Mentor Texts for Comprehension Strategy Instruction

Grades 3-5

This document was compiled by a professional learning community of educators from the Wachusett Regional School District. The goal of this group was to develop a bibliography of possible mentor texts to support instruction for the following comprehension strategies: making connections, creating sensory images, asking questions, making inferences, summarizing, and synthesizing. The attached lists of mentor texts are not exhaustive, but are ones that teachers in the district have used successfully with students in their classrooms. It is hoped that these lists of mentor texts will be helpful to teachers of grades 3-5 throughout the district, but as with all instructional materials, classroom teachers should use their professional judgment when deciding the most appropriate texts for their students and teaching objectives. Many thanks to the following educators who contributed to this document: Paula Atlas, Glenwood Elementary School Laura Costello, Glenwood Elementary School Jennifer DeFeudis, Chocksett Middle School Suellen Dumas, Glenwood Elementary School Amy LeBouf, Houghton Elementary School Jennifer Leith, Mayo Elementary School Elizabeth Sabacinski, Chocksett Middle School Kate White, Mayo Elementary School Facilitators: Charlene Griffin and Catherine Schofield, Literacy Coaches

Selecting Texts for Comprehension Strategy Instruction

Making Connections and Activating Schema Choose texts on topics that students are likely to have some background knowledge. Consider texts on topics that are familiar to students so that students are more likely to connect new information to what they already know to construct meaning. Asking Questions Choose texts that spark genuine wonder and inquiry. Consider texts with an element of ambiguity or texts/topics for which readers lack schema. Making Inferences Choose texts that contain some ambiguity in which all information/details are not explicitly stated. Fictional texts with thought-provoking characters and themes work well. Consider texts that encourage the reader to think about what they know and merge their thinking with clues in the text to make an inference and deepen their understanding. Creating Sensory Images/Visualizing Choose texts in which the writer paints a picture with words. Consider texts that include active verbs and specific nouns to show rather than merely tell the story or information. Determining Importance Choose a text that is packed with details so that readers have to sift out the most important information. Consider texts with features such as subheadings to help students to locate information easily. Summarizing and Synthesizing Choose dense texts packed with information and/or complex ideas. Consider texts that require students to get the gist, put information in their own words, and sift out the most important ideas from a sea of facts and information.

Monitoring for Meaning Choose texts will allow the teacher to model the desired comprehension monitoring behavior (e.g., noticing picture clues, using context clues). Consider texts of various genres.

Source: Strategies that Work, 2nd Edition and The Comprehension Toolkit by Stephanie Harvey and Anne Goudvis

Making Connections
A Days Work by Eve Bunting
Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A boy and his grandfather work as day laborers. The boy learns a lesson after making a mistake and seeing his grandfathers reaction. Teaching Points: text-to-world connections; see also making inferences

Advice to a Frog by Alice Schertle

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Fourteen poems about animals, many with environmental overtones. Teaching Points: text-to-world connections (environmental issues); see also creating sensory images

Baseball Saved Us by Ken Mochizuki

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Narrative story of a boys familys move to and time in a Japanese internment camp during World War II. Carries reader through time when baseball unified the group and offered opportunity for personal growth. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections (teasing, feelings of inferiority), textto-world connections (Pearl Harbor, immigration issues)

The Basket Moon by Mary Lyn Ray

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: The story of a young boy whose father makes baskets in a rural community and travels to town to sell them. Teaching Points: text-to-text connections with Ox-Cart Man by Donald Hall; see also creating sensory images; cross-curricular connections to social studies

Bee Alert! article from Scholastic News, March 30, 1998

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Article conveys information about the importance of bees including the facts that bees help grow one out of every three bites of food and that mites and pesticides are killing bees. Readers learn that bees arent dangerous. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections (personal/background experience with bees), text-to-text connections (relate to other bee information), text-to-world connections (implications of article)

The Cello of Mr. O by Jane Cutler

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: First person narrative of a girls life during wartime in a devastated city. The music from her neighbor, Mr. O, provides inspiration and gives her courage. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections (fear, worry, perceptions of elderly); text-to-text connections (Old Henry, other war stories); text-to-world connections (no power/ice storm, perceptions of elderly)

Come On, Rain by Karen Hesse

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young girl and her mother endure the heat of a summer day and wait for the rain to bring relief. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections; see also sensory images

Dad, Jackie, and Me by Myron Uhlberg

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Narrative told from a young boys perspective about Jackie Robinson and the integration of baseball. Teaching Points: text-to-text connections with Jackies Bat by Marybeth Lorbiecki (different perspectives of the same historical event)

Jackies Bat by Marybeth Lorbiecki

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Narrative told from a young boys perspective about Jackie Robinson and the integration of baseball. Teaching Points: text-to-text connections with Dad, Jackie, and Me by Myron Uhlberg (different perspectives of the same historical event)

My Ol Man by Patricia Polacco

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Patricia and her brother are spending the summer with their father and grandmother. When the father loses his job, the family finds hope in a magical rock and later realizes that the magic was inside them all the time. Teaching Points: text-to-self/world connections (loss of job, struggle to maintain hope)

Every Living Thing by Cynthia Rylant

Grade(s): 3-5

Summary: Various short stories about animals that inspires many connections. For example, in Papas Parrot Harry Tillian stops visiting his fathers candy shop as he grows up. Mr. Tillian buys a parrot named Rocky to keep him company. After Mr. Tillian becomes ill, Harry learns an important lesson. Teaching Points: text-to-self/text/world connections

Granddaddys Gift by Margaree King Mitchell

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Set in Mississippi in the 1960s, an African-American grandfather volunteers to register to vote. Despite the dangers, he longs for his granddaughters life to be better and for her to have greater opportunity. Teaching Points: text-to-text connections (use with other books about struggles of African-Americans); see also synthesizing

The Hello, Goodbye Window by Norton Juster

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A young girl is cared for by her grandparents. The family has a special window where she is greeted and waves goodbye. This book demonstrates how special family experiences can create memories that last forever. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections

Lightning by Seymour Simon

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Lightning is explored through dramatic photographs and vivid descriptions. Kids love this book! Teaching Points: text-to-self/world connections; see also creating sensory images; cross-curricular connections to science

The Relatives Came by Cynthia Rylant

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: The story of relatives visiting from Virginia. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections

Say Something by Peggy Moss

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A story about teasing, bullying, and being ignored. Important lessons in empathy and thinking about how ones actions can result in change are conveyed.

Teaching Points: text-to-self connections, text-to-text connections with The Hundred Dresses by Eleanor Estes; also ties in with Second Step program

The Story of the Sea Glass by Anne Wescott Dodd

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Nicole and her grandmother visit an island and find a rare piece of red sea glass. The red sea glass reminds the grandmother of an event from her childhood that she shares with Nicole. Information about sea glass is included in the narrative text. Teaching Points: text-to-self connections; see also creating sensory images

Under the Quilt of Night by Deborah Hopkinson and James Ransome

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Beautifully illustrated story about a slave girl who escapes on the Underground Railroad. Teaching Points: text-to-world connections; see also creating sensory images; cross-curricular connections to history/social studies

The Wall by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A boy and his father go to the Vietnam Memorial to see the grandfathers name. Teaching Points: text-to-self/world connections (losses of war, memorial items, wounded veterans, gravestone rubbings)

Creating Sensory Images

Advice to a Frog by Alice Schertle
Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Fourteen poems about animals, many with environmental overtones. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections

Astonishing Animals (Guinness World Records series) by Joanne Mattern and Ryan
Herndon Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Information about 25 record-breaking animals. Teaching Points: creating sensory images, especially visual images

The Basket Moon by Mary Lyn Ray

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: The story of a young boy whose father makes baskets in a rural community and travels to town to sell them. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections; cross-curricular connections to social studies

Charlottes Web by E. B. White

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A classic story of friendship and the circle of life on Zuckermans farm. Teaching Points: rich, descriptive language and mature vocabulary for creating sensory images

A Chair for My Mother by Vera B. Williams

Grade(s): 3 Summary: A young girl, mother, and grandmother save their spare coins to buy a special chair. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; text is also useful for teaching story elements and retelling

Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs by Judi Barrett

Grade(s): 3 Summary: The story of a town where food falls from the sky three times a day.

Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language, images of food are very accessible for students; see also summarizing

Come On, Rain by Karen Hesse

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young girl and her mother endure the heat of a summer day and wait for the rain to bring relief. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections

Eleanor by Barbara Cooney

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: The story of Eleanor Roosevelts childhood Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language about family activities and history

Hello Ocean by Pam Munoz Ryan

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A young girl spends the day at the beach and uses her five senses to describe her experience. Scientific information is incorporated into the rhyming text. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language that appeals to all five senses

If Not For The Cat by Jack Prelutsky

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A collection of haiku poetry about many creatures. Teaching Points: creating sensory images poems include strong verbs and very descriptive adjectives

Lightning by Seymour Simon

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Lightning is explored with dramatic photographs and vivid descriptions. Kids love this book! Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections; cross-curricular connections to science

10

Old Black Fly by Jim Aylesworth

Grade(s): 3 Summary: Alphabet book about a pesky black fly. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from playful and vivid descriptions

Owl Moon by Jane Yolen

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: One winter night a father and daughter go out owling. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language that appeals to several senses

Ragged Shadows: Poems of Halloween Night selected by Lee Bennett Hopkins

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A compilation of 14 poems about Halloween. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from the poets rich use of descriptive language

Song and Dance Man by Karen Ackerman

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A grandfather tells his grandchildren about his life when he worked in Vaudeville. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language

The Story of the Sea Glass by Anne Wescott Dodd

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Nicole and her grandmother visit an island and find a rare piece of red sea glass. The red sea glass reminds the grandmother of an event from her childhood that she shares with Nicole. Information about sea glass is included in the narrative text. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections

A Symphony of Whales by Steve Schuch

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: In the winter of 1984-1985, nearly 3,000 beluga whales were trapped in a strait in Siberia. The main character, Glashka, hears the cries of the whales. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; crosscurricular connections to social studies/other cultures

11

Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbitt

Grade(s): 5 Summary: The Tuck family gains eternal life after drinking from a magic spring. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language, prologue and chapter 1 include examples of figurative language, text is also useful for teaching setting (time/place/environment); see also synthesizing

Under the Quilt of Night by Deborah Hopkinson and James Ransome

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Beautifully illustrated story about a slave girl who escapes on the Underground Railroad. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; see also making connections; cross-curricular connections to history/social studies

Who Came Down That Road? by George Ella Lyon

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A mother and child look at a path near their home and consider the various groups that may have used that path throughout history. Teaching Points: creating sensory images from descriptive language; crosscurricular connections to history/social studies

12

Asking Questions
Because of Winn-Dixie by Kate DiCamillo
Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A colorful cast of characters surrounds a girl and her new dog. Themes include friendship, self-realization, and maturity. Teaching Points: asking questions, especially generating questions while reading about setting, the characters pasts, character interactions

Cheyenne Again by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: In the late 1800s, a young Cheyenne boy is taken from his home and sent to a boarding school to learn the white mans ways. The boy struggles, but learns, to hold onto his heritage and memories. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading, the ending is especially thought-provoking; see also making inferences

Granddaddys Gift by Margaree King Mitchell

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Set in Mississippi in the 1960s, an African-American grandfather volunteers to register to vote. Despite the dangers, he longs for his granddaughters life to be better and for her to have greater opportunity. Teaching Points: asking questions, especially about character motivation; see also making connections, asking questions, inferring, synthesizing

How Many Days to America? A Thanksgiving Story by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A Caribbean island family is forced to leave their homeland to escape war. They sail on an overcrowded fishing boat to America. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading good for modeling this strategy

I Can Hear The Sun by Patricia Polacco

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: An orphaned boy meets and comes to be loved by a group of lonely people at a bird sanctuary. He begins to care for the geese and has a special ability with them. Eventually, he flies away with them leaving those left behind filled with hope and wonder.

13

Teaching Points: asking questions about what really happened in the story; opportunities for students to debate the powerful but unclear ending, and cite evidence from the text to support their ideas

Knots on a Counting Rope by Bill Martin, Jr. and John Archambault

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A Native American story about a grandfather who retells the circumstances surrounding his grandsons birth and early life. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading

The Lotus Seed by Sherry Garland

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young Vietnamese girl saves a lotus seed to remember a brave emperor and her homeland. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading

Mr. Peabodys Apples by Madonna

Grades(s): 3-5 Summary: A boy sees his baseball coach apparently take an apple without paying for it and spreads the rumor that his coach is a thief. Once it becomes clear that the coach had not stolen the apple, the boy works to attempt to undo the harm done by his hasty and false judgment. Teaching Points: asking questions, especially about truth, reputation, and forgiveness

Pink and Say by Patricia Polacco

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Based on a true story, this book follows two teenage boys during the Civil War. Their friendship blossoms as they deal with injuries, fear, and death. Teaching Points: asking questions about the story line and language

The Royal Bee by Frances Park and Ginger Park

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young boy wants to learn to read and write, but because of his familys status in Korean culture he must overcome challenges to accomplish his goal. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading

14

Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Marty finds a mistreated dog. He cares for the dog in secret, but finally makes a deal with the abusive owner to work for him in exchange for the dog. Teaching Points: asking questions, especially about character behavior and motivation

Shes Wearing a Dead Bird on Her Head! by Kathryn Lasky

Grade(s): 3 Summary: Harriet and Minna are upset with the killing of birds for use in hats and decorations so they decide to take action. The story chronicles the development of the Audubon Society and how two women made a difference in 1896. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences; cross-curricular connections to social studies (Massachusetts history)

Stormy Weather by Jacob Aarons

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Nonfiction text about severe weather, including causes, dangers, and protection. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; crosscurricular connections to science

Sweet Clara and the Freedom Quilt by Deborah Hopkinson

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A young slave girl sews a quilt that shows the Underground Railroad and the route to freedom in the North. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences; cross-curricular connections to social studies

The Sweetest Fig by Chris VanAllsburg

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A dentist is given two magic figs that were promised to make his dreams come true. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading

Tight Times by Barbara Shook Hazen

Grade(s): 4-5

15

Summary: A young boy whose family is struggling financially wishes for a pet dog. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences

The Wretched Stone by Chris VanAllsburg

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A captains record of an extraordinary journey to sea and back. The crew begins as avid readers, musicians, and storytellers, but the wretched stone they find seems to change them. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences

16

Making Inferences
A Days Work by Eve Bunting
Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A boy and his grandfather work as day laborers. The boy learns a lesson after making a mistake and seeing his grandfathers reaction. Teaching Points: text-to-world connections; see also making inferences

A Picnic in October by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A boy and his family make an annual trip to Battery Park to celebrate the anniversary of his grandparents immigration to America. Teaching Points: making inferences, especially about characters actions and unspoken words; cross-curricular connections to social studies (immigration)

The Aunt in Our House by Angela Johnson

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: Two children tell the tale of the aunt who comes to their house. The true reason for the aunts presence is not revealed. Teaching Points: minimal text offers much opportunity for making inferences

Boxes for Katie by Candace Fleming

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The story of a town in post-War Holland that receives boxes of supplies from an American girl. Teaching Points: making inferences theme; see also summarizing

Cheyenne Again by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: In the late 1800s, a young Cheyenne boy is taken from his home and sent to a boarding school to learn the white mans ways. They boy struggles, but learns, to hold onto his heritage and memories. Teaching Points: making inferences character traits, character motivation, theme; see also asking questions

Crickwing by Janell Cannon

Grade(s): 3-5

17

Summary: Tired of being bullied, a cockroach with a twisted wing begins picking on smaller creatures. The smaller creatures are not as harmless as they seem, but when they are threatened, Crickwing becomes an unlikely hero. Teaching Points: making inferences - character change/development, theme; see also synthesizing

The Dot by Peter Reynolds

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A girl who thinks she cant draw makes a single dot. Gradually, her confidence grows and she becomes more and more successful as an artist. Finally, she shares her wisdom with another child. Teaching Points: making inferences predicting, character development/change, theme

Dreaming of America: An Ellis Island Story by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4 Summary: When traveling to America, Annie Moore and her younger brothers are separated from their parents. Includes details about immigration through Ellis Island Teaching Points: making inferences; cross-curricular connections to social studies (immigration)

The Gardener by Sarah Stewart

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: Set during the Great Depression, a young girl leaves her home and goes to live with her grumpy uncle in the city. She brings with her a love and knowledge of plants and flowers that transforms her city dwelling. In the process, her uncle is transformed as well. The story is told entirely through letters sent between the girl and her family. Teaching Points: making inferences drawing conclusions, character traits/development, using background knowledge to support inferences

Good Dog, Carl by Alexander Day

Grade(s): 3 Summary: In this mostly wordless picture book, Carl, the dog, is left to babysit a young child. The child and Carl have many adventures while Mom is at the store. When Mom returns, all is well in the house.

18

Teaching Points: making inferences introducing inferring, using illustrations to infer

Kamishibai Man by Allen Say

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: After being retired for many years, an old Kamishibai Man (Japanese street performer and storyteller) returns to his city to perform once again. Teaching Points: making inferences change in time/flashback

The Lily Cupboard: A Story of the Holocaust by Shulamith Levey Oppenheim

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A young Jewish girl is sent to the country for safety during World War II. Teaching Points: making inferences character traits/motivation

Minty: A Story of Young Harriet Tubman by Alan Schroeder and Jerry Pinkney

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Fictionalized account of Harriet Tubmans childhood. The basic facts about eight year old Minty are true, but some specific scenes were created by the author. Teaching Points: making inferences character traits/motivation

Mirette on the High Wire by Emily Arnold McCully

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A girl in London in the 1800s meets a high wire walker and learns to walk the high wire herself. Teaching Points: making inferences character traits/actions/motivation

Mr. Lincolns Way by Patricia Polacco

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A young boy who acts as like a bully due to racist views expressed in his home learns to accept and celebrate differences thanks to the intervention of a caring African-American principal and some special birds. Teaching Points: making inferences character development, theme

Mr. Peabodys Apples by Madonna

Grades(s): 3-5

19

Summary: A boy sees his baseball coach apparently take an apple without paying for it and spreads the rumor that his coach is a thief. Once it becomes clear that the coach had not stolen the apple, the boy works to attempt to undo the harm done by his hasty and false judgment. Teaching Points: making inferences character traits, theme; see also asking questions

The Mystery of Sara Beth by Polly Putnam

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: Sara Beth is a new student so Becky and her friends try to make her feel welcome. Becky becomes concerned when Sara Beth seems to be acting strangely so she sets out to solve the mystery. Teaching Points: making inferences about characters actions

The Royal Bee by Frances Park and Ginger Park

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young boy wants to learn to read and write, but because of his familys status in Korean culture he must overcome challenges to accomplish his goal. Teaching Points: making inferences difference between predicting/inferring, meanings of unknown words, theme; see also asking questions

Shes Wearing a Dead Bird on Her Head! by Kathryn Lasky

Grade(s): 3 Summary: Harriet and Minna are upset with the killing of birds for use in hats and decorations so they decide to take action. The story chronicles the development of the Audubon Society and how two women made a difference in 1896. Teaching Points: making inferences figurative language; see also asking questions; cross-curricular connections to social studies (Massachusetts history)

Sweet Clara and the Freedom Quilt by Deborah Hopkinson

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A young slave girl sews a quilt that shows the Underground Railroad and the route to freedom in the North. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences; cross-curricular connections to social studies

Tight Times by Barbara Shook Hazen

Grade(s): 4-5

20

Summary: A young boy whose family is struggling financially wishes for a pet dog. Teaching Points: making inferences; see also asking questions

Time Flies by Eric Rohmann

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A wordless picture book about a bird that flies into a museum and travel back in time to the days when dinosaurs roamed the earth. Teaching Points: making inferences introducing inferring, using illustrations to infer

Wave by Suzy Lee

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: A wordless picture book that depicts the interaction between a girl and the surf. Illustrations evoke the girls personality and her experience with great depth. Teaching Points: making inferences predicting, drawing conclusions, character feelings/development/change

The Wretched Stone by Chris VanAllsburg

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A captains record of an extraordinary journey to sea and back. The crew begins as avid readers, musicians, and storytellers, but the wretched stone they find seems to change them. Teaching Points: asking questions before, during, and after reading; see also making inferences

21

Summarizing
Always Remember Me: How One Family Survived World War II by Marisabina
Russo Grade(s): 5 Summary: Based on the authors family history, this book chronicles the events of a Jewish family before, during, and after World War II. Many recreations of primary source materials are included. Teaching Points: summarizing timeline of events in main characters family; using primary source materials

Boxes for Katie by Candace Fleming

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The story of a town in post-War Holland that receives boxes of supplies from an American girl. Teaching Points: summarizing events; see also making inferences

Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs by Judi Barrett

Grade(s): 3 Summary: The story of a town where food falls from the sky three times a day. Teaching Points: summarizing clear sequence and story elements; see also creating sensory images

Diary of a Worm (or Fly or Spider) by Doreen Cronin

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A humorous diary of a worms experiences. Teaching Points: Summarizing telling the gist of the worms experiences as revealed through the diary entries; see also synthesizing

George Did It! by Suzanne Tripp Jurmain

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: Engaging text and illustrations explains why Americans wanted George Washington to become president and his reluctance to accept the position. Teaching Points: summarizing timeline/sequencing of Washingtons life events

The Great Kapok Tree by Lynne Cherry

Grade(s): 3-4

22

Summary: A man enters a rainforest intending to chop down trees. After falling asleep, he is convinced by the animals and people not to destroy their home. Teaching Points: summarizing clear plot development and conflict resolution

Jumanji by Chris VanAllsburg

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: A young boy and girl find a board game. As they begin playing, the events of the game come to life. Teaching Points: summarizing story events

The Librarian of Basra: A True Story from Iraq by Jeanette Winter

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The true story of a librarians struggle to save the books in her library from the ravages of war. Teaching Points: summarizing difference between retelling and summarizing, elements of a summary

The Man Who Walked Between the Towers by Mordicai Gerstein

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The true story of Philippe Petits tightrope walk between the World Trade Center towers in 1974. Teaching Points: summarizing the difference between retelling and summarizing, elements of a summary

My Name is Georgia by Jeanette Winter

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A biography of painter Georgia OKeefe, told from her perspective. Teaching Points: summarizing text includes clear beginning, middle, and end

Rare Treasure by Don Brown

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A biographical account of the life of paleontologist, Mary Anning. Told as a narrative, this nonfiction book follows the life of a woman scientist who was ahead of her time. Teaching Points: summarizing the difference between summarizing and retelling; see also synthesizing

23

Synthesizing
Aesops Fables selected/illustrated by Michael Hauge
Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: Retellings of classic fables that teach essential life lessons Teaching Points: synthesizing lesson/theme

The Alphabet Tree by Leo Lionni

Grade(s): 3-4 Summary: The creation of the alphabet from letters to words to sentences told through nature. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in thinking

An Angel for Solomon Singer by Cynthia Rylant

Grade(s): 5 Summary: A man who lives in New York longs for the things he cant have and for places from his past. One night he enters a caf where all your dreams come true. He eventually begins to appreciate and enjoy the things in his life. Synthesizing: synthesizing changes in thinking

Chicken Soup for the Kids Soul by Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen, Patty
Hansen, and Irene Dunlap Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A collection of short stories and poems by various authors with important and inspiring themes. Teaching Points: synthesizing changes in thinking

Crickwing by Janell Cannon

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Tired of being bullied, a cockroach with a twisted wing begins picking on smaller creatures. The smaller creatures are not as harmless as they seem, but when they are threatened, Crickwing becomes an unlikely hero. Teaching Points: synthesizing noticing character change/development; see also making inferences

Diary of a Worm (or Fly or Spider) by Doreen Cronin

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A humorous diary of a worms experiences. 24

Teaching Points: Synthesizing using background knowledge to understand humor; see also summarizing

Gleam and Glow by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The story of a family who is forced to flee their war-torn country. The familys beloved goldfish are left behind, but when the family is reunited and returns home they find that the goldfish, like the family, have survived. Teaching Points: synthesizing finding symbolism

Goin Someplace Special by Patricia McKissack

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Set in segregated Nashville in the 1950s, young Tricia Ann is frustrated by the Jim Crows that exclude her from many public places but she finds welcome at the public library. Teaching Points: synthesizing changes in thinking about importance of libraries/reading, effects of segregation

Granddaddys Gift by Margaree King Mitchell

Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: Set in Mississippi in the 1960s, an African-American grandfather volunteers to register to vote. Despite the dangers, he longs for his granddaughters life to be better and for her to have greater opportunity. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in the readers understanding of the gift as the story unfolds; see also making connections, asking questions, inferring

Lemonade Club by Patricia Polacco

Grade(s): 5 Summary: Traci and Marilyn love their fifth grade teacher, Miss Wichelman and learn in her class that if life hands you lemons, make lemonade. Marilyn becomes ill with leukemia, but together the class is able to support her. Teaching Points: synthesizing using multiple strategies, changes in thinking

The Lorax by Dr. Seuss

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A story about how greed impacts the environment. Includes a strong conservation theme and teaches that ones actions do make a difference.

25

Teaching Points: synthesizing changes in thinking; cross-curricular connections to science

The Man Who Kept His Heart in a Bucket by Sonia Levitin

Grade(s): 5 Summary: A young man who keeps his heart in a bucket to protect it from being broken loses his heart in a stream to a beautiful maiden and must figure out how to get it back. He learns that when his heart is in a bucket, it is useless to him. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in thinking

The Other Side by Jacqueline Woodson

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A story of friendship across a racial divide. Teaching Points: synthesizing finding symbolism as the fence grows in significance, especially in the last line of the text

My Pig Amarillo by Satomi Ichikawa

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Pablito, a Guatemalan boy, loses his beloved pet pig, Amarillo. With the help of his grandfather, he finds a way to send his lost pet a message. Teaching Points: symbolism tracking changes in thinking

Rare Treasure by Don Brown

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: A biographical account of the life of paleontologist, Mary Anning. Told as a narrative, this nonfiction book follows the life of a woman scientist who was ahead of her time. Teaching Points: synthesizing the last page of the book demonstrates that synthesis goes beyond the content of the piece when the reader adds his/her own thoughts or opinions; see also summarizing

Rules by Cynthia Lord

Grade(s): 5 Summary: Catherines brother David is autistic and their family life revolves around his needs. She is often frustrated and embarrassed by her brother and creates rules for him to live by.

26

Teaching Points: good interactive read aloud to model using multiple comprehension strategies and synthesizing thinking, especially about authors message/theme/point of view

Smoky Nights by Eve Bunting

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: The story of a familys experiences during the Los Angeles riots. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in thinking

Tough Boris by Mem Fox

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Boris is a tough pirate, but he still mourns when his parrot dies. Teaching Points: synthesizing changes in perceptions about a character

Tomas and the Library Lady by Pat Mora

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Inspired by the childhood experiences of Tomas Rivera who became a chancellor at the University of California, this book tells the story of the child of a migrant farm family who discovers the joy and power of the public library. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in thinking about the power of books and reading

Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbitt

Grade(s): 5 Summary: The Tuck family gains eternal life after drinking from a magic spring. Teaching Points: synthesizing changes in thinking about living forever; see also creating sensory images

The Worry Stone by Marianne Dengler

Grade(s): 5 Summary: An elderly woman visits the park each day and notices a lonely boy. She is reminded of her days as a young girl spending time with her grandfather and the stories that he told her, especially one about the worry stone. The woman shares the worry stone story with the boy and they begin a new friendship. Teaching Points: synthesizing tracking changes in thinking

27

Other Great Books for Integration with Social Studies

The American Story: 100 True Tales from American History by Jennifer

Armstrong Grade(s): 3-5 Summary: One hundred engaging stories that chronicle Americas history. Some tales feature well known historical figures while others people and events are lesser known.

Journeys for Freedom: A New Look at Americas Story by Susan Buckley and

Elspeth Leacock Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Twenty stories about journeys to escape various types of oppression. The time period for the stories ranges from 1631 to 1988.

Journey to Ellis Island: How My Father Came to America by Carol Bierman

Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: This book follows a boy and his family as they travel to America from Russia in 1917.

Kids Make History: A New Look at Americas Story by Susan Buckley and Elspeth
Leacock Grade(s): 4-5 Summary: Twenty stories about kids who helped make history.

28

Sources of Short Texts for Upper Elementary and Middle School Grades
What Do Fish Have to Do with Anything? Growing Up Stories Chicken Soup for the Kids Soul Flora and Tiger: 19 Very Short Stories From Life Sing A Song of Tuna Fish: Memoir of Fifth Grade When I Was Your Age: Original Stories about Growing Up Home: American Writers Remember Rooms of Their Own All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten It Was On Fire When I Lay Down on It Short Circuits: A Collection of Science Fiction Grand Mothers: Poems, Reminiscences, and Short Stories About the Keepers of Our Traditions Childtimes: A Three-Generation Memoir Birthday Surprises: Ten Great Stories to Unwrap Some of the Kinder Planets In Short: A Collection of Brief, Creative, Non-fiction Fables An Island Like You: Stories of the Barrio Altogether, One at a Time Hey World, Here I Am! America Street: A Multicultural Anthology of Stories Tripping Over the Lunch Lady and Other School Stories Never in a Hurry: Essays on People and Places The Madonna Stories Father Water, Mother Wood: Essays on Hunting and Fishing in the Northern Woods Shelf Life: Stories by the Book Zebra and Other Stories Living Out Loud Leaving Home: Stories Somehow Tenderness Survives: Stories of Southern Africa Funny Stories: A Zany Collection of Humorous Tales Children of Christmas: Stories of the Season Every Living Thing Squids Will Be Squids: Fresh Morals, Beastly Tales A Summer Life Living up the Street: Narrative Collections Baseball in April and Other Stories Local News Listen Children: An Anthology of Black Literature A Gathering of Flowers: Stories about Being Young in America Free to Be You and Me Avi Betsy Byars Jack Canfield et. al. Eric Carle Esme Raji Codell Amy Ehrlich S. Fiffer & S. Fiffer Robert Fulghum Robert Fulghum J. Gallo Nikki Giovanni Eloise Greenfield Johanna Hurwitz Tim Wynne-Jones J. Kitchen & M.Jones Arnold Lobel Judith Ortiz Kofer E. L. Konigsburg Jean Little Anne Mazer Nancy Mercado Naomi Shihab Nye Gary Paulsen Gary Paulsen Gary Paulsen Chaim Potok Anna Quindlen H. Rochman H. Rochman Michael Rosen Cynthia Rylant Cynthia Rylant Jon Sciezka Gary Soto Gary Soto Gary Soto Gary Soto D. Strickland Joyce Carol Thomas Marlo Thomas