Tashiding HEP Raft Design

Given Data

Symbol

Value

Units

1 Column Size in X direction

1000 mm

2 Column Size in Z direction

1500 mm

3 Raft width

6.65 m

4 Raft Length
5 Required Raft depth

L
dreq

34.25 m
925 mm

6 Raft depth Provided is OK

dprov

1900 mm

7 Grade of Concrete

25 N/mm2

8 Grade of Steel

Fe

500 N/mm2

9 Raft reinf. Bar dia.

25 mm

32 mm

10 Column verical bar dia.

11 Reinf. cover

75 mm

S.No.
a

Column loads
Load on the column

ID
D4

Loads
Unit
10052.619 kN

Load on the column

D5

9932.688 kN

Load on the column

D6

7689.647 kN

Load on the column

D7

7118.72 kN

Load on the column

D8

6548.52 kN

Load on the column

D9

5067.93 kN

Max load

Pu

10052.619 kN

Total load

pi

46410.124 kN

Fig-1
0.5
0.75

7.96

6.04

6.04

5.25

0.5

7.96

6.65

34.25
II

Calculation
1 Check for Punching shear
1.a Effective Depth of raft slab

mm

Chech for Punching stress at section taken at d/2 from column face (Cl.33.2.4.1 (b):I.S.456)
1.b perimeter of critical section
1.c Total resisting area
1.d c =0.25fck

5000d+(4*d*d)
1.25

1.e K=(0.5+c)
1.f Ratio of shorter side to longer side of column c

1.1666667

0.666667
2
1.25 N/mm

1.g Permissible shear stress = Ksc

1.h Punching Shear

2
5d

6250 d

-1E+07

925 mm

1.i Adopt overall depth

1900 mm

2 Check for development length in compression area

Development length
Ld <= 1.3 M1/ V + L0

Ld

38.83929 * p/pu

st
4 bd

39 =

DL in compression
Pu

10052.619 2.105548226

Actual embedment provided from face of the

column is
3 Raft analysis as a whole
3.1 Calculation of eccentricity along Y-Y axis
C.G. of Area = AiYi/Ai (About point B)
3.1.1

3.1.2
3.1.3
3.1.4
3.1.5

16875

22.5

-6822.381

bd

As per Devedas Menon

1.4
1775 mm

17.125 m

Area ai = 227.7625 m2
AiYi = 3900.433 m3
C.G. of Load= PiYi/Pi (About point B) 15.47332 m
Total vertical load of the column Pi =

46410.12 kN

PiYi = 718118.6 kNm

Eccentricity = 1.651681 m
Moment = Me=Load x eccentricity = 76654.73 kNm
Ixx = 22264.97 m4

3.1.6

Upward pressure = Load/Area Mey/Ixx =

3.1.7

Pressure at any point at a distance y from C.G. area

=
Table-1

262.7241 kN/m2
203.7654 +3.4y

OK

Point

(In kN/m2) Pressure

Width of
slab (m)

Loading
(kN/m)

17.125

262.7240675

6.65

1747.11505

16.625

261.0026474

6.65

1735.66761

12.645

247.3001439

6.65

1644.54596

8.665

233.5976404

6.65

1553.42431

5.645

223.2002634

6.65

1484.28175

2.625

212.8028863

6.65

1415.13919

-1.355

199.1003828

6.65

1324.01755

-5.335

185.3978793

6.65

1232.8959

-8.355

175.0005022

6.65

1163.75334

-11.375

164.6031252

6.65

1094.61078

-14

155.56567

6.65

1034.51171

-16.625

146.5282147

6.65

974.412628

-17.125

144.8067947

6.65

962.965185

Figure-2-Pressure load diagram in Y-direction

2000
1800
1600
Loading kN/m

1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
-200

Table-2
Moment (kNm) for full Moment
width
per meter

Final
moment

Required
Area

-121.3246017

-18.2443

-18244301

24

Moment:At point K

8484.888394

1275.923 -1275923067

1623

Moment:At point J

9962.192194

1498.074 -1498074014

1900

Moment:At point I

22082.22247

3320.635 -3320634958

4110

Moment:At point H

23588.35679

3547.121 -3547121322

4378

Moment:At point G

36629.47179

5508.191 -5508191247

6637

S.no.

Moment location

Moment:At point M

Moment:At point L

Moment:At point F

28697.61926

4315.431 -4315431468

5275

Moment:At point E

31021.12972

4664.832 -4664831537

5678

Moment:At point D

19807.39689

2978.556 -2978555923

3703

Moment:At point C

22819.87513

3431.56

-3431560170

4242

Moment:At point B

-217.9124043

-32.7688

-32768782.6

42

Moment:At point A

1.13687E-10

1.71E-11

-1.7096E-05

Max. Area

6637

39800
34800
29800
24800
19800
Series2

14800
9800
4800
-200
-20

-15

-10

-5

10

15

Figure-3-Bending moment diagram for Y-axis

3.2 Calculation of eccentricity along X-X axis
C.G. of Area = AiXi/Ai (About point B)
3.325 m
3.2.1

3.2.2

Area ai = 227.7625 m2
AiXi = 757.3103 m3
C.G. of Load= PiXi/Pi (About point B)
5.9 m
Total vertical load of the column Pi = 46410.12 kN
PiXi = 273819.7 kNm
Eccentricity =
-2.575 m
Moment = Me=Load x eccentricity = -119506 kNm
Iyy = 839.3523 m4

3.2.3
3.2.4
3.2.5
3.2.6

Upward pressure = Load/Area Mey/Iyy =

3.2.7

Pressure at any point at a distance y from C.G. area

=

Point

Table-3
(In kN/m2) Pressure

3.325

-269.644 kN/m2
203.7654 +-142.4y

677.1753424

Width of
slab (m)
6.65

Loading
(kN/m)
4503.21603

2.575

570.3911519

6.65

3793.10116

-1.431148867

6.65

-3.325

-269.6444802

6.65

-1793.13579

20

Figure-4-Pressure load diagram in X-direction

Pressure drg
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000

Pressure drg

0
3.325
-1000

2.575

-1.431148867

-3.325

-2000
-3000

S.no.

Moment location

Table-4
Moment (kNm) for full Moment
width
per meter

Final
moment

Required
Area

Moment:At point D

Moment:At point C

2143.796715

62.5926

-62592604.8

81

Moment:At point B

5602.348837

163.5722

-163572229

211

Moment:At point A

36125.11009

1054.748 -1054747740

1346

Result

Reinf. in X-direction

32

Prov.
Spacing
(mm)
150

Reinf. in X-direction

24

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

1623

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

1900

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

4110

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

4378

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

6637

32

100

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

5275

32

150

ok

Reinf. in X-direction

5678

32

100

ok

10

Reinf. in X-direction

3703

32

150

ok

11

Reinf. in X-direction

4242

32

150

ok

12

Reinf. in X-direction

42

32

150

ok

13

Reinf. in X-direction

32

150

ok

14

Reinf. in Y-direction

20

150

ok

15

Reinf. in Y-direction

81

20

150

ok

16

Reinf. in Y-direction

211

20

150

ok

17

Reinf. in Y-direction

1346

20

150

ok

S.no.

Description

Required
reinforcement

Prov.Dia.
(mm)

Provided
Reinf.
ok

Node

L/C
255 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)
12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)
14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)
27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX
29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ
256 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)
12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)

Horizontal
Fx kN
44.402
0.696
12.781
0.642
2.488
15.268
19.169
37.947
14.5
68.618
16.171
70.335
4.777
62.87
2.688
68.842
3.284
64.363
1.195
0.002
14.565
30.672
16.105
22.904
4.695
15.439
2.77
21.411
3.202
16.932
1.277
70.335
55.377
0.639
16.194
0.665
1.052
25.752
40.206
34.288
31.398
98.617
32.931
81.488
0.62

Vertical Horizontal Moment

Fy kN
Fz kN
Mx kNm My kNm Mz kNm
493.215
0.624
14.719
19.133 372.906
59.072
3.229 234.024
32.501
3.659
187.515
0.014
14.365
51.265 115.393
42.625
4.434 170.223
3.411
3.889
2769.295
6.536
16.219
3.848
0.879
609.325
8.801
16.611
7.59 170.362
5067.93
23.005
0.588
17.158 254.224
4646.203
17.655
17.192
36.686 244.108
3983.458
22.279 281.299
52.727 198.989
3462.486
19.154
18.133
9.234 650.867
4125.23
14.53 280.358
25.275
207.77
4893.766
8.868
46.407
34.472 560.678
4065.335
14.648 326.707
54.524
6.807
3414.12
10.741
2.25
22.928
558.04
4242.551
4.961 375.364
42.979
4.169
3232.189
4.946
36.675
32.163
560.15
2403.758
10.726 336.438
52.215
6.279
1752.543
6.819
7.481
25.237 558.568
2580.974
1.039 365.632
45.288
4.697
4279.363
18.421
16.768
47.791
64.908
4003.195
23.725 204.738
9.633 198.713
3829.326
18.388
17.709
75.244 341.851
4105.494
13.083 203.797
17.819 208.046
4435.216
9.825
45.876
71.125 174.408
4090.006
16.456 231.006
0.656
7.152
3872.67
9.784
2.78
82.669
171.77
4217.88
3.153 279.663
10.888
4.514
2773.639
5.903
36.145
73.433
173.88
2428.429
12.534 240.737
1.653
6.624
2211.093
5.862
6.951
80.36 172.298
2556.303
0.769 269.931
8.579
5.042
5067.93
23.725 375.364
82.669 650.867
58.139
1.781
5.904
2.534 398.192
87.84
42.825
109.41
29.178
3.412
12.967
1.736
1.627
5.673 123.419
120.956
38.137 111.872
4.684
3.894
2703.543
9.574
12.656
1.425
7.56
1662.137
15.037
13.901
17.196 195.432
6548.52
36.917
39.836
23.657 304.488
5169.049
27.396
24.784
21.966 234.239
5344.224
80.924 163.161
53.94 239.496
5308.583
31.671
38.954
15.885
721.42
5133.407
21.857
99.423
16.089 247.685
3968.106
11.689
10.128
1.664 585.948
4187.075
78.599 183.099
41.631
6.222

14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)
27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX
29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ
257 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)
12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)
14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)
27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX

84.643
2.536
82.119
0.011
84.012
1.905
12.732
31.367
51.598
32.962
22.713
0.581
25.869
2.575
23.344
0.05
25.238
1.944
98.617
52.242
0.448
15.284
0.544
3.222
21.339
27.176
40.949
21.204
84.431
22.278
83.195
5.504
73.53
4.161
81.262
3.571
75.463
2.228
3.4
21.088
40.082
22.394
27.759
5.648
18.094
4.016
25.826

4142.522
3923.554
2345.98
2564.949
2520.397
2301.428
5223.256
5383.963
5254.376
5093.668
4035.865
4236.749
4074.764
3873.88
2413.739
2614.623
2452.638
2251.754
6548.52
204.075
93.661
69.191
160.098
2864.297
1881.516
7118.72
5450.086
5807.37
5939.866
5582.583
3990.333
4436.937
4602.558
4155.954
2271.755
2718.359
2883.979
2437.375
5611.947
5887.094
5778.005
5502.858
4192.659
4536.592
4400.232
4056.298
2474.081

17.033
49.877
5.944
72.854
11.288
55.621
27.45
75.297
31.617
16.23
11.756
71.565
16.965
42.844
6.012
65.821
11.221
48.588
80.924
0.405
0.211
0.146
1.328
0.447
2.25
4.046
3.723
3.49
2.751
2.984
1.279
0.987
0.063
0.354
1.01
0.719
0.205
0.086
3.412
1.643
3.062
4.831
0.89
1.321
0.452
2.663
0.621

27.84
145.132
2.534
175.505
20.246
152.725
29.916
166.115
33.821
102.377
16.543
186.791
21.424
148.824
8.949
179.198
13.831
156.417
186.791
1.603
26.919
2.596
38.464
7.508
15.011
33.779
25.1
5.28
28.946
59.326
8.858
29.116
13.667
51.641
4.353
33.621
9.162
47.136
23.908
19.134
30.138
73.18
7.369
46.433
15.156
68.958
2.864

5.938
45.905
2.518
42.485
5.083
45.05
25.733
13.304
12.118
24.547
6.373
9.164
10.647
4.889
7.227
8.309
9.792
5.744
53.94
52.063
0.759
14.812
12.269
0.57
16.941
26.267
41.461
20.103
83.489
21.925
77.238
0.284
78.949
1.994
77.581
0.626
78.607
1.652
3.24
35.737
38.788
6.291
21.362
19.26
23.073
17.549
21.704

608.627
16.458
590.484
1.686
604.091
11.922
95.488
238.918
391.693
248.263
173.788
5.499
196.468
17.181
178.324
0.963
191.932
12.645
721.42
389.959
2.748
121.092
3.524
1.932
185.29
275.037
247.922
216.733
687.981
223.327
587.837
7.019
582.041
1.223
586.678
5.86
583.2
2.382
74.719
215.801
365.34
224.258
184.537
8.184
178.74
2.388
183.377

29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ
258 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)
12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)
14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)
27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX
29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ
259 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)

3.715
20.027
2.083
84.431
51.136
0.327
14.938
0.52
4.915
23.503
42.627
27.262
33.71
95.465
34.493
69.332
6.882
84.077
7.862
72.281
3.933
81.128
4.913
16.176
33.478
52.027
34.725
15.035
6.593
29.779
8.152
17.984
3.644
26.83
5.203
95.465
50.95
0.228
14.931
0.47
5.298
18.979
20.522
44.723
16.144
77.558
16.691

2818.014
2681.654
2337.72
7118.72
198.445
119.096
75.035
193.438
3355.981
1770.451
7689.647
6389.852
6294.633
5913.585
6008.804
5331.639
5212.616
4736.305
4855.328
3318.05
3199.027
2722.716
2841.74
6241.761
6383.844
6061.676
5919.593
5146.524
5324.128
4921.419
4743.815
3132.936
3310.54
2907.83
2730.227
7689.647
197.136
135.258
70.794
181.996
3431.115
3190.677
9932.688
7709.587
8108.46
8182.713
7783.841

1.59
0.184
2.395
4.831
0.388
11.143
0.069
15.233
12.414
5.588
27.004
21.138
34.975
22.069
8.231
18.04
35.337
19.204
1.907
10.591
27.888
11.755
5.542
21.52
39.883
21.687
3.324
18.518
41.471
18.726
4.228
11.069
34.023
11.277
11.677
41.471
0.592
2.821
0.296
1.893
2.862
5.129
3.4
3.43
6.105
2.01
0.665

50.938
10.651
64.453
73.18
1.192
61.516
0.315
90.344
16.343
12.394
5.925
3.309
78.559
6.171
69.08
22.727
116.79
26.304
67.759
12.921
106.984
16.497
77.565
5.118
113.153
4.362
103.673
24.988
160.032
24.043
111.001
15.182
150.226
14.237
120.807
160.032
2.866
43.941
1.816
50.711
13.461
2.43
23.836
15.629
33.66
22.508
71.798

18.917
22.731
17.891
83.489
11.495
8.275
1.794
1.514
1.037
2.222
1.777
12.373
11.351
15.216
8.508
18.799
10.856
15.687
13.967
18.176
11.478
16.31
13.345
0.731
0.396
3.574
3.239
4.247
3.827
1.136
0.716
3.625
3.205
1.758
1.338
18.799
40.445
26.995
8.317
4.244
0.774
21.831
31.585
23.266
57.662
73.802
7.125

7.024
179.9
3.547
687.981
386.526
2.148
120.076
3.429
18.419
192.782
316.802
210.39
250.864
717.273
256.019
552.161
24.406
607.418
30.851
563.212
13.355
596.366
19.799
109.35
249.326
397.533
257.557
152.486
22.484
207.743
32.773
163.537
11.433
196.691
21.721
717.273
384.688
1.722
119.602
3.279
4.508
182.102
266.391
248.513
211.046
674.738
215.179

12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)
14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)
27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX
29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ
260 1 SEISMIC IN X- DIR
2 SEISMIC IN Z - DIR
3 WIND LOAD X - DIR
4 WIND LOAD Z - DIR
5 DEAD LOAD
6 LIVE LOAD
7 1.5(DL+LL)
8 1.2(DL+LL+ELX)
9 1.2(DL+LL+ELZ)
10 1.2(DL+LL-ELX)
11 1.2(DL+LL-ELZ)
12 1.5(DL+ELX)
13 1.5(DL+ELZ)
14 1.5(DL-ELX)
15 1.5(DL-ELZ)
16 0.9DL+1.5ELX
17 0.9DL+1.5ELZ
18 0.9DL-1.5ELX
19 0.9DL-1.5ELZ
20 1.2(DL+LL+WLX)
21 1.2(DL+LL+WLZ)
22 1.2(DL+LL-WLX)
23 1.2(DL+LL-WLZ)
24 1.5(DL+WLX)
25 1.5(DL+WLZ)
26 1.5(DL-WLX)

84.373
8.289
68.478
7.606
81.194
5.11
71.657
4.427
1.5
15.853
34.335
16.982
30.344
8.653
14.45
7.242
27.165
5.474
17.629
4.063
84.373
38.765
0.089
11.026
0.347
12.751
21.771
51.784
5.091
41.321
87.945
41.533
39.02
18.994
77.275
19.26
46.671
11.343
69.624
11.609
28.195
41.011
54.659
41.843
2.588
18.607
35.667

4850.969
5349.559
5442.376
4943.786
2792.299
3290.89
3383.707
2885.116
7861.197
8164.546
8031.103
7727.754
5040.482
5419.667
5252.863
4873.678
2981.813
3360.997
3194.194
2815.009
9932.688
227.753
40.845
82.952
51.147
3042.192
3659.554
10052.62
7768.792
8091.11
8315.399
7993.081
4221.658
4624.556
4904.918
4502.02
2396.343
2799.241
3079.603
2676.705
7942.553
8103.472
8141.638
7980.718
4438.86
4640.009
4687.717

3.405
0.061
5.18
8.524
1.688
1.656
3.463
6.807
3.075
4.991
2.365
0.449
3.849
1.454
4.737
7.132
2.132
0.263
3.02
5.414
8.524
1.782
0.774
2.166
0.137
9.261
19.176
42.655
31.986
35.052
36.262
33.196
11.219
15.051
16.563
12.731
5.662
9.495
11.007
7.174
31.525
33.959
36.723
34.289
10.643
13.685
17.14

15.892
45.72
24.491
86.103
7.815
53.796
16.414
78.026
16.89
41.784
21.248
79.921
17.468
55.875
22.915
96.257
9.391
63.951
14.839
88.181
96.257
30.674
318.27
28.956
198.314
48.645
82.666
196.965
120.763
224.352
194.381
539.497
26.956
404.439
118.978
550.373
2.231
433.626
89.791
521.186
122.825
80.404
192.32
395.548
29.532
224.503
116.401

61.828
39.331
59.507
41.652
61.364
39.796
59.971
41.188
15.288
20.176
35.248
30.361
13.636
7.526
11.315
5.205
13.171
7.062
11.779
5.669
73.802
25.033
20.113
1.789
12.608
0.178
15.826
24.007
10.835
43.341
49.246
4.93
37.283
30.437
37.818
29.902
37.39
30.33
37.711
30.009
17.058
4.076
21.353
34.335
2.416
18.644
2.951

583.795
9.346
570.27
4.179
581.09
6.641
572.975
1.474
69.59
209.177
356.635
217.048
186.166
11.681
172.641
1.844
183.461
8.976
175.346
0.861
674.738
355.763
1.218
110.299
2.901
38.709
191.372
345.122
150.818
274.636
703.014
277.56
475.581
56.236
591.709
59.891
498.807
33.01
568.483
36.666
143.739
272.617
408.457
279.579
107.385
53.712
223.512

27 1.5(DL-WLZ)
28 0.9DL+1.5WLX
29 0.9DL+1.5WLZ
30 0.9DL-1.5WLX
31 0.9DL-1.5WLZ

19.647
5.063
10.956
28.016
11.996
87.945

4486.567
2613.544
2814.694
2862.401
2661.252
10052.62

14.097
5.086
8.129
11.583
8.541
42.655

370.437
0.346
253.69
87.215
341.25
550.373

19.179
2.523
18.751
2.844
19.072
49.246

62.415
130.611
30.487
200.287
39.19
703.014

46410.12