Adrift

Actually found quite a bit of enjoyment out of it. Prince Durin and his wife were great additions and I loved the dialogue between them and Elrond. Nori continues to be my favorite character so far, and the scenes she had with that strange man from the fireball were fascinating. Arondir and Bronwyn grew on me this episode, and I even found Bronwyn's son to be entertaining. Some really good suspense moments throughout as well. Low point for me is Galadriel's story line. I don't find her likeable at all, and have no idea how she is gonna turn out to be the Galadriel we all love from Jackson's films.

I was so surprised by the difference in quality from the first and second episode, that I checked the writer for the 2nd, and low and behold, she was previously a BCS and BB writer. Doesn't surprise me that I found this episode to be much stronger.

It was a very good idea for Amazon to drop both episodes because if they dropped that 1st episode only, then I probably would've let this go by the wayside.

Adrift is a better episode than the choppy first, it is paced better, acted a little better and sets up the story going forwards. Like episode one, Nori is still the highlight so far, and I though the scenes with Elrond and Durin were pretty funny and well done. The scenes in Khazad-dûm were the best part of this episode, and they very much felt like they belonged in the Hobbit Trilogy. The sets and quality of the visuals during these scenes were fantastic, so props to the guys responsible for carrying these few episodes.

That being said, Galadriel is still boring, as is the elf warrior guy - Arondir and his weird relationship with Bronwyn.

We got an opening title, with was ok, but getting to hear Howard Shore do some more LotR music was a joy, and it's glad to see he hasn't lost his touch. The rest of the music, done by Bear McCreary is also very good, but this should be expected by the guy who composed the music to a much better Amazon show, The Outlander and the video game God of War.

Adrift was just fine, not great, not bad. I do hope the episodes get better going forwards, but I think Amazon should have released 3 episodes instead of 2, because I'm still not invested in these characters or the story.

How could these show writers make the decision to not stay faithful to the source material. The most successful fantasy writer of all time with a story series that has enamoured people across the world and they have decided that they could do better.

This show feels so depressing and hopeless that it becomes a slog to even try and finish an episode. I am already convinced that I will not be watching series 2. I will re-watch the Hobbit trilogy instead.

Continuity and in-world logic seem to be unimportant in the creation of this show and the lack of appreciation for the geography is a real shame. Watching adventurous travel in the LOTR trilogy was a joy and embedded the viewer in the world. In this show, it is treated as an inconvenience.

Some of the choices to change the established characters and lore is mind-boggling.

Awful, awful writing.

It's true that the first episode was not so good if we consider that the first episode in every show should be strong and exciting, but the second was much better in all aspects.

We cannot judge the story and the writing from the first two episodes because this is not a random tv show, the lore is huge and it can get even bigger with this show..So we have to let it grow and let the writers express their type o pacing I truly believe that it is gonna turn out really well The second episode was truly exciting and keeps the viewer occupied throughout the whole episode.

Also,what this show gives me even better than the lotr trilogy so far (sorry for the comparison)is the menacing nature of the freaking orks..I knew that aragorn and legolas could easily kill one of them with no effort but here ,I think these orks are far more powerful and scary ..

The trailers were drawing attention to all the wrong aspects. Like it's gonna be good b/c of you know, representation. This doesn't make a story good or bad. People are deeper than their gender and skin color.

Galadriel is a by the book Girl Boss, so you know already that she's going to be right about everything and she's like super righteous and unlikable. Her predictable arc will entail a moment when everyone has to say "Galadriel, we should have listened to you. We should have recognized your Girl Bossness from the start." etc So righteous. Eyes bulging. Shaking with girl boss righteousness.

But now, despite that, two episodes in and I like where it is going. I like most of the characters and there's some interesting things happening. The hobbits are done so well. The Dwarf city and king and queen were great. I like Arondir and Bronwyn's subplot. The look and feel of the world is quite good. I like using the maps to show us the different parts of the world. The music is pretty good too.

Let's see if it keeps moving and doesn't get weighed down by too many characters. But I'm feeling optimistic. So far, good job.

I'm not going to compare it to LOTR anymore. It's something different and should be judged according to it's own merits.

Did I mention that Galadriel was like really righteous?