Comparison Between Analog and Digital Transmission
Comparison Between Analog and Digital Transmission
frequency Digital Characteristics Discrete signal, represented as either changes in voltage or changes in light levels Bits per second (for example, a T-1 line carries 1.544Mbps, and an E-1 line transports 2.048Mbps) High bandwidth that can support high-speed data and emerging applications that involve video and multimedia High; multiplexers enable multiple conversations to share a communications channel and hence to achieve greater transmission efficiencies Low because only two discrete signalsthe one and the zeroneed to be transmitted
Traffic Hz (for example, a measurement telephone channel is 4KHz) Bandwidth Low bandwidth (4KHz), which means low data transmission rates (up to 33.6Kbps) because of limited channel bandwidth Low; one conversation per telephone channel
Network capacity
Power requirement
High because the signal contains a wide range of frequencies and amplitudes
Security
Poor; when you tap into Good; encryption can be an analog circuit, you used hear the voice stream in its native form, and it is difficult to detect an intrusion High; 105 bits (that is, 1 in 100,000 bits) is guaranteed to have an error Low; with twisted-pair, 107 (that, is 1 in 10 million bits per second) will have an error, with satellite, 109 (that is, 1 in 1 billion per second) will have an error, and with fiber, 1011 (that is only 1 in 10 trillion bits per second) will have an error
Error rates