms helpful.
3.1 Derivatives of constant functions and powers
Perhaps the simplest functions in mathematics are the constant functions and the func-
tions of the form x
n
.
Rule 1 If k is a constant then
d
dx
k = 0.
Rule 2 If n is any number then
d
dx
x
n
= nx
n1
.
Rule 1 at least makes sense. The graph of a constant function is a horizontal line and a
horizontal line has slope zero. The derivative measures the slope of the tangent, and so
the derivative is zero.
How you approach Rule 2 is up to you. You certainly need to know it and be able to use
it. However we have given no justication for why Rule 2 works! In fact in these notes we
will give little justication for any of the rules of dierentiation that are presented. We
will show you how to apply these rules and what you can do with them, but we will not
make any attempt to prove any of them.
Examples If f(x) = x
7
then f
(x) = 7x
6
.
If y = x
0.5
then
dy
dx
= 0.5x
1.5
.
d
dx
x
3
= 3x
4
.
If g(x) = 3.2 then g
(x) = 0.
If f(t) = t
1
2
then f
(t) =
1
2
t
1
2
.
If h(u) = 13.29 then h
(u) = 0.
0. 50 1. 00 1. 50 - 0. 50 - 1. 00
1. 00
2. 00
3. 00
slope = f ' (-0.5) = - 1
( 1, 1 )
( -0.5, 0.25)
slope = f ' (1) = 2
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 10
In the examples above we have used Rules 1 and 2 to calculate the derivatives of many
simple functions. However we must not lose sight of what it is that we are calculating
here. The derivative gives the slope of the tangent to the graph of the function.
For example, if f(x) = x
2
then f
(1) = 2 1 = 2.
Similarly the slope of the tangent to the graph of x
2
at x = 0.5 is found by substituting
x = 0.5 into the derivative. The slope is f
(t) = 4t
3
, and so the slope of the tangent line at t = 2 is g
(2) =
4 (2)
3
= 32.
Example
Find the equation of the line tangent to the graph of y = f(x) = x
1
2
at the point x = 4.
Solution
f(4) = 4
1
2
=
4 = 2, so the coordinates of the point on the graph are (4, 2). The
derivative is
f
(x) =
x
1
2
2
=
1
2
x
and so the slope of the tangent line at x = 4 is f
(4) =
1
4
. We therefore know the slope of
the line and we know one point through which the line passes.
Any non vertical line has equation of the form y = mx+b where m is the slope and b the
vertical intercept.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 11
In this case the slope is
1
4
, so m =
1
4
, and the equation is y =
x
4
+ b. Because the line
passes through the point (4, 2) we know that y = 2 when x = 4.
Substituting we get 2 =
4
4
+ b, so that b = 1. The equation is therefore y =
x
4
+ 1.
Notice that in the examples above the independent variable is not always called x. We
have also used u and t, and in fact we can and will use many dierent letters for the
independent variable. Notice also that we might not stick to the symbol f to stand
for function. Many other symbols are used. Some of the common ones are g and h.
Throughout this booklet we will use a variety of symbols for functions and variables to
get you used to the fact that our choice of symbols makes no dierence to the ideas that
we are introducing. On the other hand, we can make life easier for ourselves if we make
sensible choices of symbols. For example if we were discussing the revenue obtained by
a manufacturer who sells articles for a certain price it might be sensible for us to choose
the symbol p to mean price, and r to mean revenue, and to write r(p) to express the
fact that the revenue is a function of the price. In this way the symbols we have chosen
remind us of their meaning, much more than if we had chosen x to represent price and f
to represent revenue and written f(x). On the other hand, because the symbol d has a
special use in calculus, to express the derivative
df(x)
dx
, we almost never use d for any other
purpose. For this reason you will often see the letter s used to represent diSplacement.
We now know how to dierentiate any function that is a power of the variable. Examples
are functions like x
3
and t
1.3
. You will come across functions that do not at rst appear
to be a power of the variable, but can be rewritten in this form. One of the simplest
examples is the function
f(t) =
t,
which can also be written in the form
f(t) = t
1
2
.
The derivative is then
f
(t) =
t
1
2
2
=
1
2
t
.
Similarly, if
h(s) =
1
s
= s
1
then
h
(s) = s
2
=
1
s
2
.
Examples
If f(x) =
1
3
x
= x
1
3
then f
(x) =
1
3
x
4
3
.
If y =
1
x
x
= x
3
2
then
dy
dx
=
3
2
x
5
2
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 12
Exercises 3.1
Dierentiate the following functions:
a. f(x) = x
4
b. y = x
7
c. f(u) = u
2.3
d. f(t) = t
1
3
e. f(t) = t
22
7
f. g(z) = z
3
2
g. y = t
3.8
h. z = x
3
7
Exercise 3.2
Express the following as powers and then dierentiate:
a.
1
x
2
b. t
t c.
3
x
d.
1
x
2
x
e.
1
x
4
x
f.
s
3
s
3
s
g.
1
u
3
h.
t
t
2
t
i. x
1
2
x
x
Exercise 3.3
Find the equation of the line tangent to the graph of y =
3
x when x = 8.
3.2 Adding, subtracting, and multiplying by a constant
So far we know how to dierentiate powers of the independent variable. Many of the
functions that you will encounter are made up in simple ways from powers. For example,
a function like 3x
2
is just a constant multiple of x
2
. However neither Rule 1 nor Rule 2
tell us how to dierentiate 3x
2
. Nor do they tell us how to dierentiate something like
x
2
+ x
3
or x
2
x
3
.
Rules 3 and 4 specify how to dierentiate combinations of functions that are formed by
multiplying by constants, or by adding or subtracting functions.
Rule 3 If f(x) = cg(x), where c is a constant, then f
(x) = cg
(x).
Rule 4 If f(x) = g(x) h(x) then f
(x) = g
(x) h
(x).
Examples If f(x) = 3x
2
then f
(x) = 3
d
dx
x
2
= 6x.
If g(t) = 3t
2
+ 2t
2
then g
(t) =
d
dt
3t
2
+
d
dt
2t
2
= 6t 4t
3
.
If y =
3
x
2x
3
x = 3x
1
2
2x
4
3
then
dy
dx
=
3
2
x
3
2
8
3
x
1
3
.
If y = 0.3x
0.4
then
dy
dx
= 0.12x
1.4
.
d
dx
2x
0.3
= 0.6x
0.7
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 13
Warning! Although Rule 4 tells us that
d
dx
(f(x) g(x)) = f
(x) g
(x) and g
x b. y = 2x
7
+
3
x
2
c. f(t) = 2.5t
2.3
+
t
t
d. h(z) = z
1
3
+ 5z e. f(u) = u
5
3
3u
7
f. g(z) = 8z
2
5
z
g. y = 5t
8
+
t
t
h. z = 4x
1
7
+ 2x
1
2
3.3 The product rule
Another way of combining functions to make new functions is by multiplying them to-
gether, or in other words by forming products. The product rule tells us how to dieren-
tiate functions like this.
Rule 5 (The product rule) If f(x) = u(x)v(x) then
f
(x) = u(x)v
(x) + u
(x)v(x).
Examples
If y = (x + 2)(x
2
+ 3) then y
= (x + 2)2x + 1(x
2
+ 3).
If f(x) =
x(x
3
3x
2
+ 7) then f
(x) =
x(3x
2
6x) +
1
2
x
1
2
(x
3
3x
2
+ 7).
If z = (t
2
+ 3)(
t + t
3
) then
dz
dt
= (t
2
+ 3)(
1
2
t
1
2
+ 3t
2
) + 2t(
t + t
3
).
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 14
Exercise 3.5
Use the product rule to dierentiate the functions below:
a. f(x) = (4x
3
+ 2)(1 3x)
b. g(x) = (x
2
+ x + 2)(x
2
+ 1)
c. h(x) = (3x
3
2x
2
+ 8x 5)(x
2
2x + 4)
d. f(s) = (1
1
2
s
2
)(3s + 5)
e. g(t) = (
t +
1
t
)(2t 1)
f. h(y) = (2
y + y
2
)(1 3y
2
)
Exercise 3.6
If r = (t +
1
t
)(t
2
2t + 1), nd the rate of change of r with respect to t when t = 2.
Exercise 3.7
Find the slope of the tangent to the curve y = (x
2
2x + 1)(3x
3
5x
2
+ 2) at x = 2.
3.4 The Quotient Rule
This rule allows us to dierentiate functions which are formed by dividing one function
by another, ie by forming quotients of functions. An example is such as
f(x) =
2x + 3
3x 5
.
Rule 6 (The quotient rule)
f(x) =
u(x)
v(x)
f
(x) =
v(x)u
(x) u(x)v
(x)
[v(x)]
2
=
vu
uv
v
2
.
Warning! Because of the minus sign in the numerator (ie in the top line) it is important
to get the terms in the numerator in the correct order. This is often a source of mistakes,
so be careful. Decide on your own way of remembering the correct order of the terms.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 15
Examples
If y =
2x
2
+ 3x
x
3
+ 1
, then
dy
dx
=
(x
3
+ 1)(4x + 3) (2x
2
+ 3x)3x
2
(x
3
+ 1)
2
.
If g(t) =
t
2
+ 3t + 1
t + 1
then g
(t) =
(
t + 1)(2t + 3) (t
2
+ 3t + 1)(
1
2
t
1
2
)
(
t + 1)
2
.
Exercise 3.8
Use the Quotient Rule to nd derivatives for the following functions:
a. f(x) =
x 1
x + 1
b. g(x) =
2x + 3
3x 2
c. h(x) =
x
2
+ 2
x
2
+ 5
d. f(t) =
2t
1 + 2t
2
e. f(s) =
1 +
s
1
s
f. h(x) =
x
2
1
x
3
+ 4
g. f(u) =
u
3
+ u 4
3u
4
+ 5
h. g(t) =
t(t + 6)
t
2
+ 3t + 1
3.5 The composite function rule (also known as the chain rule)
Have a look at the function f(x) = (x
2
+ 1)
17
. We can think of this function as being
the result of combining two functions. If g(x) = x
2
+ 1 and h(t) = t
17
then the result of
substituting g(x) into the function h is
h(g(x)) = (g(x))
17
= (x
2
+ 1)
17
.
Another way of representing this would be with a diagram like
x
g
x
2
+ 1
h
(x
2
+ 1)
17
.
We start o with x. The function g takes x to x
2
+ 1, and the function h then takes
x
2
+ 1 to (x
2
+ 1)
17
. Combining two (or more) functions like this is called composing the
functions, and the resulting function is called a composite function. For a more detailed
discussion of composite functions you might wish to refer to the Mathematics Learning
Centre booklet Functions.
Using the rules that we have introduced so far, the only way to dierentiate the function
f(x) = (x
2
+1)
17
would involve expanding the expression and then dierentiating. If the
function was (x
2
+1)
2
= (x
2
+1)(x
2
+1) then it would not take too long to expand these
two sets of brackets. But to expand the seventeen sets of brackets involved in the function
f(x) = (x
2
+1)
17
(or even to expand using the binomial theorem) would take a long time.
The composite function rule shows us a quicker way.
Rule 7 (The composite function rule (also known as the chain rule))
If f(x) = h(g(x)) then f
(x) = h
(g(x)) g
(x).
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 16
In words: dierentiate the outside function, and then multiply by the derivative of the
inside function.
To apply this to f(x) = (x
2
+ 1)
17
, the outside function is h() = ()
17
and its derivative
is 17()
16
. The inside function is g(x) = x
2
+ 1 which has derivative 2x. The composite
function rule tells us that f
(x) = 17(x
2
+ 1)
16
2x.
As another example let us dierentiate the function 1/(z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3)
6
. This can be
rewritten as (z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3)
6
. The outside function is ()
6
which has derivative
6()
7
. The inside function is z
3
+4z
2
3z 3 with derivative 3z
2
+8z 3. The chain
rule says that
d
dz
(z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3)
6
= 6(z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3)
7
(3z
2
+ 8z 3).
There is another way of writing down, and hence remembering, the composite function
rule.
Rule 7 (The composite function rule (alternative formulation))
If y is a function of u and u is a function of x then
dy
dx
=
dy
du
du
dx
.
This makes the rule very easy to remember. The expressions
dy
du
and
du
dx
are not really
fractions but rather they stand for the derivative of a function with respect to a variable.
However for the purposes of remembering the chain rule we can think of them as fractions,
so that the du cancels from the top and the bottom, leaving just
dy
dx
.
To use this formulation of the rule in the examples above, to dierentiate y = (x
2
+ 1)
17
put u = x
2
+ 1, so that y = u
17
. The alternative formulation of the chain rules says that
dy
dx
=
dy
du
du
dx
= 17u
16
2x
= 17(x
2
+ 1)
16
2x.
which is the same result as before. Again, if y = (z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3)
6
then set u = z
3
+ 4z
2
3z 3 so that y = u
6
and
dy
dx
=
dy
du
du
dx
= 6u
7
(3z
2
+ 8z 3).
You select the formulation of the chain rule that you nd easiest to use. They are equiv-
alent.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 17
Example
Dierentiate (3x
2
5)
3
.
Solution
The rst step is always to recognise that we are dealing with a composite function and
then to split up the composite function into its components. In this case the outside
function is ()
3
which has derivative 3()
2
, and the inside function is 3x
2
5 which has
derivative 6x, and so by the composite function rule,
d(3x
2
5)
3
dx
= 3(3x
2
5)
2
6x = 18x(3x
2
5)
2
.
Alternatively we could rst let u = 3x
2
5 and then y = u
3
. So
dy
dx
=
dy
du
du
dx
= 3u
2
6x = 18x(3x
2
5)
2
.
Example
Find
dy
dx
if y =
x
2
+ 1.
Solution
The outside function is
= ()
1
2
which has derivative
1
2
()
1
2
, and the inside function is
x
2
+ 1 so that
y
=
1
2
(x
2
+ 1)
1
2
2x.
Alternatively, if u = x
2
+ 1, we have y =
u = u
1
2
. So
dy
dx
=
1
2
u
1
2
2x =
1
2
(x
2
+ 1)
1
2
2x.
Exercise 3.9
Dierentiate the following functions using the composite function rule.
a. (2x + 3)
2
b. (x
2
+ 2x + 1)
12
c. (3 x)
21
d. (x
3
1)
5
e. f(t) =
t
2
5t + 7 f. g(z) =
1
2z
4
g. y = (t
3
t)
3.8
h. z = (x +
1
x
)
3
7
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 18
Exercise 3.10
Dierentiate the functions below. You will need to use both the composite function rule
and the product or quotient rule.
a. (x + 2)(x + 3)
2
b. (2x 1)
2
(x + 3)
3
c. x
(1 x)
d. x
1
3
(1 x)
2
3
e.
x
1 x
2
3.6 Derivatives of exponential and logarithmic functions
If you are not familiar with exponential and logarithmic functions you may wish to consult
the booklet Exponents and Logarithms which is available from the Mathematics Learning
Centre.
You may have seen that there are two notations popularly used for natural logarithms,
log
e
and ln. These are just two dierent ways of writing exactly the same thing, so that
log
e
x ln x. In this booklet we will use both these notations.
The basic results are:
d
dx
e
x
= e
x
d
dx
(log
e
x) =
1
x
.
We can use these results and the rules that we have learnt already to dierentiate functions
which involve exponentials or logarithms.
Example
Dierentiate log
e
(x
2
+ 3x + 1).
Solution
We solve this by using the chain rule and our knowledge of the derivative of log
e
x.
d
dx
log
e
(x
2
+ 3x + 1) =
d
dx
(log
e
u) (where u = x
2
+ 3x + 1)
=
d
du
(log
e
u)
du
dx
(by the chain rule)
=
1
u
du
dx
=
1
x
2
+ 3x + 1
d
dx
(x
2
+ 3x + 1)
=
1
x
2
+ 3x + 1
(2x + 3)
=
2x + 3
x
2
+ 3x + 1
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 19
Example
Find
d
dx
(e
3x
2
).
Solution
This is an application of the chain rule together with our knowledge of the derivative of
e
x
.
d
dx
(e
3x
2
) =
de
u
dx
where u = 3x
2
=
de
u
du
du
dx
by the chain rule
= e
u
du
dx
= e
3x
2
d
dx
(3x
2
)
= 6xe
3x
2
.
Example
Find
d
dx
(e
x
3
+2x
).
Solution
Again, we use our knowledge of the derivative of e
x
together with the chain rule.
d
dx
(e
x
3
+2x
) =
de
u
dx
(where u = x
3
+ 2x)
= e
u
du
dx
(by the chain rule)
= e
x
3
+2x
d
dx
(x
3
+ 2x)
= (3x
2
+ 2) e
x
3
+2x
.
Example
Dierentiate ln (2x
3
+ 5x
2
3).
Solution
We solve this by using the chain rule and our knowledge of the derivative of lnx.
d
dx
ln (2x
3
+ 5x
2
3) =
d ln u
dx
(where u = (2x
3
+ 5x
2
3)
=
d ln u
du
du
dx
(by the chain rule)
=
1
u
du
dx
=
1
2x
3
+ 5x
2
3
d
dx
(2x
3
+ 5x
2
3)
=
1
2x
3
+ 5x
2
3
(6x
2
+ 10x)
=
6x
2
+ 10x
2x
3
+ 5x
2
3
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 20
There are two shortcuts to dierentiating functions involving exponents and logarithms.
The four examples above gave
d
dx
(log
e
(x
2
+ 3x + 1)) =
2x + 3
x
2
+ 3x + 1
d
dx
(e
3x
2
) = 6xe
3x
2
d
dx
(e
x
3
+2x
) = (3x
2
+ 2)e
3x
2
d
dx
(log
e
(2x
3
+ 5x
2
3)) =
6x
2
+ 10x
2x
3
+ 5x
2
3
.
These examples suggest the general rules
d
dx
(e
f(x)
) = f
(x)e
f(x)
d
dx
(ln f(x)) =
f
(x)
f(x)
.
These rules arise from the chain rule and the fact that
de
x
dx
= e
x
and
d ln x
dx
=
1
x
. They can
speed up the process of dierentiation but it is not necessary that you remember them.
If you forget, just use the chain rule as in the examples above.
Exercise 3.11
Dierentiate the following functions.
a. f(x) = ln(2x
3
) b. f(x) = e
x
7
c. f(x) = ln(11x
7
)
d. f(x) = e
x
2
+x
3
e. f(x) = log
e
(7x
2
) f. f(x) = e
x
g. f(x) = ln(e
x
+ x
3
) h. f(x) = ln(e
x
x
3
) i. f(x) = ln
x
2
+ 1
x
3
x
(x) =
cos x.(cos x) sin x.(sin x)
(cos x)
2
=
cos
2
x + sin
2
x
cos x
=
1
cos
2
x
(since cos
2
x + sin
2
x = 1)
= sec
2
x
Note also that
cos
2
x + sin
2
x
cos
2
x
=
cos
2
x
cos
2
x
+
sin
2
x
cos
2
x
= 1 + tan
2
x
so it is also true that
d
dx
tan x = sec
2
x = 1 + tan
2
x.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 22
Example
Dierentiate f(x) = sin
2
x.
Solution
f(x) = sin
2
x is just another way of writing f(x) = (sin x)
2
. This is a composite function,
with the outside function being ()
2
and the inside function being sin x.
By the chain rule, f
(x) = 2(sin x)
1
cos x = 2 sin x cos x. Alternatively using the other
method and setting u = sin x we get f(x) = u
2
and
df(x)
dx
=
df(x)
du
du
dx
= 2u
du
dx
= 2 sin x cos x.
Example
Dierentiate g(z) = cos(3z
2
+ 2z + 1).
Solution
Again you should recognise this as a composite function, with the outside function being
cos() and the inside function being 3z
2
+ 2z + 1. By the chain rule g
(z) = sin(3z
2
+
2z + 1) (6z + 2) = (6z + 2) sin(3z
2
+ 2z + 1).
Example
Dierentiate f(t) =
e
t
sin t
.
Solution
By the quotient rule
f
(t) =
e
t
sin t e
t
cos t
sin
2
t
=
e
t
(sin t cos t)
sin
2
t
.
Example
Use the quotient rule or the composite function rule to nd the derivatives of cot x, sec x,
and cosec x.
Solution
These functions are dened as follows:
cot x =
cos x
sin x
sec x =
1
cos x
csc x =
1
sin x
.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 23
By the quotient rule
d cot x
dx
=
sin
2
x cos
2
x
sin
2
x
=
1
sin
2
x
.
Using the composite function rule
d sec x
dx
=
d(cos x)
1
dx
= (cos x)
2
(sin x) =
sin x
cos
2
x
.
d csc x
dx
=
d(sin x)
1
dx
= (sin x)
2
cos x =
cos x
sin
2
x
.
Exercise 3.12
Dierentiate the following:
a. cos 3x b. sin(4x + 5) c. sin
3
x d. sin x cos x e. x
2
sin x
f. cos(x
2
+ 1) g.
sin x
x
h. sin
1
x
i. tan(
x) j.
1
x
sin
1
x
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 24
4 What is dierential calculus used for?
4.1 Introduction
The development of mathematics stands as one of the most important achievements of
humanity, and the development of the calculus, both the dierential calculus and integral
calculus is one of most important achievements in mathematics. The practical applications
of dierential calculus are so wide ranging that it would be impossible to mention them
all here. Suce to say that dierential calculus is an indispensable tool in every branch
of science and engineering.
In elementary mathematics there are two main applications of dierential calculus. One is
to help in sketching curves, and the other is in optimisation problems. For a treatment of
the uses of calculus in curve sketching see the Mathematics Learning Centre publication
Curve Sketching. In this section we will give a brief introduction to how dierential
calculus is used in optimisation problems.
4.2 Optimisation problems
There are many practical situations in which we would like to make a quantity as small
as we possibly can or as large as we possibly can. For example, a manufacturer of bicycles
trying to decide how much to charge for a model of bicycle would think that if he charges
too little for the bicycles then he will probably sell a lot of bicycles but that he wont
make much prot because the price is too low, and that if he charges too much for the
bicycle then he wont make much prot because not many people will buy his bicycles.
The manufacturer would like to nd just the right price to charge to maximise his prot.
Similarly a farmer might realise that if she uses too little fertiliser on her crops then her
yield will be very low, and if she uses too much fertiliser then she will poison the soil and
her yield will be low. The farmer might like to know just how much fertiliser to use to
maximise the crop yield. A manufacturer of sheet metal cans that are meant to hold one
litre of liquid might like to know just what shape to make the can so that the amount of
sheet metal that is used is a minimum. These are all examples of optimisation problems.
If we were to draw a graph of the prot versus price for the bicycle manufacturer mentioned
above then nding the maximum prot is equivalent to nding the highest point on the
graph. Similarly a minimisation problem may be thought of geometrically as nding the
lowest point on the graph of a funcion.
4.2.1 Stationary points - the idea behind optimisation
As a thought experiment, let us imagine that a person wearing a blindfold is walking
along a road, and that the road has a hill on it. Let us imagine also that the blindfolded
person is searching for the highest point on the road. How would this person be able to
decide when they were at the top of the hill? Well, while they were walking uphill the
person would know that this wasnt the top of the hill - because they are still going up!
And of course while they are walking downhill they would know that they are not at the
top of the hill because they are going down. In other words, while they are on a sloping
bit of the road the blindfolded person would know that this is not the top of the hill.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 25
Right at the top of the hill there would be a little bit of level road. The slope at the
top of the hill would be zero! Without even being able to see the road, the blindfolded
person would know that they could not possibly be at the top of the hill unless they were
standing on level ground. The same idea would apply if the road had a valley in it, and
the person was searching for the lowest piece of road. Right at the lowest point of the
valley the slope of the road would be zero.
So if we are searching for the highest (or lowest) point on a road, of all the possible
places we only have to consider those places where the road has slope zero. This is the
idea behind using calculus for optimisation. If we are searching for the highest or lowest
points on the graph of a function we have to look for those places where the graph has
slope zero. These points are called stationary points.
Denition For a function y = f(x) the points on the graph where the graph has zero
slope are called stationary points. In other words stationary points are where f
(x) = 0.
To nd the stationary points of a function we dierentiate, set the derivative equal to
zero and solve the equation.
Example Find the stationary points of the function f(x) = 2x
3
+ 3x
2
12x + 17.
Solution f
(x) = 6x
2
+ 6x 12. Setting f
(t) = 2te
t
2
= 0. Since e
t
2
is never zero, the only solution to this equation is
where 2t = 0, ie t = 0. Substituting into the formula for g we obtain the function value
g(0) = e
0
2
= 1. Thus the stationary point is (0, 1).
4.2.2 Types of stationary points
In our thought experiment above we mentioned two types of stationary points: one was
the top of the hill and the other was the bottom of the valley. The top of the hill is called
a local maximum, and the bottom of the valley is called a local minimum. The word
local conveys the fact that at the top of the hill the blindfolded person is not necessarily
at the highest point in the world, but merely at the highest point in the local vicinity.
Sometimes you will see local maxima and local minima called relative maxima and relative
local maximum
local minimum
s t ati onary point of infl ection
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 26
Figure 9: Graph of a function showing a local maximum and a local minimum.
minima. Figure 9 shows a function with a local maximum and a local minimum. Note
that at each of these points the slope of the curve is zero.
Local maxima and local minima are not the only types of stationary points. There is a
third kind. Figure 10 shows a stationary point that is neither a local maximum nor a
local minimum. This type of stationary point is called a stationary point of inection.
Dont worry about why it is given this name. That is beyond the scope of this booklet.
You just need to be aware of the fact that stationary points exist that are neither local
maxima nor local minima.
Figure 10: Graph of a function showing a stationary point of inection.
Let us now return to the rst of the examples in the previous section. We found that
the function f(x) = 2x
3
+ 3x
2
12x + 17 had stationary points at (1, 10) and (2, 37).
What type of stationary points are they? At the moment you probably have no idea just
what the graph of f(x) = 2x
3
+ 3x
2
12x + 17 looks like. How can you tell what type
of stationary points these are? If you could see the graph you would be able to tell what
types of stationary points they were, but it takes a lot of work to draw the graph of a
function. What we need is a way of testing a stationary point that will tell us whether we
have found a local maximium, a local minimum or neither (in other words a stationary
point of inection) without drawing the graph. There are several ways of doing this, but
in this booklet we will look at only one of them. This is called the rst derivative test.
f ' < 0
f ' < 0
f ' = 0
f' > 0
local maximum
local minimum
f ' > 0
f' = 0
f ' > 0
f ' > 0
f ' = 0
s t ati onary point of infl ection
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 27
Really we are pretty much in the shoes of the blindfolded person now. We cant see the
whole graph, so how can we tell what type of stationary point we have got? Imagine the
blindfolded person standing on a piece of level ground, and wanting to know whether this
was the top of a hill (a local maximum), the bottom of a valley (a local minimum) or
neither (a stationary point of inection). One thing the person could do is take a step
backwards from the level spot. Which way does the ground slope here? And then take a
step forwards from the level spot. Which way does the ground slope here? If the person
took a step backward and found that the ground in front of them sloped up, then returned
to the original position and took a step forward and the ground sloped down, then the
level spot must have been the top of the hill. On the other hand if the person took a step
backward and the ground sloped down, and a step forward and the ground sloped up,
then the level spot must have been the bottom of a valley. You should be able to gure
out what the blindfolded person would nd for a stationary point of inection. This idea
is the basis of the rst derivative test.
The rst derivative test
If x
0
is a stationary point of the function f, so that f
(x
0
) = 0 then to nd out the nature
of the stationary point check the sign (ie positive or negative) of f
(x) = x
2
e
x
+2xe
x
= x(x+2)e
x
. Setting f
(t) = t
2
1 = (t 1)(t + 1) = 0 so the stationary points are at t = 1, 1. Since
1 is not in the region, the possible locations of the maximum and the minimum are
t = 0, 1, 3. Substituting into g we obtain g(0) = 2, g(1) =
4
3
and g(3) = 8. The maximum
is therefore g(3) = 8 and the minimum is g(1) =
4
3
.
Example A farmer is to make a rectangular paddock. The farmer has 100 metres of fenc-
ing and wants to make the rectangle that will enclose the greatest area. What dimensions
should the rectangle be?
Solution There are many rectangular paddocks that can be made with 100 metres of
fencing. If we call one side of the rectangle x, then because the perimeter is 100, the other
side of the rectangle is 50 x. The area of the paddock is then A(x) = x(50 x). We
must maximise the function A(x) for 0 x 50 (since the sides of the rectangle cannot
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 30
have negative length). Now
dA
dx
= 50 2x which is zero when x = 25. Thus x = 25 is
the only stationary point and the maximum is found at one of the points x = 0, 25, 50.
Substituting these values into A(x) we nd that the maximum occurs when x = 25. The
rectangular paddock with the maximum area is a square.
Exercise 4.1 Find the maximum and the minimum of the function f(x) = x
4
2x
2
for
1 x 2
Exercise 4.2 Maximise the function g(t) = te
t
2
for 2 < t < 2.
Exercise 4.3 Find the minimum value of h(u) = 2u
3
+ 3u
2
12u + 5 in the region
3 u 2.
Exercise 4.4 A farmer wishes to make a rectangular chicken run using an existing wall
as one side. He has 16 metres of wire nettting. Find the dimensions of the run which will
give the maximum area. What is this area?
0. 500 1. 000
0. 200
0. 400
0. 600
y
(0.8, 0.64)
(0.5, 0.25)
x
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 31
5 The clever idea behind dierential calculus (also
known as dierentiation from rst principles)
In this section we will have a look at the idea behind dierential calculus. While it is
important that you at least see this idea once, in practice you calculate the derivative of
a function using the procedures explained in Section 3. These procedures work because
of the clever idea that we are going to describe now, but in practice we just use them
without keeping in mind the whole time where they came from.
Figure 14 shows a portion of the graph of the function f(x) = x
2
.
Figure 14: Graph of y = x
2
. The solid line is the tangent to the graph at x = 0.5, and the
dotted line is an approximate tangent line drawn through the points (0.5, 0.25) and (0.8, 0.64)
which both lie on the graph of the function.
The tangent to the graph at the point (x, y) = (0.5, (0.5)
2
) is represented by the solid
line. We are going to nd the exact slope of this tangent.
To work out the slope of a line we need to know two points on the line. If we know the
points (x
1
, y
1
) and (x
2
, y
2
) on the line then the rise between these two points is y
2
y
1
,
and the run between them is x
2
x
1
, and so the slope of the line is given by
slope =
rise
run
=
y
2
y
1
x
2
x
1
We cannot use this formula directly to work out the slope of the tangent, because we only
know the exact location of one point on the tangent line, the point (0.5, 0.25). If we were
to pick another point from the diagram that looks like it is on the line, then we would
be back to using the approximate graphical methods from Section 2. If we want to get
the exact answer, we must use another way. This is the clever idea behind dierential
calculus.
We look at another line which which has slope nearly equal to the slope of the tangent,
and on which we do know two points. In Figure 14 we have drawn such a line (the dotted
(0.6, 0.36)
(0.5, 0.25)
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 32
line) going through the points (0.5, (0.5)
2
), which is the actual point on the curve where
we are trying to nd the tangent, and (0.8, (0.8)
2
) which is another point on the curve.
This second point is not far from the point (0.5, (0.5)
2
), and so the slope of the line joining
them is not too dierent from the slope of the tangent at (0.5, (0.5)
2
). Because we know
two points on the dotted line, we can work out its slope. It is
slope =
(0.8)
2
(0.5)
2
0.8 0.5
= 1.3
The slope of the tangent is therefore about (but certainly not exactly) 1.3.
To get a better approximation we might try taking the second point closer to the point
(0.5, (0.5)
2
). In Figure 15 we have done this.
Figure 15: Graph of y = x
2
. The solid line is the tangent to the graph at x = 0.5, and the
dotted line is an approximate tangent line drawn through the points (0.5, 0.25) and (0.6, 0.36)
which both lie on the graph of the function.
Here the second point is just 0.1 units to the right of (0.5, (0.5)
2
). The slope of the dotted
line in this gure is
slope =
(0.6)
2
(0.5)
2
0.6 0.5
= 1.1
The exact slope of the tangent is closer to 1.1 than it is to 1.3, though we still dont know
its precise value.
If we wanted an even better approximation then we could choose the second point to be
even closer to (0.5, (0.5)
2
). For example we could try the second point to be (0.49, (0.49)
2
).
Notice that this point is to the left of (0.5, (0.5)
2
), whereas previously we had chosen points
to the right of the point. This is not important. What is important is that it is just 0.01
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 33
units to the left of this point. The line joining these two points is very close to the actual
tangent, and the slope of this line is
slope =
(0.49)
2
(0.5)
2
0.49 0.5
= 0.99
It seems that the closer the second point gets to the point (0.5, (0.5)
2
) the closer the slope
of the line joining the two points gets to 1. We might guess that the slope of the tangent
to the curve at the point (0.5, (0.5)
2
) must be 1. We can be sure of this with the following
calculation.
Suppose that the second point is just h units to the right (or left if h < 0) of x = 1.
We can think of h as being a very small number. For example we have used h = 0.3,
h = 0.1, and h = 0.01 in our examples above. The coordinates of the second point
will be (0.5 + h, (0.5 + h)
2
). We can work out the slope of the line joining the points
(0.5, (0.5)
2
) and (0.5 + h, (0.5 + h)
2
) in the same way that we did above. It is
Slope =
(0.5 + h)
2
0.5
2
(0.5 + h) 0.5
=
(0.5 + h)
2
0.5
2
h
=
(.25 + h + h
2
) .25
h
=
h + h
2
h
= 1 + h
Moving the second point closer and closer to the rst is the same as making h closer and
closer to zero. But the slope is 1 +h so the closer that h gets to zero the closer the slope
gets to 1. The slope of the tangent is therefore exactly 1. This puts the matter beyond
doubt. We are no longer relying on approximations or guesses. We have shown that the
slope of the tangent to the graph of y = x
2
at the point (0.5, 0.25) is exactly 1. In symbols,
d
dx
x
2
x=0.5
= 1.
With the same method we could have found the slope of the tangent to the curve when
x = 1, or x = 0.37, or indeed at any value of the independent variable x.
Exercise 5.1 (a) Using the same technique as above, nd the slope of the tangent
to the graph of x
2
at x = 2. Check that this agrees with the
answer that you would have obtained using the results of Section
3.
(b) Using the idea introduced above, nd the slope of the tangent
to the graph of x
3
at x = 1. Check your answer by using the
techniques from Section 3.
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 34
We dont really have to specify any particular value of x, but can leave it as unknown.
Slope of line through (x, x
2
) and (x + h, (x + h)
2
) =
(x + h)
2
x
2
x + h x
=
x
2
+ 2xh + h
2
x
2
h
= 2x + h
and as h 0 the line through (x, x
2
) and (x + h, (x + h)
2
) gets closer to the tangent
at x and the slope of this line gets closer and closer to 2x. The slope of the tangent is
therefore exactly 2x. This works no matter what the value of x is. For example the slope
of the tangent at x = 0.37 is 2 (0.37) = 0.74. We can say that the derivative of
the function x
2
is 2x. In symbols,
d
dx
x
2
= 2x.
We have chosen the function f(x) = x
2
for this example, because it is perhaps the simplest
function that gets across the idea. The same method works for any function, though the
resulting algebra will often be more dicult.
Exercise 5.2 (a) Using the ideas of this section, nd the derivative of x
3
.
(b) Use the same ideas to nd the derivative of x
3
+ 2x .
By now you probably have little doubt that the derivative of x
2
is 2x, and that the
derivative of x
3
is 3x
2
. Hopefully you are now willing to believe that the derivative of x
n
is nx
n1
, no matter what value n has. It would not be too dicult for us to prove this
fact, but the proof is beyond the scope of this booklet. However what you have seen in
this section is the basic idea that underlies all of dierential calculus, and all of the rules
and techniques of Section 3 come from it.
1. 00 2. 00 3. 0 - 1. 00 - 2. 00 3. 00
1. 00
2. 00
3. 00
4. 00
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 35
6 Solutions to exercises
Exercise 1.1
From the graph, at time t = 0 the motorist is 100 metres from home, and at time t = 6
the motorist is 250 metres from home.
Exercise 1.2
At time t = 0 the motorist is 100 metres from home and at time t = 2 the motorist is
150 metres from home, so in the rst 2 seconds the motorist has travelled 150 100 = 50
metres. At time t = 3 the motorist is 175 metres from home and at time t = 5 the
motorist is 225 metres from home so in the time from t = 3 to t = 5 the motorist has
travelled 225 175 = 50 metres.
Exercise 1.3
A time t = 60 the motorist is 1008 metres from home and at time t = 62 the motorist is
1032 metres from home so in the 2 second interval from time t = 60 to time t = 62 the
motorist travelled 1032 1008 = 24 metres. A time t = 64 the motorist is 1072 metres
from home so in the 2 second interval from time t = 62 to time t = 64 the motorist has
travelled 1072 1032 = 40 metres.
Exercise 2.1
Refer to Figure 16. We have used the indicated points on the lines to calculate the slopes.
You may have chosed dierent points, but your answers should be close to those here.
Remember this is only an approximate way of nding the slopes, so you shouldnt consider
yourself wrong if you dont get exactly the same answers as here.
Figure 16: Tangents to graph of f(x) = x
2
.
Slope of tangent to f(x) = x
2
at x = 1 is
f
(1)
3 1
2 1
= 2.
0. 50 1. 00 1. 50 - 0. 50 - 1. 00
- 0. 50
0. 50
1. 00
1. 50
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 36
The tangent at x = 0 is the x-axis, which has slope 0, so f
(0) = 0.
Slope of tangent to f(x) = x
2
at x = 0.5 is
f
(0.5)
2.75 0.75
3 (1)
= 1.
Exercise 2.2
Refer to Figure 17.
Figure 17: Tangents to graph of f(x) = x
3
.
Slope of tangent to f(x) at x = 1 is
f
(1)
1 (0.5)
1 0.5
= 3.
As in Exercise 2.1, the tangent at x = 0 is the x-axis which has slope 0, so f
(0) = 0.
Slope of tangent to f(x) at x = 0.5 is
f
(0.5)
0.25 (0.5)
0 (1)
= 0.75.
Exercise 3.1
(a) f
(x) = 4x
3
(b)
dy
dx
= 7x
8
(c) f
(u) = 2.3u
1.3
(d) f
(t) =
1
3
t
4
3
(e) f
(t) =
22
7
t
15
7
(f ) g
(z) =
3
2
z
5
2
(g)
dy
dt
= 3.8t
4.8
(h)
dz
dx
=
3
7
x
4
7
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 37
Exercise 3.2
(a)
1
x
2
= x
2
so
d
dx
1
x
2
= 2x
3
(b) t
t = t
3
2
so
d
dt
=
3
2
t
1
2
(c)
d
dx
3
x =
d
dx
x
1
3
=
1
3
x
2
3
(d)
d
dx
1
x
2
=
d
dx
x
5
2
=
5
2
x
7
2
(e)
d
dx
1
x
4
=
d
dx
x
5/4
=
5
4
x
9
4
(f )
d
dx
s
3
s
3
=
d
ds
s
19
6
=
19
6
s
13
6
(g)
d
du
1
u
3
=
du
3
du
= 3u
4
(h)
d
dt
t
t
2
=
d
dt
t
3
2
=
3
2
t
5
2
(i)
d
dx
x
1
2
x
x
=
d
dx
1 = 0
Exercise 3.3
When x = 8 we have y =
3
2
3
and
so
dy
dx
=
1
12
when x = 8. The tangent therefore has equation
y =
1
12
x + b.
Substituting x = 8 and y = 2 into this equation we obtain
2 =
1
12
8 + b
so that b =
4
3
. The equation is therefore y =
x
12
+
4
3
.
Exercise 3.4
(a) f
(x) = 10x x
1
2
(b)
dy
dx
= 14x
8
6x
3
(c) f
(t) = 5.75t
1.3
+
1
2
t
1
2
(d) h
(z) =
1
3
z
4
3
+ 5 (e) f
(u) =
5
3
u
2
3
+ 21u
8
(f ) g
(z) = 16z
3
+ 5z
2
(g)
dy
dt
= 40t
9
+
1
2
t
1
2
(h)
dz
dx
=
4
7
x
6
7
x
3
2
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 38
Exercise 3.5
(a) f
(x) = 12x
2
(1 3x) 3(4x
3
+ 2)
(b) g
(x) = (9x
2
4x + 8)(x
2
2x + 4) + (3x
3
2x
2
+ 8x 5)(2x 2)
(d) f
(t) = (
t
1
2
2
t
2
)(2t 1) + 2(
t +
1
t
)
(f ) h
(y) = (
y
1
2
2
+ 2y)(1 3y
2
) 6y(2
y + y
2
)
Exercise 3.6
The rate of change of r with respect to t is
dr
dt
= (1 t
2
)(t
2
2t + 1) + (t +
1
t
)(2t 2).
Substituting t = 2 we obtain (1
1
4
)(4 4 + 1) + (2 +
1
2
)(4 2) =
23
4
.
Exercise 3.7
The gradient of the tangent is given by
dy
dx
= (2x 2)(3x
3
5x
2
+ 2) + (x
2
2x + 1)(9x
2
10x).
Substituting x = 2 we obtain 28.
Exercise 3.8
(a) f
(x) =
(x + 1) (x 1)
(x + 1)
2
=
2
(x + 1)
2
(b) g
(x) =
(3x 2)2 (2x + 3)3
(3x 2)
2
=
13
(3x 2)
2
(c) h
(x) =
(x
2
+ 5)2x (x
2
+ 2)2x
(x
2
+ 5)
2
=
6x
(x
2
+ 5)
2
(d) f
(t) =
(1 + 2t
2
)2 8t
2
(1 + 2t
2
)
2
=
2 4t
2
(1 + 2t
2
)
2
(e) f
(s) =
(1
s)
1
2
s
1
2
+ (1 +
s)
1
2
s
1/2
(1
s)
2
=
s
1
2
(1
s)
2
(f ) h
(x) =
(x
3
+ 4)2x (x
2
1)3x
2
(x
3
+ 4)
2
=
x
4
+ 3x
2
+ 8x
(x
3
+ 4)
2
(g) f
(u) =
(3u
4
+ 5)(3u
2
+ 1) (u
3
+ u 4)12u
3
(3u
4
+ 5)
2
=
3u
6
9u
4
+ 48u
3
+ 15u
2
+ 5
(3u
4
+ 5)
2
(h) g
(t) =
(t
2
+ 3t + 1)(2t + 6) (t
2
+ 6t)(2t + 3)
(t
2
+ 3t + 1)
2
=
3t
2
+ 2t + 6
(t
2
+ 3t + 1)
2
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 39
Exercise 3.9
(a)
d
dx
(2x + 3)
2
= 8x + 12
(b)
d
dx
(x
2
+ 2x + 1)
12
= 12(x
2
+ 2x + 1)
11
(2x + 2)
(c)
d
dx
(3 x)
21
= 21(3 x)
20
(d)
d
dx
(x
3
1)
5
= 5(x
3
1)
4
3x
2
= 15x
2
(x
3
1)
4
(e)
d
dt
t
2
5t + 7 =
d
dt
(t
2
5t + 7)
1
2
=
1
2
(t
2
5t + 7)
1
2
(2t 5)
(f )
d
dz
2 z
4
=
d
dz
(2 z
4
)
1
2
= 2z
3
(2 z
4
)
3
2
(g)
d
dt
(t
3
t)
3.8
= 3.8(t
3
t)
4.8
(3t
2
1
2
t
)
(h)
d
dx
(x +
1
x
)
3
7
=
3
7
(x +
1
x
)
4
7
(1
1
x
2
)
Exercise 3.10
(a)
d
dx
(x + 2)(x + 3)
2
= (x + 3)
2
+ 2(x + 2)(x + 3)
(b)
d
dx
(2x 1)
2
(x + 3)
3
= 4(2x 1)(x + 3)
3
+ 3(2x 1)
2
(x + 3)
2
(c)
d
dx
1 x
1 x
x
2
1 x
(d)
d
dx
x
1
3
(1 x)
2
3
=
1
3
x
2
3
(1 x)
2
3
2
3
x
1
3
(1 x)
1
3
(e)
d
dx
1 x
2
1 x
2
+ x
2
(1 x
2
)
1
2
1 x
2
Exercise 3.11
(a) f
(x) =
6x
2
2x
3
=
3
x
Alternatively write f(x) = ln 2 + 3 ln x so that f
(x) = 3
1
x
.
(b) f
(x) = 7x
6
e
x
7
(c) f
(x) =
7
x
(d) f
(x) = (2x + 3x
2
)e
x
2
+x
3
(e) Write f(x) = log
e
7 2 log
e
x so that f
(x) =
2
x
.
(f ) f
(x) = e
x
(g) f
(x) =
e
x
+ 3x
2
e
x
+ x
3
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 40
(h) Write f(x) = ln e
x
+ 3 ln x so that f
(x) = 1 +
3
x
.
(i) Write f(x) = ln(x
2
+ 1) ln(x
3
x) so that f
(x) =
2x
x
2
+ 1
3x
2
1
x
3
x
.
Exercise 3.12
(a)
d
dx
cos 3x = 3 sin 3x
(b)
d
dx
sin(4x + 5) = 4 cos(4x + 5)
(c)
d
dx
sin
3
x = 3 sin
2
x cos x
(d)
d
dx
sin x cos x = cos
2
x sin
2
x
(e)
d
dx
x
2
sin x = 2x sin x + x
2
cos x
(f )
d
dx
cos(x
2
+ 1) = 2x sin(x
2
+ 1)
(g)
d
dx
sin x
x
=
x cos x sin x
x
2
(h)
d
dx
sin
1
x
=
1
x
2
cos
1
x
(i)
d
dx
tan
x =
1
2
x
sec
2
x
(j)
d
dx
1
x
sin
1
x
=
1
x
2
sin
1
x
1
x
3
cos
1
x
Exercise 4.1
f
(x) = 4x
3
4x so f
(t) = (1 2t
2
)e
t
2
. Setting this equal to zero and solving we nd that the stationary
points are at t =
1
2
and the maximum must occur at one of the points t = 2,
1
2
, 2.
Substituting into g(t) we nd that the maximum value occurs at t =
1
2
.
Exercise 4.3
h
(u) = 6u
2
+ 6u 12 = 6(u
2
+ u 2). The stationary points are at u = 2, 1 and the
minimum value occurs at one of the points u = 3, 2, 1, 2. Substituting into h(u) we
nd that the minimum occurs at u = 1.
x
8 - x /2
Mathematics Learning Centre, University of Sydney 41
Exercise 4.4
If we let the side of the run that is opposite the existing wall have length x, then the other
side of the run has length 8
x
2
.
The area of the run is A(x) = x(8
x
2
) and we must maximise this function in the region
0 x 16. Dierentiating gives A