Mind the Bollocks

The title of this chapter has often been applied to the output of newspapers.

Another, less ‘Tomorrow’s fish and chip wrappers’. Or it used to be, during the antiquated era when most of the news was still printed on paper.

The same applies to music reviews, which means that dubious appraisals like those found in this chapter are largely forgotten. Or they would have been, had I not cruelly fished them out from the dustbin of history.

Music journalists and writers may not thank me for dredging these snippets up from the murky depths of Lake Forgotten, but there’s no shame in it – even the best sometimes suffer from serious lapses in judgement. Including yours truly, undoubtedly the eminent-est critic of his day, who wrote for the super, soaraway under the pseudonym Johnny Cigarettes, and produced the searingly insightful report that opens this extensive hall of shame...

‘If Oasis didn’t exist, no one would want to invent them. For a start, they look and sound like they’re long overdue product from a bankrupt Polymer Records Manc scally also-rans factory. Vaguely trippy guitar almost-tunes with vaguely late 60s rock tendencies, vaguely Ian-Brown-as-Tim-Burgess slob of a frontman, singing in a vaguely tuneless half-whine, vaguely shaking a tambourine, vaguely… er, yes, well, you get the picture.

But more annoying is the fact that they’re too cool to dare to have a personality or be more surprising than the dullest retro indie fops, too well versed in old records to do anything new (e.g. a cover of I Am The Walrus and you know what it sounds like, kids), and evidently too few brains to realise that any of the above is true. Sad.’

Oasis, reviewed live by Johnny Cigarettes, NME, 1993

‘Thriller is a very patchy affair indeed… if I was Jackson, I’d ditch everyone he’s ever worked with and hunt around on the East Coast for some new talent. He has the skill, but it’s wasted here.’

Michael Jackson, Thriller, reviewed by Paolo Hewitt, Melody Maker, 1982

‘The (guest artists) put into action here reek of desperation… to cover the lack of inspiration in the music… Beat It is a terrible attempt at streetwise posin’… Jackson lays himself bare as a songwriter and the results are often acutely embarrassing… a barely developed artist being given too much artistic control.’

Michael Jackson, Thriller, reviewed by Gavin Martin, NME, 1982

Easily done, of course. And how could anyone have known what a phenomenon that

    album would become? Even those closest to Jackson could not have guessed how

history would judge the whole project. Indeed, Thriller producer Quincy Jones

argued against the inclusion of ‘Billie Jean’ on the record as he regarded it as its

weakest track. Jackson insisted on keeping it, in particular, the relatively long

opening section, because whenever he heard it, it made him want to dance.

Pffff! Imagine judging music on such simplistic dumbed down terms!

Good job Jacko never tried his hand at music criticism…

‘I think (this) record is lousy… Johnny Rotten sings flat, the song is laughably naïve, and the overall feeling is of a third-rate Who imitation…’

The Sex Pistols, ‘Anarchy In The UK’ (single), reviewed by Cliff White, NME, 1976

Cliff White soon became known as the man who slagged off the Pistols.

Hello from the man who slagged off Oasis.

‘Were I an A&R type, I’d say something terminally crass like, Sack the band, give the singer a publishing deal. As things stand, however, Radiohead are a pitiful, lily-livered excuse for a rock’n’roll group.’

Radiohead, reviewed live by Keith Cameron, NME, 1992

The headline for this review, ‘Ugly with a capital U’, accompanied by a quartet of distinctly unflattering shots of singer Thom Yorke gurning into the microphone, led to Yorke’s refusal to speak to the NME for several months afterwards.

‘Sloth posing as innovation? Not a million leg pulls away from an early Jethro Tull b-side.’

The Smiths, ‘What Difference Does It Make?’ (single), reviewed by Steve Sutherland, Melody Maker, 1984

‘God knows Rock & Roll could use some good old faggot energy, but… the sexuality that Reed proffers on Transformer is timid and flaccid… He should forget this artsy-fartsy kind of homo stuff and just go in there with a bad hangover and start blaring out his vision of lunar assf**k.’

Lou Reed, Transformer, reviewed in Rolling Stone, 1972

‘Incredibly irritating… too trivial, too lightweight… one-song album.’

Lou Reed, Transformer, reviewed by Charles Shaar Murray, NME, 1972

‘(Side one was) so utterly confused with itself it was difficult to follow… relies too heavily on taped sound effects of heartbeats, plane crashes and other insane utterances.’

Pink Floyd, Dark Side Of The Moon, reviewed by Roy Hollingworth, Melody Maker, 1973

‘Neil Young devotees will probably spend the next few weeks trying desperately to convince themselves that After The Gold Rush is good music. But they’ll be kidding themselves. None of the songs here rise above the uniformly dull surface… apparently no one bothered to tell Neil Young that he was singing a half-octave above his highest acceptable range… I can’t listen to it at all.’

Neil Young, After The Gold Rush, reviewed by Langdon Winner, Rolling Stone, 1970

‘The great Stones album of their mature period is yet to come… Exile On Main Street is the Rolling Stones at their most dense and impenetrable.’

Rolling Stones, Exile On Main Street, reviewed by Lenny Kaye, Rolling Stone, 1972

‘The album has nothing new and very little that is even recent. The main sound is pre-Rubber Soul… And it doesn’t matter if the words are sung as a put-on, they still are painful to hear… they are lacking in substance, rather like potato chips… The Beatles, though they might not have intended it, have in essence produced hip Muzak.’

The Beatles, The Beatles (White Album), reviewed by Mike Jahn, New York Times, 1968

‘(a) willingness to waste their considerable talent on unworthy material… If they’re to help fill the void created by the demise of Cream, they will have to find a producer (and editor) and some material worthy of their collective attention.

Led Zeppelin, Led Zeppelin, reviewed by John Mendelsohn, Rolling Stone, 1969

‘The kind of garage band who should be speedily returned to their garage, preferably with the engine running, which would undoubtedly be more of a loss to their friends and families than to either rock or roll.’

The Clash, reviewed live by Charles Shaar Murray, NME, 1976

The band responded by writing ‘Garageland’, one of the highlights of their debut album. And resolutely refusing to return to said garage.

‘Few memorable compositions… use of the wah-wah pedal is taken to irritating lengths.’

Jimi Hendrix, Electric Ladyland, reviewed in Melody Maker, 1968

‘Mr. Presley has no discernable singing ability. His specialty is rhythm songs which he renders in an undistinguished whine; his phrasing, if it can be called that, consists of the stereotyped variations that go with a beginner’s aria in a bathtub. For the ear he is an unutterable bore.’

Elvis Presley, profiled by Jack Gould, New York Times, 1956

‘If you appreciate good singing, I don’t suppose you’ll manage to hear this disc all (the way) through.’

Elvis Presley, ‘Heartbreak Hotel’ (single), reviewed in New Musical Express, 1956

‘Elvis Presley sounds a very mannered singer to me. His Heartbreak Hotel positively drips ersatz emotion…[his] diction is extremely poor.’

Elvis Presley, ‘Heartbreak Hotel’ (single) reviewed by Laurie Henshaw, Melody Maker, 1956

‘Tuneless, heartless exercises in secondhand dancefloor dynamics and duff metal.’

Red Hot Chili Peppers, The Uplift Mofo Party Plan, reviewed by Charlie Dick, Q, 1988

‘Their lumpy stew of speed metal, funk and street punk posturing doesn’t improve with age.’

Red Hot Chilli Peppers, Mother’s Milk, reviewed by Graeme Kay, Q, 1989

‘Leisure is a quite engaging album… but it ain’t the future. Blur are merely the present of rock’n’roll.’

Blur, Leisure, reviewed by Andrew Collins, NME, 1991

‘Blur are praised for being more ambitious than their peers. Possibly because there’s nothing much to them but ambition… Pampered, pilfered, piffle, Blur put the C*** in Pretty Vacant.’

Blur, reviewed live in New York by Simon Reynolds, Melody Maker, 1991

‘Rivers Cuomo takes a juvenile tack on personal relationships… Weezer over-rely on catchy tunes to heal all of Cuomo’s wounds. Tired of Sex, a look at a brooding stud’s empty sex life, is as aimless as the subject’s nightly routine.’

Weezer, Pinkerton, reviewed by Rob O’Connor, Rolling Stone, 1996.

The album was also voted second worst album of the year by the magazine’s readers. Six years later, Rolling Stone readers had changed their tune somewhat – they voted it as the 16th greatest album of all time.

‘This man’s muse is dead… I think it’s time we left him to rest in peace. Paul Weller doesn’t exist any more.’

Paul Weller, Paul Weller, reviewed by Steve Sutherland, Melody Maker, 1992

‘A wasted opportunity if you’re being generous. A shot in the foot if you want to be more melodramatic.’

Oasis, (What’s The Story) Morning Glory, reviewed by David Cavanagh, Q, 1995

‘It’s clear the group’s only asset is the ludicrously unphotogenic Boy George. God help ‘em.’

Culture Club, ‘Do You Really Want To Hurt Me?’ (single), reviewed by Robbie Millar, Sounds, 1982

The record duly went to number one and Boy George briefly became more famous than Jesus.

‘Their A level amateurism is hardly endearing.’

Human League, reviewed live by Ian Pye, Melody Maker, 1980

Pye roundly dismissed the Human League’s new direction with two new schoolgirl backing singers. Within a year they were at number one.

‘This album carries a sticker Do Not Pay More Than £3.99 For This Album. It should carry a sticker which says Do Not Pay Anything For This Album.’

Japan, Gentlemen Take Polaroids, reviewed by Patrick Humphries, Melody Maker, 1980

‘If you’re trying to create your own personality cult it generally helps to have a personality. Adam and the Ants don’t… too much fuss about nothing.’

Adam and the Ants, Kings Of The Wild Frontier, reviewed by Adam Sweeting, Melody Maker, 1980

Within six months, naturally, they were superstars.

‘Greatness is never so boringly repetitive [referring to singer Ian McCulloch’s claims and the advert calling it The Greatest album ever made]… It accelerates the unseamly [sic] slide of a once witty and occasionally inventive pop rock group into the swamp of pomp… dragged under by a swagbag of artrock cliché.’

Echo & The Bunnymen, Ocean Rain, reviewed by Biba Kopf, NME, 1984

Ian McCulloch memorably responded in a rival publication with the comment: ‘It’s like the manager of Rotherham United saying Liverpool are shit.’

‘Purple Rain is flawed throughout with a muso’s megalomania – so keen to seem flash that any potential drama is turned to melodrama… soul’s most sensual monarch jerkin’ off to a soundtrack of faked orgasms.’

Prince, Purple Rain, reviewed by Steve Sutherland, Melody Maker, 1984

‘Christ, so this is what John Leckie dumped the Roses for. Radiohead serve up yet another anthemic chunk of fey verse riffola and big Marshall-stack chorus action which will no doubt surf to the top of every college radio station in the US of A. But since we now have Oasis and they’ve been lumbered with Pearl Jam, we don’t really care what they think any more, do we?’

Radiohead, ‘Just’ (fourth single from The Bends), reviewed by Rupert Howe, NME, 1995

‘Monotonous… flat, predictable… (‘Superstition’) lacks textural variety.’

Stevie Wonder, Talking Book, reviewed in NME, 1973

‘They never pick the right tracks for 45 release… it seems destined to follow Red Frame White Light and Messages into chartless oblivion.’

OMD, ‘Enola Gay’ (single), reviewed by Adrian Thrills, NME, 1980

It went to number eight in the charts and was OMD’s first hit.

‘It’s all over, isn’t it? You can’t base a career on one pair of lips.’

The Charlatans, ‘Over Rising’ (single), reviewed by Paul Lester, Melody Maker, 1991

As of 2012, The Charlatans are working on their 12th studio album.

‘In musical terms they have a strong desire to emulate the ‘76-’79 bands… but the sound, while elusive and difficult to put a label on, is still fairly dull. The live evidence of the Happy Mondays is little more than uninspiring.’

Happy Mondays, reviewed live by Dave Sexton, Record Mirror,1987

‘In an obvious attempt to wrestle hip-hop away from the West, East Coast critics have been gushing over Long Island’s Nas as if he were rap’s second coming. Don’t believe the hype. Too much of the album is mired with tired attitudes and posturing.’

Nas, Illmatic, reviewed by Heidi Siegmund, Los Angeles Times, 1994

The album is now considered one of the greatest ever hip-hop albums.

‘The majority of young bands are unsure of what they truly want their band to be, aside from famous. At least Muse also know they want to be Radiohead… perhaps Radiohead can start charitable