Learning Disabilities Guide
Learning Disabilities Guide
Learning Disabilities Guide
The appendices at the end of the document contain planning tools, quick references to strategies, resource lists, and a glossary of useful terminology. Orange-highlighted text throughout the guide provides direct links to the terminology in the glossary.
PAGE | 2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
A number of people contributed to creating this resource. The Ministry of Education is especially appreciative of the partnership with the British Columbia School Superintendents Association in creating this resource. We would also like to acknowledge the following organizations for sharing their expertise and insight to ensure Supporting Students with Learning Disabilities: A Guide for Teachers provides meaningful suggestions for supporting students with learning disabilities in BC. BC Council of Administrators of Special Education BC Principals & Vice-Principals Association BC Teachers Federation Learning Assistance Teachers Association Learning Disabilities Association of British Columbia Special Education Association of British Columbia
PAGE | 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
About this Book .............................................................................................................. 2 Acknowledgements......................................................................................................... 3 SECTION 1 | WHAT IS A LEARNING DISABILITY? ............................... 6 Prevalence of Learning Disabilities.......................................................................... 8 Common Features ...................................................................................................... 9 Types of Learning Disabilities ................................................................................ 14 SECTION 2 | SETTING THE STAGE ............................................................ 22 Differentiated Instruction ....................................................................................... 22 Combining Aspects of Good Practice to Plan for Students .............................. 23 Universal Design for Learning (UDL) .................................................................. 24 Adaptations................................................................................................................ 27 Early Intervention .................................................................................................... 33 Direct Instruction ..................................................................................................... 33 Learning Strategies ................................................................................................... 36 Information and Communications Technologies ............................................... 38 Formative Assessment ............................................................................................. 39 Response to Intervention (RTI) ............................................................................. 39 SECTION 3 | PLANNING ................................................................................... 42 Assessing Learning Disabilities in BC ................................................................... 45 SECTION 4 | STRATEGIES................................................................................ 49 Emotions and Learning ........................................................................................... 50 Learning to Read....................................................................................................... 54 Reading to Learn....................................................................................................... 67 Writing and Expression ........................................................................................... 69 Learning Strategies ................................................................................................... 83 Numeracy and Mathematics ................................................................................... 86 Organization .............................................................................................................. 90 Self Regulation .......................................................................................................... 92 SECTION 5 | CASE STUDIES............................................................................ 94
PAGE | 4
APPENDIX 1 | GLOSSARY ................................................................................ 107 APPENDIX 2 | PLANNING TOOLS ............................................................. 120 Advocacy.................................................................................................................. 120 Self Advocacy .......................................................................................................... 121 Parent Input............................................................................................................. 122 Adaptations.............................................................................................................. 125 Student Reflections ................................................................................................ 128 APPENDIX 3 | QUICK REFERENCES........................................................ 140 APPENDIX 4 | ASSESSMENT TOOLS ........................................................ 168 APPENDIX 5 | RESOURCES ........................................................................... 176 Print .......................................................................................................................... 176 Government of BC Web Resources .................................................................... 179 Other Web Resources ............................................................................................ 183 Bibliography ............................................................................................................ 192
PAGE | 5
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Learning disabilities may also involve difficulties with organizational skills, social perception, social interaction and perspective taking. Learning disabilities are life-long. The way in which they are expressed may vary over an individuals lifetime, depending on the interaction between the demands of the environment and the individuals strengths and needs. Learning disabilities are suggested by unexpected academic under-achievement or achievement that is maintained only by unusually high levels of effort and support.
PAGE | 6
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Learning disabilities are due to genetic and/or neurological factors or injury that alters brain function in a manner that affects one or more processes relate to learning. These disorders are not due primarily to hearing and/or vision problems, socialeconomic factors, cultural or linguistic differences, lack of motivation, inadequate or insufficient instruction, although these factors may further complicate the challenges faced by individuals with learning disabilities. Learning disabilities may co-exist with other disorders such as attention, behavioural or emotional disorders, sensory impairments, or other medical conditions. Learning disabilities can interfere with a student meeting his or her intellectual and life potential. Learning disabilities result in unexpected academic underachievement. Learning disabilities may impact the acquisition, organization, understanding, retention and/or use of information. Learning disabilities are complex and go beyond the stereotypical perceptions of the disorder as simply reading difficulties, or letter reversals. They vary considerably, both in terms of the functions they impact and the severity of the impact experienced. The appropriate accommodations depend upon the individuals strengths as well as his/her specific difficulties. Frequently, learning disabilities are not detected before children start school. Many students with learning disabilities display no signs of difficulty, except when they attempt the specific academic tasks that challenge their particular area of cognitive processing difficulty. Unlike many other disabilities, identifying a learning disability poses some particular challenges since processing disorders are assessed through inference based on student responses. It might not be obvious that a students learning difficulties are due to a learning disability. The specific needs of individuals with learning disabilities change and evolve throughout their lifetime. This does not mean the disability no longer exists, but by varying the activities they undertake and the strategies they develop to address their particular learning disabilities, students may experience different challenges at different times.
PAGE | 7
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
PAGE | 8
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Common Features
Although there is considerable diversity among individuals with learning disabilities, the literature consistently identifies some common characteristics of learning disabilities.
Adapted from Teachers Make the Difference: Teaching Students with Learning Disabilities at Middle School and Secondary School Levels. Ministry of Education Saskatchewan. (2009)
PAGE | 9
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Due to individual differences, no single description or profile can represent all individuals with learning disabilities. Since learning disabilities occur along a spectrum of severity, people can experience mild to significant impacts. Students with learning disabilities have average to above average intelligence and potential, and while they may demonstrate unexpected underachievement compared to their abilities, they can experience academic success and lead happy, successful lives. Self-advocacy helps students gain higher self-perceptions, stronger self-esteem and independence. Students are most likely to experience success in secondary and post-secondary studies if they understand and know how to explain their disabilities, can describe the accommodations that support their learning and engage with an adult to support them in navigating their school experience. Early identification and intervention, appropriate adaptations and supports are keys to success. If a students performance is assessed in the absence of appropriate adaptations, the assessment may not accurately measure the students knowledge. Success for a student with learning disabilities does not mean the disorder disappears. It means that the student makes effective use of strengths and compensatory strategies to accomplish personal and educational goals.
PAGE | 10
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
However the learning difficulty presents itself, students with learning disabilities can experience success in school if appropriate supports are provided. It is important to focus on early identification and remediation and utilize researchbased, effective strategies to assist students before behavioural or emotional issues emerge. See Emotions and Learning (page 50) and Self Regulation (page 92) for strategies to assist with behaviour.
Also see:
Web BC Positive Behaviour Support Website Teaching Students with Learning and Behavioural Differences FRL: Family Resource Library at BC Childrens Hospital BC Childrens Hospital Mood Disorders Clinic www.bcpbs.wordpress.com
www.bced.gov.bc.ca/specialed/landbdif/toc.htm
www.bcchildrens.ca/frl
Caring for Kids. Canadian Paediatric Society Anxiety BC Collaborative Mental Health Care in Canada
www.anxietybc.com www.shared-care.ca/toolkits
PAGE | 11
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Attention Difficulty
Some students with learning disabilities have difficulties focusing, sustaining and shifting attention. These difficulties might result from physical discomfort, emotional issues, interest and motivational factors or from challenges with selfregulation. Persistent patterns of difficulties such as inattention, hyperactivity, or impulsivity, or any combination of these, might be the result of a biologically based condition known as Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder. ADHD is a regulatory problem of attention, activity level and impulse control, and it can have a significant impact on a students ability to learn. A student with self regulation or attention challenges might exhibit difficulties organizing supplies, managing time or categorizing and/or classifying information managing social interactions, taking turns, refraining from calling answers out, controlling emotions, attaining, maintaining and changing levels of arousal developing and using strategies to address academic challenges, and making and following through with a plan or task understanding personal strengths and weaknesses maintaining thought patterns and managing sensory stimulation, e.g. fidgeting, making noises (tapping etc.) or touching people/things.
See Organization (page 90), Self Regulation (page 92), Learning Strategies (page 83), and Emotions and Learning (page 50) for strategies to assist students with attention difficulties.
PAGE | 12
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Memory Difficulty
Students with learning disabilities might demonstrate problems with one or more types of memory. Working memory is a component of memory in which information is stored and/or manipulated for brief periods of time in order to perform another activity. It enables learners to hold on to pieces of information until the pieces blend into a full thought or concept. Working memory is important for a range of activities, such as controlling attention, problem-solving, and listening and reading comprehension. A student with working memory difficulties might have forgotten the first part of an instruction by the time the full instruction has been given. Or the student might be unable to recall the beginning of a sentence by the time he/she has read to the end. Some students will be unable to hold material in working memory in order to complete a task or understand a concept.
PAGE | 13
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Short term Memory is a component of memory where information is stored briefly until it is either forgotten or integrated into long term memory. It is similar to working memory, however more passive as information is not manipulated. A student with short term memory challenges might not be able to remember information long enough to copy it down from one place to another. Long-term memory refers to information that has been stored and is available over a long period of time. Effective short-term memory is critical to move information into long-term memory. A student with long-term memory difficulties might find it necessary to review and study information over a longer period of time in order for it to become part of his or her general body of knowledge. Rehearsal, repetition and association are well-known paths to improving long-term memory. See Learning Strategies (page 83) and Comprehension (page 62) for strategies to address memory difficulties.
Arithmetic Disorder
Arithmetic Disorder (Dyscalculia) is generally characterized by difficulty in learning or comprehending mathematics. It affects a persons ability to understand and manipulate numbers or understand numbers themselves. A student with arithmetic disorder might have difficulty with organizing problems on the page, keeping numbers lined up following through on multiple step calculations, such as long division transposing numbers accurately on paper or on to a calculator, such as turning 56 into 65 distinguishing right from left using the mathematical calculation signs, confusing basic operations and facts
PAGE | 14
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
applying logic but not accurately completing calculations understanding and solving word problems being hesitant, refusing or experiencing anxiety when asked to engage with mathematical concepts remembering and applying mathematical functions in various ways recalling math rules, formulas or sequences being able to perform an operation one day but not the next understanding abstract concepts like time and direction checking change, reading analog clocks, keeping score during games, budgeting, estimating remembering dance step sequences or rules for playing sports visualizing the face of a clock or places on a map recalling dates, addresses, schedules and sequences of past or future events.
See Numeracy and Mathematics (page 86) for strategies to address Arithmetic Disorder.
Writing Disorder
Writing Disorder (Dysgraphia) is generally characterized by distorted writing in spite of thorough instruction. A student with writing disorder might experience some of the following difficulties: inconsistent and sometimes illegible writing; e.g., mixing print and cursive, upper and lower case, irregular sizes, shapes or slant of letters inconsistent positioning on the page, with respect to lines and margins unfinished words or letters, omitted words and many spelling mistakes fine motor difficulty, such as inability to reproduce letters or remembering motor patterns inconsistent speed in writing, either extremely laboured or quick writing that doesnt communicate at the same level as the students other language skills
PAGE | 15
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
odd grip, unusual wrist, body or paper position pain or muscle spasms while writing talking to self while writing, or carefully watching the hand while writing refusal, reluctance or extreme stress when asked to complete a written task.
See Expressive Language Processing (page 71) and Writing (page 69) for strategies to address Writing Disorder (spelling, motor control, planning, drafting and editing).
Reading Disorder
Reading Disorder (Dyslexia) is generally characterized by difficulties with the alphabet, word recognition, decoding, spelling, and comprehension. A student with reading disorder might have difficulty with the following: naming, learning the sequence of or printing the alphabet memorizing non-phonetic words reading words that cannot be translated into a mental picture (and, a, the, etc.) sound/symbol correspondence, or sequencing of letters to create a word reading aloud without repeated mistakes and pauses comprehending reading material, grasp of vocabulary reading numbers and confusing math symbols organizing what he or she wants to say verbally, or not being able to think of the word needed retelling a story in sequence of events finding a word in the dictionary, naming the days of the week and months of the year understanding inferences, jokes or sarcasm.
See Receptive Language Processing (page 65), Phonological Processing (page 60) and Learning to Read (page 54) for strategies to address Reading Disorder (decoding, fluency and comprehension).
PAGE | 16
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
Spelling Disorder
Spelling disorders (Dysorthographia) are generally characterized by difficulties with spelling. They stem from weak awareness or memory of language structures and letters in words. A student with a spelling disorder might present some of the following difficulties, often in conjunction with poor skills in reading and/or arithmetic: arbitrary misspellings, such as addition, omission and/or substitution of letters in words reversal of vowels and/or syllables slow, hesitant or poor written expression errors in conjugation and grammar phonetic spelling of non-phonetic words misunderstanding the correspondence between sounds and letters.
See Decoding (page 54), Spelling (page 73), Organization (page 90), Learning to Read (page 54), and self regulation (page 92) for strategies associated with addressing aspects of Auditory Processing Disorder.
PAGE | 17
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
See Decoding (page 54), Fluency (page 57), Phonological Processing (page 60), Comprehension (page 62) Receptive Language Processing (page 65), Motor Control (page 75) and Organization (page 90) for strategies to assist students with Visual Processing Disorder.
PAGE | 18
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
See Self Regulation (page 92), Emotions and Learning (page 50), Receptive Language Processing (page 65), Motor Control (page 75) and Organization (page 90) for strategies to assist students with Sensory Integration (or Processing) Disorder.
PAGE | 19
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
See Organization (page 90) and Learning Strategies (page 83) for strategies to assist Organizational Learning Disorder.
PAGE | 20
W ha t i s a Le a rni ng D i sa bi li t y ?
See Self Regulation (page 92) and Emotions and Learning (page 50) for strategies to assist Social Cue Disorder.
PAGE | 21
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Learning Strategies
Differentiated Instruction
Formative Assessment
Response to Intervention
The various aspects of differentiated instruction mentioned here should be seen as complementary to one another and not mutually exclusive or competing. The following chart outlines one way that aspects of differentiation can be used together to provide effective, well planned instruction and intervention for all students. Various aspects of differentiation can be used together to plan for diversity and provide robust interventions for students with learning disabilities.
PAGE | 22
Se tti ng th e St ag e
PAGE | 23
Se tti ng th e St ag e
The principles of universal design are clearly illustrated in the world of architecture and building. The automatic door at the local grocery store provides access for patrons with disabilities. There is a subtle presence of the feature it is not labelled for persons with disabilities and it provides a benefit to all patrons, those with temporary disabilities such as a sore arm, or those who appreciate making the management of a heavily-laden cart easier. The automatic door is a simple and common-sense solution.
PAGE | 24
Se tti ng th e St ag e
In an educational context, UDL emphasizes multiple means of presentation, to provide various ways of acquiring information and knowledge (e.g. buddy activities, use of concrete manipulatives, video, computer technology, audio texts) multiple means of expression to provide students with alternatives for representing learning beyond written work (e.g. video, teaching a peer, information booth, presentation, drawing, sculpture and drama) multiple means of engagement to tap into students interests, offer appropriate challenges and/or increase motivation respect for students learning styles and personal attributes, while still focusing on the required learning outcomes.
UDL is strongly linked to technology because digital formats can be so flexible. Once a text is in digital format, it is transformable i.e. easily translated from text to speech or expanded with insertions of pictures or video. It is transportable i.e. easily stored and used again or made available to other students. It is also recordable i.e. easily stored and played again at will and as necessary for the student. Software applications (advanced organizers and/or graphic organizers for planning, word-prediction software, and spell checkers) provide access to information and the means to respond, so students work reflects their learning. When students know how to use these software applications, they can be more self-reliant and independent in completing their work. UDL is not technology for the sake of technology, an add-on at the end of unit planning, or specific only to students with learning disabilities or other special needs.
PAGE | 25
Se tti ng th e St ag e
http://www.setbc.org/Download/LearningCentre/ Access/Networks_of_Learning_2010.pdf
PAGE | 26
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Adaptations
Adaptations are teaching and assessment strategies especially designed to accommodate a students needs so he or she can achieve the learning outcomes of the curriculum and demonstrate mastery of concepts. Accommodations in the form of adaptations occur when teachers differentiate instruction, assessment and materials in order to create a flexible, personalized learning experience for a student or group of students. Adaptations can be made available to all students, both with and without a learning disability. Adaptations might be thought of as adjustments to how students: take in information (input) participate in learning activities (engagement/process) demonstrate their learning (output)
Adaptations do not represent unfair advantages to students. In fact, if appropriate adaptations are not used, students could be unfairly penalized for having learning differences, creating serious negative impacts to their achievement and selfconcept.
Adaptations might include alternate formats, strategies or settings, and may involve changes to: the social and/or physical learning environment instruction methods learning materials, resources and topics response formats and assessment procedures time frames for learning
PAGE | 27
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Based on assessment results and student records, as well as parent and teacher knowledge of a student, what are a students learning needs processing weaknesses skill deficits social or emotional issues environmental needs?
PAGE | 28
Se tti ng th e St ag e
What are a students strengths in various areas such as processing skills strategies learning style and preference areas of interest attitude and dispositions?
To what degree does the learning environment accommodate the students needs without requiring individualized adaptations? What adaptations have the potential to address the needs of this students learning disabilities? Of the adaptations that would meet the students needs, which would best suit the learning environment?
In many circumstances a range of adaptations could accommodate the needs of a student with learning disabilities. In deciding which ones to adopt, teachers should opt for those that encourage independence.
PAGE | 29
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Potential Adaptations
Some typical types of adaptations might be audio tapes, electronic texts, or a peer helper to assist with assigned readings access to a computer for written assignments (e.g. use of word-prediction software, spell checker, idea generator) alternatives to written assignments for demonstrating knowledge and understanding advance organizers/graphic organizers to assist with following directions extended time to complete assignments or tests direct instruction and practice of study skills use of computer software which provides text-to-speech/speech-to-text capabilities pre-teaching key vocabulary or concepts; multiple exposure to materials working on the learning outcomes for a lower grade level.
This chart provides examples of adaptations that personalize teaching and learning. As adaptations are introduced, the students performance should be carefully monitored to ensure the adaptation is effective.
PAGE | 30
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Instructional Methods
Visual aids to supplement verbal presentations Verbal explanations of visual aids Break tasks into small steps Advanced organizers Peer tutors Cooperative learning Maintain consistent routines
Learning Materials/Resources
Manipulatives Text readers Graph paper for math calculations Erasable markers Calculators Duplicate notes Large Print Books on tape Raised-line paper Headsets Talking calculators Computer
PAGE | 31
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Adaptations can be envisioned as scaffolding. The scaffold provides a step up to the task, and the student does the work with the scaffolds support. By providing a scaffold, teachers foster students willingness to take risks, make sustained efforts and take personal responsibility for their learning. For example, a student might lack the task-approach strategies and memory of routines required to begin a task. The teacher can make organization and routines explicit by providing a graphic organizer, such as a reading guide or a visual schedule of steps to follow. The graphic organizer provides a scaffold to help the student complete the task with greater success. The same graphic organizer might be used during tests or across a variety of other subject areas. Adaptations that introduce an element of student dependency should be used only as short-term measures, while the student acquires the skills necessary to function independently. For example, the adaptation of providing peer or adult readers or scribes should be temporary, until the student learns to access readers and scribes using technology. In some circumstances, providing adaptations might require staged implementation. For example, a fine motor deficit and illegible handwriting might lead the teacher to conclude that the student should use a laptop to complete assignments. However, if the student does not yet have adequate keyboarding skills, the development of necessary keyboarding skills becomes a goal and other optional response formats are employed in the interim. Adaptations that minimize the impact of skill deficits sometimes reduce students opportunities to apply and practice skills. Students with learning disabilities student who is provided the adaptation of using a calculator when completing complex math problems is not likely to improve basic calculation skills, so the teacher still needs to provide remediation.
can experience an increasing gap in performance compared to their peers, who continue to progress. Remediation of those missing skills might be necessary. For example, a
Some adaptations might be required on a long-term basis while others might be necessary only until the student acquires effective strategies to compensate for his/her learning disabilities. For example, students with deficits in organizational skills might be provided with a model or step-by-step directions until they learn the necessary organizational strategies to enable them to perform without that tool. A record of successful adaptations for any student should be kept in a students file to both document current practice and support future instructional planning. For Ministry of Education guidelines and clarification about adaptations see, A Guide to Adaptations and Modifications at: www.bced.gov.bc.ca/specialed/docs/adaptations_and_modifications_guide.pdf For examples of non-technology based adaptations, see Non-Technology/LowTechnology Solutions to Support Networks of Learning at: www.setbc.org/Download/LearningCentre/Access/Networks_of_Learning_20 10.pdf
PAGE | 32
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Early Intervention
In general, early intervention employs highly systematic approaches that involve monitoring student response to instruction and documenting difficulties to inform prompt, appropriate intervention decisions. Early intervention often takes the form of literacy and numeracy instruction tailored to a students current functional level, paired with accommodations to prevent the literacy and numeracy difficulties from impeding progress in the other areas. Because intervening early is so critical, schools use various means to assess students to identify those who might need early intervention in Kindergarten and Grade 1. It is often from within this group of students identified through early assessment that learning disabilities are eventually identified. Robust early intervention can reduce the impact of processing difficulties for some students with learning disabilities, moderating the long-term impacts. A University of British Columbia research study has shown that strategic literacy instruction paired with supplemental small group instruction for the lowestperforming 20 percent of Kindergarten and Grade 1 students can reduce the percentage of students reading below grade level in Grade 4 to between two and three percent. This is compelling evidence to justify the investment of time and effort involved in early intervention. For more information about this research, see Firm Foundations: Early Literacy Teaching and Learning at www.nvsd44.bc.ca/FirmFoundations/main.html
Direct Instruction
Direct instruction is an approach to teaching where the particular skill or content to be learned is presented explicitly. For some students with a learning disability, exploration or discovery methods of teaching might be ineffective for acquiring core content and developing foundational academic skills. This could be due to a students inability to make connections from existing knowledge to new learning, learn new vocabulary, develop fluency with a particular skill, create mental frameworks for organizing and remembering content, and/or develop strategies for learning. Direct instruction does not assume students will implicitly, intuitively or indirectly acquire a particular skill or set of facts. Research has shown that direct instruction can be an effective strategy for teaching mathematical procedures and computations, reading (decoding), explicit reading comprehension strategies, science facts, concepts and rules, foreign language vocabulary and grammar.
PAGE | 33
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Direct instruction involves explaining a concept, skill or strategy, modeling how to perform a task or approach a problem, providing feedback, guiding practice, reinforcing success, shaping understanding, providing a scaffold to the next steps, fostering mastery through practice and positive reinforcement and promoting generalization of skills. Direct instruction can be employed as seven steps in a teaching and learning sequence. Together, the steps make the skills to be learned explicit and provide feedback during the acquisition phase. It is an effective approach in promoting student success and confidence.
PAGE | 34
Se tti ng th e St ag e
PAGE | 35
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Learning Strategies
Learning strategies are techniques that maximize student strengths and provide structures that enable students to learn more effectively. Some examples of learning strategies include use of graphic or advance organizers, assistive software, mental rehearsal and visualization techniques. Many students with learning disabilities demonstrate a tendency to compartmentalize their learning; therefore, they often require guidance in integrating strategies broadly across a variety of situations. This graphic suggests some key facets of learning that can improve by applying effective learning strategies.
problem solving
goal setting
prioritizing
monitoring
concentrating
analyzing
evaluating
memorizing
test-taking
note-taking
scheduling
time management
PAGE | 36
Se tti ng th e St ag e
PAGE | 37
Se tti ng th e St ag e
provide assistive technologies (reading, writing and communication tools) where required to ensure students with print disability access to educational programs, and assist school districts in providing the necessary training for students and educators in the use of these technologies. The SET-BC website includes an extensive list of teacher training resources. www.SETBC.org
PAGE | 38
Se tti ng th e St ag e
Formative Assessment
Formative assessment is a model that uses feedback from the continuous monitoring of student progress to identify learning strengths and weaknesses and to guide instruction, enabling teachers to recognize the needs of their students and plan accordingly. The assessment/teaching cycle is continuous and involves assessing what a student can do and needs to learn considering student needs, learning styles and interests when planning appropriate instructional techniques and resources providing instructional support monitoring progress and using small group or personalized instruction as required reflecting and identifying areas where adjustment in strategy is necessary continuously monitoring ones instructional techniques and student response.
Assessment of what a student can do and needs to learn Teacher selfreflection and adjustments to program delivery, if necessary
An application of this process used in a reading program is a continuous cycle of running records (assessing and monitoring progress) paired with guided-reading lessons (direct teaching of academic skills, task-approach strategies, modeling and constructive feedback).
PAGE | 39
Se tti ng th e St ag e
RTI research and practice set a high standard for documenting the extent of students learning difficulties, and focuses attention on data about each students progress and use of research and evidence-based practices. Central elements of all RTI models include early screening of all students to identify those at risk for academic difficulties, implementing research-based interventions matched to student need and increasing intensity of intervention when needed. RTI also involves continuous monitoring and recording of student progress during interventions to guide decisions for both the student (e.g. further assessment, individualized planning) and the teacher (e.g. using small group or one-to-one learning contexts, topics for professional development). Although RTI originates from special education, it is intended for use with all students in general education. The three tiers of RTI could be described as a triangle divided horizontally into three unequal sections.
Tier 3: Intensive: (1-5% of students) Intensive, individualized interventions for students who have insufficient response to evidence-based interventions in the first two tiers
Tier 2: Targeted: (10-15%of students) Targeted specific prevention or remediation interventions for students whose academic performance or behaviour lag behind the norm for proficiency and in their grade
Tier 1: Universal: (80-90% of students) High quality instructional and behavioural supports for all students to reach proficiency in general education
PAGE | 40
Se tti ng th e St ag e
In the Response to Intervention model, students who do not demonstrate success in Tier 1 are provided additional differentiated instruction at the Tier 2 level. This instruction is delivered with greater frequency, duration and intensity in the areas of difficulty and is usually given within the class setting. Students who continue to demonstrate lack of success in Tier 2 then receive intensive interventions at the Tier 3 level, usually within individualized or small-group situations. Thorough recording of students response to intervention helps identify learning strengths and challenges. It also provides a clear representation of the persistence of learning difficulty even though teachers use various teaching strategies, accommodations and interventions. This persistent difficulty may be an indication that further formal assessment is needed.
PAGE | 41
Pl an ni ng
SECTION 3 | PLANNING
Teachers can plan for students with learning disabilities by asking themselves key questions about how to best to support them based on their personal learning profiles.
negative impact of this students processing difficulties in instructional and assessment contexts?
academic skills to ensure access to the curriculum? How can I continue to help this student continue to develop basic academic skills?
assessment to help this student achieve intended learning outcomes in a way that does not require excessive effort on the part of the student or excessive supports from the adults?
Adapted from Teachers Make the Difference: Teaching Students with Learning Disabilities at Middle School and Secondary School Levels. Ministry of Education, Saskatchewan. (2009)
PAGE | 42
Pl an ni ng
The following list of questions may be helpful in considering the needs of a student to help with planning teaching strategies and other interventions: 1) What are the key concerns about the students learning? (It helps to record concrete examples of situations and gather work samples to focus this consideration.) a) Which curricular areas are affected? b) What do we know about impacts in previous years? c) Are these same concerns also evident in other settings besides the current classroom? 2) What insights can the parents provide that is helpful in understanding the students interests, strengths, and difficulties? 3) Based on discussions with the student and parents, what are the students learning strengths and interests? 4) What adaptations/strategies have worked well in the past? Have been tried but not worked in the past? 5) What can be learned from school and classroom assessments that have already been done? 6) Are there any special factors in the students background which should be considered? a) Does the student have an ESL or immigrant background? b) Is the student in a language immersion program? c) Has the student been previously homeschooled? 7) Have patterns of attendance that have impacted the students opportunity to acquire skills? 8) Are there any health factors that might contribute to learning problems? a) Have the students vision and hearing been checked? b) Does the student seem alert and well-rested? c) Does the student appear to be hungry or malnourished?
PAGE | 43
Pl an ni ng
Teachers should consult with parents when children experience educational difficulties. Parents know a great deal about their children and play a vital role in their education. Parents will be able to provide pertinent information about the students unique strengths and learning needs. In addition to considering the information associated with such questions and from parent input, teachers might also want to consult with colleagues and other professionals to find out more about the learner and some new ideas about how to best support him or her. Consultation might begin with a support /learning assistance teacher or with the school-based team, depending on the local school or district processes. Consultation with colleagues and school-based team members can provide teachers with valuable insight into strategies and supports that might be more effective and alert the teacher to other considerations that might impact learning. If the students parents were not directly involved in the consultation, it is a good idea to talk with them about new strategies being tried and perhaps how they might be applied to homework. As part of planning, teachers try a range of strategies and monitor student responses to these interventions to see how useful they are. Frequently, strategies and interventions generated through a consultation process are very helpful in supporting student success. When a students difficulties persist despite intervention efforts, a more comprehensive assessment involving district-level and/or community-based personnel might be warranted.
The Learning Disabilities Instructional Support Planning Process (LDISPP) assists support teams in identifying needs and appropriate levels of supports for students suspected of learning disability. See the Learning Disabilities Instructional Support Planning Process in Appendix 2 or go online to: www.bced.gov.bc.ca/specialed/docs/ld_instructional_support_tool.pdf
PAGE | 44
Pl an ni ng
PAGE | 45
Pl an ni ng
personalized approach that addresses the students assessed needs, strengths, talents and interests. If results from a psycho-educational assessment indicate the existence of a learning disability, the board of education is responsible for identifying that student as a student with special needs. If the student is reported to the Ministry as having a learning disability then the district is responsible for developing an Individual Education Plan (IEP) and for delivering educational programs and related services in accordance with that plan.
What is an IEP?
An IEP is a documented plan developed for a student with special needs that describes individualized goals, adaptations, modifications, services to be provided, and measures for tracking achievement. It must include the goals or outcomes set for that student for the school year, if they are different from the learning outcomes set out in an applicable educational program or guide. An IEP usually list supports required to achieve goals established for the student and significant adaptations to educational materials, instructional strategies or assessment methods. It documents the special education services being provided as they relate to the students identified needs and how those services will be delivered.
PAGE | 46
Pl an ni ng
An IEP assists with: Planning formalizing the decision making process providing a collaborative tool for all people involved, including parents and students, to provide input into the plan linking formal and informal assessment results with programming strategies providing guidance about transitions
Tracking serving as a tool for monitoring individual student learning providing an ongoing record to assist with continuity in programming, and
Recording providing a record for the students file and all involved about the students special education program, and serving as the basis for reporting the students progress on goals and objectives.
IEPs do not describe every aspect of students education programs, but they should describe those aspects that require individualization. IEPs reflect the complexity of students learning profiles; they might be brief or more detailed. For example, the IEP for a student who needs adaptations only for taking tests might be relatively simple. In contrast, a student with a complex array of accommodations and interventions requires a more extensive IEP. Because students with learning disabilities by definition have average or better ability, IEP goals should be set at a high but attainable level. Individualized learning outcomes (goals and objectives) typically focus on the acquisition of basic skills (e.g. literacy or numeracy skills) and the development of compensatory and learning strategies. Socio-emotional goals focusing on such things as self-esteem and friendship skills might also be included. IEPs might also identify strategies for minimizing the impact of learning disabilities and skill deficits. IEP planning should carefully consider significant transitions that students will experience during their school career from home to Kindergarten, grade to grade, elementary to secondary, program to program, one school to another and from graduation to adulthood.
PAGE | 47
Pl an ni ng
www.bced.gov.bc.ca/specialed/docs/iepssn.pdf
http://www.bced.gov.bc.ca/specialed/ppandg.htm
PAGE | 48
St r at eg ie s
SECTION 4 | STRATEGIES
Selecting the most appropriate accommodations, interventions, or remedial approaches to assist a struggling learner requires consideration of the students learning profile, educational history and the resources available. Based on all the available information, teachers try out strategies and carefully monitor their effectiveness. Students with learning disabilities respond differently, as no two are affected in exactly the same way.
The lists of strategies and resources in this section are intended to serve as a starting point for selecting ways to support the learning of students with learning disabilities. No one strategy can be assumed to address the needs of all students with learning disabilities. Resources and strategies chosen for this section have been suggested from the literature on learning disabilities or by teachers in BC who are commonly using them for both as universal, small-group and as targeted interventions. School-based learning assistance/support teachers as well as district administrators, speech and language pathologists or reading and mathematics specialists may recommend additional effective assessment tools, strategies, resources and assessment tools for addressing the needs of students with learning disabilities. It may be possible to determine which instructional approaches did not work for a student in the past by reviewing school records or talking with previous teachers. However, previous instructional strategies and interventions might have occurred at a time when the child was not developmentally ready to benefit from the approach being used. If developmental factors contributed to learning difficulty in the past, it could mean that the same or similar approach might be successful now. Therefore, it is not always a good idea to discount strategies that have not worked in the past.
The lists of strategies and resources in this document are not meant to be comprehensive, but rather serve as a starting point for ideas about how to support students with learning disabilities.
Direct instruction for specific skill development is important for most students with learning disabilities, but they should not be restricted to working on skills in isolation. A balanced approach provides a focus on reading, writing, thinking, speaking and listening within a rich context. Teaching skills, practicing strategies in context, and building in opportunities to transfer, apply and practice is particularly important for many students with learning disabilities who do not generalize knowledge without specific instruction. Initial interventions could take the form of an adaptation that is made available for all students and be very informal. Meanwhile, a teacher might use error analysis, conduct a learning interview, and/or ask the student about the difficulties being experienced. Based
PAGE | 49
St r at eg ie s
on this, more individualized instruction, practice and monitoring should occur. Teachers will often find that no one intervention strategy will address the needs of all learners. To personalize learning for students with various learning profiles, various types of differentiation and variety of approaches and resources may be needed. In general, teachers should address challenges arising from the students learning disability by employing the students strengths whenever possible: remediating basic skills through direct instruction, multi-sensory instruction, and specific training designed to help the learner generalize the skill to multiple applications bypassing the processing deficit by providing adapted teaching and learning strategies, supplementary learning materials, alternate instructional and/or evaluation strategies, and use of technology teaching compensatory strategies to minimize the degree to which future learning is impeded addressing the affective domain
PAGE | 50
St r at eg ie s
Strategies
Provide classroom structures that accommodate a variety of learning strengths and needs: modeling and providing practice in asking for clarification and asking for help, to enable students to get beyond being stuck beginning with strengths when evaluating, and debriefing with students after assessments recognizing progress explicitly, by graphing or charting progress, setting goals, or planning and tracking achievement celebrating success providing positive role models and experiences with trusting, and respectful, adults modeling problem solving and discussing productive and unproductive strategies encouraging self-evaluation as part of the process providing consistent routines, clear rules and understandable, logical consequences.
Help students with learning disabilities develop insight about their strengths and challenges: modeling the practice of viewing mistakes as a normal part of learning that provide opportunities to self-correct and improve (Comparing struggles and mistakes practicing a sport is a helpful strategy.) digging deeper when negative statements are made (Find out what Im bored really means. It could mean the task is too difficult or that a different strategy is necessary.) orchestrating opportunities for students to explain their learning strengths and needs to others structuring opportunities for the student to relate subsequent learning tasks to what they know about their strengths and needs, building the awareness of any need for accommodation promoting self-advocacy and facilitating opportunities for the student to practice discourage comparisons to others and reinforce that everyone has personal strengths and weaknesses.
PAGE | 51
St r at eg ie s
Personalize students education programs: implementing universal design for learning in the learning environment, providing choice for all learners by reducing the stigma of the special learner focusing on passions, strengths and talents as a way to highlight different types of talent and intelligence providing individual choices, skill-appropriate responsibilities, and support for individual effort.
PAGE | 52
St r at eg ie s
Caring for Kids. Canadian Paediatric Society Collaborative Mental Health Care in Canada Family Resource Library at BC Childrens Hospital FRIENDS, FunFriends and Friends for Youth
Levine, M. Developing Minds Series LDOnline Ministry of Children Family Development See Also Appendix 3: Quick References
PAGE | 53
St r at eg ie s
Learning to Read
Many students with learning disabilities experience considerable difficulty with reading. Proficient reading is a highly complex task that requires extensive knowledge and a broad range of skills: rapid, sequential processing of visual symbols to recognize letters and word forms forming virtually instantaneous associations between visual word forms and oral word forms understanding vocabulary drawing upon linguistic knowledge to attain meaning from the word order mastery of writing conventions to know the significance of punctuation gathering and holding sufficient basic material in working memory to access the ideas being expressed collecting and holding the ideas to facilitate comprehension.
Teachers should focus on enabling the students to acquire skills, such as encoding and decoding, increasing fluency and improving comprehension. To meet with success in school and in the world, students need assistance in learning to read and in acquiring skills to actively engage in reading to learn.
Decoding
Decoding is the process of using ones knowledge of letters, sounds and word patterns to determine an unknown word. Effective decoding depends on knowledge of letter/sound relationships, the meanings of roots, prefixes and suffixes, and word patterns.
PAGE | 54
St r at eg ie s
Strategies
Use phonemic games. Teach students to move a token for each sound segment in a word. Reverse-a-Word (Say cat, then say it with the first sound last and the last sound first e.g. tac). Remove-a-part (Say cat, then say it without the beginning sound e.g. at).
Teach the tapping technique, where students identify speech sounds before they spell words by touching the thumb to successive fingers as they segment and pronounce the speech sounds. Use mnemonic devices to help students remember tricky spellings of word families. Emphasize prefixes, roots and suffixes, beginning with inflections that change the spelling of a base word (fine, finest; begin, beginning; study, studied). Link meaning and spelling. The words designate, signal and assignment, for example, share a root. Students then identify spelling patterns and learn to use them as a tool to read and write new words.
PAGE | 55
St r at eg ie s
www.learningthroughlistening.org
Lexia Learning Systems What Works Clearinghouse: Institute of Education Sciences, US Department of Education
Schacter, J., Reading programs that work: A review of programs for pre-kindergarten to 4th Grade. Milken Family Foundation. Santa Monica, CA. Retrieved December 2010 from: www.mff.org/pubs/ME279.pdf See Also Appendix 3: Quick References Decoding (page 147)
PAGE | 56
St r at eg ie s
Fluency
Reading fluency includes the ability to read with expression, while accessing meaning, at an appropriate speed or rate of reading. It involves reading text smoothly, effortlessly and automatically with little conscious attention to the mechanics of reading, at a pace appropriate to the reading purpose. Fluency requires automatic accurate decoding with appropriate phrasing and expression to convey meaning. Students who have limited fluency read less text than their peers and are less likely to remember, review and comprehend the text or to integrate information with their own prior knowledge. A lack of fluency could be the result of slow processing speed and/or inadequate sight vocabulary.
Strategies
Provide practice in reading lists of high-frequency words. Many lists are available in printed resources and online. Ask the student to read continuously from the list for one minute and record the number of correctly read words. Repeat the activity every day. An acceptable rate, established by Fischer (1999), is: Grades 1 and 2 30 words per minute Grades 3 40 words per minute Grade 4 and up 60 words per minute
Extend this practice to include recognition of words with irregular spelling patterns, such as physical and know, or said and one. A simple way to do this is to create a matrix of five rows. Each row contains lists of the same words in different order. Students review the words and are then timed for 1 minute as they read the words in each list. After each session, record the number of words read correctly. Help identify one-letter, two-letter and other small words that cannot be visualized mentally. Assist the student with understanding the definitions and functions in a sentence or phrase, until the student knows the word and is comfortable with the way the word is used. Read aloud together or choral reading. The teacher or peer reads aloud with the student for 10 to 15 minutes daily. The helper takes a position beside and slightly behind the student and points to each word, reading at a slightly faster pace than the student. This can help the student practice phrasing and intonation. Choral reading can be done with a large copy of text and the whole class or with a peer or older student mentor/buddy.
PAGE | 57
St r at eg ie s
Provide an opportunity for repeated readings. Choose a text of between 50 and 100 words in length. The text should be slightly above the students present independent reading level. The student reads the selection orally while the teacher times the reading and tallies the number of correct or incorrect words. Together, the teacher and student set a realistic goal for improvement. Students can look over the passage and practice reading difficult words at any time. The re-reading occurs daily for a week. Then a new passage is selected. Teachers can choose readings from a collection of levelled reading texts. This strategy is useful to focus on reading skills and to introduce text relevant to subjects such as science, math and social studies.
Provide an opportunity for students to listen to recordings of books while reading along. Use text reading programs, such as Kurzweil or WordQ. Students can read along with the text on the computer monitor while hearing the text read aloud by a computer generated voice.
PAGE | 58
St r at eg ie s
Resources - Fluency
Web Precision Reading Essential Skills Reading Software Wilson Reading Program Fast ForWord (Scientific Learning Corp.) WiggleWorks Kurzweil 3000 Great Leaps Reading Program The Read Naturally Program Reading Rockets See Also Appendix 3: Quick References
www.ijdcr.ca/VOL01_01_CAN/articles/updike.shtml www.essentialskills.net www.wilsonlanguage.com www.scilearn.com http://teacher.scholastic.com/products/wiggleworks/i ndex.htm www.kurzweiledu.com www.greatleaps.com/index.php http://www.readnaturally.com/approach/steps.htm www.readingrockets.org
PAGE | 59
St r at eg ie s
Phonological Processing
Phonological processing consists of the analysis and synthesis of phonemes (the smallest unit of recognized sounds). A student with a phonological processing disorder might demonstrate errors in speech production (omitting a sound in a word, mispronunciation of words, difficulty rhyming words), misperception of spoken words (confusing words that sound similar), or challenges with reading and writing (sounding out, learning conventional spelling, omitting vowel sounds when spelling).
Strategies
Provide direct instruction involving: rhyming words breaking compound words into individual words and words into syllables identifying beginning, middle and end sounds on words: teach the tapping technique, where students identify speech sounds before they spell words by touching the thumb to successive fingers as they segment and pronounce the speech sounds teach students to move a token for each sound segment in a word reverse-a-word (Say cat, then say it with the first sound last and the last sound first e.g. tac) remove-a-part (Say cat, then say it without the beginning sound e.g. at) add a beginning sound to make phoneme blends. (Say cat, then say it again, adding the s sound at the beginning e.g. scat)
phonemic games: -
charts and visuals of phonics skills throughout the class word-walls to illustrate a phonetic component.
PAGE | 60
St r at eg ie s
PAGE | 61
St r at eg ie s
Comprehension
Comprehension is the process of constructing meaning from text. It involves a range of executive functions and requires knowledge of word meanings, formation of conceptual relationships, understanding factual and/or literal content, and making inferences. A variety of factors can interfere with reading comprehension, including: insufficient processing speed, resulting in reading that is so slow the reader is unable to recall the initial portions of the reading inadequate: sight vocabulary, resulting in the need to decode each word thus slowing reading and interfering with constructing meaning receptive vocabulary, resulting in failure to recognize words even when accurately decoded oral language skills, and/or connections to prior knowledge
failure to recognize printed words learned in isolation or in other contexts, resulting from poor visual perception skills or a lack of generalization poor fluency, resulting in word-by-word reading rather than the recognition of phrases essential to accessing meaning poor working memory resulting in the inability to construct meaning
Strategies
Develop vocabulary by: pre-teaching vocabulary using analogies, synonyms or visual aids having students create sentences and then look up the key words in the dictionary to confirm they have used correctly teaching meanings of prefixes, suffixes and roots of words, or providing illustrations to help students define and learn a word having students explain word meanings to one another in a walk-and-talk format (students walk side-by-side and discuss what they are learning, connecting ideas to previously learned ideas and information.)
PAGE | 62
St r at eg ie s
Help students understand text by: teaching students how to generate questions about a text. Students can generate questions before they read, such as in a K-W-L (KnowWonder Learn) chart helping students relate a passage to an experience, another book, or other facts teaching Think-Pair-Share strategy (after students spend a minute thinking about a particular topic, they pair with another student to discuss their ideas, and then share their ideas with the larger group) teaching and modeling how to visualize and construct images to represent ideas in the text helping students make connections to personal experience, knowledge and previous reading
Help students see the connections within the text and understand how different parts of the story or text relate to one another by: explicitly teaching and modeling how to summarize important parts of a passage providing a cut up version of the text for them to organize as a re-telling of the main points teaching and modeling how to predict upcoming content by relating prior knowledge to what has already been read in the text or by using illustrations to identify themes and content
Help students learn to stop and analyze their understanding by: teaching them to summarize periodically as they read modeling how to notice when they are lost, how to re-read for clarification, speak to another reader about the text, read more slowly or more quickly as appropriate
PAGE | 63
St r at eg ie s
Resources - Comprehension
Print Jurenka, A. Teaching phonemic awareness through childrens literature and experiences. Libraries Unlimited.Westport, CT: (2005). Web Soar to Success http://languagearts.nelson.com/reading/soa rsuccess.html www.stenhouse.com
Reading Power by Adrianne Gear (also available in French under the title Lecteurs Engages, Cerveaux Branches) Revaluing Reading Instruction Thinking Reader
www.jstor.org/pss/20201677 www.tomsnyder.com/products/product.asp ?sku=THITHI# http://olc.spsd.sk.ca/de/resources/litgarde n/index.html www.accomplishonline.com www.lindamoodbell.com www.readinglady.com (see Comprehension)
ACCOMPLISH Reading Program Lindamood-Bell for Reading and Comprehension Readinglady.com See Also Appendix 3: Quick References
PAGE | 64
St r at eg ie s
Strategies
Use graphic organizers to assist in organizing information, making connections between concepts and providing different ways of looking at information. Provide opportunities to make predictions about outcomes Chunk information and teach about headings and text structures Have the students retell or restate instructions to a peer Provide information visually, orally, and graphically where possible
PAGE | 65
St r at eg ie s
www.ets.org/Media/About_ETS/pdf/lsrg.pdf
PAGE | 66
St r at eg ie s
Reading to Learn
As students move through grade levels, the task of learning to read changes to reading for pleasure and information or reading to learn. The challenge for many students with learning disabilities is that the process of reading might not become automated.
Transferring Skills
Students with learning disabilities might demonstrate significant growth in their reading skills as a result of direct instruction provided in an individualized setting but fail to transfer the skills they have acquired to other learning situations. They might require specific instruction in ways to adapt their reading skills to fit a variety of applications. For all students, but particularly for students with learning disabilities, teachers should teach specific reading strategies in the context of content learning, and across a variety of content areas, so students learn to apply strategies in more than one circumstance. For example use the same graphic organizers for making sense of a social studies text as well as for developing an outline for a report.
Strategies
Pre-teach vocabulary relevant to the content areas Deliberately use new words as often as possible in conversation and in context of relevant subject matter Model use of context to derive meanings, finding root morphemes, mapping word derivations, understanding word origins, and paraphrasing idiomatic or special uses for words Teach explicitly about structure of text such as headings and subheadings, paragraphing, starting sentences and supporting ideas Use questioning techniques as a framework for reading for information
PAGE | 67
St r at eg ie s
Use graphic organizers before during and after reading to organize ideas Use concept definition mapping-describe a concept and provide examples and non-examples of it to develop understanding Have students read and summarize longer materials in chunks, then put the summaries together to create a whole
PAGE | 68
St r at eg ie s
Supports for student with writing difficulties should incorporate both compensatory strategies and intervention strategies, so students can manage requirements for written work while still developing their writing skills. This section discusses various aspects of writing such as spelling, motor control, planning, drafting, editing, publishing, and note taking.
Remember that because written work is meant to be seen, a student with a learning disability might feel particularly vulnerable working on such tasks.
PAGE | 69
St r at eg ie s
Inspiration Kidspiration
PAGE | 70
St r at eg ie s
Strategies
Provide a framework for language and idea development by: thinking aloud as you problem solve or work through a process using visual with oral instructions using learning strategies such as: KWL Think-Pair- Share
Expand on students verbal responses by: responding to them using correct grammar elaborating on students ideas encouraging students to practice using words in sentences, listen for new words throughout their day encouraging discussions using higher level questions
PAGE | 71
St r at eg ie s
www.ets.org/Media/About_ETS/pdf/lsrg.pdf
PAGE | 72
St r at eg ie s
Spelling (Encoding)
Spelling involves using ones knowledge of letters, sounds and word patterns in a verbal word to map (encode) those sounds onto a letter sequence in order to spell out a written word. Spelling difficulties are common even for students without a learning disability; however, when they occur in combination with language or mathematics based difficulties, a learning disability might be the cause. Poor spellers have trouble noticing, remembering and recalling the features of language that letters represent. This includes the ability to analyze and remember the individual sounds in the words (phonemes), such as the sounds associated with f, sh, or p; syllables, such as cas, mem, neg; and meaningful parts of longer words (morphemes), such as re-, -ment or -est.
Strategies
Teach reading and spelling together, giving a context for language and meaningful practice. Discuss word structures, origins and meaning of words and morphemes. Encourage hands-on practice with spelling words by - providing a tray of salt or modeling clay to make words - printing a spelling word on a strip of paper, cutting the letters out and having students rearrange the letters to re-create the word - spelling with magnetic letters Use box-words that mirror the shape of letters in words. e.g. m-o-t-h-e-r would look like this:
Students then match the word to the blank boxes and use the blank boxes to guide encoding or to guide sorting a list of words into word families. Make correctly spelled words easily accessible by - keeping a list of most-commonly misspelled words or having students create a personal dictionary for reference - having students regularly re-practising and using challenging words - brainstorming with students before they write, in order to generate and provide correct spelling of pertinent words - making word prediction software available. Provide adaptations to ensure students feel successful by - reducing the number of spelling words a student needs to master, focusing on quality not quantity - ensuring that spelling tasks are at a level where students experience success, gradually increasing the degree of difficulty as the student progresses
PAGE | 73
St r at eg ie s
PAGE | 74
St r at eg ie s
Motor Control
Fine motor control describes the ability to physically perform tasks that require small amounts of movement, such as the ability to print, write, use scissors or use manipulatives. Gross motor control describes the ability to perform tasks that require movement of large muscles in the body: for example, moving around desks in a room or lining up without bumping into things. The schools occupational therapist might offer advice to teacher about helping students develop fine and gross motor skills.
Strategies
Provide a pencil grip to enhance pencil control. Place paper on a clipboard to hold it steady. Slant the clipboard at a 15-30 degree angle. Supply paper with bold or raised lines, to make it easier to stay on the line. Provide instruction and opportunities to become proficient at keyboarding. Provide voice-to-text technology.
PAGE | 75
St r at eg ie s
Planning
Planning before actually writing plays an important role the writing process. Planning goes beyond the writing process to both the acquisition of knowledge and in effectively demonstrating learning. A student who experiences difficulties with planning may, among other things, struggle to begin tasks, generate ideas, complete and hand in assignments, or participate in group projects.
Strategies
Guide students to sit back and think: What do I already know? What do I need to find out? How should I begin? Provide experience with a variety of graphic organizers such as webs, flowcharts or semantic maps, as a means to group ideas and see how to form paragraphs or decide on logical flow. Guide students to consider the purpose of their writing and the audience, so they can address the reader appropriately. Explore ideas such as writing to express personal feelings, to imagine (What if...?), to narrate, to describe, to inform, etc. Create several first lines and suggest key words to get drafts under way, often referred to as stems or starters.
PAGE | 76
St r at eg ie s
Resources - Planning
Print Unlocking Potential: Key Components of Programming for Students with Learning Disabilities. The Crown in Right of Alberta. Edmonton, Alta. (2002). Web Inspiration Kidspiration www.inspiration.com www.inspiration.com/productinfo/kidspiration /index.cfm www.ets.org/Media/About_ETS/pdf/lsrg.pdf
Learning Strategies Resource Guide. Region XIV Comprehensive Center. Educational Testing Service. Tucker, Georgia. Adolescent Literacy: Resources for Parents and Educators of Kids in Grades 4-12
www.adlit.org/strategy_library
PAGE | 77
St r at eg ie s
Drafting
Some students with learning disabilities have significant trouble showing what they know on paper. Difficulties with writing tasks can arise from challenges with generating ideas, planning how to include the ideas in the writing sample, accessing vocabulary appropriate to the topic, and following a process to complete the writing task.
Strategies
Model the drafting process: Think aloud so students can hear the dialogue that writers engage in as they create written work. Teachers can demonstrate in a step-by-step fashion how to plan, create a draft, evaluate what was written and then revise and edit. Model how to ask questions that help students progress through a writing task: How can I introduce my topic? How can I develop this next part? How can I conclude my topic? Include questions that help the student pause and reflect. Am I on topic? Do I need to say more? Is my meaning clear? Provide daily opportunities to write on a variety of topics and using a variety of genres. Support students independence by using scaffolds, such as a visual representation of the steps involved in writing or feedback for each step of the drafting process. Provide compensatory strategies for choosing vocabulary: Students can create custom dictionaries through technology, make a personal note book or jointly create a class word-wall. When there is a good match between the writing task and predicted words, students can easily find the words they are choosing to write. These words then form part of the active bank and are available when the student begins writing. If the class is studying rocks, for example, the words in the word wall could include vocabulary such as metamorphic and lava. Involve students in digital storytelling as an alternative to writing: The narration and pictures can be saved as a digital file for sharing with others. In this way students are unencumbered by the struggles involved in fine motor skills, spelling and punctuation.
PAGE | 78
St r at eg ie s
Resources - Drafting
Print Tomkins, G. Teaching writing: Balancing process and product (3rd ed.). Merrill/Prentice Hall. (Upper Saddle River, NJ. 2000). Web Kurzweil 3000 WordQ CoWriter Dragon Naturally Speaking See Also Appendix 3: Quick References Drafting (page 148) www.kurzweiledu.com www.wordq.com www.donjohnston.com/resources/cowriter6_index.html www.nuance.com/dragon/index.htm
PAGE | 79
St r at eg ie s
Editing
The editing process requires simultaneous attention to many aspects of writing. Systematically breaking down tasks into chunks helps make them clearer and less daunting to struggling writers. Editing addresses both content (ideas and organization) and structure/surface features (spelling, punctuation, letter formation).
Strategies
Conduct a group edit: - Use a teachers own weak first draft as an example and talk through the editing process - Use an anonymous sample of writing from another class to engage students thinking about how to improve a piece of writing - Read compositions aloud (or have a peer or the computer software read aloud) and have students work together asking: Does this make sense? Is there information I should take out or add more? Use criteria lists as guides for editing - provides prompt for self-evaluation; for example, ensure each sentence has a beginning (who, what) and an ending (whats happening), ensure correct use of punctuation, replace words like good or cool with other choices, or drop them altogether, etc. - formative assessment structures to provide feedback - prioritizing aspects of writing on which that student needs to focus. Create a list or blog of Notable Sentences and publish it for the group to act as sentence. Make use of technology or other writing tools: - Teach students how to use electronic spell checkers to identify misspelled words - Use the auto-correct or proofing features available in software applications - Make common use of thesauruses, which help writers expand their choice of words and rework their writing for clarity. - Use devices such as C.O.P.S C Is each sentence clear? O Is it put into a logical order? P Did I use punctuation correctly? S Check the spelling
Consider using a formative Assessment tool to give students feedback about their writing. Students can use a criteria sheet to check their work; for example the BC Performance Standards writing rubrics, teacher-made rating scales and checklists.
PAGE | 80
St r at eg ie s
Resources - Editing
Web Kurzweil 3000 WordQ CoWriter BC Performance Standards for Writing See Also Appendix 3: Quick References Editing (page 149) www.kurzweiledu.com www.wordq.com www.donjohnston.com/resources/cowriter6_index.html www.bced.gov.bc.ca/perf_stands/writing.htm
PAGE | 81
St r at eg ie s
Sharing/Publishing
Sharing work may pose particular challenges for those who have difficulty with writing. Teachers should be creative about sharing students work, so those with writing challenges are not singled out and embarrassed. Students with learning disabilities can be helped to polish a writing piece so that it can be shared with pride.
Strategies
Rather than displaying students original work, turn work into a class newsletter or book or create a digital file for print-out for polished samples. Include options for artistic or digital presentations. Help students with learning disabilities to edit and refine a final product of which they can be proud.
Resources Sharing/Publishing
Software Microsoft PowerPoint Microsoft Publisher See Also Appendix 3: Quick References Sharing/Publishing (page 163)
PAGE | 82
St r at eg ie s
Learning Strategies
Students with learning disabilities sometimes do not intuitively pick up on learning strategies. Introducing a variety of strategies, using them across a number of learning environments and discussing with the student which ones work best and where is a valuable exercise which provides insight into learning styles, different ways to organize thinking, and ways to make effective plans.
Study Skills
Provide study guides or help students to create their own. Encourage study groups, in order to support auditory learners and provide context for learning information. Have students generate possible test questions from which to study. Have students put one fact only on post-it notes, and then organize them into clusters/clumps on their desks. Discuss why each clump has been assembled and how the facts relate to one another. Have students use a highlighter and work as group to identify key words or ideas. Discuss how the highlighted text relates to the overall topic and subtopics of the piece.
Test Taking
Help students learn how to identify which questions to answer first. Teach students to skim through the test and answer the easiest questions first, before proceeding to the more challenging questions. Show them how to use a watch to judge how much time to spend on a question depending on the mark value. Teach the process of elimination for multiple choice or true and false questions. Teach the use of a mini map or outline for essay questions. Encourage students to highlight key or signal words in test questions. Teach the strategy of explicitly identifying the steps in multi-step questions.
PAGE | 83
St r at eg ie s
Memory
Teach visualization, cognitive mapping and mnemonic strategies. Provide advance notice for tests, to allow for longer study time. Teach students to divide information into categories. Exaggerate and use humour in presentations and studying tasks. Use visual, auditory and kineasthetic modes of presenting and exploring material. Provide frequent, regular opportunities to practice.
Note-taking
Taking notes involves a combination of quickly processing language, recalling spelling and engaging fine motor skills. Students with learning disabilities can have immense difficulty with this kind of writing. Teachers should directly teach learning strategies that enable students to develop skills in taking useful notes and at the same time consider arranging for students to have access to peer helper notes.
Strategies
Before lesson presentations Provide students with a table format where the left-hand column includes the teachers key points and the right-hand column has space for students to add phrases, additional words, pictures or graphics. Prepare a standard outline for the whole group that includes a spot to record the key topic, main points and a summary. Provide text materials, vocabulary and abbreviations for vocabulary ahead of time. Provide a peer helper with carbon paper for duplicating notes. During presentations Slow the presentation and cue students to important points with wait time or verbal cues. Use a SMARTBoard or an interactive whiteboard. Notes written on the board can be saved and downloaded to student files. Students can then open the file and rewind/fast forward to specific points in the lesson for review. Provide word prediction software so students can save files or print them out.
PAGE | 84
St r at eg ie s
After presentations allow additional time for students to review their work, ask questions or discuss in small groups provide photo or digital copies of notes or notes created by peers using carbonless copy paper
Notetaking practice: Prepare a short talk and write out notes for it. Blank out key words and have students fill these in as they listen. Teachers can increase the amount of text to fill in, or move to a partially completed outline that students work to complete. Help students gain experience by providing three-minute talks or lectures and ask students to take notes.
PAGE | 85
St r at eg ie s
Strategies
Provide explicit instruction in small groups in which students are given clear models of how to arrive at a solution apply the solution strategies to multiple examples receive immediate feedback on their accuracy ask questions and think aloud about the decisions they make while solving mathematical problems.
Encourage students to represent the information in math problems in a variety of ways: Use manipulatives to facilitate the students formation of mental concepts of numbers and operations. Then move to iconic forms, such as drawings, and then to symbolic representations using standard mathematical notations. Three concrete lessons (using manipulative devices) and three pictorial lessons (using pictures and/or tallies) with each lesson consisting of about 20 problems is sufficient for most students with mathematical disabilities to understand the concept being taught. Have students verbalize discussions and solutions to a mathematics problem.
PAGE | 86
St r at eg ie s
Make use of web-based and software technology to provide a variety of ways to represent numbers and operations while increasing students abilities to create mental representations of concepts represent numbers and operations in visual a format manipulate images to enact operations and problem-solving procedures project text, graphics and images and then manipulate them on a white board. These boards record the lesson, including examples used to illustrate a concept. Students download and open the lesson in digital format to review it, fast forward to a key point and review work at their own pace.
Provide a talking calculator which will say each number and symbol aloud as entered, enabling continuous self-checking of work. Provide organizational assistance by using graph paper for mathematical computations if students experience difficulties aligning their work assigning manageable amounts of practice work as skills are learned assigning a peer helper to work along with the student demonstrating ways to organize mathematics work.
PAGE | 87
St r at eg ie s
FASTT Math published by Tom Snyder Production, Scholastic First Steps in Math: For Grades K-10.
Foundations for Numeracy: an evidence based toolkit for early learning practitioners. Canadian Language and Literacy Network and the Canadian Child Care Federation.
PAGE | 88
St r at eg ie s
Math Solutions Mighty Math and MathPad Plus series published by Edmark The Power of Ten SMARTBoard Virtual Manipulatives Base Ten Blocks See Also Appendix 3: Quick References
Number Concepts and Place Value (page 158) Mathematical Reasoning (page 154) Accuracy and Neatness in Math (page 146) Computation (page 144) Reversals in Math (page 145) Sequencing Numbers and Steps (page 159) Problem Solving in Math (page 161)
PAGE | 89
St r at eg ie s
Organization
Improving organization skills can have a profound effect on both learning and overall quality of life. A person with an organizational learning disorder does not intuitively pick up on or apply strategies to different situations. Effective executive function tools and strategies can greatly improve learning efficiency.
Strategies
Instruct explicitly by teaching organizational strategies, including when and why each strategy is to be used embedding strategies across the curriculum and having students use them persistently personalizing organizational strategies to make use of a students strengths and interest conferencing with students to identify areas of weakness and set realistic goals teaching self-monitoring skills assessing students on acquisition of organizational skills, evaluating their progress, and reporting as part of their grade.
Provide scaffold support by providing both written and oral instructions teaching step-by-step approaches to work, breaking long assignments into chunks and assigning time frames for completing each chunk. forewarning students about transition times and shifts in activities creating separate work areas with complete sets of supplies for different activities.
PAGE | 90
St r at eg ie s
Model organizational skills by making checklists and to-do lists, estimating how long tasks will take providing visual organizational aids and referring to them regularly, including visual agendas, visual calendars to keep track of long term assignments, due dates, chores and activities using time organizers watch alarm functions organizing work space and scheduling a weekly time to clean and organize the work space, and minimizing clutter.
Resources - Organization
Web National Center for Learning Disabilities LDOnline Time Timer Other Franklin Day Planner Palm Pilot Lotus Organizer See Also Appendix 3: Quick References Planning (page 160) www.ncld.org
www.ldonline.org/educators http://www.timetimer.com
PAGE | 91
St r at eg ie s
Self Regulation
Difficulties with self-regulation can have a significant effect on both learning and social interactions. For example, self-regulation allows a student to both initiate on-task behaviour and inhibit off-task behaviour, both necessary for learning. Provide accommodations for students who have difficulties: Allow use of a fidget toy (i.e., modeling clay or squeeze ball). Provide an exercise ball for seating. Locate a workspace for the student away from distractions. Provide opportunities for students to stand while working. Provide authentic opportunities to move during class (store supplies at the back of the room so students can walk to get materials they need). Divide long assignments into chunks that can be shared for feedback frequently. Mark assignments in stages to break up need for sustained concentration time.
Provide supportive structures and strategies outlining the routine for the day providing visual and tangible signs of the behaviour expected acknowledging or catching the student demonstrating appropriate behaviours making assignment criteria explicit announcing changes in activities ahead of time identifying areas of interest and using them in instruction.
PAGE | 92
St r at eg ie s
Provide instruction and support to develop self-monitoring recognizing desired behaviours and the undesired behaviours focusing on a specific behaviour each day or week rather than many at once developing a secret signal that acknowledges appropriate behaviour creating with the student a process for him or her to self-monitor providing opportunities to practice learned appropriate behaviours successfully in a variety of situations, including interacting with other students.
PAGE | 93
Cas e St u di e s
Informal Assessment by Mrs. Davidson, Selinas Grade 1 teacher Mrs. Davidson assessed all her Grade 1 students while the learning support teacher taught the class how to sustain 30 minutes of independent work. Once all students were assessed, flexible reading groups were formed. For Selinas group, Mrs. Davidson delivered guided reading lessons four times each week during the sustained work periods. Based on findings of the universal assessment, Mrs. Davidson further assessed Selina. A running record using the PM Benchmarks series determined that Selina read at the early Kindergarten level - relied almost exclusively on picture clues to help with word prediction and reading comprehension - struggled to decode words and make meaning from text. An early literacy skills checklist and interview revealed that Selina - could identify most of the letters of the alphabet but not all the sounds they make - often mispronounced words with th or or sounds - had weak phonemic awareness skills (beginning/middle/end sounds, rhyming, word segmentation) - was beginning to be able to identify initial consonants in words - had difficulty spelling common one syllable words .
PAGE | 94
Cas e St u di e s
Consultation
Mrs. Davidson discussed her concerns with Selinas parents and the learning support teacher. As a result of this consultation Selinas parents agreed to have Selinas hearing and vision checked, and makes respective reports available to the school. The learning support teacher contacted the speech language pathologist for further assessment and advice.
Intervention
Selinas Grade 1 classroom already included accommodations for learning differences founded in practices of universal design, early intervention and differentiation. In addition to the reading group four times a week, Mrs. Davidson guided Selina to access the various other supports available to all students in her class. The listening center was stocked with an appropriate range of fiction and nonfiction books. The writing centre was situated at a computer station that included Kerzweil and CoWriter software. Students took turns practicing using the Earobics program. A word wall displayed new vocabulary and allowed students to take words away to copy when writing. Mrs. Davidson commonly scribed sentences for students as part of individualized writing instruction, and helped students create personal word books for independent use. Peer reading and reading with Grade Five Buddies were common practices. Sentence strips and cloze activities were provided for those who chose to use them in writing responses.
Monitoring
By November 1st, after two months of closely observing Selina and collecting assessment data, Mrs. Davidson determined that she was now was able to identify all the sounds of the alphabet; however, she had made little progress in phonemic awareness and continued to struggle with reading comprehension.
PAGE | 95
Cas e St u di e s
The learning support teacher and Mrs. Davidson began to suspect the presence of a learning disability. The team consulted with the district psychologist to determine if there were any additional interventions they could try. In addition to guided reading lessons and speech therapy, they agreed that Selina would benefit from additional work with phonemic awareness and sight word recognition. To work on this, Selina would participate in small-group instruction with the learning support teacher. Progress would be reviewed at a follow-up meeting after three weeks. In early December, the learning support teacher carried out a second diagnostic reading assessment with Selina. Results showed little to no improvement since the previous assessment. After consulting with Selinas parents, the school team began a referral process for psycho-educational assessment.
Develop an IEP
Results of the psycho-educational assessment in March affirmed that Selina had a learning disability, and provided additional information to that already gathered by the school team. The team assisted Mrs. Davidson in preparing an Individualized Educational Plan and set a date to review the plan at the end of the school year.
PAGE | 96
Cas e St u di e s
Objectives
Selina will identify beginning, middle and end sounds in words using beginning Grade 1 text with 90 per cent accuracy use written context and picture clues to predict words when reading with 90 per cent accuracy.
Goal 2
Selina will improve various aspects of phonemic awareness by school year end.
Objective
Selina will master the pronunciation of difficult sound combinations: make the th sound with 90% accuracy make the or sound with 90% accuracy.
Objective
Selina will Accurately identify the sounds in words and begin to pair them with letters by school year end: identify beginning and end sounds of any words at 100%. make rhymes with one syllable words at 80 % accuracy segment words into syllables with 60% accuracy.
PAGE | 97
Cas e St u di e s
Implementation
The strategies in the IEP were implemented and Selinas progress monitored. The school-based team reviewed her progress in relation to the IEP goals and objectives at the end of the year in preparation for Selinas Grade 2 program.
PAGE | 98
Cas e St u di e s
Informal Assessment
Based on this information, Mr. Scott, Tonys Grade 4 teacher, completed the following informal assessments: A District Assessment of Reading test (DART) revealed that Tonys reading comprehension was significantly challenged although he was able to decode words and read with relative fluency. Informal math assessment using a teacher-developed test revealed that Tonys math reasoning was good and that he had a strong grasp of number sense.
Consultation
Mr. Scott called a meeting with Tonys parents and Ms. Campbell, the learning assistance teacher. At the meeting they shared information and made plans to provide supports for Tony. Mr. Scotts approach was to provide a combination of whole-class instruction, peer tutoring, and small-group instruction. Mr. Scott typically recorded a learning plan for students who appear to be experiencing difficulty rather than waiting to develop an IEP. Together the team created the learning plan for Tony.
PAGE | 99
Cas e St u di e s
Learning Plan
Name: Tony Strengths Uses letter-sound relationships well Uses picture clues well Overall good verbal skills Mathematics is a clear strength Likes cards, chess, basketball, video games Gets along well with his sister and others Accepts help from older sister, Sarah Grade: 4 Date: December 2011 Challenges Reading comprehension Following written instructions Word problems in math Written and verbal responses to reading Reading for pleasure
Focus for Tony Improve overall reading comprehension Ms. Campbell will teach: pre-, during, and post reading strategies during small-group instruction the use of graphic organizers to record ideas and notes teach text structures of various genres. teach Tony to use Kerzweil
Mr. Scott will model and teach students to make use of the same strategies throughout curricular areas. He will: provide partial outlines of text information provide new vocabulary ahead of time ensure understanding of directions by checking with Tony seat Tony by a helpful peer provide opportunities to discuss concepts encourage peer readers and audio books provide opportunities for Tony to use Kerzweil
PAGE | 100
Cas e St u di e s
Improve comprehension of word problems and written instructions Mrs. Campbell will teach: the use of graphic organizers to record ideas and notes strategies to break instructions down, break information into chunks and represent information graphically
Mr. Scott will model the use of and teach students to make use of the same strategies throughout curricular areas. He will also: provide directions both in writing and verbally provide new vocabulary ahead of time check-in with Tony to ensure understanding
Improve written and verbal responses to reading Mrs. Campbell will teach the use of graphic organizers to assist in responding, both orally and in writing. Mr. Scott will model the use of and teach students to make use of the same strategies throughout curricular areas. He will also: provide opportunities to discuss concepts
Learn to enjoy reading Mr. Scott will introduce a variety of genres to Tony, including graphic novels.
PAGE | 101
Cas e St u di e s
Further Assessment
In order to obtain more information about Tonys current achievement level, Mrs. Campbell completed a norm referenced assessment.
Referral
Based on these results, Mr. Scott and Ms. Campbell felt they needed more indepth information to help Tony. They decided to refer Tony to the school-based team to consider whether he might need to be assessed by the district school psychologist for a psycho-educational assessment. In the meantime, supports and monitoring of progress were maintained. The school-based team agreed and made the referral to the district school psychologist.
Develop an IEP
The psycho-educational assessment report confirmed that Tony had a learning disability, and affirmed what the school-based team saw in samples of Tonys day-to-day work, his responses to Mr. Scotts learning plan and the school-based assessment carried out by Mr. Scott and Ms. Campbell. Using Tonys learning plan, the school-based team assisted Mr. Scott in developing an Individualized Educational Plan for Tony. Strategies in the IEP were implemented and Tonys progress monitored. The team agreed to meet at the end of each reporting period to review progress.
PAGE | 102
Cas e St u di e s
Christopher: A Grade 9 student with a learning disability transitioning into secondary school
File Review
Chris had been identified in Grade 2 as a student with a learning disability in the areas of reading comprehension and executive functioning. Chriss IEPs indicated that he had been receiving reading interventions throughout his elementary school years and was provided with adaptations, such as text readers, peer readers and graphic organizers to guide his thinking and writing. In middle school, Chris continued to receive learning assistance for reading comprehension and to teach him how to use graphic organizers, rubrics and personal schedules to keep track of assignments. In Grade 8, he had been working on improving self-advocacy skills. By the end of Grade 8, Chriss reading comprehension was assessed at midGrade 6 level, and he was coping well with assignments when provided with the appropriate adaptations. Difficulties in middle school included handing work in late or not at all, trouble generating ideas for written work, both starting and completing written assignments, arriving late for class, and forgetting or losing his supplies. When frustrated, Chris expressed anger, would not ask for help, and became generally disinterested in school.
Informal Assessment
Mr. Findlay, Chriss Grade 9 homeroom and English teacher read Chriss file before classes started. Because he was alerted to Chriss past difficulty, he quickly completed an informal reading inventory to check Chriss current level. He found that Chris was reading at about a Grade 6 level and would need to have an IEP for Grade 9. In preparation for an IEP meeting, he asked Chris to fill out a Secondary Student Reflection Sheet (See Appendix 2) which helped identify Chriss current needs and interests and supports that he found most helpful in the past.
PAGE | 103
Cas e St u di e s
Consultation
Mr. Findlay met with Mrs. Hansen, the schools learning support teacher, the school counsellor, Chris and his mother to discuss Chriss program and to develop his Grade 9 IEP. The major concerns that Chris identified were: keeping track of his assignments allocating reasonable amounts of time for completion of the work asking for assistance from teachers remembering to take the supplies he needed for the variety of classes
Goal 2
Chris will master use of technology to compensate for reading comprehension difficulties on tests and with long reading texts. Objective 2a: By end of first semester, Chris will be able to use independently text to speech software applications for tests and reading assignments. Strategy: Mrs. Hansen will provide Chris with practice using Kurzweil.
PAGE | 104
Cas e St u di e s
Goal 3
Chris will improve his organizational skills. Objective 3a: Chris will independently use organizational tools to complete assignments 100 per cent of the time. Strategy: Teachers provide samples of completed work, rubrics that explain project criteria, allowances to reduce the quantity of work, extra time, chunking of tasks and a checklist for longer projects. Objective 3b: Chris will develop and follow a schedule. Strategy: Chris will maintain a weekly calendar to keep track of dates and a study/homework routine. Teachers will provide outlines and due dates via their homework blogs. The learning support teacher will meet with Chris weekly, phasing out support as appropriate. Chriss mom will monitor homework completion. Objective 3c: Chris will consistently have the materials and tools that he needs for learning activities. Strategy: The learning support teacher will help Chris set up locker checklist and electronic reminders. Daily emails will remind him of the items he needs for the day.
Goal 4
Chris will advocate appropriately for himself with his teachers. Objective 4a: Chris will understand when he needs help and ask teachers for assistance. Strategies: During a weekly support group, the school counsellor will work with Chris and other students on how to recognize when they need help and practice positive ways to get assistance. Chriss teachers will personally invite Chris to ask them for assistance when needed. Objective 4b: Chris will explain to teachers the accommodations he needs to be successful. Strategies: During weekly support group, the school counselor using modeling, role playing, and guided practice will work with Chris and other students on ways to advocate for their needs.
PAGE | 105
Cas e St u di e s
Implementation
Mrs. Hansen connected with all of Chriss other teachers to discuss the IEP goals and strategies. She met with Chris during support block to set up a homework schedule on his electronic calendar, with reminders to his email about the supplies he needed for the day. She also showed him how to add the URL for each teachers homework blog to Chriss homepage, for ease of access. Mrs. Hansen and Chris did a weekly review during the first month to set new goals for the week. Goals were shared via email with Chriss mother. Together, Mrs. Hansen and Chris created a checklist for him to self-monitor his use of organizational strategies and to monitor the use of technology to complete assignments. They moved to less frequent reviews as independent implementation success was noted. Mr. Findlay and Chris used the Performance Standards Reading rubric and data from Chriss reading strategies checklist to monitor reading progress and use of reading strategies. The school counsellor included Chris in a group that was learning to practice, implement and monitor the use of self-advocacy skills. Mrs. Hansen also offered to meet with Chris at the beginning of the next term to discuss supplies for each class and how to best communicate with his new teachers for the term.
PAGE | 106
Gl oss a r y
APPENDIX 1 | GLOSSARY
Accommodations
Accommodations are adjustments that facilitate a students ability to focus, to engage in acquisition or consolidation of a skill, and to work toward mastery. Accommodations provide a personalized approach to meet the individual needs of the student and could take the form of adaptation or modification.
Advance organizers
An advance organizer is a tool used to organize or interpret information. Advance organizers provide clarity at the beginning of a task, and direction and support throughout the task to completion. Some specific examples of advanced organizers include: KWL (Know, Want to Know, Learn) charts Four quadrants Sort and predict Venn diagrams Brainstorming and categorizing Going for the big ideas Concept mapping
Advance organizers can take a variety of forms to: activate background knowledge; for example, through brainstorming activities to help the student transfer what they know to what they are learning create anticipation guides; for example, a set of statements about the topic to be presented; students can either challenge or support the ideas, thereby developing an interest in the topic present information visually such as concept maps, tables and charts; the teacher can present a partially completed map or a blank map as an example describe new content; for example, a statement of the main ideas highlight important concepts, such as in a book walk provide a narrative of the content; for example, in a story form
PAGE | 107
Gl oss a r y
Affective
Affective refers to matters arising from or influencing feelings or emotions.
Assistive software
Assistive software is computer programs created to assist those with disabilities.
Attention
Attention is defined as the act or state of focusing, especially through applying the mind to an activity or thought. Attention is enabled by conditions in the childs environment and personal factors, such as the bodys internal environment (worry, perception of threat, physical sensations, blood sugar levels, arousal, interests and motivation). The ability to regulate attention is not only a function of the intellect (executive function), but is also closely tied to arousal (emotional state). Arousal is important to all mental functions, including attention, perception, memory, emotion and problem-solving. Under-arousal results in an inability to select attention and/or stay on task; over-arousal has the same effect.
Auditory processing
Auditory processing is the taking in and making sense of sounds received through the ears, enabling one to comprehend spoken language.
Chunking
Chunking involves breaking a task into easy to manage and often sequential pieces. Chunking helps the student move forward when they feel stuck.
Cognitive Mapping
A method used to process information allowing the "mind's eye" to visualize images.
PAGE | 108
Gl oss a r y
Cognitive processing
Cognitive processing is a term used to describe thinking and applying knowledge.
Collaboration
Collaboration is a way of interacting in which people approach a task together. Successful collaboration is characterized by the following features: it is voluntary, there is mutual trust and open communication among the people involved, identification/clarification of the task is a shared, the goal is shared by all participants, each participants contribution is valued equally, all participants skills are employed in identifying and selecting problem-solving strategies, and there is shared responsibility for the outcome.
Compartmentalize
Compartmentalizing, in education terms, refers to sectioning off or categorizing information the opposite of integration and application.
Compensatory strategies
Compensatory strategies are generally actions and tools the student uses to make up for a weakness/difficulty. Compensatory strategies are identified based on the students assessed needs and strengths/preferences. For example, if the student has a great deal of difficulty remembering things such as what to put in their backpack (homework, lunch, etc.), using a list, an audio file, or a set of pictures as part of the backpack routine is a compensatory strategy. Choices made depend on the strengths/preferences of the individual student.
Conceptual Relationships
Conceptual Relationships are the connections made between concepts or ideas.
Concrete
Concrete, in education, usually refers to a physical representation or manipulative.
PAGE | 109
Gl oss a r y
Differentiated instruction
Differentiated instruction is a flexible approach to teaching that employs strategies to accommodate a range of abilities and learning styles. Differentiation can address content, process, procedures, presentation strategies or assessment.
Dyslexia
According to the National Centre for Learning Disabilities (2005), Dyslexia is a specific learning disability that is neurobiological in origin. It is characterized by difficulties with accurate and/or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities. These difficulties typically result from a deficit in the phonological component of language that is often unexpected in relation to other cognitive abilities and the provision of effective instruction. Secondary consequences might include problems in reading comprehension and reduced reading experience that can impede growth of vocabulary and background knowledge. (as cited in Educators Diagnostic Manual of Disabilities and Disorders, 2007)
Dysgraphia
According to Pierangelo & Guiliani (2006), Dysgraphia is a neurological disorder characterized by writing disabilities. The disorder generally emerges when students are introduced to writing. They make inappropriately sized and spaced letters or write incorrect or misspelled words, in spite of thorough instruction. (National Center of Neurological Disorders and Strokes, 2006; as cited in Educators Diagnostic Manual of Disabilities and Disorders, 2007)
PAGE | 110
Gl oss a r y
Error analysis
Error analysis studies the types and causes of errors in student work, whether it is in reading, writing, mathematics, acquisition of language or any other skill area.
Executive functions
Executive functions are the decision-making and planning processes that are invoked at the start of a task and in the face of a challenge or project. Executive functions include inhibiting actions, restraining and delaying responses, attending selectively, setting goals, strategizing, planning and organizing, maintaining and shifting attention or purpose, managing time and space, self monitoring and checking. Executive functions are used when setting goals, manipulating those plans in working memory and determining what is necessary in order to execute them.
PAGE | 111
Gl oss a r y
Gifted
A student is considered gifted when he or she possesses demonstrated or potential abilities that give evidence of exceptionally high capability with respect to intellect, creativity or the skills associated with specific disciplines. Students who are gifted often demonstrate outstanding abilities in more than one area. They might demonstrate extraordinary intensity of focus in their particular areas of talent or interest. However, they might also have accompanying disabilities and should not be expected to have strengths in all areas of intellectual functioning.
Graphic organizers
A graphic organizer is a visual framework or representation of concepts, information and knowledge that can incorporate both text and pictures. Graphic organizers help construct meaning in reading, writing and speaking. Graphic organizers are widely available and include storyboards, charts, concept mapping, KWL tables and mind-mapping.
High-frequency words
High frequency words are those most-frequently used in the English language, commonly known as sight words that students are expected to learn to read without sounding out.
Informal Assessment
A method of measuring performance by using techniques such as observing or interviewing, where the graded individual is less aware of the assessment in progress
PAGE | 112
Gl oss a r y
Language processing
Language processing refers to the way human beings process speech or writing and understand it as language. Language processing deficits (receptive and expressive) can result in difficulty with making connections between words and the ideas they represent organizing thoughts verbally and in written form understanding instructions and expressing oneself.
Learning interview
Learning interviews between teacher and student are used to better understand the reason(s) behind a students difficulty and in particular the use of a particular strategy in learning.
Learning strategy
Learning strategies are techniques that maximize student strengths and provide structures that enable students to learn more effectively. Some examples of learning strategies include use of graphic organizers, mental rehearsal, visualization techniques and assistive software.
Learning style
Learning style is an individuals natural or preferred way of receiving, processing and manipulating stimuli or information. A visual/spatial learner learns best by seeing, reading and visualizing. An auditory (linguistic) learner learns best by hearing, talking and singing. A kinesthetic learner learns best by doing, acting out and building.
Long-term memory
Long-term memory is the system the brain uses to store, manage and retrieve information over a long period of time. It has unlimited capacity and can hold information for a long time.
Mapping
Mapping is a term used to describe an information management system used to organize, generate and/or collect information.
PAGE | 113
Gl oss a r y
Mnemonic Strategies
Mnemonic strategies are those which use word association to improve intake and recall of content.
Modifications
Modifications are instructional and assessment-related decisions made to accommodate a students education needs. They consist of individualized learning goals and outcomes, which are different than learning outcomes of a course or subject. Modifications might be considered for those students whose special needs are such that they are unable to access the curriculum (i.e. students with limited awareness of their surroundings, students with fragile mental/ physical health, students medically and cognitively/multiply challenged).
Morpheme
Morpheme is the smallest part of a word that has conceptual meaning.
Numeracy
Numeracy is a term used to describe the ability to reason with and understand the use of numbers and their operations.
Occupational Therapist
Occupational therapists are specially trained and certified experts. In education, they aim to improve the students performance of the tasks and activities important to success at school by ensuring an understanding and matching of the students skills and abilities with expectations placed on them at school. This may include use of assistive devices or direct intervention such as therapy to develop motor coordination, visual-motor coordination and/or visual perceptual skills.
Phoneme
A phoneme is the smallest unit of speech distinguishing one sound from another.
PAGE | 114
Gl oss a r y
Phonics
Phonics is a method of teaching reading by teaching the phonetic sounds of letters followed by the phonetic sounds of combined letters. Phonics usually involves controlled vocabulary.
Phonological awareness
Phonological awareness is the ability to discern sounds and sound sequences, including an awareness that words are made up of sounds in sequences.
Phonological processing
Phonological processing consists of the analysis and synthesis of phonemes (the smallest unit of recognized sounds); for example understanding rhyme; e.g. that ball rhymes with call understanding onset median and final sounds; e.g. that ball and bird share the same initial sound differentiating sounds (i.e. segmenting and blending a word in its constituent sounds p-l-ee-z to make please) differentiating syllables (e.g. counting the four syllables in wishy-washy)
Physical Therapist
Physical therapists are licensed experts in movement and function. Physical therapists in the school setting use a variety of treatments such as therapeutic exercises. They often consult on the design of education settings to support movement, prevent injuries and improve participation.
Processing speed
Processing speed is the rate at which an individual can process incoming and outgoing information. Individuals with slower processing speed can have difficulty with comprehension and following instructions. They tend to complete tasks slowly.
Proprioceptive
Proprioceptive pertains to stimuli that originate from within the body.
PAGE | 115
Gl oss a r y
Psycho-educational assessment
Psycho-educational assessment is a testing process that utilizes standardized instruments such as tests and questionnaires to identify a students strengths and weaknesses across many areas of functioning and attributes. These areas include but are not limited to cognitive development, academic achievement, adaptive functioning, visual perception, motor coordination, visual-motor integration, and behaviour (e.g. attention, aggression, etc.).
Rating scale
A rating scale is a tool that estimates acquisition of a skill. Generally, the scale has three to five intervals to show progress toward mastery. Rating scales could be used for assessing a variety of skill-based goals, such as work habits.
Receptive Vocabulary
Receptive Vocabulary is the body of words that an individual recognizes well enough to use to understand by reading or hearing.
Rubric
A rubric is a tool used to assess student progress along a continuum. It is a grid comprised of explicit criteria describing levels of potential achievement, often accompanied by a rating scale. The BC Performance Standards are examples of rubrics that have been created to assess skill levels of individual students in relation to the widely held expectations for the students grade placement.
Scaffolding
In education, scaffolding support is the practice of providing support to a student in acquiring a skill or task or obtaining or expressing knowledge until the student can be successful independently.
PAGE | 116
Gl oss a r y
School-based team
A school-based team is a school-based group that works together to develop and implement instructional and/or management strategies and co-ordinate resources to assist students with special needs.
Self-advocacy
Self-advocacy involves communicating ones needs to others who can help, and actively taking part in using strategies that support ones own progress. A student can self-advocate by being aware of his or her disability, strengths and needs, and by using strategies to deal with them.
Self-monitoring
Self-monitoring refers to the practice of observing and noting ones own behaviour or actions.
Self-regulation
Self-regulation refers to an individuals ability to manage his or her own thoughts and behaviour in order make good decisions, solve problems, and interact socially. In turn, these abilities rely on the sub-skills of self-monitoring (problem identification and attention), self-evaluation (appropriate goal setting), and selfreinforcement (evaluating performance and resetting goals when necessary).
Short-term memory
Short-term memory is a process of the brain where information is held temporarily until it is transferred to long-term memory or forgotten. It is similar to working memory, but more passive.
PAGE | 117
Gl oss a r y
Sight vocabulary
Sight vocabulary consists of words that one recognizes automatically when reading without sounding out.
Task-approach strategies
Task-approach strategies help the student initiate and sustain efforts on a variety of tasks. They help the student with a learning disability move beyond passivity into an active role in task completion. Simple strategies include: mnemonics, to help the student remember the steps to follow: i.e. HOMES (names of the Lakes are: Huron, Ontario, Michigan, Erie and Superior) picture prompts: e.g. a visual schedule of the daily agenda rhymes or audio files to listen to: e.g. When two vowels go walking, the first one does all the talking, and he says his name!
Transitions
Transitions refer to the passage of a student from one environment to another: home to school, grade to grade, school to school, school district to school district, or from school to community life and/or post-secondary education. Transition planning is the preparation, evaluation and implementation of the plans required to enable students to make major transitions during their lives.
Vestibular
Vestibular refers to the sensory system relating to balance and equilibrium.
Visualization
Visualization is the act of processing information into a visual form.
PAGE | 118
Gl oss a r y
Word-prediction software
Word-prediction software automatically predicts the word a person would type, based on spelling, word frequency and context. The software might also include features such as spell checking, speech synthesis, and hot-keys for frequently used words.
Working memory
Working memory refers to a system in the brain that holds new information while it is being processed and used. Working memory is a component of shortterm memory.
PAGE | 119
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Advocacy
Tips for Parents to Help Children Develop Self-Advocacy Skills
Talk with your child about his or her special education needs and what they mean for learning. You can clarify your understanding of your childs unique learning characteristics by consulting with the staff who conducted assessments and by reading articles and books. Provide specific feedback that helps your child understand how they learn best, such as You seem to remember better when you get a chance to see the information while listening. Explain assessment results, so your child understands his or her abilities and needs and the implications for schooling and life. Stress that your child is not alone with his or her difficulties. Parents, grandparents, siblings and school staff can all help with learning. Describe the assistance that is available to your child in a concrete, realistic and positive manner. Role-play ways to handle difficult situations at school. Seek resources for support and information. Help your child, as they mature, access those resources and become a self-advocate for their own education needs. Encourage your child to be an active participant in the learning team by participating in IEP conferences (where appropriate) and setting realistic goals as they progress through school. Introduce your child to books that deal with challenges similar to those they face themselves.
Adapted from Tips For Parents on Helping Their Children Develop Self-Advocacy Skills. Alberta Education, Alberta, Canada (2006)
PAGE | 120
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Self Advocacy
Be Your Own Self-Advocate: Tips for Students
Being a self-advocate means understanding and recognizing that there are times when you need to ask for things, such as an alternative assignment, an extension on a deadline or notes from a class you missed. The idea is to let the teacher know that you have thought about the situation and are prepared to contribute to a solution. When you go to your teacher with a solution, you let them know that you are taking responsibility for your situation and that you dont expect them to solve the problem for you. Be flexible. You might need to negotiate a solution that is acceptable to everyone involved. When you need something changed, its your responsibility to bring it to the attention of your teacher. Plan and practice what you want to say. Always go with a solution and a positive attitude. 1. State the problem and find an example. 2. Let people know you are working on this problem (so they dont think you are trying to avoid work or are not trying hard enough). 3. Briefly explain your solution to the problem. 4. Ask for his or her help in using the accommodation. You might find yourself saying: I am working on my reading skills, but I have trouble with exam questions. I understand better when someone reads the questions to me. One of the peer tutors is willing to tape the test questions for me- would you be willing to give this a try? I work hard to spell correctly, but I need to use a spell checker. I always have one with me in class. Is it okay for me to use it on tests? I need extra time to show all that I know on a test. If I could have an extra half hour to finish the social studies test, my result would be a better reflection of what I know. Id be willing to stay through lunch hour to do this. Adapted from Tips For Parents on Helping Their Children Develop Self-Advocacy Skills. Alberta Education, Alberta, Canada (2006)
PAGE | 121
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Parent Input
About My Child Form A
Student Name__________________________________Date___________________
Parents Name __________________________________________________________ Identifying priorities is important in developing a meaningful IEP. This form will provide important information for school staff to consider. If you need additional space, feel free to attach another sheet of paper. My child has these strengths: _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ My child has these needs: _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ My first priority for my child this year is: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE | 122
Pl an ni ng To o ls
This is what I will do at home to help my child make progress: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
How I will know my child has made progress: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
Another important priority for my child this year is: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
This is what I will do at home to help my child make progress: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
How I will know my child has made progress: ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________________
Parents Name ______________________________________________ Date:__________________ Adapted from Tips For Parents on Helping Their Children Develop Self-Advocacy Skills. Alberta Education, Alberta, Canada (2006)
PAGE | 123
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Recommendations you feel are important from the past report card were:
What my child likes best about school, in his or her own words is:
What my child would like to accomplish this year, in his or her own words is:
What my child says would help him or her learn better at school is:
PAGE | 124
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Adaptations
Adaptation Log
Use this list to record the adaptations that have been tried, or are currently being used for a student. Include additional adaptations in the blanks at the end of each section or observations about which adaptations are successful and which are not. Students Name _____________________________ Grade: ____ Date: _____________ Physical Arrangements Seat student near the teacher. Seat student near a positive role model. Stand near the student when giving directions or presenting lessons. Avoid distracting stimuli (e.g. air conditioner, high traffic areas). Arrange different work areas in the room. Comments:__________________________________________ ____________________ Lesson Presentation Provide peer tutoring. Write key points on board. Provide visual aids such as large print, films, charts, graphics, advanced organizers or notes. Use text-reading technology to provide access to written work. Teach through multisensory modes: visual, kinesthetic, auditory. Repeat directions to the student after they are given to the class, then have him or her re-state and explain the directions to the teacher. Provide written outlines of lessons, with main ideas. Allow student to record lessons to review later. Have student review key points orally. Accompany oral directions with written directions to refer to later. Provide and post a work sample, and refer to it often. Use underlining or highlighting to help student find main ideas and details in text. Break longer presentations into shorter segments. Use technology to augment presentations and provide opportunities for interaction (e.g. SMART board). Comments: ____________________________________________________________
PAGE | 125
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Assignments Give extra time to complete tasks. Simplify complex directions. Lower the reading level of assignments. Provide text-reading technology for reading assignments. Provide word-prediction and other software for written assignments. Require fewer correct responses to achieve completion (quality vs. quantity). Provide study skills training and personalized learning strategies. Shorten assignments, breaking the work into smaller segments. Allow computer-printed assignments prepared by the student or dictated by the student. Use self-monitoring checklists, charts, cue cards, etc. Allow printing instead of cursive handwriting on assignments. Monitor students self-paced assignments (daily, weekly, bi-weekly). Arrange for homework tasks to make it home with clear concise directions. Recognize and give credit for oral participation in class. Comments: ____________________________________________________________ Test Taking Allow open book exams. Give exams orally. Give take-home tests. Allow student to give recorded test answers. Provide text-reading technology for reading assignments. Give frequent short quizzes, not long exams. Allow extra time for exams. Provide text-reading technology for exams Provide word-prediction and other software to assist with writing. Avoid placing student under pressure of time or for completion. Comments: ____________________________________________________________
PAGE | 126
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Organization Provide peer assistance with organizational skills. Set up one-binder system for notes and assignments. Assign a volunteer homework buddy. Allow student to have an extra set of books at home. Prepare advance study/assignment schedules with students. Send daily/weekly progress reports home. Develop a reward system for in-school work and homework completion. Provide student with a homework assignment book or develop a homework website. Comments: ____________________________________________________________ Behaviours Keep rules simple, clear and available for reference. Use timers to facilitate task completion. Structure transitional/unstructured times (e.g. recess, hallways, lunchroom). Praise specific behaviours. Teach self-monitoring strategies. Give special privileges/positive reinforcements, and increase their immediacy. Make prudent use of negative consequences. Allow for short breaks between assignments. Use non-verbal signals to cue students to stay on task. Mark students correct answers, not their mistakes. Implement a behaviour-management system. Allow legitimate movement and student time-out-of-seat activities. Ignore inappropriate behaviours that are not drastically outside classroom limits. Contract with the student. Implement reasonable time-out procedures. Comments: ____________________________________________________________
PAGE | 127
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Student Reflections
Student/Teacher Interview
The following questions provide a guide to discuss the students perceptions about school and learning. Teacher:____________________________________________Date:___________________ Students Name:____________________________________________ Grade:___________ Birth date:______________________ Age:_____
Schools previously attended: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Best year in school? Why? ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Worst year in school? Why? ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Impression of present school year (easy parts/hard parts). ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Ways to change school to make it better? ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Favourite friends in school/friends at home: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE | 128
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Family parents, siblings: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ What would you like to be when you grow up? ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Favourite fun activities at home/school: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Three wishes you might have: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Ways we can help you the most: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Additional comments: ___________________________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________________________ Informal Student Interview: BCTF: The Vital Link, Volume 9, Number 1, Fall 2003
PAGE | 129
Pl an ni ng To o ls
PAGE | 130
Pl an ni ng To o ls
B. In the classroom
What seating works best for me? ___________________________________________________________________________________ What do I read best from?
board overhead projector chart paper my own copy
Does the type of printing make a difference (e.g. printed, handwritten or typed)? ___________________________________________________________________________________ Does the size and spacing of print make a difference? ___________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE | 131
Pl an ni ng To o ls
PAGE | 132
Pl an ni ng To o ls
Learning Strengths
Learning Challenges
List some things you are good at doing outside of school draw a picture of one of these strengths: __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE | 133
Pl an ni ng To o ls
List some things you find challenging doing outside of school draw a picture of one of these challenges: __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________ Adapted from Tips For Parents on Helping Their Children Develop Self-Advocacy Skills. Alberta Education, Alberta, Canada (2006)
PAGE | 134
P ag e 1 of 5
The Learning Disabilities Instructional Support Planning Process helps to connect information about a students learning profile with the appropriate interventions.
Learning Disabilities Instructional Support Planning Process
Students Name: _________________________________ School: _____________________________________ Grade: ___ DOB: ______________ ________________
A DOMAIN STRENGTHS NEEDS B C
Date:
ACADEMIC
SELFDETERMINATION/ INDEPENDENCE
COGNITIVE FUNCTIONING
SOCIAL/EMOTIONAL
*Team Decision: N/A = no impairment of functionality, A = Mild impairment of functionality; B = Moderate impairment of functionality; C = Complex and/or intense impairment of functionality. Goals Developed to Address Needs Identified Above:
Objectives and Strategies to Address Goals Developed: (What interventions/services/strategies can maximize functioning?)
Data Sources to Monitor Outcome/s and Goal Achievement: (What are the outcomes? How useful were the interventions? How can the goals/strategies/services be improved for better outcomes?)
Review Date:
PAGE | 135
P age 2 of 5
A (MILD)
The students level of functioning
B (MODERATE)
C (COMPLEX)
The Academic Domain consists of oral language, reading, writing and mathematics. Oral Language expressive and receptive Reading phonemic awareness, decoding, vocabulary, fluency, comprehension Writing fine motor (printing, cursive), written expression (meaning, form, style, conventions) Mathematics number sense, operations, measurement, patterns, geometry, data analysis, mathematical problem solving Application of reading, writing, mathematics to other subject areas Possible sources of information Classroom observation Parental input Teacher(s) File review Student interviews Academic assessment, Curriculum-based assessment, Informal individual assessments Level B assessments, Level C Psycho-educational assessment
Student exhibits moderate impairment in functioning but not necessarily in every setting or at all times
Working on the performance standards of the curriculum with minor adaptations Minor difficulties with receptive language use Minor difficulties with expressive language use Minor difficulties with reading decoding Minor difficulties with reading comprehension Minor difficulties with writing Minor difficulties with mathematics Shows variability in academic skills and requires mild level of support (between and/or within subject areas) Aware of several learning strategies but may use some of them inconsistently Represents learning in a variety of forms but requires options Minor difficulties attending to instruction and learning activities Minor difficulties independently completing tasks in one or more of the academic areas Some difficulty with organization (time, materials) Tendency to be slow in completing work Some carelessness with work/paperwork
Working on the performance standards of the curriculum with significant adaptations Moderate difficulties with receptive language Moderate difficulties with expressive language Moderate difficulties with reading decoding Moderate difficulties with reading comprehension Moderate difficulties with writing Moderate difficulties with mathematics Variations in academic skills require moderate level of support (between and/or within subject areas) Has a few learning strategies and may use them inconsistently Represents learning through a limited variety of forms Moderate difficulties attending to instruction and learning activities Significant difficulties independently completing tasks in one or more of the academic areas Moderate difficulty with organization (time, materials) Slow to complete work, may require intermittent to ongoing monitoring to ensure completion Requires periodic to regular assistance with work/paperwork in terms of care and materials (i.e., binder, desk set up, etc.)
Students needs require significant adaptations and/or some modified learning outcomes Significant difficulties with receptive language Significant difficulties with expressive language Significant difficulties with reading decoding Significant difficulties with reading comprehension Significant difficulties with writing Significant difficulties with mathematics Variations in academic skills require significant level of support (between and/or within subject areas) Requires considerable practice and ongoing support to apply learning strategies Restricted to representing learning in few forms Significant difficulties attending to instruction and learning activities Rarely able to independently complete tasks in one or more of the academic areas Substantial difficulty with organization (time, materials) Unable to complete work on time unless directly assisted Needs direct/regular contact regarding work/paperwork in terms of care and materials
Examples of Support
ACADEMIC
Some file management Some adaptations of curriculum in specific areas of need Some smaller group instruction and/or individualized instruction in areas of academic need based on ongoing assessment Provide a variety of adaptations for representing learning based on students strengths Some use of cueing/teacher redirection/preferred seating Intermittent use of accommodations (for example, pre-teaching)
Some file management and monitoring Significant adaptations of curriculum in specific areas of need High levels of smaller group instruction and/or high levels of individualized instruction in areas of need (academic, learning strategies, organization) based on ongoing assessment Provide a variety of adaptations for representing learning based on students strengths Frequent use of cueing/teacher redirection/preferred seating Use of accommodations (reader, scribe, computer, etc.)
Daily or frequent contact throughout the week Significant adaptations and/or modifications of curriculum in specific areas of need Intensive smaller group instruction and/or intensive individualized instruction in areas of need (academic, learning strategies, organization) based on ongoing assessment Provide a variety of adaptations or modifications for representing learning based on students strengths Constant use of cueing/constant redirection/preferred seating Use of accommodations (reader, scribe, computer, etc.)
PAGE | 136
P age 3 of 5
A (MILD)
The students level of functioning
B (MODERATE)
Student exhibits moderate impairment in functioning but not necessarily in every setting or at all times
C (COMPLEX)
SELF-DETERMINATION/INDEPENDENCE
The Self-Determination Domain consists of awareness of strengths and weaknesses, ability to evaluate learning (environment, process, product,) ability to solve problems and make informed and appropriate decisions. Understanding personal strengths and weaknesses Ability to describe his/her individual learning disability Determining preferred learning strategies and ways of demonstrating knowledge Ability to make appropriate personal choices Setting realistic personal goals Ability to solve academic and social problems
Aware of and uses most areas of personal strength Aware of some areas of personal weakness and some successful ways to address them Functions independently in the classroom environment most of the time Follows most school/class routines May require some staff intervention (teacher, specialist, paraprofessional) May require assistance with some activities during transitioning Actively seeks assistance from staff when needed Occasional difficulties adapting to new teacher(s)/educational staff Some problems with academic problem solving Some problems with social problem solving May fail to accept personal responsibility for some academic/social difficulties Occasionally discouraged with self
Some awareness of but doesnt use personal strengths Aware of some areas of personal weakness but struggle with what to do to address them Has difficulty functioning independently in the classroom environment Occasionally follows some, but not all, school/class routines Requires frequent staff intervention (teacher, specialist, paraprofessional) Requires assistance frequently during transitioning Occasionally seeks assistance from staff Frequent difficulties adapting to new teacher(s)/educational staff Frequent problems with academic problem solving Frequent problems with social problem solving Fails to accept personal responsibility for academic/social difficulties Often personally discouraged
Unaware of personal strength Unaware of personal weakness Is unable to function independently in a classroom environment Frequently does not follow school or class routines Requires constant staff intervention (teacher, specialist, paraprofessional) Requires continuous assistance during transitioning Constant problems with academic problem solving May avoid seeking assistance with staff completely Extreme challenges with adapting to new teacher(s)/educational staff Constant problems with academic problem solving Constant problems with social problem solving Places blame for difficulties on external circumstances Lack of agency or locus of control (does not believe she/he has any power to make change/s) Extremely discouraged with self, resulting in negative self-concept
POSSIBLE SOURCES OF INFORMATION File review Parental input Teacher(s) Vineland Adaptive Behaviour Scales Scales of Independent Behaviour Revised (SIB-R) Behaviour Assessment System for Children (BASC) Supports Intensity Scale (SIS) Other
Examples of Supports
Some file management Instruction in self-advocacy skills, academic and social problem solving skills and learning strategies Support for significant transitions (school to school, school to community) Some structured support to develop self-awareness/self esteem
Some file management and monitoring Targeted direct instruction in self-advocacy skills, academic and social problem solving skills and learning strategies Support for major transitions (semester changes, staff changes) Structured support to develop self-awareness/self esteem
Daily or frequent contact throughout the week Intense direct instruction in self-advocacy skills, academic and social problem solving skills and learning strategies Support for regular transitions (class to class, beginning and end of day) Intense specialized support to develop self-awareness/self-esteem
PAGE | 137
P age 4 of 5
A (MILD)
The students level of functioning
B (MODERATE)
Student exhibits moderate impairment in functioning but not necessarily in every setting or at all times
C (COMPLEX)
The Cognitive Functioning Domain includes thinking, reasoning skills and problem solving. The ability to generalize learning. Higher order thinking skills Language processing Phonological processing Visual-spatial processing Processing speed Memory Attention Executive functions Motor Skills (fine and gross)
May struggle to complete tasks and assignments Minor difficulties with multi-step or complex tasks Mild difficulty with problem solving, especially when dealing with abstractions Processing difficulties (attention, memory, phonological processing, language processing, visual-spatial processing, processing speed and planning, etc.) that minimally impact learning Some difficulty acquiring new information, making connections, generalizing Inconsistent use of learning strategies Some difficulty with fine motor coordination Understands task/work assigned but may need cuing to get started and complete
Often fails to complete tasks and assignments Moderate difficulty with multi-step complex tasks Moderate difficulty with problem solving especially when dealing with abstractions Processing difficulties (attention, memory, phonological processing, language processing, visual-spatial processing, processing speed and planning etc.) that moderately impact learning Moderate difficulty acquiring new information, making connections and generalizing Lacks knowledge of appropriate learning strategies Moderate difficulty with fine motor coordination Struggles to get started and continue with task/work assigned unless teacher checks in regularly
Rarely completes tasks and assignments Significant difficulty with multi-step or complex tasks Significant difficulty with problem solving especially dealing with abstractions Processing difficulties (attention, memory, phonological processing, language processing, visual-spatial processing, processing speed and planning, etc.) significantly impact learning Significant difficulty acquiring new information, making connections and generalizing Significant lack of learning strategies Significant difficulty with fine motor coordination Unable to start task/work without assistance to begin and to complete
COGNITIVE FUNCTIONING
POSSIBLE SOURCES OF INFORMATION File review Parental input Teacher(s) Level C psycho-educational Assessment Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC) Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery (WJPB)-Cognitive The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale
Examples of Supports
Some file management Some adaptation to support curriculum Some direct instruction based on ongoing assessment of skill development and instructional need Some instruction in compensatory strategies to support independent functioning At times or periodically, may require specialist teacher support
Some file management and monitoring Adaptations to support curriculum Targeted direct instruction based on ongoing assessment of skill development and instructional need Ongoing instruction in compensatory strategies to support independent functioning Regular specialist teacher support
Daily or frequent contact throughout the week Adaptations and/or modifications are highly individualized Intense direct instruction based on ongoing assessment of skill development and instructional need Individualization of learning outcomes Ongoing specialist teacher support integrated with classroom practice
PAGE | 138
P age 5 of 5
A (MILD)
The students level of functioning
B (MODERATE)
C (COMPLEX)
The Social / Emotional Domain consists of adapting and coping behaviours across environments and contexts to meet social/ community expectations. Exhibit social and emotional behaviours that are acceptable and support learning. Social and emotional functioning Impulse control Mood (optimism, depression) Anxiety Appropriate reciprocal Social behaviour Ability to make appropriate social choices Setting realistic social and learning goals Difficulties responding to routine changes Possible sources of information File review
Student exhibits moderate impairment in functioning but not necessarily in every setting or at all times
Some difficulties with impulse control May misinterpret emotions, moods, humour, social cues and inferences Minor levels of embarrassment, anxiety and/or worry (e.g. test results, grades, etc.) Minor frustration and/or anger due to unrealistic expectations (student, adult) and/or time required to complete school work Some feelings of failure and/or hopelessness due to exclusion from elective/choice activities or lack of any area of excellence Occasionally critical of themselves or vulnerable to perfectionism Sometimes lacks resilience to overcome challenges Tends to demonstrate immaturity (interacting with younger peers or engages in atypical play for age) Occasionally avoids risk-taking or refuse to try new tasks Sometimes demonstrates learned helplessness (dependence on others for completing tasks, etc.) Occasionally fails to respond to mild behavioural intervention (e.g. proximity, signalling, stating expectations, redirection, verbal correction, etc.) Occasionally uses inappropriate strategies as coping mechanisms Occasional difficulty relating to peers due to lack of social knowledge/skills
Ongoing moderate problems with impulse control Occasionally misinterprets emotions, moods, humour, social cues and inferences Moderate levels of embarrassment, anxiety, and/or worry (e.g. test results, grades) Moderate frustration and/or anger due to unrealistic expectations (student, adult) and/or time required to complete school work Feelings of failure and/or hopelessness due to exclusion from elective/choice activities or lack of area of excellence Frequently critical of themselves or vulnerable to perfectionism Occasionally perseveres to complete tasks Frequently lacks resilience to overcome challenges Often demonstrates immaturity (interacting with younger peers or engages in atypical play for age) Frequently avoids risk-taking or refuses to try new tasks Often demonstrates learned helplessness (dependence on others for completing tasks, etc.) Fails to respond to mild behaviour intervention (e.g. redirection, verbal correction, proximity, etc.) Often uses inappropriate strategies as coping mechanisms Frequent difficulty relating to peers due to lack of social knowledge and/or skills
Ongoing severe problems with impulse control Needs constant verbal/visual cueing attending to instructions and discussions Frequently misinterprets emotions, moods, humour, social cues and inferences Concrete visual supports always needed Needs supports & prompts to communicate appropriately Extreme embarrassment, anxiety and/or worry (e.g. test results, grades) Severe frustration and/or anger due to unrealistic expectations (student, adult) and/or time required to complete schoolwork Overwhelming feelings of failure and/or hopelessness due to exclusion from elective/choice activities or lack of area of excellence Constantly self critical/vulnerable to perfectionism Rarely perseveres to complete tasks Lacks resilience to overcome challenges Exclusively demonstrates immaturity (interacting with younger peers or engages in atypical play for age) Always avoids risk-taking or refuses to try new tasks Frequently demonstrates learned helplessness (dependence on others for completing tasks, etc.) High frequency of socially inappropriate behaviours (shouting, vocalizing, intruding) Fails to respond to behaviour intervention and demonstrates ongoing, continuous noncompliance/defiance Regularly uses inappropriate strategies to cope Needs timely & immediately available intervention Constant difficulty relating to peers due to lack of social skills/knowledge
SOCIAL/EMOTIONAL
Parental input Teacher(s) Observation Student interviews Physician/Psychiatrist Counsellor Medication review Other Examples of Supports
Some file management Some structuring of class routines (transition cueing, re-direction, slower paced instruction, adjustment of timelines/expectations, quiet time, etc.) Small group instruction or individualized instruction (social skills, friendship groups) intermittently throughout the year Some support for self-advocacy Teach coping strategies Promote the development of positive attachments to adults/peers
Some file management and monitoring Consistent and structured class routines (clear schedules, routines, rules and expectations) Small group or individualized instruction on an ongoing basis throughout the year (positive attribute and social skill development, managing anger/anxiety, etc.) Frequent support for self-advocacy Referral for specialized support (paediatrician, counselling, etc.) Promote the development of positive attachments to adults/peers
Daily or frequent contact throughout the week Intensive individualized structures/routines Unique and highly structured learning and positive behavioural support approaches Direct individualized instruction and intensive practice in most/all social situations Ongoing intensive support for self-advocacy Ongoing inter-agency involvement and/or outside treatment Promote the development of positive attachments to adults/peers
PAGE | 139
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
PAGE | 140
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Affective Domain
Description of difficulty frustration feeling left out or inadequate anger self doubt confusion/embarrassment about achievement shame or anxiety de-emphasizing areas of strength avoidance techniques (such as leaving washroom breaks, pencil sharpening or erasing) disruptive behaviours Potential Supports implement universal design in planning build awareness about strengths discourage comparisons with others and reinforce that everyone has strengths and weaknesses relate learning tasks to student strengths celebrate success focus on passions, strengths and talents as a way to highlight different types of intelligence orchestrate opportunities for the student to explain his/her learning strengths and needs to others promote self-advocacy and facilitate opportunities for the student to practice using it integrate use of learning strategies across the curriculum help students learn from their mistakes and struggles model viewing mistakes as a normal part of learning that provide opportunities to self correct and improve model problem solving and discuss productive and unproductive strategies model and provide practice in asking for clarification dig deeper when negative statements are made
begin with strengths when evaluating and debrief with students following assessments encourage self evaluation as part of the process make progress explicit by graphing or charting progress, setting goals, planning and tracking achievement
PAGE | 141
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Attention
Description of difficulty problems focusing appears not to be listening does not complete assignments or rushes through them does not follow instructions difficulty starting tasks difficult organizing seeks sensory information: fidgeting, tapping, touching, making noise loses things changes thoughts quickly shouts out answers or speaks out of turn, difficulty with turn taking in games and lining up poor time management difficulty blocking out competing noise Potential Supports check vision and hearing allow a fidget toy (modeling clay, chewing gum or squeeze ball) seat student away from distractions use a timer for chunking times on task provide authentic opportunity to move class (keep supplies at the back of the room) provide a sizzle seat or exercise ball for seating chunk longer assignments mark assignments in stages make assignment criteria explicit identify areas of interest and use them in instruction allow student to stand while working teach self-monitoring skills
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations make sure notes are complete before studying provide time markers during exams to assist with time monitoring teach test taking strategies provide alternative environment for testing develop tests with plenty of visual white space provide extra time
PAGE | 142
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Comprehension
Description of difficulty insufficient processing speed focus on decoding words lack of phrasing when reading ignores punctuation monotone voice skips lines or words difficult responding accurately to text unable to differentiate relevant words from details difficulty predicting or making inferences literal interpretation of slang or figurative language Potential Supports Assessment Strategies and Adaptations use graphic organizer allow oral recall assess students understanding through a think-pair-share and record the answers confirm understanding of written directions pre-teach vocabulary use dictionary to confirm meanings use pre-reading strategies to bring forward previous knowledge make predictions before reading Think-Pair-Share generate questions before reading explicitly teach summarizing main facts reconstruct cut-up versions of text encourage discussion about text teach about text structures of various genres use text formats to organize information (headings, subtitles) build students vocabulary, knowledge of the world, understanding of story elements regular check-ins with teacher or a buddy to ensure understanding of written direction SQ3R (Scan, Question, Read, Recite, Review) RAP (Read the paragraph, Ask questions about content, Paraphrase the content)
PAGE | 143
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Computation Skills
Description of difficulty remembering basic facts performing basic operations choosing correct operations completing simple mental math counts on fingers lack mathematical automaticity Potential Supports use number lines, multiplication charts and fact sheets allow use of a calculator have the student think aloud while doing math write out steps of a mathematical process encourage estimation highlight operation signs
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow use of manipulatives, multiplication tables, fact sheets, formula sheets or calculator
PAGE | 144
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Reversals in Mathematics
Description of difficulty reverses numbers reverses mathematical symbols Potential Supports combine the numeral or symbol with the word (+, plus) and (5, five) use a highlighter to colour code and identify key words, symbols and operations have student talk about the process before completing reduce copying errors by reducing copying of work (provide work already copied with space for calculations) encourage estimating before calculating colour code operations or symbols create a visual association with operations (number line or > points to higher number so means greater than)
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow additional time provide a calculator monitor student during tests provide prompts reduce the number of questions provide part marks for different aspects of mathematics: calculations, thinking, accurate copying. reduce copying of work teach test taking strategies: do all the same operations at one time, highlight operations in colour code
PAGE | 145
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow additional time permit calculator use regular monitoring during tests provide prompts reduce the number of questions provide part marks for different aspects of mathematics: calculations, thinking, and accurate copying
PAGE | 146
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Decoding
Description of difficulty fluency or automaticity is limited distinguishing between similar speech sounds matching letters and sounds developing sight word vocabulary identifying a word in a previous sentence or paragraph poor phonemic awareness difficult sequencing sounds adds or omits letters, sounds or syllables from or to words segmenting words into syllables or phonemes blending sounds or phonemes to form words Potential Supports select materials at the students instructional or independent level do not require student to read aloud provide peer reader, reading buddy, or reading technology provide audio books provide high interest/low-vocabulary books mark written work for content and dont mark spelling errors provide instruction in phonemic awareness teach word attack skills such as chunking, breaking words into beginning middle and end teach using word families use phonemic awareness activities
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations provide text reader, reader or scribe for tests do not discount marks for spelling errors allow spell checkers
PAGE | 147
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Drafting
Description of difficulty generating and organizing ideas, choosing topics ideas over simplified unable to write complex ideas on paper overuse of a few common words simplistic sentences lodes train of thought short, underdeveloped written product rambling ideas lacks use of pre-writing, revising and editing strategies gets tired easily when writing Potential Supports model and facilitate brainstorming, and other pre-writing strategies provide a frame or structure for writing make explicit the steps of the writing process use graphic organizers to organize writing (story maps, webs, timelines, and flow charts) write ideas on post-it notes to help organize use a checklist to make sure the writing process is followed encourage read-aloud Think aloud while writing use custom dictionaries either in print or digital format
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations assign marks for using the steps in the writing process use writing conferences to provide scaffolding and immediate feedback provide rubrics and exemplars provide self and peer assessment opportunities
PAGE | 148
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Editing
Description of difficulty identifying areas where improvement is needed identifying spelling or grammatical mistakes Potential Supports provide regular, explicit, repeated lessons in grammar provide rubrics for self and peer evaluation use mnemonics to identify steps in editing provide personal dictionaries or writing software practice group edits
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations assign marks for using the steps in the writing process use writing conferences to provide scaffolding and immediate feedback provide rubrics and exemplars provide self and peer assessment opportunities
PAGE | 149
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Encoding
Description of difficulty limited spelling difficulty distinguishing between similar speech sounds developing sight word vocabulary matching letters and sounds segmenting words into syllables or phonemes difficult sequencing sounds blending sounds or phonemes to form words adds or omits letters, sounds or syllables Potential Supports provide manipulatives for practicing words (sand tray, magnetic letters) break words into pieces and have the student reconstruct them use box-words (see page 54) create a personal dictionary or list of commonly misspelled words provide regular practice and re-practice provide word prediction software brainstorm vocabulary and provide correct spelling in advance of writing reduce number of spelling words to learn teach word structures, meanings of words and morphemes teach reading and spelling together
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations do not discount marks for spelling allow spell check software encourage the student to use a personal dictionary to check spelling
PAGE | 150
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Fluency
Description of difficulty monotone reading voice choppy, disconnected reading focus on identifying words mispronounced words or words run together or omitted lines are skipped or reread difficulty decoding words ignoring punctuation very slow pace Potential Supports provide practice learning high frequency words explicitly teach irregular spelling patterns teach functions of words that cannot be visualized teach using repeated reading use choral reading provide audio text choose text at or below independent reading level use buddies to read grade-level text prepare student in advance for any oral reading use a ruler or index card to follow along with text model fluency use text-to-voice software
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations use text to voice software read questions to the student
PAGE | 151
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Learning Strategies
Description of difficulty Study Skills student gets stuck not knowing where to begin a task work is incomplete missing content information inability to pick out key concepts does poorly on tests does not see the relationship between concepts or ideas Potential Supports Study skills students create their own study guides encourage study groups highlighting key words in text generate possible test questions from which to study organize clusters of ideas on post-it notes.
Test Taking skim through the test identify which questions to complete first judge how much time to spend on a question depending on the mark value use the process of elimination for multiple choice or true and false questions use mini maps or outlines for essay questions highlight key or signal words explicitly identify the steps in multi- step questions
Test Taking does poorly on tests overwhelmed by tests does not complete in time answers are incomplete or missed spends too much time on one question misses steps in multi-step questions
Memory unable to recall what has just been said, read or seen forgets concepts from one day to the next has difficulty retrieving materials previously learned difficulty remembering rote information (like math facts)
Memory teach visualization, cognitive mapping and mnemonic strategies provide advance notice for tests to allow for longer study time teach students to divide information into categories exaggerate and use humour in presentations and studying tasks use visual, auditory and kinaesthetic modes of presenting and exploring material provide frequent, regular opportunities to
PAGE | 152
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
practice Assessment Strategies and Adaptations assess frequently assess deeper understanding instead of memory based learning provide an outline or verbal prompts provide a study guide teach preparation of study guides provide test questions in advance allow open book tests or fact sheets activate prior knowledge before instruction use index cards to record key info use visual cues use checklists to identify steps identify students learning styles and make use of related strategies
PAGE | 153
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Mathematical Reasoning
Description of difficulty classifying spatial relationships temporal relationships estimating equivalence transferring number from one form to another, for example, 20 = twenty whispering when performing math reliance on manipulatives verbally expressing mathematical ideas generalizing mathematical concepts into other situations over reliance on memorization use of calculator or computer math anxiety and avoidance Potential Supports use simple numbers when introducing new concepts provide manipulatives and introduce iconic and symbolic representations as appropriate provide discussion around math concepts provide scaffolded instruction use math games connect life to math incorporate math thinking into non-math subjects use graph paper for math computations reduce numbers of questions use a talking calculator allow peer assistance
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations focus on deeper understanding rather than speed give credit for math thinking even if the answer is wrong allow a calculator for some parts of the test allow rewrites to demonstrate further understanding reduce the number of questions allow extra time
PAGE | 154
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Memory
Description of difficulty sequencing events or behaviours completing list of tasks or following instructions remembering the beginning of a sentence or story maintaining attention, problem solving listening comprehension reading comprehension retaining test information remembering what has just been seen, heard or said remembering concepts from one day to the next remembering rote facts Potential Supports ensure vision and hearing are intact employ multisensory approaches activate prior knowledge record key information use mnemonics, raps, songs and acronyms visualization techniques use checklists and routines encourage and use frequent review provide study guides identify the students learning style and make use of that strength to make up for challenges
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations break assessment in chunks provide alternate assessments that rely less on memory such as project work or journals use verbal prompts teach study skills use and teach the use of study guides have student predict exam questions allow open book tests, or notes provide questions in advance encourage group study
PAGE | 155
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Motor Control
Description of difficulty Fine writing, using scissors accurately remembering how to produce letters appropriately spacing, letter size and formation Potential Supports Fine Gross Assessment Strategies and Adaptations Fine do not discount marks for neatness allow word processor accept point-form answers allow extra time allow oral testing provide a scribe or computer software provide tasks in a progression of difficulty encourage social interaction allow transition from class to class when hallways are clear provide a pencil grip use a clip board to hold pages steady use raised or bolded lined paper teach and encourage handwriting over printing provide partially completed notes photocopy notes from another student facilitate buddy support accept alternatives to written assignments develop keyboarding skills use voice to text software
Gross difficulty writing on the board falls out of chair bumps into things and others difficulty sitting upright speech difficulties social interactions
PAGE | 156
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Note-taking Strategies
Description of difficulty difficulty recording oral presentations provide photocopies or peer copies of notes provide partial notes for student to complete cue students to important points provide regular practice in note taking teach abbreviations for vocabulary use word prediction software complete lessons using Smartboard technology and print notes afterward teach strategies such as: summarizing at end of each page notes on one side of page leaving room for additional study note on the other Potential Supports
PAGE | 157
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow use of manipulatives, multiplication tables, fact sheets, formula sheets or calculator encourage students to draw their mathematical thinking
PAGE | 158
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations provide a number line or other concrete supports encourage student to write acronym at the top of the page and use it as a cue
PAGE | 159
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Planning
Description of difficulty defining a problem or setting goals choosing appropriate strategies for tasks developing and sticking to a plan monitoring and adjusting effort and strategies assessing product and personal performance advanced planning or organizing time unprepared for class disorganized notes, desk and materials Potential Supports provide structures such as KWL provide and model use of calendar or planner involve parents in planning homework provide rubrics or checklists for planning and providing clarity provide instruction orally and in writing break projects down in chunks provide criteria for assessing performance or products provide regular check-ins for projects model use of metacognitive strategies assist in goal setting provide graphic organizers use sentence starters provide key vocabulary before writing teach planning frameworks like; PROJECT (Preview the task, Rough out a plan, Organise tasks and resources, Jot down job assignments, Examine obstacles and develop strategies, Commit to goals, Target time lines
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations explicitly teach, monitor and evaluate time management use self and peer evaluation provide criteria ahead of time.
PAGE | 160
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Problem Solving
Description of difficulty reading word problems lack of structure for addressing word problems cannot determine if an answer to a problem is logical solves problems slowly focuses on unimportant details in math problems Potential Supports highlight key words draw pictures to represent problems explain the problem in his or her own words read the problem to the student or have a peer do it teach problem solving steps provide regular review of math vocabulary create a dictionary of math vocabulary and processes encourage the use of a variety of different problems solving strategies relate math to life
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations read the problem to the student allow text to voice technology have student restate the problem in his own words reduce the number of problems give marks for solving the same problem in a variety of ways allow student to do math orally with manipulatives
PAGE | 161
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow use of graphic organizers provide written assessment instruction in chunks or orally simplify instructions
PAGE | 162
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Sharing/Publishing
Description of difficulty embarrassment or emotional difficulty with the idea of sharing work publicly comparing work with that of others Potential Supports allow choice of representation of knowledge or final product (artistic, musical, oral, digital or tactile) arrange work groups to allow for contributions that consider individual strengths and weaknesses allow a scribe (person or digital)
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations do not penalize for neatness or whichever aspect the student struggles with provide rubrics give part marks for various aspects of the work
PAGE | 163
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Transferring Skills
Description of difficulty student applies strategies in only one context uses questioning strategies before reading novels, but not before reading non-fictional text breaks complex questions down for mathematical problem solving but not in language arts tests uses strategies when guided but not independently spells words correctly when writing a test but not in the context of writing Potential Supports model use of strategies across the curriculum set goals around use of strategies across the curriculum encourage and reward independent use of learning strategies model evaluation of appropriate strategies for various contexts provide spelling practice in the context of writing explicitly notice and encourage use of new vocabulary in writing choose words that are meaningful and commonly used in spelling
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations explicitly track the use of learning strategies across the curriculum
PAGE | 164
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Phonological Processing
Description of difficulty omits sounds in words mispronounces sounds in words difficulty rhyming confuses words that sound similar difficulty sounding out sounds when reading difficulty moving beyond invented spelling omits vowels when spelling Potential Supports Provide direct instruction using: rhyming words breaking words into sounds identify beginning, middle and end sounds tapping technique to break down words play phonemic games (see page 44) provide charts of phonetic skills use word walls to illustrate a phonetic component, and provide practice using software
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations allow text to voice technology, books via digital files use Co-writer to aid with written work permit opportunities for student to develop ideas without worrying about spelling
PAGE | 165
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations use Co-writer to aid with written work provide voice-to-text technology allow the student to represent learning using art or drama encourage the use of graphic organizers as a framework for students to demonstrate knowledge
PAGE | 166
Qui c k R e fe r e n ce s
Assessment Strategies and Adaptations encourage the use of graphic organizers as a framework for students to demonstrate knowledge use text to speech software allow student to represent learning using art or drama
PAGE | 167
A ssess me nt T oo ls
PAGE | 168
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Level B assessments require specific assessment training in administration, scoring and interpretation procedures and are used when more specialized information and support is needed in order to support children in their learning. Level C assessments are those which require advanced protocol training and may only be administered by a certified psychologist. Level C testing may be used to help inform a diagnostic and or functional assessment and for the purpose of informing intervention/accommodations strategies. The following chart lists Level A and B assessment instruments commonly used in British Columbia school districts. This is not an exhaustive list, nor does the Ministry of Education endorse the use of any particular assessment tool.
Level B
Boehm Test of Basic Concepts - Revised Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills - DIBELS Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test PPVT III Expressive Vocabulary Test EVT Test of Phonological Awareness - TOPA Phonological Awareness Test
PAGE | 169
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Level B
Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills DIBELS Curriculum-Based Measurement (CBM): Reading Fluency Words Read Correctly Gray Oral Reading Test (Grade 6-12) GORT-4 Stanford Diagnostic Reading Test SDRT Gates-MacGinitie Reading Tests GMRT-4 Group Reading Assessment and Diagnostic Evaluation - GRADE Canadian Achievement Test (CAT): Vocabulary, Comprehension subtests Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition Reading Recovery Observation Survey (Level A assessment tool that require specific administration training)
PAGE | 170
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Level B
Curriculum-Based Measurement (CBM): Written Expression Total Words Written, Words Spelled Correctly Test of Written Language (TOWL 4) Canadian Achievement Test (CAT) Written Language Subtests Written Language Observation Scale (WLOS) Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA) Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition (WIAT) Reading Recovery Observation Survey (Level A Assessment Tool that needs specific administration training)
PAGE | 171
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Level B
Curriculum-Based Measurement (CBM): Correct Digits KeyMath Diagnostic Arithmetic Test Group Mathematics Assessment and Diagnostic Evaluation (G-MADE) Canadian Achievement Test (CAT) Math subtests Test of Mathematical Abilities (TOMA) Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement
PAGE | 172
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Level B
Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test PPVT III DIBELS Brigance Diagnostic Inventory (Choose from subtests B-3R, B-4R, Word Analysis) Visual-Spatial Processing: Visual-Spatial Processing Skills checklist Brigance Diagnostic Inventory (Visual-motor, Visual-discrimination, Reading maps/graphs) Memory: Brigance Diagnostic Inventory (Subtests for Sentence Memory and Following Directions) Attention: On-off task with average peer comparison Teacher Rating Scale Processing Speed: Timed measures of task completion with average peer comparison (speed/accuracy) Expressive Vocabulary Test EVT Test of Phonological Awareness TOPA Phonological Awareness Test Beery-Buktenica Visual-Motor Integration Test Test of Auditory of Processing Skills TAPS
PAGE | 173
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Assessment Resources
Print Alper, S., Lea Ryndak, D., Schloss, C.N. Alternate Assessment of Students with Disabilities in Inclusive Settings. Allyn &Bacon. Boston, MA (2000) Brownlie, F. Grand Conversations, Thoughtful Responses - A Unique Approach to Literature Circles. Portage & Main Press. Winnipeg, MB (2005) Clay, Marie M. An Observation Survey-Of Early Literacy Achievement. Heinemann. Portsmouth, NH (2005) Gregory, K., Cameron, C., Davies, A., Setting and Using Criteria (Second Edition). Solution Tree Press. Connections Publishing. Courtenay, BC (2011) Hume, K. 50 Tools and Techniques for Classroom Assessment Grades 6-10. Pearson Canada. Toronto, ON (2009) Miller, W. Alternate Assessment Techniques for Reading and Writing. Jossey-Bass. New York, NY (1995) Politano, C., Paquin,J., Cameron,C., Gregory, K., Voices Of Experience: Practical Ideas To Spark Up The Year, Grades K-3. Portage & Main Press. Winnipeg MB (2004) Silvaroli, N. J., Wheelock, W., Classroom Reading Inventory. McGraw-Hill. New York, NY (2000). Web Curriculum-Based Assessments and Curriculum-Based Measurement Developmental Reading Assessment (DRA) http://www.interventioncentral.org
PAGE | 174
A ssess me nt T oo ls
Numeracy Nets (2008) Pearson Canada. Don Mills, Ont. Resource for the Identification and Teaching of Students with Specific Learning Disability: High School Program Savage Bird Assessments (built from BC Performance Standards, free downloads); Assessment for Numeracy in Education (ANIE) Assessment for Literacy in Education (ALIE) Social Responsibility Assessment (SaRA)
http://www.gnb.ca/0000/publications/ss/ LDHandbook611.pdf
http://members.shaw.ca/savagebird
Special Education/Learning Assistance Designations Assessment Tools. This page lists and describes a number of commonly used assessment tools. Transitioning to Kindergarten: A Toolkit for Early Childhood Educators. Includes Kindergarten Readiness Indicators Checklist and Get Ready to Read! Screening Tool Unlocking Potential: Key Components of Programming for Students with Learning Disabilities Vancouver Island Net Diagnostic Math A
http://bctf.ca/issues/resources.aspx?id=11 546
http://www.recognitionandresponse.org/co ntent/view/23/108/#grtr
http://education.alberta.ca/media/511999/ unlocking.pdf
http://web.sd71.bc.ca/islandnet/index.php? d
PAGE | 175
Reso u r ce s
APPENDIX 5 | RESOURCES
Print
Allen Jurenka, N. Teaching phonemic awareness through childrens literature and experiences. Libraries Unlimited. Westport, CT (2005). Axelrod, A. Pigs will be pigs: Fun with math and money. Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers. New York, NY (1994). Beers, S. & Howell, L. Reading strategies for the content areas (Vol. 1). Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Alexandria, VA (2003). Bender, W. Differentiating instruction for students with learning disabilities. Corwin Press. Thousand Oaks, CA (2002). Bird, R. The dyscalculia toolkit. Sage Publications. Thousand Oaks, CA (2007). Bodrova, E. & Leong, D. Tools of the mind: The Vygotskian approach to early childhood education. Allyn & Bacon. Boston, MA (2007). Delaney, T. The sensory processing disorder answer book: Practical answers to the top 250 questions parents ask. Sourcebooks, Inc. Naperville, IL (2008). Erlich, V. Gifted children: A guide for parents and teachers. Prentice Hall. Engelwood Cliffs, NJ (1982). Fisher, D. & Frey, N. Enhancing RTI: How to ensure success with effective classroom instruction and intervention. Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Alexandria, VA (2010). Graham, S. and Hebert, M.A. Writing to read: Evidence of how writing can improve reading. Carnegie Foundation. New York, NY (2010). Haylock, D. & DEon, M. Helping low achievers succeed at mathematics. Trifolium Books Inc Toronto, ON (1999).
PAGE | 176
Reso u r ce s
Print (continued)
Jayanthi, M., Gersten, R., & Baker. S. Mathematics instruction for students with learning disabilities or difficulty learning mathematics: A guide for teachers. RMC Research Corporation, Center on Instruction. Portsmouth, NH (2008). http://centeroninstruction.org/files/Mathematics%20Instruction%20LD%20Guide%20for% 20Teachers.pdf Jenkins, S. Actual size. Sandpiper.London, UK (2010). Johns, J.L. & Lenski, S.D. Improving writing: Resources strategies and assessments. Kendall Hunt Publishing Company.Dubuque, IA (2000). Johns, J.L. & Wham, M. Reading and learning strategies for middle and high school students. Kendall Hunt Publishing Company.Dubuque, IA (2000). Lavoie, R. The Motivation breakthrough: 6 secrets to turning on the tuned-out child. Simon and Schuster.New York, NY (2007). Leinwand, S. Accessible mathematics: 10 instructional shifts that raise student achievement. Heinemann.Portsmouth, NH (2010). Levine, M. Educational care: A system for understanding and helping children with learning problems at home and in school. Educator Publishing Services, Inc. Cambridge, MA (1994). Osborn, P. Reading smarter (Grades 7-12). Center for Applied Research in Education. New York, NY (1995). Pierangelo, R. & Giuliani, G. The educators diagnostic manual of disabilities and disorders. JosseyBass. San Francisco, CA (2007). Richardson, K. Developing number concepts using unifix cubes. Addison Wesley Publishing Co. Menlo Park, CA (1984). Rockwell, S. Back off, cool down, try again: Teaching students how to control aggressive behaviour. Council for Exceptional Children. Reston, VA (1995).
PAGE | 177
Reso u r ce s
Print (continued)
Rose, D., Meyer, A. & Hitchcock, C. The universally designed classroom Accessible curriculum and digital technologies. Harvard Education Press. Cambridge, MA (2005). Sliva, J. Teaching inclusive mathematics to special learners K-6. Corwin Press. Thousand Oaks, CA (2003). Small, M. Good questions: Great ways to differentiate mathematics instruction. College Press. New York, NY (2009). Sousa, D. How the brain learns mathematics. Corwin Press. Thousand Oaks, CA (2002). Stock Kranowitz, C. The out-of-sync child Recognizing and coping with sensory processing disorder. Skylight Press. New York, NY (1998). Tang, G. The grapes of math. Scholastic Press. New York, NY (2001). Tomkins, G. Teaching writing: Balancing process and product (3rd ed.). Merrill/Prentice Hall. Upper Saddle River, NJ (2000). Tomlinson, C. The differentiated classroom. Association of Supervision and Curriculum Development. Alexandria, VA (1999). Wood, J. Reaching the hard to teach. Virginia Commonwealth University Press.Richmond, VA (1996).
PAGE | 178
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 179
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 180
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 181
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 182
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 183
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 184
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 185
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 186
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 187
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 188
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 189
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 190
Reso u r ce s
PAGE | 191
Reso u r ce s
Bibliography
Andrews & Lupart. The inclusive classroom: Educating exceptional children. Nelson Education. Scarborough, ON (1993). Berry, R. W.A. Teacher talk during whole-class lessons. Engagement strategies to support verbal participation by students with learning disabilities. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice, Vol. 21, No. 4, pp. 211-233 (2006). Burden, P. & Byrd, D.M. Methods for effective teaching. Allyn and Bacon. Boston, MA (1994). Butler, F., Miller, S., Crehan, K., Babbitt, B. & Pierce, T. Fraction instruction for students with mathematical Disabilities: Comparing two teaching sequences. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. pp 99-111 (2003). Dawson, P. & Guare, R. Executive skills in children and adolescents: A practical guide to assessment and intervention. The Guilford Press. New York, NY (2004). Driekurs, R., Grunwald, B. & Pepper, F. Maintaining sanity in the classroom: Classroom management techniques. Harper and Row. New York, NY (1982). Elrich, Virginia. Gifted children: A guide for parents and teachers. Prentice Hall. Englewood Cliffs, NJ (1982). Howell, K. & Nolet, V. Curriculum-based evaluation, teaching and decision making. Wadsworth/Thomson Learning. Scarborough, ON (2000). Levine, Mel. Keeping ahead in school: A students book about learning disabilities. Educators Publishing Services, Inc. Cambridge, MA (1990). Levine, Mel. All kinds of minds: A young students book about learning abilities and learning disorders. Educators Publishing Services, Inc. Cambridge, MA (1993). Mather, N. & Goldstein, S. Learning disabilities and challenging behaviours: A guide to Intervention and Classroom Management. Paul H. Brooks Publishing Co. Baltimore, MD (2001). McLoughlin, J. & Lewis, R.B. Assessing students with special needs (6th ed.). Merrill Prentice Hall. Upper Saddle River, NJ (2005). The power to hope, to learn, and to succeed. (2005). National Center for Learning Disabilities. Retrieved from www.ncld.org
PAGE | 192
Reso u r ce s
Pierangelo, R. & Giuliani, G. The educators diagnostic manual of disabilities and disorders. Jossey-Bass.San Francisco, CA (2007). Politano, C. & Paquin, J. Brain-based learning with class. Portage and Main Press. Winnipeg, MB (2000). Rubenzer, R.L. Stress management for the learning disabled. (1988). Retrieved December 20, 2010, from www.ericdigests.org/pre-928/stress.htm Singer, B. & Bashir, A. What are executive functions and self-regulation and what do they have to do with language learning disorders? Language, Speech and Hearing Services in Schools Vol. 30, pp.265273 (1999) Scala, Marilyn, C. Working together: Reading and writing in inclusive classrooms. International Reading Association. Newark, DE (2001). Scholey, A., Wesnes, K. & Wilkinson, L. Chewing gum selectively improves aspects of memory in healthy volunteers. pp 235-236. Appetite, 38(3) (2002) Schrag, J. & Burnett, J. Inclusive schools and gifted students and educational reform. pp 64-68.Teaching Exceptional Children, 26(3) (1994) Westman, J.C. Handbook of learning disabilities: A multi-system approach. Allyn and Bacon. Boston, MA (1990). Ysseldyke, J. & Christenson, S. Functional assessment of academic behaviour: Creating successful learning environments. Sopris West Educational Services. Longmont, CO (2002).
PAGE | 193