Challenges of P2P Streaming Technologies for IPTV

Services
Yennun Huang,
Yih-Farn Chen,
Rittwik Jana,
Bin Wei
AT&T Labs
180 Park Avenue
Florham Park, NJ 07932

Michael Rabinovich
Electrical Engineering &
Computer Science
Case Western Reserve
University
Cleveland, Ohio 44106

ABSTRACT



 

    
! " #$"&%#'(
")+*$,*-./ '(01
2"&#"&34)5"768*$9:.;1("<=?>A@B
"C1/ %#D'(";'E%"= &%

F 11.G2IH"J;KMLNO.C 

#3.GHC
21
P.
2"/HCG

<C 2#Q32?*$,*4./ '( 1
2"&#QR
"37" A>A@BS"1/ %2#D'(";'E 11.G2IH"J'7 /3"<=#"= 
HCQ1
2A 
T"&+")U
2 2IH"JT."F

<D
2 ;2'% VD")
;HW$HC
"+1/ (1&X;"&U("";7Y;2 #Q83'7 /3 1
##Q3
% O/1/ZKU["&'\
]
;3^H+1"21#
D

<X*W,*_./ '?R
A1V
2"&#"3?)`"68*$9a.;1$W% b
1 #
"&#3HC
2?

".
#JF")c >A@Bed<1/ %#+'(";'\HCQ1
f"C
]."&
P#2J;
")U #"1/ #g;h"?.;2"i(1A <]
2+% ".#21J;K

Keywords

68*$9^=*$,*e^&jW"&U.%"& 2IH"J ^=[MGk ^=lP2#Q'(R

 ^m@./ '(^9D"Rn"&RI>D'7 2

Zhen Xiao
IBM T. J. Watson
Research Center
19 Skyline Drive
Hawthorne, NY 10532

2
}. />A@B"1/ %2#S2IH"J;("4#=V;"|1"&R

D"F;HZ..R"0% "/KwX] 0 '(#&^ZBg&
V@; /
o 0wUGx+68*$9.;1<rX.+[e% .R"R
RnkD&
% "
2"";
o[MGk+r]kO8HW"J;^c 2!
2(8HW"J! 1
2Q1(")XBZ
.R
@ /N1"2. ")X P.'7 ##$'% ]")C
<"&
#Doq"&"&2 #hr
.2 VA
2/ Rn
+ 2! F# &(;'% D")#"1/ #$;"P.;2
"i?1Kc
W.2 VM
2/ Rn2.V= e
2c/
2 e
<"&
#
1";; &= "_ "+)5";"T"&|'7 2!1";2K

2C"
# "+
;2%?"i(1$"<;hX &= <"&f 
".R
W")#"1/ #1"&/Kg6Ig.=  C9O"RDRn>]'7 2 oq9OD>Ar
#% .3D)5"#"1/ #=;"X.VG"i(1^HC
1V
+]A.%
;"?1"&G"?
2]12"&'(VKG@;21
P f6*U9.;1A"R
;A1"&'(A
%2#(1" 1
2"1F 
!9DD>\1/ 2 %2#QR
c;  HCQ

2# <U1"&'(.."&( 
&Q #

'7 2 '(+oq>]DlTr$1
22"#"&3K

w;HWP1 }1&!68*$9p;"t"";yY2 #Q83_)A


/ # %#"/HC2#2J%

HC;
T")c
2A;HDD O



;"]21";D%M <&KU"O"<;h.i?1c%
2HC

)`"G68*$9t.V1$)5"G/ 1V
(
"&'(&^.V1X"<;$ X2.

9OD>U   1=' 2#Q'(/ C3'

<MH"J;M#J=G1/ <R
%2#X#;."g^
2DJ&37Qsm21O
2 
D1#G1/ P.#1V
S'(";()`"' S1. #z/|;"0"&K{68

#$1#
! %#0"|HG <1V
ysmVP"& '(HC
}
23_HC.
a"^
'7 J;2!
2T3' N/ #z/ <"a")A
2T;"{; #D.
"&
%"2
;X"
2+
"&'(&KWjW"'(
"?. &"
#g1/ %# 9^
"&W'7 /u"c && ; &$")
68*$94.;1M
2 M68*$9"<;
4 #'("&2#'(Q/N;'% +")X9DD>\"& '(KPD"/H&/^
"<;2P9DD>)5"? P# <&7;2'% V+")G;HW 1V/ =.3
Qi(12#QW1
2"&#"&3(1

##&G"F% "
(3' 
?2V8H"JR
2f."1K0@2 ".P9OD>i(1;#Q3N"&{68*2V8H"J;


M%  X./ <1V
"&21W)`"$Y2Q."'($'(&KMg"]'(2#'(
9OD>3'f^m
2?.'(2#]."&#"&{/1 A N
;R

#1"221"&|"S./ '
271";;"S/ 1
|1#/K{

'(
";]1"&.2'( G.'(
"&2g '("2g")1"&#Q3+%2 
;HC

2 #/ c"] )5"Y
#I3./ ')`"c
21#/^&'7 J;2
Q/ #Q3N'( "..%2#()5"? f.;17"<;hA"T.=FY
#QI3
./ '(D"]# D 
21MHC
#C&2 <+"b2C <^ ^
QnK

IPTV Workshop International World Wide Web Conference, May 23, 2006,
Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom

D2+."#"&f"
+"%2#'")c
&
T2#"/3'(C 2P'7 R

2 21 1"]O"7. ( V.Rn"Rn ?o*$,*$rX1"&'('21/ <"
3'fKf6I{.21
{3'(^M
N.oqqK &K^U r+;V/
f  .
2 2?2 .1
<A C% "
1#O 
F.=^83R
1/ ##Q37
"2&
F P 22#1/ <"P"<=# 372V8H"J KeLt
2 A2.V
#"1/ G  +)`"' "
G2.V/^
2O"/HC2#"= 2


2 ]1#Q3T% 8HWf
IH"(HCQ
2"&+&"27
"&&
S
1. #X.V=/KL}
2#f/ #Q3_*$,*E3'(? f'("#34./

1.

INTRODUCTION

6I2""1"#9poq6*U9+r]"&'(.+"T"sm ;H 

2"<& <=G.")m1V
"&1W 2?1"&."&#$"&c
2QW9t1"&/K
WHW"7'7 <u8"]vK @mK2#1"&'(' 221/ <"&f1"'(
2^ wUGx+y 

9Uz"g^

/=C1#Q3F 2"221/(.2Qb
1 G;='($"
2# 17
271"2 #{
Q?2V8H"J;HCQ
|b
% "1
1 %2#c)5"G#&2]'7 ;368*$9}1

2#c"].h #212R
"'(K]@'(#h <D;='(;X 
T;V] < #."F

2 R
 7~c"& D 2(wO. K$lf /u"C1Q& 
g^)`"G '(2#&^
#Q/ &;3"<D
2
Rn. /72IH"J$HC
21V
 ##"/Hy12"'(
""&% f;h"?"<=C68*eK

)`"b2#D"<HC#"= &2^;1#3
2X

/=C% 7.& #
Vsm".
"S2.27
2A .R"RI + 2"& 1
T".2 ".O#=./ '?R
 ^] <n^]^+Q&V^]Q] 
49DD>./ '(2^Q ^] /n^
<nK0
F*W,* 2"= 1V
4 /="h
7#"<3'(A"&%2#'")
68*' 2#Q1/ A.;17 AHW## A
?% ".#1J! <A
2?;"
.V=K
O"/H=V/^<O*$,*f. '(2=d"/HC#"& &O# .)5"'(g#J=
@;J3  Q/^2+"&JcQ</M@HG <'(1/ AQ/<M"2"G1"2.C

1"&2. ;+")$

V#327.;1 )` .21?.21
0 

 1 
1Q83S") 11.+8HW"JfHCQ1
2?oqK KA>A@B{"+1/ %2#
'(";'FrV^Z"+
( /& # %2#?
"2&
2+")G. '(2.=K

.A1"&. D' 2C% ] J&f"( 11"&2Of6*U9..R
;1F;;"2'(]HC
P*$,*;"T./ '(2T1"&2#{ <R
 < 
 / # %2# 22#2J%

HC;
0")W 1
0 A 2f"<=.R
#"& &(
2G>A@BPHCQ1
2K$$3?1"&.h2+
2X22#Q32+.R
HW"J})` .1^DH0.
2"/H

P221. a8HW"J
1"&
Q"2^Z*$,*};"(.
2 2FD 1
##3f

'?)`2#ZRW

<D^
.2A*$,*N./ '(2D.#Q$)`HW;2'% VM")m;HVUHC
"
1 P1=A&"";TY
#QI3;"&^
1"&'(
</F"? ."&#"T2R
( 1. #zSjW"&.Rn>].%"&RnkDIH"JTonjW>Dk+rVK

DG")
D
 GG"& z/P )5"&##"/HCK$LND <.GHC

!"<=VH")U# /SH"JT"0*W,*y./ '(2F.;1&^m)5"&#QR
#"/H}%;3 }.";21V""N
f1V
2 ##2F")A*$,*\68*$9
.V1Kwp*$,*2V8H"J'(";#DP %2#.
2a
2 #h <

#?"A.2?
X1"&2. ;$")Z.

<2+HCQ
2F A1"&'('2Q83

PP #"1/ #e"i(1&K
2.

RELATED WORK ON P2P STREAMING

SERVICES


.1"
&
2#&
g."&'(c");
2c'("M "&2# M*$,*./ '?R

?.;1C

X <+.211.)5##Q3f#"/3"&
2]6I;V2/K
m &!&
 D <
2 

4/ #2SHCQ
HC
"&#b2#?"HC

. '(24."&#"2^]@;H '(1/ f2.F
!*$,*8HW"J"
=.3S# <&b2#+"F.'7 ##Co=,<rD
1J=KvO.F)`".R
H ."c1".1"&Po[M~WjGr1";^=@;HG <'(1/ M 
"&'(#Q3
Y;e2 1J=)h"&'
W'7 1
2

<c $
2"O
W1"R
;/K$@HG <'(1/ G
%#G2.$" 1""  + .%/
t"|"<f)q f"/HC2#"& &"<=%"= %2 
_2IH"J;K

!"&
#@HG <'(1/ 1V
2"#"3}Y;Q/}

b
#% 
)`2##Q3?"/HC2#"= /? 
?1";/ % )`"
b
#c1"&# % G2.ZK
X1;#Q3^D"&+kDV8H"J;g
2 .";1/+@HG <'(./ '(2&
^
HC
1V
##"/HC0. '(2_"T"&..&{2# 3%
1J}")?'(/h
b2#K}
('(/ 

<(2.(1 4HG 1
;"&HC
#f
3
<A##Z% 2("/HC2#"= /mKOQK
 5g R]+"&J;CO>D#&.3|1V
2"&#"3

2FR
2..3m Xb]1"'('(1 #g."&#"0%2 ./T"TT1"&'(2
1"&21^=HCQ
?"<=VX]'(##"&2";$.&/ 
?=/ <
8HW"J_i(113Q/<K+"&J;O'(2#"/3F N.1S}")
*$jWf 
}.&^OHC
1V
a#&P1"&HCQ
a {

t#=#
")W8HW"Ji(113T 
T1. #z/T1"."&#qKD6IfS#R
V.3^g1"&]+#&/T"P 72.]2"]"&2#Q3T)h"&'
.&
HC
(QA"&2 ^M% #.")`"&' 3S'% ]")8HW"JR
1"&21/1"&'(
2 X #."(
2 <&]1"&O")e
2O/Y2/
1"&/K
2(+"&J;c3'3
'(1 ##Q3!"'(z#R
V.3 )h"&'-'7 3 *WjW$ 2'(/h O.=U%3 1 1
22+1"W <

W=V.3+/W")2
2$2IH"JmKe
2M1/ <M2V8H"J+i(113
& 2X")W/"7,'(G"<=C. &"
# "= 1V
K


2$+"&J;;O>]#=V.3]1
22"#"&3A'(2#"/3Z.=V #;%


R
HC
f
2 = 1
2Y;K
| q0/`I !2+"&J;.=VO.1
2/2#A1. S'(R
 S#= ?"s Rn / J!
2"&"S.'(""
|"&%

R
HCh;
P &A"<=G
A2 3K
| e/` F`/`<20Z;< g0+"&J& ##"/HCM G1#;
"" !' 2#Q2#1"&21"&]".= #c.&D"VR
Y;+.'7 ##U
<.+.'2#Q 2"2.#Q3K7lP""<=/^e
2V.R
H"JFHC##e "'7 1/ ##Q3P"&'(zAQXY;C"?)5"1
"&?
2G1"&'(2MHC
21
(

/=
2G#/ ;2' % c")Z
"&2
HC
P1"&&/1"&21"2K
g; f
e SM+";J;$)`"'( f# /3N1/ 1
2
7HC
21
P/ 1V
1"&'($1;2 b
#]2 ..GQC"F"
"
2VHC
2"O2/AQc eHW##qKM6Ic ##"/HCc.'(""
"<HC#"= &
)5"22.7HC
2#T/12{
S'7 
("t%

R
HCh;
)`"O6.@*G X 
F1"&C.&K
gmgc RA@J3 
( f)`f*W,*-9U"&68*.;1&^UHC
21V
#."
 "X;"?1"&)5212(; 
]2.+")U 
2QRn2 .837#2Rn
)`"'@;J;3 fQK02@;J3 ? ##"<HC(@J3 ?2.AHCQ
f1"&R
21/_HW% 1/ '"|'7 J=T;h"{1/ ##;h N
0@J3 f1#/K

2(3'p
2  P&2 ##Q3!)q /=" %2#(2 "&!)5"H"JR
24 1"&.PQsm783 7")8HW"J1"&21"20oq1#
;R
2bHG ##O 2kDw$Cr$% 1/ .+="&1+2 1J=C ]"/%;3

2X1"'%2/2.V")Z
2G)`].J;"(.")h8HG <+ 2#1/ "gK

2D1V
2"&#"3THG A.2/f"F.22 ".]"&2+ 20"
2
&Rn"&4.;1.21
_ ?.

<2K{6I?
2 ?%2#Q.Rn++@| 

1"2 #Q3! & ]"7
1
<2P%2 2HC
! 20"Qz
'#Q#/42  0 11"&#Q3K6I7 #."N"<;1. #z/
%

;HCh;
!1"&."&#c)5" .
2 /01"&21V"2K7
('# "
1
2Q1V+.1/ #X" .22 ".C# &A"&2C")M"(,&? 
1/ ##qK
A2 Z<; N N ;2 KA
] O./ 1
0#Q <R
 "&N*W,*./ '(KvD2#J= ./ <1V
0

<A1"&R
1. <G"&P#=.37"<=X "<=V#h 3F2V8H"J7")e +oq&K K^
Q/<5rV^CHWT1"&.h*W,*\#&.3_Q1#Q3_"&(
2f
3.1/ #
2V8H"J] 
] J=c"X 11"2g1/ 2 1Q83]#'(Q "2")
c2R
V#32F2
3.1/ #M8HW"JT)h .1&KD1"2./Y221
")
22H 2"= 1V
a
!2.
;

<T*$,*#=V.3t")
6*U9-D'("&#Q3P% 2b21 #HCQ
S"2A>A@B{"]1/ %2#'(";'
1"'('2Q83^U 27)5 17")`.'( #"N.1/ #h %2#Q83
HC
2"&2f 1".(1"&'(' 22QKDV)5/ !( #qK.7
1".RI"b7 2 #Q3.7")+ !'( 0. '(20.;1T2#"/3/
"<=S 4 .R"RI {o*$,*$r)h .21V}Q/<K
3a #."
1"2.(
f#'(1/ 
1Q83_ (H##O ?
P
"&2I3
") +!
? 2 #Q3.K7
27 
#Q3.A.
2"/HC]

<+HC
0
2
" 021=F)5"f
<.1
_ V^O
0.V1
"<;! 1V
=0'("|"b2/K68 2"g^A
24 
#Q3.
.
2"/HCA
2"/HE P.;1(";VA1/ !'7 '(zQ+=;2%;3
1";."##7
 '("&C")U21=C"sm/P"( KCO"/HGR
=V/^]
2QS 
#3.Sa2"T1"&.T
!%2 
;HC
y1"&R
. C")M
]22#Q32)` .1+#'(K
3. CHALLENGES FOR P2P IPTV
SERVICES


2V! <S.= #D1

##&F)5""<;2N6*U9.;1^
."&'(+")eHC
21
T +"#2/% #"<H+K

 / E
5hV f;<`& @"'(f6*U9.V1 <
 "</?"<=c
2C2%2#1C682V/^&HC
2VC
X < # %#O%2 
;R
HC;
1/ F2212 D3
'(1 ##Q37O"2IH"J(1"&
Q"2K

$'7 J=cQi?12#Qc"+"<;C O# %#DY
#I3")m.;1
)`"U68M./ '(2X..."&2^&HC
21V
'7 3A

/= X#"&2D R
"N 
T/Y2Q.&Qb
1/ ;+ '("&]")$2V8H"JT%

HC;
gK
O
G68*$9y.;1G <+#=7
"&2
F 1/ F.R
HW"J ^;.21
(  ]1/ %2#&^;>A@BP"Ub
% $2V8H"J 1"&212A/ 1V


"&'(&KN~c=4."^U."&1f ##"1 "&)5"?9DD>.;1? 

."&1 .
2 2?HCQ
T"
D 2#1 "&oq.21
S X9U"&6*$rWR
'7 2X 1

##&&K
A M/T
`g/5& wXAHWF.12..| A
2(% R
2")e
2O
 /^
*$,*|1
2"&#"&O
2 <&D% 1"'(]  "2#h <
2"= 1
()5"W.1/ # %2#D#=.3")m'#Q'( D1";;/Ke68

1.X%"& &%2 2
2"'(]2V8H"J;( 1
2Q1V&^
2+1"'?R
' 21 "&|% IH4IH"S6*U9;H'(
. /=V.F

#"1/ # HCQ1V
]oq.21
( W#"1/ # 1 %2#X
2/ 2rVKM>D 
2+"&

D1"2. C")g
2O2IH"J ^QG'7 3F 12 ##Q31 .D

;'% U")g6*U9a;VHW
2 W1/ 7% X.22 "./ZKLt
2#OR
;"&]H"J0
2 ]"/!*W,*a1
2"&#"&A!'#'(/ FR
#=.3^;"2]'7 /u"G1

##&+W" V.)5"' A&""&O 
#3.
")
D. 1Qb21D1"
Q"&HC
2D*W,*. '(2 1/ F21/ .

+;2'% V")c1"&21.C;HK
wX2"
2T1

##2&NP
2"/H"_""_1"&'(.."gK:vDR
1"&'(../F;"1/ F J=+ A"&
%2Q=+ '("2")e8HW"J
%2 2HC
?"+. .'(Q/KMO1#Q3^= "&W1"'(.."&F #"R
Q
'(X
2 /=]% f=#" /"?/21]
A '("2C")c%2 
;R
HC;
N1"2.2'("&gK
.;21/ 2 1QI3!")W>A@Bed&jGlfC@
HCQ1
2 U#'(Q/+ gHW##
oq.M
2UwUGx+!BZ
V@ /]"u81
C 7 '(#<rVKUj V)52#m#h 2 //?" .1/ #D
2X..R
;1]"?'(##"&2C")c12"'(K
V & /` N 55` 5& 68"?"N21" 
;HW$"+'7 J=
2QU..R"&(% "/U"$"
W;HC2;1
/ # %# )5"+*W,*y./ '(2^m."'(21&D'7 3f%  &=
"0 HC
2"02#"& &|;"02 < S"S"
2 )h"&'
Q
"/HC!..R"&0% "<K @;"&'(*W,*a3'(D.21
N ]A =m &  

/lP2# . 2 .1
<"&S#=#D"]1QVd< <"T3'(
" . 1JF
]1"&.%2"&f")M/ 1
f V/^

P1"& + 
"+1"&.%2G%3 &;2+
2
2$.;1C"Q83 "D
2".C 
HCQ
{'("(1"&.%2"&gKFO"<HW=/^.21
{3'(A 7Q

""(1"&'(2# 
P/ #1A"X=.3F/ 3"% +1V
/ /P 

'(../ZKC$g".].FIQ.R)5".R <F1=+'(1

.'
"4=V!5_sm1=#3}."
2  PHCQ
a
2&

2#"= (%
2HC


/=C1".. "&
2A
2&
F"<HC#"= &(%2 
;R
HC;
gKD[2"O6*U9-.;1^Z (3':1 0 &"&] |8%2#.Rn2
1=f'(";#HC
2P
f*$,*E #&"
'('(#'(/
0
2.V+20% "/S") 1
N6*U92./K
2?1=+2"
=(2#1Q#Q3??
2U1/ .^ 
(*$,*{.
2 2+$
22)`"'
;HWK{6n1/  #."!.P tnHG <0%
.4'(";#$HC


"&'(72.V1/ |.&42{)`"(*$,*.
2 2S")OQ;h"S|".R
]"7 /=
]'("
2#Q3f%##qK
2 '("2D")W /;2+1"&#h
 2 "& 
2G '("&2M")m%3M% 2]2#"= /A)`"&'-
c..R
"(% "/K$D2G1

##&X?
X*W,*{6*U9t.;1O$"]b2

" (21;=GHC
1
(1/  <.. 1W'("G "2#C".
2 X%2
<C
2+ '(]'(]1/ .+
]=;2O)5"X
2D6*U9.;1
"</K
<2&/5&2 A2 M`2 q!Mh20 / @./ '(2
1"&c'7 3+% 1";/ 2 1"'(...+ O"&V .3
1";2]"U&Q #&
M'7 
'(oq>D]lTrg.1
2'(&KM
R

<|
Zg 
)5"&^; O "&g1"&%#"1VJ;g)h"&'y& <"&2g g"&

2$23+)5" X" .3 6*U93'U D&.3Qi(1#QM .J K
wO#."^68*$9.= 
72# 3W2.+ A" .37. '(2
""1"&#"TV1

2 <2 
{1"&."&#W
7./ '(2S%
 KTwD2f*W,*./ '(T1"&'( "2]"S f" <.3
6*U9)` .21W'7 3+.)5UHCQ

W./ '(O""R
1"#K$wXG A.2#Q/^./ '(#.G'(2#'(; <"&7")e*W,*4. '(2
1
2"&#"&3"? O"&V .3 6*U9)h .21V.1V
 M
2
lP1"&.")`D6*U92# .)`"'O %2?1

##&&K
68F
2]X")M
2+
 /^H+)5"1O"P
2+.1"&2P1V
2 ##2+R


<U^= 2 #Q3zG
28HW"J1"&2Q"&2MHC
(*$,*!. '(2
1/ _21V/ .P
P;2' %  ")];HW?HC
2"01/ 41&f&"";
Y
#QI3!")C;h"P.V1^M1"&'(2 /S"T P1;. #z/{1#.R
.=VO. '(2?'(1V
2 2.'fK
4. NETWORK MODEL FOR IPTV
SERVICES

wO.
2"/HCy&_&^]"4./ '(2.=VT !"= <R

2z0T8HW"#=#]RG F#"1/ #U;".;2F"i?1 HC
1
01"&R
.P") |1#P")./ '(2|.V=P"P"/7"4.=
;HCQ1#Q3 
7
<"&
#coq"G"
#`r"i(1HC
1
F1/ 
.%2P;""0#"1 #C.;2N"i(1%
."_2
 "&#1!"!"&-'7 
mKLN|1"&.N% "
;"t"VR
'7 24 
4#=f%"& &1/ /K~$ 1V
_#"1/ #X"i(1f1"&21V?"N
.W")m>A@Bw]lHCQ1V
W"W1 %2#X'(";''(2 "&?3'
onjGlfC@2rGHCQ1V
C
"&&
"&1/ #b
% VC1/ %#KG~U 1
fHCQ1V

1"221 f1"&'(' 22QI3T")C68*$9.V1(12"&'(VA
"&&

8HC/;Rn
QX1"2 CHCQK
w1"&'(' 2I3F1"&.+") ##M
2"&'(OHC
21
0 1"&21/f"

2 '(f>+@BwDl"jGlfC@4HCQ1V
ZKa
222#2J;Toq".
R
#2J;rg")2.;1W"&eA
2W#"1/ #"i(1$1"&21"D
<"&
#
"i?1c%3A
2&
RI. / "1/ #b
% e2IH"J;Kc
G
< '(
2.F
"2
2"&C
2]2  O +.
"/HCffe %2#(&K
OZ 0M`T + x  &W Z<Zc
68A
2Ub2c

.W") wUGx+{"<u1$Bg&
V@ /Z^/ 1V

2"&'($
##"1/ </0,&,&%2C"<HC#"= &T%2 
;HC
NoOy},&,&%22r
2}<%2?2#"& &|%

;HCh;
ao  <%2rVK4BZ
.R
@ /2.U
CwO#1/ #m&+6.@w]l[MGkoq>A@Bgw]lTreHCQ1V
Z^
HC
21

2 0,<%2T"/HC#JtHC1
21/ 
1I3-oI:
,=+rVK|~U 1
[MGkHCQ1
1 1"&21 _+j$R8,Sb
% V "
?.;1+"&Xf ?#"1 #e;""i(17o I & ,<&-%2rVK

=+.8I
 
 
 I
 I
F
F
N
P
[
W

\
_ `
7
_"b

.=
/=
 U= <

 Q
A/+
 = <

 && Z/+
 8
   m
&  !
"= ? Q#%$&'U=Q#)(* Z %+ ,.-0/213*/  + 4
5
3 
  
=C /n !6
7& ? Q#8$9==Q#(: O
 .;  I8<Q=
=A
=G8
&
 >=&Q#<?@
;I
h
/D

5
+D =A  B<C  =C4 
5QCD   
=C8
E G&IQ D=. B<;
/ 
QG=}
=
C= &H QAC =V7  B< IQJ=.88<
Q& K
L<  QH 
I
E $&I8I/&
& :/#<
=Q
  1 /WII8<
QCX84 E<I Q D =.  B< ;
/ 
QG=M
   
=C /n !5 Q#< m8
E G &I8 QO  A  B< ;
- E<8
C/CII8<
QCG
 cIO
9/c
E = ; / &I
;C$QnU
=0 E = +  QC<
 cI ;
/ 
QG= =

;  :/ =8I%
E Q)M8
==" /II Q
L(A

5.;OR /
=D
7E<D
=) ?
/. I P QWQ8W

Y NZ  I Y N.(5;
/U
S  DTVU6WX$  ID
R8

/
 E Q)M8 QG
/+
= DDC/. E& /H h /y8 I= H h /D =V.  B<L ;
/ 
QG=a= =G

;H  X/+
=
Q* /&= I ? ]D  . E = ]I4 EQCD B< ;
/ 
QG=a= =G

;H  X/ &88< E Q)M8c &=" /II 
= D =.  B< ;J]^S =2 GW P ;
a =G

;H  EQ)M8H ]I  E<0 E = / h /y;IH 
Q
=C+ /+G
= L;
a =G

;H  EQ)M8H ]I  E<0 E = / h /y;I Q & /+G
=  Q' ;
`{
2< 0?


C.;1"&VDoq&K KcwO#1/ <# &@;]r( D#"1/ #
;"]")`R
b21G1"2# 
2?1"&21VU 7+j$R/&,Ob
% Xo F ya/=+re"]2 R
"
#m;"A.;2"i?1KU
2OHCQ1V
 1 
1Q837")e A..R
;1U"&Ve X#"1/ #"i(1$M,&&_%2KekO"c

e F  #."
1"&2. 2/%3]
W" #
"&&
2e")2
./ '(O.V=
P #"1/ #g"i(1&K$wO F '(2#&^;"2]23T ,,<Z.
2"/HF

<
f]*_*c"#h AlfB|&F+, .=VO22 Lt
"/HCO.&
,&^G1"b2&4HCQ
_
#X,;K DOzf68# cD"_"1.."^
=y")mDwDl: 
 )`"&GjW"&'(2 &YAvD#Q. A@2jG@;6W<^ &AD*$l


.J;&^C

 !'7 '2'
"2&
2(")(/%2Ka6I)+
#"1/ #G"i(1
2  f1#2 ")A/T.21
|.=^U F e
d/=
%2KW~$ 1V
T
&
RIb
"{oqD>ArW1

2#g.O=lp%22C%2 
;R
HC;
_ 
|/ 1V
 22 ;RIb22Q"&ton@>+rA1

22#2.(,&l
%2O%
2HC
ZK]~U 1
0[MGkEHCQ1
S].&/f"7.22 ".
"P=,1"21.C;VHgo fd/&,&rVK
5.

NETWORK CONSTRAINTS FOR CONVENTIONAL IPTV SERVICES

g"F"< (&"";;RIY;2 #Q83T68*$9-.;1&^ 
+)5"&##"/HC2f.R

HW"J|1"
"2('% '(/K|[eQ/^$
2"/HC2#"= _%2 
;R
HC;
f"
2+
"&'(]' 2C% + O

F
2+O>./ '(2
 <&N i
hkj K@1"
m^
2S"<HC#J 
_22#2J4%2 
;R
HC;
2e")
G>A@Bw]lTdjGlfC@AHCQ1
' 2g/ 1
A% W %2#$"X.2R
 ".V
 f01"&21.+;HVN 1"'('2Q83mOI hlj f0 

I hmj fmKD
2QZ^2
2A" #'% X")$1"&'('2QC.=/
%3P ?#"1/ #M"i(1AD% "&
/P%3
]" #M"/HC2#2JF
"2&
R
XS ?#"1/ #M"i(1& F hon I hpn f j " n } F  q go f j rVK
["&.
Z^W
f'7 '';2' % ?")]1"21.7;VH7.2R
 "./P%3F #"1/ #e;h""i(1A n f K

G. i(1G"?
22#2J;c")Z ]#"1/ #2"i(1+oq% "22/%;3 F Or
 2D"0
 ;"P.%"&0 "&#13S2.S%3S !68*$9
.V1+"</KU" 21D
2O#"& &P"
]
<"
#g"i(1^
 "2#h <T;"f N.%2/}"#"1/ #A"i(1T4"s R
  J
"&KM68
U1 .&^ ?6*U9t.;1X &'(. <"$1/ 
2#3! f.%"&N "&#13!HC
?
2'("&A "&2# A;"&
<X < # %#G#"1 #2;"]"i(1$."O

M
G2#JM") #"1/ #
;"?"i(1XHC##"C% 1"&'(+ % ".#21J K
6.

NETWORK CONSTRAINTS FOR P2P

STREAMING

6.1 P2P Sharing within a Community

"T.'(2#Q)`30
27.12.."&Z^M
2(1"2.  2 #Q3. 1"&1R

. "&#3"&72"2Rn".R8 ## 1/ .&K$~U 1
7   AQ#Q3
)`"'Q
2A
2(.V="  KP
2? .J!")C.;T;h"
./ '(]"&! P*$,*a2IH"JT1/ 0% .
2 /0%;3f.= #U K
D"/HW=/^=
X 
#Q3.$./?
C1/ (% C/ .#3?;
/
"{
2T1 .SHC
20 {;HP1/ t
.F") {;"{)`"&'

2d<
2X C"O2 .C)`"'
2+#"1/ #;"?"i(1+.&/K
[eQ/^;#/ 1"&.*W,*{.

 '("&2+ $HCQ
2F +1"&'?R
'2Q83K687
2G1/ .&^ '("&2fF1"&21.G;HVXP 1"&'?R
'2Q83H^ r ` oqqK &K4J;%|;VHr ")O
'HC##C&V(;h"& )`"&'
 cHCQ
2?
2G '(G1"&'(' 2I3^ 2
 f0str ` HC##&$;"
)`"'.V=KO*W,*};VHO&D"()`"&': XSO1"&'?R
'2Q83^."]
X2#"= /*W,*{"D. i?1X j r ` Kc
)5"&^

2T" #O. <i(1S& a%3*W,*\.

<2|)5"P
2T."
R
#2J;Oo"/HC2#2J;rc")Z +>A@Bgw]lTd&jGlfC@HCQ1
(G, r ` KM68

1/ .&^
21/ 2 1QI3_")D
P."&
;% "&22#2J;fo"/HC2#2J;r")
HCQ1
{']% ?/ V
2 S
2?.'")". '(2
. i?1{go fusMr ` r j 1"&'(20)`"';h"N.V=7 24
P" #
*$,*;". i(1^m, r ` j K
["'-
C % "<=C.12.."&Z^
2)5"##"/HC21"
Q"&$' 2 c% 
 b2/)5"D"";TY
#Q83F68*$9.;1
<
7
I h go fsvr ` r jw , r ` j dgo f w r ` r j
dMfmo wyx r j
<

I h go fsvr ` r j dMfmo%
s xrj
F h n go fVsyr ` r j^z " n _ F q go fZoO
s x r j rI
{
d
f F X q go fZoO
s x r j rI
n f7e
D=}
01/ .}22#"& &}. i(1^D*$,*.
2 2|HCQ
2a
1 "'('2Q83O'7 /3]"M'7 3]"M% U)5/ .%2#Q)2
W"<HC#J+%

R
HC
0") F>A@BwDlTd&jGlfC@0HCQ1
!]
 % ".#21J K O"/HGR
=V/^*$,*y.

<f1/ .]
2 #"& &N"0
2#2J;]")$
2
HCQ1V
] D.
"<HCS0jW"&. A,KX
2)`"&^g*$,*}.
2 2
)5"]68*$9HCQ
2S ?1"'('2Q837HC##e

/=]
'("D% 2bOQ)
%

;HCh;
+g1"2. /+"&]
U2#2JO "."&+")2 G>A@BwDl!K

6.2 P2P Sharing in a Local Office

BZGW
271"2.VX*W,*.
2 2 '("& ##m GP A#"1/ #

"i(1&KN68{
F.1"&241 .&^cH1"&.?*W,*"S.


'("&T ##;HV .&/N%3! P#"1/ #"i(1&KLtQ
2| f1"'?R
' 2I3O
^ r ` ;HVFP ##O
Q;"&()`"' FHCQ


  '(1"'('2Q83P 2|
 r b ;VH]]
 Q"+
<.
")g
Q;"W)`"'\ VW7"
2V1"'('2Q^=HC
2Gr ` w
r b dmf x KM
c'7 '2'_. i(1U]
2c2#JO")2 >+@BwDlTd&jGlfC@
HCQ1
"11FHC
2t/ 1V
a") 
v
 r b ;HP&PQ
;"P)`"' A"&.(A1"'('2Q83K?"T'7 '(z 

1 
1Q83")c #"1 #"i(1&^H+%2 # 1]
2D".
2 2. <)`R
b21F '("&f | ##1"&'('2QK7Lt
2| |/Y#%'

2 A% S/ 1V
/Z^/ 1
N1"'('2Q83fHC##U22#"& &}
 r b j %22]"
"
2X1"'('2QG 21&K
 r b j %2)`"&'"
2C1"'('R
QO)5"]*$,*};"(.

KC
;2^2
2]" #e;"(./ '?R
"<HC#"= &7. i(1OF
O2#2Jfoq".
F#J2rc")e HCQ1

go fVs}r ` svr b r j %2G1"'( )h"&'
2D#"1 #"i(1+.&X 

r b j %2C1"&'()`"' VXT"
2O1"&'(' 2HC
#+

2#"= P. i(1A<
 r b j %2C"(.2 ".X OP"
2VD1"'('R
QKC
2V)5"^mT%2 # 1&^

]" #. i(1A"P
2A2#J
")M
2]HCQ1
fAgo fs}r ` s}r b r jw , r b j K
["&'
27 % "<=.1.."&g^c
?)5"&##"/HC2N1"&2. ; '
% + <b
/"&
< +"";TY;2 #Q83F.;1&
2 
~
I h go fs}r ` syr b r jw , r ` jw , r b j
dgo f w r ` w r b r jh fmo w}x r j
2 V

AI h go fs}r ` syr b r jw , r b j
dgo fs}r ` w r b r jh fmo
s xrj
F h n go fsvr ` syr b r jw , n r b j
d n go fsvr ` w r b r jJz "
q go fs}r ` w r b r j
n F 
{
d
f F q go fs}r ` w r b r j
n fe
["&'
1"2. ^e1/ .f*$,*.
2 2P '("2F 
1"&.U ##;1"'('2Q$oqqK &KM1/ .<
 r b rg21V/ .e
U. <)`R
b21+"&% "
P
]2#J 
7
2+"<HC#J;X")U >A@Bw]l
djGlfC@?HC1
g^&%2U21M
2#"= ?"&
G2#J")Z D#"1/ #
"i(1&K(@"^gQ)C F ]
% ".#1Jm^ 2#Q32*W,*a1
2"&#QR
"3 )5"$ c( ##1"&'(' 2M")Z D#"1/ #2"i(1GU% 2Vb
1 #qK
O"/H=V/^
=Pf
2C1/ .^m f68*$9.;1"<X1"&#h
2#3!"
 1"& .%2"{1
22"#"&&oqqK KT1/ 1
2
"O2#1/ "&
rC"(.%A;"b2#X)h"&'
<"&
#e"i?1
"
2#"1/ #W"i(1+"21
2?#"& &!"!
?2#JT")

#"1/ #C"i(1K@"^*$,*.

<2! '("&0 ##G1"&'(' 2'7 3
"X% ]/ZK
[ 6.2.1
"&'
27Bottleneck
2 #Q3.?")CObservations

2F % "&7
71/ .^UHW1 4V&

])5"##"/HC271"21#2."2
$* ,*1V
2"&#"3_(.)5#XHC
."'(f")D
2f8HW"J
#2J;(_>A@BwDlTd&jGlfC@_HCQ1
2("7#"1 #D"i(17 <

2D% ".#21VJ K
6I)DI?
P% ".#21J ^*$,*-.

<N"(2"(
2#
% 1/ 2.C ;3A c.

<]21 .M
2"/HC2#2J]. <i(1

") >A@BwDlTd&jGlfC@(HC1
gKc6I()q 1V/^Q$HC## /21C
2

'% ")M;HVC
2 X1/ f% ].=ZK
6I) F F
2T% ".#21J ^X*W,*.

4 '("&|;VHGR
OT ##1"'('2QG")U #"1/ #e"i(1
#2G"?/21

2(#"= {"&| F KPO"/H=V/^c)X .;1F"<1/ 
2#Q3P"
2X1
22"#"&&X"7.%2;"?b
#C)`"&'

"
#$"i(1"f
(#"1/ #"i(1^U*$,*.

T'7 /3
2"C% +//ZK
6I)CAIE" F {A
2(% ".#1Jm^e*W,*.

<2PHCQ
2
41"&'('2Q834/21
2S#"= y"}
202".
t#J}")
P>A@Bgw]lTdjGlfC@NHC1
4 2NQA#"1 #"i(1&KP68!

1/ .&^*$,*{.
2 2+HCQ
2F ]1"'('2Q83
2#U"+/21

2C#"= &("?
2.C1"2&/(#JKeD"/H&/^*W,*{.

<.R
0 1".(1"&'(' 22Q21/ .
 "..%#QI3|


I "? F  P% ".#21J Kf
)5"&^U*$,*.
2 2
1".1"&'('2QD.
"&#h02"+% ?2.SHC
NAI"
F ]
2 % ".#1VJ K 6I) F2 "&2 #U".VP")hR
b
1X"<=#"= /m^2 68*$9a.;1O"<;h1  2#Q3
1/ 1
22^&#"& &A%
# 212^= 
+"
M1"M.%2"&
1V
2Y2e"O/1
2#"& &?"&
2G2 "&2 #2"i(1&Ke68

2g1 .&^
2cZ#Q.#W""C% 2bm"O 2#3D*$,*T;h"
.

1
22"#"&37)`"X;VHX '("2 
"
#Z"i?1K
7. CONCLUDING REMARKS


2FJ=3N1V
2 ##2"0"<;F*W,*6*U9:.V1? F
2
Y
#QI3_")A.;1&^C.1/ #h %2#Q83^X1"&'(.."&1V
2Y27 

./ '(#. <"A")*W,*f./ '(HC
A"& <.3]68*$9
2# <.)5"'(Kc6IF

 /^;HO)`"12."&7
2O.1/ # %2#I3P1

#QR
#2&KE@1 #2|
2S2V8H"J;|)` .21!") t6*U9
.;1+"(.=A T1/ .7'% ")c1"&'(X22X
/ ."&
%2#W1"&e.1c% 1"&'(g "&+"I3]"G
2c6*U9
.;1";VKM*$,*S./ '(2X1"2#% 1"&'(U"&W1"2"'?R
1/ #."&#"&T"?
+.1/ # %#I3T"%2#'fKWD"/H&/^
"O
3
.
2"/HC

 *$,*. '(2T'7 3! 12 ##Q3{"<=#"& &{>A@Bw]l
djGlfC@7HCQ1
2C 
?
2V)5"X/1O
O3'1/ 
1I3K

2T1"&
Q"2F227HC
21
t*$,*\./ '(2{1"2#% b2
6*U9.;1+";VO <A.1../P
+
 V/K
 ./N"&S
2
3^ HW?

/=?.&/0
(lP/ =O{*$,*
 ./ '({ #"Q
2'fK
2f #&"
';
 "N'7 '(z

2D% 2bG")e*W,*_.

<2HC
#+'(2'(z2  "&..%2#Q83F)5"
2V8H"JN1"2"&gK!>]?"S
7"& .3N
7")C
2
lP1"&.")` 2 2# .)`"'f^&
G <"&F.'(#'(R
 "f1V
2 ##2K
[2"()5HW"J ^"N
#?= & #2 %#P.&
7 24"
 #2 "&].&^ HA2# f"F2#"/3P
lP =OT3R
'/ #]6*U9)h .1KL{S #."{HW"&#h}#J=f"
2#Q3f.= #g& < "&O"?
2 lP/ =OT.=D 2P1#
#"Q
2'(G)5"O)`.
C"&'(z/ <"&gK

8. REFERENCES

Q @;'("f@;
2Z^+TwKD2 ^L| ## 

Je / 
 "&^
J 525@
0XV V  .
4 5
m  g 2W 
Z)

A 6 ' 2
.= ' ^
T*M"1&K
")e
2+68~$~U~_6I/ #
jW")8K
DTlP#Q'( (jW"&'(2 2T@;3'f^O. HG ;^
D "^ j 
& ^
&2/=;^
2gKm/L 2&/;K
,<A>]1+wKg g^+TwKO
^
@'("f@;
2Z^ A'
 5;
X  ;.C 
> nV Z) 
A 6 '
V'
/ ' V & <
 Vm ^2P6~U~$~@;3'( "&.2'E"&
wX22#1/ <"2X 2F
]68Aon@wX68k]},&=rV^Z,&K

 <A>]21+wAKg Z^2+TwAKD

;^
gDK
>]"^>lXV &OV
X  ;
G
N. . 5^
f68~$~U~&"2 #"
@#1PwX XfjW"&'(' 221/ <"&g^2@; 1 #g68..2D"&
wD 1SD&# /3FkO8HW"J ^ ,&K
<
 2(D"^]3"&2H"&f@
g^&'+"&.^2>]"f"/HC.#3
%  %0=p 4 `;t
 ' 7U 
LmV / V^

L}L}L /,<
g^2W22  /^2O22& .3^2,&;K
/ @;)5 S@ "&Z^
*eK].

D2'('7 &q^2 
P@;=P>K
O%%2#&^ 7 ;' (V  Q0 V V%

7 V`;2
= ' ^ T*M"1&K2")UwXjGlTd&@*c6~"&SlP#Q'(
jW"&'(22? 
FkDIH"J;2PonlTlTjWk =,rV^m@ T&".&^
jw^v+@wA^= ;2 .3f,&&,;K
<~U=#+9$#"^29O#"7wX#'(h ^ L| &DlPQ ^ wXz
W /"&^m@;
;
"2 &g>^ ]V  
J  VV y
  6 D
. 58
N. y  ^
6~U~$~6.lL &,;^Z,&=,^
gKm&/<R/K
/A+fwKD2 ^2lP"&2QOwK2e  "&2q^ >D 6 

g= 8 . 5
m  g 2' ^ fW"J="7[2
/^
D&lf YAoq/K rVc] 
% ""&J7")c9Oh"?>+ < %2 .^
jWXjt.^
,&&,;K
<<
 2RnO
jW
Z^ @ u. 3P K
O "^2 2O2gZ 2X^  


 8
.= '  ^2P*c"1K
")UwXjGl
@6.+lf~UX6.jG@P,&^ gKmR<,K
<<
 2(D"^]3"&2H"&f@
g^&'+"&.^

>D"&
"/HC.#V3>^ XV &OVu
WA 6 ' 8
 5;2
mV /

XV5 ' G
0  g 2^
T*M"1&K2")M68~$~U~_6I;/K
jW"&)IK
"TlP2#Q'(/h ~c "foq6jGlf~C &&rV^m,&&;K
QA K>].


^
l!K2 HG ( 
PK2] 1 R8lP"#2 ^
 5; 6 G
N. V OV' &XVK
 ) ^
@; )5"P2 < %2 .A"2P1
21/ #m ".on,&VR8,=rV^
wO2K2,&;&K
Q @mK2 2qu8&^ $"&%2%3W
2 . 1

<qu^m 2fjOK
+"&'('7 23.^     V<
  ^

*c"1&K O)MwXjGl@6+jG+lTl,&=,^ *cQ..%2
g^2*mw^2,=,;^
2gK2,=<R8,<;K

Q<,/K
& 2".q^
> K
DQsm"Z^
?K2&"
22."g^
l!K2A  .
"J ^

PK ""#^00V  C  D  5;8c &
V ( 
^ P*c"1&K2")M
+[2"&.
T@3'( ".2'\"
D  <2(@3'(G>].&f 
F68'(#'( "&Z^,&^
gKm/&<R8,;/,;K
Q/< jW
"&DDJ& .hO 
*M %2#"(X";&z&KkDIH"J
jW";)5"]Bg @1/ # jW";;C>D.%"&ZK26I
6I)5"1"&':,=K
Q lf /3 2JF H ^
X.
2J=.
f>D.
22 
&^D1V"
] <1 R8lP"&#
;%
^ 2 . nV 
8
XV' 8
 5;
N. ^2PwOjGl@;6.+jG+lTljW"&'(OjW"'('21/ <"&2
X;H+^
& ;
<.3^
,&^ ="#qK
^2gKZ/&<R&/,;K
Q</wOHG <XwO#Z] '? ;^~cXLK
W 1VJ ^ D2##h 2'(
vX="/3Rn+##/A^ l0 6 

)   L
V'
/ +5Q
%LM ) =^ +@;k+lTjt,^ 2ZK2=/R&K
Q/<8
.   D:V@ %=l @ X .  

Q</
  0HH  9  &
Q/<8
7=
0H 5= &
Q/< l!K2O)52 ? 
fwAKD %%P 2fOK2W

<= /& ;^

)
  6 < V' V
( . 5
 ;V^Z1V
21/ #m "./^ j~cO68w]@F,=,/R8&;^
*c2]vO2=.Q83^22,&^

.g dd1Q.V/K /K 2.ZK /
d .1#<d<
2)`/ &=,<1"&"b/K
'(#
,< " X H V '
& D nV 42.
7 4. ) = 
 7. V'
/ ' 8