0% found this document useful (0 votes)
27 views43 pages

University of Twente: Faculty of Mathematical Sciences

The document presents a new discontinuous Galerkin finite element method for solving the inviscid compressible Euler equations in three-dimensional time-dependent domains. The method uses a space-time discretization with dynamic grid motion. It achieves second-order accuracy in space and time for smooth subsonic flows on both structured and locally refined meshes. The numerical scheme is demonstrated with simulations of a shock tube and an oscillating airfoil.

Uploaded by

Sadiq Sarfaraz
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
27 views43 pages

University of Twente: Faculty of Mathematical Sciences

The document presents a new discontinuous Galerkin finite element method for solving the inviscid compressible Euler equations in three-dimensional time-dependent domains. The method uses a space-time discretization with dynamic grid motion. It achieves second-order accuracy in space and time for smooth subsonic flows on both structured and locally refined meshes. The numerical scheme is demonstrated with simulations of a shock tube and an oscillating airfoil.

Uploaded by

Sadiq Sarfaraz
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 43

Faculty of Mathematical Sciences

University of Twente
The Netherlands

P.O. Box 217


7500 AE Enschede
The Netherlands
Phone: +31-53-4893400
Fax: +31-53-4893114
Email: [email protected]
www.math.utwente.nl/publications

Memorandum No. 1599

Space-time discontinuous Galerkin finite element


method with dynamic grid motion for
inviscid compressible flows
I. General formulation
J.J.W. van der Vegt and H. van der Ven1

December 2001

ISSN 0169-2690

1 National

Aerospace Laboratory NLR, P.O. Box 90502, 1006 BM Amsterdam, The Netherlands

 
          
  
          
    
 
  


 

  
     


 
   
   !! "#
#$  %$
 %
 "
& '(

 %')  
 *! ! !!+  "$ 
%$
  
   
      

  
 
   
  

 


 
  
     
  

    
   
   

 

   
 
  
   
  


   
  
     
   
     
 
 !""# $  %
   
   
 
 
%  
 

  


  

  

      


 
 

      
 

 
 


  
  
 & '

 
 
   
% 
 
  
 

 
  



    
 
         



  
 
     
%   
  % 
   
 (# ))*+      
 



 
    

  , -     

%   %
  

     




  

    
 
    

    
 
  
      
  
   
     
 


  
   
     
         
 


.%/
 
0 123+2 41(*2

   
    

 

               
         ! " #    !   $
 $  %             
        &        !  '
       $ !      (  $
         ')   '     ' 
      &     *         %
    $  *     !  ! 
*        !        
#    '            
                  
  '               
      &      !    *   ' '
   $  $             ! '
    !        !   
    
       ' '     * !
  &    '              
        *  '     
 + $, 
      *  '   !     '! -'   .
   !  '   /01* 002        
  '               
 #    &     3         $
    4 !   3  /02  .' /02
     '      ' '   $ 
 ' *  #       ' !   
            * '   " #    !
    *   '          &$
         * '        
  #    $          
  $        !      
*            #    $
              $    
        4            $
           !  $ 
 ' %*
 
 
 
 /52     
        $            
" #   $  %  (       
    !    
 
 
 
 /62*  
   !&       #      
          & 
 '         '      $
     &       ' ! 4   7   
 !    '! 8    /092            

    


      

 $  *   #  ;      $     & 
     *    ! 4      
(       $           #
      " #    !       
'   <  *   4 !        
 $             7 '  ! 8$
  "  78"    #        
     %     !   %$       
'  !            $
  &       !         *
        %    ' % '!    *
                !   
#      '  !&    '! 8  <  /052*
        '         !  *  
 '!    <  /0:2
  $        &        
  !   $ #      !&  $ 
                 !  
#  (  #  $ #       &   
      $       !     $  
$         !   '!  &  + $, 
              #      & 
 !  '   ;   #     #     $
  ;             !   
             & *         
 &     
.  " #    !   !  '    $
                     $
  (  
 + $,           
'!       *    !  -'  /012 (       
    /5* 92* '            
  !           ;      ! ( 
          '&              
       #   !     !
     !      $     
    &  '          $
       '   #    #    !
 $   *  *  '      (   
           '        
   
          7       
.  :       $        & 
<  *  78"      *  '!       $
 #     4    =4 *      88%4  '   '       '&       !
              ( .  > 

>

   
    

      $              $


  #         ' !  !&     
   .  ?  4           
 $          .  @

 
        
  

   " #    !   $  % $
 .  %  ' !         
   4      '        '  $
  " #    !    8    '     7
               * '     # !  
   A
    *   A B                
  B       %  C      D
C DB A    A
   *             
    %    $   ' !      
!    C  DB       B  * C  DB       B   
 DB           
8 D 
    %4  *    D



B


 
 
 

  E

  
  
  
  E

  
  
  
  E

 E
   E
   E
 


 
 
 




 


  *
*    !*  *       !*   !* 
   !      -         *  0  : 
  !   D 
  8    D 
      
%  '     D

 B  
  " #    !    D

  B 1

  

0

         ' !  D

 B  
 B    

  C 
  

   D C 
      % * D  
  ' !
      D 
   ' ' ! %      

        D  B 
*     4 

           " #        
 #            D
B  0    *    
      

    


      

 
 
  

      
  !"#$$# % &'()$ *#&
-                         
      D  B       $        
     '   $  'D             
%              '!    F * 
  D

F D C 
C D A 
F A


   



   F    '  !  *       
 '        * '  ' ;   ;     
   '           '   !
      !    7       4$
          A D

A  B C
A        B    B    0       
A DB    
 

  C  
C   
1*           
  !       A *      '  4 
G B  0 0
 C   "     A         

      
D
G
  D A 
A B

 D 

    A



        * 0   9*              4$


         A     $       
G          '  '!
 4 *   A B        
      4     A      F  
      B  *        D
G
  D A 
A B

 D 





F      A

  $      '  '!       C  
C  '!                 &$
    $     D



D G
 D  
A  B  0  
   E  0 E  
  

 

E   E     

:

G              


G *   
    

G
D  B  0 0    $       D
G     A 
 DB  B 


   
    

    # !              * 


  D   B A    A
      $     '

'!  !       B    E *  
  B    * 






 B     
                 
    !        

 ' !      '        : <
0    9          $   *     B
   * '!D
G   B 0
  B 
     
G   B 0
 B 
     

0    >

>


=    B 
  *  
  B  *     B  

               ' 
                 '
            '   '! '
     H             # 

  '()$ !$&)#$#++& (*,$# "#$ *# (''-$($#

     


(        ;            "
#    !*        *     
   '      D

   DB D 
      D       I

       D     I



            E          

              
















I




       8'    '  *    B       


    *               * D 

    !  4*              
       # !             

     D 
   D    B 
  !' D

    !             *
    D B   

          &   '  '!  4$
                !
4          * '      
G  '   G D 
G
    
<  *      

    


      

         D

G   B 0
B  

 B 1
 B 0     >

=4 *  '    D 


             & 

D

 B G 


 B 1     >

     '    D 


*     D

 A  B0
B A
  

0
 
 

 B 1

 

 A 
 B 0     >
  

?

                   


      %        !  ' '  
     '&               *
  .  :?  >
             D

   DB     !      

   !   !   B     B 1     >    


 D 
          D

 A     A   B



G

 A 

@



G   
   D 
    )            


4        " D 
     !*
G         " #  
!   G   '! "
   '    '    D
<      *     "    *     
#    D

  




"     



E
  "     D 



 B 1 5

   E 0    '   $  '    '   


         '   5    '&    $
                
           *       .  :?

        


     5  '          '!    
 J       '       

   
    

     4 #   *    ' /0>2    
    '! .'   /2 ( *  * '   ' 
  '   7 '  ! 8   "  78"   * !
      *    $      '
     !     ;   # *    '! K
   /062*         . J  *  3 
/?2 (       '    '    $   78"
         !*    #     ;  
 *                  ' 
(   

"      B  "      "  D   

9

       5   ! J      '   $
               9   ' D




 "     B

 


  "    

   

6

               ' !     78"


     ' '  '!         
     &  A
  B 
     $   *   
     ' !         * 0   >* 
 >*                *   *    
        0     >    !   4         

   D  B 
*    #   :D





0  
B 

 B 





 
 



E  0 E  
1

 A
A 

 


B

 











 LA 
L




 B 0  :

             ! 1 1 1 0  1 1 1 0*   !*
  ' !             # D




 "  


 




B

 

"   

 

"     01


      D  B    *  B  
    B   

<   ' !   '       0 0 


A  *    $  '!
  *       B 


            
A  A
    *
      8 
0   @* '             ' !      
3!  * 
A    
A  * 0    :*         

    


      



E  0E  
    B  0   







*   # B 0  *         B

0  : *     A


  $               
 *   !    D


 LA
A 
 

E  $L B 1

      $         * 0   @*     #
D

 B A  %  A  
     ! %    '!   D % B A& .   $
  
A     
       *        

A   B 0& 0 E %  %   ' ! %4      * 0   @   #
D





  "    
B

 
A  "  





 

A    
A   % "   

00

   %4  A D 


     A B    0    :
(          6      01  00  
    B    *         5  '   
     " #    !  78"  D
<      *     "    *     
#    D

  

  "  D     E




 

"    E


  "



 





 



"  A   A A   %  E

  D 


"   

 B 1

0


   !
(       $   *         
   *              0     *
              (    $
     '           $ %4
     *      B       
  & *   #      (        
%4     ' !   '  *   ! *   

01

   
    

     '    D


A  
A 
 
     

 B 
M   A
 B M   A 

  

0:

                    & %4


 M D 
   D

M   B A   %  
  %  B %             
      D

 

 

"    B

 

 

"     E   

        


      %4    
     %4 ' *         !    %4*
  D

'      B 
B 

  

  
 

   %4 '   '    ' !   
 *   
4      '!        B      %4
'   '          $  '   
   0*    $  ' !       $
 '        %4           
'   $  '  !   $     
            $  %4      & 
N 0:*        0  '    D

 




"   M   A   B

 




"   M   A E M   A  0>

       %4  0>      '         
            &   ;     $
        K      '  '! 
  '&           !    %4  
    %4    !           & * 
        '              +$
 '        %4  M   A
 A E M   A A
           /  E        
%4 '     *     D '      B M   A
 *    D
'      B '      7 4   ' !    !   $
 * '     4          '!  ' !
    D  B     

    


      

00

7!   $  4  +  *      $


* +* 84$<  *  O *    !    /@2*  '  
    %4 (    *
 
 
 
 /52*  
 O %4 '      !       * '
 O %4     ! 4         88- %4
 88- %4    '!  * .   .   /?2    !&
'! 3    /:* >2  88- %4         #$
 !   O %4* '     #          
    88- %4         .  :> 7 $
  '        %4     !    !
        '&       7  !    '&$
                 '! .'*   
 /2      #          
'              $   
       &    " #    ! 
 # D
<      *     "    *     
#    D

 




  "  D     E

"     E


 


  "




 





 

"   

"  '      E

  D 


 B 1

0?

 .+($#& % / 01 "*! -'(#&$# ))$#&

7           &         


         A D 
      
 %    M D 
 D
M  
 A  B A  
  E  A

A
    

0@

 D
G
A  
  B  

 

05

M A   B 1

09

 %    '    D

 A  B A  


  E



G


  A 

A
    

0

   
    

        #      '    A


 
       D

 A 
   B 1

 

0

06

       (    *         $ 


      &  '    * '  #  
              &  7    
               '&      
             '&      
     * !   %     7! )   
 %       '&           ; 
 *               
'          !   #      
                   
   *          
(     ! 4  @    "    
     " #  0?*  0@$06      $
G    '  !*      #     
  "

A
   * 0   ?*  ' D

   A   




 

 A 
  E




'       B 1 1

G       B 0     >*
     %      % 
  # D



G


  

 




 


A
 A 
  
  A
      

 A '      



G

  






 A 
 A   E















 A 
 A
 
 



 A 
E


 A  A
    E


 A 
    A    B 1


( B 0     >I B 0     ?
0

       '        '    $
 '               
     (    !       A
 
  


      
       '  
       
 
 A 
 
  A
       

.  ?0  ?  ;   '   0        !

    


      

0:

      )  )     D




) B
) B




 A 
 A  


 

 A 
 
  A
  

 B ) E ) 
    *   *      $  '* D


*   
   B

 

 A 
  
  A
  



     %4  '  !   * !     
D

!          B


!     B






 A '      

:

 A  A
    


>

        '&      "       D

"        B




 A 
       A   


?

                  


       %4   '&           
.  :>  :?*   !  !   $ #  0  
4    G     ' 4  D

# G   G   B 1

@

G        1    > 0   ?*  # D  



  G  B

       $   D


A
# B  
 E !       
      *   
 





# B



5

   E "        G    *  G 


  

 
 



) A  
  E !          !    

( B 0     > 9

  $        &        $
#  @   4    G      $ # 
     < 7 4  .    <7.    *  
  .  > .          * ' 
 $  '   !             

0>

   
    



 %  


 


    
 







 
  


,


 
  
 

)


     ! " # !$""% %& #  '( &)"% &%  *+ &)
+%", -"# *%)".    !   # &   *& ! ",# +%", ",* *%)"" 
# %*"% " #  ,"%   " !""!! /.  - -"# *%)".  
 #        (          !
 D

*   
   B  G   
 D

 B

 

 A 
 
  A
  

A  
(       B     G   B
   5  
        &     
 (   '         %
    $           %  
 
 * '           #    
    #    %   M       ' 
 ;   '       0?

2 *+-
(*)+*($#

" !   #$   %& 


( .  ::     88- %4          
                
88-        /?* @2  3    /:* >2 *  *
!   $  (        4  
 88-      4    !  
'!                + ' 
    88- *  <   0  88-   
                     *  
   ' '!              - 

    


      

0?

- *   !             '!     


    ! -  O                 
    *            #      
   *   ! (      /   E     
          ! %   # D



  

 
B









    

 - . %
 -  %  - 
 -  %  - 
 -  %

6

        ! %      ;  


                     
    + '
7  -  % * - . % *  -
% *       %4
'            /   E '!      " # 
     ,  +  )*    <   0 N J
   '       ,  +   D

 






  E

 

 

     E

   E  

  


     

 

 

     E

  


G   %   :1

)* D

   E   E

G      



 

  


   E   E

G   %  

  





 

G       :0

  G    B 
A  A    (              *
    D

 B

-

0
- 
0

- - 

 
 



 

   E  
   E  

             B %   + '


  '    '   :1   :0   4   

0@

   
    

88- %4            /   E D

'      B   G   %  E G   % 


B   G    E G    E - %  E - %   E
- %  - %   -  -  
<      D -  % - . % -  % * -  % -  % -  % *
 - . % - . % - . %    !  '  (  ' 
    '    4    88- %4   
         /   E D


'      B  G    E G    - %  - %   E

- %  - %   E - %   - %  

%   E   

:

(      !   88- %4            


   *      - * -  -    '     !*
'      ;     88-   $ * 
!               3    /:2 
  D

- B G B G B G 
  G B 
A    *  G     !      88  $
4        4   - D

- B

 G - G   G - G  E



 - G   - G 

        '    +$        
      -  - D

 B

- G
0
E
- -  - -






 A


 -
 G




::

         * !             


    # D

 B  - G - G  E
 

 B  - G - G  E
 
'     -   
 B
 B
 *   #     
  !     -  -          /02
D

- B G  /  G / 

- B 4G  E /  G E / 

:>

    


      

05

  / B 
&      3    />2     '  
    '   +     * '      !
) ;            :>    
    

" %  ! &


 %4    :  >      '!       
G *   !*    
     0 0     
      4      #     <  
 %4    :  $    #        
              *    *      
#                       $
 %4    >          $    #   
 (
 
 
 
 /62* -  ! 0@*     
#        !            
  &                 ' .'
     #         %4    $
 !      !    -   8 -8  -8* 
   !    '!   8'  />2* #      %
     ' '!               
'         !  *    '!    < 
/0:2

   #       !    * ' #  0 %4
         90 %4       
 '  '   !         #    * 
 ' '! .  /:2* '  '  %4      (


 
 
 /62   '  !&  #   
'  %4     %4      *    
     !  '       #    
    # *  * '!       

3 (4$*$5($# '(

             '&     
                 
(          !    
      <  + $,        -$
' *   . /92     )          
      $        
  ) '           !  '   ; $
 #  '  !          & 
4      ' !             ' 
          '     &    '
#         #      4  $
 ! %   !     '     
 *
 
 *
 
  3 /5* 92 O    
        *        & *  ' 

09

   
    

 -'   . /62* -' * ,   . /002*  ,   
/0@2
     '                
 !     !     !        %
        !      ! '  ' 
       -'   .     
   3

3    &  /52* '  #    !   !  $
      '          
   + !* 3 '* .   3  /@2       $
              '     
   '            
 '        !     '!     
             !   '    $
     &       .       
 !   !        # *    '  $
      ! ( *       
    *  ;        *  
             ! !  $
   *            - 
  !           ! ' ( .  >  
 $ #     4    @ '!   
$          !     $     <7.
      
 '  '   !               
 * '                $
  '   ! '  '     4  + $, 
       7  4         
 '        '!  '&       
'!             '! 3  /02* 3$
 /2*  ; *   .& ! /0?2      
         .  N  P    .NP 
   #    (         '& 
        $             
       #  4      $
    !     $    '&         )
  !              
  &      (  !       
          &          
        & 
 ;     '&      "   ?*   !  
     !  4               
   !  4             '&       
  !                '! $
     !  4 M           

    


      

 D



M        
     B  



06

:?

    4      D

 B  '   

  4 '          ' 
         *    D

:@

  M   

' B         


           4      
:  
        * 0   >           
 :@           4        4  
         !          '& 
    "  '! ?   '    *   D

"        B




B>
B





M          
 





G
'   M        '   0  

> 



M        
 



      D   


 B  &   & B   
    M       

  '&        !          
        #   '   !    
)            *   !*
'      ! '         &  (
          '           
           !        
       D
'  (     !  ( !  )      
   %   '&   4  #    ! 
 '   %         !  4 
 D

M



       B

+  1 
 

B 1



 


    


   E
  



2 B 0  :
  

 
  B  
                * 
            1   D 1 B A    %  E /* 
  4       %4 '  A &     

1

   
    

    
 *   
A         *  %  %  
 !*  / B 
&         +       O 

  !  * '       !*   '  * '
 ;         !   ! 

'  < '             ! 


   !& '! ; *   .& ! /0?2   (  
'   )               
   !D

M         B 4 +           +  


2 B 0  :







B 1
 

  



   

       B





 






1



A M  





E +     &E


 
A  M     

:5

   B  E  E  E              3 *
+ * +  +          #  + B 0* + B 10* + B 01
 3 B 10 <          #$     $
     :5*       '         :5*
  !    '      *    '$
        !  =        ' 
      #$ #     '   
)   %4       #!    

2      




 
2 +*$6$! (*6$/ % '&+!$ $#6($#

  $        &       
 !     $ #    4    G   ( 
     '      #    $
#              '!      
 *  '             &  
   4       !        
   #       *         $
      #      '   '   
          &       
 #      ' $ 
 $ #     $        & 
@    '!        $    D

 
 

 G  
0
B # G   G  
4


:9

    


      

0

        :9   '!     '  ' 
  !       
$* '  #      
!  :9       $     & + $,  
 '     <7.               
 !    O     !  #       
    !          *  * !  + $
,  
        $  + $,    4 
          D
G  
 - # #    "
G 


        G  B "

    5 B 0  


$! 1A  
A  G !  G ! B




E
"
  

$ 1A 
G  E !    E "A  G ! G ! # G !  G    E 
:6
 


E


  
G  B G 


!    "
   - "
G     4    4 
    B  
 (    "


G
      ;    # * G       4  $
               # *      
   *      #$% 7     # B 6 *
 $     # D  
  D # B #*   #
G  * G     7    
  5$9*    G  * G  * "
 0  #  6            # D  
   # D
G  * G        G    ! 
# B # *    G  * "
A   D
G    1
       % 
"
A
1 B  *   4       $       + $, 
  $!    D $ B 11560>?0* $ B 10@:??0* $ B 19:@@:*
$ B 1?*  $ B 01*   &      #   
  ' !         + $,     4
A      D
"
A B
"

1 1 
1 "

A  
    *        4 "    '! ?*  "
&        = *            .  :?
'        4*          ' 
         4          !  4



   
    

 

% ", / ! % $+  # +/  # %! %& #  &
% # +/ %& * " # / # ! #! *" #%- -# #  " ! # $
,"! )** ! #  *", )%  ,"! )**  #%- % # ",#

 + $,   :6  '           $  
+ $,   D

G ! B G 

$! 1A  G ! G  
# 
  
  

 5 B 0     ?

>1

G    $  !     '!  $


'!   G  # G 
A G D    E "
A G ! E A    G !    A  
4  A E "
A    E
  4   ! G  5  9   '  $! 1

!

A
G
"
&      '          >1  $
        #     '     #  G   G   % 1
         !   *         
      
 $  + $,     ! '  $  $
A       
       '  '    1
   $  + $,      '! K* .  
7  /12  $               $
 !       &     ' = $.  # 
A 
( .  >  !&           1
  !    ' !   $         
 $        & 
       #           
                     
     '      <     
      (       ! *     
     *      '      !
  '                 ' 
 '       4 !       ( <   
 4             '   

    


      

 

*","! ** "  !! + # /% #  0012 "&%"*

:

>

   
    



* 0  #  6 *    *     D




DB 
 
B         

                    




 
 = *      # B 6   
B   7 4 
        !      <   :
                    
  ! 4          ' 
       !  #       #$
                   &   
         '     &          
 '!                  
    & *     #    %  %  *
        !   #     
     
<    &            
   *     D

 






  B A     
 DB
    


 0  #  6




4 

 # B 6






         D  

 
       
      D




  B

  

G   

 
  

>0




    
          D  
 
    
  )    D

    B A  


 

>


        
           

       <7.           $   
    &   !  D

G  '
 #$%&# #    "
G      ( #


    ! -  # #    "

)*!      

G     G    E    # "


G 
G    
  B #  "



+   B 1

G  '

 # . 1   #$%&# 0"#    "

    


      

10

L2 residual
L2 xi-gradient
L2 eta-gradient
L2 residual
L2 xi-gradient
L2 eta-gradient

-2

10-3

residuals

10
10

?

-4

-5

10-6
10

-7

10-8
10

-9

100

200

300

400

500

600

3-3 cycles

  %,)  )%+" % %& #  "!* &% # *+ + ! ')",

)%)" 3"%  ", ",* ! +*","! )%+"% 4!5 *" 6 %  -") !!
+ # %&   0012 "&%"*
G  B "
G  E   "
G 

! *  *      ( # "


G  

 "
G    ( #


    ! -  # #    "

   #$%

(       #$%   05$09*      !


              !     G  
  )     '       #$%  
$!
      ! O  !    *    $!  ' ' 
        #$%          
           * '       
  7 4     <   >       % '
 =7-7 110     !           
     *        *     !
 '!      * '    #     
  %     4 !             *
   #    %  %   G  *  0   
      '               7  
          $   !*  
                '* 
  #                 
     " #      

@

   
    

2  (4$*$ (#(* &$& % '&+!$ $#6($#

(           ' !   $       


  .  >0 7   '       # 
 E /  B 1*   /       <  #    !  
  &   ' *    &   7 4  + $, 
 :6     $     
(        *  &*   !    * 
 B  * L B   B  *  5 B 5 B 5     *  

    !   #  & *       #   


  #     7 4  ' 4  D

# G   G   B  G   G   & G  


       &    D

0 E

B

0




E
1

E








B

1






>:

0
1
&B




1


1 1



0 1 1

  B / 5&  5  / -      <  D

G   B 7#$ G  

  8  /1 9   : B 0 .   ' !   $      
   '!     !        # 
  <   G  D
0
G 
B  8 G  
4
L

>>

   8 B  7#$    4     $         D


 B ;6; *   ;   4         6     4
     < 8*  B 1 0    8 (      G  B
; G   >> '  !       ! ;   # D

G 
< 8 G 
B
 
4


  B 1 0 

 !     ! ;   #       $  + $
,   :6*         = *   =    
$          '          
   = 8  0*   B 1 0 I 8  /1 9    = 8  
"
= 8 B 
 < 8 
  ' !  !&  ;     !  $ 
  + $'    +   B /&  +  " B /4&* $
  !*     5&/ ( <   ?       ' ! 
=   0   ?$   $  + $,   :6    &

5

    


      

0.8

10

0.6

0.2

0.4

0.4

Im(z)

0.6

0.
2

10

0.8

1
20

18

16

14

12

10
Re(z)

1
4

0.2

0.

.4

0.6

8
0.

0.4

0.6

0.8

Im(z)

5
6

2
Re(z)

 
%) %& # ",*  467  80 267 4!% 6 %& # 
!" )"9"% %&
 :  ; 0 ! # /"*". !%+" %& # < , +""+*")" , +#%! -"#
%"+"9! )%)" 
 ; 1 07
 ; = 0 4%67
 ; 100 07
 ; 2 2
4/%%+67 % ,"! *%)".

9

   
    

0.4

0.2

0.8
Im(z)

0.6

2
0.4

0.

6
20

18

16

14

12

10
Re(z)

10

0.8

0.

0.2

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.4

Im(z)

0.8 0.6
10

20

18

16

14

12

10
Re(z)



%) %& # ",*  467  80 267 4!% 6 %& # 
!" )"9"% %&
 :  ; 0 ! # /"*". !%+" %& # (*")" < , , +#%! 4>06 -"# %"
+"9! )%)" 4%6 ! # $ , +""+*")" + % , )#+ 4/%%+6

 ; 1 0
 ; = 07 % ,"! *%)".

    


      

6

       ! -<8 '  +   B 0  011*  $


! 7          = 8* 8  /1 9 *  
'    ' !        ' !   $    $
 < +   B 0  + $,     '  +  "  @:  
+   B 011  $    -<8 '  '   +  "  >*
         +        ' !  
4        $  + $,     
   !    -<8 '      $   $
  ( <   @  ;   $     G  :6  
 +   B 0 <  !    -<8 '    '& $
   #   !     $    -<8 ' 
'   09     ' !   $  #   
< ! -<8 '     011  ;   $  + $
,   *  *   '  ;    &  
  + $,   :6    *   '   <   @  
  ' !      $  + $,      
$! B   
     0      5 B 0     ?         
   + $,  *      + $,    
    % !    # !         
    <  + $,    $  -<8 '  '
  +  "  9*   ! -<8 '  #  +   B 0
  ! -<8 '  #  +   B 011   $ 
-<8 '  '   +  "  009    + $, 
  ;    !   '&     !     
1  5  /      #     B +   0 5&/ 
   !          ;  !   
-<8 '    $           ' ! 
    +       ' !

3    
(        !         & 
                   %
            '      
     '! '     *   !  
          * 0   >*         
       #        * 
   '    $           & *
   !     
 
 
 
 /52 
               '   
#  D

'   *    ;   % #       
    I
'   !  *       !     I
'   *         !      
    

:1

   
    

            $         * 


 #  !    !      " # 
7            *     
  $  '*   '            ! (
 4             '   
    

3 '()$ &*(4 )+'*$#6 % *# "##

   '    $  '*       
              *   '   
  $  '  *   *    $        D



A  
A
A
 DB 
 

  B            A
    
 4  D

 A 
 B



G


   A 
 

    4        '       


  ! '    $  '       
   * # B 1  0*   '   D


*   
   B

 



G


 A 
 
  A
 

 






  A 
 
  A
  

( B 1     >
>?

      4       &    * 


 A 
  B 1  ?              
 >? #   4  4     A
 
       .
G   ' $
 '            

G
  *      A
               
(       *   0   :*  # B 1  0*     D

 D G
G  D  




 





E#

 B 
 B 

 D
G  B  0 0     0 E # #      0 0


$   !
   '                
=   
  
                 
    !     '         '  

    


      

:0

          '     *        


>?*   D


  B G 
B G  
B

 







 

E#

 B 
 B 

>@

    >@    '           ( 
G  
  >@   >?    '      
'    4          '     
  #                  

3  '()$ &*(4 )+'*$#6 % *# )(&#$#6

  $  '    $  '*     ' 
     $  '  *     *   $   


A  
A
A
 D  DB 
  B                 
   '   D

*   
  B





 A 
 
  A
  E
 A 
 
  A
 

 

G


 

G  





  A 
  
  A
  E

  A 
 
  A
  

>5

            '! >@ 7      


                   >5   
  #                  

7 
   
  $            '  
  '  '      4 ! (     
        !         (
 

 
 
 /62    $  *  
   *       ' !    $    
  !  !

7 !8& &/), +4 '4*

.J '       ' '*    /@2 ( 


                  
  !       '   *     
      3             011 
            ! -<8 ' +  
    #  16 <         *  

:

   
    

0.2

0.1

0.25

0.5

0.75

 

)"+ + # &% # !" %*"% %& %!?

#%)5 / %/*+

         '    *    0 4  


        #           
               '   
           '          
              ' ' 
(  '#      !      *    
'         4 '  
  '     *            
                      $
     <   5   $    !      
         '        
           %      
      B 1?:0     <   9 - !*    
       '     4    %   
.J '  ' '        ((*      !
          <    '  
'        (   

    


      

::

1
0.9
0.8
0.7

, U, P

0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0.25

0.5

0.75

0.25

0.5

0.75

1
0.9
0.8
0.7

, u, p

0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0

   * %& %!? #%)5 / %/*+   ; 0 2<@1 %  "&%+ 4%6 ! !!
+ # 4/%%+6 %+!  * *%!  )")* 7 () %*"% *%!  *" 

:>

   
    

 

","* ! % "+ !! + # &% )%,",!",", )#*

 

             
 
  
5))
  

 **+)

  

 *215

  
6+))
775)
1+4+

 
*+5))
*48+)
+2)55

7  ))+() &+! % / !$&)#$#++& (*,$# !$&)$5($#

   $   &  '         $
 '           &   
  !        (  *  * '     
       !  $       $  
(     !    !  !  '    ;  
            4   <   
 ' $ %          '  $
    #     911* :11*  0911     
    <   6 .    !
&%  '    '
   %*   $    ;  '        ! 
               &     ( <  
01   $           !     $ 
      & *   '           
-'  /012   '  '            
    
*   '       !  ' 

      !    $    & 
"        !           
  !      $        7 
     *   &      >1Q .     
            *        
   !D    '  !             
               4     

    


      

10

:?

-4
2.5

h
no adaptations
one adaptation
two adaptations

-5

10

-6

L2-error

10

10

10

number of grid points

 

!! + # 

 % " '%- )*)*"% &% )%,",!",", )#* % "&%+ !

                !  '  
  &            7  !   ' 
      ' 0 (         !   '
   7        *   !  911 
 *    <   6   $           
  <   01*   !       $   ! 
         &       
&     !  *          
       $ 

7 &)$**($#6 
 99 ($%$* $# (#&#$) 01

       $    &          
  !  %  '            %
 '    =7-7 110       K '  19*
       '  1?  >?        
  B 1  &   &/ *           /  
      *         #! > B 9&01 
%      '        :*5@9      
*    4 ! 6*>11          
         *        '!  
3          01      /:1 0:12    *
      1?           
                !    

:@

   
    

            !       


 (                  

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

0.7
0.65
0.6

CL

0.55
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3

Angle of attack

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

0.08

0.07

CD

0.06

0.05

0.04

0.03

Angle of attack

 

"& ! !, )%)" % % )"**",  0012 "&%"* 4 ; 0 A7  ; 106

    


      

:5

    *              
     ( <   00  !            
  +  +'               
 !  *    ;       '  '   
   !             '  
       +      <   0  0>*  
 *  

       + B 



 &  
   
       !*   !        
       !  * 4   *      
      ! '              
    ! %    !    !     
 %   *             
 !   

:

  
(           $       
     $        ' % 
!* 4  !     !       $
        $      #  
           $ #    4 $
        &    $      '
    '           
    !  $       $  
       #   4  !     '$
 (       *
 
 
 
 /62*    
          !    $   $
     &        ' !      
 $  ! %


;
# !") ! )%"! % /.  B  5+ 4 6 !", # )%  %& #" %C)
" ,*. )"!7  )"**. #"  "* )%"/"% % # !*%+ %& # "$
)"* !" ""% %% ") #5  * % ! %  B%* 4 6 &% )%!)",
+. "+*"% -"# # %,+ D -#")# ","$)*. )%"/! % # *"!"%
! "+%+ %& # +")* )#+  * % #5 E *! 4 6 &% #  " )
-"# # /"*". *. " %& # , )#+ ! #  ", %& #  )#+7 !
 !"#+ 4 6 &% )%!)", # ))).    #  )# %& # $  #% - 
"**. %! /.   )# , &%+ # #*! "%* % ) /%%.7 -#")#
" ,&**. )5%-*!,!

 <
 
   
 
 =
  
(  7 4   &   $        $
   &       # D



E/
B 1



   
    

0.5

0.5

-Cp

-Cp

:9

T=32.0
=0.5

-0.5

T=35.0
=-0.5

-0.5

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

-1

-1
0

0.25

0.5

0.75

0.25

0.5

0.75

 
!! + # %! % )"**",  0012 "&%"*7 )%% %& ! ".7 !
  )%)"
% # "&%"* &) &%  ; 0 < 4")#", !%--!6 !  ; 0 <
4 ; 0 A7  ; 106

:6

0.5

0.5

-Cp

-Cp

    


      

T=37.5
=0.23

-0.5

T=40.0
=2.0

-0.5

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

-1

-1
0

0.25

0.5

0.75

0.25

0.5

0.75

 
!! + # %! % )"**",  0012 "&%"*7 )%% %& ! ".7 !
  )%)"
% # "&%"* &) &%  ; 0 2@ 4")#", -!6 !  ; 2 0
4")#", -!6 4 ; 0 A7  ; 106

>1

   
    

1
1

0.5

-Cp

-Cp

0.5

T=42.5
=3.77

-0.5

T=47.0
=4.0

-0.5

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid

medium grid with adaptation


fine grid
-1

-1
0

0.25

0.5

0.75

0.25

0.5

0.75

 
!! + # %! % )"**", 0012 "&%"*7 )%% %& ! ".7 !
  )%)"
% # "&%"* &) &%  ; @ FF 4")#", -!6 !  ; > 0
4")#", !%--!6 4 ; 0 A7  ; 106

    


      

>0

  / . 1       !    ! *    
!&           &  .    . 
>   $        &      
#          5  /*  B 0     *     '
   *  '      4   D

 G   G   B & G  


 D

   E ?


 B / E ?  /





?







/
 






?
 
B  ? 







?

?



?  ? 



1
 ? 

E ? E



 



?

/ ? E /

 / E  ?
 
   E 


 
&B 1







1


 







1 

1

   B   * A B   E  * / B A  A * / B    *

 &  
/ B  E   * ? B  / 5 *  5 B  



       '            *   !
           '!           



1  B#7 +")* +#%! &% , !.+") . + %  )! + #  " G%7
#*/, ! %#! 4! 67  
    
 
 7 1H<2A< 4 ", *,7
1HHA6
2  B+7  #!" !" )%"% $" *+ +#%! &% )%+"%* '"!
!.+") 7 # !" "%7 # " ". %& (   "7 , 1HHF
@  B7  *57  +/ !   %7  # )#%") %& - ! &% # 
"+ %*7     
     7 1<<@1<F0 41HHF6
>  B7   )#9" ! 
%*!/,7 ,  )%/" ! "+*")" +#
%! &% )%+ "/* " )% ! /* '%- 7      7 @AFA 41HHF67
!%"I10100=JC)#1HHF<FH@
<  B% %7  # )%+"% %& # /%!. ",* %& )"+ !&%+", $"
*+ 7  
  

 7 <@<H 41HHF6
=  B/7  , ! #  B7  %/*+"!! *"+" &% #",#
%! , !" )%"%
*5" +#%! 7     
7 1111<0 4200167
!%"I10100=JC)#2001=F1A
F B %)5/ !  #7 B , *%)* %C)"% !" )%"%
*5" $"
*+ +#%! &% )% "% *- I
* &+-%57    7 >11>@< 41HAH6
A B %)5/7  % !  #7 # , *%)* %C)"% !" )%"%
*5"
$" *+ +#%! &% )% "% *- I # +*"!"+ "%* ) 7    7
<><<A1 41HH06
H B %)5/ !  #7 # , !" )%"%
*5" +#%! &% )% 
"% *- 7     7 1HH22> 41HHA67 !%"I10100=JC)#1HHA<AH2
10 B %)5/7 " )%"%
*5" +#%! &% )%)"%!%+"! %/*+ 7 " 
B# !  )%")5 4! 67  
    
 
 4 ", *,7
1HHH6

>

   
    

11 B %)5/7
 "!5" 7  #7 4! 67 " )%"%
*5" +#%!  #%.7
)%+"% ! *")"% 7  
    
 
  4 ", *,7 20006
12  " 7 "+*"$! )%!%!
%!%. +#%! 7
>><>F@ 41HAA6

       7

1@ 
"**! !  #7  # ","$)) %& #
 &% '%- )%+"% % +%",
+ # 7   HH0FH@7 @F# % ) )") ", ! (#"/"7 %7 !
41HHH6
1>   /%7  ) %& )% "% " $" *+ '%- )%+"% 7
 
  7 >2@>@F 41HH>6

    

1<  K7  %# % !  9 .7 %,) %& # !" )%"%
*5" $" *+
+#%! &% #./%*") )% "% *- 7   
 
    7 @=F@A=
41HH<6
1=    #-7   !7  #- !  "*%")#7 @  )! + #  #.!%
!.+") -"# # -"! !" )%"% $" *+ +#%!7      

  7 A111= 41HHA6
1F   %" !  #7
%+") )% "% *- &% '%- %/*+ -"# +%", /%!
" ! !&%+/* + # 7 ! #" "+) % %* ") )%+"% 7   
   
 7 F1H0 41HH=6
1A B %-"7  %7 B  7 )"+ +#%! &% #./%*") )% "% *- 7 "
  
 

  
   
 7  55" #  * 4! 67
FH 41HHA6
1H   ! !   ,# 7  )"+
*5"J*  3 $" *+ &%+*"%
%& # " %5 3"% &% +%", !%+" %/*+ 7      

 
7 H112= 41HHF6
20  * %7  "5 !  5" 7 "+)) " %5 )*)*"% -"#
+*","! ))*"%7 "     


! 
    41HH@6

  &% '"! '%- "+*"%7 "  B# !  )%")5 4!

    
 
 4 ", *,7 1HHH6

21 # )#-/7

67



22  #5"/7   ,# ! L %#7  - $" *+ +#%! &% )%+"%*
'"! !.+") I D # )%+ "/* * ! " %5 3"% 7     
 
 7 1>121H 41HH16
2@   %!7
7 1HF16

 "   


!   
 4") **7 ,*-%%! *"K

2>  #%+ !  %+/!7


%+") )% "% *- ! " *")"% % '%)%+"% % +%", ,"! 7    7 10@010@F 41HFH6
2<  %%7  ) !   7  %"% %& # )%) &) " #  "+
%*7 # $% 7 2<@> 41HH>6
2=  %%7 &  

% 

  
 
2! !""% 4 ", *,7 1HHH6

 ! '  


    
(

2F   ! , !   ! 7 " )%"%
*5" $" *+ +#%! -"#
" %%") *%)* ,"! $+ &% "" )"! )%+ "/* '%- 7     7 >=FF
41HHA67 !%"I10100=JC)#1HHA<H0>
2A   ! ,7   ! 7 !  B%* 7 " )%"%
*5" $" *+
+#%! &% #./%*") "* !"K"* 3"% 7 "
%!% #%! I #%. ! 
*")"% 7 !"! /.  %%7 *- )!+")J*+ /*" # 7 - E%5 ! %!%7
 HA<100=7 4200167
2H   !  !   ! ,7 )"+ !" )%"%
*5" $" *+
+#%! -"# !.+") ,"! +%"% &% "" )"! )%+ "/* '%-   )" '( 3!7
/+"! %       
 420016

You might also like